DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 001 TIME: 12:53:45 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 187/Polk VRSN: W 187-907/Livingston ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 2 $ 13,174 - $ 40,329 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ COUNTRY SUNSHINE LT 59 C1750005900 S 06/2004 25,000 24,407 25,000 0.9763 CRYSTAL CREEK FOREST TR 1 C2300001300 S 11/2004 25,000 34,453 25,000 1.3781 INDIAN SPRINGS LOT 17 LOT I0800129000 S 08/2004 26,600 38,298 26,600 1.4398 LAKE LIVINGSTON EST NO 1 L0200003800 S 08/2004 27,000 36,724 27,000 1.3601 MEMORIAL POINT B 7 LT 12 M1400024800 S 05/2004 19,000 31,941 19,000 1.6811 MENARD CREEK EST LTS 5 & M1600000500 S 05/2004 55,000 32,648 55,000 0.5936 PINE SHADOWS NO 2 B 2 LT P0800011300 S 08/2004 35,000 35,542 35,000 1.0155 CRESCENT SHORES B 6 LT 7 P1000005200 S 05/2004 36,500 28,859 36,500 0.7907 REILYS LANDING R0500011700 S 04/2004 37,500 20,786 37,500 0.5543 ROB SUB 164 TR 8 R1150000700 S 10/2004 55,000 39,927 55,000 0.7259 SHELTER COVE NO 2 L 4 S1100009000 S 11/2004 27,500 38,159 27,500 1.3876 TAYLOR LAKE EST NO 6 LT 5 T0200020200 S 01/2004 33,000 33,883 33,000 1.0268 CHOATE A 15 S 1 PT LT 85 10015036900 S 02/2004 34,000 29,045 34,000 0.8543 DIKES A 27 TR 113 10027015100 S 01/2004 20,000 19,696 20,000 0.9848 DIKES A 27 TR 117 10027015600 S 08/2004 20,900 24,652 20,900 1.1795 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 2 TOTALS 469,020 477,000 0.9833 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 3 $ 40,330 - $ 69,574 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ BRIARBEND NO 1 LT 18 B1000001700 S 12/2004 80,000 60,340 80,000 0.7543 CHEROKEE FOREST NO 1 LTS C0600003800 S 01/2004 52,000 51,447 52,000 0.9894 CRESCENT SHORES B 3 LT 8B C2200002300 S 07/2004 85,000 62,339 85,000 0.7334 GARDEN CITY LT 18 G0500001800 S 09/2004 67,000 63,773 67,000 0.9518 HOLIDAY LAKE EST NO 2 B 1 H1200029000 S 06/2004 65,000 45,545 65,000 0.7007 INDIAN HILL EST NO 1 B 4 I0500005400 S 07/2004 65,000 41,632 65,000 0.6405 LAKE LIVINGSTON AIR PARK L0150005300 S 06/2004 64,500 40,384 64,500 0.6261 LAKELAND HIDAWAY NO 4 LT L0500066200 S 08/2004 23,000 50,696 23,000 2.2042 LAKESIDE VILLAGE NO 1 B 1 L0800007800 S 09/2004 90,000 60,841 90,000 0.6760 LAKESIDE VILLAGE NO 1 B 1 L0800008800 S 06/2004 90,000 59,168 90,000 0.6574 LIVINGSTON OT B 44 P LT2 L1400013000 S 05/2004 55,000 51,498 55,000 0.9363 PINE SHADOWS NO 2 B 11 LT P0800018000 S 03/2005 45,000 51,805 45,000 1.1512 SHELTER COVE NO 1 LT 56 S1100005200 S 12/2004 32,000 40,351 32,000 1.2610 SUGAR HILLS TR 2 S2500000200 S 05/2004 86,000 56,221 86,000 0.6537 TAYLOR LAKE EST #5A LT 2 T0200023300 S 06/2004 80,000 49,732 80,000 0.6217 THUNDER MTN LKS NO 1 B 3 T0500008200 S 05/2004 52,000 50,092 52,000 0.9633 WILD COUNTRY LAKES NO 4 B W1400035200 S 08/2004 45,500 42,910 45,500 0.9431 DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 002 TIME: 12:53:45 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 187/Polk VRSN: W 187-907/Livingston ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 3 $ 40,330 - $ 69,574 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ FALCON A 32 TR 98 10032001205 S 03/2004 40,000 61,498 40,000 1.5375 BEECH CREEK VILLAGE S TR 10720000119 S 07/2004 79,900 51,499 79,900 0.6445 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 3 TOTALS 991,771 1,196,900 0.8286 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 4 $ 69,575 - $ 114,106 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ BRIARBEND NO 1 LT 4 B1000000400 S 03/2004 93,500 95,259 93,500 1.0188 BRIARBEND NO 1 LT 51 B1000004800 S 08/2004 85,201 91,501 85,201 1.0739 INDIAN HILL NO 2 B 6 L 5 I0400034000 S 09/2004 75,000 77,138 75,000 1.0285 INDIAN HILL EST NO 1 B 6 I0500013200 S 07/2004 150,000 76,654 150,000 0.5110 INDIAN HILL EST NO 4 LT 1 I0500043200 S 05/2004 145,000 74,745 145,000 0.5155 LAKE LIVINGSTON ESTS NO 1 L0200009100 AND L02000092 S 02/2004 110,000 76,284 110,000 0.6935 LAKE LIVINGSTON EST NO 1 L0200011700 & 9600 S 08/2004 160,000 81,787 160,000 0.5112 LAKE LIVINGSTON EST NO 5 L0200089700 S 09/2004 150,000 103,421 150,000 0.6895 MEMORIAL POINT B 10 LT 13 M1400044000 S 05/2004 74,000 92,884 74,000 1.2552 OAK FOREST B 3 LT 7 O0100003100 S 11/2004 110,000 101,283 110,000 0.9208 RESORT COUNTRY S 2 LT 87 R0700011200 S 04/2004 213,000 104,582 213,000 0.4910 ROLLINGSWOODS TR 25 R1050002600 S 05/2004 75,500 80,376 75,500 1.0646 SKYLINE B 4 LTS 3 & 4 S1500001500 S 08/2004 88,500 72,214 88,500 0.8160 TAYLOR LAKE EST NO 5 LTS T0200015300 S 11/2004 94,500 94,157 94,500 0.9964 TOWNE FOREST NO 1 LT 1 T0800000100 S 06/2004 65,000 75,587 65,000 1.1629 CHOATE A 15 S 1 SUB LOT 9 10015038600 S 09/2004 72,316 81,316 72,316 1.1245 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 4 TOTALS 1,379,188 1,761,517 0.7830 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 5 $ 114,107 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ COTTON HILLS EST LT 25 C1500002405 S 12/2004 290,000 174,624 290,000 0.6022 DAVIS WOODS B 1 L 9 D0150000900 S 03/2004 140,000 145,514 140,000 1.0394 DICKENS LANDING NO 2 PT L D0375004400 S 11/2004 280,000 152,130 280,000 0.5433 INDIAN HILL NO 2 B 16 LT I0400042800 S 07/2004 127,500 185,081 127,500 1.4516 INDIAN HILL ESTATES NO 1 I0500001400 S 04/2004 400,000 273,051 400,000 0.6826 OAK TERRACE EST NO 4 LTS O0300019200 & 9100 S 06/2005 225,000 175,674 225,000 0.7808 OAK TERRACE EST NO 4 LT 1 O0300019800 S 11/2004 280,000 137,965 280,000 0.4927 RESORT COUNTRY S 1 LTS 35 R0700003100 S 07/2004 165,000 144,267 165,000 0.8743 DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 003 TIME: 12:53:45 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 187/Polk VRSN: W 187-907/Livingston ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 5 $ 114,107 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ THE RETREAT TR 33 R0800003300 S 08/2004 167,500 160,275 167,500 0.9569 SHELTER COVE NO 5 B 2 LTS S1100047400 S 09/2004 234,000 172,906 234,000 0.7389 TEXAS LANDING T0425000400 S 08/2004 181,000 156,079 181,000 0.8623 TEXAS LANDING LT 49 & 50 T0425004800 & 4900 S 09/2004 312,000 199,333 312,000 0.6389 TEXAS LANDING LT 77 T0425007600 S 08/2004 170,000 115,832 170,000 0.6814 TEXAS LANDING LT 91A T0425009100 S 10/2004 325,000 