DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 001 TIME: 12:55:54 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 210/Shelby VRSN: W 210-901/Center ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 2 $ 15,841 - $ 41,190 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ 0203 FORYSTH JOHN BLK 18 R18046 S 03/2004 45,000 21,920 45,000 0.4871 0010 AMASON JESSE BLK 7 T R20276 S 04/2004 30,000 33,910 30,000 1.1303 0010 AMASON JESSE BLK 27 R20561 S 04/2004 22,000 30,320 22,000 1.3782 0010 AMASON JESSE BLK 39 R20951 S 01/2004 40,000 40,300 40,000 1.0075 0010 AMASON JESSE BLK 57 R21034 S 07/2004 22,500 21,070 22,500 0.9364 0010 AMASON JESSE BLK 66 R21333 S 05/2004 31,800 30,250 31,800 0.9513 0010 AMASON JESSE BLK 67 R21369 S 10/2004 40,000 30,890 40,000 0.7723 0010 AMASON JESSE BLK 68 R21387 S 08/2004 27,000 27,170 27,000 1.0063 0573 PARKER ROBERT L BLK R22782 S 06/2004 34,000 34,820 34,000 1.0241 0644 SMITH NANCY BLK 54 T R22974 S 07/2004 45,000 38,690 45,000 0.8598 0096 CARZENAVA ESTEVAN BL R41444 S 07/2004 50,500 32,010 50,500 0.6339 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 2 TOTALS 341,350 387,800 0.8802 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 3 $ 41,191 - $ 63,310 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ 0096 CARZENAVA ESTEVAN BL R17047 S 07/2004 35,000 48,030 35,000 1.3723 0096 CARZENAVA ESTEVAN BL R17301 S 03/2004 53,000 61,970 53,000 1.1692 0010 AMASON JESSE BLK 23 R20516 S 05/2004 39,500 43,470 39,500 1.1005 0010 AMASON JESSE BLK 42 R20986 S 06/2004 45,000 48,770 45,000 1.0838 0010 AMASON JESSE BLK 59 R21056 S 08/2004 50,000 44,930 50,000 0.8986 0010 AMASON JESSE BLK 62 R21174 S 06/2004 76,500 52,520 76,500 0.6865 A279 HILL WESLEY BLK 82 T R22345 S 07/2004 77,500 60,770 77,500 0.7841 0308 HOPKINS DAVID BLK 0 R22672 S 01/2004 28,000 48,850 28,000 1.7446 0308 HOPKINS DAVID BLK 0 R22673 S 09/2004 28,500 50,080 28,500 1.7572 0644 SMITH NANCY BLK 50 T R22895 S 03/2004 60,500 56,880 60,500 0.9402 0644 SMITH NANCY BLK 52 T R22935 S 02/2004 55,000 58,770 55,000 1.0685 0732 TURPIN WM BLK 0 TR 3 R23737 S 02/2004 55,000 43,620 55,000 0.7931 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 3 TOTALS 618,660 603,500 1.0251 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 4 $ 63,311 - $ 102,260 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ 0203 FORSYTH JOHN BLK 17 R18023 S 08/2004 73,000 65,060 73,000 0.8912 DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 002 TIME: 12:55:54 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 210/Shelby VRSN: W 210-901/Center ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 4 $ 63,311 - $ 102,260 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ 0942 FARMER R C BLK 0 TR R19951 S 10/2004 84,000 71,100 84,000 0.8464 0010 AMASON JESSE BLK 3 T R20068 S 05/2004 62,000 75,750 62,000 1.2218 0010 AMASON JESSE BLK 27 R20567 S 04/2004 69,500 75,360 69,500 1.0843 0010 AMASON JESSE BLK 27 R20570 S 01/2004 113,000 88,700 113,000 0.7850 0010 AMASON JESSE BLK 60 R21117 S 04/2004 56,000 65,200 56,000 1.1643 0010 AMASON JESSE BLK 62 R21173 S 07/2004 112,500 86,460 112,500 0.7685 0010 AMASON JESSE BLK 62 R21183 S 08/2004 109,000 95,220 109,000 0.8736 0010 AMASON JESSE THE OAK R21509 S 07/2004 85,000 92,710 85,000 1.0907 0279 HILL WESLEY BLK 82 T R22330 S 04/2004 66,500 81,370 66,500 1.2236 0279 HILL WESLEY BLK 85 T R22393 S 01/2004 57,500 68,730 57,500 1.1953 0307 HOPKINS DAVID BLK 9 R22633 S 06/2004 88,500 70,300 88,500 0.7944 0644 SMITH NANCY BLK 93 T R23307 S 05/2004 145,000 90,970 145,000 0.6274 0644 SMITH NANCY