Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   1/22/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:     19
TIME:     15:40                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             152  Lubbock
                                                         152-906  Lubbock-Cooper

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  RIDGEVIEW ESTATES L 76           109487                     C       4/02        120,000         120,590       126,120     .9562
  RIDGEVIEW ESTATES L 86           109887                     C       6/02        143,171         147,220       148,755     .9897
  COUNTRY ESTATES L 45             110325                     C      11/02         95,000          95,475        95,855     .9960
  COUNTRY ESTATES L 50 & 51        110533                     C      12/02         80,000         102,689        80,240    1.2798
  WEST LAKE ESTATES L 3            115815                     C      10/02        208,000         196,762       211,120     .9320
  WEST LAKE ESTATES L 5            115859                     C      10/02        255,000         250,162       258,825     .9665
  WEST LAKE ESTATES L 11           116019                     C       2/03        225,000         231,426       222,975    1.0379
  WEST LAKE ESTATES L 30           116517                     C       5/02        320,000         325,165       334,400     .9724
  BLK E SEC 7 AB 48 TR C3A ACS:    118165                     C       9/02         42,000          37,464        42,882     .8737
  INDIANA SOUTH ESTATES L 11-12    118175                     C       6/02        650,000         644,983       675,350     .9550
  BLK AK SEC 9 AB 161 TR 11A ACS   119725                     C      12/02         85,000          81,640        85,255     .9576
  SLIDE PARK TR 16                 124344                     C       5/02        210,000         211,954       219,450     .9658
  BLK 20 SEC 102 AB 1573 TR 8A O   131776                     C       4/02         85,000          75,889        89,335     .8495
  TUMBLEWEED PASS ESTATES L 8      138251                     C       7/02        178,000         178,000       183,874     .9681
  HIGHLAND GARDENS L 20            142696                     C      11/02        123,450         113,723       124,561     .9130
  HIGHLAND GARDENS L 28            142704                     C       6/02        115,000         114,999       119,485     .9625
  HIGHLAND GARDENS L 30            142706                     C      12/02        127,000         113,958       127,381     .8946
  HIGHLAND GARDENS L 40            142716                     C       5/02        144,000         172,748       150,480    1.1480
  HIGHLAND GARDENS L 46            142722                     C      11/02        137,776         137,776       139,016     .9911
  HIGHLAND GARDENS L 47            142723                     C      11/02        129,000         117,305       130,161     .9012
  HIGHLAND GARDENS L 48            142724                     C       4/02        133,000         142,992       139,783    1.0230
  HIGHLAND GARDENS L 54            142730                     C      12/02        184,500         158,886       185,053     .8586
  HIGHLAND GARDENS L 58            142734                     C       2/03        145,000         145,164       143,695    1.0102
  HIGHLAND GARDENS L 63            142739                     C       8/02        132,000         141,330       135,564    1.0425
  HIGHLAND GARDENS L 77            142753                     C       5/02        143,000         153,000       149,435    1.0239
  HIGHLAND GARDENS L 80            142756                     C       8/02        158,000         147,970       162,266     .9119
  HIGHLAND GARDENS L 88            142764                     C       8/02        147,000         143,696       150,969     .9518
  KEMPER ESTATES L 13              147047                     C       9/02        402,000         364,095       410,442     .8871
  SUNRIDGE L 3                     147667                     C       5/02        169,900         171,230       177,545     .9644
  SUNRIDGE L 8                     147672                     C       7/02        231,500         235,964       239,139     .9867
  SUNRIDGE L 13                    147677                     C      10/02        212,000         212,000       215,180     .9852
  SOUTHHAVEN L 12                  148113                     C       3/03        225,000         271,679       221,625    1.2258
  SOUTHHAVEN L 22                  148123                     C      10/02        217,500         217,499       220,762     .9852
  SOUTHHAVEN L 29                  148130                     C       5/02        197,500         220,181       206,387    1.0668
  SOUTHHAVEN L 31                  148132                     C       9/02        270,000         267,152       275,670     .9691
  SOUTHHAVEN L 38                  148139                     C       8/02        178,300         219,649       183,114    1.1995
  SOUTHHAVEN L 39                  148140                     C       5/02        225,000         221,254       235,125     .9410
  SOUTHHAVEN L 41                  148142                     C      10/02        285,000         285,311       289,275     .9863
  SOUTHHAVEN L 49                  148150                     C       1/03        289,900         289,899       289,030    1.0030
  MEADOWS SOUTH L 43               150070                     C       5/02        132,950         117,691       138,933     .8471
  MEADOWS SOUTH L 45               150072                     C      12/02        119,000         123,375       119,357    1.0337
  MEADOWS SOUTH L 56               150083                     C       6/02        127,000         119,454       131,953     .9053
  MEADOWS SOUTH L 71               150089                     C       4/02        126,000         128,089       132,426     .9672
  MEADOWS SOUTH L 9                150091                     C      12/02        129,000         124,920       129,387     .9655
  MEADOWS SOUTH L 21               150098                     C      11/02        133,000         121,597       134,197     .9061
  MEADOWS SOUTH L 66               150109                     C      11/02        118,500         114,200       119,566     .9551
  SUNRIDGE L 64A                   150163                     C      10/02        200,000         187,516       203,000     .9237

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 20 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-906 Lubbock-Cooper CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ SUNRIDGE L 66A 150165 C 4/02 177,000 173,693 186,027 .9337 SUNRIDGE L 76 150550 C 4/02 174,950 175,822 183,872 .9562 SUNRIDGE L 91 150555 C 2/03 265,000 195,973 262,615 .7462 SUNRIDGE L 97 150569 C 6/02 160,000 159,932 166,240 .9621 SUNRIDGE L 116 150595 C 5/02 149,900 149,900 156,645 .9569 SUNRIDGE L 126 150601 C 3/03 182,500 166,234 179,762 .9247 SUNRIDGE L 129 150604 C 3/03 165,400 157,423 162,919 .9663 SOUTHHAVEN L 55 151032 C 6/02 260,000 259,006 270,140 .9588 SOUTHHAVEN L 59 151036 C 10/02 256,000 245,489 259,840 .9448 SOUTHHAVEN L 60 151037 C 12/02 257,950 239,977 258,724 .9275 SOUTHHAVEN L 68 151045 C 7/02 244,000 244,000 252,052 .9681 SOUTHHAVEN L 92 151088 C 9/02 266,814 280,236 272,417 1.0287 SUNRISE ESTATES L 15 154218 C 1/03 69,000 62,841 68,793 .9135 SUNRISE ESTATES L 29 154232 C 4/02 69,500 67,105 73,045 .9187 SUNRISE ESTATES L 34 154237 C 1/03 72,900 74,891 72,681 1.0304 SUNRISE ESTATES L 36 154239 C 6/02 73,000 65,052 75,847 .8577 SUNRISE ESTATES L 50 154253 C 3/03 72,500 69,066 71,413 .9671 SUNRISE ESTATES L 52 