Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   1/22/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:      5
TIME:     17:06                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             236  Walker
                                                         236-902  Huntsville

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  BURDITT A-8 TR 22                10423                      C       5/02         80,000          79,530        80,000     .9941
  COX SUR A-13, TR 33.3            11289                      C       1/03         74,500          73,590        74,500     .9878
  COX A-13 TR 69.3                 11334                      C       5/02         30,000          30,840        30,000    1.0280
  A-BST 14 J CRANE SUR TR 23       11443                      C       2/03         52,000          50,140        52,000     .9642
  CRANE SUR A-14 TR 3.2            11460                      C       6/02         47,500          44,930        47,500     .9459
  CRANE A-14, TR 9                 11467                      C       9/02         31,000          36,890        31,000    1.1900
  ROBINSON A-42 TR 17.1            14403                      C       6/02         20,000          19,640        20,000     .9820
  ABST-67 BEARD, TR 7.1            15347                      C       4/02         69,900          62,850        69,900     .8991
  BOBO A-74 TR 13.1                15554                      C       5/02         87,200          86,390        87,200     .9907
  E DAV A-157, TR 2.1              16180                      C      12/02        126,000         124,560       126,000     .9886
  TMBER CRK EST LT 29              17174                      C       7/02         41,900          42,180        41,900    1.0067
  INGRAM SUR A-295, TR 5.3         17695                      C       5/02         66,500          63,390        66,500     .9532
  LAMB SUR A-326, TR 5             18027                      C       2/03         89,775          83,040        89,775     .9250
  LAMB SUR A-326 TR 14.4           18097                      C      12/02        128,000         124,840       128,000     .9753
  PARKER A-345 TR 9                18353                      C       6/02         90,000          88,570        90,000     .9841
  MELTON A-361, TR 4.9             18658                      C       4/02         22,000          32,040        22,000    1.4564
  MCMILLIAN A-388 TR 10            18983                      C       6/02         66,000          62,990        66,000     .9544
  MCMILLIAN A-388 TR 64.3          19091                      C      12/02        102,000         102,650       102,000    1.0064
  MCMILLIAN A-388 TR 68.3          19097                      C       7/02        110,000         109,530       110,000     .9957
  PALMER SUR A-445 TR 17           19583                      C       6/02         75,000          68,590        75,000     .9145
  ROBT SUR A-466, TR 5             19734                      C       6/02        225,000         215,710       225,000     .9587
