Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   1/22/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:     27
TIME:     15:40                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             152  Lubbock
                                                         152-907  Frenship

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  RANCHO VERDE ESTATES L 50        101244                     C       9/02        150,000         139,636       151,575     .9212
  REVIER FARM L 229                101409                     C       7/02         72,000          71,003        73,188     .9701
  REVIER FARM L 284                103009                     C       2/03         85,000          78,305        84,618     .9254
  TERRA EST NORTH W70'OF L 153 &   103083                     C       6/02        180,000         197,293       183,510    1.0751
  FRENSHIP HEIGHTS L 36            103269                     C       2/03         59,500          63,059        59,232    1.0646
  REGAL PARK L 77                  103520                     C       2/03        210,000         216,875       209,055    1.0374
  REGAL PARK L 93                  103974                     C       4/02        206,500         206,500       211,766     .9751
  REGAL PARK L 103                 104310                     C       8/02        197,500         196,248       200,166     .9804
  FRENSHIP HEIGHTS L 56            105332                     C      12/02         75,000          71,189        75,113     .9478
  WESTWOOD L 14                    108605                     C       7/02        239,900         219,677       243,858     .9008
  BOLT AND CASEY L 22              108798                     C       2/03         70,000          72,850        69,685    1.0454
  WESTWOOD L 26                    109389                     C       8/02        370,000         367,129       374,995     .9790
  WESTWOOD L 34                    109922                     C       1/03        212,988         196,318       212,669     .9231
  WESTWOOD L 48                    111399                     C       7/02        321,000         320,999       326,296     .9838
  NORTHWEST ACRES L 42             113134                     C      10/02        147,000         147,000       148,102     .9926
  WESTWOOD L 67                    113805                     C       6/02        233,000         222,866       237,543     .9382
  WESTWOOD L 74                    114391                     C       7/02        221,000         223,209       224,646     .9936
  REGENCY PARK L 81                115110                     C       6/02        258,000         229,731       263,031     .8734
  TERRA ESTATES L 12               115258                     C       3/03        180,000         129,950       178,650     .7274
  TERRA ESTATES L 38               118519                     C       8/02        189,000         174,025       191,551     .9085
  TERRA ESTATES L 47               118696                     C       2/03        135,000         116,019       134,392     .8633