190,518 325,000 0.5862 MORGAN A 56 TR 34-0-2 10056003499 S 12/2004 169,900 115,569 169,900 0.6802 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 5 TOTALS 2,498,818 3,466,900 0.7208 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM COMP SAMPLE STRATUM SAMPLE SAMPLE STRATUM STRATUM STRATUM CATEGORY _______ ____ ______ _______ ______ ______ _______ _______ _______ ________ CODE PARCELS PARCELS LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE LOCAL VALUE RATIO PTD VALUE RATIO ____ _______ _______ ___________ _________ ___________ _____ _________ _____ 1 U 0 3,083 0 0 20,470,404 20,470,404 2 R 15 3,591 469,020 477,000 97,213,719 0.9833 98,864,761 3 R 19 1,686 991,771 1,196,900 97,139,409 0.8286 117,233,175 4 R 16 1,015 1,379,188 1,761,517 97,194,483 0.7830 124,130,885 5 R 15 542 2,498,818 3,466,900 97,157,631 0.7208 134,791,386 TOTAL 65 9,917 5,338,797 6,902,317 409,175,646 495,490,611 0.8258 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 004 TIME: 12:53:45 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 187/Polk VRSN: W 187-907/Livingston ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY C - STRATUM 2 $ 1,585 - $ 5,924 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ DOGWOOD LAKE EST NO 1 B 5 D0400008500 S 02/2004 5,500 2,025 5,500 0.3682 FOREST SPRINGS NO 4 LT 19 F0500039200 S 07/2004 2,500 2,300 2,500 0.9200 FOREST SPRINGS NO 4 LT 25 F0500039600 S 06/2004 3,000 2,290 3,000 0.7633 INDIAN HILL EST NO 2 B 7 I0500022600 S 12/2004 3,500 3,300 3,500 0.9429 LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLAGE N L0400017200 S 03/2005 3,800 3,850 3,800 1.0132 LAKESIDE VILLAGE NO 1 B 1 L0800010000 S 01/2004 6,667 5,016 6,667 0.7524 MANGUM ESTATES NO 2 LTS 2 M0500018100 S 03/2005 933 2,000 933 2.1436 MEMORIAL POINT B 7 LT 18 M1400025400 S 07/2004 1,500 1,773 1,500 1.1820 NUGETS COVE NO 2 B 1 LTS N1000026800 S 04/2004 3,000 5,250 3,000 1.7500 NGENTS COVE NO 2 B 6 LT 1 N1000036800 S 09/2004 3,500 1,635 3,500 0.4671 OAK TERRACE EST NO 4 LT 3 O0300021400 S 03/2004 3,000 5,460 3,000 1.8200 OAK TERRACE EST NO 3 LT 4 O030017100 S 01/2004 5,000 5,222 5,000 1.0444 REILY'S LANDING R0500018300 S 07/2004 1,500 1,860 1,500 1.2400 WIGGINS RIDGE LTS 93 & 94 W1100007300 S 02/2005 1,000 2,080 1,000 2.0800 WIGGINS VILLAGE S 2 LTS 1 W1200026900 S 02/2004 1,800 2,000 1,800 1.1111 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 2 TOTALS 46,061 46,200 0.9970 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY C - STRATUM 3 $ 5,925 - $ 15,304 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ COMMODORE CAPE S 2 LTS 7 C1200007300 & 7400 S 04/2005 5,000 8,616 5,000 1.7232 COMMODORE CAPE S 2 LTS 81 C1200008000 & 8200 S 10/2004 3,500 9,240 3,500 2.6400 ENCHANTED FOREST NO 2 LT E0800008700 S 07/2004 12,500 8,000 12,500 0.6400 GLEN COVE LT 1 & 3 G0125000100 & 0300 S 01/2004 17,000 11,400 17,000 0.6706 LAKE LIVINGSTON EST NO 3 LO200026500 S 02/2005 3,500 8,103 3,500 2.3151 NUGENTS COVE NO 1 B 5 LTS N1000012200 S 02/2005 6,000 12,375 6,000 2.0625 PINE SHADOWS NO 2 B 7 LT P0800016100 S 01/2005 5,000 7,332 5,000 1.4664 PUTNAMS LANDING NO 1 LT 2 P1700002100 & P1700029800 S 