Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   1/22/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:     34
TIME:     16:40                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             212  Smith
                                                         212-909  Chapel Hill

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  A0051 J ARNOLD,  TR 24           100000005100024000         C       8/02         57,000          45,000        57,000     .7895
  A 185 B CLARK,  TR 80E           100000018500080050         C       7/02         90,000          89,300        90,000     .9922
  A0265 J CHAFFIN,  TR 5R.1        100000026500005181         C       4/02         42,000          68,600        42,000    1.6333
  A0288 H DAVIS,  TR02000          100000028800016010         C       9/02         95,500          88,200        95,500     .9236
  A0317 J DELANY,  TR 10A          100000031700010010         C       1/03         57,360          35,400        57,360     .6172
  A0317 J DELANY,  TR 20A          100000031700020010         C       4/02         48,500          38,500        48,500     .7938
  A0317 J DELANY,  TR 37           100000031700037000         C      12/02         89,000          75,000        89,000     .8427
  A0317 J DELANY,  TR 39A          100000031700039010         C       6/02         82,000          78,500        82,000     .9573
  A0394 S GAGE,  TR 14A.1          100000039400014011         C       8/02         69,000          89,100        69,000    1.2913
  A0394 S GAGE,  TR 15.1           100000039400015001         C       8/02         31,000          41,000        31,000    1.3226
  A0493 A HARRIS,  TR 6G           100000049300006070         C       5/02        135,000         131,500       135,000     .9741
  A0502 J JORDAN,  TR 44           100000050200044000         C       3/03         80,000          80,100        80,000    1.0013
  A0530 I KIRKPATRICK,  TR 2C      100000053000020030         C       5/02         81,000          72,800        81,000     .8988
  A0579 W LOVE,  TR 5A.2           100000057900005012         C       8/02         85,000          81,400        85,000     .9576
  A0617 M LORANCE,  TR 7A          100000061700007010         C       6/02         89,500          93,400        89,500    1.0436
  PINE TREE ESTATES,  LT 13        100000071300003070         C      12/02         97,500          90,200        97,500     .9251
  PINE TREE ESTATES,  LT 4,PT 5    100000071300003110         C       4/02         95,000         107,900        95,000    1.1358
  A0800 I RENFRO,  TR0004D         100000080002004040         C       9/02         13,000          33,200        13,000    2.5538
  A0866 G SLAUGHTER,  TR 24 Z      100000086600024260         C       3/03         78,500          78,000        78,500     .9936
  A0869 E SMITH,  TR 5F,5F.1,32,   100000086900005060         C      10/02        234,000         217,200       234,000     .9282
  TIMBERCREEK SUB,  LT 7           100000086900005070         C       3/03         96,000          86,000        96,000     .8958
  A0869 E SMITH,  TR 5M            100000086900005130         C       6/02        168,000         178,300       168,000    1.0613
  A0869 E SMITH,  TR 7E            100000086900007050         C      11/02         65,500          65,900        65,500    1.0061
