Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   1/22/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:      8
TIME:     16:40                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             212  Smith
                                                         212-903  Lindale

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  A0003 M D L CARMONA,  TR 23A     100000000300023010         C      12/02         39,900          40,000        39,900    1.0025
  A0003 M D L CARMONA,  TR 85H,    100000000300085080         C       6/02        118,500         123,100       118,500    1.0388
  A0003 M D L CARMONA,  TR00122,   100000000300122000         C       6/02         66,000          68,400        66,000    1.0364
  A0019 P DEL RIO,  TR 6 D         100000001902006040         C      10/02         50,000          76,700        50,000    1.5340
  A0037 J ANDERSON,  TR 12, 10.2   100000003700012000         C      11/02        181,000         180,000       181,000     .9945
  A0071 T BURBRIDGE,  TR 8D        100000007102008040         C       4/02         44,000          47,100        44,000    1.0705
  A0373 T GARDNER,  TR 4E          100000037300004050         C       4/02         59,800          63,800        59,800    1.0669
  A0381 J GIBSON,  TR 17A          100000038101017010         C       7/02         60,000          65,500        60,000    1.0917
  A0381 J GIBSON,  TR 49C          100000038101049030         C      11/02         55,000          57,300        55,000    1.0418
  A0381 J GIBSON,  TR 12H          100000038102012080         C       4/02         85,000          87,600        85,000    1.0306
  A0381 J GIBSON,  TR 39C          100000038102039030         C       4/02         80,000          93,000        80,000    1.1625
  A0409 W GATLIN,  TR 2B           100000040900002020         C       5/02        125,000         127,600       125,000    1.0208
  A0409 W GATLIN,  TR 6L           100000040900006120         C      10/02        115,000         114,700       115,000     .9974
  A0425 A HALE,  TR 28A            100000042500028010         C       6/02         45,000          49,200        45,000    1.0933
  A0556 M LOUT,  TR 30.1           100000055600030001         C       9/02         75,000          76,600        75,000    1.0213
  A0630 L MANN,  TR 7.5            100000063001007005         C       8/02        159,000         159,700       159,000    1.0044
  COUNTRY MANOR,  LT 15            100000074800013005         C       6/02        166,450         179,000       166,450    1.0754
  A0901 D SAVAGE,  TR00010         100000090100010000         C       5/02        117,000         121,300       117,000    1.0368
  A0929 J STAPLES,  TR 17.2        100000092900017002         C       2/03        225,000         209,600       225,000     .9316
  A0948 J SANDERS,  TR7            100000094801007000         C       4/02         80,000          82,300        80,000    1.0288
  A0948 J SANDERS,  TR 15G         100000094801015070         C       4/02         76,000          76,100        76,000    1.0013
  A0948 J SANDERS,  TR0008B        100000094803008020         C       1/03         82,500          86,400        82,500    1.0473
  A0948 J SANDERS,  TR0016A        100000094803016010         C       8/02         68,000          64,200        68,000     .9441
  A0948 J SANDERS,  TR 3A          100000094804003010         C       9/02         38,000          40,400        38,000    1.0632
  A948 J SANDERS,  TR 9A           100000094804009010         C       3/03         99,500          92,300        99,500     .9276
  A0972 J TILDEN,  TR 3A           100000097200003010         C       2/03        113,000         111,300       113,000     .9850
  A1034 J WHITE,  TR 22.7          100000103400022007         C       6/02         44,137          50,500        44,137    1.1442
  A1091 D WHITE,  TR 10A           100000109100010010         C       9/02         74,900          74,900        74,900    1.0000
  BOAZ ADDN,  LT 4                 106482000000004000         C       1/03        185,000         182,900       185,000     .9886