03/2004 7,000 8,880 7,000 1.2686 SKYLINE B 6 LTS 7 & 8 S1500003200 S 10/2004 3,000 6,938 3,000 2.3127 TEMPE TIMBERED TERR NO 1 T0300000900 S 05/2004 13,000 13,300 13,000 1.0231 TEXAS LANDING LT 101 T0425010100 S 10/2004 7,500 7,058 7,500 0.9411 TEXAS LANDING LTS 110 & 1 T0425011000 S 03/2005 12,500 12,900 12,500 1.0320 TWO FORTY TR 29 T1400002900 S 03/2004 7,500 5,943 7,500 0.7924 BARCO A 101 TR 17 10101003300 S 10/2004 5,000 7,521 5,000 1.5042 MILES A 413 TR 23 1041303100 S 04/2004 10,000 10,173 10,000 1.0173 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 3 TOTALS 137,779 118,000 1.1676 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 005 TIME: 12:53:45 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 187/Polk VRSN: W 187-907/Livingston ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY C - STRATUM 4 $ 15,305 - $ 39,895 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ BEACON BAY S 2 LT 11 B0250002300 S 01/2005 28,000 39,375 28,000 1.4063 BEACON BAY S 2 LT 18 B0250002500 S 10/2004 23,200 35,000 23,200 1.5086 ENCHANTED FOREST LT 22 & E0800002100 & 2200 S 07/2005 25,000 16,000 25,000 0.6400 INDIAN HILL NO 2 B PT 16 I0400042601 A 20,350 16,650 1.2222 JENNINGS COVE LT 11 J0010001100 A 16,921 17,260 0.9804 LAKE LIVINGSTON EST NO 3 L0200019500 A 17,500 17,500 1.0000 MEMORIAL POINT B 11 LT 36 M1400049300 S 08/2004 31,200 30,250 31,200 0.9696 SHELTER COVE NO 1 LTS 12 S1100001200 & 1300 S 11/2004 55,000 28,200 55,000 0.5127 TEMPE TIMBERED TERRACE LT T0300003200 A 16,625 17,500 0.9500 TIMBERLAND COVE TR 26 T0600002600 A 28,290 24,600 1.1500 BURKES A 9 TR 19A 10009003010 A 20,794 15,120 1.3753 CHOATE A 15 TR 144J-4 10015019910 S 04/2004 23,000 19,878 23,000 0.8643 CHOATE A 15 S 1 PT TR 67H 10015034420 A 33,628 32,270 1.0421 BRADLEY A 98 PT TR 13A & 10098001600 A 27,959 24,525 1.1400 BBB& CRR A 152 PT TR 5 & 10152000740 S 08/2004 30,000 30,822 30,000 1.0274 PARISH A 470 TR 43 10470004901 A 19,907 16,030 1.2419 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 4 TOTALS 401,499 396,855 1.0117 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY C - STRATUM 5 $ 39,896 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ BEACON BAY S 2 L 2 B025001300 S 10/2004 71,950 72,489 71,950 1.0075 DEERFIELD LT 2 D0250000200 A 67,450 49,700 1.3571 DEERFIELD LT 12 D0250001200 A 45,030 27,650 1.6286 DICKENS LANDING NO 1 L 6 D0375000600 A 46,101 54,236 0.8500 DICKENS LANDING NO 2 LTS D0375004900 A 42,000 42,000 1.0000 INDIAN HILL ESTATES NO 1 I0500001600 A 42,300 32,900 1.2857 LAKESIDE B 1 LTS 1,2,3, P L0700000105 A 205,776 181,500 1.1338 LIVINGSTON OT B 34 LTS 1, L1400010600 A 48,400 48,400 1.0000 OAK TERRACE EST NO 1 LT 2 O0300002400 A 42,660 55,300 0.7714 RAINBOWS END NO 4 RES 4 R0050023004 A 60,159 55,248 1.0889 RESORT COUNTRY NO 1 LT 1 R0700000100 S 09/2004 89,500 61,875 89,500 0.6913 CHOATE A 15 PT S 1 SUB LT 10015044601 A 44,625 32,640 1.3672 CHOATE A 15 PT OF TR 15 10015056801 A 174,002 111,690 1.5579 CHOATE A 15 S 3 TR 18-D-1 10015057612 A 50,377 40,000 1.2594 VIESCA A 78 TR 77I 10078009175 A 79,593 70,000 1.1370 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 5 TOTALS 1,082,837 962,714 1.1248 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 006 TIME: 12:53:45 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 187/Polk VRSN: W 187-907/Livingston ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY C - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM COMP SAMPLE STRATUM SAMPLE SAMPLE STRATUM STRATUM STRATUM CATEGORY _______ ____ ______ _______ ______ ______ _______ _______ _______ ________ CODE PARCELS PARCELS LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE LOCAL VALUE RATIO PTD VALUE RATIO ____ _______ _______ ___________ _________ ___________ _____ _________ _____ 1 U 0 9,192 0 0 7,578,514 7,578,514 2 R 15 11,422 46,061 46,200 35,877,015 0.9970 35,984,970 3 R 15 3,906 137,779 118,000 35,873,864 1.1676 30,724,447 4 R 16 1,498 401,499 396,855 35,902,308 1.0117 35,487,109 5 R 15 431 1,082,837 962,714 35,833,725 1.1248 31,857,864 TOTAL 61 26,449 1,668,176 1,523,769 151,065,426 141,632,904 1.0666 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 007 TIME: 12:53:45 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 187/Polk VRSN: W 187-907/Livingston ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY D3 - STRATUM 0 $1 - $99,999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ BEACON BAY S 2 LT 3 B0250001400 S 11/2004 85,000 76,781 85,000 0.9033 CARMONA ESTATES NO 1 TR 1 C0300000700 S 12/2004 7,000 9,775 7,000 1.3964 CLEARWATER SPRINGS LT 7 C080000700 S 06/2004 32,900 54,138 32,900 1.6455 CLEARWATER SPRINGS LT 2 C0890000200 S 07/2004 21,029 30,702 21,029 1.4600 CLEARWATER SPRINGS LT 14 C0890001400 S 09/2004 44,000 55,356 44,000 1.2581 CLEARWATER SPRINGS LOT 19 C0890001900 S 08/2004 45,000 60,144 45,000 1.3365 ROLLINGWOODS TR 11A R1050001200 & R1050001100 S 08/2004 155,000 110,719 155,000 0.7143 SOUTHLAND PLANTATION S 1 S1825001500 S 11/2004 22,400 20,940 22,400 0.9348 SOUTHLAND PLANTATION S 7 S1825015200 S 04/2004 27,000 20,560 27,000 0.7615 SOUTHLAND PLANTATION S 8 S1825016900 S 01/2005 20,196 28,158 20,196 1.3942 SOTHLAND PLANTATION S 9 T S1825018300 S 03/2005 54,400 52,736 54,400 0.9694 SOUTHLAND PLANTATION S 14 S1825026100 S 08/2004 9,000 17,051 9,000 1.8946 SOUTHLAND PLANTATION S 21 S1825032700 S 06/2005 15,000 21,838 15,000 1.4559 SPRING WOODS NO 1 LT 21 S2100000300 S 03/2005 17,000 24,664 17,000 1.4508 BEAZLEY A 4 TR 14 10004001500 S 01/2005 74,700 89,787 74,700 1.2020 BURKES A 9 TR 41-3-3 10009005714 S 02/2005 26,000 27,158 26,000 1.0445 BURKES A 9 TR 41-3-5 10009005727 S 01/2005 140,000 122,140 140,000 0.8724 GARNER A 33 TR 4A 10033000600 S 10/2004 33,500 28,350 33,500 0.8463 GARNER A 33 TR 6A 10033001400 S 01/2005 24,000 31,822 24,000 1.3259 GARNER A 33 TR 12A 10033002400 S 09/2004 12,000 26,043 12,000 2.1703 HIROMS A 37 TR 9 D 10037001010 S 06/2004 21,500 19,309 21,500 0.8981 MORGAN A 56 PT TR 119B 10056011503 S 03/2004 108,900 112,148 108,900 1.0298 PARKER A 61 TR 19 LTS 12 10061003600 S 01/2005 71,650 114,640 71,650 1.6000 VIESCA A 77 TR 27-2 10077003525 S 06/2004 16,320 21,934 16,320 1.3440 WILBURN A 80 TR 3 10080000400 A 480,427 480,427 1.0000 BBB & C RR A 152 TR 5M-3 10152000773 S 04/2005 35,000 43,350 