  A1007 A VICKERY,  LT 5C.1        100000100700005031         C       4/02        159,000         158,000       159,000     .9937
  MYRTLEWOOD,  LT0002B             100000100700005070         C       6/02        113,000          99,100       113,000     .8770
  MYRTLEWOOD,  LT 7, 8A            100000100700005130         C       3/03        115,000          93,900       115,000     .8165
  A1007 A VICKERY,  TR0006F        100000100700006060         C      10/02         91,500          91,100        91,500     .9956
  A1007 A VICKERY,  TR 9.5         100000100700009005         C      11/02        117,500         123,700       117,500    1.0528
  A1007 A VICKERY,  TR0017.3       100000100700017003         C       7/02         78,000          76,700        78,000     .9833
  A1007 A VICKERY,  TR 17A.2       100000100700017012         C       9/02         71,500          77,800        71,500    1.0881
  MYRTLEWOOD,  LT 15               100000100700840000         C       1/03        109,000         111,600       109,000    1.0239
  CAMERON PARK ADDN,  LT 4         112740000002004000         C       7/02        263,400         280,800       263,400    1.0661
  CHANDLER ESTATES,  LT 6          114130000000006000         C       5/02         75,500          79,900        75,500    1.0583
  DEER RUN ADDN,  LT 8A            120615000100008010         C       3/03        300,000         300,100       300,000    1.0003
  DEER RUN ADDN,  LT 13            120615000100013000         C       7/02        395,000         393,200       395,000     .9954
  DEER RUN ADDN,  LT 14            120615000100014000         C       1/03        345,000         325,300       345,000     .9429
  DEER RUN ADDN,  LT 17            120615000100017000         C       9/02        270,765         325,100       270,765    1.2007
  DEER RUN ADDN,  LT00019          120615000100019000         C      10/02        245,000         244,500       245,000     .9980
  DEER RUN ADDN,  LT 5             120615000300005000         C       9/02        293,000         321,900       293,000    1.0986
  DEER RUN ADDN,  LT 4             120615000500004000         C      12/02        241,500         264,900       241,500    1.0969
  DEER RUN ADDN,  LT 5             120615000500005000         C       7/02        197,519         199,000       197,519    1.0075
  EAST SIDE LAKE TYLER,  LT 16     125010000600016000         C       5/02        365,000         364,800       365,000     .9995
  FAIRMOUNT OAKS,  LT 12           126400000100012000         C       2/03         82,000          81,300        82,000     .9915
  FAIRMOUNT OAKS,  LT 1            126400000200001000         C       6/02         89,000         101,300        89,000    1.1382
  FAIRMOUNT OAKS,  LT00005         126400000200005000         C      10/02         95,000          84,600        95,000     .8905
  SAMPSON VILLAGE,  LT 3           150000107100003000         C       9/02         31,500          38,800        31,500    1.2317
  SAMPSON VILLAGE,  LT 2           150000107200002000         C      12/02         53,000          34,500        53,000     .6509