  HIDE A WAY LAKE,  LT 68          115000000000006800         C      11/02        152,000         109,400       152,000     .7197
  HIDE A WAY LAKE,  LT 71,72B      115000000000007100         C       8/02        127,000         128,200       127,000    1.0094
  HIDE A WAY LAKE,  LT 81          115000000000008100         C      10/02         57,500          84,400        57,500    1.4678
  HIDE A WAY LAKE,  LT 92          115000000000009200         C      12/02        116,000         115,000       116,000     .9914
  HIDE A WAY LAKE,  LT 186         115000000000018600         C       3/03        125,500         127,700       125,500    1.0175
  HIDE A WAY LAKE,  LT 207         115000000000020700         C       7/02        238,000         176,900       238,000     .7433
  HIDE A WAY LAKE,  LT 221         115000000000022100         C       6/02        143,000         132,400       143,000     .9259
  HIDE A WAY LAKE,  LT 226         115000000000022600         C       1/03        104,900         104,400       104,900     .9952
  HIDE A WAY LAKE,  LT 228         115000000000022800         C       2/03        198,000         163,700       198,000     .8268
  HIDE A WAY LAKE,  LT 238         115000000000023800         C       9/02         57,500          59,500        57,500    1.0348
  HIDE A WAY LAKE,  LT 277A & W    115000000000027710         C       5/02         99,750          94,400        99,750     .9464
  HIDE A WAY LAKE,  LT 291         115000000000029100         C       4/02         70,000          97,300        70,000    1.3900
  HIDE A WAY LAKE,  LT 292         115000000000029200         C       4/02        135,000         135,000       135,000    1.0000
  HIDE A WAY LAKE,  LT 293, 294    115000000000029300         C       8/02        340,000         336,700       340,000     .9903
  HIDE A WAY LAKE,  LT 395         115000000000039500         C       9/02        153,000         159,000       153,000    1.0392
  HIDE A WAY LAKE,  LT 405         115000000000040500         C       6/02        122,900         162,300       122,900    1.3206
  HIDE A WAY LAKE,  LT 439         115000000000043900         C       2/03         59,500          65,500        59,500    1.1008
  HIDE A WAY LAKE,  LT 446         115000000000044600         C      10/02        120,000         110,400       120,000     .9200

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 9 TIME: 16:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 212 Smith 212-903 Lindale CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 471A 115000000000047101 C 8/02 178,000 177,100 178,000 .9949 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 485 115000000000048500 C 6/02 82,000 89,400 82,000 1.0902 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 505 115000000000050500 C 7/02 150,000 183,800 150,000 1.2253 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 524 115000000000052400 C 1/03 152,000 153,100 152,000 1.0072 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 549 115000000000054900 C 10/02 57,000 65,800 57,000 1.1544 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 562 115000000000056200 C 5/02 65,900 80,700 65,900 1.2246 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 600 115000000000060000 C 9/02 55,400 60,000 55,400 1.0830 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 615 115000000000061500 C 10/02 178,500 171,700 178,500 .9619 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 631 115000000000063100 C 6/02 90,500 90,300 90,500 .9978 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 635 115000000000063500 C 5/02 108,500 100,100 108,500 .9226 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 685 115000000000068500 C 9/02 116,000 121,100 116,000 1.0440 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 687 115000000000068700 C 7/02 72,500 74,300 72,500 1.0248 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 699 115000000000069900 C 1/03 75,500 86,000 75,500 1.1391 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 701 115000000000070100 C 9/02 135,500 142,900 135,500 1.0546 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 712 115000000000071200 C 10/02 52,000 67,700 52,000 1.3019 