Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   1/22/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:     41
TIME:     16:48                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             220  Tarrant
                                                         220-906  Grapevine-Colleyville

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  _1905____3___17_____             00129232                   B      10/02        152,000         159,900       152,000    1.0520
  _3810____G____3_____             00310565                   B       9/02        127,000         121,800       127,000     .9591
  _7150____1___10_____             00531472                   B       7/02        245,000         211,400       245,000     .8629
  _7740____3___29___30             00576050                   B      10/02        185,000         157,900       185,000     .8535
  _7740____6____3_____             00576654                   B       1/03        151,000         152,600       151,000    1.0106
  _8665____1___33_____             00650625                   B       4/02        179,850         179,500       179,850     .9981
  _9640____8____7R____             00702226                   B       5/02        152,500         141,400       152,500     .9272
  16060___34____4___11             01091921                   B       2/03        232,000         229,700       232,000     .9901
  16720____1____2_____             01143913                   B       1/03        185,000         156,100       185,000     .8438
  19105____2____7_____             01360736                   B       6/02        129,000         138,600       129,000    1.0744
  23075____2____2_____             01519263                   B       4/02        152,500         158,100       152,500    1.0367
  23045____2___15_____             01585746                   B      11/02        123,500         123,600       123,500    1.0008
  23045____3____4_____             01586130                   B       9/02        119,000         119,400       119,000    1.0034
  24780_________6_____             01629573                   B       6/02        189,900         183,500       189,900     .9663
  27285____3___10_____             01841238                   B      10/02        162,500         177,600       162,500    1.0929
  30380____3____5_____             01983814                   B       7/02        154,000         158,600       154,000    1.0299
  30380___10___11_____             01985353                   B       8/02        138,000         149,200       138,000    1.0812
  30385___14___14_____             01986635                   B       5/02        158,000         159,600       158,000    1.0101
  30385___16___14_____             01987038                   B       7/02        153,500         158,500       153,500    1.0326
  30385___17____6_____             01987135                   B       5/02        164,270         169,800       164,270    1.0337
  30385___18___14_____             01987704                   B       9/02        136,150         137,400       136,150    1.0092
  31625____3____2_____             02128101                   B       8/02        136,000         131,400       136,000     .9662
  32720____3____7_____             02230658                   B      12/02        200,000         202,300       200,000    1.0115
  36830____1___14_____             02581280                   B       6/02        163,000         160,000       163,000     .9816
  37045____6___45_____             02643308                   B       8/02        139,900         144,000       139,900    1.0293
