DATE: 02/25/2005 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 001 TIME: 08:13:27 2004 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 187/Polk VRSN: P 187-907/Livingston ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 2 $ 12,813 - $ 38,874 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ CRYSTAL LAKES NO 1 LT 295 C2400012100 S 05/2003 48,000 26,728 48,000 0.5568 CRYSTAL LAKES NO 3 LTS 71 C2400026400/26300 S 07/2003 19,000 15,957 19,000 0.8398 GREEN ACRES LT 16 G0500001400 S 07/2003 25,000 21,363 25,000 0.8545 INDIAN HILL ESTATES NO 2 I0500017100 S 03/2003 30,000 32,168 30,000 1.0723 INDIAN HILL HEIGHTS NO 1 I0700006800 S 08/2003 17,000 20,444 17,000 1.2026 INDIAN SPRING LAKE NO 11 I0800085200 S 03/2003 9,000 14,332 9,000 1.5924 LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLAGE N L0400000300 S 03/2003 30,000 30,467 30,000 1.0156 LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLAGE N L0400001100 S 08/2003 13,500 29,140 13,500 2.1585 LAKEVIEW NO 2 B 10 LTS 16 L0900009000 S 05/2003 10,000 17,340 10,000 1.7340 MANGUM EST NO 1 LT 271 M0500015300 & M0500015100 S 10/2003 37,500 34,674 37,500 0.9246 PINEHILL B 2 LTS 12/13 P1200001600 S 08/2003 20,000 21,190 20,000 1.0595 PUTNAMS LANDING NO 1 LTS P1700006400 S 07/2003 12,000 19,077 12,000 1.5898 PUTNAMS LANDING NO 1 LTS P1700014200 S 04/2003 11,000 12,845 11,000 1.1677 SHELTER COVE NO 3 LT 1 S1100015000 S 07/2003 23,000 24,765 23,000 1.0767 SHELTER COVE S 3 LT 60 S1100020400 S 05/2003 16,204 16,437 16,204 1.0144 TAYLOR LAKE EST NO 6 LT 5 T0200020200 S 01/2004 33,000 33,883 33,000 1.0268 WILD COUNTRY LAKES NO 3 L W1400021700 S 05/2003 10,000 13,080 10,000 1.3080 CHOATE A 15 S 1 PT LT 85 10015036900 S 02/2004 34,000 29,045 34,000 0.8543 CHOATE A 15 S 1 LOT 90 10015038400 S 02/2003 45,000 24,395 45,000 0.5421 DIKES A 27 TR 113 10027015100 S 01/2004 20,000 19,696 20,000 0.9848 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 2 TOTALS 457,026 463,204 0.9867 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 3 $ 38,875 - $ 66,627 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ CHEROKEE FOREST NO 1 LTS C0600003800 S 01/2004 52,000 51,447 52,000 0.9894 CHESSWOOD NO 1 B 2 LT 12 C0700002600 S 04/2003 91,000 53,280 91,000 0.5855 CHESSWOOD NO 2 B 2 LTS 1, C0700006400 S 03/2003 69,000 52,750 69,000 0.7645 FOREST SPRINGS NO 3 LT 10 F0500036800 S 06/2003 80,000 48,090 80,000 0.6011 HOLIDAY LAKE ESTATES NO 4 H1200034600 & H1200034500 S 11/2003 45,000 45,182 45,000 1.0040 INDIAN HILL EST NO 2 B 7 I0500026200 S 03/2003 39,016 45,312 39,016 1.1614 INDIAN HILL EST NO 2 B 8 I0500028400 S 05/2003 65,000 45,280 65,000 0.6966 INDIAN HILL HEIGHTS NO 2 I0700016800/16900 S 07/2003 73,000 51,597 73,000 0.7068 LAKE LIVINGSTON EST NO 3 L0200019200 S 12/2003 142,000 59,958 142,000 0.4222 DATE: 02/25/2005 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 002 TIME: 08:13:27 2004 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 187/Polk VRSN: P 187-907/Livingston ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 3 $ 38,875 - $ 66,627 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLAGE N L0400000700 S 05/2003 50,000 49,903 50,000 0.9981 LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLAGE N L0400201700 S 08/2003 62,000 63,920 62,000 1.0310 MEMORIAL POINT B 1 LTS 8/ M1400001500 S 07/2003 71,000 57,022 71,000 0.8031 