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 720 115000000000072000 C 10/02 118,000 118,000 118,000 1.0000 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 734 115000000000073400 C 3/03 117,000 117,000 117,000 1.0000 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 735 115000000000073500 C 9/02 98,000 97,700 98,000 .9969 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 760 115000000000076000 C 11/02 78,000 78,200 78,000 1.0026 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 782 115000000000078200 C 4/02 115,000 125,600 115,000 1.0922 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 816 115000000000081600 C 11/02 99,750 107,500 99,750 1.0777 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 854 115000000000085400 C 3/03 142,000 134,400 142,000 .9465 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 871 115000000000087100 C 7/02 65,000 80,900 65,000 1.2446 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 883 115000000000088300 C 9/02 155,900 157,200 155,900 1.0083 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 920 115000000000092000 C 6/02 120,000 120,700 120,000 1.0058 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 934,935A 115000000000093400 C 7/02 121,000 120,400 121,000 .9950 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 978 115000000000097800 C 3/03 216,000 165,800 216,000 .7676 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1004 115000000000100400 C 8/02 79,000 108,600 79,000 1.3747 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1005 115000000000100500 C 7/02 100,000 98,800 100,000 .9880 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1034 115000000000103400 C 5/02 375,000 343,900 375,000 .9171 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1078 115000000000107800 C 9/02 67,000 82,600 67,000 1.2328 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1090 115000000000109000 C 8/02 85,200 91,700 85,200 1.0763 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1111 115000000000111100 C 7/02 131,550 127,300 131,550 .9677 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1126 115000000000112600 C 8/02 150,000 134,000 150,000 .8933 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1130 115000000000113000 C 4/02 147,000 114,000 147,000 .7755 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1198 115000000000119800 C 5/02 126,500 131,200 126,500 1.0372 COUNTRY ACRES, LT 9 117170000001009000 C 6/02 119,000 116,400 119,000 .9782 COUNTRY ACRES, LT 17 117170000001017000 C 2/03 82,000 77,000 82,000 .9390 COUNTRY ACRES, LT 30 117170000102030000 C 7/02 85,000 96,200 85,000 1.1318 COUNTRY ACRES, LT 33 117170000102033000 C 4/02 123,000 122,500 123,000 .9959 COUNTRY ACRES, LT 41 117170000102041000 C 11/02 105,500 102,700 105,500 .9735 COUNTRY ACRES, LT 42 117170000102042000 C 12/02 92,000 101,800 92,000 1.1065 COUNTRY ACRES, LT00012 117170000202012000 C 9/02 124,000 117,600 124,000 .9484 COUNTRY ACRES, LT 9 117170000302009000 C 8/02 72,011 86,000 72,011 1.1943 COUNTRY ACRES, LT 10 117170000302010000 C 10/02 103,000 100,100 103,000 .9718 COUNTRY ACRES, LT 14 117170000302014000 C 4/02 100,161 102,100 100,161 1.0194 COUNTRY ACRES, LT 26B 117170000302026020 C 7/02 81,340 83,700 81,340 1.0290

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 10 TIME: 16:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 212 Smith 212-903 Lindale CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ COUNTRY ACRES, LT 41 117170000302041000 C 5/02 95,000 99,400 95,000 1.0463 COUNTRY ACRES, LT 44 117170000302044000 C 7/02 98,000 93,000 98,000 .9490 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1315 120000000000131500 C 5/02 205,000 216,100 205,000 1.0541 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1357 120000000000135700 C 9/02 166,250 170,000 166,250 1.0226 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1358 120000000000135800 C 6/02 156,000 155,100 156,000 .9942 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1374 120000000000137400 C 6/02 116,500 139,800 116,500 1.2000 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1389 120000000000138900 C 12/02 129,000 124,600 129,000 .9659 