  RANDOLPH A-467 TR 16.1           19828                      C       9/02         90,000          90,580        90,000    1.0064
  SHPRD SUR A-502, TR 13.4         20280                      C       4/02        162,000         154,210       162,000     .9519
  WM TOM SUR A-542 TR 37.1         20739                      C      11/02         70,000          64,560        70,000     .9223
  TINSLEY A-548, TR 6.5            20867                      C       7/02         99,500         103,920        99,500    1.0444
  ING RR A-692, TR 13              21569                      C       6/02        155,000         148,220       155,000     .9563
  ALLEN LT 1.1                     21889                      C      12/02         37,500          41,640        37,500    1.1104
  BLAYLOCK SEC 1 LT 16             22136                      C       6/02         45,000          43,850        45,000     .9744
  BLAYLOCK LT 28                   22153                      C       5/02         30,000          29,380        30,000     .9793
  CAROLINA COVE SEC 1 BK 5 LTS 1   22742                      C       6/02         74,500          75,380        74,500    1.0118
  E DAVID SUR LT 43                24015                      C      11/02         45,000          42,370        45,000     .9416
  E DAVID SUR LT 1.2               24061                      C      12/02         76,900          69,930        76,900     .9094
  E DAVIDS TR 3.5                  24117                      C       2/03         84,000          81,720        84,000     .9729
  E DAVIDS SUR LT 9                24300                      C       8/02         95,000          91,340        95,000     .9615
  DEERFIELD CROSS LT 29            24378                      C       7/02         80,500          76,440        80,500     .9496
  EDGEWOOD SEC 1 LT 3              24762                      C       8/02         83,500          77,940        83,500     .9300
  ELK LK SEC 1 BK 3 LT 10          24803                      C       9/02        143,000         143,170       143,000    1.0012
  LKINS LK SEC 1 BK 3 LT 12        24805                      C      11/02        173,476         159,390       173,476     .9188
  ELK LK SEC 1 BK 3 LT 29          24822                      C       6/02         82,500          86,670        82,500    1.0505
  ELK LK SEC 1 BK 4 LT 6           24829                      C       1/03         50,000          51,280        50,000    1.0256
  ELKINS LK SEC 1 BK 4 LT 25       24848                      C       5/02        130,000         124,060       130,000     .9543
  ELK LK SEC 1 BK 4 LT 36          24858                      C      11/02        122,000         121,270       122,000     .9940
  ELKINS LK SEC 1 BK 4 LT 45       24867                      C       5/02        100,500          98,710       100,500     .9822
  ELK SEC 1 BK 4 LT 46             24868                      C       1/03        112,000         110,360       112,000     .9854
  ELKINS LK SEC 1 BK 4 LT 51       24873                      C       5/02        122,000         118,250       122,000     .9693
