DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 1 TIME: 16:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 212 Smith 212-901 Arp CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ A0012 J JORDAN, TR 25 100000001201025000 C 10/02 35,000 39,000 35,000 1.1143 A0012 J JORDAN, TR02000 100000001201044010 C 2/02 48,000 70,100 48,000 1.4604 A0012 J JORDAN, TR 135 100000001201135000 C 3/03 13,000 36,800 13,000 2.8308 A0012 J JORDAN, TR 187 100000001201187000 C 2/03 28,500 29,700 28,500 1.0421 A0012 J JORDAN, TR 26.2 100000001203026002 C 5/02 42,000 41,200 42,000 .9810 A0098 H BROOKS, TR 24B 100000009800024020 C 6/02 82,500 82,600 82,500 1.0012 A0456 M HUGHES, TR 1A 100000045600001010 C 7/02 20,000 30,000 20,000 1.5000 A0665 J MINCHEW, TR0013A 100000066500013010 C 10/02 50,000 68,500 50,000 1.3700 A0665 J MINCHEW, TR 15 100000066500015000 B 8/02 54,000 48,900 54,000 .9100 A0796 J RECTOR, TR 13 100000079601013000 C 12/02 75,000 76,200 75,000 1.0160 CHAMBER OF COMMERCE, LT 8 105020000200008000 C 6/02 27,500 33,000 27,500 1.2000 OAKLAND HILL, LT 1 105072000300001000 B 6/02 45,600 47,600 45,600 1.0400 EAST LAKE WOODS, LT 6,7 123240000001006000 C 9/02 197,500 198,400 197,500 1.0046 EAST LAKE WOODS, LT 25 123240000001025000 C 7/02 250,000 257,600 250,000 1.0304 EAST LAKE WOODS, LT 45 123240000001045000 B 1/03 167,000 179,700 167,000 1.0800 EAST LAKE WOODS, LT 54 123240000001054000 B 2/02 149,000 154,500 149,000 1.0400 EAST LAKE WOODS, LT0008E 123240000002008050 C 4/03 580,000 602,600 580,000 1.0390 EAST LAKE WOODS, LT 12 123240000002012000 B 3/03 218,000 210,600 218,000 .9700 EAST LAKE WOODS, LT 14, 15 123240000002014000 B 12/02 469,000 471,700 469,000 1.0100 EAST LAKE WOODS, LT 26, 27, 2 123240000002026000 B 3/03 895,000 872,700 895,000 .9800 EAST LAKE WOODS, LT 43 123240000002043000 B 2/02 152,500 158,200 152,500 1.0400 EAST LAKE WOODS, LT 45 123240000002045000 C 5/02 185,000 199,700 185,000 1.0795 EAST LAKE WOODS, LT 48 123240000002048000 C 3/03 189,500 205,600 189,500 1.0850 EAST LAKE WOODS, LT 52A 123240000002052010 C 2/02 182,500 188,400 182,500 1.0323 EAST LAKE WOODS, LT 4 123240000003004000 C 5/02 155,000 160,500 155,000 1.0355 EAST LAKE WOODS, LT 7 123240000003007000 B 2/03 179,500 189,800 179,500 1.0600 EAST LAKE WOODS, LT 9A 123240000003009010 B 6/02 196,000 190,600 196,000 .9700 EAST LAKE WOODS, LT 10 123240000003010000 C 9/02 178,500 182,200 178,500 1.0207 EAST LAKE WOODS, LT 11 123240000003011000 B 5/02 129,500 132,300 129,500 1.0200 EAST LAKE WOODS, LT 13 123240000003013000 C 3/02 181,226 184,700 181,226 1.0192 EAST LAKE WOODS, LT 17 123240000003017000 C 4/02 147,000 147,100 147,000 1.0007 EAST LAKE WOODS, LT 21 123240000003021000 B 1/03 205,000 182,100 205,000 .8900 EAST LAKE WOODS, LT 23 123240000003023000 B 10/02 180,000 199,300 180,000 1.1100 EAST LAKE WOODS, LT 22 123240000004022000 B 6/02 167,000 174,500 167,000 1.0400 R&S INVESTMENTS EMMA, LT 19 166180000000019000 C 2/02 32,500 31,700 32,500 .9754 REYNOLDS LANDING, LT 1,2 167177000200001000 B 6/02 209,000 217,500 209,000 1.0400 BIG OAK BAY, LT 9 180050000000009000 B 9/02 176,000 176,700 176,000 1.0000 BIG OAK BAY, LT 10 180050000000010000 B 8/02 160,000 186,000 160,000 1.1600 BIG OAK BAY, LT 24 180050000000024000 C 2/02 160,000 183,300 160,000 1.1456 BIG OAK BAY, LT 37,38 180050000000037000 C 1/03 231,000 240,500 231,000 1.0411 BIG OAK BAY, LT 39 180050000000039000 C 3/02 175,000 199,800 175,000 1.1417 BIG OAK BAY, LT 92A 180050000000092010 B 8/02 190,000 190,300 190,000 1.0000 BIG OAK BAY, LT 97 180050000000097000 C 1/03 180,750 187,800 180,750 1.0390 BIG OAK BAY, LT 106 180050000000106000 B 7/02 253,000 252,700 253,000 1.0000 BIG OAK BAY, LT 108 180050000000108000 B 5/02 242,500 242,500 242,500 1.0000 EAST SHORES