  TERRA ESTATES II L 56            119640                     C       6/02        155,000         158,643       158,022    1.0039
  TERRA ESTATES II L 57            119662                     C       6/02        198,900         178,493       202,779     .8802
  TERRA EST NORTH L 68             119834                     C      10/02        235,000         256,919       236,762    1.0851
  TERRA ESTATES II L 79            121175                     C       1/03        152,000         140,610       151,772     .9265
  WEST VIEW L 14                   123781                     C      10/02         78,000          64,302        78,585     .8182
  TERRA EST NORTH E50'OF L 139 &   125072                     C      12/02        210,000         171,738       210,315     .8166
  AMERICAN PARK L 185              125674                     C       9/02         47,500          47,009        47,998     .9794
  MEADOWGREEN L 23                 126624                     C       7/02         64,000          67,117        65,056    1.0317
  MEADOWGREEN L 33                 126900                     C      12/02         72,800          53,498        72,909     .7338
  MEADOWGREEN L 41                 127116                     C      11/02         80,000          75,183        80,360     .9356
  MEADOWGREEN L 67                 127811                     C       2/03         81,950          63,576        81,581     .7793
  MEADOWGREEN L 71                 127934                     C       3/03         73,200          65,569        72,651     .9025
  TERRA EST NORTH L 181            128397                     C       7/02        129,977         126,493       132,122     .9574
  MEADOWGREEN L 133                129712                     C       6/02         63,000          63,000        64,229     .9809
  PHEASANT RUN L 337               130950                     C       4/02        149,000         137,742       152,799     .9015
  MEADOWGREEN L 185                131192                     C       7/02         60,000          81,917        60,990    1.3431
  REVIER FARM L 316                132523                     C       9/02         82,000          78,881        82,861     .9520
  STONEGATE L 368                  132875                     C       6/02         96,700         104,241        98,585    1.0574
  REVIER FARM L 363                133744                     C       4/02         99,500          94,101       102,037     .9222
  PARK LORRAINE L 49               134361                     C       3/03         72,500          59,684        71,956     .8294
  PARK LORRAINE L 57               134585                     C       5/02         62,000          53,618        63,395     .8458
  WOLFFORTH HTS L 51               135145                     C       9/02         98,000          97,909        99,029     .9887
  SHADOW HILLS L 287A              135668                     C      10/02         96,885          94,852        97,612     .9717
  PARK LORRAINE L 123              136386                     C       9/02         69,900          63,090        70,633     .8932