MEMORIAL POINT B 10 LT 20 M1400044700 S 11/2003 35,000 42,452 35,000 1.2129 MEMORIAL POINT TWN HSE NO M1500004400 S 06/2003 53,200 51,425 53,200 0.9666 OAK TERRACE EST NO 4 LT 3 O0300021700/22200 S 09/2003 60,450 56,461 60,450 0.9340 SHELTER COVE NO 5 B 2 L S1100047300 S 12/2003 85,000 60,580 85,000 0.7127 SHELTER COVE NO 5 B 2 LTS S1100050400 S 09/2003 41,000 48,261 41,000 1.1771 SIESTA COUNTRY NO 2 LT 38 S1300012700 AND S13000129 S 02/2003 42,000 47,460 42,000 1.1300 SUNSET SHADOWS NO 1 LT 54 S300001940 S 12/2003 50,000 48,774 50,000 0.9755 FALCON A 32 TR 98 10032001205 S 03/2004 40,000 61,498 40,000 1.5375 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 3 TOTALS 1,040,652 1,245,666 0.8354 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 4 $ 66,628 - $ 109,408 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ BAY HAVEN NO 1 B 2 LTS 16 B0200004500 S 06/2003 110,000 107,350 110,000 0.9759 BRIARBEND NO 1 LT 52 B1000004900 S 02/2003 75,000 75,680 75,000 1.0091 CAMPBELL-WOOD LT 22 C0150002200 S 02/2003 86,500 85,600 86,500 0.9896 CHESSWOOD NO 1 B 5 L 1 & C0700004200 S 05/2003 90,100 90,280 90,100 1.0020 CHESSWOOD NO 2 B 1 LT 1 C0700005500 AND C07000056 S 03/2003 69,650 69,183 69,650 0.9933 CRESCENT SHORES B 9 LT 4 C2200009700 S 11/2003 125,500 96,234 125,500 0.7668 CRESCENT SHORES B 9 LT 33 C2200012500 S 01/2003 125,000 69,076 125,000 0.5526 FOREST SPRINGS NO 3 LT 7 F0500038500 S 03/2003 69,000 78,561 69,000 1.1386 INDIAN HILL EST NO 1 B 4 I050008000 S 06/2003 145,000 103,412 145,000 0.7132 LAKE LIVINGSTON EST NO 1 L0200007500 S 05/2003 61,000 67,952 61,000 1.1140 LAKE LIVINGSTON ESTS NO 1 L0200009100 S 02/2004 110,000 67,534 110,000 0.6139 LAKE LIVINGSTON EST NO 3 L0200022400 S 09/2003 58,000 71,164 58,000 1.2270 LAKEWOOD NO 2 LT 11 L1000003900 S 11/2003 75,000 75,178 75,000 1.0024 MEMORIAL POINT B 9 LT 53 M1400041900 S 04/2003 69,000 72,153 69,000 1.0457 OAK FOREST B 5 LOT 4 O0100005200 S 01/2003 89,900 81,226 89,900 0.9035 PINEHILL B 1 PT OF LTS 1 P1200000100 S 02/2003 65,000 67,755 65,000 1.0424 SCHWAB CITY ACRES TR 11 S0400001200 S 03/2003 80,000 70,117 80,000 0.8765 TEXAS LANDING LT 31/32 T0425003100/003200 S 09/2003 113,000 92,740 113,000 0.8207 TEXAS LANDING LOT 103 T0425010300 S 08/2003 127,500 93,179 127,500 0.7308 TEXAS LANDING LT 115 T0425011500 S 10/2003 77,500 68,549 77,500 0.8845 THUNDER MTN LAKES NO 1 B T0500002300 S 03/2003 62,000 68,215 62,000 1.1002 BURRIS A 10 TR 32-L 10010004706 S 09/2003 68,950 86,005 68,950 1.2474 HAMPTON A 280 TR 3A 10280000400 S 05/2003 53,000 67,517 53,000 1.2739 SMITH A 820 S 4 TR 44 10820004000 S 05/2003 42,000 71,594 42,000 1.7046 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 4 TOTALS 1,896,254 2,047,600 0.9261 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 02/25/2005 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 003 TIME: 08:13:27 2004 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 187/Polk VRSN: P 187-907/Livingston ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 5 $ 109,409 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ BRIARBEND NO 1 LTS 29/30 B1000002800 S 06/2003 140,000 145,873 140,000 1.0420 COMMODORE CAPE S 2 LT 59 C1200005900 S 09/2003 220,000 172,984 220,000 0.7863 COMMODORE CAPE S 2 LOT 11 C1200010700 S 01/2003 230,000 144,386 230,000 0.6278 COUNTRY CHARM TR 3 C1625000101 S 11/2003 115,000 