  37045____6___47_____             02643324                   B      11/02        118,500         114,700       118,500     .9679
  37045____6___51_____             02643367                   B       4/02        124,000         138,900       124,000    1.1202
  30890____3___10R____             03119297                   B      10/02        214,900         183,800       214,900     .8553
  47715____J____2_____             03124037                   B      12/02        136,000         128,000       136,000     .9412
  47715____K____2_____             03124274                   B       2/03        137,500         132,100       137,500     .9607
  47328C___2___21_____             03573575                   B       8/02        225,850         249,400       225,850    1.1043
  47328C___4____6_____             03573729                   B       6/02        242,000         250,800       242,000    1.0364
  47328C___5____2_____             03573923                   B      12/02        289,900         288,900       289,900     .9966
  47328C___6____8_____             03574156                   B       3/03        310,000         308,500       310,000     .9952
  47328C___6___35_____             03574458                   B      11/02        230,000         207,700       230,000     .9030
  _7338____B____3_____             04409434                   B       4/02        122,500         119,500       122,500     .9755
  _7338____E___15_____             04410394                   B       3/03        130,000         132,400       130,000    1.0185
  _7338____I____5_____             04411102                   B      12/02        132,500         131,000       132,500     .9887
  27355____A___23_____             04422716                   B       3/03        153,000         150,900       153,000     .9863
  A__34___3B05________             04464583                   B      10/02        122,500         119,600       122,500     .9763
  17570_________A3__20             04537017                   B       8/02        182,000         132,500       182,000     .7280
  _8519____1___75_____             04781430                   B       4/02        178,000         193,100       178,000    1.0848
  _8519____5____1_____             04782720                   B       7/02        199,900         216,600       199,900    1.0835
  47598C___6___22_____             04961374                   B       6/02        430,000         442,200       430,000    1.0284
  _7338____O____4_____             05020948                   B      12/02        127,000         124,400       127,000     .9795
  _8669____6___27_____             05035902                   B       6/02        283,500         257,600       283,500     .9086
  47598C__10____3_____             05061601                   B       8/02        370,000         371,300       370,000    1.0035

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 42 TIME: 16:48 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 220 Tarrant 220-906 Grapevine-Colleyville CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 47598C__16____4_____ 05127777 B 7/02 295,000 295,200 295,000 1.0007 47313________22_____ 05156319 B 12/02 212,000 237,100 212,000 1.1184 47598C___8___24_____ 05161363 B 7/02 437,615 456,200 437,615 1.0425 14218____1___30_____ 05162602 B 1/03 153,000 145,900 153,000 .9536 _1288____2___23_____ 05163315 B 11/02 146,392 145,100 146,392 .9912 _1288____3___27_____ 05163722 B 6/02 118,900 118,400 118,900 .9958 _8518H___2___25_____ 05182557 B 8/02 213,000 206,100 213,000 .9676 _8518H___3___12_____ 05182778 B 10/02 172,500 175,100 172,500 1.0151 _8518H___5___20_____ 05183332 B 8/02 199,000 194,400 199,000 .9769 _8669____5___36_____ 05492998 B 10/02 233,000 253,800 233,000 1.0893 _3725____A____6_____ 05522129 B 8/02 434,500 463,900 434,500 1.0677 _3725____A___29_____ 05523060 B 5/02 515,000 467,000 515,000 .9068 _3725____G____6___40 05526132 B 8/02 515,000 537,700 515,000 1.0441 _3725____H___11___40 05527244 B 5/02 673,000 711,900 673,000 1.0578 _3725____H___15___40 05527295 B 1/03 880,000 845,200 880,000 .9605 36985____2____2_____ 05527996 B 8/02 275,000 318,300 275,000 1.1575 36985____2____5_____ 05528054 B 7/02 302,000 278,000 302,000 .9205 36985____6____8_____ 05529980 B 7/02 260,000 258,200 260,000 .9931 36985____6___11_____ 05530024 B 5/02 397,000 365,200 397,000 .9199 36985____6___41_____ 05530415 B 6/02 333,450 346,000 333,450 1.0376 36985____7____4_____ 05530539 B 11/02 340,000 336,500 340,000 .9897 36985____9____4_____ 05531187 B 6/02 322,000 286,600 322,000 .8901 10129____1___38_____ 05568315 B 9/02 145,000 140,900 145,000 .9717 10129____4___38_____ 05570166 B 8/02 147,000 153,900 147,000 1.0469 10129____4___64_____ 05570794 B 12/02 141,500 136,100 141,500 .9618 _7657____A___11_____ 05572290 B 6/02 148,000 137,800 148,000 .9311 10129____9___20_____ 05573254 B 2/03 139,500 134,900 139,500 .9670 10129___10___16_____ 05573858 B 1/03 130,950 130,300 130,950 .9950 10129___10___23_____ 05574021 B 10/02 140,000 137,600 140,000 .9829 46093____1___12_____ 05629403 B 10/02 305,000 286,300 305,000 .9387 47472____1___25R____ 05691478 B 11/02 168,500 161,400 168,500 .9579 37933H___1___36_____ 05783100 B 7/02 204,000 203,500 204,000 .9975 37933H___1___46_____ 05783216 B 7/02 250,000 237,600 250,000 .9504 37933H___2____3_____ 05783321 B 5/02 160,000 166,700 160,000 1.0419 _2775____1___12_____ 05788471 B 12/02 209,500 207,500 209,500 .9905 48028____1___10_____ 05792509 B 1/03 180,000 190,700 180,000 1.0594 48028____2___36_____ 05793114 B 7/02 231,000 230,200 231,000 .9965 48028____3___26_____ 05793432 B 12/02 177,000 192,400 177,000 1.0870 15399____2___23_____ 05823668 B 7/02 205,000 211,200 205,000 1.0302 37933M__11____9_____ 05840295 B 3/03 198,900 203,100 198,900 1.0211 37933M__11___24_____ 05840457 B 8/02 175,000 170,900 175,000 .9766 37933M__12___13_____ 05840627 B 7/02 195,000 200,000 195,000 1.0256 31805H___6____7_____ 05841747 B 2/03 187,500 184,500 187,500 .9840 31805H___7___25_____ 05842085 B 10/02 186,500 175,500 186,500 .9410 31805H___7___27_____ 05842115 B 4/02 185,000 178,500 185,000 .9649 42235____1___26_____ 05998425 B 9/02 258,000 234,700 258,000 .9097 42235____2____7_____ 05998549 B 1/03 283,000 258,700 283,000 .9141

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 43 TIME: 16:48 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 220 Tarrant 220-906 Grapevine-Colleyville CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 42235____3___22_____ 05998980 B 4/02 285,000 284,700 285,000 .9989 __795M___1____2_____ 06070825 B 7/02 316,500 300,800 316,500 .9504 __795M___2___19_____ 06071546 B 12/02 329,300 328,900 329,300 .9988 __795M___2___25_____ 06071600 B 8/02 356,000 320,300 356,000 .8997 __795M___2___36_____ 06071724 B 6/02 355,000 333,200 355,000 .9386 __795M___2___37_____ 06071732 B 7/02 240,000 241,200 240,000 1.0050 18095____4___15R____ 06109764 B 4/02 325,000 335,900 325,000 1.0335 18095____4___18R____ 06109799 B 7/02 320,000 317,700 320,000 .9928 18095___12____1R____ 06109942 B 5/02 362,000 372,900 362,000 1.0301 18095___17____6_____ 06110681 B 7/02 311,000 311,300 311,000 