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 35 TIME: 16:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 212 Smith 212-909 Chapel Hill CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ SAMPSON VILLAGE, LT 8 150000107200008000 C 8/02 32,000 32,000 32,000 1.0000 SAMPSON VILLAGE, LT 3 150000107600003000 C 3/03 54,000 49,200 54,000 .9111 GREENWOOD, LT 5 150000142000005000 C 10/02 60,501 70,500 60,501 1.1653 ROCK CREEK VILLAGE, LT 16 150000144102016000 C 12/02 265,000 267,900 265,000 1.0109 STOREY LAKE ESTATES, LT 3 150000144103003000 C 8/02 330,000 322,700 330,000 .9779 OAK TREE VILLAGE, LT 17 150000144104017000 C 12/02 167,400 159,400 167,400 .9522 WOODS, LT 43 150000144104043000 C 2/03 245,397 243,600 245,397 .9927 OAK TREE VILLAGE, LT00007 150000144107007000 C 6/02 195,000 200,300 195,000 1.0272 BROADMOORE AT WOODS, LT 49 150000144107049000 C 6/02 191,500 192,800 191,500 1.0068 BROADMOORE AT WOODS, LT00059 150000144107059000 C 10/02 202,500 198,200 202,500 .9788 WOODS, LT 64 150000144107064000 C 5/02 199,900 203,100 199,900 1.0160 WOODS, LT 74 150000144107074000 C 5/02 279,000 280,000 279,000 1.0036 WOODS, LT 77 150000144107077000 C 5/02 360,000 356,700 360,000 .9908 WOODS, LT 16 150000144108016000 C 1/03 352,000 347,300 352,000 .9866 WOODS, LT 17 150000144108017000 C 6/02 283,000 279,100 283,000 .9862 WOODS, LT 43 150000144108043000 C 4/02 450,000 488,000 450,000 1.0844 WOODS, LT00011 150000144109011000 C 2/03 380,000 366,300 380,000 .9639 WOODS, LT 19-A 150000144109019010 C 11/02 342,500 342,200 342,500 .9991 RIVER OAKS @ WOODS, LT 6 150000144110006000 C 8/02 369,210 383,000 369,210 1.0374 RIVER OAKS @ WOODS, LT00019 150000144110019000 C 2/03 320,000 319,700 320,000 .9991 WOODS, LT 2 150000144111002000 C 4/02 330,000 324,300 330,000 .9827 WOODS, LT 5 150000144111005000 C 8/02 340,000 333,100 340,000 .9797 WOODS, LT 2 150000144112002000 C 6/02 422,500 411,400 422,500 .9737 WOODS, LT 4 150000144112004000 C 11/02 284,900 282,100 284,900 .9902 WOODS, LT 8 150000144112008000 C 8/02 315,000 325,600 315,000 1.0337 WOODS, LT 12 150000144112012000 C 1/03 320,000 302,600 320,000 .9456 WOODS, LT 3 150000144114003000 C 8/02 358,000 367,400 358,000 1.0263 WOODS, LT 5A 150000144114005010 C 5/02 312,000 333,300 312,000 1.0683 UNIVERSITY PLACE, LT 16 150000144301016000 C 10/02 93,000 96,400 93,000 1.0366 UNIVERSITY PLACE, LT00008 150000144302008000 C 8/02 92,500 93,400 92,500 1.0097 UNIVERSITY PLACE, LT 21 150000144302021000 C 3/03 110,000 104,400 110,000 .9491 UNIVERSITY PLACE, LT 6 150000144305006000 C 9/02 123,000 123,500 123,000 1.0041 UNIVERSITY PLACE, LT 15 150000144305015000 C 3/03 120,000 120,000 120,000 1.0000 UNIVERSITY PLACE, LT 23 150000144305023000 C 1/03 122,000 120,900 122,000 .9910 UNIVERSITY PLACE, LT 25 150000144305025000 C 8/02 132,000 142,300 132,000 1.0780 UNIVERSITY PLACE, LT 34 150000144305034000 C 1/03 117,000 116,400 117,000 .9949 WOODS, LT 11A 150000153900011010 C 3/03 245,000 207,800 245,000 .8482 OAK TREE VILLAGE, LT 14 150000153900014000 C 4/02 155,000 165,100 155,000 1.0652 OAK TREE VILLAGE, LT00020 150000153900020000 C 10/02 184,000 174,000 184,000 .9457 OAK TREE VILLAGE, LT00033 150000153900033000 C 6/02 176,500 171,400 176,500 .9711 WOODS, LT 21A 150000153901021010 C 5/02 125,000 124,700 125,000 .9976 WOODS, LT 22A 150000153901022010 C 5/02 210,000 228,900 210,000 1.0900 WOODS, LT 8 150000153902008000 C 8/02 158,500 145,700 158,500 .9192 WOODS, LT00011 150000153902011000 C 12/02 167,500 166,700 167,500 .9952 WOODS, LT 2A 150000153903002010 C 6/02 272,500 276,900 272,500 1.0161 WOODS, LT00062 150000153903062000 C 8/02 300,000 323,600 300,000 1.0787 WOODS, LT 35 150000153915035000 C 11/02 173,500 176,400 173,500 1.0167