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1404 120000000000140400 C 7/02 56,650 53,500 56,650 .9444 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1405 120000000000140500 C 9/02 189,500 154,500 189,500 .8153 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1434 120000000000143400 C 7/02 97,500 95,500 97,500 .9795 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1448 120000000000144800 C 9/02 94,500 94,500 94,500 1.0000 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1479 120000000000147900 C 10/02 167,500 167,800 167,500 1.0018 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1558 120000000000155800 C 7/02 151,000 146,500 151,000 .9702 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1559 120000000000155900 C 6/02 45,500 71,300 45,500 1.5670 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1577 120000000000157700 C 10/02 155,000 158,200 155,000 1.0206 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1596,1597 120000000000159600 C 12/02 341,000 340,600 341,000 .9988 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1631 120000000000163100 C 9/02 119,000 125,400 119,000 1.0538 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1643 120000000000164300 C 4/02 215,000 221,100 215,000 1.0284 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1646A 120000000000164601 C 4/02 123,750 134,300 123,750 1.0853 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1667 120000000000166700 C 9/02 149,500 140,000 149,500 .9365 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1676 120000000000167600 C 7/02 67,500 82,000 67,500 1.2148 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1699 120000000000169900 C 4/02 84,000 84,300 84,000 1.0036 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1710 120000000000171000 C 1/03 26,710 40,000 26,710 1.4976 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1714 120000000000171400 C 11/02 72,000 72,000 72,000 1.0000 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1783 120000000000178300 C 12/02 98,000 98,300 98,000 1.0031 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1789 120000000000178900 C 2/03 68,114 63,900 68,114 .9381 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1882 120000000000188200 C 1/03 210,000 192,200 210,000 .9152 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1937 120000000000193700 C 9/02 75,000 79,200 75,000 1.0560 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1939 120000000000193900 C 5/02 215,000 206,800 215,000 .9619 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1940 120000000000194000 C 4/02 110,000 110,900 110,000 1.0082 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1941 120000000000194100 C 11/02 166,900 138,300 166,900 .8286 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1955 120000000000195500 C 10/02 126,000 123,600 126,000 .9810 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1960 120000000000196000 C 5/02 85,000 109,600 85,000 1.2894 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1976 120000000000197600 C 1/03 170,500 126,900 170,500 .7443 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 1988 120000000000198800 C 2/03 86,500 75,700 86,500 .8751 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 2016 120000000000201600 C 10/02 280,000 271,600 280,000 .9700 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 3023 120000000000302300 C 3/03 220,500 222,000 220,500 1.0068 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 3034 120000000000303400 C 2/03 250,000 250,000 250,000 1.0000 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 3038 120000000000303800 C 5/02 335,000 320,900 335,000 .9579 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 3042 120000000000304200 C 1/03 230,000 235,400 230,000 1.0235 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 3054 120000000000305400 C 3/03 225,000 230,000 225,000 1.0222 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 3055 120000000000305500 C 6/02 420,000 418,800 420,000 .9971 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 3059 120000000000305900 C 6/02 318,900 315,800 318,900 .9903 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 3060 120000000000306000 C 12/02 304,500 304,400 304,500 .9997 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 3092 120000000000309200 C 1/03 267,500 271,600 267,500 1.0153 HIDE A WAY LAKE, LT 3094 120000000000309400 C 1/03 399,000 402,300 399,000 1.0083 DOVE RIDGE, LT 1 122282000000001000 C 3/03 210,000 209,700 210,000 .9986

