Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   1/22/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:      2
TIME:     17:14                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             244  Wilbarger
                                                         244-903  Vernon

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  STEPHENS K SEAN & VICKIE L       0009-027-0223-110-4        C       3/02         47,000          48,220        47,000    1.0260
  PIPER CURWIN & DARYLA            0012-016-0609-300-3        C       2/03         45,000          30,600        45,000     .6800
  JASSO ARTHUR & STACEY            0012-021-0160-020-3        C       7/02         45,000          49,700        45,000    1.1044
  WALKER MARQUITA                  0012-062-0726-180-3        C       7/02         25,000          41,910        25,000    1.6800
  CONN TONY                        0012-063-0177-080-3        C       1/02         72,000          63,350        72,000     .8799
  ESCOBEDO RODRIGO & MARITZA       0012-063-0177-310-3        C       8/02         36,000          42,150        36,000    1.1708
  NAVA MELANIE & MICHAEL VALVERD   0012-063-0177-370-3        C       8/02         51,550          46,980        51,550     .9113
  REED JIM C & TONYA C             0014-071-0289-061-4        C       7/02         85,000          82,540        85,000     .9711
  HOLLINGSWORTH CAROL ANN          0014-087-0297-010-4        W       9/02         21,900          11,980        21,900     .5470
  TAYLOR TRAVIS N & CAROL  ANN     0014-090-0855-440-3        C       3/02        115,000         100,020       115,000     .8697
  DUCKWORTH RHONALD T & BRENDA L   0014-092-0728-171-4        C       6/02         66,500          68,260        66,500    1.0265
  LAMBERT GREGORY T & AMANDA       0130-002-0583-010-3        W       1/03         37,000          21,190        37,000     .5727
  SIPPEL REBECCA C                 0132-000-0536-241-4        W       1/03         89,000          35,550        89,000     .3994
  URQUIZO MICHELLE D & JOHN A J    2841001                    C       3/03         47,500          51,680        47,500    1.0900
  MUSICK NORMAN & KEITHA           3636001                    C       9/02         77,500          81,780        77,500    1.0552
  SHIVERS BOBBY R                  4496001                    C      10/02         18,000          17,850        18,000     .9917
  ZAMORA JESUS H & CAROLYN         5001-030-0000-130-3        C       4/02         45,000          39,920        45,000     .8871
  SCHEIDE JOSHUALINE A &           5001-077-0000-120-3        C       1/02         33,700          30,060        33,700     .8920
  TURKETT JOHNNY W JR              5001-081-0000-110-3        C       2/03         15,000          18,490        15,000    1.2327
  SMITH TERRY J                    5010-002-0000-030-3        B       7/02         39,468          45,160        39,468    1.1442
  HALL BILLY & PATTY               5040-003-0000-070-3        C      10/02         52,000          48,680        52,000     .9362
  ANDERSON ALLEN                   5040-003-0000-070-3-A      C       5/02         35,000          51,730        35,000    1.4780
