DATE: 06/29/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 001 TIME: 12:49:54 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 146/Liberty VRSN: W 146-901/Cleveland ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 2 $ 17,141 - $ 45,700 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ RICE, BLOCK 2, LOT 35 36 101548 S 11/2004 38,400 26,080 38,400 0.6792 PINE BEND, BLOCK 1, LOT 4 125356 S 02/2005 39,000 27,430 39,000 0.7033 000136 R BARROW, TRACT 63 125562 S 01/2004 36,000 37,480 36,000 1.0411 IMPROVEMENT ONLY MOBILE H 138476 S 07/2004 38,000 30,090 38,000 0.7918 SOUTHERN CROSSING, SEC 4, 138782 S 02/2005 47,000 44,950 47,000 0.9564 000170 THOMAS DEVER, TRAC 144203 S 02/2004 19,800 19,290 19,800 0.9742 000441 JOSEPH FENNER, TRA 29518 S 09/2004 30,000 30,860 30,000 1.0287 COX-GARVEY-CLEV, BLOCK 29 37816 S 01/2005 26,000 34,830 26,000 1.3396 GLEN PARK-CLEV, BLOCK 4, 48781 S 04/2004 35,000 35,700 35,000 1.0200 GLEN PARK-CLEV, BLOCK 59, 48972 S 01/2005 38,500 32,290 38,500 0.8387 HARVEST ACRES, SEC 3, BLO 52815 S 07/2004 78,000 45,250 77,300 0.5854 HARVEST ACRES LT PT 22 52916 S 05/2004 51,000 34,390 51,000 0.6743 MCGINNIS, BLOCK 5, LOT 3 59234 S 10/2004 37,500 38,340 37,500 1.0224 MERCY, LOT 38 39 59600 S 01/2005 21,500 32,230 21,500 1.4991 NORTH CLEVELAND, BLOCK 9, 60429 S 08/2004 21,000 26,540 21,000 1.2638 PARKER-CLEV, BLOCK 2, LOT 63162 S 01/2004 18,500 18,750 18,500 1.0135 POST OAK MANNOR, LOT 16, 64581 S 02/2005 38,703 42,700 38,703 1.1033 TANGLEWOOD, BLOCK 5, LOT 70637 S 08/2004 45,000 39,860 45,000 0.8858 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 2 TOTALS 597,060 658,203 0.9071 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 3 $ 45,701 - $ 66,590 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ 000306 M B LAWRENCE, TRAC 121766 S 10/2004 102,150 62,810 102,150 0.6149 SOUTHERN OAKS, BLOCK 2, S 128953 S 04/2004 83,230 63,310 83,230 0.7607 SOUTHERN CROSSING, SEC 3, 137686 S 05/2004 65,000 63,440 65,000 0.9760 000306 M B LAWRENCE, TRAC 138730 S 05/2004 45,900 51,440 45,900 1.1207 000339 WM ROBERTS, TRACT 147655 S 08/2004 55,000 54,660 55,000 0.9938 000168 J C DEVERS, TRACT 22635 S 03/2004 60,000 60,770 60,000 1.0128 000168 J C DEVERS, TRACT 22637 S 11/2004 45,000 63,500 45,000 1.4111 000209 C HARPER, TRACT 40 24079 S 01/2005 67,875 50,300 67,875 0.7411 000209 C HARPER, TRACT 46 24087 S 04/2004 60,705 59,680 60,705 0.9831 000339 WM ROBERTS, TRACT 27093 S 05/2004 40,000 52,820 40,000 1.3205 000352 JAMES TAYLOR, TRAC 27631 S 07/2004 56,700 57,080 56,700 1.0067 000394 T J WILLIAMS, TRAC 28532 S 03/2005 55,000 52,570 55,000 0.9558 DATE: 06/29/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 002 TIME: 12:49:54 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 146/Liberty VRSN: W 146-901/Cleveland ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 3 $ 45,701 - $ 66,590 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ 000432 JOHN BREEDING, TRA 29270 S 11/2004 74,850 58,630 74,850 0.7833 000432 JOHN BREEDING, TRA 29272 S 01/2005 69,000 48,510 69,000 0.7030 000977 WILLIAM