DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 001 TIME: 12:39:29 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 092/Gregg VRSN: W 092-904/Pine Tree ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 2 $ 44,791 - $ 87,560 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ AB 71 D FERGUSON SUR TR 2 R16712 S 09/2004 60,000 47,490 60,000 0.7915 AB 177 WM ROBINSON SUR TR R26129 S 05/2004 84,800 74,100 84,800 0.8738 AB 177 WM ROBINSON SUR TR R26142 S 10/2004 40,501 48,430 40,501 1.1958 AB 177 WM ROBINSON SUR TR R26158 S 02/2005 60,400 60,260 60,400 0.9977 AB 4 I C SKILLERN SUR TR R27731 S 09/2004 67,000 47,180 67,000 0.7042 AB 4 I C SKILLERN SUR TR R27806 S 05/2004 82,000 79,450 82,000 0.9689 LT 19 BLK 7 (NCB 3710) CL R38600 S 07/2004 105,000 86,560 105,000 0.8244 LT 2 BLK 1 (NCB 3380) COU R39013 S 12/2004 64,500 61,390 64,500 0.9518 LT 21 BLK 6 (NCB 3364) CO R39069 S 06/2004 62,500 57,940 62,500 0.9270 LT 1 BLK 2 (NCB 5003) CRE R39511 S 01/2005 94,000 86,430 94,000 0.9195 LT 8 BLK F (NCB 3753) HOW R41652 S 09/2004 91,500 71,310 91,500 0.7793 LTS 5A & 6 BLK X (NCB 373 R41788 S 01/2005 84,000 75,660 84,000 0.9007 LTS 10 & 11A BLK Z (NCB 3 R41802 S 12/2004 59,500 78,510 59,500 1.3195 LT 9 BLK 2 GLENDALE R44033 S 04/2004 84,500 74,340 84,500 0.8798 LT 6 BLK 1 (NCB 3799) GRA R44241 S 08/2004 100,000 85,140 100,000 0.8514 LT 17 BLK 3 (NCB 3703) GR R44935 S 04/2004 45,000 60,450 45,000 1.3433 LT 20 BLK 3 (NCB 3703) GR R44938 S 12/2004 65,000 47,260 65,000 0.7271 LTS 1 & 2 BLK 5 NCB 3700 R44968 S 07/2004 55,000 56,430 55,000 1.0260 LTS 14 & 15A BLK 5 GREENW R44980 S 12/2004 73,200 75,580 73,200 1.0325 LT 4 BLK 5 (NCB 3662) GRE R45157 S 01/2005 64,000 71,520 64,000 1.1175 LT 1 BLK 4 (NCB 3668) GRE R45300 S 12/2004 85,000 81,990 85,000 0.9646 LT 3 BLK 5 (NCB 3671) GRE R45307 S 09/2004 88,900 78,410 88,900 0.8820 LT 11 BLK 3640 LANDSDOWNE R51859 S 04/2004 68,500 70,240 68,500 1.0254 LT 4 BLK 3648 LANDSDOWNE R51925 S 08/2004 68,000 70,900 68,000 1.0426 LT 4 BLK 1 (NCB 3126) LAR R51975 S 12/2004 43,000 45,320 43,000 1.0540 LT 1 BLK C (NCB 3721) J W R52653 S 09/2004 70,000 66,310 70,000 0.9473 LT 8 BLK 2 (NCB 3614) LEE R52747 S 11/2004 65,000 55,450 65,000 0.8531 LT 12 BLK 2 (NCB 3614) LE R52750 S 01/2005 78,500 62,070 78,500 0.7907 LT 7 BLK 6 (NCB 3615) LEE R52804 S 05/2004 72,500 74,640 72,500 1.0295 LT 8 BLK 3 (NCB 3628) PIN R60292 S 09/2004 81,000 82,320 81,000 1.0163 LT 8 BLK 4 (NCB 3629) PIN R60305 S 12/2004 82,500 84,160 82,500 1.0201 LT 21 BLK 4 (NCB 3629) PI R60318 S 06/2004 86,000 84,550 86,000 0.9831 LT 5 BLK 5 (NCB 3630) PIN R60332 S 06/2004 63,125 74,820 63,125 1.1853 LT 12 BLK 3647 PINE HILL R60419 S 11/2004 70,755 68,130 70,755 0.9629 LT 2 BLK 11 (NCB 3375) PI R60521 S 08/2004 72,500 56,350 72,500 0.7772 LT 2 BLK 5 (NCB 3366) PIN R60525 S 02/2005 79,750 73,670 79,750 0.9238 LT 2 BLK 6 PINE TREE C C R60536 S 10/2004 55,500 61,630 55,500 1.1105 LT 21 BLK 6 (NCB 3376) PI R60555 S 04/2004 67,500 67,600 67,500 1.0015 LT 11 BLK 8 (NCB 3378) PI R60579 S 07/2004 71,000 56,310 71,000 0.7931 LT 5 BLK 11 (NCB 3375) PI R60591 S 04/2004 77,500 64,570 77,500 0.8332 LT 18 BLK 12 (NCB 3374) P R60626 S 10/2004 75,500 64,700 75,500 0.8570 LT 21 BLK 12 (NCB 3374) P R60629 S 01/2005 75,500 76,120 75,500 1.0082 DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 002 TIME: 12:39:29 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 092/Gregg VRSN: W 092-904/Pine Tree ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 2 $ 44,791 - $ 87,560 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ LT 23 BLK 12 (NCB 3374) P R60631 S 02/2005 75,000 65,910 75,000 0.8788 LT 11 BLK 3 PINE TREE C C R60637 S 06/2004 72,000 60,310 72,000 0.8376 LT 12 BLK 3505 PRESTONWOO R61555 S 10/2004 58,000 57,730 58,000 0.9953 LT 18 BLK 1 RIVER OAKS R63229 S 12/2004 85,500 55,670 85,500 0.6511 LTS 27B, 28A, 28B, 47I, & R63264 S 10/2004 69,000 51,280 69,000 0.7432 LT 2 BLK 3 (NCB 3007) (N R63278 S 04/2004 63,000 53,480 63,000 0.8489 LT 3 BLK 3639 SHADOWVIEW R64675 S 08/2004 79,000 80,600 79,000 1.0203 LT 5 BLK 1 TANGLEWOOD R67784 S 12/2004 73,500 66,000 73,500 0.8980 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 2 TOTALS 3,356,670 3,614,931 0.9286 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 3 $ 87,561 - $ 115,880 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ AB 4 I C SKILLERN SUR TR R27591 S 01/2005 95,000 96,490 95,000 1.0157 AB 4 I C SKILLERN SUR TR R27792 S 06/2004 128,000 107,740 128,000 0.8417 AB 4 I C SKILLERN SUR TR R27803 S 05/2004 101,500 93,600 101,500 0.9222 AB 4 I C SKILLERN SUR TR R27808 S 06/2004 101,500 92,310 101,500 0.9095 LT 8 BLK 4173 BRIAR MEADO R36730 S 11/2004 114,900 106,350 114,900 0.9256 LT 1 BLK 3 (NCB 3729) CLE R38519 S 07/2004 105,000 106,520 105,000 1.0145 LT 6 BLK 6 (NCB 3709) CLE R38562 S 06/2004 96,500 94,970 96,500 0.9841 LT 24 BLK 6 (NCB 3709) CL R38580 S 08/2004 119,500 106,380 119,500 0.8902 LT 2 BLK 8 (NCB 3711) CLE R38608 S 09/2004 105,000 112,410 105,000 1.0706 LT 1 BLK 3699 CLEARMONT A R38663 S 12/2004 91,000 99,920 91,000 1.0980 LT 13 BLK 3698 CLEARMONT R38702 S 08/2004 115,000 113,730 115,000 0.9890 LT 18 BLK 3510 CLEARWOOD R38732 S 05/2004 116,000 110,070 116,000 0.9489 LT 7 BLK 2 (NCB 5003) CRE R39517 S 05/2004 116,500 106,120 116,500 0.9109 LT 12 BLK 3 (NCB 5004) CR R39539 S 12/2004 118,000 104,080 118,000 0.8820 LTS 9A & 10 BLK O (NCB 37 R41743 S 11/2004 89,900 92,130 89,900 1.0248 LTS 13A & 14 BLK Z (NCB 3 R41805 S 02/2005 93,000 87,700 93,000 0.9430 LT 16 BLK 7 EVERGREEN HIL R42051 S 04/2004 104,000 96,940 104,000 0.9321 LT 38 BLK 2 (NCB 5041) EV R42122 S 06/2004 92,000 96,040 92,000 1.0439 LT 3 BLK 6 (NCB 5043) EVE R42127 S 06/2004 102,500 104,440 102,500 1.0189 LT 13 BLK 5043 EVERGREEN R42170 S 06/2004 107,900 106,110 107,900 0.9834 LT 14 BLK 5029 EVERGREEN R42192 S 07/2004 112,000 106,070 112,000 0.9471 LT 5 BLK 5045 EVERGREEN H R42226 S 08/2004 99,500 101,370 99,500 1.0188 LT 17 BLK 3 GARDEN ACRES R43683 S 07/2004 89,500 88,060 89,500 0.9839 LT 2 BLK 1 (NCB 3669) GRE R45286 S 08/2004 97,000 96,120 97,000 0.9909 LT 6 BLK 5 (NCB 3671) GRE R45310 S 10/2004 98,500 97,520 98,500 0.9901 LT 2 BLK 15 (NCB 4108) HE R46624 S 04/2004 99,000 89,100 99,000 0.9000 DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 003 TIME: 12:39:29 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 092/Gregg VRSN: W 092-904/Pine Tree ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 3 $ 87,561 - $ 115,880 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ LT 22 BLK 5 (NCB 4115) HE R46696 S 08/2004 89,000 90,430 89,000 1.0161 LT 3 BLK 5020 HIALEAH UNI R46911 S 12/2004 122,500 114,080 122,500 0.9313 LT 7 BLK 5021 HIALEAH UNI R46922 S 01/2005 120,000 113,210 120,000 0.9434 LT 10 BLK 5015 HIALEAH UN R46970 S 05/2004 127,000 114,820 127,000 0.9041 LT 12 BLK 5015 HIALEAH UN R46972 S 11/2004 117,000 113,090 117,000 0.9666 LT 1 BLK 5016 HIALEAH UNI R47006 S 01/2005 132,000 112,570 132,000 0.8528 LT 6 BLK 2 MILL RUN R55022 S 02/2005 118,000 110,820 118,000 0.9392 LT 5A & 6 BLK 3 MILL RUN R55031 S 04/2004 99,000 94,070 99,000 0.9502 LT 1 BLK 5 MILL RUN R55054 S 