  BESS KIM & JOHNNIE               5065-001-0000-070-3        C       9/02         75,000          66,900        75,000     .8920
  STREIT SUE ANN                   5080-001-0000-060-3        C       4/02         33,000          42,410        33,000    1.2852
  RICHARDSON DAN & CATHY           5080-001-0000-110-3        C       7/02         36,500          46,330        36,500    1.2693
  CALIFORNIA FEDERAL BANK FSB      5090-001-0000-010-3        C       5/02         40,700          46,650        40,700    1.1462
  HERRERA MACKENZIE R &            5090-001-0000-030-3        C       2/03         23,500          22,850        23,500     .9723
  MCCUE GARY C & NANCY A           5105-001-0000-030-3        B       5/02        115,000         105,450       115,000     .9170
  BELLAR CHRIS D                   5105-001-0000-050-3        C       4/02         16,000          20,870        16,000    1.3044
  BRUMLEY WILLIAM & DEBBIE         5106-005-0000-060-3        C       2/03         47,000          48,030        47,000    1.0219
  RODRIQUEZ JOE A & SUSAN R        5135-001-0000-120-3        C       9/02         48,150          47,140        48,150     .9790
  REYNA  ANGELA                    5175-006-0000-050-3        W       3/02         34,000          29,130        34,000     .8568
  RUBLE MICHAEL J & ANGELA         5180-001-0000-050-3        C       9/02        105,000         111,630       105,000    1.0631
  MITCHELL JAMES L                 5180-001-0000-080-3        B       4/02         89,000          84,190        89,000     .9460
  AYDELOTT RAY & ELAINE            5185-001-0000-080-3        W       2/03         17,200          12,520        17,200     .7279
  SLAUGENHOP JAMES C & GAYLA       5210-002-0000-120-3        W       9/02         25,000          19,640        25,000     .7856
  WHITE  MARK                      5210-003-0000-140-3        C       2/03         19,000          22,810        19,000    1.2005
  SADLER JOE D & EVELYN R          5235-001-0000-040-3        C       4/02         57,120          54,110        57,120     .9473
  MAY DOUGLAS M & MITZI M          5240-001-0000-070-3        W      12/02         25,000          14,030        25,000     .5612
  JOUETT RICHARD & PATTI           5270-001-0000-150-3        B       8/02         25,000          18,570        25,000     .7428
  DAUGHTY MINNIE P                 5270-002-0000-070-3        B      12/02         25,726          29,030        25,726    1.1284
  WHITE CARL D & DORIS             5270-004-0000-060-3        C       2/03         22,500          36,930        22,500    1.6413
  HAYNES ROBERT L & PRISCILLA      5270-005-0000-200-3        C       3/02         54,700          52,460        54,700     .9590
  WATTS JAMES LARRY                5279001                    C      10/02         25,000          33,610        25,000    1.3444
  GAMMON KENNETH R                 5295-003-0000-100-3        C       4/02         47,500          64,780        47,500    1.3638
  QUISENBERRY DAVID & CHRIS        5295-004-0000-030-3        C       5/02         62,000          65,530        62,000    1.0569
