Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   1/22/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:     14
TIME:     16:21                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             187  Polk
                                                         187-907  Livingston

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  ALSTON B 2 LT 9                  A0400001700                C       6/02         56,200          60,639        56,200    1.0800
  BAY HAVEN NO 1 B 2 LT 1          B0200003200 AND B02000033  O       5/02         82,500          62,494        82,500     .7600
  BRIARBEND NO 1 LT 42             B1000003900                O       7/02         80,000          83,943        80,000    1.0500
  BRIARBEND NO 1 LT 52             B1000004900                C       2/03         75,000          83,189        75,000    1.1100
  CHESSWOOD NO 2 B 1 LT 1          C0700005500 AND C07000056  C       3/03         69,650          69,183        69,650     .9900
  1300 CHURCH PLACE LT 9           C0875000900                O      10/02         75,000          62,366        75,000     .8300
  COMMODORE CAPE S 2 LT 50         C1200005000                W       8/02         69,200          64,063        69,200     .9300
  COMMODORE CAPE S 2 LOT 110       C1200010700                O       1/03        230,000         144,386       230,000     .6300
  COUNTRYWOOD LOT 58               C1800005200                O       7/02         88,000          93,993        88,000    1.0700
  CRESCENT SHORES B 9 LT 33        C2200012500                O       1/03        125,000          69,076       125,000     .5500
  ENCHNTED FOREST LT 45            E0800004200                C       3/03        170,000         160,574       170,000     .9400
  ENCHANTED FOREST LOT 51          E0800004800                O       8/02        139,000         123,259       139,000     .8900
  ENCHANTED FOREST NO 2 PT LT 90   E0800008500                O       1/03        215,000         226,418       215,000    1.0500
  FORSET SPRINGS NO 3 L 6          F0500036400                O       9/02         77,648          53,691        77,648     .6900
  GARDEN ACRES LT 28-1             G0025000210                C       6/02         84,000          93,608        84,000    1.1100
  HILL-DVIDSON LOT 29              H1000001900                O       8/02         42,000          40,802        42,000     .9700
  HOLIDAY LAKE EST NO 3 B 19 LT    H1200031300                W       9/02         67,500          75,212        67,500    1.1100
  HOLIDAY LAKE ESTATES NO 4 B 20   H1200034800                O       4/02         39,900          20,381        39,900     .5100
  INDIAN HILL NO 2 B 5 LT 19       I0400033400                C      11/02         60,000          94,602        60,000    1.5800
  INDIAN HILL NO 2 B 10 PT LTS 1   I0400036700                O      11/02        178,000         127,566       178,000     .7200
  INDIAN HILL NO 2 B 16 LT 2       I0400042800                C       3/03        145,000         186,281       145,000    1.2800