35,000 1.2386 MOORE A 424 TR 1 1024000100 A 324,829 324,849 0.9999 HARDIN A 273 TR 8 10273001400 S 03/2005 140,250 124,715 140,250 0.8892 MASSEY A 422 TR 22A 10422002710 S 10/2004 20,000 19,345 20,000 0.9673 MCCAUGHRAN A 437 10437000300 A 93,156 97,020 0.9602 STUBBLEFIELD A 525 TR 49 10525006100 S 08/2004 6,500 10,000 6,500 1.5385 SMITH A 526 TR 7 10526001100 A 30,955 29,406 1.0527 WHITE A 593 TR 6 B-1 10593000610 S 04/2004 43,938 37,707 43,938 0.8582 STEPHENSON A 761 TR 55 LT 10761006510 S 02/2005 23,000 21,075 23,000 0.9163 VIESCA A 77 TR 8 1077000800 A 50,000 55,000 0.9091 VIESCA A 78 TR 83 1078009700 S 10/2004 11,500 15,991 11,500 1.3905 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 0 TOTALS 2,428,443 2,350,385 1.0332 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 008 TIME: 12:53:45 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 187/Polk VRSN: W 187-907/Livingston ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY D3 - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM COMP SAMPLE STRATUM SAMPLE SAMPLE STRATUM STRATUM STRATUM CATEGORY _______ ____ ______ _______ ______ ______ _______ _______ _______ ________ CODE PARCELS PARCELS LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE LOCAL VALUE RATIO PTD VALUE RATIO ____ _______ _______ ___________ _________ ___________ _____ _________ _____ 0 R 36 4,208 2,428,443 2,350,385 70,458,078 1.0332 68,194,036 TOTAL 36 4,208 2,428,443 2,350,385 70,458,078 68,194,036 1.0332 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 009 TIME: 12:53:45 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 187/Polk VRSN: W 187-907/Livingston ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 2 $ 32,497 - $ 161,389 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ COUNTRY OAKS LT 1 C17000000100 A 38,330 39,540 0.9694 LAKE LIVINGSTON AIR PARK L0150003105 S 11/2004 57,000 35,538 57,000 0.6235 LIVINGSTON OT B 20 LT 1,2 L1400005800 S 02/2004 60,000 72,222 60,000 1.2037 LIVINGSTON OT B 21 LTS 3 L1400006400 A 153,895 164,035 0.9382 OAK TERRACE EST NO 2 RES O0300012400 A 38,232 14,739 2.5939 SOUTH PT B 1 S1800000100 S 05/2005 96,300 102,841 96,300 1.0679 SPRING CREEK BUSINESS PAR S1960002150 S 01/2005 51,750 63,948 51,750 1.2357 BEAZLEY A 4 PT TR 4-40 10004000440 A 52,365 71,780 0.7295 BURKES A 9 TR 61 10009007800 A 70,397 59,645 1.1803 CHOATE A 15 TR 75 10015008900 S 01/2005 50,000 51,509 50,000 1.0302 DIKES A 27 TR 28 10027003700 A 74,609 39,960 1.8671 MORGAN A 56 TR 49-A 10056005050 A 40,078 58,233 0.6882 FERGUSON A 245 TR 32C 10245004300 A 111,053 158,899 0.6989 WHITE A 593 TR 6-2A 10593000603 A 137,139 161,462 0.8494 SMITH A 820 S 3 10820000701 S 12/2004 168,721 150,228 168,721 0.8904 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 2 TOTALS 1,192,384 1,252,064 0.9523 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 3 $ 161,390 - $ 463,154 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ LIV-DREW B 6 L 7 D0600002510 A 167,485 266,579 0.6283 JONES-MATHEWS J040000500 A 182,724 211,512 0.8639 LIVINGSTON OT B 33 LTS 1B L1400010401 S 07/2004 135,625 229,590 135,625 1.6928 CHOATE A 15 S 2 SUB LOT 5 10015050700 