  PARK LORRAINE SW55'OF L 144      136962                     C      11/02         63,500          63,007        63,785     .9878
  LLANO ESTATES L 55               138497                     C      12/02        288,000         242,457       288,432     .8406

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 28 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-907 Frenship CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LLANO ESTATES L 86 138524 C 11/02 349,500 325,421 351,073 .9269 LLANO ESTATES L 98 138536 C 11/02 622,500 669,225 625,301 1.0702 LLANO ESTATES L 102 138540 C 6/02 335,000 314,550 341,532 .9210 PAPALOTE SOUTH L 28 138665 C 11/02 480,000 396,167 482,160 .8217 WESTCHESTER PARK L 154 140286 C 7/02 105,500 108,221 107,241 1.0091 WESTCHESTER PARK L 182 140314 C 6/02 94,600 92,323 96,445 .9573 J A M L 1 142473 C 11/02 82,500 82,498 82,871 .9955 FRENSHIP HOLLOW L 6 142641 C 9/02 65,000 66,576 65,683 1.0136 FRENSHIP HOLLOW L 10 142645 C 8/02 74,000 74,178 74,999 .9891 LLANO ESTATES L 11 142775 C 9/02 289,900 276,758 292,944 .9447 LLANO ESTATES L 136 142848 C 6/02 359,000 359,000 366,000 .9809 LLANO ESTATES L 157 142869 C 9/02 335,000 361,073 338,517 1.0666 REVIER FARM L 374 143012 C 5/02 78,000 79,314 79,755 .9945 PARK LORRAINE VILLAGE L 9 143059 C 9/02 70,500 70,640 71,240 .9916 REVIER FARM L 434 144205 C 5/02 75,900 77,715 77,607 1.0014 REVIER FARM L 472 144243 C 5/02 72,000 62,231 73,620 .8453 REVIER FARM L 493 144264 C 6/02 96,500 95,009 98,381 .9657 FRENSHIP MESA L 28 146438 C 7/02 153,000 147,718 155,524 .9498 FRENSHIP MESA L 33 146443 C 2/03 154,900 147,532 154,203 .9567 FRENSHIP MESA L 37 146447 C 8/02 137,500 143,304 139,356 1.0283 FRENSHIP MESA L 40 146450 C 5/02 140,000 142,072 143,150 .9925 FRENSHIP MESA L 47A 146457 C 5/02 102,450 102,404 104,755 .9776 FRENSHIP MESA L 167 146497 C 2/03 142,500 141,812 141,859 .9997 WEST END PL BLK 19 W/2 OF L 5 146541 C 4/02 49,950 51,669 51,224 1.0087 REGENCY PARK L 99 146939 C 8/02 385,000 406,752 390,197 1.0424 REGENCY PARK L 103 146952 C 5/02 310,000 297,287 316,975 .9379 REGENCY PARK L 108 146957 C 9/02 250,000 279,031 252,625 1.1045 WESTCHESTER PARK L 222 147545 C 4/02 121,000 87,296 124,085 .7035 WESTCHESTER PARK L 238 147561 C 5/02 76,500 85,442 78,221 1.0923 WESTCHESTER PARK L 244 147567 C 11/02 91,000 90,350 91,410 .9884 WESTCHESTER PARK L 199-A 147578 C 1/03 122,000 120,322 121,817 .9877 WESTCHESTER PARK L 203-A 147582 C 5/02 87,000 98,282 88,958 1.1048 REVIER HOMESTEAD L 12 150025 C 12/02 76,500 74,469 76,614 .9720 REVIER HOMESTEAD L 16 150143 C 3/03 94,500 87,241 93,791 .9302 REVIER HOMESTEAD L 15 150145 C 6/02 71,500 70,500 72,894 .9672 REVIER HOMESTEAD L 17 150146 C 4/02 67,950 68,362 69,683 .9810 REVIER FARM L 546 150305 C 5/02 90,950 88,161 92,996 .9480 TEJAS ESTATES L 8-A 150517 C 1/03 310,000 314,405 309,535 1.0157 WESTCHESTER PARK L 294 150676 C 6/02 98,000 101,577 99,911 1.0167 WEST END PL BLK 22 W/2 OF L 10 151151 C 6/02 82,900 83,697 84,516 .9903 REVIER FARM L 629 154065 C 7/02 79,000 78,905 80,304 .9826 REVIER FARM L 650 154086 C 5/02 89,500 93,025 91,513 1.0165 REVIER FARM L 662 154098 C 1/03 98,000 96,042 97,853 .9815 FRENSHIP MESA L 261 154594 C 3/03 173,000 155,992 171,702 .9085 FRENSHIP MESA L 302 154635 C 4/02 174,500 182,988 178,950 1.0226 FRENSHIP MESA L 183 154638 C 10/02 179,000 175,540 180,342 .9734 FRENSHIP MESA L 188 154643 C 6/02 199,000 198,595 202,880 .9789

