School and Appraisal Districts' Property Value Study 2003 Preliminary Report

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 42 TIME: 17:16 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 246 Williamson 246-912 Thrall CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AW0131 COURSEY P SUR, ACRES 2. R006150 O 5/02 140,000 131,902 140,000 .9422 AW0131 COURSEY, P. SUR., ACRES R006152 C 7/02 168,000 133,449 168,000 .7943 AW0319 HT & BRR CO SUR, ACRES R006305 O 5/03 75,000 63,034 75,000 .8405 AW0493 PACE, H. SUR., ACRES 2. R006693 B 3/02 45,000 48,045 45,000 1.0677 THRALL CITY OF, BLK 4, LT 4-5, R007063 B 12/02 90,000 86,245 90,000 .9600 OIL CITY ADDN, BLK 13, LT 7-11 R007134 B 7/02 103,000 100,192 103,000 .9700 OIL CITY ADDN, BLK 20, LT 4-7 R007176 B 10/02 75,500 61,817 75,500 .8200 OIL CITY ADDN, BLK 24, LT 7-8, R007207 B 8/02 40,000 47,782 40,000 1.1946 OIL CITY ADDN, BLK 24, LT 15-1 R007210 O 4/03 46,000 32,134 46,000 .6986 OIL CITY ADDN, BLK 25, LT 30-3 R007222 O 4/03 37,500 43,052 37,500 1.1500 BEAUKISS ESTATES, LT 1 & 2(W P R301916 O 8/02 150,000 105,362 150,000 .7024 OAK CREEK SUB, LT 4, ACRES 10. R313858 B 5/02 96,500 130,219 96,500 1.3494 BEAUKISS ESTATES, LT 4(E/PT), R367646 W 8/02 84,000 69,816 84,000 .8311 KELM ESTATES SEC 1, BLK A, LT R372286 B 9/02 105,000 106,163 105,000 1.0100 KELM ESTATES SEC 1, BLK B, LT R372630 B 4/02 99,500 98,856 99,500 .9900 KELM ESTATES SEC 1, BLK C, LT R372650 W 9/02 110,000 97,284 110,000 .8844 KELM ESTATES SEC 1, BLK C, LT R372651 O 2/03 112,850 96,585 112,850 .8600 KELM ESTATES SEC 1, BLK C, LT R372662 B 4/02 103,000 98,737 103,000 .9600 QUAIL CREEK ADDN, LT 4 R373879 W 5/02 138,000 124,599 138,000 .9029 QUAIL CREEK ADDN, LT 54-62 R373935 O 11/02 260,000 189,596 260,000 .7292 20 SALES CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER MOD OBS APPR VAL APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AW0014 ZARZA P SUR, ACRES .75 R005605 1.00 .00 58,449 57,356 1.0200 AW0014 ZARZA P SUR, ACRES 1.94 R005650 .99 .00 86,638 95,335 .9100 AW0014 ZARZA F SUR, ACRES 3.26 R005670 1.00 .00 84,248 86,056 .9800 AW0059 BEVIL J SUR, ACRES .20 R005829 .99 .00 77,550 80,977 .9600 AW0418 MILLER S SUR, ACRES .86 R006405 .99 .00 31,788 34,478 .9200 TUCEK ESTATES, LT A, ACRES 10. R006718 .99 .00 159,276 164,629 .9700 OIL CITY ADDN, BLK 13, LT 46-4 R007135 .99 .00 83,280 85,832 .9700 OIL CITY ADDN, BLK 19, LT 29-3 R007174 .99 .00 97,345 113,597 .8600 OIL CITY ADDN, BLK 21, LT 1-2 R007183 .99 .00 46,886 49,410 .9500 OIL CITY ADDN, BLK 23, LT 17-1 R007203 .99 .00 70,270 73,692 .9500 AW0433 MILHRON J SUR, ACRES 1. R096047 .99 .00 80,221 86,948 .9200 AW0061 BAKER C W SUR, ACRES 2. R097291 .99 .00 56,869 58,218 .9800 AW0443 MCDANIEL M SUR, ACRES 1 R363983 .99 .00 234,076 252,922 .9300 AW0014 ZARZA P SUR, ACRES 1.14 R407326 .99 .00 130,017 139,655 .9300 14 APPRAISALS

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 43 TIME: 17:16 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 246 Williamson 246-912 Thrall STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9235 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AW0014 ZARZA P SUR, ACRES 237. R005491, R005492 O 2/03 351,644 431,971 .8140 AW0014 ZARZA, P. SUR., ACRES 1 R005501, R005502 B 6/02 275,761 261,000 1.0566 AW0014 ZARZA P SUR, ACRES 73.4 R005627 O 5/03 172,116 135,021 1.2700 AW0014 ZARZA, P. SUR., ACRES 1 R005693 B 8/02 69,589 67,082 1.0374 AW0061 BAKER, C.W. SUR., ACRES R005859 B 5/02 162,486 130,575 1.2444 AW0123 CARTWRIGHT W SUR, AC 11 R005995 W 8/02 248,349 168,750 1.4717 AW0123 CARTWRIGHT W SUR, AC 6. R006015 O 3/03 75,263 87,500 .8600 AW0223 EIGENAUER C SUR, ACRES R006177 O 4/02 128,541 91,000 1.4125 AW0443 MCDANIEL M SUR, ACRES 7 R006474 O 1/03 154,700 220,620 .7012 AW0647 WHITE, H. SUR., ACRES 2 R006898 B 10/02 412,375 398,305 1.0353 AW0014 ZARZA, P. SUR., TRACT 6 R051286 B 8/02 79,028 82,300 .9602 AW0480 NICHOLS WM SUR, ACRES 3 R086503, R310894, R430224 O 8/02 224,155 236,000 .9498 AW0656 WEST W SUR, ACRES 264.8 R331421, R005988, R006935 O 1/02 669,420 675,000 .9900 13 SALES CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER APPR VAL APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AW0123 CARTWRIGHT W SUR, ACRES R006018 225,000 200,000 1.1300 AW0234 FOLEY HRS G SUR, ACRES R006217 118,098 122,583 .9600 AW0418 MILLER S SUR, ACRES 11. R006356 48,832 51,210 .9500 AW0451 MAHAN P J SUR, ACRES 89 R006481 203,454 178,000 1.1400 AW0647 WHITE H SUR, ACRES 229. R006852 436,888 459,640 .9500 AW0014 ZARZA P SUR, ACRES .70 R325201 2,711 2,800 .9700 6 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0148 CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE.