Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   1/22/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:    103
TIME:     16:48                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             220  Tarrant
                                                         220-918  Eagle Mt-Saginaw

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  _8685____1____7_____             00656666                   B       7/02        685,000         681,700       685,000     .9952
  _8685____1___18_____             00656798                   B       9/02        644,000         685,600       644,000    1.0646
  _8685____2____9_____             00657093                   B       6/02        370,000         370,300       370,000    1.0008
  10430___23____5___20             00747742                   B       7/02        114,900         146,000       114,900    1.2707
  16280____1____C_____             01112406                   B       7/02        133,900         131,000       133,900     .9783
  16280___12____2___10             01115499                   B      11/02         84,000          89,500        84,000    1.0655
  21690____8R__49_____             01461028                   B      11/02         73,000          65,000        73,000     .8904
  23120____2___26_____             01525484                   B       5/02        200,000         183,300       200,000     .9165
  23120____2___29_____             01525514                   B      10/02        237,000         187,100       237,000     .7895
  23120____3____9_____             01525859                   B       5/02        598,900         551,700       598,900     .9212
  23120____4___33A____             01526618                   B      11/02        400,000         417,900       400,000    1.0448
  23120____5___20_____             01527452                   B       9/02        195,000         200,200       195,000    1.0267
  23120____8___12_____             01528939                   B       9/02        203,000         168,500       203,000     .8300
  23120___10____2_____             01529595                   B       4/02        127,500         122,400       127,500     .9600
  23120___11___39_____             01530429                   B      11/02        153,000         156,200       153,000    1.0209
  23120___14____7_____             01531239                   B       9/02        210,000         206,100       210,000     .9814
  23120___18___14_____             01532294                   B       7/02        162,500         161,800       162,500     .9957
  23120___23___25_____             01534270                   B       7/02        140,000         186,500       140,000    1.3321
  23120___33____6_____             01536796                   B       1/03        263,900         229,100       263,900     .8681
  23270________13_____             01557785                   B       8/02        145,000         119,000       145,000     .8207
  24815____1___12_____             01630237                   B       9/02         84,000          86,800        84,000    1.0333
  24815____4___47_____             01631357                   B       3/03         75,750          76,700        75,750    1.0125
  24815____5____9_____             01631640                   B       4/02         90,900          96,200        90,900    1.0583
  24815____5___22_____             01631780                   B       5/02        105,000         104,500       105,000     .9952