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 29 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-907 Frenship CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ FRENSHIP MESA L 190 154645 C 8/02 195,000 187,272 197,632 .9476 FRENSHIP MESA L 219 154674 C 4/02 190,000 199,848 194,845 1.0257 DAY ESTATES L 3 154923 C 2/03 178,500 204,303 177,697 1.1497 DAY ESTATES L 6 154926 C 8/02 219,500 197,816 222,463 .8892 DAY ESTATES L 9 154929 C 12/02 265,000 251,981 265,397 .9494 DAY ESTATES L 11 154931 C 8/02 227,000 237,036 230,064 1.0303 DAY ESTATES L 25 154945 C 4/02 175,000 170,498 179,462 .9500 DAY ESTATES L 26 154946 C 10/02 195,000 174,017 196,462 .8858 DAY ESTATES L 29 154949 C 9/02 195,000 182,487 197,047 .9261 DAY ESTATES L 49 154969 C 2/03 184,850 202,475 184,018 1.1003 DAY ESTATES L 59 154979 C 8/02 163,900 162,350 166,113 .9773 WESTCHESTER PARK L 314 156142 C 6/02 77,805 83,095 79,322 1.0476 REVIER HOMESTEAD L 104 156530 C 2/03 75,000 66,850 74,663 .8954 REGAL PARK L 133 156624 C 6/02 143,000 142,001 145,788 .9740 REGAL PARK L 141 156632 C 6/02 130,000 122,460 132,535 .9240 REGAL PARK L 149 156640 C 1/03 194,000 158,835 193,709 .8200 REGAL PARK L 158 156649 C 12/02 175,000 170,335 175,262 .9719 REGAL PARK L 184 156675 C 11/02 139,000 144,398 139,625 1.0342 REVIER FARM L 717 158511 C 4/02 117,600 114,273 120,598 .9475 REVIER FARM L 747 158543 C 4/02 96,715 91,916 99,181 .9267 REVIER FARM L 749 158545 C 4/02 102,573 87,191 105,189 .8289 REVIER FARM L 786 158597 C 2/03 118,500 96,295 117,967 .8163 REVIER FARM L 798 158609 C 6/02 85,428 98,539 87,094 1.1314 REVIER FARM L 807 158618 C 4/02 76,125 72,460 78,066 .9282 REVIER FARM L 820 158631 C 9/02 89,175 88,041 90,111 .9770 REVIER FARM L 822 158633 C 3/03 125,475 82,411 124,534 .6618 PAPALOTE SOUTH L 90 159610 C 10/02 350,000 304,532 352,625 .8636 PAPALOTE SOUTH L 94 159614 C 6/02 248,391 293,837 253,235 1.1603 PAPALOTE SOUTH L 109 159629 C 9/02 338,988 338,987 342,547 .9896 SOUTHWEST VISTAS L 38 159766 C 7/02 125,000 132,912 127,062 1.0460 REGAL PARK L 229 161527 C 5/02 120,569 133,329 123,282 1.0815 REGAL PARK L 258 161556 C 11/02 117,711 122,152 118,241 1.0331 REGAL PARK L 264 161562 C 9/02 182,000 202,028 183,911 1.0985 REGAL PARK L 270 161568 C 9/02 178,000 187,509 179,869 1.0425 REGAL PARK L 271 161569 C 12/02 214,950 220,532 215,272 1.0244 REGAL PARK L 272 161570 C 11/02 192,500 192,877 193,366 .9975 REGAL PARK L 275 161573 C 1/03 185,000 187,727 184,722 1.0163 REGAL PARK L 283 161581 C 10/02 203,600 199,232 205,127 .9713 REGAL PARK L 287 161585 C 1/03 187,500 187,500 187,219 1.0015 REGAL PARK L 288 161586 C 1/03 231,000 192,104 230,653 .8329 REGAL PARK L 291 161589 C 11/02 207,000 212,952 207,931 1.0241 REGAL PARK L 292 161590 C 10/02 227,583 225,476 229,290 .9834 REGAL PARK L 293 161591 C 4/02 213,000 197,441 218,431 .9039 WESTCHESTER PARK L 414 161625 C 6/02 109,370 110,158 111,503 .9879 WESTCHESTER PARK L 418 161629 C 8/02 93,000 103,899 94,256 1.1023 WESTCHESTER PARK L 436 161647 C 8/02 115,820 113,606 117,384 .9678 WESTCHESTER PARK L 447 161658 C 9/02 101,460 101,374 102,525 .9888