S 02/2004 430,000 430,246 430,000 1.0006 CHOATE A 15 S 3 TR 18C 10015057500 S 03/2004 257,000 177,937 257,000 0.6924 CHOATE A 15 S 3 LT 1D-1-C 10015057601 S 02/2005 180,000 335,657 180,000 1.8648 CHOATE A 15 S 2 SUB LT 1 1001545700 A 190,818 250,709 0.7611 HARDING A 35 TR 1B 10035000205 A 168,780 238,536 0.7076 MORGAN A 56 TR 12 10056001101 A 234,402 247,556 0.9469 BB&CRR CO A 153 PT TR 4 & 10153000412 S 04/2004 235,000 231,862 235,000 0.9866 HICKS A 282 PT TR 9 & 10A 10282001220 S 12/2004 133,600 176,293 133,600 1.3196 HICKS A 282 PT TR 9 & 10B 10282001225 A 201,455 218,116 0.9236 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 3 TOTALS 2,727,249 2,804,233 0.9725 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 4 $ 463,155 - $ 1,298,425 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ LIVINGSTON FIELD OF DREAM L1375000100 A 481,327 739,143 0.6512 DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 010 TIME: 12:53:45 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 187/Polk VRSN: W 187-907/Livingston ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 4 $ 463,155 - $ 1,298,425 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ CHOATE A 15 PT TR 112 10015012701 A 493,052 958,117 0.5146 CHOATE A 15 TR 122 10015013650 A 895,081 1,031,146 0.8680 CHOATE A 15 TR 135-2 10015015015 A 831,499 677,001 1.2282 CHOATE A 15 TR 163-I 10015022585 A 475,284 528,341 0.8996 CHOATE A 15 TR 165D 10015023130 S 10/2004 630,000 589,085 630,000 0.9351 CHOATE A 15 TR 16C PT L 2 10015023600 A 496,817 530,736 0.9361 BB&CRR A 153 PT TRS 4 & 5 10153000403 A 852,644 994,536 0.8573 BB&CRR A 153 PT TR 4 & 5 10153000408 A 764,019 844,284 0.9049 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 4 TOTALS 5,878,808 6,933,304 0.8479 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 5 $ 1,298,426 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ LIVINGSTON VENTURES 10015012520 A 1,852,001 2,695,612 0.6870 CHOATE A 15 RE 110-F 10015012535 A 1,810,516 2,189,388 0.8270 CHOATE A 15 TR 121-A 10015013500 A 7,958,862 7,414,161 1.0735 CHOATE A 15 TR 168 10015023300 A 5,794,367 4,971,587 1.1655 MORGAN A 56 TR 207 & 204 10056017800 A 2,041,027 1,671,845 1.2208 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 5 TOTALS 19,456,773 18,942,593 1.0271 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM COMP SAMPLE STRATUM SAMPLE SAMPLE STRATUM STRATUM STRATUM CATEGORY _______ ____ ______ _______ ______ ______ _______ _______ _______ ________ CODE PARCELS PARCELS LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE LOCAL VALUE RATIO PTD VALUE RATIO ____ _______ _______ ___________ _________ ___________ _____ _________ _____ 1 U 0 310 0 0 5,093,040 5,093,040 2 R 15 295 1,192,384 1,252,064 24,181,371 0.9523 25,392,598 3 R 12 89 2,727,249 2,804,233 24,307,204 0.9725 24,994,554 4 R 9 29 5,878,808 6,933,304 24,924,197 0.8479 29,395,208 5 R 5 8 19,456,773 18,942,593 22,706,163 1.0271 22,107,062 TOTAL 41 731 29,255,214 29,932,194 101,211,975 106,982,462 0.9461 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 011 TIME: 12:53:45 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 187/Polk