  27920____2____9_____             01862448                   B       2/03         80,000          65,000        80,000     .8125
  27920____3____8_____             01862537                   B       7/02         75,000          81,900        75,000    1.0920
  30255___17____1_____             01884840                   B       4/02         66,474          66,100        66,474     .9944
  30255___17____5_____             01884883                   B       9/02         70,000          71,000        70,000    1.0143
  30255___20___23_____             01886088                   B      10/02         68,400          69,600        68,400    1.0175
  30255___20___28_____             01886142                   B       5/02         66,500          71,500        66,500    1.0752
  30255___21___12_____             01886355                   B      11/02         69,900          69,500        69,900     .9943
  30255___21___14_____             01886371                   B       9/02         69,000          69,400        69,000    1.0058
  30255___21___25_____             01886509                   B       9/02         66,900          63,200        66,900     .9447
  30255___22___13_____             01886770                   B       2/03         70,000          63,700        70,000     .9100
  30255___24___26_____             01887831                   B       2/03         92,100          94,000        92,100    1.0206
  30255___25____8_____             01887920                   B       5/02         81,000          82,500        81,000    1.0185
  30255___26___19_____             01888315                   B       4/02         71,900          81,200        71,900    1.1293
  33470____2___29_____             02308169                   B       4/02         69,500          69,300        69,500     .9971
  33470____2___35_____             02308223                   B       5/02         77,500          82,100        77,500    1.0594
  33470____9___57_____             02310449                   B      10/02        119,900         113,500       119,900     .9466
  33470___12___13_____             02311100                   B       3/03         88,850          91,100        88,850    1.0253
  33470___20___17_____             02313529                   B       4/02         96,000         103,600        96,000    1.0792
  33470___28____9_____             02315653                   B       4/02         88,500          88,700        88,500    1.0023
  33470___28___26_____             02315831                   B      12/02         89,900         109,700        89,900    1.2202
  37050____5___11_____             02643995                   B       1/03         63,000          67,800        63,000    1.0762
  37070____1___18_____             02645084                   B       6/02        120,000         122,400       120,000    1.0200
  37070____6___19_____             02646870                   B       2/03         80,500          88,000        80,500    1.0932

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 104 TIME: 16:48 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 220 Tarrant 220-918 Eagle Mt-Saginaw CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 37070____6___41_____ 02647117 B 2/03 90,000 88,000 90,000 .9778 37070____7____6_____ 02647273 B 6/02 72,000 79,900 72,000 1.1097 37070____7___11_____ 02647346 B 5/02 91,500 95,700 91,500 1.0459 37070____7___14_____ 02647370 B 6/02 89,000 80,500 89,000 .9045 37070___18____3_____ 02650851 B 12/02 88,000 82,300 88,000 .9352 37070___18___28_____ 02651122 B 11/02 91,000 92,100 91,000 1.0121 37070___20___24_____ 