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 36 TIME: 16:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 212 Smith 212-909 Chapel Hill CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ RIDGE AT THE WOODS, LT 56 150000153915056000 C 6/02 425,000 423,100 425,000 .9955 RIDGE AT THE WOODS, LT 57 150000153915057000 C 11/02 485,000 459,900 485,000 .9482 WOODS, LT 3 150000153916003000 C 7/02 180,000 189,900 180,000 1.0550 WOODS, LT 4 150000153916004000 C 11/02 159,000 163,900 159,000 1.0308 WOODS, LT0027A 150000153917027010 C 7/02 233,000 235,300 233,000 1.0099 RIDGE AT THE WOODS, LT 41 150000153917041000 C 2/03 495,000 476,200 495,000 .9620 WOODS, LT 17 150000153918017000 C 7/02 217,000 216,200 217,000 .9963 WOODS, LT 9 150000153919009000 C 6/02 230,000 251,800 230,000 1.0948 WOODS, LT 2 150000153920002000 C 5/02 227,500 229,000 227,500 1.0066 STONEBROOK PLACE, LT 10 150000161000010000 C 7/02 125,000 130,500 125,000 1.0440 STONEBROOK PLACE, LT 18A 150000161000018010 C 11/02 159,900 159,300 159,900 .9962 CHAPEL WOODS, LT 12 150000161100012000 C 8/02 182,000 182,800 182,000 1.0044 CHAPEL WOODS, LT 20 150000161100020000 C 2/03 189,000 197,800 189,000 1.0466 STONEBROOK PLACE, LT 1 150000161200001000 C 12/02 136,000 137,900 136,000 1.0140 CHAPEL WOODS, LT00014 150000161200014000 C 6/02 159,500 154,700 159,500 .9699 CHAPEL WOODS, LT 18 150000161300018000 C 6/02 150,500 157,000 150,500 1.0432 CHARLESTON PARK, LT 3 150000162000003000 C 6/02 274,000 286,100 274,000 1.0442 CHARLESTON PARK, LT 5 150000162000005000 C 11/02 226,000 225,600 226,000 .9982 CHARLESTON PARK, LT 8 150000162000008000 C 6/02 199,000 212,800 199,000 1.0693 CHARLESTON PARK, LT 15 150000162000015000 C 4/02 300,000 303,900 300,000 1.0130 CHARLESTON PARK, LT 18 150000162000018000 C 9/02 245,000 252,900 245,000 1.0322 CHARLESTON PARK, LT 24 150000162000024000 C 9/02 203,000 208,600 203,000 1.0276 CHARLESTON PARK, LT 28 150000162000028000 C 6/02 250,000 260,700 250,000 1.0428 RANCHO M, LT 24 166730000000024000 C 8/02 82,000 77,200 82,000 .9415 CHEYENNE HILLS, LT 51 180130000000051000 C 3/03 235,000 199,600 235,000 .8494 DOGWOOD ESTATES, LT 125 180239000000125000 C 6/02 63,500 80,000 63,500 1.2598 HOLIDAY FARMS, LT 144 180500000000144000 C 5/02 44,000 45,300 44,000 1.0295 HORSESHOE CLUB LAKE, LT 3 180520000000003000 C 8/02 107,500 98,100 107,500 .9126 HORSESHOE CLUB LAKE, LT 29 180520000000029000 C 4/02 129,000 114,800 129,000 .8899 HORSESHOE CLUB LAKE, LT00047 180520000000047000 C 6/02 88,000 111,200 88,000 1.2636 LAKE PINES ESTATES, LT 9 180660000100009000 C 3/03 101,500 99,500 101,500 .9803 RAINBOW RIDGE, LT 32 181020000000032000 C 6/02 64,900 62,300 64,900 .9599 TANGLEWILDE, LT 8 181210000100008000 C 8/02 61,500 59,300 61,500 .9642 TANGLEWILDE, LT00015 181210000200015000 C 7/02 75,600 89,900 75,600 1.1892 TANGLEWILDE, LT 14 181210000400014000 C 8/02 79,000 75,500 79,000 .9557 TANGLEWILDE, LT 35 181210000500035000 C 8/02 72,000 75,000 72,000 1.0417 TANGLEWILDE, LT00007,6B,8 181210000600007000 C 7/02 90,500 93,900 90,500 1.0376 TANGLEWILDE, LT00007 181210000700007000 C 8/02 69,900 73,100 69,900 1.0458 TUCSON OAKS, LT 41 181310000000041000 C 9/02 74,500 69,100 74,500 .9275 WHISPERING PINES, LT 15 181310000100015000 C 6/02 74,500 76,000 74,500 1.0201 134 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9984 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE.