WILLS, TRA 32426 S 03/2004 63,000 47,910 63,000 0.7605 BRIAR OAKS, BLOCK 3, LOT 35515 S 03/2004 57,500 61,360 57,500 1.0671 COX-GARVEY-CLEV, BLOCK 20 37738 S 03/2004 92,750 62,590 92,750 0.6748 COX-GARVEY-CLEV, BLOCK 26 37794 S 05/2004 33,000 49,670 33,000 1.5052 GLEN PARK-CLEV, BLOCK 8, 48815 S 05/2004 70,000 61,140 70,000 0.8734 GLEN PARK-CLEV, BLOCK 9, 48821 S 06/2004 65,000 66,300 65,000 1.0200 GLEN PARK-CLEV, BLOCK 70, 48999 S 03/2005 65,000 55,820 65,000 0.8588 GLEN PARK-CLEV, BLOCK 71, 49012 S 07/2004 65,900 64,830 65,900 0.9838 MACDONALD, LOT PT 7 TR 17 57583 S 04/2004 75,000 53,480 75,000 0.7131 MACDONALD, LOT PT 56 57, 57674 S 09/2004 62,900 61,400 62,900 0.9762 ROBINSON SPRINGER-CLEV, B 68894 S 06/2004 57,500 59,120 57,500 1.0282 WOODLAND, LOT 13, ACRES . 75189 S 04/2004 35,000 54,430 35,000 1.5551 GLEN PARK-CLEV, BLOCK 63, 95938 S 12/2004 55,500 50,560 55,500 0.9110 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 3 TOTALS 1,548,130 1,678,460 0.9224 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 4 $ 66,591 - $ 91,590 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ 59 EST SEC 1 BK 2 LT 20 131345;131344 S 09/2004 80,405 80,320 80,405 0.9989 SOUTHERN CROSSING, SEC 2, 135346 S 03/2004 79,000 83,770 79,000 1.0604 HUNTER'S CREEK, LOT 9, AC 137966 S 12/2004 74,900 69,160 74,900 0.9234 SOUTHERN CROSSING, SEC 4, 138825 S 04/2004 86,735 84,690 86,735 0.9764 COOK AT TRAVIS ADDITION, 143330 S 08/2004 80,000 78,650 80,000 0.9831 COOK AT TRAVIS ADDITION, 143331 S 05/2004 80,000 80,780 80,000 1.0098 GLEN PARK-CLEV, BLOCK 45, 146960 S 03/2004 90,000 89,960 90,000 0.9996 GLEN PARK-CLEV, BLOCK 45, 146961 S 10/2004 89,900 91,160 89,900 1.0140 000209 C HARPER, TRACT 15 24209 S 03/2004 75,000 79,600 75,000 1.0613 000209 C HARPER, TRACT 17 24244 S 10/2004 68,000 68,960 68,000 1.0141 000209 C HARPER, TRACT 40 24457 S 02/2005 112,000 78,040 112,000 0.6968 000441 JOSEPH FENNER, TRA 29423 S 05/2004 85,000 91,110 85,000 1.0719 000441 JOSEPH FENNER, TRA 29428 S 02/2005 65,000 69,720 65,000 1.0726 ANGLIN (H&TC-106), BLOCK 32939 S 07/2004 65,000 83,210 65,000 1.2802 CARTER ADDN, BLOCK 1, LOT 36502 S 02/2004 70,000 89,870 70,000 1.2839 COX-GARVEY-CLEV, BLOCK 27 37800 S 03/2004 82,000 89,150 82,000 1.0872 COX-GARVEY-CLEV, BLOCK 28 37802 S 12/2004 83,500 81,110 83,500 0.9714 DATE: 06/29/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 003 TIME: 12:49:54 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 146/Liberty VRSN: W 146-901/Cleveland ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 4 $ 66,591 - $ 91,590 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ COX-GARVEY-CLEV, BLOCK 29 37807 S 09/2004 76,260 72,940 76,260 0.9565 DUNNAM, SEC 1, BLOCK 5, L 47238 S 09/2004 63,500 67,980 63,500 1.0706 GLEN PARK-CLEV, BLOCK 5, 48786 S 08/2004 65,000 89,380 65,000 1.3751 GLEN PARK-CLEV, BLOCK 28, 48914 S 01/2005 80,000 75,350 80,000 0.9419 GLEN PARK-CLEV, BLOCK 71, 49008 S 06/2004 81,267 82,500 81,267 1.0152 GLEN PARK-CLEV, BLOCK 72, 49014 S 12/2004 75,260 69,580 75,260 0.9245 HIGHLAND PARK, BLOCK 2, L 53089 S 05/2004 