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 11 TIME: 16:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 212 Smith 212-903 Lindale CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ EAGLE PEAK ESTATES, LT 1 123030000000001000 C 7/02 106,100 104,400 106,100 .9840 EAGLE PEAK, LT 54 123030000000054000 C 9/02 106,000 107,700 106,000 1.0160 EAGLE PEAK, LT 63 123030000000063000 C 10/02 101,350 103,900 101,350 1.0252 EAGLE PEAK, LT 68 123030000000068000 C 8/02 102,900 102,900 102,900 1.0000 EAST FOOTHILLS, LT 23 123040000000023000 C 5/02 88,000 94,500 88,000 1.0739 EAST FOOTHILLS, LT 24 123040000000024000 C 7/02 102,500 111,900 102,500 1.0917 EAGLES PEAK NEST, LT 8 123060000100008000 C 12/02 122,000 120,400 122,000 .9869 EAGLES PEAK NEST, LT 10 123060000100010000 C 12/02 86,580 87,100 86,580 1.0060 EAGLES PEAK NEST, LT 6 123060000200006000 C 8/02 95,250 98,800 95,250 1.0373 EASTWOOD ESTATES, LT 22 124140000000022000 C 5/02 60,000 43,600 60,000 .7267 LOVE BETTS, LT 2 130010000000002000 C 8/02 66,000 70,700 66,000 1.0712 S T MCMURRAIN, LT 12 130011000000012000 C 10/02 79,000 78,800 79,000 .9975 ODEN HTS, LT 40 130012000000040000 C 6/02 111,500 116,800 111,500 1.0475 POOL, LT 4 130013000000004000 C 8/02 87,000 89,900 87,000 1.0333 SCENIC HILLS, LT00005 130014000200005000 C 12/02 119,500 122,300 119,500 1.0234 SCENIC HILLS, LT 12 130014000200012000 C 10/02 74,000 78,500 74,000 1.0608 SCENIC HILLS, LT 7 130014000500007000 C 10/02 95,000 95,300 95,000 1.0032 SOUTHSIDE-LINDALE, LT00008 130015000000008000 C 3/03 115,000 115,400 115,000 1.0035 SOUTHSIDE-LINDALE, LT00028 130015000000028000 C 6/02 88,608 95,000 88,608 1.0721 WILLOW CREEK, LT 16 130018000000016000 C 5/02 105,000 111,300 105,000 1.0600 COLONIAL HEIGHTS, LT 3 130020000000003000 C 4/02 76,000 75,100 76,000 .9882 FRUITDALE HEIGHTS, LT 10A 130030000000010010 C 8/02 89,500 90,300 89,500 1.0089 GREENLANE, LT0003A 130040000200003010 C 5/02 110,000 115,000 110,000 1.0455 HILLCREST, LT0007A 130050000002007010 C 7/02 57,000 60,000 57,000 1.0526 HYLAND PARK, LT 1, 2, 3 130060000200001000 C 10/02 82,900 83,300 82,900 1.0048 HYLAND PARK, LT 10-12A 130060000200010000 C 10/02 71,500 74,000 71,500 1.0350 KINGS COUNTRY, LT 7 130080000200007000 C 4/02 60,000 60,800 60,000 1.0133 MARCHMAN-ARTHUR, LT0003B 130090000400003020 C 7/02 47,000 54,000 47,000 1.1489 SUMMIT HEIGHTS, LT 4 130155000000004000 C 5/02 45,000 52,700 45,000 1.1711 HIGHLANDS OF LINDALE, LT 11 137250000100011000 C 3/03 103,000 103,800 103,000 1.0078 HIGHLANDS OF LINDALE, LT00025 137250000100025000 C 1/03 88,000 102,200 88,000 1.1614 HIGHLANDS OF LINDALE, LT 26 137250000100026000 C 11/02 119,000 119,900 119,000 1.0076 HIGHLANDS OF LINDALE, LT 31 137250000100031000 C 6/02 120,000 120,700 120,000 1.0058 HIGHLANDS OF LINDALE, LT 32 137250000100032000 C 5/02 112,318 111,400 112,318 .9918 HIGHLANDS OF LINDALE, LT 34 137250000100034000 C 11/02 102,900 107,700 102,900 1.0466 HIGHLANDS OF LINDALE, LT 35 137250000100035000 C 7/02 110,400 111,100 110,400 1.0063 HIGHLANDS OF LINDALE, LT00036 137250000100036000 C 4/02 91,400 97,700 91,400 1.0689 HIGHLANDS OF LINDALE, LT 39 137250000100039000 C 8/02 124,900 129,200 124,900 1.0344 HIGHLANDS OF LINDALE, LT 41 137250000100041000 C 11/02 105,000 106,100 105,000 1.0105 HIGHLANDS OF LINDALE, LT00042 137250000100042000 C 1/03 100,000 102,300 100,000 1.0230 HIGHLANDS OF LINDALE, LT43 137250000100043000 C 7/02 107,000 112,300 107,000 1.0495 HIGHLANDS OF LINDALE, LT45 137250000100045000 C 1/03 96,000 107,000 96,000 1.1146 HIGHLANDS OF LINDALE, LT 46 137250000100046000 C 8/02 106,900 106,900 106,900 1.0000 HIGHLANDS OF LINDALE, LT 1 137250000300001000 C 6/02 112,800 108,200 112,800 .9592 HIGHLANDS OF LINDALE, LT 6 137250000300006000 C 11/02 102,000 109,200 102,000 1.0706 HIGHLANDS OF LINDALE, LT00007 137250000300007000 C 1/03 112,000 110,800 112,000 .9893 HIGHLANDS OF LINDALE, LT 13 137250000300013000 C 6/02 100,000 100,400 100,000 1.0040