138,787 115,000 1.2068 DAVIS WOODS B 1 L 9 D0150000900 S 03/2004 140,000 145,514 140,000 1.0394 ENCHNTED FOREST LT 45 E0800004200 S 03/2003 170,000 160,574 170,000 0.9446 ENCHANTED FOREST NO 2 LT E0800008800 S 07/2003 180,000 141,862 180,000 0.7881 INDIAN HILL NO 2 B 16 LT I0400042800 S 03/2003 145,000 185,081 145,000 1.2764 INDIAN HILL EST NO 3 LT 4 I0500036500 S 08/2003 192,500 181,064 192,500 0.9406 INDIAN HILLS EATATES NO 3 I0500040600 S 01/2003 110,000 113,135 110,000 1.0285 INDIAN HILL HEIGHTS NO 1 I0700003000 S 08/2003 130,000 127,596 130,000 0.9815 LAKE LIVINGSTON EST NO 2 L0200016700 S 10/2003 195,000 140,804 195,000 0.7221 LAKE LIVINGSTON EST NO 3 L0200036400 S 12/2003 215,000 138,998 215,000 0.6465 PINE VALLEY LT 9 P0900000900 S 02/2003 163,900 162,813 163,900 0.9934 PINE VALLEY LT 18 - 20 P090001900/2000/2100 S 08/2003 153,000 113,455 153,000 0.7415 SUNSET SHADOWS NO 2 LT 6 S300002600 S 04/2003 98,500 118,670 98,500 1.2048 TEXAS LANDING LT 60 T0425005900 S 12/2003 249,500 172,581 249,500 0.6917 CHOATE A 15 TR 144C 10015018900 S 02/2003 333,000 326,733 333,000 0.9812 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 5 TOTALS 2,830,910 3,180,400 0.8901 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM COMP SAMPLE STRATUM SAMPLE SAMPLE STRATUM STRATUM STRATUM CATEGORY _______ ____ ______ _______ ______ ______ _______ _______ _______ ________ CODE PARCELS PARCELS LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE LOCAL VALUE RATIO PTD VALUE RATIO ____ _______ _______ ___________ _________ ___________ _____ _________ _____ 1 U 0 3,034 0 0 18,828,716 18,828,716 2 R 20 3,566 457,026 463,204 89,484,485 0.9867 90,690,671 3 R 20 1,686 1,040,652 1,245,666 89,434,445 0.8354 107,055,836 4 R 24 1,022 1,896,254 2,047,600 89,445,872 0.9261 96,583,384 5 R 18 543 2,830,910 3,180,400 89,467,277 0.8901 100,513,737 TOTAL 82 9,851 6,224,842 6,936,870 376,660,795 413,672,344 0.9105 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 02/25/2005 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 004 TIME: 08:13:27 2004 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 187/Polk VRSN: P 187-907/Livingston ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY C - STRATUM 2 $ 1,558 - $ 5,754 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ CHEROKEE FOREST NO 1 LT 7 C0600006600 S 07/2003 2,000 3,281 2,000 1.6405 COUNTRY CHARM TR 2 A 408 C1625000100 S 06/2003 6,000 5,241 6,000 0.8735 FOREST SPRINGS NO 2 B D L F0500031900 S 02/2003 3,500 3,510 3,500 1.0029 FOREST SPRINGS NO 3 LT 28 F0500036001 S 11/2003 3,000 2,933 3,000 0.9777 FOREST SPRINGS NO 4 LT 11 F0500045900 S 06/2003 2,670 3,200 2,670 1.1985 HOLLY HILLS NO 1 BLK 4 LT H1500004800 S 03/2003 1,500 2,811 1,500 1.8740 LAKE LIVINGSTON EST NO 3 L0200030200 S 09/2003 4,400 4,400 4,400 1.0000 LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLAGE N L04000202400 S 08/2003 2,000 4,150 2,000 2.0750 MEMORIAL POINT B 1 LT 4 M1400001100 S 02/2003 1,500 2,024 1,500 1.3493 MEMORIAL POINT B 2 LT 27 M1400005100 S 11/2003 2,500 2,376 2,500 0.9504 MEMORIAL POINT B 5 LT 2 M1400019300 S 08/2003 1,000 2,173 1,000 2.1730 MEMORIAL POINT B 10 LT 10 M1400043700 S 04/2003 1,080 2,160 1,080 2.0000 OAK TERRACE EST NO 5 LT 4 O0300026700 S 08/2003 3,600 3,600 3,600 1.0000 OAK TERRACE EST NO 6 LT 5 O0300028400 S 11/2003 1,500 1,680 1,500 1.1200 OAK TERRACE EST NO 3 