  ELKINS LK SEC 1 BK 4 LT 65       24886                      C       8/02         92,000          89,490        92,000     .9727
  ELK LK SEC 1 BK 5 LT 16          24911                      C       9/02        126,700         126,430       126,700     .9979

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 6 TIME: 17:06 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 236 Walker 236-902 Huntsville CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ELK LK SEC 1 BK 7 LT 16 24980 C 7/02 130,000 129,490 130,000 .9961 ELKINS LK SEC 1 BK 9 LT 2 25060 C 9/02 110,000 107,770 110,000 .9797 ELKINS LK SEC 2 BK 3 LT 33 25100 C 5/02 104,000 98,870 104,000 .9507 ELK SEC 2 BK 6 LT 33 25136 C 7/02 165,000 165,670 165,000 1.0041 ELK LJ SEC 2 BK 11 LT 36 25177 C 7/02 130,000 128,990 130,000 .9922 ELK LK SEC 2 BK 12 LT 4 25229 C 2/03 90,000 101,590 90,000 1.1288 ELK LK SEC 2 BK 15 LT 33 25277 C 12/02 108,000 107,150 108,000 .9921 ELK LK SEC 2 BK 15 LT 34 25278 C 8/02 115,000 128,150 115,000 1.1143 ELK SEC 2 BK 17 LT 1 25301 C 11/02 157,000 155,230 157,000 .9887 ELKINS LK SEC 2 BK 18 LT 10 25397 C 8/02 142,000 139,170 142,000 .9801 ELK LK SEC 2 BK 18 LT 16 25403 C 9/02 148,000 148,490 148,000 1.0033 ELKINS LAKE SEC 2 BK 18 LTS 18 25405 C 11/02 225,000 213,220 225,000 .9476 ELKINS LK SEC 3 BK 9 LT 81 25493 C 9/02 169,500 161,710 169,500 .9540 ELKINS LK SEC 3 BK 21 LT 25 25543 C 4/02 163,000 156,710 163,000 .9614 ELK LK SEC 3 BK 22 LT 18 25574 C 12/02 132,000 132,030 132,000 1.0002 ELK SEC 3 BK 22 LT 24,25 25579 C 2/03 165,000 163,360 165,000 .9901 ELKINS LK SEC 3 BK 24 LT 14 25646 C 6/02 110,000 105,620 110,000 .9602 ELK LK SEC 3A BK 25 LT 28 25680 C 9/02 83,000 98,500 83,000 1.1867 ELKINS LK SEC 3 BK 25 LT 31 25683 C 11/02 170,000 161,350 170,000 .9491 ELKINS LK SEC 3A BK 25 LT 50 25700 C 2/03 146,900 142,540 146,900 .9703 ELK LK SEC 3 BK 26 LT 10 25748 C 8/02 164,000 165,000 164,000 1.0061 ELK LK SEC 3 BK 26 LT 43 25781 C 4/02 112,000 113,480 112,000 1.0132 ELKINS LK SEC 3 BK 26 LT 45 25783 C 11/02 105,000 102,440 105,000 .9756 ELK LK SEC 3 BK 28 LTS 1,2 25826 C 9/02 195,000 194,430 195,000 .9971 ELK LK SEC 3 BK 28 LT 22 25846 C 7/02 128,000 128,800 128,000 1.0063 ELK SEC 3 BK 28 LT 40 25863 C 8/02 123,000 123,680 123,000 1.0055 ELK LK SEC 3 BK 28 LT 44 25866 C 11/02 129,900 129,700 129,900 .9985 ELKINS LK SEC 3A, BK 29 LT 26 25894 C 6/02 184,000 176,420 184,000 .9588 ELK LK SEC 3 BK 30 LT 10 25928 C 8/02 95,500 99,170 95,500 1.0384 ELKINS LK SEC 3 BK 30 LT 22 25939 C 12/02 170,000 165,690 170,000 .9746 ELK LK SEC 3 BK 31 LT 1 25941 C 11/02 132,500 137,160 132,500 1.0352 ELKINS LK SEC 3 BK 31 LT 2 25942 C 2/03 157,500 149,530 157,500 .9494 ELK LK SEC 3 BK 31 LT 25,26 25962 C 5/02 135,000 137,900 135,000 1.0215 ELK LK SEC 3 BK 31 LT 34 25970 C 12/02 85,000 104,730 85,000 1.2321 ELK LK SEC 3 BK 32 LT 24 25997 C 8/02 127,500 146,780 127,500 1.1512 ELK SEC 3 BK 33 LT 7,8 26052 C 5/02 177,000 174,640 177,000 .9867 ELKINS LAKE SEC 3 BK 33 LT 29 26071 C 1/03 243,900 228,480 243,900 .9368 ELK LK SEC 3 BK 34 LT 6 26075 C 5/02 60,000 81,360 60,000 1.3560 ELK LK SEC 3 BK 36 LT 5 26148 C 9/02 136,200 135,610 136,200 .9957 ELK LK SEC 3 BK 37 LT 31 26186 