89,000 90,610 89,000 1.0181 MACDONALD, LOT PT 13, ACR 57591 S 11/2004 89,000 76,730 89,000 0.8621 MACDONALD, LOT PT 45, ACR 57654 S 12/2004 115,000 81,190 115,000 0.7060 MAGNOLIA ESTATES, SEC 2, 58009 S 02/2004 86,500 85,940 86,500 0.9935 PINE FOREST, BLOCK 9, LOT 64309 S 08/2004 78,500 79,360 78,500 1.0110 PRESSLEY, LOT PT 5, ACRES 64638 S 07/2004 79,000 76,720 79,000 0.9711 SMITH-CLEV, BLOCK O, LOT 68453 S 04/2004 84,900 84,910 84,900 1.0001 TANGLEWOOD, BLOCK 3, LOT 70627 S 07/2004 85,000 86,180 85,000 1.0139 TANGLEWOOD BK 6 LT 4-6 70639 S 04/2004 65,000 68,140 65,000 1.0483 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 4 TOTALS 2,576,770 2,579,627 0.9989 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 5 $ 91,591 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ 000132 W M BARKER, TRACT 119737 S 03/2004 132,500 104,690 132,500 0.7901 EARL J WOOD, LOT H, ACRES 128501 S 01/2005 121,540 103,760 121,540 0.8537 59 EST SEC 1 BK 2 LT 6 131331 S 03/2004 54,000 92,750 54,000 1.7176 SOUTHERN CROSSING, SEC 2, 135291 S 04/2004 142,404 124,250 142,404 0.8725 SOUTHERN CROSSING, SEC 2, 135324 S 01/2004 113,400 113,600 113,400 1.0018 SOUTHERN CROSSING, SEC 2, 135330 S 03/2005 124,000 92,930 124,000 0.7494 SOUTHERN CROSSING, SEC 3, 137670 S 01/2005 105,000 106,820 105,000 1.0173 SOUTHERN CROSSING, SEC 3, 137671 S 01/2005 131,000 98,630 131,000 0.7529 SOUTHERN CROSSING, SEC 3, 137707 S 09/2004 99,860 98,480 99,860 0.9862 GLEN PARK-CLEV, BLOCK 46, 145866 S 08/2004 114,374 98,910 114,374 0.8648 GLEN PARK-CLEV, BLOCK 45, 146962 S 10/2004 105,000 95,320 105,000 0.9078 COX-GARVEY-CLEV, BLOCK 33 147259 S 11/2004 154,000 162,020 154,000 1.0521 000157 J CORONADO, TRACT 22258 S 06/2004 180,000 177,470 180,000 0.9859 000168 J C DEVERS, TRACT 22673 S 09/2004 211,000 209,630 211,000 0.9935 000209 C HARPER, TRACT 37 24422 S 04/2004 159,900 161,140 159,900 1.0078 000441 JOSEPH FENNER, TRA 29634 S 11/2004 87,000 100,470 87,000 1.1548 COX-GARVEY-CLEV, BLOCK 39 37876 S 09/2004 103,000 105,200 103,000 1.0214 DATE: 06/29/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 004 TIME: 12:49:54 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 146/Liberty VRSN: W 146-901/Cleveland ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 5 $ 91,591 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ GLEN PARK-CLEV, BLOCK 37, 48933 S 03/2005 120,000 103,270 120,000 0.8606 GLEN PARK-CLEV, BLOCK 45, 48946 S 02/2005 109,000 94,930 109,000 0.8709 KIRBY WOODS, BLOCK 2, SEC 54151 S 05/2004 137,000 142,810 137,000 1.0424 KIRBY WOODS, BLOCK 2, SEC 54162 S 09/2004 99,000 97,900 99,000 0.9889 KIRKHAM, BLOCK 1, LOT TRA 54241 S 07/2004 143,500 144,670 143,500 1.0082 LIBERTY ACRES, LOT PT 56, 57187 S 02/2004 171,000 170,950 171,000 0.9997 LIBERTY OAKS, LOT 5 6, AC 57260 S 11/2004 90,000 97,960 90,000 1.0884 PLUMTREE ESTATES, LOT 26 64555 S 06/2004 97,000 96,550 97,000 0.9954 POST OAK MANNOR, LOT 14 1 64580 S 11/2004 120,000 121,260 120,000 1.0105 ROYAL ACRES, BLOCK 1, LOT 65462 S 02/2004 177,000 194,500 177,000 1.0989 ROYAL ACRES, BLOCK 2, SEC 65473 