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 30 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-907 Frenship CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LLANO ESTATES L 201 162813 C 9/02 331,167 335,127 334,644 1.0014 REGAL PARK L 314 163255 C 10/02 128,173 144,132 129,134 1.1161 REGAL PARK L 324 163265 C 1/03 145,200 133,174 144,982 .9186 REGAL PARK L 328 163269 C 11/02 140,092 147,018 140,722 1.0447 REGAL PARK L 345 163286 C 5/02 116,941 108,879 119,572 .9106 REGAL PARK L 351 163292 C 6/02 119,461 137,162 121,790 1.1262 REGAL PARK L 354 163295 C 12/02 134,352 134,352 134,554 .9985 REGAL PARK L 363 163304 C 5/02 124,000 117,036 126,790 .9231 REGAL PARK L 371 163312 C 8/02 132,140 127,694 133,924 .9535 REGAL PARK L 373 163314 C 1/03 136,825 144,552 136,620 1.0581 REGAL PARK L 375 163316 C 7/02 116,350 113,425 118,270 .9590 REGAL PARK L 377 163318 C 7/02 206,200 187,005 209,602 .8922 REGAL PARK L 379 163320 C 12/02 201,700 208,685 202,003 1.0331 REGAL PARK L 380 163321 C 1/03 198,000 199,903 197,703 1.0111 REGAL PARK L 383 163324 C 10/02 197,000 200,137 198,477 1.0084 WESTCHESTER PARK L 490 166355 C 1/03 120,000 75,691 119,820 .6317 WESTCHESTER PARK L 506 166371 C 2/03 76,500 53,123 76,155 .6976 WESTCHESTER PARK L 517 166382 C 1/03 132,065 111,111 131,867 .8426 WESTCHESTER PARK L 523 166388 C 1/03 101,897 103,674 101,744 1.0190 SHADOW HILLS L 323 166441 C 9/02 87,893 87,863 88,816 .9893 SHADOW HILLS L 324 166442 C 9/02 109,797 125,824 110,950 1.1341 SHADOW HILLS L 332 166450 C 7/02 104,067 104,553 105,784 .9884 SHADOW HILLS L 335 166453 C 6/02 129,717 120,298 132,246 .9096 SHADOW HILLS L 339 166457 C 7/02 94,886 93,872 96,452 .9733 SHADOW HILLS L 340 166458 C 9/02 90,926 89,622 91,881 .9754 SHADOW HILLS L 358 166476 C 1/03 78,750 71,526 78,632 .9096 SHADOW HILLS L 360 166478 C 7/02 107,914 106,639 109,695 .9721 SHADOW HILLS L 361 166479 C 10/02 135,000 139,199 136,012 1.0234 SHADOW HILLS L 364 166482 C 8/02 124,812 118,555 126,497 .9372 SHADOW HILLS L 365 166483 C 8/02 90,500 88,751 91,721 .9676 SHADOW HILLS L 366 166484 C 8/02 111,150 111,149 112,651 .9867 SHADOW HILLS L 381 166499 C 9/02 95,425 100,652 96,427 1.0438 SHADOW HILLS L 383 166501 C 7/02 93,634 99,214 95,179 1.0424 SHADOW HILLS L 385 166503 C 10/02 94,850 101,984 95,561 1.0672 MONTEREY L 121 167019 C 3/03 118,550 91,243 117,661 .7755 PAPALOTE SOUTH L 65A 169292 C 2/03 261,000 189,638 259,825 .7299 PARK LORRAINE L 226 25762 C 6/02 60,000 67,783 61,170 1.1081 PARK LORRAINE L 233 25951 C 12/02 65,000 69,746 65,098 1.0714 PARK LORRAINE L 242 26177 C 1/03 70,000 58,468 69,895 .8365 BLK JS SEC 19 AB 363 TR 16 REE 26935 C 2/03 65,000 72,775 64,708 1.1247 WOLFFORTH ACS BLK 5 L 6 & 7 27666 C 5/02 30,000 39,892 30,675 1.3005 PARK LORRAINE L 303 27775 C 3/03 70,000 68,182 69,475 .9814 PARK LORRAINE L 316 28131 C 8/02 68,500 73,653 69,424 1.0609 CASEY #4 BLK 6 L 3 & 4 29448 C 7/02 49,950 48,173 50,774 .9488 WESTWOOD L 104-A 30716 C 11/02 183,500 175,033 184,326 .9496 WESTWOOD L 107-A 30813 C 8/02 157,000 182,008 159,119 1.1438 WESTWOOD L 117 31058 C 6/02 212,500 207,124 216,644 .9561