C 7/02 110,000 111,320 110,000 1.0120 ELKINS LK SEC 4 BK 37 LT 72 26248 C 7/02 141,000 135,720 141,000 .9626 ELK LK SEC 4 BK 37 LT 121 26289 C 5/02 159,000 158,450 159,000 .9965 ELK LK SEC 4 BK 42 LT 43 26330 C 7/02 124,000 122,780 124,000 .9902 ELK SEC 4 BK 43 LT 1 26359 C 3/03 187,680 185,480 187,680 .9883 ELKIN LK SEC 4 BK 43 LTS 38,39 26393 C 2/03 335,000 326,740 335,000 .9753 ELK LK SEC 4 BK 43 LTS 63,64 26416 C 5/02 170,000 177,670 170,000 1.0451 ELK LK SEC 4 BK 44 LT 29 26448 C 6/02 125,000 126,230 125,000 1.0098

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 7 TIME: 17:06 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 236 Walker 236-902 Huntsville CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ELKINS LK SEC 4 BK 45 LT 45 26487 C 8/02 108,000 105,380 108,000 .9757 GOLF VIEW MANOR SEC 1 BK 1 LT 26579 C 10/02 100,000 101,720 100,000 1.0172 GOLF VIEW MANOR SEC 1 BK 1 LT 26592 C 8/02 122,000 117,140 122,000 .9602 LAKEVIEW SEC 1 BK 1 LT 26 26630 C 1/03 255,000 239,490 255,000 .9392 WATERS EDGE BK 47 LT 7 26656 C 8/02 130,000 123,170 130,000 .9475 WATERS EDGE BK 48 LT 8 26683 C 7/02 172,500 168,790 172,500 .9785 WATERS EDGE BK 48 LT 25 26700 C 6/02 89,000 90,600 89,000 1.0180 FAR HILLS SEC 2 LT 27 26954 C 12/02 70,000 65,830 70,000 .9404 FAR HILL 2 LT 40 26967 C 9/02 107,500 106,080 107,500 .9868 FAR HILLS 2 LT 59 26985 C 6/02 86,500 85,150 86,500 .9844 FAR HLS SEC 2 LT 75 27011 C 6/02 130,000 124,590 130,000 .9584 FOR HILLS SEC 1 BK 2 LT 9 27036 C 7/02 110,000 123,880 110,000 1.1262 OR HILLS BK 3 LT 2 27048 C 6/02 81,000 87,070 81,000 1.0749 FOR HILLS SEC 1 BK 3 LT 12 27058 C 5/02 147,500 146,470 147,500 .9930 FOR HILLS SEC 1 BK 3 LT 20 27066 C 7/02 69,000 129,770 69,000 1.8807 FOR HILLS SEC 1 BK 15 LT 9 27119 C 4/02 121,000 119,780 121,000 .9899 FOR HILLS BK 15 LT 22 27132 C 5/02 145,000 145,430 145,000 1.0030 FOREST HILLS SEC 1 BK 15 LT 23 27133 C 6/02 116,000 109,380 116,000 .9429 FOR HILLS BK 18 LT 3 27142 C 9/02 115,500 114,030 115,500 .9873 FOREST HILLS SEC 1 BK 18 LT 26 27164 C 12/02 133,400 125,930 133,400 .9440 FOR HILLS SEC 1 BK 21 LT 24 27188 C 4/02 100,000 104,500 100,000 1.0450 FOR HLS SEC Q 1 BK 23 LT 3 27191 C 1/03 70,000 99,190 70,000 1.4170 FOR HILLS SEC 4 BK 2 LT 14 27252 C 9/02 95,000 97,740 95,000 1.0288 FORET HILLS SEC 4 BK 3 LT 4 27261 C 8/02 139,900 133,110 139,900 .9515 FOR HILLS SEC 4 BK 4 LT 3 27268 C 9/02 90,000 94,550 90,000 1.0506 FOR HILLS SEC 4 BK 4 LT 8 27273 C 5/02 105,000 116,210 105,000 1.1068 FOR HILLS SEC 4 BK 5 LT 8 27295 C 2/03 99,500 94,040 99,500 .9451 FOREST HILLS SEC 4 BK 5 LT 12 27299 C 10/02 120,000 116,990 120,000 .9749 FOREST HILLS SEC 4 BK 7 LT 4 27323 C 4/02 118,000 114,040 118,000 .9664 FOREST HILLS SEC 5 BK 2 LT 1 27340 C 11/02 93,000 90,030 93,000 .9681 FOR JILLS SEC 5 BK 3 LT 8 27356 C 11/02 125,500 124,580 125,500 .9927 GIBBS-PRITCHEET BK B LT 1 27838 C 9/02 107,000 101,350 107,000 .9472 ABERCROMBIE BK 7 PT LT 4 27878 C 10/02 86,000 82,790 86,000 .9627 GIBB-PRITCHETT BK I PT LT 1 27893 C 4/02 63,000 60,770 63,000 .9646 GIBBS-PRITCHETTE BK 12 LT 4 27936 C 4/02 94,500 94,290 94,500 .9978 GIBBS-PRITCHETT BK 