VRSN: W 187-907/Livingston ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - STRATUM 2 $ 10,303 - $ 63,533 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ AVS MUFFLER & SHOCKS BP000024000 A 17,663 8,660 2.0396 SECURITY FINANCE BP000678000 A 10,790 8,426 1.2806 PERFORMANCE CAR WASH BP004162200 A 11,974 114,091 0.1050 BIG THICKETT ORTHEPEDICS BP200024700 A 43,000 43,200 0.9954 BURGER KING BP940029100 A 33,210 30,642 1.0838 COINMATCH CORP BP980037751 A 14,108 5,706 2.4725 V & M CLEANERS BP990784000 A 14,400 9,754 1.4763 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 2 TOTALS 145,145 220,479 0.6583 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - STRATUM 3 $ 63,534 - $ 203,487 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ MARINE SALES AND SERVICE BP000113000 A 125,894 92,264 1.3645 GARDENS ALC BP001070000 A 77,745 58,191 1.3360 VFS FINANCING, INC BP002223200 A 199,123 183,635 1.0843 DL PETERSON TRUST BP970162500 A 101,781 95,235 1.0687 ALL STAR CARPET BP980016675 A 93,442 155,099 0.6025 PEOPLES STATE BANK BP990162500 A 99,128 69,987 1.4164 WELLS FARGO FINANCIAL P980147900 A 114,356 92,847 1.2317 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 3 TOTALS 811,469 747,258 1.0859 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - STRATUM 4 $ 203,488 - $ 1,140,552 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ SEARS ROEBUCK BP000675000 A 250,542 250,282 1.0010 VANITY FAIR FACTORY OUTLE BP000785060 A 714,366 393,056 1.8175 O'REILLY AUTO PARTS BP002158500 A 415,281 422,168 0.9837 PEYTO MEDICAL SUPPLY BP002160100 A 439,427 409,102 1.0741 JOE CLIFTON TRUCKING BP004107610 A 443,644 654,364 0.6780 CVS PHARMACY BP9400053000 A 862,684 826,550 1.0437 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 4 TOTALS 3,125,944 2,955,522 1.0577 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 012 TIME: 12:53:45 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 187/Polk VRSN: W 187-907/Livingston ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - STRATUM 5 $ 1,140,553 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ BROOKSHIRE BROS BP000095000 A 1,747,807 1,772,169 0.9863 WAL-MART BP000792000 A 8,457,725 8,486,208 0.9966 WINDHAM AND SONS BP000817000 A 1,508,120 1,283,700 1.1748 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 5 TOTALS 11,713,652 11,542,077 1.0149 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM COMP SAMPLE STRATUM SAMPLE SAMPLE STRATUM STRATUM STRATUM CATEGORY _______ ____ ______ _______ ______ ______ _______ _______ _______ ________ CODE PARCELS PARCELS LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE LOCAL VALUE RATIO PTD VALUE RATIO ____ _______ _______ ___________ _________ ___________ _____ _________ _____ 1 U 0 648 0 0 3,224,890 3,224,890 2 R 7 508 145,145 220,479 15,376,895 0.6583 23,358,492 3 R 7 110 811,469 747,258 15,370,849 1.0859 14,154,940 4 R 6 28 3,125,944 2,955,522 15,770,591 1.0577 14,910,269 5 R 3 4 11,713,652 11,542,077 14,706,550 1.0149 14,490,639 TOTAL 23 1,298 15,796,210 15,465,336 64,449,775 70,139,230 0.9189 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ **** END OF REPORT ****