154255 C 5/02 62,500 69,020 65,313 1.0568 STONEBROOK L 8 154734 C 1/03 94,500 100,801 94,217 1.0699 STONEBROOK L 12 154738 C 10/02 109,000 111,145 110,635 1.0046 STONEBROOK L 13 154739 C 5/02 115,000 102,911 120,175 .8563 STONEBROOK L 24 154750 C 7/02 125,000 126,371 129,125 .9787 STONEBROOK L 48 154774 C 8/02 151,500 144,723 155,590 .9302 STONEBROOK L 56 154782 C 2/03 143,663 113,614 142,370 .7980 STONEBROOK L 63 154789 C 4/02 145,000 145,000 152,395 .9515 STONEBROOK L 66 154792 C 4/02 144,800 165,963 152,184 1.0905 STONEBROOK L 74 154800 C 9/02 140,255 139,658 143,200 .9753 SANDY MARIAH ESTATES L 30 155113 C 12/02 224,900 225,290 225,574 .9987 SOUTHHAVEN L 105 155465 C 10/02 242,500 257,601 246,137 1.0466 SOUTHHAVEN L 120 155480 C 4/02 270,000 269,040 283,770 .9481 MEADOWS SOUTH L 73 156276 C 8/02 129,000 130,339 132,483 .9838 MEADOWS SOUTH L 81 156285 C 10/02 145,000 136,191 147,175 .9254 MEADOWS SOUTH L 83 156287 C 6/02 137,000 134,368 142,343 .9440 MEADOWS SOUTH L 103 156307 C 4/02 130,000 135,291 136,630 .9902 MEADOWS SOUTH L 127 156330 C 5/02 124,950 128,164 130,573 .9816 MEADOWS SOUTH L 141 156346 C 4/02 132,950 140,874 139,730 1.0082 SUNRISE ESTATES L 77 158695 C 12/02 82,900 78,168 83,149 .9401 SUNRISE ESTATES L 78 158696 C 7/02 78,500 73,982 81,091 .9123 SUNRISE ESTATES L 80 158698 C 10/02 82,500 76,804 83,738 .9172 SUNRISE ESTATES L 101 158719 C 5/02 70,700 70,104 73,882 .9489 SUNRISE ESTATES L 111 158729 C 6/02 74,000 69,842 76,886 .9084 SUNRISE ESTATES L 113 158731 C 6/02 73,400 69,842 76,263 .9158 SUNRISE ESTATES L 119 158737 C 8/02 67,500 69,384 69,323 1.0009 SUNRISE ESTATES L 122 158740 C 4/02 70,850 69,384 74,463 .9318 SUNRISE ESTATES L 123 158741 C 5/02 68,900 69,384 72,001 .9637 SUNRISE ESTATES L 124 158742 C 7/02 67,450 69,384 69,675 .9958 SUNRISE ESTATES L 125 158743 C 6/02 70,700 69,608 73,457 .9476

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 21 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-906 Lubbock-Cooper CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ SUNRISE ESTATES L 126 158744 C 5/02 69,900 69,291 73,046 .9486 SUNRISE ESTATES L 127 158745 C 6/02 69,450 69,291 72,158 .9603 SUNRISE ESTATES L 129 158747 C 2/03 91,924 94,211 91,097 1.0342 SUNRISE ESTATES L 130 158748 C 6/02 71,700 76,946 74,496 1.0329 SUNRISE ESTATES L 131 158749 C 1/03 91,000 93,073 90,727 1.0259 SUNRISE ESTATES L 133 158751 C 8/02 67,500 70,901 69,323 1.0228 SUNRISE ESTATES L 134 158752 C 4/02 71,700 71,116 75,357 .9437 SUNRIDGE L 138 158775 C 7/02 165,500 177,732 170,961 1.0396 SUNRIDGE L 141 158778 C 5/02 158,000 155,762 165,110 .9434 SUNRIDGE L 157 158794 C 4/02 163,000 180,656 171,313 1.0545 WINDSOR PARK L 3 158842 C 3/03 155,500 101,652 153,167 .6637 WINDSOR PARK L 10 158849 C 12/02 165,000 161,129 165,495 .9736 WINDSOR PARK L 19 158858 C 7/02 279,900 297,663 289,136 1.0295 WINDSOR PARK L 33 158872 C 12/02 279,950 273,409 280,790 .9737 WINDSOR PARK L 61 158900 C 2/03 182,000 133,621 180,362 .7408 HIGHLAND OAKS L 22 158955 C 3/03 575,000 568,108 566,375 1.0031 HIGHLAND OAKS L 43 158976 C 5/02 235,000 236,518 245,575 .9631 HIGHLAND OAKS L 45 158978 C 2/03 350,000 333,377 346,850 .9612 HIGHLAND OAKS L 62 158995 C 3/03 300,000 246,161 295,500 .8330 HIGHLAND OAKS L 65 158998 C 11/02 247,650 216,052 249,879 .8646 HIGHLAND OAKS L 67 159000 C 6/02 430,000 427,787 446,770 .9575 KEMPER ESTATES L 32 159130 C 8/02 355,000 354,999 364,585 .9737 KEMPER ESTATES L 45 159144 C 9/02 223,841 223,842 228,542 .9794 KEMPER ESTATES L 53 159152 C 10/02 378,800 378,864 384,482 .9854 KINGS RIDGE L 11 159202 C 7/02 182,000 139,388 188,006 .7414 SOUTHHAVEN L 141 159558 C 12/02 365,000 371,380 366,095 1.0144 SOUTHHAVEN L 150 161449 C 1/03 333,750 249,018 332,749 .7484 SOUTHHAVEN L 155 161454 C 11/02 279,900 272,009 282,419 .9631 SOUTHHAVEN L 170 161469 C 9/02 239,500 239,500 244,529 .9794 