ESTATES, LT00004, 180260000000004000 B 7/02 110,000 113,600 110,000 1.0300 EAST SHORES ESTATES, LT 7 180260000000007000 B 7/02 110,000 110,600 110,000 1.0100DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 2 TIME: 16:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 212 Smith 212-901 Arp CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ EAST SHORES ESTATES, LT00090 180260000000090000 C 8/02 85,000 86,600 85,000 1.0188 EAST SHORES ESTATES, LT 240-2 180260000000240000 B 3/03 126,000 136,700 126,000 1.0800 EAST SHORES ESTATES, LT 301 180260000000301000 C 1/02 136,500 133,400 136,500 .9773 EAST SHORES ESTATES, LT00340, 180260000000341000 B 4/02 126,000 121,400 126,000 .9600 EAST SHORES ESTATES, LT00350 180260000000350000 B 4/02 105,000 109,900 105,000 1.0500 EAST SHORES ESTATES, LT 435 180260000000435000 C 7/02 170,000 181,400 170,000 1.0671 EAST SHORES ESTATES, LT00436 180260000000436000 C 5/02 285,000 277,900 285,000 .9751 LITTLE JOHN, LT0003A, 4-10, 2 180717000000009000 C 4/02 45,000 47,600 45,000 1.0578 MAEGIN COVE, LT 15A,26A 180740000000015010 B 6/02 130,000 140,900 130,000 1.0800 MAEGIN COVE, LT 88 180740000000088000 C 11/02 68,500 72,300 68,500 1.0555 MAEGIN COVE, LT00089,90 180740000000089000 C 4/02 69,000 74,200 69,000 1.0754 QUIET BAY, LT 42 181010000000042000 C 2/02 54,000 47,300 54,000 .8759 QUIET BAY, LT 84 181010000000084000 C 3/03 105,000 105,100 105,000 1.0010 60 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0453 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ A0012 J JORDAN, TR 21.4 100000001203021004 C 4/02 29,300 40,000 .7325 A0012 J JORDAN, TR 72 100000001203072000 C 8/02 80,400 78,211 1.0280 A0012 J JORDAN, TR 90 B 100000001203090020 C 12/02 37,000 42,500 .8706 A0013 B LAFFERTY, TR 5A 100000001301005010 C 2/02 167,000 166,984 1.0001 A0013 B LAFFERTY, TR 8B 100000001301008020 C 8/02 40,000 25,000 1.6000 A0013 B LAFFERTY, TR 8 D 100000001301008040 C 10/02 13,900 15,000 .9267 A0013 B LAFFERTY, TR 8F 100000001301008060 C 11/02 25,000 25,000 1.0000 A0013 B LAFFERTY, TR 25 A 100000001302025010 C 10/02 50,400 50,459 .9988 A0013 B LAFFERTY, TR 7 (PT 20 100000001303007000 C 4/02 106,000 107,500 .9860 A0025 H AUGUSTINE, TR 2H 100000002500002080 C 10/02 10,000 10,000 1.0000 A0025 H AUGUSTINE, TR 2J 100000002500002100 C 5/02 3,200 3,200 1.0000 A0098 H BROOKS, TR 17.3 100000009800017003 C 3/02 6,100 5,000 1.2200 A0153 J BLACKMAN, TR 8.6 100000015300008006 C 8/02 87,700 89,500 .9799 A0186 M CALDWELL, TR0051B 100000018600051020 C 10/02 45,200 51,400 .8794 A0229 A CUMMINGS, TR 2A (PT 5 100000022900002010 C 1/03 144,700 110,000 1.3155 A0310 I DUNAHOE, TR 10 100000031000010000 C 6/02 5,000 7,000 .7143
DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 3 TIME: 16:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 212 Smith 212-901 Arp CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ A0342 F EMMA, TR 6 A, 6 B 100000034200006010 C 5/02 61,700 64,500 .9566 A0569 J LONG, TR 9B 100000056900009020 C 10/02 87,500 69,500 1.2590 A0638 W MILLER, TR 41.2 100000063801041002 C 8/02 84,500 90,000 .9389 A0667 W MANIER, TR 12A 100000066700012010 C 2/02 6,400 6,000 1.0667 A0759 F OSULLIVAN, TR 3E 100000075900003050 C 6/02 64,700 64,660 1.0006 A0796 J RECTOR, TR 2A 100000079603002010 C 9/02 157,500 155,000 1.0161 A1068 R WHITE, TR 6 100000106800006000 C 5/02 48,400 47,952 1.0093 A1068 R WHITE, TR 6 A 100000106800006010 C 12/02 17,500 20,000 .8750 A1068 R WHITE, TR 6B 100000106800006020 C 1/03 25,300 23,000 1.1000 A1068 R WHITE, TR 6C 100000106800006030 C 3/03 17,500 22,500 .7778 INTERLAKE HILLS UNREC, LT 34 140850000000034000 C 8/02 161,800 161,900 .9994 27 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0206 CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE.