02651688 B 6/02 86,000 82,300 86,000 .9570 37085____3___10_____ 02658259 B 4/02 85,000 85,200 85,000 1.0024 A_154___1HH_________ 03762653 B 10/02 278,500 181,200 278,500 .6506 31805____7___29_____ 04430956 B 6/02 88,000 96,700 88,000 1.0989 31805___11____6_____ 04432045 B 1/03 90,000 91,800 90,000 1.0200 31805___12___12_____ 04432436 B 3/03 99,500 90,700 99,500 .9116 A_564___1S_____20___ 04769252 B 1/03 495,000 519,200 495,000 1.0489 17084C___1___13_____ 04795628 B 11/02 525,000 526,600 525,000 1.0030 _8768___10___34_____ 05786681 B 6/02 103,991 96,600 103,991 .9289 37927____1____5_____ 05991226 B 7/02 540,000 440,100 540,000 .8150 37927____1____6_____ 05991234 B 7/02 425,000 376,600 425,000 .8861 24813___14___16_____ 05994950 B 4/02 92,500 82,100 92,500 .8876 24813___15___21_____ 05995264 B 11/02 96,000 106,000 96,000 1.1042 24813___16___20_____ 05995493 B 2/03 92,000 82,600 92,000 .8978 24813___18____5_____ 05995868 B 2/03 100,000 109,700 100,000 1.0970 24813___19___27_____ 05996449 B 5/02 77,500 78,900 77,500 1.0181 24813___19___36_____ 05996554 B 2/03 83,000 79,700 83,000 .9602 24813___20____7_____ 05996643 B 12/02 88,000 82,100 88,000 .9330 46091____1___20_____ 06003877 B 12/02 99,500 95,200 99,500 .9568 46091____4___21_____ 06004628 B 2/03 87,000 85,100 87,000 .9782 46091____5____7_____ 06004784 B 5/02 96,500 96,500 96,500 1.0000 46091____6___35_____ 06005365 B 6/02 119,000 118,700 119,000 .9975 46091____9___13_____ 06006124 B 11/02 99,000 100,100 99,000 1.0111 46091___12___45_____ 06007147 B 10/02 99,900 97,500 99,900 .9760 24813___13____6_____ 06177662 B 4/02 80,000 83,000 80,000 1.0375 24813___13___26_____ 06177875 B 12/02 85,000 89,500 85,000 1.0529 24813___14___47_____ 06178197 B 2/03 89,900 91,100 89,900 1.0133 18133____3___11_____ 06216927 B 4/02 121,000 120,800 121,000 .9983 18133____4___12_____ 06217354 B 7/02 133,000 135,100 133,000 1.0158 18133___12____8_____ 06218709 B 1/03 120,000 119,400 120,000 .9950 18133___17___32_____ 06220177 B 9/02 119,000 119,400 119,000 1.0034 31805___17___43_____ 06281745 B 1/03 110,000 113,400 110,000 1.0309 10077____1____6_____ 06675212 B 5/02 486,500 510,500 486,500 1.0493 10077____2____3_____ 06675271 B 4/02 183,128 230,500 183,128 1.2587 10077____2___11_____ 06675379 B 4/02 169,000 227,300 169,000 1.3450 18135H___2___12_____ 06852106 B 10/02 247,000 244,300 247,000 .9891 __526____2____1_____ 07019416 B 11/02 120,000 112,900 120,000 .9408 __526____4____7_____ 07019831 B 1/03 93,000 97,000 93,000 1.0430 __526____5____8_____ 07020090 B 9/02 112,000 111,900 112,000 .9991 __526____8___15_____ 07020910 B 9/02 105,095 104,800 105,095 .9972 __526___10___11_____ 07021526 B 4/02 99,000 105,700 99,000 1.0677

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 105 TIME: 16:48 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 220 Tarrant 220-918 Eagle Mt-Saginaw CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 25571____1____9_____ 07027583 B 3/03 160,000 185,700 160,000 1.1606 45259H___B____3_____ 07029519 B 7/02 275,000 262,600 275,000 .9549 25571____1___39_____ 07032072 B 3/03 190,000 195,300 190,000 1.0279 47149K___8____3_____ 07041101 B 6/02 113,500 114,600 113,500 1.0097 28500____1____1_____ 07089309 B 12/02 174,500 164,800 174,500 .9444 28500____2___10B____ 07089899 B 7/02 165,500 162,300 165,500 .9807 46528____2___32_____ 07091249 B 8/02 114,950 116,100 114,950 1.0100 46528____4____9_____ 07092091 B 11/02 107,500 100,300 107,500 .9330 46528____6____9_____ 07092989 B 7/02 126,000 121,200 126,000 .9619 46528____7___26_____ 