  DAVIS THAYER H                   5295-004-0000-080-3        C       5/02         78,500          76,370        78,500     .9729

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 3 TIME: 17:14 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 244 Wilbarger 244-903 Vernon CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ GOCO ELEAMAR B & MARYLOU 5295-004-0000-100-3 C 4/02 63,000 70,000 63,000 1.1111 PATE SHIRLEY 5300-003-0000-130-3 C 9/02 21,150 22,540 21,150 1.0657 MARTIN BOBBY & LINDA 5300-004-0000-070-3 B 7/02 31,000 25,110 31,000 .8100 WILSON TODD & DIANA 5300-005-0000-030-3 B 1/03 38,000 59,500 38,000 1.5658 WHITESIDE KEVIN & BRANDI 5310-002-0000-090-3 B 7/02 75,000 63,930 75,000 .8524 BAKER THERON W & BRENDA KAY 5315-002-0000-100-3 C 5/02 76,350 72,990 76,350 .9560 SELMAN JOHN H 5320-002-0000-180-3 W 7/02 67,500 52,010 67,500 .7705 MARTINEZ JAMES L & CYNTHIA E 5390-002-0000-010-3 C 3/02 80,750 77,650 80,750 .9616 DOCKERY BURT & NANCY 5403001 C 9/02 25,500 25,020 25,500 .9812 MARTINEZ JERRY D & ELLEN D 5435-004-0000-080-3 B 12/02 20,000 19,710 20,000 .9855 ELROD MISTY 5490-005-0000-040-3 C 3/02 28,500 20,310 28,500 .7126 GARY CHERYL 5515-002-0000-100-3 B 1/02 60,000 62,510 60,000 1.0418 AGUILAR JOSE & YOLANDA 5550-001-0000-015-3 W 6/02 27,000 14,300 27,000 .5296 MORALES JOSE D & ANA IMELDA 5550-001-0000-021-3 W 1/03 100,000 121,290 100,000 1.2129 2 C PARTNERSHIP 5550-001-0000-032-3 C 9/02 25,020 23,645 25,020 .9450 RYERSON DENZEL E & PATRICIA AN 5550-001-0000-111-3 C 1/02 30,000 47,960 30,000 1.5987 GILLISPIE LARRY G & 5627-001-0000-030-3 C 12/02 14,400 18,600 14,400 1.2917 FREEMAN JAMES II 5670-036-0000-070-3 C 1/03 8,500 14,650 8,500 1.7235 PARKER CHARLES & ALICE 5670-057-0000-011-3 C 3/02 13,000 12,520 13,000 .9631 CAMPBELL CHRISTINA 5670-067-0000-050-3 B 2/03 20,200 21,170 20,200 1.0480 BAILEY RONNIE M 5690-002-0000-140-3 C 12/02 58,000 51,390 58,000 .8860 WHITESIDE TONY & MELINDA MENDE 5691-002-0000-310-3 B 9/02 55,000 64,990 55,000 1.1816 SHERMAN LENA E 5691-004-0000-140-3 W 9/02 73,500 49,460 73,500 .6729 WILLS JAMES G & REBECCA D 5715-001-0000-020-3 B 5/02 33,450 25,450 33,450 .7608 CARR JIMMY & SUE MITCHELL 5735-001-0000-050-3 C 6/02 15,000 26,080 15,000 1.7387 HICKMAN JESSIE & DANNY STILLWE 5735-001-0000-050-3-A C 7/02 25,000 26,080 25,000 1.0432 WEAVER CHAZ 5735-005-0000-040-3 C 10/02 30,000 31,450 30,000 1.0483 CAMPBELL AARON E & ELVIRA 5735-006-0000-010-3 W 1/02 40,000 18,620 40,000 .4655 MARLOW MICHAEL DON 5735-011-0000-070-3 B 2/02 47,250 43,610 47,250 .9230 OLIVARES ROSALINDA 5735-013-0000-090-3 C 5/02 45,000 42,410 45,000 .9424 MONTENEGRO ROBERTO 5735-016-0000-060-3 C 6/02 17,500 18,450 17,500 1.0543 MORROW M L 5735-052-0000-070-3 W 5/02 19,513 13,760 19,513 .7052 DAVIS MIKEL R & MELISSA D 5735-080-0000-040-3 C 1/02 13,640 14,110 13,640 1.0345 STORY TERRELL & ROSA 5735-109-0000-010-3 C 10/02 15,000 18,150 15,000 1.2100 TAYLOR JEFFREY E 5765-001-0000-040-3 C 12/02 28,800 34,060 28,800 1.1826 DRAKE JACOB & VERONICA HILL 5770-004-0000-170-3 C 2/02 69,800 65,530 69,800 .9388 OSWALT LARRY & JAN 5770-009-0000-050-3 C 8/02 58,000 74,410 58,000 1.2829 HELMS CONNIE 5770-014-0000-040-3 C 2/02 65,000 61,870 