  INDIAN HILL ESTATES NO 2 B 2 L   I0500017100                C       3/03         30,000          32,168        30,000    1.0700
  INDIAN HILL EST NO 2 B 7 LT 3    I0500026200                C       3/03         39,016          45,312        39,016    1.1600
  INDIAN HILLS EATATES NO 3 LTS    I0500040600                O       1/03        110,000         113,135       110,000    1.0300
  INDIAN HILL HARBOR LT 47         I0600004200                W      10/02         15,000          14,115        15,000     .9400
  INDIAN HILL HEIGHTS NO 1 B 10    I0700015200                O      12/02         39,000          34,593        39,000     .8900
  INDIAN SPRING LAKE NO 11 B 1 L   I0800085200                C       3/03          9,000          14,332         9,000    1.5900
  INDIAN SPRING LAKE NO 20 LTS 2   I0800152000                C       8/02         12,000          17,854        12,000    1.4900
  JONES B 2 LTS 5 AND PT OF 8      J0500002200                C      11/02         26,000          31,062        26,000    1.1900
  LAKE LIVINGSTON EST NO 1 B 2 L   L0200002900                C       4/02         58,000          59,350        58,000    1.0200
  LAKE LIVINGSTON EST NO 1 BLK 3   L0200004100                O       4/02         45,000          49,553        45,000    1.1000
  LAKE LIVINGSTON ESTATES NO 3     L0200024400 AND L02000245  O       4/02         19,500          21,113        19,500    1.0800
  LAKE LIVINGSTON EST NO 3 B 7 L   L0200033800 AND OTHERS     W       9/02         34,500          38,214        34,500    1.1100
  LAKE LIVINGSTON ESTATES NO 3 B   L0200037400                O       8/02         95,000          94,124        95,000     .9900
  LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLAGE NO 1 L   L0400008400                O       9/02         28,000          29,704        28,000    1.0600
  LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLAGE NO 3 L   L0400024800                O      11/02         12,000          12,864        12,000    1.0700
  LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLIAGE NO 12   L0400197200 AND L04001973  O       7/02        250,000         268,698       250,000    1.0700
  LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLAGE NO 13    L0400258200 & L0400258100  O       5/02         69,000          73,652        69,000    1.0700
  LAKESHORE EST NO 2 B 4 LT 1 AN   L0600006700                C      10/02         15,000          16,256        15,000    1.0800
  LAKESIDE VILLAGE NO 1 B 1 LT 6   L0800000600                W       5/02        103,500          99,057       103,500     .9600
  LAKEVIEW NO 1 B 1 LT 13 THRU 1   L0900001300                C       5/02         33,000          46,602        33,000    1.4100
  LAKEVIEW #1BLK 2 LOT 7           L0900002600                C       5/02          9,500          14,794         9,500    1.5600
  LAKEVIEW NO 2 B 10 LTS 16 & 17   L0900009000                C       7/02         19,840          28,150        19,840    1.4200