LT 4 O030017100 S 01/2004 5,000 5,222 5,000 1.0444 REILYS LANDING LTS 229/23 R0500013005 S 08/2003 6,470 5,000 6,470 0.7728 SHILOH RIDGE LT 7 AND PT S1200005900 S 06/2003 4,000 3,938 4,000 0.9845 SPRING CREEK NO 2 LT 7 S1950006000 S 03/2003 1,275 2,442 1,275 1.9153 TAYLOR LAKE EST NO 6 LT 4 T0200019505 S 01/2003 2,500 1,600 2,500 0.6400 WIGGINS VILLAGE S 2 LTS 1 W1200026900 S 02/2004 1,800 2,000 1,800 1.1111 PRICE A 720 TR 1YY BEECH 10720000148 S 01/2003 2,600 4,200 2,600 1.6154 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 2 TOTALS 67,941 59,895 1.1343 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY C - STRATUM 3 $ 5,755 - $ 14,714 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ ALEXANDER B 2 A0300000100 A 9,190 13,515 0.6800 GARDEN ACRES LT 21-23 G0025002100//200/3000 S 02/2003 15,000 13,889 15,000 0.9259 HIDDEN VALLEY EST NO 4 B H0800003400 S 05/2003 4,000 9,384 4,000 2.3460 INDIAN HILLS NO 2 B 22 PT I0400050200 S 05/2003 7,000 10,536 7,000 1.5051 INDIAN HILL NO 2 B 22 LT I0400053600 A 5,880 4,200 1.4000 INDIAN HILL ESTATES NO 2 I0500031900/32000 S 06/2003 6,000 7,680 6,000 1.2800 MAXWELL TR 19 M1100002800 S 05/2003 7,000 6,957 7,000 0.9939 OAK FOREST B 8 LT 7 O0100000900 A 11,742 8,807 1.3333 OAK FOREST B 8 LT 10 O0100009300 S 01/2003 9,000 9,981 9,000 1.1090 PUTNAMS LANDING NO 1 LT 2 P1700002100 & P1700029800 S 03/2004 7,000 8,880 7,000 1.2686 DATE: 02/25/2005 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 005 TIME: 08:13:27 2004 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 187/Polk VRSN: P 187-907/Livingston ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY C - STRATUM 3 $ 5,755 - $ 14,714 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ SOUTHLAND PLANTATION S 6 S1825013500 S 05/2003 8,668 8,668 8,668 1.0000 TEMPE TIMBERED TERR NO 1 T0300000900 S 05/2004 13,000 13,300 13,000 1.0231 OAK TERRACE EST NO 3 LTS 00300017800 S 02/2003 9,000 6,916 9,000 0.7684 DIKES A 27 TR 31 LT 24 10027004150 S 06/2003 8,000 10,037 8,000 1.2546 MILES A 413 TR 27B L 1 10413003800 S 02/2003 3,500 10,102 3,500 2.8863 MILES A 413 TR 23 1041303100 S 04/2004 10,000 10,173 10,000 1.0173 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 3 TOTALS 153,315 133,690 1.1468 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY C - STRATUM 4 $ 14,715 - $ 37,800 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ CHESSWOOD NO 1 B 3 L 1 C0700003000 A 26,168 36,408 0.7187 EASTON OAKS LT 12/14 E0150001200/1400 S 01/2003 21,000 16,601 21,000 0.7905 EASTWAY B 12 LTS 1 THRU 3 E0200002500 A 19,260 15,408 1.2500 ENCHANTED FOREST LT 1 TH E0800000100/200/300/400 S 05/2003 20,000 24,000 20,000 1.2000 HIDDEN VALLEY EST NO 2 B H0800001500 A 14,954 14,910 1.0030 INDIAN HILL EST NO 2 B 12 I0500035701 S 01/2003 20,000 20,062 20,000 1.0031 JENNINGS COVE LT 6 J0010000600 S 02/2003 15,500 30,564 15,500 1.9719 JENNINGS COVE LT 12 J0010001200 A 17,391 19,323 0.9000 LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLAGE N L0400195100 A 16,875 18,000 0.9375 RESORT COUNTRY NO 2 LT 30 R0700006100 A 35,550 23,700 1.5000 RESORT COUNTRY S 2 LT 84 R0700010900 A 20,250 16,200 1.2500 TIMBERLAND COVE TR 12 T0600001200 A 24,150 22,869 1.0560 CHOATE A 15 S 1 LUB LT 65 10015033500 A 17,201 19,602 0.8775 CHOATE A 15 S 4 TR 9 10015063100 A 25,842 27,565 0.9375 MORGAN A 56 TR 34 10056003491 A 15,443 12,112 1.2750 