1.0010 18095___17___10_____ 06110754 B 11/02 325,000 316,200 325,000 .9729 15396D___2____9_____ 06160352 B 5/02 215,000 195,600 215,000 .9098 26493C___2____1_____ 06162606 B 9/02 404,000 371,500 404,000 .9196 15396D___2___18_____ 06201059 B 8/02 210,000 213,400 210,000 1.0162 _8998H___2____7_____ 06211666 B 8/02 312,500 338,400 312,500 1.0829 40454____1____9_____ 06296831 B 8/02 265,000 240,500 265,000 .9075 40454____2____1_____ 06296912 B 9/02 203,200 223,000 203,200 1.0974 40693____1____4_____ 06303021 B 7/02 359,000 364,100 359,000 1.0142 40693____4____1_____ 06303757 B 10/02 377,000 400,800 377,000 1.0631 47598C___5____2_____ 06303846 B 2/03 354,000 360,600 354,000 1.0186 _1588____3___16_____ 06307418 B 6/02 125,000 123,300 125,000 .9864 10130H___4____4_____ 06321461 B 9/02 146,500 142,400 146,500 .9720 10130H___4___10_____ 06321585 B 1/03 139,600 141,300 139,600 1.0122 _3725____D___13R____ 06350720 B 3/03 349,000 363,000 349,000 1.0401 14678D___5____2_____ 06352774 B 4/02 206,500 210,500 206,500 1.0194 40543____6___20_____ 06353282 B 3/03 357,000 356,200 357,000 .9978 _9077____1____5R1___ 06355455 B 7/02 384,000 359,600 384,000 .9365 26493C___1___25R____ 06355927 B 3/03 445,000 406,200 445,000 .9128 18095____7___15_____ 06373984 B 8/02 355,000 387,800 355,000 1.0924 37515____4____1_____ 06375480 B 7/02 258,000 245,000 258,000 .9496 23265____1____8_____ 06395740 B 12/02 430,000 450,500 430,000 1.0477 23265____3___17_____ 06396704 B 12/02 485,000 501,900 485,000 1.0348 18095___22____5_____ 06413641 B 5/02 365,000 382,800 365,000 1.0488 _1255____6___13_____ 06428932 B 10/02 202,000 195,500 202,000 .9678 _1255____6___30_____ 06429114 B 6/02 219,000 211,400 219,000 .9653 _8894____3____6_____ 06434029 B 8/02 178,500 179,100 178,500 1.0034 _8894____4____5_____ 06434126 B 3/03 213,000 204,900 213,000 .9620 40684H___3____9_____ 06442862 B 5/02 458,000 463,400 458,000 1.0118 26044____J___18_____ 06462707 B 7/02 445,000 440,100 445,000 .9890 46096____3___52_____ 06468012 B 10/02 320,000 303,000 320,000 .9469 _8605____1___21_____ 06472281 B 3/03 423,500 397,400 423,500 .9384 20789____7____8_____ 06479197 B 7/02 175,000 179,200 175,000 1.0240 40454H___2___16_____ 06482341 B 9/02 315,000 303,500 315,000 .9635 26044____K____3_____ 06487564 B 4/02 279,900 256,400 279,900 .9160 26044____L____5_____ 06487661 B 12/02 305,000 303,700 305,000 .9957 17899____4___21_____ 06489257 B 9/02 202,000 195,300 202,000 .9668 36607____2___13R____ 06509258 B 10/02 379,000 380,000 379,000 1.0026

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 44 TIME: 16:48 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 220 Tarrant 220-906 Grapevine-Colleyville CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 36607____6___12_____ 06521770 B 4/02 325,000 286,900 325,000 .8828 47313____1___44R____ 06533078 B 2/03 247,500 239,800 247,500 .9689 __805____2___10_____ 06537723 B 5/02 174,000 184,800 174,000 1.0621 47318H___2____6_____ 06547710 B 10/02 370,000 353,300 370,000 .9549 47318H___2___22_____ 06547893 B 8/02 348,800 348,200 348,800 .9983 _1168____1____8_____ 06550762 B 6/02 562,500 555,800 562,500 .9881 _6476____4___24_____ 06588646 B 10/02 395,000 347,200 395,000 .8790 26417____1___25_____ 06596673 B 4/02 925,000 904,200 925,000 .9775 18095___28____1_____ 06628761 B 10/02 342,000 368,100 342,000 1.0763 _6090H___1___26_____ 06644740 B 7/02 485,000 464,100 485,000 .9569 _6090H___2___25_____ 06645380 B 3/03 445,000 460,900 445,000 1.0357 30965____1____7_____ 06702651 B 10/02 164,500 158,700 164,500 .9647 _1910C___C___15R____ 06703240 B 7/02 265,000 