07093357 B 10/02 124,000 124,600 124,000 1.0048 _7545____1___38R____ 07135572 B 4/02 132,000 119,400 132,000 .9045 33437C___E___18_____ 07136730 B 11/02 184,500 180,500 184,500 .9783 33437C___E___23_____ 07136781 B 9/02 188,153 190,600 188,153 1.0130 33437C___F___10_____ 07136900 B 3/03 178,500 180,900 178,500 1.0134 33437C___B____2_____ 07138067 B 10/02 206,000 198,700 206,000 .9646 33437C___B____5_____ 07138091 B 9/02 188,000 181,100 188,000 .9633 17084G___4____7_____ 07140789 B 12/02 221,450 271,200 221,450 1.2247 17084G___4___12_____ 07140835 B 8/02 250,000 280,400 250,000 1.1216 47163E___4___18_____ 07158181 B 3/03 117,500 113,300 117,500 .9643 31742____1____5_____ 07158416 B 7/02 139,900 134,300 139,900 .9600 31742____1___12_____ 07158483 B 6/02 110,000 109,900 110,000 .9991 31742____4___36_____ 07158998 B 4/02 98,900 100,400 98,900 1.0152 37505____4___11_____ 07222092 B 4/02 60,000 110,500 60,000 1.8417 _8685____1___22R____ 07254733 B 10/02 700,000 694,500 700,000 .9921 33957C___5___17_____ 07301847 B 11/02 456,000 457,500 456,000 1.0033 33957C___2___49_____ 07302002 B 4/02 619,400 555,300 619,400 .8965 33957C___2___68_____ 07302215 B 7/02 589,000 542,900 589,000 .9217 18133___23____1_____ 07346719 B 9/02 125,000 124,300 125,000 .9944 33901C___2___14_____ 07376359 B 4/02 124,400 131,700 124,400 1.0587 33901C___2___20_____ 07376413 B 5/02 122,475 117,700 122,475 .9610 _8537C___5___12_____ 07381832 B 1/03 128,000 131,400 128,000 1.0266 33437C___E___29R____ 07515804 B 10/02 128,150 135,000 128,150 1.0535 33437C___E___30R____ 07515812 B 7/02 125,800 140,800 125,800 1.1192 33437C___F____6R____ 07516460 B 2/03 179,000 180,500 179,000 1.0084 28500____6___10_____ 07519362 B 3/03 159,000 170,400 159,000 1.0717 18406C___1___37_____ 07524994 B 5/02 225,000 224,300 225,000 .9969 18406C___1___39_____ 07525028 B 5/02 250,000 236,400 250,000 .9456 18406C___1___46_____ 07525095 B 2/03 181,000 195,100 181,000 1.0779 18406C___2___13_____ 07525222 B 6/02 180,000 197,000 180,000 1.0944 18406C___2___20_____ 07525303 B 6/02 219,660 233,400 219,660 1.0626 18406C___2___21_____ 07525311 B 5/02 190,000 180,200 190,000 .9484 18406C___2___22_____ 07525338 B 6/02 183,990 181,300 183,990 .9854 18406C___2___29_____ 07525400 B 9/02 145,050 145,100 145,050 1.0003 18406C___3____9_____ 07525540 B 8/02 187,500 211,800 187,500 1.1296 18406C___4____3_____ 07525648 B 7/02 200,000 230,700 200,000 1.1535 17657D___4____5_____ 07551932 B 5/02 109,500 115,300 109,500 1.0530 17657D___5____4_____ 07552300 B 4/02 139,990 145,800 139,990 1.0415

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 106 TIME: 16:48 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 220 Tarrant 220-918 Eagle Mt-Saginaw CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 17657D___6___16_____ 07552734 B 4/02 116,450 119,900 116,450 1.0296 17657D___8___34_____ 07553595 B 9/02 130,990 135,900 130,990 1.0375 _8894C__13____8_____ 07600178 B 6/02 132,990 125,500 132,990 .9437 _8894C__13____9_____ 07600194 B 5/02 138,769 143,200 138,769 1.0319 41485K___C___15_____ 07664648 B 6/02 128,000 144,800 128,000 1.1313 41485K___D___31_____ 07665229 B 6/02 119,500 141,100 119,500 1.1808 24813___39___24_____ 07718500 B 5/02 92,200 92,900 92,200 1.0076 24813___40___16_____ 07718861 B 5/02 106,000 106,100 106,000 1.0009 24813___40___28_____ 07719019 B 4/02 110,000 100,100 110,000 .9100 24813___42___18_____ 07719264 B 8/02 86,900 86,100 86,900 .9908 24813___42___32_____ 07719434 B 6/02 115,770 112,700 115,770 .9735 24813___42___33_____ 07719442 B 6/02 