  LAKEWOOD LT 12                   L1000001100                O      12/02        410,000         299,171       410,000     .7300
  MEMORIAL POINT B 6 LT 9          M1400021300                W       4/02         22,000          27,742        22,000    1.2600
  MEMORIAL POIN TWN HSE NO 1 LT    M1500001000                W       5/02         43,500          40,370        43,500     .9300
  MEMORIAL POINT TWN HSE NO 2 LT   M1500003100                C       9/02         55,000          63,709        55,000    1.1600

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 15 TIME: 16:21 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 187 Polk 187-907 Livingston CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ NUGENTS COVE NO 1 B 6 LT 5 N1000014000 AND N10000139 C 7/02 43,000 46,423 43,000 1.0800 OAK FOREST B 5 LOT 4 O0100005200 W 1/03 89,900 81,226 89,900 .9000 OAK HOLLOW TR 35-8 O0150003510 O 7/02 45,000 70,497 45,000 1.5700 OAK TERRACE ESTATES NO 2 LT 14 O0300005200 AND O03000053 O 5/02 69,900 67,267 69,900 .9600 OAK TERRACE EST NO 2 LT 44 O0300008200 O 6/02 65,000 48,315 65,000 .7400 OAK TERRACE EST NO 6 LT 26 O0300027700 C 9/02 20,500 22,068 20,500 1.0800 OAK TERRACE EST 10 LT 12 O0300054600 C 6/02 15,000 18,276 15,000 1.2200 OAKHURST PT BLKS 2 AND 3 O0400000201 O 9/02 60,000 58,814 60,000 .9800 THE OAKS LTS 7 & 8 O0450000800 W 4/02 370,000 371,712 370,000 1.0000 PINE SHADOWS NO 1 BLK 4 LOTS 3 P0800004500 O 9/02 105,000 121,544 105,000 1.1600 PINE SHADOWS NO 1 B 10 LTS 14/ P0800008700 AMD P08000088 C 10/02 31,000 36,228 31,000 1.1700 PINE SHADOWS NO 2 B 3 PT LT 30 P0800014500 W 12/02 42,900 49,912 42,900 1.1600 PINEHILL B 1 PT OF LTS 1 AND 2 P1200000100 C 2/03 65,000 67,755 65,000 1.0400 REILYS LANDING LTS 305 & 307 R000018200 W 5/02 53,000 34,179 53,000 .6400 RAINBOWS END NO 1 LT 27 R0050002900 W 11/02 68,000 62,702 68,000 .9200 RAINBOWS END NO 4 LT 182 R0050018200 W 5/02 53,000 43,225 53,000 .8200 RAINBOWS END NO 4 LT 200 R0050020000 C 12/02 51,000 51,543 51,000 1.0100 SHELTER COVE NO 3 LOTS 16 AND S1100016400 O 11/02 12,500 14,349 12,500 1.1500 SHELTER COVE NO 5 B 2 LT 29 S1100048900 O 12/02 115,000 108,902 115,000 .9500 SHELTER COVE NO 5 B 2 LTS 33 A S1100049400 O 8/02 148,000 100,145 148,000 .6800 SHILOH RIDGE NO 3 LT 301 AND 3 S1200010700 AND S12000061 C 8/02 26,000 36,189 26,000 1.3900 SIESTA COUNTRY NO 2 LT 38 S1300012700 AND S13000129 C 2/03 42,000 47,460 42,000 1.1300 TAYLOR LAKE EST NO 4 LT 26 T0200-0113-00 C 12/02 27,000 26,545 27,000 .9800 TAYLOR LAKE EST NO 1 LTS 59,61 T0200002500, T0200002501 C 7/02 111,000 112,373 111,000 1.0100 TEXAS LANDING LOT 109 T0425010900 W 7/02 115,000 87,344 115,000 .7600 THUNDER MTN LAKES NO 1 B 1 LTS T0500002300 C 3/03 62,000 68,215 62,000 1.1000 TOWNE FOREST NO 1 LT 18 T0800001800 O 10/02 65,000 75,832 65,000 1.1700 TOWNE FOREST #2LOT 54 T0800005500 C 5/02 90,000 93,494 90,000 1.0400 WEAVERS COVE LT 25 W0300000800 W 9/02 152,000 107,337 152,000 .7100 WEAVERS COVE LT 26 W0300000900 W 5/02 93,500 62,560 93,500 .6700 WEAVERS COVE LT 57 W0300003600 C 7/02 12,500 13,893 12,500 1.1100 WILD COUNTRY LAKES