DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 1 TIME: 16:05 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 171 Moore 171-901 Dumas CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ PT OF LT 17 & LT 18 15669 C 5/02 35,000 29,900 35,000 .8500 LT 1-2 15910 C 12/02 45,000 31,000 45,000 .6900 LT 13-15 16057 C 11/02 61,000 57,220 61,000 .9400 LT 16-17 BLK 160 16236 W 11/02 38,000 36,270 38,000 .9500 LT 11-12 16436 C 5/02 45,000 33,140 45,000 .7400 LT 15-16 16632 C 5/02 32,500 28,200 32,500 .8700 LT 13-14 16712 C 1/03 54,000 63,630 54,000 1.1800 LT 5-6 16765 C 10/02 49,000 35,180 49,000 .7200 LT 1 & PT OF LT 2 16926 C 5/02 122,500 126,920 122,500 1.0400 LT 12 16931 C 9/02 65,000 59,100 65,000 .9100 LT 18 BLK 20 BELMONT 16949 W 11/02 104,000 86,320 104,000 .8300 LT 6 BLK 15 16970 Y 9/02 63,000 47,290 63,000 .7500 PT OF LT 12 & LT 13 17004 C 1/03 104,000 84,920 104,000 .8200 LT 11 17032 C 9/02 145,000 121,960 145,000 .8400 LT 4 & PT OF LT 5 BLK 19 17070 W 9/02 104,000 88,710 104,000 .8500 LT 30 17073 C 11/02 145,000 128,120 145,000 .8800 LT 3 BLK 8 BELMONT 17100 W 9/02 73,000 67,690 73,000 .9300 LT 9 BLK 18 BELMONT 17136 W 2/02 89,900 86,320 89,900 .9600 PT OF LT 7 & LT 8 17146 C 4/02 81,000 79,100 81,000 .9800 LT 19 BLK 7 17201 W 11/02 75,000 74,380 75,000 .9900 PT OF LT 10 & LT 11 17220 C 5/02 80,000 78,650 80,000 .9800 PT OF LT 2 & 3 17291 C 10/02 40,000 31,330 40,000 .7800 PT OF LT 24 & LT 25 17313 C 2/03 87,000 94,460 87,000 1.0900 PT OF LT 26 & LT 27 17346 C 3/03 49,900 40,810 49,900 .8200 PT OF LT 18 BLK 4 17367 W 2/03 120,000 128,170 120,000 1.0700 PT OF LT 13 BLK 6 17370 W 12/02 92,000 76,210 92,000 .8300 PT OF LT 7 & ALL OF LT 8 17377 C 4/02 89,500 85,550 89,500 .9600 PT OF LT 20 AND ALL OF LT 21 17423 C 10/02 110,000 94,070 110,000 .8600 PT OF LT 23 & LT 24 17432 C 2/03 86,750 86,980 86,750 1.0000 PT OF LT 1 & LT 2 17443 C 12/02 72,500 73,660 72,500 1.0200 PT OF LT 24 & 25 BLK 7 17760 W 9/02 37,620 40,880 37,620 1.0900 LT 9 BLK 2 CORONADO 17878 W 4/02 19,000 31,500 19,000 1.6600 LT 2 17924 C 9/02 39,000 26,690 39,000 .6800 LT 1 BLK 12 EAST HILLS 18012 W 12/02 120,000 96,420 120,000 .8000 LT 1 18014 C 5/02 105,000 103,530 105,000 .9900 LT 3 BLK 6 EAST HILLS 18034 W 10/02 99,000 103,880 99,000 1.0500 LT 2 & PT OF LT 3 18047 C 8/02 265,000 238,120 265,000 .9000 PT OF LT 10 & 11 18065 C 5/02 83,000 82,900 83,000 1.0000 PT OF LT 3 18077 C 9/02 112,000 109,880 112,000 .9800 LT 18 18080 C 5/02 190,000 183,490 190,000 .9700 LT 1 18081 C 6/02 180,000 180,320 180,000 1.0000 PT OF LT 17 & ALL LT 18 18099 C 10/02 280,000 287,310 280,000 1.0300 PT OF LT 13 & 14 18119 C 6/02 92,000 82,130 92,000 .8900 LT 3 18123 C 10/02 98,000 84,400 98,000 .8600 LT 16 18155 C 8/02 45,000 35,590 45,000 .7900 LT 10 BLK 7 GREEN AC 18203 W 11/02 52,784 38,920 52,784 .7400 LT 73 18279 