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 37 TIME: 16:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 212 Smith 212-909 Chapel Hill CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ A0033 J ARENDT, TR 10D 100000003300010040 C 4/02 110,300 110,251 1.0004 A0185 B CLARK, TR 80C 100000018500080030 C 7/02 101,600 85,000 1.1953 A0288 H DAVIS, TR 4 100000028800004000 C 7/02 272,300 270,500 1.0067 A-422 J HERRIN, TR 1T 100000042200001200 C 3/02 73,900 74,000 .9986 A0422 J HERRIN, TR 39 A 100000042200039010 C 1/02 52,700 49,900 1.0561 A0438 T HAYS, TR 4 100000043800004000 C 6/02 458,400 465,000 .9858 A0438 T HAYS, TR 9.1 (PT 57.7 100000043800009001 C 1/02 401,200 390,000 1.0287 A0483 S HOPKINS, TR 8A 100000048300008010 C 11/02 438,600 445,000 .9856 A0605 J LINDLEY, TR 10B 100000060500010020 C 1/02 14,400 12,000 1.2000 A0606 W LAKEY, TR 1B 100000060600001020 C 2/02 40,000 25,500 1.5686 A0653 E MCCLURE, TR00013 100000065300013000 C 9/02 80,400 78,000 1.0308 A0763 T PAYNE, TR 16 B 100000076300016020 C 10/02 95,200 95,350 .9984 A0856 J SLAYDEN, TR00018 100000085602018000 C 4/02 8,600 4,961 1.7335 A0980 L THOMPSON, TR 10 100000098000010000 C 12/02 111,200 97,000 1.1464 A0983 E TUNNELL, TR 12 A 100000098300012010 C 9/02 36,800 25,000 1.4720 A1016 B WALTERS, TR 8C 100000101600008030 C 4/02 138,200 139,000 .9942 BASS PLANTATION, LT 20 104150000000020000 C 6/02 45,600 61,500 .7415 FOREST LAKE HILLS, LT 5 127720000003005000 C 5/02 165,100 170,000 .9712 FOREST LAKE HILLS, LT 7 127720000003007000 C 7/02 176,300 172,500 1.0220 MOJAR (BARNES CLARK), LT0018. 153762000000018001 C 2/02 99,300 108,000 .9194 THUNDERSTRUCK TWICE, LT00010, 180100000100010000 C 5/02 44,200 46,845 .9435 21 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0133 CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ SOUTHPOINT IND PARK 150000155100003000 C 7/03 530,000 531,000 530,000 1.0000 SOUTHPOINT IND PARK 174102000000003000 C 6/03 115,000 115,100 115,000 1.0009 2 SALES CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 38 TIME: 16:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 212 Smith 212-909 Chapel Hill CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ TR 37 L SEC 01 IMP ONLY A0191 100000019101037120 .00 1.00 .00 141,500 120,270 1.1800 A191 P CHERINO TR 50 A 17.83 A 100000019101050010 .00 1.00 .00 341,250 375,684 .9100 TR 79B A0191 P CHERINO 100000019101079020 .00 1.00 .00 88,550 97,358 .9100 TR 80 A0191 P CHERINO 100000019101080000 .00 1.00 .00 95,300 122,898 .7800 TR 80B A0191 P CHERINO 8.810 A 100000019101080020 .00 1.00 .00 437,400 443,089 .9900 TR 3B S02 A 0191 P CHERINO 100000019102003020 .00 1.00 .00 481,400 473,407 1.0200 LT 18 BL 14470 CITY OF TYLER 100000028900056000 .00 1.00 .00 58,630 64,843 .9000 TR 7B A1007 A VICKERY 