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 31 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-907 Frenship CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ WESTWOOD L 84 33451 C 6/02 375,000 386,668 382,312 1.0114 REGAL PARK L 41 34047 C 9/02 229,000 216,803 231,404 .9369 REGAL PARK L 44 34116 C 11/02 198,000 180,460 198,891 .9073 REGAL PARK L 49 34268 C 6/02 142,000 142,768 144,769 .9862 PARK LORRAINE TR C-6 34609 C 9/02 62,500 55,556 63,156 .8797 REVIER FARM L 46 34778 C 7/02 58,750 58,750 59,719 .9838 REVIER FARM L 51 34904 C 6/02 68,000 73,126 69,326 1.0548 BLK AK SEC 30 AB 1421 TR 2 PEC 35226 C 6/02 133,500 107,980 136,103 .7934 BLK AK SEC 30 AB 1421 TR 3 PEC 35257 C 9/02 150,000 157,926 151,575 1.0419 REGENCY PARK L 12-A 35348 C 8/02 230,000 234,914 233,105 1.0078 REGENCY PARK L 25 35763 C 6/02 159,900 153,059 163,018 .9389 REGENCY PARK L 26 35793 C 8/02 265,000 286,074 268,577 1.0651 REVIER FARM L 81 35802 C 6/02 64,900 65,870 66,165 .9955 REGENCY PARK L 29 35890 C 6/02 275,000 275,000 280,362 .9809 REGENCY PARK L 44 36308 C 5/02 202,000 202,000 206,545 .9780 SOUTH FRENSHIP HTS L 9 36519 C 10/02 52,900 52,771 53,296 .9901 REVIER FARM L 111 36686 C 3/03 72,000 63,811 71,460 .8930 BLK AK SEC 30 AB 1421 W142'TR 36691 C 4/02 345,000 382,529 353,797 1.0812 BLK AK SEC 30 AB 1421 TR G PEC 36735 C 8/02 140,000 130,182 141,890 .9175 REVIER FARM L 168 38264 C 2/03 72,000 78,355 71,676 1.0932 REVIER FARM L 187 38748 C 12/02 85,900 77,035 86,028 .8955 REVIER FARM L 188 38775 C 3/03 85,500 70,684 84,858 .8330 WEST END PL ANX BLK 6 L 2 38817 C 5/02 57,000 56,650 58,283 .9720 REVIER FARM L 220 39609 C 8/02 89,000 74,761 90,202 .8288 WEST END PL BLK 9 L 10 44744 C 2/03 48,000 58,000 47,784 1.2138 WESTCHESTER PARK L 58 46721 C 5/02 101,500 105,936 103,784 1.0207 WEST END PL BLK 15 E/2 OF L 5 46760 C 12/02 61,000 58,228 61,092 .9531 PHEASANT RUN L 380 49003 C 8/02 162,000 162,459 164,187 .9895 PHEASANT RUN L 383 49079 C 9/02 134,500 131,017 135,912 .9640 RIDGE WOOD L 86 50607 C 7/02 49,950 49,223 50,774 .9694 RIDGE WOOD L 146 52273 C 11/02 69,500 66,898 69,812 .9582 RIDGE WOOD L 158 52637 C 5/02 57,950 57,080 59,254 .9633 PHEASANT RUN L 315 52988 C 3/03 129,500 130,624 128,529 1.0163 STONEGATE L 251 53311 C 5/02 103,500 113,937 105,829 1.0766 PARK LORRAINE L 47 53513 C 9/02 61,500 49,046 62,145 .7892 BLK JS SEC 16 AB 903 TR 4 PLOT 53609 C 11/02 64,000 50,629 64,288 .7875 RIDGEWOOD II L 29 53693 C 2/03 62,000 60,090 61,721 .9736 STONEGATE L 301 54760 C 5/02 104,000 109,475 106,340 1.0295 WOLFFORTH HTS L 92 59209 C 10/02 58,450 50,063 58,888 .8501 SAGEWOOD L 27-A 59436 C 1/03 115,000 103,242 114,827 .8991 PHEASANT RUN L 216 60467 C 5/02 147,000 148,371 150,307 .9871 STONEGATE L 68 64054 C 11/02 78,500 77,692 78,853 .9853 WEST VIEW L 59 64551 C 6/02 87,000 79,358 88,697 .8947 PHEASANT RUN L 157 69949 C 9/02 114,000 108,071 115,197 .9381 PHEASANT RUN L 160 70026 C 10/02 104,000 105,001 104,780 1.0021 CROWS NEST L 12-A 70597 C 5/02 66,500 67,062 67,996 .9863 PHEASANT RUN L 185-A 70786 C 1/03 121,000 119,558 120,818 .9896