PICKNEY A 63 TR 45B 10063005402 A 28,532 45,651 0.6250 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 4 TOTALS 352,843 348,248 1.0132 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 02/25/2005 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 006 TIME: 08:13:27 2004 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 187/Polk VRSN: P 187-907/Livingston ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY C - STRATUM 5 $ 37,801 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ BEACON BAY S 1 L 1 B0250000100 S 08/2003 55,000 78,750 55,000 1.4318 BEACON BAY S 1 LT 2 B0250000200 A 49,613 37,800 1.3125 DEERFIELD LT 2 D0250000200 A 67,450 42,600 1.5833 DEERFIELD LT 12 D0250001200 A 45,030 23,700 1.9000 DICKENS LANDING NO 2 LT 9 D0375002900 A 38,968 45,844 0.8500 INDIAN HILL EST NO 1 B 2 I0500000110 A 39,600 22,000 1.8000 LAKE LIVINGSTON ESTS NO 3 L0200020800 &L0200020700 S 04/2003 38,000 38,500 38,000 1.0132 LAKEWOOD LT 22 L100002100 A 54,780 36,155 1.5151 OAK TERRACE EST NO 1 LT 2 O0300002400 A 42,660 31,600 1.3500 CHOATE A 15 TR 113A-1 10015012900 A 113,815 100,118 1.1368 VIESCA A 78 TR 15 10078002400 A 50,400 37,800 1.3333 BRADLEY A 98 TR 24 10098002800 A 77,242 57,935 1.3333 BRADLEY A 98 TR 26 10098003000 A 67,920 59,172 1.1478 BRADLEY A 98 TR 27 10098003100 A 43,080 31,276 1.3774 FERGUSON A 245 TR 10 L 1 10245001201 A 39,060 28,358 1.3774 HAYNES A 324 TR 1H 10324000108 A 60,946 73,745 0.8264 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 5 TOTALS 907,814 721,103 1.2589 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY C - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM COMP SAMPLE STRATUM SAMPLE SAMPLE STRATUM STRATUM STRATUM CATEGORY _______ ____ ______ _______ ______ ______ _______ _______ _______ ________ CODE PARCELS PARCELS LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE LOCAL VALUE RATIO PTD VALUE RATIO ____ _______ _______ ___________ _________ ___________ _____ _________ _____ 1 U 0 9,159 0 0 7,657,353 7,657,353 2 R 21 11,428 67,941 59,895 36,380,304 1.1343 32,072,912 3 R 16 3,993 153,315 133,690 36,376,461 1.1468 31,719,969 4 R 16 1,576 352,843 348,248 36,431,931 1.0132 35,957,295 5 R 16 478 907,814 721,103 36,315,866 1.2589 28,847,300 TOTAL 69 26,634 1,481,913 1,262,936 153,161,915 136,254,829 1.1241 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 02/25/2005 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 007 TIME: 08:13:27 2004 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 187/Polk VRSN: P 187-907/Livingston ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY D3 - STRATUM 0 $1 - $99,999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ COPELAND CREEK 113 TR 3 C1250000300 A 24,806 26,250 0.9450 OATES LT 18 O0500000900 A 26,238 26,600 0.9864 PEBBLE CREEK TR 6/141 P0350000600/ S 08/2003 175,000 182,279 175,000 1.0416 SOUTHLAND PLANTATION SEC S1825007800 S 02/2003 7,000 9,474 7,000 1.3534 SOUTHLAND PLANTATION SEC S1825017409 S 01/2003 22,000 20,000 22,000 0.9091 SOUTHLAND PLANTATIONS S 2 S1825036700 S 12/2003 55,000 52,281 55,000 0.9506 BURKES A 9 100090006205 & 1000900620 S 10/2003 29,500 29,523 29,500 1.0008 CHOATE A 15 S 1 TR 8 10015001100 S 02/2003 8,000 16,412 8,000 2.0515 COLLVILLE A 16 TR 2 10016000200 A 61,301 59,278 1.0341 DIKES A 28 TR 23 10028002800 A 36,323 28,885 1.2575 HIROMS A 37 TR 37 10037004600 S 02/2003 