13 LT 18 27957 C 7/02 84,900 87,230 84,900 1.0274 GIBBS PRIT BK P LT 19 27958 C 1/03 85,000 91,890 85,000 1.0811 HARDY OAKS LT 6 28381 C 10/02 133,000 142,840 133,000 1.0740 HARMON CREEK RNCHETES BK 1 LT 28429 C 6/02 113,300 107,490 113,300 .9487 HARMONY CRK RNCH BK 5 LT 65 28484 C 2/03 125,000 122,810 125,000 .9825 HARMON CRK RDG LT 217 28567 C 6/02 39,900 39,790 39,900 .9972 HGLND PK BK 3 LT 2 29181 C 6/02 89,000 85,360 89,000 .9591 HIGHLND PK BK 4 LT 11 29202 C 7/02 97,500 95,100 97,500 .9754 HIGHLND SEC 1 BK 1 LT 5 29215 C 9/02 97,000 107,850 97,000 1.1119 HGLND #2 BK 10 LT 8 29261 C 6/02 117,000 114,480 117,000 .9785 HIGHLAND ADDN SEC 3 BK 12 LT 9 29272 C 2/03 97,000 91,500 97,000 .9433 HGLND SEC 3 BK 17 LT 9 29326 C 8/02 138,000 132,490 138,000 .9601

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 8 TIME: 17:06 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 236 Walker 236-902 Huntsville CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ HGLND ADDN SEC 3 BK 29 LT 7 29400 C 7/02 130,000 124,690 130,000 .9592 HIGHLND #4 BK 4 LT 10 29439 C 5/02 124,000 119,890 124,000 .9669 HIGHLAND TERR LT 9 29483 C 11/02 135,000 126,130 135,000 .9343 HIGHLAND TERR LT 12 29486 C 12/02 142,000 134,950 142,000 .9504 HILL N DALE LT 17 29561 C 10/02 89,900 86,840 89,900 .9660 HILL-N-DALE LT 32 29575 C 8/02 95,000 92,270 95,000 .9713 HILL-N DALE LT 39 29581 C 4/02 78,000 78,740 78,000 1.0095 HNTVLLE TWNSITE BK 10 LT 2 29819 C 10/02 20,000 26,070 20,000 1.3035 HNTSVLLE TWNSITE BK 21 LT 2 29892 C 2/03 107,500 102,290 107,500 .9515 HNTVLLE TWNSITE BK 134 LT 4.1 30347 C 7/02 56,500 56,590 56,500 1.0016 HNTVLLE TWNSITE BK 139 LT 11 30415 C 10/02 30,000 29,380 30,000 .9793 HNTSVLE TWNSITE BK 149 LT 12 30500 C 2/03 43,000 40,570 43,000 .9435 JOHNSON #1 LT 19.1 31491 C 5/02 66,000 64,310 66,000 .9744 MALONE ADDN SEC 1 LT 47 32547 C 6/02 49,000 46,290 49,000 .9447 NEUMAN SPORTSMAN CLB SEC 1 LT 33079 C 11/02 84,950 78,320 84,950 .9220 PINECREST BK 2 LT 1 33895 C 3/03 98,900 89,290 98,900 .9028 PINECREST BK 2 LT 5 33899 C 3/03 108,333 100,830 108,333 .9300 PINECREST BK 4 LT 9 33913 C 11/02 109,600 109,910 109,600 1.0028 PINEMEADOWS SEC 1 LT 9 34025 C 12/02 92,400 89,980 92,400 .9738 PINE VW BK 1 LTS 7,8 34120 C 12/02 47,500 66,070 47,500 1.3909 PINE VW BK 7 LT 6 34151 C 3/03 89,500 97,080 89,500 1.0847 PINE SHADOWS BK 4 LT 17 34217 C 11/02 87,000 84,630 87,000 .9728 PINESHADOWS BK 7 LT 10 34260 C 12/02 86,000 83,810 86,000 .9745 PRAYTOR ADDN BK 1 LT 6 34346 C 8/02 74,000 67,190 74,000 .9080 RAVENWOOD LT 13,14 34635 C 10/02 123,500 113,070 123,500 .9155 RIVERSIDE LKLND SEC 5 BK 3 LTS 35103 C 10/02 20,000 29,860 20,000 1.4930 RVSIDE LKLND SEC 6 BK 5 LTS 16 35198 C 6/02 107,000 99,490 107,000 .9298 RIVERSIDE LAKELAND SEC 9 BK 4 35317 C 10/02 63,500 58,880 63,500 .9272 RIVERSIDE HARBOR BK 2 LT 13-16 35402 C 10/02 77,000 70,350 77,000 .9136 RIVERSIDE HAR BK 16 LT 34, 35. 