NO 6 LTS 5 W1400053300 W 4/02 34,000 28,851 34,000 .8500 BURKES A 9 TR 25L 10009004311 O 10/02 110,000 115,437 110,000 1.0500 CHOATE A 15 S 3 TR 35C 10015060700 C 11/02 34,000 33,097 34,000 .9700 MENARD A 50 TR 36-12 100500004712 C 8/02 90,000 87,424 90,000 .9700 PICKNEY A 63 TR 28 10063003200 C 6/02 35,000 75,248 35,000 2.1500 VIESCA A 78 TR 11-I 10078001840 O 4/02 150,000 156,273 150,000 1.0400 VIESCA A 78 PT TRS 44 - 47 10078005420 W 4/02 182,000 127,884 182,000 .7000 CAREY A 187 TR 18 10187002800 AND 101870028 O 9/02 125,000 124,396 125,000 1.0000 JONES A 360 TR 11 12A-2 & 12A- 10360001400 C 6/02 98,000 104,026 98,000 1.0600 MASSEY A 422 TR 8E 10422001104 AND OTHERS O 12/02 125,000 66,867 125,000 .5300 MARSH A 446 TR 16 10446002300 AND 105920005 O 6/02 130,000 123,630 130,000 .9500 SMITH A 820 S 4 TR 47 10820004400 C 9/02 12,068 13,637 12,068 1.1300 90 SALES

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 16 TIME: 16:21 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 187 Polk 187-907 Livingston STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9744 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BALLAS 343 TR 1-B B0150000125 W 7/02 5,000 7,700 5,000 1.5400 BRENTWOOD NO 1 LT 22 B0950001900 C 8/02 3,000 4,225 3,000 1.4100 CEDAR RIDGE NO 1 LTS 12 - 14 C0550000905 C 8/02 6,000 6,952 6,000 1.1600 COMMODORE CAPE S 2 LT 39 C1200003900 C 6/02 4,000 6,911 4,000 1.7300 COMMODORE CAPE S 2 PT LT 116 C1200011300 C 11/02 7,000 9,675 7,000 1.3800 COMMODORE CAPE S LT 117 & PT L C1200011500 C 8/02 7,500 11,880 7,500 1.5800 CRYSTAL LAKES #1 LOTS 214, 216 C2400007700 & 007900 C 1/02 3,000 3,805 3,000 1.2683 DICKENS LANDING NO 2 LT 31 D0375005100 W 7/02 26,500 25,412 26,500 .9600 FOREST SPRINGS NO 1 B C LTS 20 F0500007000 W 4/02 4,500 3,900 4,500 .8700 FOREST SPRINGS #1BLK E LOTS 14 F0500008400 C 2/02 3,750 3,600 3,750 .9600 FOREST SPRINGS NO 2 B D LT 6 - F0500031900 C 2/03 3,500 3,510 3,500 1.0000 GLEN COVE LT 14 G0125001400 C 3/03 8,000 12,075 8,000 1.5100 HIDDEN VALLEY EST NO 2 B 9 H0800001500 C 8/02 14,575 14,953 14,575 1.0300 HOLLY HILLS NO 1 B 2 LT 11 H1500003400 C 10/02 1,000 2,289 1,000 2.2900 HOLLY HILLS NO 1 BLK 4 LT 5 H1500004800 C 3/03 1,500 2,811 1,500 1.8700 INDIAN HILL EST NO 1 B 4 LT 13 I0500005300 C 12/02 5,500 5,355 5,500 .9700 INDIAN HILL EST NO 1 B 5 LT 2 I0500009300 W 7/02 4,200 3,500 4,200 .8300 INDIAN HILL EST NO 2 B 3 LT 6 I0500018600 C 7/02 7,000 7,254 7,000 1.0400 INDIAN HILL EST NO 2 B 3 LT 17 I0500019700 W 5/02 3,000 2,589 3,000 .8600 INDIAN HILL EST NO 2 B 12 PT L I0500035701 C 1/03 20,000 20,062 20,000 1.0000 INDIAN HILL EST NO 3 LT 39 I0500039900 W 4/02 1,750 3,780 1,750 2.1600 INDIAN HILL EST NO 1 B 10 LTS I0700014600 W 4/02 8,600 7,000 8,600 .8100 INDIAN HILL HEIGHTS NO 2 B 5 L I0700020700 W 11/02 10,000 11,250 10,000 1.1300 INDIAN HILL HEIGHTS NO 2 B 5 L I0700020800 W 10/02 10,000 8,437 10,000 .8400 JENNINGS COVE LT 6 J0010000600 W 2/03 15,500 30,564 15,500 1.9700 LAKE LIVINGSTON EST NO 3 B 2 L L0200022300 AND L02000223 C 7/02 6,000 8,847 6,000 1.4700 LAKE LIVINGSTON EST