65,000 .9518 MASSARO DANIEL & HARRIET 5770-014-0000-060-3 C 12/02 79,000 72,870 79,000 .9224 HIGHT JOE W & CYNTHIA 5770-017-0000-020-3 C 10/02 50,000 50,090 50,000 1.0018 MANLY TODD D & TRESSA 5770-017-0000-020-3-A C 1/02 54,625 52,620 54,625 .9633 CUELLAR JULIO & SYLVIA T 5770-030-0000-130-3 B 5/02 14,715 24,200 14,715 1.6446 BENEFICIAL TEXAS INC 5770-033-0000-070-3 C 6/02 26,320 29,600 26,320 1.1246 HENRY ROBERT & HAZEL 5770-039-0000-030-3 B 4/02 48,000 31,020 48,000 .6463 GARCIA MIGUEL & MIRNA 5770-041-0000-110-3 C 4/02 20,000 22,490 20,000 1.1245 SALDIVAR FIDENCIO & 5770-044-0000-080-3 C 10/02 15,000 39,140 15,000 2.6093 RUEDA FABIAN 5770-045-0000-030-3 C 12/02 53,550 53,390 53,550 .9970

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 4 TIME: 17:14 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 244 Wilbarger 244-903 Vernon CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ANDERSON ALLEN & LA DONNA 5776-004-0000-060-3 C 6/02 67,500 83,980 67,500 1.2441 STRINGER JAY & SHELLEY 5780-001-0000-010-3 C 2/03 50,856 56,220 50,856 1.1055 TOLENTINO REYNALDO T 5790-004-0000-030-3 W 1/02 142,000 54,850 142,000 .3863 LEE LARRY & VICKY 5795-001-0000-090-3 C 4/02 42,550 45,410 42,550 1.0672 SORTO JAMES A & CRISTA L 5795-001-0000-130-3 B 5/02 29,700 23,820 29,700 .8020 BANDA TOMMY LEE 5830-001-0000-010-3 B 2/02 42,000 51,940 42,000 1.2367 GARCIA DAVID & ROSALBA 5830-001-0000-130-3 C 8/02 43,000 46,060 43,000 1.0712 ENLOE MARVIN & SHELLEY 5830-001-0000-200-3 W 9/02 67,500 59,920 67,500 .8877 CHAVEZ VINCENT SR & CONNIE 5830-002-0000-100-3 C 3/02 63,000 64,970 63,000 1.0313 RAMIREZ SAM & MARY 5835-007-0000-070-3 B 6/02 42,300 36,090 42,300 .8532 FULTON KIM R 5835-008-0000-020-3 W 8/02 68,875 60,210 68,875 .8742 REEVES MATTHEW TRAVIS 5835-012-0000-140-3 C 9/02 20,000 18,770 20,000 .9385 BRISTO W L JR & PEGGY 5835-013-0000-040-3 C 6/02 55,000 63,370 55,000 1.1522 GREER DEBRA L 5835-013-0000-161-3 C 7/02 35,000 34,620 35,000 .9891 MUNOZ JOSE & YOLANDA 5845-001-0000-200-3 C 4/02 10,000 11,790 10,000 1.1790 HILL ROGER L & ROBBIE C 5850-001-0000-060-3 C 4/02 23,840 27,090 23,840 1.1363 DRENNAN JOSHUA & LARRY 5920-010-0000-020-4 C 3/02 14,000 12,060 14,000 .8614 RANJEL LUIS & REYMUNDA 5961-001-0000-030-4 C 4/02 7,000 12,600 7,000 1.8000 PARKER CHARLES & ALICE 6180001 C 8/02 15,500 13,940 15,500 .8994 HERRERA MACKENZIE R & 6253001 C 10/02 19,000 22,850 19,000 1.2026 WHITE MARK 6393001 C 3/03 15,000 17,160 15,000 1.1440 WHITE CARL D & DORIS 6629001 C 3/03 37,000 32,580 37,000 .8805 RANGEL ALBERT L 9674001 C 3/03 58,088 55,620 58,088 .9600 117 SALES CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER MOD OBS APPR VAL APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BLK 1 LOT 2 PART NABORS & STEP 1516 1.00 .00 121,290 124,560 .9700 BLK 14 SEC 88 LOT 3-4 TIERRA S 3376 1.00 .00 112,070 107,759 1.0400 BLK 3 LOT 13/BLK 1 LOT 14 TWIN 4120001 1.00 .00 114,350 117,853 .9700 AB 177 BLK 12 SEC 63 H&TC #45 5002001 1.00 .00 98,790 101,575 .9700 BLK 2 LOT 3-4 PART C P MCDONAL 7595001 1.00 .00 95,570 92,987 1.0300 5 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9784 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE.