C 12/02 85,000 84,250 85,000 .9900DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 2 TIME: 16:05 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 171 Moore 171-901 Dumas CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LT 73 18285 C 6/02 110,500 103,620 110,500 .9400 PT OF LT 86 & ALL LT 87 18308 C 10/02 135,000 115,760 135,000 .8600 PT OF LT 59 & ALL OF 60 18319 C 10/02 84,000 88,380 84,000 1.0500 LT 47 18404 C 8/02 24,050 31,840 24,050 1.3200 LT 52 18415 C 3/03 49,000 44,170 49,000 .9000 LT 12 18525 C 6/02 45,000 41,290 45,000 .9200 LT 7 BLK 7 HILLCREST 18547 W 9/02 45,000 34,400 45,000 .7600 LT 1 18555 C 4/02 41,000 35,450 41,000 .8600 LT 22 18563 C 11/02 79,000 66,720 79,000 .8400 LT 4 18867 C 6/02 32,000 23,260 32,000 .7300 LT 9 18883 C 6/02 37,000 36,770 37,000 .9900 LT 15 18930 C 8/02 45,000 30,850 45,000 .6900 LT 18 18946 C 7/02 47,600 41,360 47,600 .8700 PT OF LT 11 & LT 12 BLK 8 19078 W 2/02 30,000 27,210 30,000 .9100 PT OF LT 11 & LT 12 19238 C 7/02 36,500 44,990 36,500 1.2300 LT 17 19252 C 3/03 77,900 62,580 77,900 .8000 LT & PT OF LT 2 BLK 16 19399 W 7/02 57,500 50,720 57,500 .8800 PT OF LT 12 & ALL OF LT 13 19500 C 4/02 69,900 56,800 69,900 .8100 PT OF LT 1 19558 C 11/02 80,000 63,930 80,000 .8000 LT 11 BLK 12 MORNINGSIDE 19599 W 8/02 55,000 57,030 55,000 1.0400 LT 19 19731 C 6/02 67,000 61,540 67,000 .9200 PT OF LT 6 BLK 13 19750 W 10/02 59,000 57,590 59,000 .9800 LT 10 BLK 18 19767 W 3/03 85,200 77,920 85,200 .9100 PT OF LT 15 & 16 19773 C 7/02 89,000 85,620 89,000 .9600 PT OF LT 6 19795 C 5/02 70,000 71,810 70,000 1.0300 PT OF LT 18 19811 C 10/02 67,500 71,720 67,500 1.0600 LT 15 & PT OF LT 16 BLK 10 19843 W 9/02 76,800 73,360 76,800 .9600 LT 1 19864 C 4/02 42,000 28,980 42,000 .6900 PT OF LT 13 & 14 19985 C 3/03 83,500 85,610 83,500 1.0300 PT OF LT 16 & LT 17 19996 C 5/02 80,000 67,650 80,000 .8500 LT 8 BLK 27 20045 W 5/02 122,000 107,930 122,000 .8800 PT OF LT 4 & 5 BLK 17 20062 W 9/02 167,500 129,300 167,500 .7700 PT OF LT 2 & 3 BLK 24 20068 W 12/02 95,000 92,180 95,000 .9700 LT 4 BLK 2 PHILLIPS 20105 W 1/02 59,900 60,880 59,900 1.0200 LT 9 20149 C 6/02 45,000 36,470 45,000 .8100 LT 14 20155 C 11/02 65,000 55,830 65,000 .8600 PT OF LT 5 & 6 20201 C 12/02 100,000 91,640 100,000 .9200 LT 4 20218 C 6/02 103,500 89,160 103,500 .8600 PT OF LT 5 & 6 20220 C 5/02 112,500 97,200 112,500 .8600 PT OF LT 6 & 7 20243 C 7/02 65,000 59,760 65,000 .9200 LT 8 20246 C 4/02 42,000 38,420 42,000 .9100 PT OF LT 10 & 11 BLK 13 20249 W 10/02 98,000 77,260 98,000 .7900 PT OF LT 4 & 5 20254 C 9/02 90,000 96,470 90,000 1.0700 PT OF LT 3 & 4 20333 C 7/02 153,000 140,040 153,000 .9200 PT OF LT 2 & 3 20339 C 12/02 107,000 98,260 107,000 .9200 PT OF LT 9 & 10 20344 C 3/03 108,000 96,600 108,000 .8900 PT OF LT 22 & LT 23 20444 C 9/02 43,328 41,180 43,328 .9500
DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 3 TIME: 16:05 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 171 Moore 171-901 Dumas CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LT 3 20656 C 10/02 67,500 67,320 67,500 1.0000 LT 3 20756 C 9/02 29,000 30,310 29,000 1.0500 LT 12 BLK 4 20793 W 9/02 108,000 72,780 108,000 .6700 LT 14 20889 C 4/02 168,000 166,520 168,000 .9900 LT 17 7 PT OF LT 18 20907 C 7/02 330,000 324,710 330,000 .9800 PT OF LT 5 & 6 20923 C 6/02 109,000 94,840 109,000 .8700 PT OF LT 12 & 13 20931 C 11/02 107,950 91,110 107,950 .8400 PT OF LT 15 & LT 16 BLK 6 20933 W 8/02 108,000 99,450 108,000 .9200 LT 7 21063 C 11/02 106,000 92,760 106,000 .8800 LT 29 21103 C 10/02 108,000 90,940 108,000 .8400 LT 30 21104 C 6/02 77,900 74,300 77,900 .9500 LT 6 BLK 11 21134 W 7/02 156,350 160,850 156,350 1.0300 PT OF LT 18 & 19 27142 C 11/02 119,500 119,070 119,500 1.0000 PT OF LT 13 BLK 5 BURNETT 28874 W 7/02 147,500 120,720 147,500 .8200 LT 21 29897 C 7/02 161,450 147,870 161,450 .9200 LT 27 29903 C 2/03 165,000 152,870 165,000 .9300 LT 8,9 &10 BLK 4 30270 W 2/03 199,900 138,810 199,900 .6900 PT OF LT 9 BLK 1 BOWNDS-KINIKI 31110 W 12/02 87,675 76,220 87,675 .8700 LT 6 BLK 1 UNIT 1 31124 C 10/02 99,600 96,080 99,600 .9600 LT 8 BLK 1 UNIT 1 EASTLAND 31126 W 12/02 98,550 96,080 98,550 .9700 LTS 19-20 31179 C 1/03 65,000 66,170 65,000 1.0200 115 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9112 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 480 AC & 349.14 AC SEC 113 & 1 23124 W 7/02 159,810 247,800 .6400 159 AC IN SEC 119 BLK 44 23222 W 1/03 39,910 25,000 1.6000 318 AC IN SEC 54 BLK 44 23667 W 6/02 75,620 88,000 .8600 31.306 AC IN SEC 269 BLK 44 24076 C 6/02 62,610 87,000 .7200 86.05 AC IN BLK 2-T SEC 37 24433 W 1/03 22,100 17,500 1.2600 127.088 AC INSEC 7 BLK 1 24884 C 5/02 49,030 85,000 .5800 6 SALES
DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 4 TIME: 16:05 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 171 Moore 171-901 Dumas CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER APPR VAL APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 30 AC IN SEC 280 BLK 44 H&TC 23236 13,310 15,000 .8873 1 AC IN SEC 225 BLK 44 H&TC 24263 41,470 51,775 .8010 1 AC IN SEC 392 BLK 44 H&TC 26428 127,780 103,910 1.2297 320 AC IN SEC 15 BLK 1 29055 24,660 32,000 .7700 20 AC IN SEC 276 BLK 44 H&TC 29858 23,160 19,799 1.1698 5 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .8275 CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LT 6 BLK 73 16112 W 2/02 35,000 31,140 35,000 .8900 LT 20-22 BLK 98 OT 16690 W 4/02 70,341 36,880 70,341 .5200 LT 19-24 BLK 97 16759 W 3/02 315,000 317,690 315,000 1.0100 TR IN SEC 268 BLK 44 23561 W 4/02 150,000 141,010 150,000 .9400 2.5 AC IN SEC 240 BLK 44 28577 C 12/02 165,000 95,750 165,000 .5800 5 SALES CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LT 7-12 BLK 6 OT 15883 .00 1.00 .00 151,050 164,109 .9200 LT 13-24 AND ALLEY 15958 .00 1.00 .00 602,990 619,222 .9700 LT 11 & 12 BLK 72 16166 .00 1.00 .00 173,190 149,900 1.1600 PT OF LT 6 & ALL LTS 7-12 BLK 16192 .00 1.00 .00 154,790 150,095 1.0300 LT 15-18 AND LT 19-23 BLK 103 16795 .00 1.00 .00 41,890 43,908 .9500 PT OF LT 4 AND LTS 5-6 BLK 33 16821 .00 1.00 .00 46,930 48,471 .9700 LT 3-24 BLK 110 16850 .00 1.00 .00 432,570 423,437 1.0200 S/2 TRACT D 19079 .00 1.00 .00 1,123,650 1,177,496 .9500 PT OF BLK B 19108 .00 1.00 .00 184,070 173,628 1.0600 PT OF BLK E 19177 .00 1.00 .00 258,990 263,654 .9800 PT OF BLK 13 MORNINGSIDE 19549 .00 1.00 .00 488,990 576,506 .8500 LT 1-8 BLK 1 UNIT 1 20587 .00 1.00 .00 338,020 330,933 1.0200 LT 10-12 BLK 1 SUNSET 20638 .00 1.00 .00 1,179,510 1,227,625 .9600 8.91 AC IN BLK 6 TRI CANYON 22141 .00 1.00 .00 227,750 234,175 .9700 1.46 AC TR IN SEC 226 BLK 44 H 23570 .00 1.00 .00 1,149,760 1,238,609 .9300
DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 5 TIME: 16:05 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 171 Moore 171-901 Dumas CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 450 X 320 TR IN SEC 268 BLK 44 24008 .00 1.00 .00 60,910 58,500 1.0400 .5 AC IN SEC 236 BLK 44 24165 .00 1.00 .00 63,590 67,754 .9400 LT 2 BLK 1 26999 .00 1.00 .00 2,352,830 2,347,989 1.0000 LT 7-12 BLK 71 OT 27612 .00 1.00 .00 177,440 185,370 .9600 19 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9201 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ HISE MACHINE SHOP 14442 82,950 91,550 .9100 JC PENNEY 14536 670,990 678,630 .9900 JAMES STEWART DIRT WORK 14554 338,990 344,525 .9800 WAL-MART 14563 2,526,320 2,546,020 .9900 SWIFT AND CO 162975-0-9900180 2,435,540 2,387,238 1.0200 VULCAN MATERIALS CO 172450-0-9900530 12,720 5,342 2.3800 NORTH TRUCK STOP 26970 109,900 105,890 1.0400 WITT MOTORS 27312 279,910 279,910 1.0000 PARTS HEADQUARTERS 27989 207,010 204,039 1.0100 WESTCO RENTAL 28185 361,380 361,380 1.0000 LA POTOSINA PANADERIA 28201 14,590 15,118 .9700 CROP QUEST 28839 29,050 33,190 .8800 MERLE NORMAN COSMETICS 2920 28,160 27,831 1.0100 BAR W FORD 29700 259,840 254,704 1.0200 VASQUEZ PAUL C 30248 10,650 11,840 .9000 MIGUEL ARPERO TRUCKING 30781 17,600 19,216 .9200 DEKALB GENETICS 41930-0-9900260 3,303,220 3,375,000 .9800 FOOT SB TANNING 700397-0-9900120 2,088,750 2,022,266 1.0300 FOOT SB TANNING 700397-0-9900160 144,130 144,130 1.0000 FRISCHE BROTHERS 701047-0-9901060 111,220 78,024 1.4300 AUTOMOTIVE RENTALS 701990-0-9900190 17,560 16,063 1.0900 T & R VALLEY SERV INCORP 702483-0-9900700 110,780 110,780 1.0000 FARM CREDIT 703409-0-9900640 93,780 85,120 1.1000 HI-PRO ANIMAL HEALTH DIV 703593 1,352,820 1,352,820 1.0000 24 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0140