S 06/2004 160,000 123,250 160,000 0.7703 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 5 TOTALS 3,434,120 3,561,478 0.9642 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM COMP SAMPLE STRATUM SAMPLE SAMPLE STRATUM STRATUM STRATUM CATEGORY _______ ____ ______ _______ ______ ______ _______ _______ _______ ________ CODE PARCELS PARCELS LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE LOCAL VALUE RATIO PTD VALUE RATIO ____ _______ _______ ___________ _________ ___________ _____ _________ _____ 1 U 0 1,421 0 0 14,390,578 14,390,578 2 R 18 2,145 597,060 658,203 68,338,525 0.9071 75,337,366 3 R 27 1,151 1,548,130 1,678,460 68,278,134 0.9224 74,022,261 4 R 32 838 2,576,770 2,579,627 68,350,855 0.9989 68,426,124 5 R 28 546 3,434,120 3,561,478 68,245,446 0.9642 70,779,347 TOTAL 105 6,101 8,156,080 8,477,768 287,603,538 302,955,676 0.9493 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 06/29/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 005 TIME: 12:49:54 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 146/Liberty VRSN: W 146-901/Cleveland ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY C - STRATUM 2 $ 2,331 - $ 6,740 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ TRLS END SEC 2 BK 11 LT 1 139326 A 4,650 6,730 0.6909 TRAILS END SEC 2 BK 21 LT 139615 A 4,730 6,861 0.6894 PHILLIPS BK 4 LT 14 147273 S 04/2004 4,000 3,200 4,000 0.8000 BLAGG-FENNER, BLOCK G, LO 35337 S 07/2004 2,500 3,400 2,500 1.3600 MACDONALD, LOT 41 TR 5, A 57880 S 11/2004 5,250 5,500 5,250 1.0476 PEBBLE CRK LT 4 63497 A 4,000 4,100 0.9756 PEBBLE CRK LT 81 63567 A 4,000 4,100 0.9756 SPLENDORA WOODS, LOT 41 S 68668 S 03/2005 7,900 6,270 7,900 0.7937 WINDWOOD BK 1 LT 21 74522 A 4,420 4,000 1.1050 WINDWOOD BK 3 LT 14 74599 A 4,140 4,000 1.0350 WINDWOOD BK 4 LT 24 74645 A 4,140 4,000 1.0350 WOODLANE, BK 1 SEC B LT 1 75253 A 2,510 3,125 0.8032 RANCHITO ALEGRE, BK 2 LT 92027 A 4,260 3,941 1.0809 RANCHITO ALEGRE BK 5 LT 4 92468 A 4,330 4,005 1.0811 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 2 TOTALS 59,550 64,512 0.9231 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY C - STRATUM 3 $ 6,741 - $ 13,210 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ WINDWOOD BK 8 LT RES F, T 119624 A 9,480 10,001 0.9479 SOUTHERN CROSSING, SEC 4 138799 A 12,260 23,174 0.5290 TRLS END SEC 2 BK 7 LT 20 139255 A 7,070 9,420 0.7505 TRLS END SEC 2 BK 13 LT 1 139384 A 9,100 12,132 0.7501 TRLS END SEC 2 BK 16 LT 3 139448 A 9,470 12,600 0.7516 000209 C HARPER, TRACT 55 147285 S 04/2004 6,000 9,870 6,000 1.6450 COHN BK 1 LT 1-10 37201 A 12,500 13,125 0.9524 HAYES HANKS, BLOCK 2, LOT 52197 S 09/2004 7,500 6,850 7,500 0.9133 HILLSIDE, BLOCK 16, LOT 1 53156 S 02/2005 9,000 11,250 9,000 1.2500 JORDAN, BLOCK 3, LOT 19 54011 S 09/2004 16,000 12,380 16,000 0.7738 MAGNOLIA EST SEC 2 LT 8 57996 A 9,480 9,480 1.0000 NEWMAN-SNYDER, BLOCK 4, L 60277 S 07/2004 10,000 12,990 10,000 1.2990 PHILLIPS BK 4 LT 12,13 63801 S 03/2004 8,000 8,400 8,000 1.0500 ROYAL ACRES, BLOCK 1, LOT 65463 S 04/2004 7,500 12,700 7,500 1.6933 TANGLEWOOD, BLOCK 12, LOT 70671 S 04/2004 7,950 7,680 7,950 0.9660 EDWARD RUSSELL, TR 50.2 90820 A 8,950 6,300 1.4206 E LABRINTZ, TR 5.1 91210 A 10,170 9,540 1.0660 PEACH CRK VALLEY LT 15 91645 A 9,200 12,800 0.7188 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 3 TOTALS 179,800 190,522 0.9437 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 06/29/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 006 TIME: 12:49:54 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 146/Liberty VRSN: W 146-901/Cleveland ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY C - STRATUM 4 $ 13,211 - $ 21,840 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ M RUCKER, TR 20.2 117324 A 13,240 12,000 1.1033 FIVE OAK EST BK 2 LT 4 131208 A 20,360 21,141 0.9631 59 ESTSSEC 2 BK 1 LT 25 131594 A 20,540 20,540 1.0000 TRLS END, BK 4 LT 4 132092 A 13,860 18,480 0.7500 TRLS END BK 5 LT 6 132109 A 13,770 18,360 0.7500 TRLS END SEC 2 BK 4 LT 12 139174 A 16,640 21,264 0.7825 TRLS END SEC 2, BK 4 LT 1 139179 A 13,660 18,216 0.7499 TRLS END SEC 2 BK 23 LT 3 139671 A 13,480 17,676 0.7626 FRY HOMESITES LT 8 48528 A 21,450 21,606 0.9928 GLEN PARK-CLEV, BK 43 LT 48944 A 20,460 25,245 0.8105 MACDONALD, LOT 1 TR 1, AC 57757 S 04/2004 19,000 18,750 19,000 0.9868 MACDONALD, LOT 16, TRACT 57806 S 01/2004 13,500 14,740 13,500 1.0919 MACDONALD, LOT 30 31, TRA 57855 S 01/2005 19,000 18,750 19,000 0.9868 SPLENDORA WOODS, LOT 9 SE 68759 S 02/2005 18,000 17,930 18,000 0.9961 SPLENDORA WOODS, LOT 23 S 68773 S 06/2004 13,300 13,960 13,300 1.0496 WOODLANE, BLOCK 3 SEC E, 75316 S 05/2004 12,000 14,600 12,000 1.2167 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 4 TOTALS 266,190 289,328 0.9200 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY C - STRATUM 5 $ 21,841 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ FIVE OAK EST, BK 1 LT 5 131162 A 25,470 26,447 0.9631 59 ESTATES SEC 1 BK 3 LT 131370 A 30,430 31,718 0.9594 59 ESTATES SEC 1 BK 6 LT 131439 A 22,490 23,874 0.9420 59 ESTATES, SEC 2 BK 1 LT 131580 A 30,610 36,010 0.8500 000441 JOSEPH FENNER, TRA 29504 S 10/2004 36,900 36,040 36,900 0.9767 ANGLIN AL BK 1 LT 9 11-19 32910 A 25,500 26,010 0.9804 COUNTRY COLONY, LOT PT 12 35756 S 04/2004 28,000 27,020 28,000 0.9650 37081 A 22,500 22,500 1.0000 37673 A 26,100 26,100 1.0000 EDWARDS BK 27 TR 1 47666 A 54,980 52,360 1.0500 GLEN PARK-CLEV, BK 38 LT 48936 A 25,520 28,420 0.8980 GLEN PARK-CLEV, BK 40, LT 48939 A 33,500 40,673 0.8236 GLEN PARK-CLEV BK 49 LT 3 48955 A 29,020 30,250 0.9593 WINSLOW-ROBINSON, BK 5 LT 74970 A 89,110 77,960 1.1430 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 5 TOTALS 478,290 487,222 0.9817 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 06/29/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 007 TIME: 12:49:54 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 146/Liberty VRSN: W 146-901/Cleveland ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY C - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM COMP SAMPLE STRATUM SAMPLE SAMPLE STRATUM STRATUM STRATUM CATEGORY _______ ____ ______ _______ ______ ______ _______ _______ _______ ________ CODE PARCELS PARCELS LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE LOCAL VALUE RATIO PTD VALUE RATIO ____ _______ _______ ___________ _________ ___________ _____ _________ _____ 1 U 0 1,126 0 0 1,228,789 1,228,789 2 R 14 1,462 59,550 64,512 5,826,119 0.9231 6,311,471 3 R 18 675 179,800 190,522 5,828,994 0.9437 6,176,745 4 R 16 389 266,190 289,328 5,913,259 0.9200 6,427,455 5 R 14 152 478,290 487,222 5,730,677 0.9817 5,837,503 TOTAL 62 3,804 983,830 1,031,584 24,527,838 25,981,963 0.9440 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 06/29/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 008 TIME: 12:49:54 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 146/Liberty VRSN: W 146-901/Cleveland ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY D3 - STRATUM 0 $1 - $99,999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ 000310 JAMES MCCOY, TRACT 136741 S 08/2004 43,500 27,670 43,500 0.6361 SHIPP, BLOCK 3, LOT 1 3, 145126 S 06/2004 8,400 13,390 8,400 1.5940 MACDONALD, LOT PT 39-41, 202440 S 09/2004 24,000 15,840 24,000 0.6600 000168 J C DEVERS, TRACT 22611 S 11/2004 96,815 97,680 96,815 1.0089 000170 THOMAS DEVER, TRAC 22712 S 03/2005 398,702 312,480 398,702 0.7837 000170 THOMAS DEVER, TRAC 22719 S 01/2004 18,000 43,150 18,000 2.3972 000170 THOMAS DEVER, TRAC 22741 S 05/2004 60,000 69,670 60,000 1.1612 000171 WM B DUNCAN, TRACT 22791 S 06/2004 42,500 49,920 42,500 1.1746 23901 A 1,530 1,530 1.0000 000209 C HARPER, TRACT 42 24081 S 06/2004 47,000 44,950 47,000 0.9564 24893 A 10,010 10,010 1.0000 000337 M S RUCKER, TRACT 26982 S 11/2004 186,940 202,700 186,940 1.0843 32446 A 2,550 2,550 1.0000 COUNTRY COLONY, LOT 2, AC 35743 S 08/2004 20,000 19,930 20,000 0.9965 91485 A 60,000 60,000 1.0000 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 0 TOTALS 971,470 1,019,947 0.9525 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY D3 - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM COMP SAMPLE STRATUM SAMPLE SAMPLE STRATUM STRATUM STRATUM CATEGORY _______ ____ ______ _______ ______ ______ _______ _______ _______ ________ CODE PARCELS PARCELS LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE LOCAL VALUE RATIO PTD VALUE RATIO ____ _______ _______ ___________ _________ ___________ _____ _________ _____ 0 R 15 2,340 971,470 1,019,947 42,683,737 0.9525 44,812,322 TOTAL 15 2,340 971,470 1,019,947 42,683,737 44,812,322 0.9525 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 06/29/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 009 TIME: 12:49:54 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 146/Liberty VRSN: W 146-901/Cleveland ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 2 $ 41,901 - $ 145,550 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ 000209 C HARPER, TRACT 41 24080 S 08/2004 55,382 45,670 55,382 0.8246 CLEV CITY, BK 8 PT LTS 11 37141 A 130,120 132,102 0.9850 CLEVELAND CITY, BK 9 LT 1 37154 A 109,850 124,701 0.8809 COX-GARVEY-CLEV, BK 21LT 37745 A 72,740 88,449 0.8224 LIBERTY ACRES, BLOCK 1, L 57176 S 10/2005 60,000 