05/2004 120,000 112,800 120,000 0.9400 LT 6 BLK 5 MILL RUN R55059 S 12/2004 125,000 108,430 125,000 0.8674 LT 10 OAK FOREST R57987 S 08/2004 119,900 96,410 119,900 0.8041 LT 5 BLK 6007 OAK FOREST R58111 S 07/2004 120,000 107,680 120,000 0.8973 LT 8 BLK 6007 OAK FOREST R58114 S 12/2004 126,500 112,020 126,500 0.8855 LT 4 BLK 9 (NCB 3634) PIN R60374 S 12/2004 96,000 109,240 96,000 1.1379 LT 17 BLK 3505 PRESTONWOO R61573 S 12/2004 101,455 105,620 101,455 1.0411 LT 19 BLK 3505 PRESTONWOO R61575 S 12/2004 100,000 98,530 100,000 0.9853 LT 5 BLK 5032 RAVEN CREST R62207 S 04/2004 102,000 107,420 102,000 1.0531 LT 6 BLK 5032 RAVEN CREST R62208 S 04/2004 110,000 104,560 110,000 0.9505 LT 5 BLK 1 (NCB 3465) ROC R63680 S 07/2004 102,000 88,890 102,000 0.8715 LT 16 & 17A BLK 4157 (W P R64320 S 08/2004 115,000 115,090 115,000 1.0008 LT 3 BLK 1 RUTHLYNN TERRA R64359 S 04/2004 97,954 100,550 97,954 1.0265 LT 4 BLK 5072 SHENANDOAH R64886 S 10/2004 105,000 105,430 105,000 1.0041 LT 23 BLK 5073 SHENANDOAH R64924 S 08/2004 97,500 93,830 97,500 0.9624 LT 27 BLK 5073 (E80' LT 2 R64928 S 10/2004 97,000 102,480 97,000 1.0565 LT 5 BLK 5075 SHENANDOAH R64942 S 05/2004 101,000 98,630 101,000 0.9765 LT 6 BLK 5075 SHENANDOAH R64943 S 09/2004 118,000 111,570 118,000 0.9455 LT 7 BLK 3315 E TALL TIMB R67603 S 11/2004 113,000 108,820 113,000 0.9630 LT 3 BLK 1 TANGLEWOOD R67782 S 06/2004 98,500 93,200 98,500 0.9462 LT 7 BLK 3727 TANGLEWOOD R67818 S 11/2004 112,000 97,460 112,000 0.8702 LT 14 BLK 5061 WAIN MANOR R69984 S 10/2004 86,000 99,220 86,000 1.1537 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 3 TOTALS 5,753,260 5,996,509 0.9594 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 4 $ 115,881 - $ 171,580 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ LT 11 BLK 1 COTTON VALLEY R101011 S 01/2005 144,500 142,550 144,500 0.9865 LT 7 BLK 1 DUNDEE PLACE P R109187 S 07/2004 165,000 171,500 165,000 1.0394 LT 3 BLK 1 HENDRIX COURT R195239 S 01/2005 135,000 133,670 135,000 0.9901 AB 177 WM ROBINSON SUR TR R25881 S 08/2004 134,000 125,750 134,000 0.9384 DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 004 TIME: 12:39:29 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 092/Gregg VRSN: W 092-904/Pine Tree ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 4 $ 115,881 - $ 171,580 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ AB 177 WM ROBINSON SUR TR R26119 S 09/2004 132,000 126,060 132,000 0.9550 LT 10 BLK 4170 BRIAR MEAD R36694 S 06/2004 125,500 120,150 125,500 0.9574 LT 6 BLK 4173 BRIAR MEADO R36728 S 08/2004 140,000 129,790 140,000 0.9271 LT 4 BLK 9 EVERGREEN HILL R42069 S 11/2004 160,000 159,463 160,000 0.9966 LT 8 BLK 5021 HIALEAH UNI R46923 S 08/2004 120,000 121,260 120,000 1.0105 LT 4 BLK 5014 HIALEAH UNI R46952 S 07/2004 117,500 124,100 117,500 1.0562 LT 12 BLK 5014 HIALEAH UN R46960 S 07/2004 132,000 122,050 132,000 0.9246 LT 21 BLK 5017 HIALEAH UN R47041 S 08/2004 133,000 120,220 133,000 0.9039 LT 1 BLK 7 MILL RUN R55072 S 10/2004 200,000 166,170 200,000 0.8309 LT 4 BLK 8 MILL RUN R55082 S 08/2004 138,500 127,540 138,500 0.9209 LT 6 BLK 8 MILL RUN R55084 S 05/2004 113,000 116,570 113,000 1.0316 LT 2 BLK 1 MILL RUN #2 R55089 S 06/2004 157,500 160,050 157,500 1.0162 LT 3 BLK 2 MILL RUN #2 R55099 S 08/2004 166,000 151,020 166,000 0.9098 LT 10 BLK 5082 NORTHRIDGE R57130 S 12/2004 140,000 142,070 140,000 1.0148 LT 6 BLK 5084 NORTHRIDGE R57135 S 09/2004 140,525 133,060 140,525 0.9469 LT 2 BLK 5086 NORTHRIDGE R57153 S 06/2004 140,000 144,740 140,000 1.0339 LT 5 BLK 5085 NORTHRIDGE R57181 S 02/2005 