266,200 265,000 1.0045 _1910C___E____1R____ 06703283 B 6/02 560,000 558,300 560,000 .9970 _2012J___A____5_____ 06723799 B 11/02 289,500 281,400 289,500 .9720 _2012J___B___13_____ 06724213 B 1/03 318,000 319,300 318,000 1.0041 23276____1___35_____ 06726895 B 7/02 272,900 274,000 272,900 1.0040 23276____1___43_____ 06726984 B 7/02 270,000 262,700 270,000 .9730 _3584H___2___16_____ 06746810 B 6/02 295,900 282,800 295,900 .9557 _3584H___4___12_____ 06747124 B 7/02 282,000 282,400 282,000 1.0014 23396C___B____7_____ 06787959 B 10/02 329,000 306,500 329,000 .9316 17787____1___10_____ 06840256 B 8/02 564,000 613,900 564,000 1.0885 17787____2___10_____ 06840450 B 5/02 582,500 580,400 582,500 .9964 30739____C____4_____ 07009348 B 3/03 763,000 781,100 763,000 1.0237 17826____1____7_____ 07045182 B 6/02 280,000 283,900 280,000 1.0139 17826____2____1_____ 07045379 B 4/02 235,000 231,200 235,000 .9838 _1167____6___20_____ 07065930 B 4/02 870,000 865,900 870,000 .9953 42158C___B____3_____ 07109881 B 3/03 507,500 501,500 507,500 .9882 17826____1____3R____ 07167830 B 11/02 216,000 241,900 216,000 1.1199 38165____1____1_____ 07182783 B 11/02 429,000 470,600 429,000 1.0970 23927C___A____7_____ 07193874 B 6/02 939,000 889,800 939,000 .9476 44718C___B___13_____ 07210760 B 4/02 436,500 411,300 436,500 .9423 23278___12___28_____ 07397143 B 4/02 251,566 268,400 251,566 1.0669 26427C___3____4_____ 07411820 B 11/02 309,999 324,400 309,999 1.0465 26427C___4___12_____ 07412088 B 9/02 303,990 308,800 303,990 1.0158 26427C___6___10_____ 07412487 B 7/02 348,740 364,100 348,740 1.0440 42158C___B___33_____ 07643748 B 9/02 869,000 833,500 869,000 .9591 42158C___I____8_____ 07644027 B 8/02 760,000 704,600 760,000 .9271 47013C___1____5_____ 07652836 B 4/02 768,000 661,900 768,000 .8618 47013C___1___11_____ 07652895 B 5/02 426,500 562,500 426,500 1.3189 24420____6____9R3___ 07691858 B 5/02 299,950 257,700 299,950 .8591 33900C___4____4___71 07703368 B 7/02 578,000 552,700 578,000 .9562 33900C___5___16_____ 07703503 B 6/02 580,000 544,700 580,000 .9391 33900C__12____4_____ 07703694 B 3/03 590,000 533,000 590,000 .9034 37481________24_____ 07828489 B 12/02 282,990 301,600 282,990 1.0658 37481________27_____ 07828519 B 11/02 349,999 374,200 349,999 1.0691 37481________30_____ 07828543 B 1/03 490,000 635,600 490,000 1.2971

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 45 TIME: 16:48 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 220 Tarrant 220-906 Grapevine-Colleyville CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 44724C___1___14_____ 07855192 B 10/02 264,000 263,100 264,000 .9966 44724C___1___16_____ 07855214 B 10/02 262,305 250,400 262,305 .9546 44724C___1___25_____ 07855311 B 12/02 243,000 260,000 243,000 1.0700 44724C___2___23_____ 07855745 B 4/02 247,151 267,200 247,151 1.0811 44724C___2___24_____ 07855753 B 6/02 230,991 251,900 230,991 1.0905 38602C___4____8_____ 07856806 B 10/02 268,000 317,300 268,000 1.1840 38602C___4___10_____ 07856822 B 6/02 356,893 355,500 356,893 .9961 12681____A____4_____ 07896999 B 10/02 160,000 172,700 160,000 1.0794 10057G___1____6_____ 07898908 B 8/02 201,200 208,200 201,200 1.0348 24074____B___10_____ 07986823 B 10/02 265,000 264,800 265,000 .9992 24074____J____4_____ 07988435 B 1/03 235,990 236,400 235,990 1.0017 15399P___C____4_____ 40001598 B 9/02 181,620 181,800 181,620 1.0010 15399P___C____8_____ 40001644 B 7/02 210,000 218,800 210,000 1.0419 15399P___C___12_____ 40001687 B 7/02 220,000 217,700 220,000 .9895 202 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9930 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 