BLK 93 T R23314 S 07/2004 70,000 66,520 70,000 0.9503 0644 SMITH NANCY BLK 94 T R23341 S 01/2004 71,500 70,170 71,500 0.9814 0010 AMASON JESSE THE OAK R40288 S 01/2004 89,900 83,750 89,900 0.9316 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 4 TOTALS 1,247,370 1,352,900 0.9220 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 5 $ 102,261 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ 0010 AMASON JESSE BLK 29 R20603 S 10/2004 135,000 137,440 135,000 1.0181 A 10 JESSE AMASON BLK 31 R20750 A 305,560 245,510 1.2446 A 10 JESSE AMASON BLK 32 R20754 A 109,120 144,096 0.7573 A10 JESSE AMASON BLK 62 T R21166 A 111,460 118,338 0.9419 0307 HOPKINS DAVID BLK 9 R22664 S 08/2004 167,000 103,570 167,000 0.6202 A 644 NANCY SMITH BLK 93 R23321 A 187,230 157,748 1.1869 0644 SMITH NANCY BLK 94 T R23340 S 04/2004 105,000 107,610 105,000 1.0249 A 751 MASON VANN M BLK 0 R26181 A 233,320 193,597 1.2052 0751 VANN MASON M BLK 0 T R26212 S 02/2004 196,712 175,220 196,712 0.8907 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 5 TOTALS 1,470,530 1,463,001 1.0051 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 003 TIME: 12:55:54 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 210/Shelby VRSN: W 210-901/Center ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM COMP SAMPLE STRATUM SAMPLE SAMPLE STRATUM STRATUM STRATUM CATEGORY _______ ____ ______ _______ ______ ______ _______ _______ _______ ________ CODE PARCELS PARCELS LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE LOCAL VALUE RATIO PTD VALUE RATIO ____ _______ _______ ___________ _________ ___________ _____ _________ _____ 1 U 0 654 0 0 5,726,620 5,726,620 2 R 11 944 341,350 387,800 27,133,885 0.8802 30,826,954 3 R 12 540 618,660 603,500 27,180,184 1.0251 26,514,666 4 R 16 342 1,247,370 1,352,900 27,169,587 0.9220 29,468,099 5 R 9 183 1,470,530 1,463,001 27,042,341 1.0051 26,905,125 TOTAL 48 2,663 3,677,910 3,807,201 114,252,617 119,441,464 0.9566 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 004 TIME: 12:55:54 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 210/Shelby VRSN: W 210-901/Center ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY D3 - STRATUM 0 $1 - $99,999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ YORDT D T F BLK 1 TR 1 AC R13442 A 121,600 120,575 1.0085 YORDT D T F BLK 1 TR 2 AC R13445 A 42,240 42,240 1.0000 0096 CARZENAVA ESTEVAN BL R17056 S 10/2004 30,488 42,010 30,488 1.3779 0464 MCKILVEY HEZAKIAH BL R17498 S 01/2004 135,000 117,830 135,000 0.8728 0203 FORSYTH JOHN BLK 0 T R17956 S 02/2004 73,920 65,460 73,920 0.8856 0640 STRICKLAND SAMUEL BL R18215 S 06/2004 90,000 89,200 90,000 0.9911 0274 HOOPER JAMES W BLK 0 R19502 S 04/2004 110,872 69,540 110,872 0.6272 0423 LINDSEY ALFORD BLK 0 R19654 S 08/2004 225,000 274,990 225,000 1.2222 0942 FARMER R C BLK 0 TR R19948 S 06/2004 94,488 70,090 94,488 0.7418 0644 SMITH NANCY BLK 87 T R23087 S 05/2004 23,000 26,460 23,000 1.1504 0516 MCBROWN JACOB BLK 0 R26156 S 07/2004 39,150 32,120 39,150 0.8204 A0870 MCCAULEY O M BLK 0 R26337 S 11/2004 68,400 74,100 68,400 1.0833 0962 HOOPER CHARLES BLK 0 R26403 S 09/2004 65,000 55,900 65,000 0.8600 0592 RUSK CO SCHOOL LAND R28968 S 10/2004 42,000 45,520 42,000 1.0838 1085 BRIDGES G F BLK 0 TR R29089 S 07/2004 130,000 200,160 130,000 1.5397 0096 CARZENAVA ESTEVAN BL R40911 S 07/2004 240,000 218,940 240,000 0.9123 0639 STRICKLAND SAMUEL BL R43512 S 09/2004 20,000 19,000 20,000 0.9500 0591 RUSK CO SCHOOL LAND R48128 S 05/2004 10,000 13,090 10,000 1.3090 0096 CARZENAVA ESTEVAN BL R48240 S 08/2004 15,000 10,500 15,000 0.7000 