NO 3 B 3 L L0200023500 C 8/02 2,100 2,200 2,100 1.0500 LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLAGE EST NO L0200031200 C 12/02 3,000 4,400 3,000 1.4700 LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLAGE NO 1 L L0400009500 C 10/02 1,680 2,025 1,680 1.2100 LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLAGE NO 2 L L0400014100 C 10/02 1,680 1,662 1,680 .9900 LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLAGE #2LOT L0400017200 C 5/02 3,800 3,850 3,800 1.0132 LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLAGE NO 2 L L0400197900 C 10/02 3,800 3,850 3,800 1.0100 LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLAGE N0 12 L0400200900 C 10/02 1,680 2,025 1,680 1.2100 LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLAGE NO 12 L0400202900 C 10/02 1,064 2,085 1,064 1.9600 LAKESIDE VILLAGE NO 1 B 5 LT 1 L0800002700 W 8/02 5,000 8,709 5,000 1.7400 LONGHORN VALLEY EST B 3 LTS 1, L1450010800 C 11/02 2,000 3,825 2,000 1.9100 MANGUM ESTATES #1LOTS 25 & 26 M0500001700 C 1/02 1,600 2,500 1,600 1.5625 MEMORIAL POINT B 1 LT 4 M1400001100 C 2/03 1,500 2,024 1,500 1.3500 MEMORIAL POINT B 3 LT 6 M1400009500 C 8/02 1,100 1,980 1,100 1.8000 MEMORIAL POINT B 8 LT 67 M1400034500 C 8/02 2,000 2,412 2,000 1.2100 MEMORIAL POINT BLK 11 LOT 36 M1400049300 O 2/02 11,000 20,625 11,000 1.8750

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 17 TIME: 16:21 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 187 Polk 187-907 Livingston CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ MILLS FOREST LT 8 PT LT 9 M1700000800 C 5/02 13,000 13,497 13,000 1.0400 NUGENTS COVE #1 BLK 1 LOTS 7 & N1000000600 & 000700 C 2/02 2,000 2,250 2,000 1.1250 NUGENTS COVE NO 1 B 4 LTS 8 AN N1000009600 C 8/02 4,200 6,000 4,200 1.4300 NUGENTS COVE NO 2 B 5 LTS 9/10 N1000032800 C 10/02 2,000 4,500 2,000 2.2500 NUGENTS COVE NO 2 B 6 LTS 40/4 N1000038400 C 5/02 5,000 5,160 5,000 1.0300 OAK FOREST B 8 LT 10 O010009300 C 1/03 9,000 9,980 9,000 1.1100 OAK TERRACE EST NO 3 LTS 50/51 O0300017800 W 2/03 9,000 6,916 9,000 .7700 OAK TERRACE ESTATES#4LOT 25 O0300020600 C 3/02 6,000 6,171 6,000 1.0285 OAK TERRACE EST NO 9 LT 148 O0300053400 C 9/02 1,500 1,800 1,500 1.2000 OAK TERRACE EST NO 9 LT 149 O0300053500 C 9/02 1,500 1,800 1,500 1.2000 OAK TERRACE EST NO 10 LOT 37 O0300057100 W 5/02 2,000 1,800 2,000 .9000 PINE SHADOWS NO 2 B 7 LT 14 P0800016700 C 8/02 6,000 5,535 6,000 .9200 RESORT COUNTRY NO 1 LT 2 R0700000200 W 9/02 80,000 85,050 80,000 1.0600 RESORT COUNTRY S 2 LT 128 R0700014700 C 10/02 3,000 4,803 3,000 1.6000 SCHWAB CITY ACRES TR 3 S0400000400 C 6/02 4,000 7,700 4,000 1.9300 SHELTER COVE NO 1 LT 14 S1100001300 C 9/02 7,000 6,637 7,000 .9500 SHELTER COVE NO 1 LT 32 S1100003000 C 6/02 3,000 3,381 3,000 1.1300 SHELTER COVE NO 2 LT 34 S1100011600 C 9/02 25,720 24,750 25,720 .9600 SIESTA COUNTRY #1TR 22 & 23 S1300001700 C 3/02 3,300 3,366 3,300 1.0200 SPRING CREEK NO 2 LT 7 S1950006000 C 3/03 1,275 2,442 1,275 1.9200 SUNSET SHADOWS NO 2 LT 58 S3000006500 C 9/02 6,000 7,700 6,000 1.2800 TAYLOR LAKE EST NO 4 LT 