33235____1___10_____ 02292092 B 6/02 90,000 84,800 90,000 .9422 33235____1___19_____ 02292181 B 9/02 89,900 80,500 89,900 .8954 33235____1___23_____ 02292246 B 12/02 85,000 80,500 85,000 .9471 33235____2____8_____ 02292467 B 10/02 90,600 85,600 90,600 .9448 42225____1___11_____ 03148785 B 7/02 177,000 192,800 177,000 1.0893 33235____3___23_____ 04539079 B 3/03 88,500 82,100 88,500 .9277 33235____5___24_____ 04539915 B 8/02 82,500 86,500 82,500 1.0485 33235____5___47_____ 04540174 B 5/02 86,000 82,100 86,000 .9547 _6348____1___18_____ 05016509 B 3/03 102,500 100,100 102,500 .9766 _6348____1___35_____ 05016681 B 1/03 92,000 86,600 92,000 .9413 _6348____1___59_____ 05016959 B 8/02 98,000 100,100 98,000 1.0214 _6348____3____9_____ 05018404 B 12/02 104,000 103,600 104,000 .9962 _6348____4___25_____ 05018692 B 5/02 85,000 90,300 85,000 1.0624 _6348____4___34_____ 05018781 B 3/03 89,000 87,100 89,000 .9787 30283____1___12_____ 05082641 B 4/02 87,000 81,100 87,000 .9322 30283____1___17_____ 05082706 B 3/03 86,500 89,400 86,500 1.0335 30283____1___27_____ 05082811 B 10/02 91,000 91,100 91,000 1.0011 30283____1___41_____ 05082978 B 11/02 78,500 79,400 78,500 1.0115 30283____2____6_____ 05083095 B 10/02 75,000 80,100 75,000 1.0680 30283____2___16_____ 05083206 B 4/02 86,600 79,400 86,600 .9169 30283____2___30_____ 05083362 B 6/02 91,500 92,000 91,500 1.0055

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 46 TIME: 16:48 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 220 Tarrant 220-906 Grapevine-Colleyville CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 30283____3____3_____ 05083613 B 3/03 88,500 88,200 88,500 .9966 30283____4____3_____ 05083761 B 6/02 89,000 92,100 89,000 1.0348 30283____5____9_____ 05083907 B 9/02 89,000 89,400 89,000 1.0045 30283____4___18_____ 05084199 B 8/02 80,000 80,100 80,000 1.0013 TIMBERLINE EST 05130042 O 2/02 230,000 219,600 230,000 .9500 COLLEGE CREEK 05574013 O 4/02 210,000 210,000 210,000 1.0000 COLLEGE CREEK 05574625 O 4/02 204,000 191,600 204,000 .9400 _7155____A____3_____ 05617928 B 1/03 100,000 95,900 100,000 .9590 _7155____A___18_____ 05618150 B 10/02 101,000 95,900 101,000 .9495 _7155____A___25_____ 05618282 B 10/02 91,000 83,000 91,000 .9121 _7155____B____7_____ 05620449 B 9/02 94,070 98,600 94,070 1.0482 25753____2___19_____ 05624142 B 12/02 88,000 80,400 88,000 .9136 MARSHALL ESTATES 05638496 O 12/02 395,000 393,200 395,000 1.0000 34 SALES CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD APPR TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER MOD OBS VALUE APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ A312-2-20 04477960 1.00 .00 10,300,000 10,778,000 .9600 10133-1-1-20 04971132 1.00 .00 10,900,000 10,402,000 1.0500 46775-1-1 04971655 1.00 .00 4,400,000 4,356,000 1.0100 16125-1-1 05750636 1.00 .00 8,800,000 8,596,000 1.0200 44715-5-1 05876052 1.00 .00 10,950,000 10,506,000 1.0400 16125-04 05989930 1.00 .00 20,000,000 19,873,000 1.0100 16315-1-1A-20 06718035 1.00 .00 14,300,000 12,272,000 1.1700 37140J-1-1 06824943 1.00 .00 15,000,000 17,852,000 .8400 31210-1-1R 07039379 1.00 .00 14,500,000 14,934,000 .9700 24769-A-1 07169647 1.00 .00 20,000,000 18,148,000 1.1000 46786-1-1 07352093 1.00 .00 23,000,000 22,580,000 1.0200 44715-5-2 07577303 1.00 .00 12,663,989 12,588,000 1.0100 21347-1-1R-T2 07913176 1.00 .00 32,999,216 32,611,000 1.0100 26167-1-1R-T2 07913281 1.00 .00 22,889,662 22,450,000 1.0200 14 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO WITH EXCEPTIONS: 1.0020 CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE.