100000100700007020 .00 1.00 .00 58,500 56,160 1.0400 LT 2 BL 950 A CITY OF TYLER 150000095001002000 .00 1.00 .00 226,000 272,502 .8300 LT 3A U-1 BL 950A LOOP EAST AD 150000095001003010 .00 1.00 .00 2,970,600 3,028,976 .9800 LT 6B BL 965C CITY OF TYLER 150000096503006020 .00 1.00 .00 57,310 59,674 .9600 LT 20 BL 14000 CITY OF TYLER 150000140000020000 .00 1.00 .00 180,000 172,516 1.0400 LT 3 BL 14020 CITY OF TYLER 150000140200003000 .00 1.00 .00 3,259,000 1,388,844 2.3500 LT 4B BL 14020 CITY OF TYLER 150000140200004020 .00 1.00 .00 500,000 472,245 1.0600 LT 4E BL 1402 DIXIE PAPER ADDN 150000140200004050 .00 1.00 .00 1,199,200 1,223,176 .9800 GREENWOOD LT 18 BL 14260 AC 37 150000142600018000 .00 1.00 .00 3,190,000 3,215,045 .9900 LT 4A BL 14380 TEAGUE INDUSTRI 150000143800004010 .00 1.00 .00 226,100 245,023 .9200 LT 27A U01 BL 1553 SOUTHPOINT 150000155300027010 .00 1.00 .00 543,200 501,687 1.0800 LT 4-6 U-2 SOUTHPOINT IND PARK 174102000000004000 .00 1.00 .00 292,200 313,150 .9300 LT 16 U-2 SOUTHPOINT IND PARK 174102000000016000 .00 1.00 .00 252,900 301,668 .8400 20 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0214 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ SOUTHERN UTILITIES CO 400300000111 1,041,698 1,133,105 .9200 BOLTON FRANK SONS INC DIRT 400300000750 134,815 135,000 1.0000 BROOKSHIRES FOOD STORE NO 28 400300000780 1,178,046 1,049,492 1.1200 GLENWOOD BLIND & AWNING CO 400300001300 115,395 117,500 .9800 MINK PLUMBING CO INC 400300001360 71,305 82,588 .8600 SCHLUMBERGER WELL SER#3808 400300002130 3,802,270 3,875,000 .9800 PETERSEN ALUMINUM CORP 400300005770 2,449,516 2,123,265 1.1500 TIP TOP SALES 400900054300 283,262 284,617 1.0000 ANDREWS LEASING INC 400900093221 136,663 103,853 1.3200 RED BALL OXYGEN CO 401001336870 193,035 192,500 1.0000 NEXTEL PARTNERS EQUIP CORP 401001338900 33,618 30,110 1.1200 HUNTSMAN CORPORATION 401001339700 638,106 638,106 1.0000 DOLLAR GENERAL STORE 3693 401001375720 228,453 216,578 1.0500 MUSTANG FUEL CORPORATION 401001376950 1,386,850 1,387,000 1.0000 ERC WOOD GROUP PREASSURE CO 401001377330 2,154,490 2,102,761 1.0200

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 39 TIME: 16:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 212 Smith 212-909 Chapel Hill CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ TACO BELL #19674 401001380040 172,419 172,966 1.0000 FOOD FAST #62 401001380380 106,791 107,072 1.0000 INDEPENDENT GAS OF TYLER 401001380490 418,300 428,000 .9800 HOLLYWOOD DOOR OF TYLER 401001389570 69,885 89,600 .7800 TREES INC 401001407710 242,887 227,793 1.0700 SMITH DRILLING & COMPLETION 405000000060 1,236,300 1,240,500 1.0000 SWACO GEOLOGRAPH 980000102409 1,236,610 1,170,918 1.0600 22 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO WITH EXCEPTIONS: 1.0103