166,500 168,510 166,500 1.0121 LT 7 BLK 5085 NORTHRIDGE R57183 S 12/2004 145,000 153,400 145,000 1.0579 LT 2 BLK 5091 NORTHRIDGE R57218 S 05/2004 155,000 138,230 155,000 0.8918 LT 11 BLK 2 (NCB 6015) OA R57902 S 06/2004 110,000 134,760 110,000 1.2251 LT 26 BLK 6014 OAK CREEK R57945 S 12/2004 172,500 142,610 172,500 0.8267 LT 11 BLK 6005 OAK FOREST R58076 S 05/2004 141,500 119,510 141,500 0.8446 LT 3 BLK 6007 OAK FOREST R58109 S 12/2004 160,000 146,870 160,000 0.9179 LT 11 BLK 6000 OAKLAWN MA R58701 S 04/2004 133,000 127,410 133,000 0.9580 LT 5 BLK 3688 PINE TREE H R60728 S 01/2005 140,000 127,900 140,000 0.9136 LT 17 BLK 6 (NCB 5008) PO R61487 S 04/2004 130,000 128,170 130,000 0.9859 LTS 18 & 19A BLK 6 PONDER R61488 S 10/2004 119,300 129,040 119,300 1.0816 LT 19 BLK 4007 ROCKWALL E R63540 S 11/2004 163,000 158,320 163,000 0.9713 LT 8 BLK 4000 ROCKWALL MA R63553 S 08/2004 169,000 159,320 169,000 0.9427 LT 2 BLK 4004 ROCKWALL MA R63613 S 10/2004 131,000 144,520 131,000 1.1032 LT 3 BLK 4006 ROCKWALL MA R63628 S 02/2005 135,000 129,870 135,000 0.9620 LTS 1 & 2A BLK 5 (NCB 348 R63711 S 11/2004 175,000 163,650 175,000 0.9351 LT 1 BLK 7 ROCKWALL PLACE R63717 S 03/2005 175,000 140,490 175,000 0.8028 LT 4 BLK 5070 SHENANDOAH R64977 S 10/2004 151,500 136,620 151,500 0.9018 LT 6 BLK 5 SPRING RIDGE H R66649 S 02/2005 119,000 117,120 119,000 0.9842 LT 14 BLK 3315-E TALL TIM R67614 S 02/2005 123,500 119,010 123,500 0.9636 LT 5 BLK 3315 F TALL TIMB R67621 S 06/2004 139,500 137,870 139,500 0.9883 LT 14 BLK 3315-A TALL TIM R67631 S 06/2004 120,500 116,600 120,500 0.9676 LT 10 BLK 3906 WHISPERING R70876 S 08/2004 149,700 149,500 149,700 0.9987 LT 1 BLK 3909 WHISPERING R70899 S 11/2004 125,000 128,540 125,000 1.0283 LTS 12A & 13 BLK 3905 WHI R70963 S 09/2004 167,500 162,150 167,500 0.9681 LT 6 BLK 3900 WHISPERING R70974 S 10/2004 190,000 166,870 190,000 0.8783 LT 8 BLK 7020 WILDWOOD UN R71429 S 05/2004 165,500 155,200 165,500 0.9378 DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 005 TIME: 12:39:29 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 092/Gregg VRSN: W 092-904/Pine Tree ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 4 $ 115,881 - $ 171,580 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ LT 13 BLK 7008 WILDWOOD U R71528 S 05/2004 149,000 150,230 149,000 1.0083 LT 7 BLK 7032 WILDWOOD UN R71550 S 06/2004 133,000 136,340 133,000 1.0251 LT 20 BLK 7032 WILDWOOD U R71595 S 11/2004 179,000 169,230 179,000 0.9454 LT 24 BLK 7028 WILDWOOD # R71718 S 12/2004 157,500 157,350 157,500 0.9990 LT 6 BLK 1 WOODCREEK R72466 S 09/2004 125,500 121,900 125,500 0.9713 LT 15 & 16A BLK 1 WOODCRE R72475 S 04/2004 129,900 127,450 129,900 0.9811 LT 18 BLK 1 DEER PARK #1 R82266 S 04/2004 126,000 131,530 126,000 1.0439 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 4 TOTALS 7,533,873 7,806,425 0.9651 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 5 $ 171,581 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ LT 12 BLK 1 FAIRWAY OAKS R100313 S 08/2004 398,000 338,030 398,000 0.8493 LOT 7 BLK 7027 WILDWOOD U R102138 S 09/2004 206,900 209,080 206,900 1.0105 LT 16 BLK 2 DUNDEE PLACE R109203 S 05/2004 178,500 181,010 178,500 1.0141 LT 5 BLK 1 DUNDEE PLACE P R180854 S 09/2004 190,000 190,670 190,000 1.0035 LT 6 BLK 1 DUNDEE PLACE P R180855 S 12/2004 176,000 177,480 176,000 1.0084 LT 7 BLK 2 DUNDEE PLACE P R180866 S 02/2005 188,000 188,230 188,000 1.0012 LT 10 BLK 2 DUNDEE PLACE R180869 S 08/2004 185,000 180,740 185,000 0.9770 LT 6 BLK 1 WILDWOOD UNIT R181767 S 11/2004 259,000 258,430 259,000 0.9978 