17,000 23,943 17,000 1.4084 PARKER A 61 TR 38 10061006600 A 182,000 182,000 1.0000 VIESCA A 78 10078004900 A 37,466 24,818 1.5096 WILBURN A 80 TR 15 & 35 10080001800 A 24,575 25,002 0.9829 JONES A 364 TR 7 10364000900 A 23,625 24,000 0.9844 MARSH A 445 TR 4 10445000400 A 25,976 26,219 0.9907 RUDDLE A 516 TR 9 10516001600 S 06/2003 60,000 65,113 60,000 1.0852 TRACEY A 569 TR 11 & 9 10569001600 A 24,857 26,500 0.9380 VIESCA A 77 TR 149 1077020700 A 27,619 26,000 1.0623 POITEVENT A 1016 TR 1 11016000100 A 469,700 422,730 1.1111 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 0 TOTALS 1,363,511 1,271,782 1.0721 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY D3 - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM COMP SAMPLE STRATUM SAMPLE SAMPLE STRATUM STRATUM STRATUM CATEGORY _______ ____ ______ _______ ______ ______ _______ _______ _______ ________ CODE PARCELS PARCELS LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE LOCAL VALUE RATIO PTD VALUE RATIO ____ _______ _______ ___________ _________ ___________ _____ _________ _____ 0 R 20 4,071 1,363,511 1,271,782 64,437,479 1.0721 60,103,982 TOTAL 20 4,071 1,363,511 1,271,782 64,437,479 60,103,982 1.0721 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 02/25/2005 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 008 TIME: 08:13:27 2004 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 187/Polk VRSN: P 187-907/Livingston ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 2 $ 29,532 - $ 136,111 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ LIVINGSTON OT B 20 LTS 3/ L1400005900 A 92,082 79,664 1.1559 MILLS FOREST LT 9 & 9 SF M1700000900 A 79,083 97,027 0.8151 SPRING CREEK BUSINESS PAR S196001300 A 46,349 49,015 0.9456 SPRING CREEK BUSINESS PAR S196002150 A 54,696 57,354 0.9537 TH;UNDER MTN LAKES NO 1 B T0500008000 A 109,650 173,429 0.6322 CHOATE A 15 S 1 CA & SUB 10015042600 A 87,623 59,483 1.4731 CHAOTE A 15 PT S 2 SUB LO 10015045800 A 73,648 109,105 0.6750 CHOATE A 15 S 3 TR 5B 10015056000 A 77,582 58,896 1.3173 MORGAN A 56 TR 21 10056001700 A 104,325 125,028 0.8344 MORGAN A 56 PT TR 36 10056003510 A 47,269 39,628 1.1928 PICKNEY A 63 TR 25 10063002600 A 105,198 153,540 0.6852 VIESCA A 78 TR 60-C 10078006910 A 71,993 89,826 0.8015 FERGUSON A 245 TR 3B 10245003001 A 56,104 25,840 2.1712 HICKS A 282 PT TR 9 & 10B 10282001225 A 128,701 206,719 0.6226 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 2 TOTALS 1,134,303 1,324,554 0.8564 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 3 $ 136,112 - $ 386,295 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ ENCHANTED FOREST LT 70 E0800006700 A 220,052 205,825 1.0691 LAKESIDE B 3 PT OF 2 ALL L0700000400 A 266,779 241,928 1.1027 LIVINGSTON OT B 26 LT 4A, L1400008600 A 176,605 116,964 1.5099 NORTH PT B E PT LTS 5 AND N0800001001 A 260,337 191,410 1.3601 CHOATE A 15 TR 130 10015014600 A 144,420 150,137 0.9619 CHOATE A 15 TR 168C LT 3 10015023800 A 261,534 286,940 0.9115 CHOATE A 15 S 2 SUB LT 1 10015045700 A 190,818 250,829 0.7607 CHOATE A 15 S 2 SUB LOT P 10015047901 A 223,875 246,915 0.9067 CHOATE A 15 S 4 PT TR 3 10015062201 A 224,842 270,081 0.8325 BBB&CRR A 153 TRS 4 AND 5 10153000406 A 168,468 167,778 1.0041 HICKS A 282 PT TR 9 & 10A 10282001215 A 221,608 157,784 1.4045 HICKS A 282 PT TR 9 & 10 10282001252 A 229,098 251,383 0.9114 HICKS A 282 PT TR 9 & 10J 10282001260 A 321,338 244,826 1.3125 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 3 TOTALS 2,909,774 2,782,800 1.0456 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 4 $ 386,296 - $ 1,183,570 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ MILLS FOREST LT 1 M1700000100 A 1,177,281 1,461,895 0.8053 DATE: 02/25/2005 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 009 TIME: 08:13:27 2004 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 187/Polk VRSN: P 187-907/Livingston ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 4 $ 386,296 - $ 1,183,570 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ CHOATE A 15 TR 110A (IMP 10015012509 A 549,086 451,946 1.2149 CHOATE A 15 PT TR 112 10015012701 A 493,052 945,230 0.5216 CHOATE A 15 TR 122 10015013650 A 895,081 1,001,541 0.8937 CHOATE A 15 TR 127B 10015014300 A 509,902 460,928 1.1063 HEB GROCERY CO 10015023700 A 845,229 665,861 1.2694 CHOATE A 15 TR 169 10015023900 S 10/2003 697,451 1,086,370 697,451 1.5576 CHOATE A 15 TRS 171A AND 10015024100 A 463,154 316,511 1.4633 CHOATE A 15 PT S 1 LT 150 10015044701 A 433,042 420,430 1.0300 CHOATE A 15 S 2 SUB LT 59 10015050700 S 02/2004 430,000 430,246 430,000 1.0006 CHOATE A 15 S 2 SUB LOTS 10015051400 A 517,718 399,590 1.2956 CHOATE A 15 S 3 PT SUB LO 10015057300 A 812,506 1,009,168 0.8051 HICKS A 282 PT TR 9 & 10H 10282001250 A 524,333 770,278 0.6807 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 4 TOTALS 8,737,000 9,030,829 0.9675 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 5 $ 1,183,571 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ LIVINGSTON VENTURES 10015012520 A 1,852,001 2,548,845 0.7266 CHOATE A 15 TR 121-A 10015013500 A 7,408,436 7,108,166 1.0422 CHOATE A 15 TR 163C 10015022502 A 1,298,425 1,035,112 1.2544 CHOATE A 15 TR 168 10015023300 A 3,510,787 4,770,763 0.7359 CHOATE A 15 S 3 PT LT 18A 10015057301 A 1,739,955 2,493,024 0.6979 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 5 TOTALS 15,809,604 17,955,910 0.8805 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM COMP SAMPLE STRATUM SAMPLE SAMPLE STRATUM STRATUM STRATUM CATEGORY _______ ____ ______ _______ ______ ______ _______ _______ _______ ________ CODE PARCELS PARCELS LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE LOCAL VALUE RATIO PTD VALUE RATIO ____ _______ _______ ___________ _________ ___________ _____ _________ _____ 1 U 0 288 0 0 4,468,255 4,468,255 2 R 14 291 1,134,303 1,324,554 21,392,636 0.8564 24,979,724 3 R 13 90 2,909,774 2,782,800 21,150,759 1.0456 20,228,346 4 R 13 30 8,737,000 9,030,829 22,405,438 0.9675 23,158,075 5 R 5 8 15,809,604 17,955,910 20,176,164 0.8805 22,914,440 TOTAL 45 707 28,590,681 31,094,093 89,593,252 95,748,840 0.9357 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 02/25/2005 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 010 TIME: 08:13:27 2004 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 187/Polk VRSN: P 187-907/Livingston ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - STRATUM 2 $ 10,551 - $ 61,364 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ TOYOTA MOTOR CREDIT CORP BP000774600 A 25,917 27,071 0.9574 RICK'S RECREATIONAL VEHIC BP001184600 A 34,984 17,408 2.0097 COUNTRY COTTAGE BP002037500 A 25,000 25,270 0.9893 GE CAPITAL BP002072300 A 25,488 24,466 1.0418 SUMMIT FUNDING BP003199400 A 27,235 