112,000 116,900 112,000 1.0438 47163E___2___16_____ 07747330 B 5/02 105,015 104,200 105,015 .9922 23067____E____6_____ 07758227 B 5/02 223,900 264,700 223,900 1.1822 23067____F___42_____ 07758529 B 11/02 227,169 267,700 227,169 1.1784 23067____F___43_____ 07758537 B 6/02 225,427 261,200 225,427 1.1587 17084G___4___35_____ 07760469 B 12/02 298,900 297,500 298,900 .9953 17084G___6____4_____ 07760590 B 9/02 240,000 313,000 240,000 1.3042 17084G___6A__45_____ 07761023 B 8/02 259,900 296,700 259,900 1.1416 _8894C___3___26_____ 07815980 B 4/02 144,990 143,900 144,990 .9925 _8894C___4____5_____ 07816146 B 7/02 155,990 162,100 155,990 1.0392 _8894C___4____7_____ 07816162 B 5/02 145,865 146,600 145,865 1.0050 _8894C___4___15_____ 07816243 B 7/02 164,990 164,100 164,990 .9946 _8894C___4___20_____ 07816308 B 7/02 155,990 162,100 155,990 1.0392 _8894C___5___13_____ 07816561 B 7/02 155,990 162,100 155,990 1.0392 _8894C___8___32_____ 07816758 B 5/02 128,490 131,300 128,490 1.0219 _8894C__14___19_____ 07816839 B 7/02 137,000 142,600 137,000 1.0409 33901C__16___21_____ 07833946 B 10/02 142,000 137,600 142,000 .9690 33901C__16___22_____ 07833954 B 8/02 118,000 116,400 118,000 .9864 24817____2___21_____ 07836783 B 10/02 147,060 164,600 147,060 1.1193 23623G__18____2_____ 07849710 B 5/02 142,990 138,800 142,990 .9707 23623G__20____7_____ 07849923 B 7/02 121,710 121,700 121,710 .9999 23623G__21___25_____ 07850301 B 11/02 123,660 132,000 123,660 1.0674 23623G__21___41_____ 07850484 B 9/02 136,140 138,800 136,140 1.0195 23623G__21___48_____ 07850557 B 5/02 125,600 132,000 125,600 1.0510 23623G__22___27_____ 07850654 B 9/02 139,000 132,000 139,000 .9496 23623G__24____4_____ 07851154 B 6/02 154,740 152,400 154,740 .9849 23623G__25___13_____ 07851359 B 11/02 154,815 160,100 154,815 1.0341 23623G__27___15_____ 07852010 B 12/02 180,318 172,900 180,318 .9589 23623G__27___17_____ 07852037 B 11/02 143,856 137,300 143,856 .9544 23623G__13___18_____ 07852703 B 12/02 111,659 105,900 111,659 .9484 23623G__13___20_____ 07852738 B 7/02 123,770 127,500 123,770 1.0301 23623G__14____9_____ 07853432 B 10/02 125,000 127,500 125,000 1.0200 23623G__15___10_____ 07853548 B 8/02 120,990 123,300 120,990 1.0191 23623G__18___26_____ 07853718 B 12/02 111,980 117,300 111,980 1.0475 23623G__18___30_____ 07853750 B 6/02 119,000 127,500 119,000 1.0714 23623G__18___33_____ 07853785 B 8/02 111,000 117,200 111,000 1.0559

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 107 TIME: 16:48 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 220 Tarrant 220-918 Eagle Mt-Saginaw CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 23623G__19____9_____ 07853904 B 5/02 124,990 134,100 124,990 1.0729 _8894C___5___17_____ 07979363 B 9/02 158,000 162,100 158,000 1.0259 _8894C___5___25_____ 07979460 B 1/03 144,500 147,900 144,500 1.0235 _8894C__13___30_____ 07979797 B 9/02 119,990 119,500 119,990 .9959 _8894C__13___41_____ 07979916 B 8/02 127,990 125,500 127,990 .9805 _8894C__13___47_____ 07979975 B 8/02 129,694 130,400 129,694 1.0054 _8894C__13___53_____ 07980035 B 11/02 119,365 114,700 119,365 .9609 _8894C__14___13_____ 07980205 B 12/02 108,166 110,100 108,166 1.0179 24813___50___15_____ 07983964 B 10/02 98,000 93,100 98,000 .9500 23623G__15___34_____ 40040038 B 2/03 94,730 112,100 94,730 1.1834 198 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0080 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ RANCHO NORTH IND PK BLK A LT 1 02319160 .00 1.00 .00 696,575 742,640 .9400 GSID IND PARK MARK IV BLK 3 LT 03694895 .00 1.00 .00 656,250 