LT 2 BLK 2 MILL RUN #2 R55098 S 02/2005 209,000 209,780 209,000 1.0037 LT 12 BLK 2 MILL RUN #2 R55108 S 09/2004 179,000 175,290 179,000 0.9793 LT 4 BLK 5080 NORTHRIDGE R57223 S 04/2004 200,000 190,530 200,000 0.9527 LT 20 & 21A BLK 5085 NORT R57238 S 10/2004 196,900 187,610 196,900 0.9528 LT 8 BLK 5091 NORTHRIDGE R57266 S 07/2004 202,000 202,410 202,000 1.0020 LT 4 BLK 4157 ROYAL FORES R64305 S 02/2005 176,000 172,300 176,000 0.9790 LT 11 BLK 3682 WARD PLACE R70040 S 11/2004 181,000 171,680 181,000 0.9485 LT 20 BLK 3908 WHISPERING R71001 S 06/2004 241,250 233,140 241,250 0.9664 LT 6 BLK 3910 WHISPERING R71017 S 06/2004 212,500 218,370 212,500 1.0276 LT 13 BLK 3911 WHISPERING R71044 S 04/2004 228,000 235,640 228,000 1.0335 LT 4 BLK 7003 WILDWOOD UN R71322 S 12/2004 260,000 267,680 260,000 1.0295 LT 12 BLK 7003 WILDWOOD U R71330 S 01/2005 200,000 204,460 200,000 1.0223 LT 14 BLK 7010 WILDWOOD U R71398 S 12/2004 208,000 199,700 208,000 0.9601 LT 7 BLK 7012 WILDWOOD UN R71419 S 05/2004 274,050 280,180 274,050 1.0224 LT 8 BLK 7012 WILDWOOD UN R71420 S 08/2004 232,000 227,510 232,000 0.9806 LT 10 BLK 7012 WILDWOOD U R71422 S 02/2005 191,000 181,380 191,000 0.9496 LT 6 BLK 7016 WILDWOOD UN R71485 S 01/2005 271,600 266,710 271,600 0.9820 L 5 B 7007 WILDWOOD UNIT R71522 S 08/2004 195,000 191,470 195,000 0.9819 LT 1 BLK 7032 WILDWOOD UN R71544 S 08/2004 180,000 183,750 180,000 1.0208 LT 1 BLK 7033 WILDWOOD UN R71603 S 07/2004 210,000 201,230 210,000 0.9582 DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 006 TIME: 12:39:29 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 092/Gregg VRSN: W 092-904/Pine Tree ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 5 $ 171,581 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ LT 10 BLK 7024 WILDWOOD U R71626 S 10/2004 236,000 237,940 236,000 1.0082 LT 5 BLK 7025 WILDWOOD UN R71631 S 07/2004 233,000 236,600 233,000 1.0155 LT 12 BLK 7018 WILDWOOD U R71639 S 08/2004 218,000 203,340 218,000 0.9328 LT 11 BLK 7019 WILDWOOD U R71649 S 07/2004 239,000 219,080 239,000 0.9167 LT 18 BLK 7019 WILDWOOD U R71652 S 08/2004 200,000 186,420 200,000 0.9321 LT 21 BLK 7029 WILDWOOD U R71677 S 12/2004 225,000 224,950 225,000 0.9998 LT 25 BLK 7029 WILDWOOD U R71681 S 06/2004 251,000 262,090 251,000 1.0442 LT 11 BLK 7033 WILDWOOD U R71690 S 01/2005 225,000 208,730 225,000 0.9277 LT 13 BLK 7033 WILDWOOD U R71692 S 08/2004 248,000 259,640 248,000 1.0469 LTS 9 & 8 BLK 7028 WILDWO R71703 S 12/2004 168,000 178,170 168,000 1.0605 LT 16 BLK 7016 WILDWOOD U R71724 S 05/2004 465,000 454,440 465,000 0.9773 LTS 6 & 6A BLK 7026 WILDW R82300 S 12/2004 189,900 188,060 189,900 0.9903 LT 11 BLK 7026 WILDWOOD # R82305 S 07/2004 190,650 194,710 190,650 1.0213 LT 14 BLK 7029 WILDWOOD # R87048 S 10/2004 430,000 428,080 430,000 0.9955 LT 15 BLK 7030 WILDWOOD # R87066 S 06/2004 383,000 381,610 383,000 0.9964 LT 1 BLK 1 CAMILLE ADDN R98741 S 05/2004 190,000 192,910 190,000 1.0153 LT 7 BLK 1 CAMILLE ADDN R98748 S 02/2005 188,000 192,060 188,000 1.0216 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 5 TOTALS 10,173,320 10,308,250 0.9869 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM COMP SAMPLE STRATUM SAMPLE SAMPLE STRATUM STRATUM STRATUM CATEGORY _______ ____ ______ _______ ______ ______ _______ _______ _______ ________ CODE PARCELS PARCELS LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE LOCAL VALUE RATIO PTD VALUE RATIO ____ _______ _______ ___________ _________ ___________ _____ _________ _____ 1 U 0 1,281 0 0 34,559,925 34,559,925 2 R 50 2,292 3,356,670 3,614,931 164,073,310 