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 32 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-907 Frenship CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ WEST SIDE L 12 72395 C 11/02 60,000 57,496 60,270 .9540 WEST SIDE L 19 72623 C 7/02 66,900 66,900 68,003 .9838 STONEGATE L 351 73719 C 3/03 109,500 97,668 108,679 .8987 CROWS NEST L 15-B 74085 C 9/02 59,950 52,131 60,579 .8605 WEST SIDE L 72 74261 C 6/02 70,500 70,903 71,874 .9865 WEST SIDE L 81 74528 C 6/02 72,000 70,415 73,404 .9593 WEST SIDE L 101 75104 C 6/02 64,000 57,920 65,248 .8877 PHEASANT RUN L 77 80574 C 5/02 141,000 141,000 144,172 .9780 PHEASANT RUN L 123 82032 C 6/02 136,000 136,257 138,652 .9827 BLK D6 SEC 20 AB 879 TR 35A CO 84128 C 5/02 75,900 70,970 77,607 .9145 STONEGATE L 136 85103 C 9/02 95,000 87,381 95,998 .9102 STONEGATE L 143 85320 C 12/02 89,000 87,856 89,134 .9857 STONEGATE L 178 86405 C 6/02 84,500 78,696 86,147 .9135 WEST VIEW L 63 88337 C 7/02 111,900 115,388 113,746 1.0144 BROOKMEADE L 32 88359 C 11/02 94,000 95,531 94,423 1.0117 PHEASANT RUN L 268 91596 C 4/02 140,000 132,903 143,570 .9257 PHEASANT RUN L 282 91956 C 9/02 128,000 134,821 129,344 1.0423 AMERICAN PARK L 42 94476 C 6/02 44,000 54,759 44,858 1.2207 SHADOW HILLS L 198-A 97951 C 4/02 86,000 79,807 88,193 .9049 SHADOW HILLS L 52 98673 C 4/02 104,500 111,968 107,165 1.0448 SHADOW HILLS L 59 98870 C 3/03 112,500 109,782 111,656 .9832 256 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9621 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ PARK LORRAINE L 179 137923 C 8/02 94,000 82,824 94,000 .8811 SHADOW HILLS VILLAS L 68 146930 C 4/03 82,500 65,447 82,500 .7933 SHADOW HILLS VILLAS L 69 146931 C 4/03 82,500 65,447 82,500 .7933 PARK LORRAINE L 323 28313 C 4/03 184,000 81,823 184,000 .4447 CROWS NEST L 25-B-1 58614 C 3/03 72,500 71,678 72,500 .9887 STONEGATE L 1 61962 C 1/03 123,500 106,440 123,500 .8619 6 SALES

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 33 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-907 Frenship CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD APPR TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER MOD OBS VALUE APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ JPI TR A 146318 1.00 .00 10,731,330 10,833,843 .9900 BENNETT-BARNES LOT 1 33355 1.00 .00 5,646,837 5,722,924 .9900 SUMMER PLACE LOT 2 & 3 33837 1.00 .00 1,707,143 1,593,751 1.0700 SUMMER PLACE LOT 4-6 33860 1.00 .00 3,615,605 3,743,132 .9700 ALLIANCE ACRES TR A 69126 1.00 .00 2,557,762 2,294,156 1.1100 CROSSROADS LOT 1 89258 1.00 .00 6,760,551 6,723,119 1.0100 SAGEWOOD TR A. B & D 89645 1.00 .00 6,302,584 6,188,253 1.0200 SHADOW HILLS TR D & TRS F2 - F 93259 1.00 .00 11,444,862 11,331,293 1.0100 SHADOW HILLS LOT 1 97318 1.00 .00 137,644 136,949 1.0100 9 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO WITH EXCEPTIONS: .9424 CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ STRONG DAVIS TR