13 T0200010100 W 10/02 6,000 5,913 6,000 .9900 TEXAS LANDING LT 3 T0425000300 C 10/02 3,000 3,062 3,000 1.0200 TEXAS LANDING LT 20 T0425002000 W 12/02 2,500 4,156 2,500 1.6600 TEXAS LANDING LT 26 T0425002600 W 2/03 5,000 4,311 5,000 .8600 TEXAS LANDING LT 110/111 T04250110000 C 7/02 12,500 12,899 12,500 1.0300 THUNDER MOUNTAIN EST NO 1 B 6 T0500014500 C 4/02 1,500 1,800 1,500 1.2000 TIMBERLAND COVE TR 12 T0600001200 C 6/02 25,000 24,150 25,000 .9700 WILD COUNTRY LAKES NO 6 LT 10 W1400053600 C 3/02 1,000 2,030 1,000 2.0300 MENARD A 50 TR 76H 10050008620 C 4/02 1,750 1,958 1,750 1.1200 J MORGAN ABST 56TR 210 10056018000 C 3/02 3,000 4,025 3,000 1.3400 PRICE A 720 TR 1YY BEECH CREEK 10720000148 C 1/03 2,600 4,200 2,600 1.6200 CURRIE A 751 PT TR 1 & 2 10751000110 C 11/02 8,000 12,270 8,000 1.5300 74 SALES CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER APPR VAL APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ALEXANDER B 9 PT LT 1 A0300000501 16,946 19,503 .8700 CHESSWOOD NO 3 B 3 LT 15 C0700009700 26,115 20,892 1.2500 CRESCENT SHORES B 9 LT 7 C2200010000 22,500 24,000 .9400 DEERFIELD LT 9 D0250000900 35,625 18,000 1.9800 DEERFIELD LT 12 D0250001200 45,030 18,000 2.5000

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 18 TIME: 16:21 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 187 Polk 187-907 Livingston CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER APPR VAL APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ INDIAN HILL NO 2 B 16 LT 21 I0400044501 34,902 18,900 1.8500 OAK TERRACE EST NO 1 LT 16 O0300001600 23,220 17,200 1.3500 OAK TERRACE ESTATES NO 1 LT 24 O0300002400 42,660 31,600 1.3500 PEBBLE CREEK TR 10 P0350001000 14,781 19,940 .7400 RESORT COUNTRY S 2 LT 82 R0700010700 20,000 16,000 1.2500 CHOATE A 15 TR 113A-1 10015012900 113,815 100,118 1.1400 CHOATE A 15 TR 127E 10015014330 45,218 40,162 1.1300 CHOATE A 15 S 1 SUB LT 22 10015030200 46,220 24,045 1.9200 CHOATE A 15 S 1 SUSB LT 77-1 10015036001 16,085 23,143 .7000 CHOATE A 15 S 1 SUB LT 80 W 10015036600 16,800 18,000 .9300 CHOATE A 15 S 1 10015042700 46,200 46,200 1.0000 BRADLEY A 98 TR 24 10098002800 77,240 57,935 1.3300 BARCO A 101 TR 9 10101002300 45,471 43,050 1.0600 HICKS A 282 PT TR 9 & 10D 10282001236 21,000 15,246 1.3800 HAYNES A 324 TR 1-I 10324000110 24,930 30,172 .8300 20 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.1757 CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ EASTON OAKS LT 13 E0150001300, E0150001200 C 1/03 34,946 21,000 1.6600 PEBBLE CREEK TR 8 P0350000800 C 6/02 20,475 19,000 1.0800 SOUTHLAND PLANTATION TR 5 S 1 S1825000500 W 12/02 115,399 100,000 1.1500 SOUTHLAND PLANTATION SEC 3 TR S1825007800 C 2/03 9,474 7,000 1.3500 SOUTHLAND PLANTATION SEC 8 TR S1825017409 W 1/03 20,000 22,000 .9100 BOULTER A 6 TR 87 10006009500 AND 008100 O 11/02 29,995 25,000 1.2000 CHOATE A 15 TR 1,1A,2A,2 10015000200 C 6/02 57,726 35,000 1.6500 CHOATE A 15 S 1 TR 8 10015001100 W 2/03 16,412 8,000 2.0500 HIROMS A 37 TR 37 10037004600 W 2/03 23,943 17,000 1.4100 MORGAN A 56 PT TR 99B, 100 & 1 10056009725 W 5/02 139,267 148,000 .9400 I PARKER ABST 61TR 159 10061021800 C 3/02 26,403 16,659 1.5849 JONES A 360 TR 17 10360002600 W 12/02 55,472 95,000 .5800 RUDDLE A 516 TR 9 10516001600 C 6/03 65,113 60,000 1.0900 STEPHENSON A 761 TR 16 10761002100 O 8/02 76,673 54,000 1.4200 14 SALES