0.9286 176,688,897 3 R 56 1,572 5,753,260 5,996,509 164,214,878 0.9594 171,164,142 4 R 54 1,112 7,533,873 7,806,425 163,768,045 0.9651 169,690,234 5 R 45 656 10,173,320 10,308,250 163,958,794 0.9869 166,135,165 TOTAL 205 6,913 26,817,123 27,726,115 690,574,952 718,238,363 0.9615 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 007 TIME: 12:39:29 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 092/Gregg VRSN: W 092-904/Pine Tree ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY B - STRATUM 2 $ 40,171 - $ 76,050 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ LT 14 BLK 3513 CLEARWOOD R38781 A 70,800 67,150 1.0544 LT 4 BLK 5 (NCB 3362A) CO R39041 S 11/2004 74,500 61,880 74,500 0.8306 LTS 7 & 8A BLK 6 COUNTRY R39055 A 64,090 65,066 0.9850 LTS 12, 13A BLK 6 COUNTRY R39059 A 45,740 48,687 0.9395 LT 23 BLK 1 HILLCREST R47513 A 41,190 42,721 0.9642 LTS 30A & 31A OAK FOREST R58011 A 47,790 46,407 1.0298 LT 9 BLK 3315-H TALL TIMB R67660 A 66,730 69,591 0.9589 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 2 TOTALS 398,220 414,122 0.9616 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY B - STRATUM 3 $ 76,051 - $ 94,340 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ LT 8 BLK 4200 DELTA DOWNS R39918 A 76,950 73,670 1.0445 LT 21 BLK 3309 PINE TREE R60684 A 77,480 72,535 1.0682 LT 6 BLK 3784 QUAIL CREEK R61682 A 83,540 86,472 0.9661 LTS 13A,13B 3784 QUAIL CR R61689 A 88,290 92,027 0.9594 LT 15 BLK 3784 QUAIL CREE R61693 A 85,140 78,286 1.0876 LT 17 BLK 3801 SHADOW-WOO R64795 S 02/2005 83,000 84,560 83,000 1.0188 LT 5 BLK 3323A TALL TIMBE R67705 A 84,540 66,580 1.2698 LT 11 BLK 3776 WINCHESTER R72235 A 89,980 87,925 1.0234 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 3 TOTALS 670,480 640,495 1.0468 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY B - STRATUM 4 $ 94,341 - $ 2,360,000 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ AB 177 WM ROBINSON TR 86 R26195 A 94,910 110,896 0.8558 AB 4 I C SKILLERN SUR TR R27677 A 140,280 128,826 1.0889 LT 10 BLK 3520 FARIMONT R42266 A 108,100 121,074 0.8928 LT 17 BLK H GEO JONES EST R49581 A 155,150 152,850 1.0150 LT 4 BLK 3323 TALL TIMBER R67679 A 98,340 96,184 1.0224 LT 8 BLK 3777 WINCHESTER R72222 A 120,080 115,351 1.0410 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 4 TOTALS 716,860 725,181 0.9885 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 008 TIME: 12:39:29 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 092/Gregg VRSN: W 092-904/Pine Tree ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY B - STRATUM 5 $ 2,360,001 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ AB 4 I C SKILLERN TRS 36, R28050 R28049 A 4,489,310 5,699,080 0.7877 AB 4 I C SKILLERN SUR TR R28053 A 3,344,030 3,634,656 0.9200 LT 1 BLK 3 HICKORY RIDGE R47077 A 2,920,770 2,737,000 1.0671 LT 2,1 BLK 1,3 HICKORY RI R47077 R47075 A 7,407,475 7,216,224 1.0265 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 5 TOTALS 18,161,585 19,286,960 0.9417 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY B - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM COMP SAMPLE STRATUM SAMPLE SAMPLE STRATUM STRATUM STRATUM CATEGORY _______ ____ ______ _______ ______ ______ _______ _______ _______ ________ CODE PARCELS PARCELS LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE LOCAL VALUE RATIO PTD VALUE RATIO ____ _______ _______ ___________ _________ ___________ _____ _________ _____ 1 U 0 97 0 0 3,214,027 3,214,027 2 R 7 254 398,220 414,122 15,279,978 0.9616 15,890,160 3 R 8 186 670,480 640,495 15,283,655 1.0468 