23,045 1.1818 WESTAR LEASE ORIGINATION BP003232109 A 14,750 33,963 0.4343 UHAUL INTERNATIONAL BP200213605 A 27,618 58,981 0.4683 FRITO-LAY INC BP920068000 A 11,934 11,934 1.0000 SUBWAY SNADWICHES BP970736300 A 22,733 17,920 1.2686 DE LAGE LANDEN OPERATIONA BP980207591 A 19,280 74,835 0.2576 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 2 TOTALS 234,939 314,893 0.7461 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - STRATUM 3 $ 61,365 - $ 235,333 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ PINE RIDGE NURSING HOME BP000104000 A 203,487 190,071 1.0706 MOBILE SUN MART BP000215010 A 68,500 55,484 1.2346 FORD MOTOR CREDIT BP000272001 A 127,525 83,190 1.5329 LIVINGSTON JEWELRY COMPAN BP000471000 A 72,244 90,736 0.7962 OWEN FURNITURE BP000576000 A 224,779 137,200 1.6383 PETROLEUM WHOLESALE CONVE BP000599500 A 144,057 78,053 1.8456 FIRST STATE BANK - WESTSI BP200064700 A 79,794 86,947 0.9177 TEXAS PEPPER RESTAURANT BP930202500 A 75,259 85,805 0.8771 PITNEY BOWES CREDIT CORP BP970165413 A 99,997 86,158 1.1606 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 3 TOTALS 1,095,642 893,644 1.2260 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - STRATUM 4 $ 235,334 - $ 1,011,513 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ BASKINS DEPARTMENT STORE BP000044500 A 414,631 415,837 0.9971 RED BARN BUILDERS SUPPLY BP000644300 A 606,555 518,791 1.1692 SAM HOUSTON ELECTRIC COOP BP000668000 A 849,054 834,639 1.0173 SMITH AND SONS GRAVEL BP0006965 A 255,070 269,027 0.9481 AUTOZONE BP001019100 A 423,566 434,096 0.9757 ORILEY AUTO PARTS BP002158500 A 381,836 202,005 1.8902 DOLLAR GENERAL BP9600047800 A 258,484 267,720 0.9655 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 4 TOTALS 3,189,196 2,942,115 1.0840 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ DATE: 02/25/2005 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 011 TIME: 08:13:27 2004 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET REPT: PTS236 187/Polk VRSN: P 187-907/Livingston ISD ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - STRATUM 5 $ 1,011,514 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER S/A SALE DATE SALE PRICE LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO _________________ ______________ ___ _________ __________ ___________ _________ _____ BROOKSHIRE BROS BP000095000 A 1,821,547 1,742,742 1.0452 FIRST NATIONAL BANK BP000267000 A 1,140,552 771,072 1.4792 ECKERD DRUG BP940053000 A 1,198,091 1,184,955 1.0111 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 5 TOTALS 4,160,190 3,698,769 1.1247 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM COMP SAMPLE STRATUM SAMPLE SAMPLE STRATUM STRATUM STRATUM CATEGORY _______ ____ ______ _______ ______ ______ _______ _______ _______ ________ CODE PARCELS PARCELS LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE LOCAL VALUE RATIO PTD VALUE RATIO ____ _______ _______ ___________ _________ ___________ _____ _________ _____ 1 U 0 619 0 0 2,613,298 2,613,298 2 R 10 494 234,939 314,893 12,425,812 0.7461 16,654,352 3 R 9 112 1,095,642 893,644 12,659,005 1.2260 10,325,453 4 R 7 28 3,189,196 2,942,115 12,888,088 1.0840 11,889,380 5 R 3 4 4,160,190 3,698,769 11,769,908 1.1247 10,464,931 TOTAL 29 1,257 8,679,967 7,849,421 52,356,111 51,947,414 1.0079 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ **** END OF REPORT ****