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 5 TIME: 17:14 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 244 Wilbarger 244-903 Vernon CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ MINTS WENDELL & PATRICIA 0003-020-1633-010-4 W 10/02 160,500 275,000 .5836 HEFFERNAN HENRY TROY 0008-003-0254-070-4 C 1/03 72,100 66,000 1.0924 HANDLEY RODNEY D & VALERIE 0008-007-0253-060-4 C 11/02 59,860 66,000 .9070 KIESCHNICK LARRY & JANET 0009-015-0217-100-4 C 10/02 87,000 78,000 1.1154 HOLIFIELD BROOKS & TABITHA 0012-062-0726-370-3 B 4/02 40,500 61,200 .6618 PINCHAK WILLIAM & IRIS 0012-063-0177-741-3 C 8/02 205,620 180,000 1.1423 PINCHAK WILLIAM & IRIS 0014-082-1066-010-4 B 10/02 52,590 51,000 1.0312 STREIT GARY 0014-086-0611-020-4 C 6/02 80,000 76,300 1.0485 PHILLIPS-GRAHAM PARTNERSHIP 0016-021-0409-010-4 B 7/02 96,680 83,790 1.1538 BOYD MICHAEL & KELI 0024-025-0009-300-4 C 6/02 93,410 85,590 1.0914 HANDLEY MYRON JACK & KATHY 0036-000-0019-052-4 C 2/02 41,410 26,000 1.5927 WISDOM J ROCKNE &GINA M 0045-000-0541-020-4 C 8/02 105,900 68,575 1.5443 BYARS BOBBY & LUANNE 0115-029-0532-020-4 C 2/02 126,090 77,990 1.6167 WHITE MICHAEL & GENE 0130-001-0583-060-4 B 8/02 75,890 85,000 .8928 CAPPS MARSHALL 4468 C 8/02 38,350 39,400 .9700 15 SALES CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER APPR VAL APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AB 131 BLK 2 SEC 19 1198 172,430 174,425 .9900 SEC 69 WAGGONER COLONY SUBD 4017 77,000 82,471 .9300 AB 1038 BLK 9 SEC 10 H&TC 4610001 89,340 93,208 .9600 AB 238 BLK 2 SEC 37 H&TC 9092088 241,300 254,285 .9500 4 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9957 CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ COLEMAN EMMETT R & EVELYN O 0012-015-0157-070-3 W 2/02 30,000 70,470 30,000 2.3490 TAYLOR STEPHEN & CARRIE 5001-015-0000-131-3 B 3/02 23,500 39,630 23,500 1.6864 POWELL GARY 5001-039-0000-010-3 B 4/02 50,000 68,640 50,000 1.3728 LEIJA ROBERT 5001-053-0000-050-3 C 10/02 12,000 20,680 12,000 1.7233 LALA & SONS INC 5001-076-0000-130-3 C 2/03 30,000 42,350 30,000 1.4117 WHITE ROSALINDA JUANITA & 5175-012-0000-010-3 C 3/02 7,000 28,040 7,000 4.0057

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 6 TIME: 17:14 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 244 Wilbarger 244-903 Vernon CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ STREIT SUE ANN 6493001 C 3/03 48,000 48,380 48,000 1.0079 7 SALES CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AB 160 BLK 12 SEC 21 H&TC 4A 1482001 .00 1.00 .00 68,110 72,145 .9400 AAB 807 BLK 12 SEC 20 H&TC 2121 .00 1.00 .00 154,570 150,395 1.0300 AB 157 BLK 12 SEC 15 H&TC 2392001 .00 1.00 .00 266,420 347,326 .7700 BLK 19 LOT 1-5 & 12-16 NAORTH 2737001 .00 1.00 .00 78,730 84,015 .9400 BLK 17 SW/4 TEXAS TOWNSITE 3208001 .00 1.00 .00 2,211,070 2,101,650 1.0500 BLK 4 LOT 6-14 PETTIT 3248001 .00 1.00 .00 136,370 132,597 1.0300 BLK 12 SEC 20 15.116 ACRES 4274001 .00 1.00 .00 4,570,130 4,533,883 1.0100 BLK 3 LOT 1 TR C NABORS & STEP 4930 .00 1.00 .00 269,930 250,508 1.0800 BLK 21 LOT 4-8 & 11-16 PARTS N 5509001 .00 1.00 .00 41,550 43,308 .9600 BLK 5 LOT 1-2 PARTS NABORS & S 5890001 .00 1.00 .00 224,570 222,933 1.0100 BLK 10 LOT 11 OT 6956001 .00 1.00 .00 21,220 23,825 .8900 BLK 47 LOT 13-16 OT 7401001 .00 1.00 .00 68,750 69,790 .9900 AB 155 BLK 12 SEC 11 H&TC 7613001 .00 1.00 .00 72,860 75,718 .9600 BLK 14 LOT 7-8 OT 8008001 .00 1.00 .00 22,360 22,960 .9700 BLK 25 LOT 4-13 PARTS OT 827 .00 1.00 .00 578,800 550,810 1.0500 BLK 3 LOT 1 TR A NABORS & STEP 8323001 .00 1.00 .00 505,280 526,489 .9600 BLK 21 LOT 1-3 & 14-16 PART NO 855001 .00 1.00 .00 22,960 28,258 .8100 BLK 9 LOT 1-4 PARTS BACON & BE 8598001 .00 1.00 .00 239,740 310,739 .7700 AB 807 BLK 12 SEC 20 H&TC #1 8674001 .00 1.00 .00 551,050 575,513 .9600 BLK 7 T H JONES 9003001 .00 1.00 .00 196,920 273,063 .7200 BLK 24 LOT 5-15 PART NORTH ADD 9398001 .00 1.00 .00 288,800 287,354 1.0100 BLK 4 LOT 3-4 PARTS NABORS & S 9565001 .00 1.00 .00 884,820 810,921 1.0900 22 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO WITH EXCEPTIONS: 1.0241 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ PMH ENTERPRISES 815000411 17,500 17,180 1.0200

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 7 TIME: 17:14 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 244 Wilbarger 244-903 Vernon CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ FAMILY PHARMACY 815000420 199,030 219,350 .9100 MGA INC 815000468 92,850 90,200 1.0300 WHEELS INC 815000483 23,624 30,650 .7700 DOLGENCORP OF TEXAS #01726 815000746 221,030 219,768 1.0100 MAC FLYING SERVICE 815000783 25,500 26,231 .9700 INDEPENDENT ENVIRONMENTAL 815000796 105,000 101,850 1.0300 FARMER'S CO-OP ELEVATOR 815001104 334,200 324,234 1.0300 WINTER-HAYS MONUMENT CO 815001176 71,950 70,639 1.0200 UNITED SUPERMARKET #513 815001241 1,317,490 1,317,494 1.0000 SUMNER-COLLEY HARDWARE 815001302 270,940 270,603 1.0000 VERNON DAILY RECORD 815001579 106,000 103,540 1.0200 LORRIE'S 815001681 19,250 19,212 1.0000 HERRING NATIONAL BANK 815001727 351,400 340,858 1.0300 MOBILE CLEAN INC 815002283 20,000 19,400 1.0300 JACK'S FORD TRACTOR 815101513 82,140 82,140 1.0000 RUBLE - VANCE AUTOPLEX 815112944 472,230 482,575 .9800 CHRISTANELLI FORD 815121066 552,120 557,871 .9900 PRAXAIR INC 99055 19,480 19,869 .9800 PEGASUS SATELLITE TELEVISION I 99080 16,200 15,718 1.0300 WAL MART STORE TEXAS LP #0555 99090 4,896,070 5,033,506 .9700 O'REILLY AUTO PARTS 99186 327,930 325,737 1.0100 WEST TEXAS APPLIANCE 99199 65,910 65,478 1.0100 23 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO WITH EXCEPTIONS: .9871