47,390 60,000 0.7898 NORTHSIDE SEC 1 BK 2 LT 5 60690 A 47,430 42,406 1.1185 ROBINSON SPRINGER-CLEV, B 68855 S 02/2004 120,000 133,350 120,000 1.1113 WOODLAND, LT 20,21 75195 A 67,950 57,775 1.1761 PEEBLES 2, BK 3 LT 5,6 92631 A 116,680 113,543 1.0276 000310 JAMES MCCOY, TRACT 95691 S 04/2004 75,000 94,260 75,000 1.2568 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 2 TOTALS 865,440 869,358 0.9955 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 3 $ 145,551 - $ 352,260 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ J BOOTH, TR 21-23 100769 A 225,030 182,381 1.2338 COX-GARVEY-CLEV. BK 17 LT 119732 A 183,390 175,937 1.0424 JOHN BREEDING, TR 57 141546 A 281,420 296,277 0.9499 CLEVELAND CITY, BLOCK 3, 143181 S 05/2004 235,000 231,210 235,000 0.9839 C HARPER, TR 17 24186 A 310,830 360,606 0.8620 CLEVELAND CITY, BK 7 LT 1 37122 A 199,820 207,365 0.9636 COX-GARVEY-CLEV, BK 10 37689 A 264,130 353,232 0.7478 EDWARDS PT BK 38, TR 2 47714 A 305,090 248,676 1.2269 HAYES HANKS, BLOCK 5, LOT 52211 S 02/2004 95,000 165,260 95,000 1.7396 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 3 TOTALS 2,166,180 2,154,474 1.0054 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 4 $ 352,261 - $ 1,086,800 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ 139 J BOOTH TR 17,19,37 125773 A 439,840 459,842 0.9565 DATE: 06/29/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 010 TIME: 12:49:54 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 146/Liberty VRSN: W 146-901/Cleveland ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 4 $ 352,261 - $ 1,086,800 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ J MCCOY TR 24 26602 A 690,900 686,015 1.0071 J MCCOY, TR 35 26609 A 957,690 1,051,332 0.9109 000394 T J WILLIAMS, TRAC 28525 S 06/2004 750,000 674,380 720,000 0.9366 CLEV CITY BK 1 LT 1-4 37056 A 780,610 859,500 0.9082 CLEVELAND CITY, BK 3 LT 7 37083 A 759,830 900,102 0.8442 COX -GARVEY-CLEV BK 10 LT 37690 A 513,570 628,131 0.8176 HOLLIS, BK 1-4, LT TR 5 53235 A 729,310 866,315 0.8419 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 4 TOTALS 5,546,130 6,171,237 0.8987 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 5 $ 1,086,801 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ MB LAWRENCE, TR 20 26394 A 1,131,730 1,053,007 1.0748 JOHN BREEDING, TR 33, 34 29293 A 6,831,510 6,644,540 1.0281 CLEVELAND CITY, BK 6 LT 1 37120 A 1,558,490 1,708,805 0.9120 HOLLIS, BK1-4, LT TR 2 53232 A 1,271,630 1,709,263 0.7440 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 5 TOTALS 10,793,360 11,115,615 0.9710 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM COMP SAMPLE STRATUM SAMPLE SAMPLE STRATUM STRATUM STRATUM CATEGORY _______ ____ ______ _______ ______ ______ _______ _______ _______ ________ CODE PARCELS PARCELS LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE LOCAL VALUE RATIO PTD VALUE RATIO ____ _______ _______ ___________ _________ ___________ _____ _________ _____ 1 U 0 190 0 0 4,162,167 4,162,167 2 R 10 209 865,440 869,358 19,882,952 0.9955 19,972,830 3 R 9 72 2,166,180 2,154,474 19,667,000 1.0054 19,561,369 4 R 8 29 5,546,130 6,171,237 20,163,654 0.8987 22,436,468 5 R 4 6 10,793,360 11,115,615 19,230,069 0.9710 19,804,396 TOTAL 31 506 19,371,110 20,310,684 83,105,842 85,937,230 0.9671 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 06/29/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 011 TIME: 12:49:54 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 146/Liberty VRSN: W 146-901/Cleveland ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - STRATUM 2 $ 13,601 - $ 142,047 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ TODAY'S RENTAL P106989 A 20,000 19,626 1.0191 BROOKSHIRE'S DISCOUNT PHA P112788 A 36,000 48,500 0.7423 LEASECOMM CORP P120757 A 15,760 14,485 1.0880 DISH NETWORK P140110 A 28,290 22,939 1.2333 CAPROCK PIPE & SUPPLY P144273 A 37,790 30,065 1.2569 CONCRETE PLUS P146881 A 14,900 12,404 1.2012 CHURCH'S FRIED CHICKEN P96492 A 65,240 74,624 0.8742 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 2 TOTALS 217,980 222,643 0.9791 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - STRATUM 3 $ 142,048 - $ 622,790 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ POTETZ HOME CTR P121343 A 316,540 284,257 1.1136 VOICESTREAM HOUSTON P129260 A 293,610 274,126 1.0711 SEARS ROEBUCK & CO P139019 A 249,570 250,026 0.9982 BOUNDS PHARMACY P76518 A 442,220 400,964 1.1029 O'REILLY AUTO PARTS P76851 A 333,570 332,975 1.0018 WESTERN AUTO ASSOC STORE P77868 A 372,020 402,040 0.9253 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 3 TOTALS 2,007,530 1,944,388 1.0325 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - STRATUM 4 $ 622,791 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ CAMPBELL READY MIX P109220 A 2,388,840 2,388,835 1.0000 MCCOY'S BLDG SUPPLY CTR # P112684 A 1,118,290 1,114,100 1.0038 ENTERPRISE LEASING CO P123096 A 977,420 978,208 0.9992 PERFORMANCE TRUCK P125271 A 1,857,000 1,857,000 1.0000 BROOKSHIRE BROS #16 P76532 A 951,450 1,062,933 0.8951 WAL-MART STORE #249 P77850 A 6,781,030 6,878,579 0.9858 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 4 TOTALS 14,074,030 14,279,655 0.9856 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 06/29/2006 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 012 TIME: 12:49:54 2005 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 146/Liberty VRSN: W 146-901/Cleveland ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM COMP SAMPLE STRATUM SAMPLE SAMPLE STRATUM STRATUM STRATUM CATEGORY _______ ____ ______ _______ ______ ______ _______ _______ _______ ________ CODE PARCELS PARCELS LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE LOCAL VALUE RATIO PTD VALUE RATIO ____ _______ _______ ___________ _________ ___________ _____ _________ _____ 1 U 0 583 0 0 2,727,942 2,727,942 2 R 7 300 217,980 222,643 12,948,063 0.9791 13,224,454 3 R 6 49 2,007,530 1,944,388 13,405,144 1.0325 12,983,190 4 R 6 13 14,074,030 14,279,655 25,295,611 0.9856 25,665,190 TOTAL 19 945 16,299,540 16,446,686 54,376,760 54,600,776 0.9959 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ **** END OF REPORT ****