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 19 TIME: 16:21 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 187 Polk 187-907 Livingston CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER APPR VAL APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ SOUTHLAND PLANTATION S 9 TR 19 S1825-0183-00 52,736 66,083 .8000 SOUTHLAND PLANTATION NO 24 TR S1825-0394-00 99,603 98,177 1.0100 DIKES TR 3/3D/3E 10027000300 125,636 82,106 1.5300 PARKER A 61 TR 97A 10061014700 119,450 119,597 1.0000 VIESCA A 77 TR 101 10077-0141-00 65,273 60,021 1.0900 STEPHENSON A 761 TR 46 10761-0057-00 71,666 78,356 .9100 6 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0827 CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ INDIAN SPRINGS LAKE NO 5 LT 13 I0800041900 C 7/02 23,000 28,353 23,000 1.2300 NORTHBLK 2 N0800000700 C 3/02 60,000 98,693 60,000 1.6400 M L CHOATE ABST 15 TR 74 10015008800 C 4/02 40,000 40,338 40,000 1.0100 M L CHOATE ABST 15 SEC 4TR 6A 10015062600 C 2/02 32,175 35,131 32,175 1.0900 MORGAN A 56 TR 36 10056003500 W 5/02 105,000 137,251 105,000 1.3100 MORGAN A 56 TR 174-D-56 10056016931 AND 100560169 C 7/02 850,000 873,102 850,000 1.0300 6 SALES CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ JONES MATTHEWS B 2 PT LTS 1 & J0400000500 .00 1.00 .00 177,402 161,067 1.1000 JONES-MATTHEWS B 3 PT LTS 1/2 J0400000800 .00 1.00 .00 61,448 64,507 .9500 LIVINGSTON OT B 13 LTS 1 AND 2 L1400003300 .00 1.00 .00 162,223 180,286 .9000 LIVINGSTON OT B 14 LTS 1 - 3A, L1400004000 .00 1.00 .00 1,340,326 1,373,580 .9800 LIVINGSTON OT B 21 LTS 3 THRU L1400006400 .00 1.00 .00 129,415 135,292 .9600 LIVINGSTON OT B 23 L 3 L1400007300 .00 1.00 .00 186,197 148,102 1.2600 LIVINGSTON OT B 24 LT 2 L1400007700 .00 1.00 .00 45,626 55,834 .8200 LIVINGSTON OT B 33 LT 2A L1400010500 .00 1.00 .00 141,881 91,293 1.5500 NORTH PT B E PT LTS 5 AND 6 N0800001001 .00 1.00 .00 219,823 184,085 1.1900 COOPER CANERON COPR P1000002300 .00 1.00 .00 382,807 283,281 1.3500 RAINBOWS END NO 1 LOT 11 R0050001100 .00 1.00 .00 509,310 469,807 1.0800 RAINBOWS ENC NO 1 RES B R0050003500 .00 1.00 .00 158,919 127,473 1.2500 SOUTH PT B 2 S1800000500 .00 1.00 .00 59,908 66,744 .9000

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 20 TIME: 16:21 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 187 Polk 187-907 Livingston CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LIVINGSTON VENTURES 10015012520 .00 1.00 .00 1,852,001 2,540,114 .7300 HEB GROCERY CO 10015023700 .00 1.00 .00 752,349 655,038 1.1500 CHOATE A 15 TRS 171A AND 171A- 10015024100 .00 1.00 .00 370,754 296,872 1.2500 CHOATE A 15 PT S 1 LT 150 10015044701 .00 1.00 .00 399,722 439,669 .9100 CHOATE A 15 SEC 2 SUB LOT 66 A 10015051300 .00 1.00 .00 97,776 159,103 .6100 CHOATE A 15 S 2 SUB LOTS 