14,600,358 4 R 6 63 716,860 725,181 17,039,531 0.9885 17,237,765 5 C 4 4 18,161,585 19,286,960 18,161,585 0.9417 19,286,960 TOTAL 25 604 19,947,145 21,066,758 68,978,776 70,229,270 0.9822 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 009 TIME: 12:39:29 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 092/Gregg VRSN: W 092-904/Pine Tree ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 2 $ 52,241 - $ 188,020 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ LT 3 BLK 1 GREGGTON BUSIN R113330 A 102,120 119,319 0.8559 LT 1 BLK 1 WEST IND BUS P R183161 A 92,040 87,320 1.0541 AB 177 WM ROBINSON SUR TR R25570 S 09/2004 89,500 103,370 89,500 1.1550 AB 4 I C SKILLERN SUR TR R27910 S 12/2004 60,000 85,740 60,000 1.4290 AB 4 I C SKILLERN SUR TR R27966 S 12/2004 175,000 103,360 175,000 0.5906 WESTERN PT OF LT 16 BLK A R49540 A 83,920 73,762 1.1377 LT 2A & 3A BLK 4 NORTH DI R56222 A 79,650 80,794 0.9858 AB 124 J LAGRONE SUR TR 8 R92753 A 137,150 143,162 0.9580 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 2 TOTALS 787,350 828,857 0.9499 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 3 $ 188,021 - $ 444,940 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ AB 71 D FERGUSON SUR TR 7 R16777 A 257,280 228,846 1.1242 AB 71 D FERGUSON SUR TR 8 R16785 S 04/2004 255,000 210,790 255,000 0.8266 AB 77 S T FORD SUR TR 9 R17020 A 334,770 339,318 0.9866 AB 177 WM ROBINSON SUR TR R26076 A 234,190 241,543 0.9696 AB 4 I C SKILLERN TR 164 R27741 A 241,740 282,058 0.8571 AB 4 I C SKILLERN SUR TRS R28056 A 194,920 207,770 0.9382 LT 1A BLK 2 BELLADONNA #1 R36032 A 240,950 262,084 0.9194 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 3 TOTALS 1,714,640 1,816,619 0.9439 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 4 $ 444,941 - $ 1,043,860 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ AB 256 M MANN TR 20-02 SE R187818 A 475,490 467,082 1.0180 AB 124 J LAGRONE SUR TR 1 R21515 S 09/2004 675,000 458,620 675,000 0.6794 AB 176 J RUDDLE SUR TR 35 R26334 A 682,790 681,555 1.0018 AB 4 I C SKILLERN SUR TR R27952 A 784,600 758,802 1.0340 LTS 1B & 1B-1 BLK 1 HICKO R47069 A 623,620 602,633 1.0348 LT 1 BLK 1 CASSITY'S CORN R99008 A 660,410 1,010,292 0.6537 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 4 TOTALS 3,685,530 4,195,364 0.8785 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 010 TIME: 12:39:29 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 092/Gregg VRSN: W 092-904/Pine Tree ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 5 $ 1,043,861 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ AB 71 D FERGUSON SUR TR 2 R16826 A 2,732,260 2,795,687 0.9773 LT 1 BLK 1 NORTHWEST MEDI R195963 A 2,270,380 1,936,539 1.1724 LT 2 BLK 1 PARK PLACE R59336 A 1,759,110 1,768,668 0.9946 LT 2 NCB 4220 PINETREE SH R60949 A 1,863,180 1,838,193 1.0136 LT 2 BLK 1 MCWHORTER CENT R87094 A 2,421,204 2,848,328 0.8500 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 5 TOTALS 11,046,134 11,187,415 0.9874 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM COMP SAMPLE STRATUM SAMPLE SAMPLE STRATUM STRATUM STRATUM CATEGORY _______ ____ ______ _______ ______ ______ _______ _______ _______ ________ CODE PARCELS PARCELS LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE LOCAL VALUE RATIO PTD VALUE RATIO ____ _______ _______ ___________ _________ ___________ _____ _________ _____ 1 U 0 204 0 0 6,777,967 6,777,967 2 R 8 259 787,350 828,857 31,953,340 0.9499 33,638,636 3 R 7 101 1,714,640 1,816,619 31,939,514 0.9439 33,837,815 4 R 6 41 3,685,530 4,195,364 32,887,811 0.8785 