A 104647 C 1/02 250,000 244,237 250,000 .9769 PINE GROVE ESTATES E/PT TR A A 109445 C 6/02 700,000 762,238 700,000 1.0889 SPUR 327 BUSINESS PARK L 1 128812 C 8/02 625,000 573,325 625,000 .9173 BLK AK SEC 42 AB 1262 TR 3 KIL 138061 C 2/02 315,000 305,670 315,000 .9704 BLK AK SEC 30 AB 1421 TR K2A A 139421 C 7/02 215,000 220,624 215,000 1.0262 SPUR 327 BUSINESS PARK L 20 154202 C 1/03 220,000 237,938 220,000 1.0815 HERON DEVELOPMENT L 4 156091 C 12/02 550,000 560,535 550,000 1.0192 CAMELOT L 3B 168666 C 12/02 410,000 409,176 410,000 .9980 SOUTHWEST COMM PARK TR E-6 33227 C 1/02 265,000 247,805 265,000 .9351 CROWS NEST TR C-1 71423 C 1/02 250,000 233,491 250,000 .9340 WESTVIEW COMM AREA L 38 85412 C 3/02 72,500 102,245 72,500 1.4103 CARAVAN TR F 89897 C 1/02 135,000 200,056 135,000 1.4819 12 SALES

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 34 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-907 Frenship CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ FRANKFORD BUSINESS PARK L 1 128587 .00 1.00 .00 1,393,469 1,330,107 1.0500 TERRA ESTATE NORTH TR A-1 129002 .00 1.00 .00 793,518 799,068 .9900 BLK AK SEC 31 AB 243 TR 8 131145 .00 1.00 .00 274,034 237,019 1.1600 LUSKEY TR A 150038 .00 1.00 .00 714,999 744,362 .9600 HILLD N129.8' X W232.42 OF TR 164465 .00 1.00 .00 1,040,000 1,111,246 .9400 SANTE FE PARK L 8 63221 .00 1.00 .00 327,837 317,046 1.0300 SPUR 327 AUTOPLEX TR A 71074 .00 1.00 .00 3,770,101 3,607,632 1.0500 SPUR 327 AUTOPLEX TR B 71103 .00 1.00 .00 2,866,081 2,741,373 1.0500 WEST 82ND COMM PARK L 41A 42 & 77247 .00 1.00 .00 511,049 506,908 1.0100 WOMBLE TR A & B 77495 .00 1.00 .00 2,343,591 2,238,167 1.0500 CROSSROADS L 6 88259 .00 1.00 .00 724,464 645,775 1.1200 SEWEL TR A 92683 .00 1.00 .00 2,238,600 2,273,390 .9800 12 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0250 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ SAMS 104140 7,653,948 7,746,913 .9900 D & L MASONRY 109093 393,336 387,420 1.0200 AMERICAN BANK OF COMMERCE 110247 700,174 692,940 1.0100 B & R PLUMBING 113095 147,203 150,166 .9800 LOWERY PLUMBING 119450 263,630 274,602 .9600 FRONTIER DODGE 123606 436,891 446,245 .9800 NICHOLS TILLAGE 131997 611,837 614,858 1.0000 REYNA FINANCIAL 145200 144,835 137,081 1.0600 MODULE TRUCKS SYSTEMS 146577 77,175 75,995 1.0200 SATURN GOLF 148079 100,000 99,999 1.0000 KINGS HIGHWAY 148313 389,000 375,895 1.0300 LUSKEYS 151672 203,772 202,143 1.0100 PARTS WAREHOUSE 152093 52,875 52,821 1.0000 CREATIVE LEARNING CENTER 153696 61,000 58,795 1.0400 UNITED 161793 4,778,954 4,784,100 1.0000 D L PETERSON 163794 441,407 399,795 1.1000 FORD MOTOR CREDIT CO 164847 20,617 21,495 .9600 CULLIGAN WATER 55369 263,802 264,784 1.0000 STEPHEN JOSEPH 60343 525,901 548,732 .9600 BIG STATE TIRE 71584 2,365,079 2,355,254 1.0000 FRANK BROWN 77172 519,814 516,115 1.0100 SOUTH PLAINS REPRODUCTION 78908 87,371 81,877 1.0700 AMERICAN STATE BANK 80997 19,440 21,197 .9200 23 APPRAISALS

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 35 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-907 Frenship STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0052