0760 WALKER PHILLIP BLK 0 R49489 S 09/2004 161,058 123,160 161,058 0.7647 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 0 TOTALS 1,711,910 1,736,191 0.9860 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY D3 - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM COMP SAMPLE STRATUM SAMPLE SAMPLE STRATUM STRATUM STRATUM CATEGORY _______ ____ ______ _______ ______ ______ _______ _______ _______ ________ CODE PARCELS PARCELS LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE LOCAL VALUE RATIO PTD VALUE RATIO ____ _______ _______ ___________ _________ ___________ _____ _________ _____ 0 R 20 4,635 1,711,910 1,736,191 64,822,523 0.9860 65,742,924 TOTAL 20 4,635 1,711,910 1,736,191 64,822,523 65,742,924 0.9860 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 005 TIME: 12:55:54 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 210/Shelby VRSN: W 210-901/Center ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 2 $ 22,221 - $ 72,960 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ 0010 AMASON JESSE BLK 1 T R20006 S 08/2004 58,900 50,940 58,900 0.8649 AMASON JESSE BLK 8 TR 11 R20315 A 54,400 60,456 0.8998 AMASON JESSE BLK 14 TR 4 R20398 A 48,700 50,036 0.9733 AMASON JESSE BLK 41 TR 18 R20974 A 40,250 46,756 0.8609 0010 AMASON JESSE BLK 64 R21223 S 09/2004 61,500 43,510 61,500 0.7075 AMASON JESSE BLK 71 TR 4 R21561 A 27,070 25,729 1.0521 0644 SMITH NANCY BLK 93 T R23333 S 06/2004 48,050 46,710 48,050 0.9721 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 2 TOTALS 311,580 351,427 0.8866 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 3 $ 72,961 - $ 155,340 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ 0010 AMASON JESSE BLK 2 T R20021 S 03/2004 130,000 137,120 130,000 1.0548 AMASON JESSE BLK 5 TR 509 R20211 A 89,920 111,089 0.8094 0010 AMASON JESSE BLK 23 R20512 S 03/2004 150,000 111,320 150,000 0.7421 AMASON JESSE BLK 27 TR 6 R20564 A 77,420 76,689 1.0095 AMASON JESSE BLK 36 TR 24 R20902 A 74,110 73,010 1.0151 SMITH NANCY BLK 92 TR 22. R23275 A 91,580 148,514 0.6166 SMITH NANCY BLK 91 TR 10 R40695 A 148,540 241,788 0.6143 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 3 TOTALS 730,010 931,090 0.7840 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 4 $ 155,341 - $ 536,760 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ AMASON JESSE BLK 1 TR 1 R19991 A 164,630 175,323 0.9390 AMASON JESSE BLK 10 TR 1 R20338 A 189,030 193,862 0.9751 AMASON JESSE BLK 14 TR 6 R20400 A 211,570 229,261 0.9228 AMASON JESSE BLK 38 TR 4 R20937 A 204,860 186,327 1.0995 AMASON JESSE BLK 69 TR 3 R21434 A 158,023 118,835 1.3298 HILL WESLEY BLK 0 TR 21.1 R41572 A 197,126 202,799 0.9720 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 4 TOTALS 1,125,239 1,106,407 1.0170 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 006 TIME: 12:55:54 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 210/Shelby VRSN: W 210-901/Center ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 5 $ 536,761 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ AMASON JESSE BLK 1 TR 21 R20008 A 593,910 1,039,824 0.5712 AMASON JESSE BLK 23 TR 6 R20511 A 1,114,640 1,238,162 0.9002 AMASON JESSE BLK 65 TR 9 R21256 A 654,420 884,349 0.7400 SMITH NANCY BLK 55 TR 15 R22994 A 651,900 439,115 1.4846 SMITH NANCY BLK 93 TR 44. R47158 A 4,746,280 5,496,878 0.8635 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 5 TOTALS 7,761,150 9,098,328 0.8530 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM COMP SAMPLE STRATUM SAMPLE SAMPLE STRATUM STRATUM STRATUM CATEGORY _______ ____ ______ _______ ______ ______ _______ _______ _______ ________ CODE PARCELS PARCELS LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE LOCAL VALUE RATIO PTD VALUE RATIO ____ _______ _______ ___________ _________ ___________ _____ _________ _____ 1 U 0 230 0 0 2,365,496 2,365,496 2 R 7 234 311,580 351,427 11,168,213 0.8866 12,596,676 3 R 7 98 730,010 931,090 11,094,093 0.7840 14,150,629 4 R 6 44 1,125,239 1,106,407 11,605,349 1.0170 11,411,356 5 R 5 13 7,761,150 9,098,328 10,611,978 0.8530 12,440,771 TOTAL 25 619 9,927,979 11,487,252 46,845,129 52,964,928 0.8845 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 007 TIME: 12:55:54 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 210/Shelby VRSN: W 210-901/Center ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - STRATUM 2 $ 14,291 - $ 116,220 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ CITICORP VENDOR FINANCE I P31093 A 18,160 18,357 0.9893 LANCE INC P31401 A 14,886 14,392 1.0343 SOUTHLAND FEED & SUPPLY P40424 A 37,625 34,787 1.0816 GELCO CORP P40499 A 15,958 15,781 1.0112 FRITO-LAY INC. P47458 A 18,739 18,739 1.0000 SONIC DRIVE IN P47925 A 88,828 92,392 0.9614 MURPHY USA #7108 P49934 A 51,934 58,757 0.8839 RIVERVIEW LEASE/LOAN HOLD P50511 A 31,190 53,357 0.5846 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 2 TOTALS 277,320 306,562 0.9046 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - STRATUM 3 $ 116,221 - $ 288,130 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ SHELBY TRANSPORT COMPANY P31056 A 147,400 124,261 1.1862 COVINGTON LUMBER CO P31098 A 267,460 289,310 0.9245 DANCE FURNITURE & APPLIAN P31107 A 221,647 223,353 0.9924 NEW HOLLAND CREDIT CO P43816 A 184,979 307,581 0.6014 BOLES FEED COMPANY P44067 A 157,000 207,800 0.7555 PPG INDUSTRIES INC P44939 A 196,249 196,249 1.0000 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 3 TOTALS 1,174,735 1,348,554 0.8711 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - STRATUM 4 $ 288,131 - $ 2,738,350 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ BROOKSHIRE BROS P31060 A 1,118,725 1,169,548 0.9565 STEEL BUILDING SUPPLY INC P31419 A 1,573,825 1,482,129 1.0619 IVAN SMITH FURNITURE P40352 A 300,620 310,070 0.9695 AUTOZONE P41344 A 319,739 343,148 0.9318 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 4 TOTALS 3,312,909 3,304,895 1.0024 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 008 TIME: 12:55:54 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 210/Shelby VRSN: W 210-901/Center ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - STRATUM 5 $ 2,738,351 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ KLLM INC P31187 A 5,348,323 5,348,323 1.0000 WAL-MART P31325 A 5,002,892 5,029,357 0.9947 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 5 TOTALS 10,351,215 10,377,680 0.9974 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM COMP SAMPLE STRATUM SAMPLE SAMPLE STRATUM STRATUM STRATUM CATEGORY _______ ____ ______ _______ ______ ______ _______ _______ _______ ________ CODE PARCELS PARCELS LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE LOCAL VALUE RATIO PTD VALUE RATIO ____ _______ _______ ___________ _________ ___________ _____ _________ _____ 1 U 0 399 0 0 1,973,445 1,973,445 2 R 8 224 277,320 306,562 9,421,463 0.9046 10,415,060 3 R 6 48 1,174,735 1,348,554 9,580,042 0.8711 10,997,637 4 R 4 12 3,312,909 3,304,895 10,903,899 1.0024 10,877,792 5 C 2 2 10,351,215 10,377,680 10,351,215 0.9974 10,377,680 TOTAL 20 685 15,116,179 15,337,691 42,230,064 44,641,614 0.9460 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ **** END OF REPORT ****