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 12 TIME: 16:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 212 Smith 212-903 Lindale CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ HIGHLANDS OF LINDALE, LT00014 137250000300014000 C 12/02 111,000 110,700 111,000 .9973 HIGHLANDS OF LINDALE, LT 20, 137250000300020000 C 12/02 139,500 142,700 139,500 1.0229 INDIAN HILL SUB, LT 3,4B 140650000000003000 C 10/02 150,000 160,500 150,000 1.0700 INDIAN HILL SUB, LT 15, A908 140650000000015000 C 10/02 199,400 197,600 199,400 .9910 MALLORY PLACE, LT 5 150120000000005000 C 11/02 86,500 76,900 86,500 .8890 MEADOW CREST, LT 8 152450000000008000 C 8/02 191,500 192,500 191,500 1.0052 PAULS OAK, LT00016 160840000000016000 C 12/02 57,000 58,800 57,000 1.0316 SCOTTS VILLAGE, LT 27 170030000000027000 C 8/02 130,000 137,400 130,000 1.0569 SCOTTS VILLAGE, LT 31 170030000000031000 C 5/02 116,000 117,800 116,000 1.0155 STEVENSON CREEK EST, LT00036 175490000000036000 C 5/02 46,832 43,400 46,832 .9267 STEVENSON CREEK EST, LT 66B 175490000000066020 C 2/03 47,600 46,200 47,600 .9706 THE THICKET, LT 12 179940000000012000 C 5/02 161,200 162,600 161,200 1.0087 THE THICKET, LT 21 179940000000021000 C 5/02 203,500 197,500 203,500 .9705 THE THICKET, LT 55 179940000000055000 C 4/02 249,000 247,500 249,000 .9940 THE THICKET, LT 68 179940000000068000 C 7/02 181,500 187,700 181,500 1.0342 THE THICKET, LT 77 179940000000077000 C 9/02 237,000 245,200 237,000 1.0346 THE THICKET, LT 79 179940000000079000 C 8/02 214,900 216,000 214,900 1.0051 THE THICKET, LT 88 179940000000088000 C 12/02 195,500 210,000 195,500 1.0742 GARDEN VALLEY RESORT, LT 69A, 180350000000069010 C 11/02 122,500 111,600 122,500 .9110 PECAN HILLS ESTATES, LT 17 180889000000017000 C 8/02 187,500 194,600 187,500 1.0379 WENDELL PLACE, LT 35 185710000000035000 C 4/02 81,200 84,200 81,200 1.0369 WENDELL PLACE, LT 36 185710000000036000 C 5/02 57,500 71,400 57,500 1.2417 WESTWOOD ESTATES, LT 17 186560000103017000 C 1/03 72,900 69,600 72,900 .9547 WOODED ACRES, LT 7 189135000000007000 C 8/02 167,000 167,000 167,000 1.0000 WOODED ACRES, LT 15 189135000000015000 C 8/02 165,000 161,700 165,000 .9800 WOODLANDS (SANDERS), LT 7,8 189410000100007000 C 9/02 192,500 201,700 192,500 1.0478 WOODLANDS (SANDERS), LT00011 189410000200011000 C 11/02 132,000 136,800 132,000 1.0364 WOODLANDS (SANDERS), LT 16A 189410000200016010 C 1/03 105,000 111,200 105,000 1.0590 WOODLANDS (SANDERS), LT 19A 189410000200019010 C 5/02 121,100 120,500 121,100 .9950 WOODLANDS (SANDERS), LT 13,12 189410000300013000 C 4/02 140,000 147,400 140,000 1.0529 WOODLANDS (SANDERS), LT 16 189410000300016000 C 7/02 129,900 133,800 129,900 1.0300 WOODLANDS (SANDERS), LT00002 189410000400002000 C 7/02 107,950 112,600 107,950 1.0431 WOODLANDS (SANDERS), LT 9 189410000400009000 C 7/02 124,445 131,000 124,445 1.0527 WOODLANDS (SANDERS), LT 25 189410000400025000 C 10/02 103,000 103,700 103,000 1.0068 WOODLANDS (SANDERS), LT 54 189410000400054000 C 8/02 165,000 172,100 165,000 1.0430 WOODLANDS (SANDERS), LT00055 189410000400055000 C 3/03 129,000 135,400 129,000 1.0496 WOODLANDS (SANDERS), LT 57 189410000400057000 C 1/03 133,000 130,300 133,000 .9797 WOODLANDS (SANDERS), LT00058 189410000400058000 C 7/02 129,400 130,300 129,400 1.0070 WOODLANDS (SANDERS), LT 61 189410000400061000 C 3/03 121,800 132,400 121,800 1.0870 WOODLANDS (SANDERS), LT 78 189410000400078000 C 3/03 134,000 134,300 134,000 1.0022 WOODLANDS (SANDERS), LT79 189410000400079000 C 11/02 114,000 113,700 114,000 .9974 WOODLANDS (SANDERS), LT80 189410000400080000 C 11/02 95,000 95,500 95,000 1.0053 WOODLANDS PARK ADDN, LT 6 189442000100006000 C 6/02 75,790 79,500 75,790 1.0490 WOODLANDS PARK ADDN, LT 9 189442000100009000 C 10/02 89,000 88,300 89,000 .9921 WOODLANDS PARK ADDN, LT 1 189442000200001000 C 5/02 72,000 75,000 72,000 1.0417 WOODLANDS PARK ADDN, LT 3 189442000200003000 C 11/02 72,685 75,600 72,685 1.0401 WOODLANDS PARK ADDN, LT 2 189442000300002000 C 6/02 78,010 80,500 78,010 1.0319