35813 C 11/02 70,000 66,150 70,000 .9450 RWA RNCHETTES SEC 3 LT 1 36005 C 9/02 118,199 117,900 118,199 .9975 SNDVRK SEC 1 BK 2 LT 5 36145 C 10/02 65,000 65,950 65,000 1.0146 SANDBROOK SEC 1 BK 2 LT 6 36146 C 5/02 91,500 86,470 91,500 .9450 SANDBROOK SEC 4 BK 2 LT 8 36148 C 4/02 73,900 69,500 73,900 .9405 SANDBROOK SEC 2 BK 4 LT 2 36188 C 12/02 82,500 78,400 82,500 .9503 SANDBRK SEC 2 BK 4 LT 3 36189 C 12/02 75,000 74,860 75,000 .9981 SNDBRK SEC 3 BK 2 LT 27 36212 C 10/02 87,000 83,800 87,000 .9632 SLEEPY HOLLOW SEC 1 BK 1 LT 3 36453 C 9/02 78,000 74,220 78,000 .9500 SLEEPY HOLLOW SEC 2 BK 2 LT 13 36482 C 2/03 89,000 85,100 89,000 .9562 SMITHER ADDN LT 2 36566 C 5/02 139,000 131,320 139,000 .9447 SOUTHPARK BK 13 LT 1 36771 C 2/03 94,000 88,330 94,000 .9397 SPRING HILL SEC 1 LT 16 36877 C 2/03 147,000 132,640 147,000 .9023 SP HILL SEC 2 LT 5 36882 C 10/02 95,000 92,790 95,000 .9767 SPRINGLK SEC 2 LT 11 36964 C 10/02 100,500 95,540 100,500 .9506 SP LK SEC 5 BK 3 LT 3 37025 C 9/02 125,000 122,040 125,000 .9763 SP LK SEC 5 BK G LT 2 37064 C 4/02 101,500 97,370 101,500 .9593 SPRINGLAKE SEC 5 BK H LT 1 37073 C 6/02 100,000 93,670 100,000 .9367

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 9 TIME: 17:06 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 236 Walker 236-902 Huntsville CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ STERLING ISLAND SEC 2 LT 901 37218 C 11/02 119,000 117,940 119,000 .9911 SUNSET LK LT 40 37272 C 5/02 45,000 43,330 45,000 .9629 TMBERCRST BK 5 LT 1 37472 C 9/02 55,600 52,980 55,600 .9529 TMBERCRST BK 6 LT 2 37477 C 9/02 48,000 50,940 48,000 1.0613 TMBRCRST BK 7 LT 1 37482 C 10/02 53,500 52,980 53,500 .9903 BK 7 LT 2 TIMBERCREST 37483 C 1/03 54,000 48,180 54,000 .8922 TIMBRCRST BK 9 LT 1 37492 C 2/03 54,000 52,980 54,000 .9811 TIMBERCREST BK 9 LT 4 37495 C 7/02 56,000 50,940 56,000 .9096 VERONICA ADDN LT 17 37719 C 6/02 65,500 59,640 65,500 .9105 VILLA D ESTES LT 53B 37773 C 3/03 39,900 36,310 39,900 .9100 WALNUT CRK SEC 1 BK 1 LT 10 37841 C 1/03 30,000 28,820 30,000 .9607 WESTLK SHORES SEC 1 BK 2 LTS 2 38231 C 5/02 129,000 124,630 129,000 .9661 WEST LK SHORES SEC 1 BK 10 LT 38271 C 10/02 137,000 135,660 137,000 .9902 WESLAKE SHORES SEC 3 BK 5 LT 1 38332 C 10/02 163,500 150,380 163,500 .9198 WESTLK SHORES SEC 3 BK 8 LTS 7 38345 C 8/02 165,000 164,970 165,000 .9998 WESTLAKE SHORES SEC 3 BK 8 LT 38347 C 7/02 145,075 142,230 145,075 .9804 WESTRIDGE SEC 1 BK 1 LT 3 38454 C 7/02 124,000 115,490 124,000 .9314 WESTRIDGE SEC 1 BK 3 LT 3 38477 C 4/02 107,000 107,700 107,000 1.0065 WESTRIDGE SEC 2 BK 2 LT 11 38527 C 8/02 112,000 100,020 112,000 .8930 WESTRIDGE SEC 3 BK 2 LT 2 38561 C 10/02 135,000 124,460 135,000 .9219 WESTRIDGESEC 3 BK 4 LT 6 38585 C 2/03 124,500 114,080 124,500 .9163 WHITE ADDN BK 7 LT 4 38842 C 4/02 72,000 65,100 72,000 .9042 WOODLDGE SEC 1 LT 4 39219 C 7/02 127,000 118,040 127,000 .9294 WILDWOOD SHORES SEC 1 BK 3 LT 42886 C 12/02 159,400 144,060 159,400 .9038 ALLBRITTON LT 5 44059 C 12/02 109,000 104,190 109,000 .9559 SOUTHSIDE EST LT 13 44520 C 1/03 99,900 91,060 99,900 .9115 HINSON A-272 TR 2.42 46035 C 7/02 147,500 147,040 147,500 .9969 215 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9879 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD APPR TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER MOD OBS VALUE APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ROBINSON WAY, LT 16 R35920 1.00 .00 4,242,820 3,964,083 1.0700 HIGHLAND SEC 3, BK 23 LT 3.1 29336 1.00 .00 152,870 150,666 1.0100 HNTSVLLE TWSTE BK 55 LT 6 30086 1.00 .00 91,220 83,915 1.0900 BK 106 LT 6,13 HNTSVLLE T/S 30216 1.00 .00 633,310 680,733 .9300 HNVLLE TWNSTE BK 155 LT 8 30558 1.00 .00 1,079,260 1,079,260 1.0000 JOHNSON SUR, LT 2.1,2.2 31641 1.00 .00 1,592,300 1,567,142 1.0200 TR 10 MOCK SURVEY 32806 1.00 .00 92,460 94,971 .9700 MURRAY, LT 3 32902 1.00 .00 2,638,400 2,646,383 1.0000

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 10 TIME: 17:06 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 236 Walker 236-902 Huntsville CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD APPR TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER MOD OBS VALUE APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ MURRAY, BK 6 LT 1 32904 1.00 .00 2,199,970 2,566,450 .8600 MURRAY ADDN 32922 1.00 .00 8,093,800 9,233,750 .8800 PRAYTOR BK 1-3 34334 1.00 .00 2,680,270 3,100,367 .8600 PRAYTOR BK 5, LT 1 34356 1.00 .00 1,202,000 1,250,958 .9600 PRAYTOR BK 5 LT 1.1 34357 1.00 .00 3,609,260 3,881,292 .9300 TR 13 ROBINSON WAY 35881 1.00 .00 111,340 110,046 1.0100 ROBINSON WAY, LT 4 35908 1.00 .00 3,684,130 3,492,885 1.0500 TR 18 ROBINSON WAY 35921 1.00 .00 1,486,600 1,424,147 1.0400 ROBINSON WAY, LT 21.1 35924 1.00 .00 1,617,450 1,617,450 1.0000 SLEEPY HOLLOW-SEC 3 BK 8 LT 21 36564 1.00 .00 93,490 95,020 .9800 TR 8 SMITHER C9 36572 1.00 .00 268,280 286,935 .9300 19 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO WITH EXCEPTIONS: .9594 CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ A-9 CARUTHERS J 10559 C 5/02 22,380 22,500 .9900 A-15 CRABB HM, TR 23 11657 C 2/03 144,910 149,745 .9700 A-25 HERRERA M, TR 22.4 12777 C 12/02 24,370 20,800 1.1700 TR 2.1 A-71 BANKHEAD 15462 W 10/02 27,460 30,000 .9200 A-73 BOBO F, TR 19 15508 C 9/02 28,460 31,900 .8900 TR 16-C TALL TIMBERS A-227 GRO 17138 C 8/02 14,980 16,000 .9400 A-246 HUTCHINSON JG 17277 C 8/02 112,850 121,878 .9300 TR 1.2 A-295 INGRAM 17670 C 10/02 28,460 28,000 1.0200 TR 1 A-330 LOGRE E 130 18235 C 11/02 103,560 110,000 .9400 TR 3 A-390 MORRIS J 19128 C 9/02 27,460 30,000 .9200 A-405 MCGARY I, TR 3 19213 W 7/02 77,910 81,800 .9500 A-428 PARKER WS, TR 3 19349 C 3/03 28,000 28,924 .9700 BLYTHE-CHANDLER LT 10 22308 C 2/03 30,520 31,000 .9800 COYOTE TRL LT 1 44481 C 9/02 30,520 34,000 .9000 CAROLINA CREEK EST LT 9 45311 C 8/02 27,100 30,500 .8900 A-49 STEVENS T, TR 9 45950 C 5/02 17,360 16,700 1.0400 A-43 ROBINSON W TR 13.25 46056 C 8/02 43,600 45,000 .9700 17 SALES

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 11 TIME: 17:06 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 236 Walker 236-902 Huntsville CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER APPR VAL APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ TR 8 A-164 DAVIS LD 16258 21,980 23,000 .9600 A-457 RESINHOVER 19689 30,600 31,350 .9800 TR 5.7 A-578 WILSON 21007 20,260 20,230 1.0000 3 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9551 CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ HNTSVLLE TWNSTE BK 44 LT 7,14 29989 C 4/02 55,900 62,100 55,900 1.1100 HNTSVLLETWNSTE, BK 139, LT 2.1 30405 C 6/02 108,500 111,570 108,500 1.0300 2 SALES CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ A-6 BIRDSELL W 10336 .00 1.00 .00 411,640 456,380 .9000 TR 26.11 A-15 CRABB HM 11670 .00 1.00 .00 194,030 222,536 .8700 A-15 CRABB HM, TR 31.3 11724 .00 1.00 .00 2,363,810 2,320,774 1.0200 TR 2.2 A-539 TOMLINSON 20704 .00 1.00 .00 723,040 729,374 .9900 TR 5.1 DAVIDS E 69 24328 .00 1.00 .00 161,280 172,434 .9400 FOREST HILLS COMM, BK 6 LT 51 27106 .00 1.00 .00 97,240 94,449 1.0300 BK 6 LT 5,6 GIBBS 28044 .00 1.00 .00 296,570 339,827 .8700 BK 25 LT 8 HIGHLAND 29363 .00 1.00 .00 1,919,240 2,205,657 .8700 BK 26 LT 1.2 HIGHLAND 29366 .00 1.00 .00 726,930 742,333 .9800 HIGHLAND SEC 3 BK 27, LT 7 29382 .00 1.00 .00 368,470 386,867 .9500 BK 8 LT 1.4 HIGHLAND #4 29470 .00 1.00 .00 1,397,950 1,332,805 1.0500 BK 1 LT 1 HNTSVILLE T/S GIATE 29706 .00 1.00 .00 84,930 81,884 1.0400 BK 20 LT 1 HNTSVLLE T/S 29889 .00 1.00 .00 3,189,710 3,462,662 .9200 BK 22 LTS 1-6 12-14 HNTSVLLE T 29902 .00 1.00 .00 532,860 641,492 .8300 BK 151 LT 6-8,11-13 30527 .00 1.00 .00 167,100 185,380 .9000 HNTSVLLE TWNSTE BK 151 LT 16 30534 .00 1.00 .00 247,970 216,926 1.1400 MOCK SURVEY C5 CARRIAGE LN 32792 .00 1.00 .00 3,099,140 3,249,716 .9500 NW FRWY LT 7 33555 .00 1.00 .00 356,510 340,957 1.0500 TR 19.1 ROBINSON WAY 35923 .00 1.00 .00 981,630 957,229 1.0300 TR 6 ROBINSON WAY C53 35945 .00 1.00 .00 758,190 857,586 .8800

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 12 TIME: 17:06 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 236 Walker 236-902 Huntsville CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BK 1 LT 1 WEST HILL 125E 38204 .00 1.00 .00 5,247,530 5,203,480 1.0100 WEST HILL PARK-SEC 1 LT 3 38213 .00 1.00 .00 1,100,340 1,336,796 .8200 BK 6 LT 1 YOAKUM RIDGE 39495 .00 1.00 .00 246,990 237,155 1.0400 23 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9547 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ TOWN & CNTRY CLEANERS P41338 63,510 63,510 1.0000 FAMILY DOLLAR P41411 211,980 205,114 1.0300 JC PENNEY STORE P41421 996,740 886,480 1.1200 JESSICA'S P41422 26,760 28,800 .9300 LEE BARON FASHIONS P41426 40,250 42,850 .9400 HYPONEX CORP P41479 4,079,720 4,198,164 .9700 HEB GROCERY P41518 774,210 705,750 1.1000 KROGER 3219 P41534 1,304,730 1,552,150 .8400 VIACOM SIGNS P41665 207,110 221,791 .9300 ECKERDS P41695 1,120,950 1,116,292 1.0000 GAMBRO HEALTHCARE P41708 169,940 136,440 1.2500 FLEET NAT'L BANK P41824 1,797,100 2,012,757 .8900 HPSC INC P41868 73,210 68,360 1.0700 IOS CAPITAL P41874 614,190 866,449 .7100 BLOCKBUSTER #48350 P42022 178,260 137,532 1.3000 WENDY'S P42124 66,760 69,333 .9600 P42153 757,490 757,884 1.0000 HUNTSVILLE SURGERY CTR P42529 889,530 889,530 1.0000 DOLLAR GENERAL P43677 235,050 232,755 1.0100 1ST STATE BANK P44542 267,620 267,620 1.0000 CIT TECH P44757 142,040 103,740 1.3700 CITI-CORP P45757 176,040 179,224 .9800 FMA ALLIANCE P46720 56,080 51,459 1.0900 HOME DEPOT P46779 5,589,960 5,536,312 1.0100 24 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0192