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 47 TIME: 16:48 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 220 Tarrant 220-906 Grapevine-Colleyville CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ GRAPEVINE BLK 16 L B - C 01090674 .00 1.00 .00 830,000 893,722 .9300 COMMERCE BUS BLK C LT 9 06000835 .00 1.00 .00 1,592,415 1,440,221 1.1100 TOWNE CENTER B 1 LT 5R 06382592 .00 1.00 .00 625,068 673,348 .9300 HAYLEY BLK 1 LT 3R2 06383076 .00 1.00 .00 881,301 867,487 1.0200 D F W HILTON LT 1A 06530591 .00 1.00 .00 32,934,392 32,906,845 1.0000 KROGER BLK 1 LT 1 06550622 .00 1.00 .00 6,500,000 7,012,200 .9300 KROGER BLK 1 LT 2 06550630 .00 1.00 .00 732,480 869,960 .8400 TOWNE CENTER BLK 1 LT 1R2 06582362 .00 1.00 .00 2,215,440 2,118,030 1.0500 GRAPEVINE MILLS 2 BLK 1 LT 1 07056567 .00 1.00 .00 33,000,000 31,501,691 1.0500 GRAPEVINE MILLS BLK 1 L 2 07056575 .00 1.00 .00 2,269,720 2,227,244 1.0200 GRAPEVINE MILLS BLK 2 LT 2 07066953 .00 1.00 .00 4,254,228 4,311,842 .9900 TOM THUMB BLK 1 LT 1 07067224 .00 1.00 .00 7,312,525 8,822,084 .8300 TOM THUMB BLK 1 LT 3 07067240 .00 1.00 .00 1,405,274 1,131,453 1.2400 WESTPORT BUS PK BLK 1 LT 1 07157428 .00 1.00 .00 3,056,300 3,132,505 .9800 MAGIC MIKES BLK 1 LT 1 07161883 .00 1.00 .00 2,000,000 1,910,652 1.0500 METROPLACE BLK 6 L 11 07162677 .00 1.00 .00 9,844,794 10,268,185 .9600 GATEWAY PLAZA BLK 1 LT 3 07349645 .00 1.00 .00 34,650,700 39,987,292 .8700 HERITAGE BUS PK BLK 2 LT 1B 07355955 .00 1.00 .00 12,438,518 11,305,692 1.1000 HERITAGE HIGH SCHOOL BLK 2 LT 07583702 .00 1.00 .00 522,130 476,684 1.1000 GRAPEVINE MILLS MALL 07708823 .00 1.00 .00 6,018,413 4,067,774 1.4800 GRAPEVINE MILLS MALL 07708831 .00 1.00 .00 8,853,760 4,426,246 2.0000 WESTPORT BUS BLK 2 LT 3 07713150 .00 1.00 .00 11,569,536 11,190,558 1.0300 GRAPEVINE MILLS MALL 07909756 .00 1.00 .00 147,030,063 193,700,000 .7600 GRAPEVINE MILLS MALL 07909764 .00 1.00 .00 2,550,000 4,582,062 .5600 24 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9582 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AMERICAN AIRLINES 08338671 286,547,335 286,547,335 1.0000 DELTA AIRLINES 08340617 89,904,635 89,904,635 1.0000 HERTZ 08342563 50,000,000 50,000,000 1.0000 NATIONAL CAR SYSTEM 08344248 33,465,656 33,465,656 1.0000 ATLANTIC SW AIRLINES 09485430 63,642,929 63,622,952 1.0000 TRINITY WASTE SVCS 09538860 323,651 323,651 1.0000 DFS NORTH AMERICA 09605746 1,514,497 1,509,011 1.0000 KITTY HAWK INC 09940103 3,716,328 3,455,293 1.0800 GENERAL ELEC CAPITAL 09953043 54,939,337 54,939,337 1.0000 AMR EAGLE HOLDING 10129197 111,752,679 111,752,679 1.0000 UPS 10378456 40,357,279 40,357,279 1.0000

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 48 TIME: 16:48 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 220 Tarrant 220-906 Grapevine-Colleyville CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ HALLMARK 10466819 346,487 256,710 1.3500 INTERNATIONAL PAPER 10477292 5,291,550 5,244,490 1.0100 GAMEWORKS 10701222 3,250,000 4,190,738 .7800 J C PENNEY OUTLET 10731180 2,617,224 2,481,755 1.0500 VIRGIN MEGASTORE 10737049 1,868,491 1,760,926 1.0600 SIMUFLITE TRAINING 10878742 58,226,262 58,226,262 1.0000 AVIS RENT A CAR 10879226 37,337,833 37,327,998 1.0000 CARDINAL HEALTH 10884106 188,147,041 187,967,302 1.0000 AVNET LOGISTICS 10976973 54,002,916 54,895,251 .9800 AVIALL SVCS 11215062 267,135,596 278,691,855 .9600 21 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO WITH EXCEPTIONS: .9915