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 13 TIME: 16:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 212 Smith 212-903 Lindale CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ WOODLANDS PARK ADDN, LT 9 189442000300009000 C 7/02 84,439 84,900 84,439 1.0055 WOODVILLE, LT 23 189530000000023000 C 8/02 26,750 47,900 26,750 1.7907 WOODVILLE, LT 37 189530000000037000 C 1/03 40,000 49,400 40,000 1.2350 238 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0170 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ A0003 M D L CARMONA, TR00133- 100000000300133000 C 3/02 108,500 105,000 1.0333 A0019 P DEL RIO, TR 23.1 100000001901023001 C 3/02 96,200 89,500 1.0749 A0019 P DEL RIO, TR 24 100000001901024000 C 1/02 114,700 101,750 1.1273 A0041 W ATTAWAY, TR 5E 100000004100005050 C 3/02 30,700 32,500 .9446 A0067 J BURCH, TR 5 (PT 6.567 100000006700005000 C 3/02 146,300 129,500 1.1297 A0071 T BURBRIDGE, TR 41A,42, 100000007101041010 C 8/02 73,200 71,000 1.0310 A0138 M BINGHAM, TR 6 100000013800006000 C 8/02 29,200 29,244 .9985 A0151 R BAILEY, TR 7 100000015100007000 C 1/02 403,200 357,350 1.1283 A0162 J BENTON, TR 1 100000016200001000 C 1/03 241,100 235,000 1.0260 A0162 J BENTON, TR 2.1 100000016200002001 C 4/02 146,700 143,000 1.0259 A0162 J BENTON, TR 4K,4L 100000016200004110 C 8/02 65,800 67,538 .9743 A0162 J BENTON, TR 4R 100000016200004180 C 11/02 16,200 16,500 .9818 A0162 J BENTON, TR 5.4 100000016200005004 C 2/02 196,000 186,650 1.0501 A0192 G CHISSUM, TR 3 A 100000019200003010 C 11/02 17,500 17,500 1.0000 A0263 H COOK, TR0004A 100000026300004011 C 12/02 302,000 305,000 .9902 A0401 J GALBREATH, TR 6,7 100000040100006000 C 1/02 115,200 127,500 .9035 A0416 T GARDNER, TR 24 (PT 22 100000041600024000 C 11/02 169,200 170,000 .9953 A0420 M HEMPHILL, TR 4A 100000042000004010 C 2/03 276,900 275,000 1.0069 A0485 W HARRISON, TR 3 100000048500003000 C 2/02 69,000 30,000 2.3000 A0485 W HARRISON, TR 3 A 100000048500003010 C 2/02 58,800 51,000 1.1529 A0485 W HARRISON, TR 12A(PT 1 100000048500012010 C 3/03 541,200 558,000 .9699 A0544 T KING, TR00003 100000054400003000 C 12/02 98,200 81,494 1.2050 A0554 J LEWIS, TR 4A 100000055400004010 C 6/02 80,100 81,000 .9889 A0556 M LOUT, TR 6G & 6H 100000055600006070 C 2/03 310,500 363,660 .8538 A0628 J MERCHANT, TR00006,19 100000062800006000 C 11/02 250,500 212,171 1.1807 A0630 L MANN, TR 22F,25A 100000063001022060 C 4/02 67,600 63,000 1.0730

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 14 TIME: 16:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 212 Smith 212-903 Lindale CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ A0634 B MCNEELEY, TR 9.1 100000063400009001 C 10/02 60,200 57,500 1.0470 A0634 B MCNEELEY, TR0010B 100000063400010020 C 10/02 22,300 22,300 1.0000 A0663 P MAULDING, TR 3.2 100000066300003002 C 12/02 57,400 60,000 .9567 A0680 J MURPHY, TR 5A 100000068000005010 C 6/02 26,400 25,000 1.0560 A0711 W MOORE, TR 1A,1B 100000071100001010 C 12/02 41,800 38,000 1.1000 A0772 J PUGH, TR 22A 100000077200022010 C 10/02 90,400 66,177 1.3660 A0772 J PUGH, TR00025 100000077200025000 C 8/02 102,800 102,000 1.0078 A0802 T RIVES, TR00004 100000080200004000 C 1/02 44,400 44,392 1.0002 A0853 J ROBERTSON, TR 4 100000085300004000 C 1/03 133,000 140,000 .9500 A0901 D SAVAGE, TR 5A 100000090100005010 C 9/02 76,600 85,000 .9012 A0901 D SAVAGE, TR 5C 100000090100005030 C 9/02 14,600 12,500 1.1680 A0901 D SAVAGE, TR00009 100000090100009000 C 8/02 96,400 98,400 .9797 A0904 H SMITH, TR 7B.2 100000090400007022 C 8/02 97,100 97,000 1.0010 A0924 J SHAW, TR 19 100000092400019000 C 1/03 21,400 21,500 .9953 A0930 W SHAMBLIN, TR 2.1 100000093000002001 C 2/03 88,000 84,500 1.0414 A0948 J SANDERS, TR 9B (PT 11 100000094804009021 C 3/02 102,300 85,000 1.2035 A0948 J SANDERS, TR 3 J 100000094805003100 C 6/02 34,300 28,000 1.2250 A0948 J SANDERS, TR 7 100000094805007000 C 6/02 189,800 134,090 1.4155 A0996 G TAYLOR, TR0002E 100000099600002050 C 8/02 62,900 62,500 1.0064 A1049 J WILKINSON, TR 6 100000104900006000 C 8/02 454,500 468,767 .9696 JUSTIN ACRES, LT00002 142200000000002000 C 12/02 121,900 125,000 .9752 STALLION LAKE RANCH, LT 6 PT 175340000000006001 C 6/02 70,100 34,900 