67-69 10015051400 .00 1.00 .00 517,718 335,037 1.5500 CHOATE A 15 S 3 PT LT 18A 10015057301 .00 1.00 .00 1,739,955 2,076,362 .8400 DIKES A 27 TR 19 10027002900 .00 1.00 .00 140,655 118,812 1.1800 DIKES A 27 TR 26 10027003500 .00 1.00 .00 153,728 158,814 .9700 D52ES A 27 TR 28 10027003700 .00 1.00 .00 70,621 48,263 1.4600 MORGAN A 56 TR 21A 10056001805 .00 1.00 .00 260,221 238,606 1.0900 MORGAN A 56 TR 21A-1 10056001900 .00 1.00 .00 870,268 788,644 1.1000 MORGAN A 56 TR 174E 10056016925 .00 1.00 .00 2,917,031 2,232,519 1.3100 MORGAN A 56 TR 207 AND 204 10056017800 .00 1.00 .00 2,184,383 2,462,636 .8900 BBB&CRR A 153 TRS 4 AND 5, PT 10153000406 .00 1.00 .00 151,195 159,713 .9500 FERGUSON A 245 TR 8 10245001000 .00 1.00 .00 107,286 67,926 1.5800 HARDIN A 273 TR 7 10273001300 .00 1.00 .00 54,967 61,193 .9000 RUDDLE A 16 10516002105 .00 1.00 .00 26,828 32,078 .8400 SMITH A 820 10820001100 .00 1.00 .00 217,671 180,073 1.2100 BROCK A 962 10962000100 .00 1.00 .00 256,800 171,270 1.5000 33 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0531 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ WAL-MART STORES INC BP000-7920-00 7,904,675 7,319,749 1.0800 WINDHAMMM & SONS BP000-8170-00 1,024,175 659,331 1.5500 CORNER TEXACO BP000089500 58,750 44,544 1.3200 BROOKSHIRE BROS BP000095000 1,792,518 1,264,397 1.4200 CATFISH BILLS BP000128506 15,919 18,470 .8600 EL BURRITO RESTAURANT BP000238800 59,600 62,953 .9500 FIRST STATE BANK BP000268000 535,695 751,392 .7100 FOUNTAIN FLORIST BP000273000 23,097 19,200 1.2000 NELL FRANKLIN'S ART GALLERY BP000282000 26,700 41,590 .6400 CARQUEST AUTO PARTS BP000315680 79,550 98,010 .8100 JACKSON HARDWARE BP000387000 235,333 204,355 1.1500 JIMMY'S AUTO PARTS BP000404700 179,770 175,229 1.0300 MEDICAL CENTER DISCOUNT PHARMA BP000518000 32,412 41,820 .7800 OWEN FURNITURE BP000576000 236,550 243,825 .9700 PARK INN INTERNATIONAL BP000584150 131,000 69,565 1.8800

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 21 TIME: 16:21 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 187 Polk 187-907 Livingston CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ PEDIGO FURNITURE INC BP000594000 466,660 439,746 1.0600 PIZZA HUT BP000610000 67,888 73,129 .9300 POLKS PICK IT UP BP000618000 145,000 85,120 1.7000 PUTT WATSON MOTOR CO BP000630000 169,528 148,583 1.1400 RED BARN BP000644300 690,729 482,518 1.4300 SEARS ROEBUCK BP000675000 232,379 161,600 1.4400 SHRIMP BOA T MANNY BP000690250 28,000 44,985 .6200 THOMAS SUPPLY CO BP000767000 794,417 1,535,646 .5200 VAINTY FAIR FACTORY OUTLET BP000785060 675,207 548,904 1.2300 AUTOZONE INC BP001019100 403,675 307,549 1.3100 FIRST STATE BANK BP200064700 159,946 115,930 1.3800 HEB BP940-0805-00 1,011,513 854,903 1.1800 ANCO INSURANCE BP940016000 28,300 30,660 .9200 WHIRLWIND PRIVATE CLUB BP970233800 12,720 5,002 2.5400 CANON FINANCIAL SERVICES BP990031100 33,637 42,905 .7800 CHASE AUTOMOTIVE FINANCE BP990033900 60,714 19,276 3.1500 POLK COUNTY TRACTOR SUPPLY BP990167600 60,485 176,555 .3400 32 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9793