37,436,324 5 R 5 14 11,046,134 11,187,415 30,959,132 0.9874 31,354,195 TOTAL 26 619 17,233,654 18,028,255 134,517,764 143,044,937 0.9404 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 011 TIME: 12:39:29 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 092/Gregg VRSN: W 092-904/Pine Tree ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - STRATUM 2 $ 21,001 - $ 142,010 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ MARATHON OIL CO P112007 A 63,040 63,041 1.0000 FOOD FAST HOLDINGS P114552 A 74,630 73,031 1.0219 E-Z WASH P188401 A 126,870 128,553 0.9869 CAB EAST LLC P196973 A 90,320 94,604 0.9547 TEXTRON FINANCIAL CORP P197033 A 66,690 63,417 1.0516 MSC INDUSTRIAL SUPPLY P81141 A 68,230 67,640 1.0087 E-Z HINGE CON INC P92381 A 91,520 112,820 0.8112 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 2 TOTALS 581,300 603,106 0.9638 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - STRATUM 3 $ 142,011 - $ 355,560 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ INTERNATIONAL GOLF DISCOU P111559 A 147,810 175,063 0.8443 CROWN KIA P114300 A 193,290 155,276 1.2448 HIBERNIA NATIONAL BANK P181207 A 187,960 156,260 1.2029 EAST TEXAS FASTENERS P181475 A 296,380 292,261 1.0141 WEYERHAEUSER CO P183468 A 279,880 279,878 1.0000 COURTHOUSE P75663 A 167,380 214,678 0.7797 CONTINENTAL LUMBER PRODUC P92251 A 224,090 224,089 1.0000 TEGRON LP P92389 A 216,250 233,495 0.9261 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 3 TOTALS 1,713,040 1,731,000 0.9896 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - STRATUM 4 $ 355,561 - $ 1,053,010 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ ABC AUTO PARTS P102752 A 491,090 458,224 1.0717 OLMSTED-KIRK P185532 A 470,840 464,676 1.0133 ADVANCE AUTO PARTS #10601 P188402 A 394,990 381,231 1.0361 MASTER AUDIO VISUAL P76000 A 672,910 667,672 1.0078 BASS ENGINEERING CO P77420 A 820,130 892,123 0.9193 LAFAMA FOODS INC P79255 A 647,850 687,266 0.9426 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 4 TOTALS 3,497,810 3,551,192 0.9850 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 01/23/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 012 TIME: 12:39:29 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 092/Gregg VRSN: W 092-904/Pine Tree ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - STRATUM 5 $ 1,053,011 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ FNBC LEASING CORP P104691 A 2,274,080 2,040,707 1.1144 US BANCORP EQUIP FIN INC P186881 A 1,130,890 864,320 1.3084 EFC VALVE & CONTROLS P77571 A 1,094,840 1,107,497 0.9886 WAL-MART STORES EAST INC P80110 A 8,392,760 8,401,911 0.9989 ALBERTSONS P80831 A 1,655,740 1,675,342 0.9883 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 5 TOTALS 14,548,310 14,089,777 1.0325 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM COMP SAMPLE STRATUM SAMPLE SAMPLE STRATUM STRATUM STRATUM CATEGORY _______ ____ ______ _______ ______ ______ _______ _______ _______ ________ CODE PARCELS PARCELS LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE LOCAL VALUE RATIO PTD VALUE RATIO ____ _______ _______ ___________ _________ ___________ _____ _________ _____ 1 U 0 663 0 0 5,726,294 5,726,294 2 R 7 412 581,300 603,106 27,156,001 0.9638 28,175,971 3 R 8 104 1,713,040 1,731,000 27,248,196 0.9896 27,534,555 4 R 6 37 3,497,810 3,551,192 27,214,183 0.9850 27,628,612 5 R 5 13 14,548,310 14,089,777 26,770,182 1.0325 25,927,537 TOTAL 26 1,229 20,340,460 19,975,075 114,114,856 114,992,969 0.9924 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ **** END OF REPORT ****