2.0086 STALLION LAKE RANCH, LT 22 PT 175340000000022001 C 3/03 43,500 39,900 1.0902 STALLION LAKE RANCH, LT 84 PT 175340000000084001 C 7/02 39,900 39,900 1.0000 STALLION LAKE RANCH, LT 139 175340000000139000 C 11/02 40,100 39,900 1.0050 STALLION LAKE RANCH, LT 140 175340000000140000 C 8/02 44,900 44,900 1.0000 STALLION LAKE RANCH, LT 142 175340000000142000 C 12/02 60,100 44,900 1.3385 STALLION LAKE RANCH, LT 220 175340000000220000 C 3/03 48,900 47,500 1.0295 54 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0432 CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ A0371 S GRACE 100000037100002080 C 5/02 700,000 700,000 700,000 1.0000 A0381 J GIBSON 100000038102013122 C 8/02 80,000 122,500 80,000 1.5313 A0948 J SANDERS 100000094803800000 C 3/03 250,000 331,900 250,000 1.3276 A1034 J WHITE 100000103400021005 C 10/02 103,000 107,700 103,000 1.0456 4 SALES

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 15 TIME: 16:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 212 Smith 212-903 Lindale CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ TR 45B SEC 01 A 0019 P DEL RIO 100000001901045020 .00 1.00 .00 77,000 81,569 .9400 A0052 P ARCHER TR 6 100000005200006002 .00 1.00 .00 76,410 82,572 .9300 . 100000007102068000 .00 1.00 .00 352,700 340,373 1.0400 TR 21.3 A 0116 J W BREWER 100000011600021003 .00 1.00 .00 71,600 89,612 .8000 TR0021A A 0116 J W BREWER 100000011600021010 .00 1.00 .00 71,060 93,215 .7600 TR 4M, A 120 J BOND 100000012000004130 .00 1.00 .00 229,500 222,973 1.0300 TR 4N PTS .474AC TR 4K A0120 J 100000012000004140 .00 1.00 .00 213,400 293,008 .7300 TR0001 2.O AC A 371 S GRACE 100000037100001000 .00 1.00 .00 535,800 530,020 1.0100 TR 1B A0371 S GRACE 100000037100001020 .00 1.00 .00 877,310 1,036,307 .8500 . 100000037100002020 .00 1.00 .00 702,500 689,710 1.0200 TR 2B.1 A371 S GRACE 100000037100002021 .00 1.00 .00 1,900,000 1,892,750 1.0000 TR 2J A371 S GRACE 100000037100002100 .00 1.00 .00 229,000 270,076 .8500 TR0002L A0371 S GRACE 100000037100002120 .00 1.00 .00 1,904,200 1,989,353 .9600 TR 7,7.1,1.2,4 A0388 J GUEST 100000038800007000 .00 1.00 .00 35,898,800 35,280,798 1.0200 A0504H TR 16A 4.849 AC 100000050400016010 .00 1.00 .00 293,200 273,751 1.0700 TR00011 A 0948 J SANDERS 100000094801011000 .00 1.00 .00 237,400 220,805 1.0800 A0948 J SANDERS TR 33.4, 39 S 100000094801033004 .00 1.00 .00 2,100,400 1,255,438 1.6700 TR0009C 9H PART OF 11.051 AC A 100000111800009032 .00 1.00 .00 500,500 486,415 1.0300 LT 5,6 CITY OF LINDALE 13000000700005000 .00 1.00 .00 497,100 479,027 1.0400 19 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO WITH EXCEPTIONS: 1.0121 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ CAMPCO AUTO INC 00500000770 165,342 157,525 1.0500 GARDEN VALLEY GOLF RES 400500000750 97,875 98,000 1.0000 LATIF'S ANTIQUES & MR BYGONES 400500000820 289,682 287,185 1.0100 BUMPER TO BUMPER #211 400500002150 173,769 169,588 1.0200 MEA NURSERY 400500002190 347,391 296,508 1.1700 TOTAL PETROLEUM #4539 400500002930 220,000 185,219 1.1900 BROOKSHIRE FOOD STORE NO 3 400500003140 754,176 683,716 1.1000 SOUTHWEST CORRECT CRAFT 400800000221 1,613,426 1,631,667 .9900 K MAC #1 400900109800 99,565 100,100 .9900 KING MFG INC 401001234330 860,164 978,884 .8800 GOTT KARNE DDS 401001260430 355,590 351,198 1.0100 R J CARROLL COMPANY INC 401001293840 322,081 322,000 1.0000 ELLIOTTS PHARMACY INC 401001337190 155,650 159,142 .9800 TEX CHEC 401001363230 97,439 97,200 1.0000

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 16 TIME: 16:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 212 Smith 212-903 Lindale CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ TREES USA 401001385730 152,801 147,583 1.0400 CRACKERBARREL #430 401001389710 612,100 563,703 1.0900 HIBERNIA NATIONAL BANK 401001389840 111,730 112,000 1.0000 TARGET STORES T-578 401001391440 48,537,220 48,537,220 1.0000 PALLET PLACE 401001408580 116,177 116,000 1.0000 CRAIGS DIRT SERVICE 401001410220 245,962 251,701 .9800 HAMPTON INN 401001410230 93,000 95,340 .9800 TIGER EXPRESS 401001413730 169,400 168,582 1.0000 22 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO WITH EXCEPTIONS: 1.0038