803,991 .8200 GSID IND PK MARKE IV BL 4 LT 7 03695158 .00 1.00 .00 885,600 1,014,564 .8700 FOSSIL CREEK BLK 1 LT 3 04414756 .00 1.00 .00 856,660 826,218 1.0400 FOSSIL CREEK BLK 1 LT 2B 05967201 .00 1.00 .00 589,000 791,950 .7400 FOSSIL CREEK BLK 2 LT 1R1 06038476 .00 1.00 .00 1,770,500 1,923,520 .9200 FOSSIL CREEK BLK 7 LT 1A 06198473 .00 1.00 .00 1,834,561 1,885,692 .9700 FOSSIL CREEK BLK 5 LT 1R2 06302351 .00 1.00 .00 5,697,000 7,121,482 .8000 NORTHERN CROSSING BLK 7 LT 1 06602592 .00 1.00 .00 952,000 860,490 1.1100 MERCANTILE BLK 2A LT 1 06624766 .00 1.00 .00 18,581,283 18,440,680 1.0100 FOSSIL CREEK BL 6 LT 3R1 06887201 .00 1.00 .00 8,534,900 8,480,518 1.0100 MERCANTILE CENTER BL 1 LT 3 06890687 .00 1.00 .00 4,071,861 4,753,200 .8600 FOSSIL CREEEK #1 SEC 4 BLK 1 06896154 .00 1.00 .00 7,703,040 7,800,370 .9900 BOSSIL CREEK SEC 4 BLK 1 LT 2 06896162 .00 1.00 .00 12,183,402 13,117,853 .9300 RAILHEAD BLK B LT 1 06990517 .00 1.00 .00 9,787,500 10,100,660 .9700 NORTHERN CROSSING BL 9A LT 5A 07008473 .00 1.00 .00 2,967,644 3,036,600 .9800

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 108 TIME: 16:48 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 220 Tarrant 220-918 Eagle Mt-Saginaw CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ FOSSI6 CREEK BLK 7 LT 3R1 07038461 .00 1.00 .00 1,696,038 1,614,732 1.0500 NORTHERN CROSSING BLK 8 LT 1 07038496 .00 1.00 .00 3,035,207 3,701,900 .8200 NORTHERN CROSSING BLK 9A LT 6A 07039778 .00 1.00 .00 6,012,614 6,679,455 .9000 PRIME CENTRE BUS BLK 1 LT 2 07062567 .00 1.00 .00 4,565,323 4,834,093 .9400 NORTHERN CROSSING BLK 9B LT 2 07125100 .00 1.00 .00 3,541,000 4,575,918 .7700 NORTHERN CROSSING BLK 9B LT 8 07216890 .00 1.00 .00 325,911 415,577 .7800 MERCANTILE CTR BLK 3 LT 2 07532598 .00 1.00 .00 8,100,000 9,215,840 .8800 GSID MARK IV BLK 10 R LT 5 07584458 .00 1.00 .00 3,401,190 3,625,440 .9400 24 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9208 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ UNITED REFRIGERATION 08182124 6,480,066 6,516,811 .9900 CARGILL 08395241 10,613,071 14,347,368 .7400 WW GRAINGER INC 08396213 1,934,383 1,871,728 1.0300 ILLINOIS TOOL WORKS 08396590 153,610 153,610 1.0000 NORTON METAL PRODUCTS 08397686 4,448,717 4,444,047 1.0000 VENTURA FOODS 08399484 10,759,292 7,592,680 1.4200 SEARS SVC CTR 08502269 1,422,716 816,294 1.7400 SWEET PUBLISHING 09150986 181,175 175,550 1.0300 UNIVERSAL FOREST PRODUCTS 09739343 8,811,765 7,988,693 1.1000 TTI INC 09963227 52,590,880 53,257,402 .9900 CITICAPITAL COMM LEASING 10141456 552,662 552,662 1.0000 FT WORTH FREIGHTLINER 10172734 2,102,670 2,072,858 1.0100 RDO EQUIPMENT 10583491 591,670 591,670 1.0000 FIRST FINACIAL RESOURCES 10771298 1,678,064 1,785,920 .9400 THE SCOTTS CO. 10887792 17,760,815 17,760,815 1.0000 NEFF RENTAL 10887806 2,406,905 2,798,013 .8600 MACARONI GRILL 10940332 239,603 227,500 1.0500 QUORUM INTERNATIONAL 11022981 3,349,464 3,345,285 1.0000 PRECISION RX 11049340 6,996,588 6,480,613 1.0800 WELLS FARGO BANK 11078189 145,616 89,420 1.6300 SALTGRASS 11084189 266,129 256,799 1.0400 SOUTHWEST TRUCK AND TRAILER 11084626 195,068 195,068 1.0000 BIDGET SUITES 11112999 686,864 1,294,188 .5300 ADM / FARMLAND 11202521 38,197,807 38,202,602 1.0000 COMMERCIAL METAL FORMING 11214635 2,028,304 2,125,707 .9500 25 APPRAISALS

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 109 TIME: 16:48 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 220 Tarrant 220-918 Eagle Mt-Saginaw STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO WITH EXCEPTIONS: .9742