SOUTHHAVEN L 171 161470 C 9/02 203,700 203,699 207,977 .9794 SOUTHHAVEN L 178 161477 C 10/02 365,000 339,929 370,475 .9175 SOUTHHAVEN L 180 161479 C 9/02 298,000 284,243 304,258 .9342 SOUTHHAVEN L 181 161480 C 9/02 290,000 277,316 296,090 .9366 SOUTHHAVEN L 182 161481 C 10/02 355,000 348,182 360,325 .9663 SOUTHHAVEN L 183 161482 C 6/02 400,000 341,951 415,600 .8228 SOUTHHAVEN L 184 161483 C 6/02 287,000 288,863 298,193 .9687 SOUTHHAVEN L 185 161484 C 12/02 298,800 297,017 299,696 .9911 SOUTHHAVEN L 200 161499 C 2/03 156,000 169,999 154,596 1.0996 SUNCREST L 9 161966 C 3/03 185,500 182,574 182,717 .9992 SUNCREST L 10 161967 C 2/03 169,900 178,860 168,370 1.0623 SUNCREST L 30 161987 C 10/02 192,000 183,315 194,880 .9407 SUNCREST L 32 161989 C 9/02 146,270 150,628 149,342 1.0086 SUNCREST L 37 161994 C 11/02 177,000 174,798 178,593 .9788 SUNCREST L 38 161995 C 5/02 221,411 226,015 231,374 .9768 SUNCREST L 42 161999 C 3/03 159,000 150,349 156,615 .9600 SUNCREST L 84 162041 C 2/03 150,000 143,942 148,650 .9683 SUNCREST L 91 162048 C 3/03 200,000 165,215 197,000 .8387

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 22 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-906 Lubbock-Cooper CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ SUNCREST L 94 162051 C 8/02 181,350 186,657 186,246 1.0022 SUNCREST L 96 162053 C 8/02 160,000 160,000 164,320 .9737 SUNCREST L 99 162056 C 8/02 172,350 171,310 177,003 .9678 STONEBROOK L 102 162096 C 4/02 114,950 112,369 120,812 .9301 STONEBROOK L 103 162097 C 9/02 115,890 107,209 118,324 .9061 STONEBROOK L 104 162098 C 9/02 115,950 106,480 118,385 .8994 STONEBROOK L 105 162099 C 9/02 119,500 106,209 122,009 .8705 STONEBROOK L 120 162114 C 3/03 134,500 125,579 132,482 .9479 STONEBROOK L 131 162125 C 8/02 133,750 128,541 137,361 .9358 STONEBROOK L 152A 162146 C 10/02 161,400 149,262 163,821 .9111 STONEBROOK L 158 162152 C 10/02 99,500 115,482 100,992 1.1435 STONEBROOK L 161 162208 C 9/02 87,500 96,921 89,338 1.0849 STONEBROOK L 165 162229 C 12/02 123,000 102,576 123,369 .8315 STONEBROOK L 167 162231 C 1/03 99,820 101,405 99,520 1.0189 STONEBROOK L 174 162238 C 8/02 131,375 130,862 134,922 .9699 STONEBROOK L 178 162242 C 7/02 116,667 132,371 120,517 1.0984 STONEBROOK L 181 162245 C 8/02 120,501 120,501 123,755 .9737 STONEBROOK L 183 162247 C 9/02 134,000 133,404 136,814 .9751 STONEBROOK L 196 162260 C 7/02 122,675 122,675 126,723 .9681 STONEBROOK L 205 162269 C 11/02 159,000 160,848 160,431 1.0026 SUNRISE ESTATES L 146A 162633 C 8/02 84,500 76,238 86,782 .8785 SUNRISE ESTATES L 152A 162639 C 5/02 83,500 84,327 87,258 .9664 SUNRISE ESTATES L 156A 162643 C 11/02 86,705 85,875 87,485 .9816 SUNRISE ESTATES L 158A 162645 C 11/02 85,000 76,162 85,765 .8880 SUNRISE ESTATES L 159A 162646 C 7/02 90,000 81,676 92,970 .8785 SUNRISE ESTATES L 161A 162648 C 2/03 82,000 78,818 81,262 .9699 SUNRISE ESTATES L 162A 162649 C 5/02 82,999 79,288 86,734 .9142 SUNRISE ESTATES L 164A 162651 C 11/02 89,900 79,807 90,709 .8798 SUNRISE ESTATES L 167A 162654 C 4/02 81,300 81,281 85,446 .9513 SUNRISE ESTATES L 168A 162655 C 4/02 81,500 77,876 85,657 .9092 SUNRISE ESTATES L 177 162664 C 5/02 81,500 84,759 85,168 .9952 SUNRISE ESTATES L 190 162677 C 8/02 69,000 65,104 70,863 .9187 SUNRISE ESTATES L 195 162682 C 9/02 87,800 76,591 89,644 .8544 SUNRISE ESTATES L 196 162683 C 11/02 82,500 78,363 83,243 .9414 SUNRISE ESTATES L 198 162685 C 12/02 87,000 74,905 87,261 .8584 SUNRIDGE L 168 162841 C 1/03 154,000 142,160 153,538 .9259 SUNRIDGE L 171 162844 C 6/02 155,000 166,024 161,045 1.0309 MEADOWS SOUTH L 175 167261 C 10/02 124,100 134,035 125,961 1.0641 MEADOWS SOUTH L 189 167275 C 10/02 135,900 134,095 137,938 .9721 MEADOWS SOUTH L 194 167280 C 1/03 130,950 131,002 130,557 1.0034 MEADOWS SOUTH L 195 167281 C 10/02 128,950 129,568 130,884 .9899 MEADOWS SOUTH L 200 167286 C 8/02 148,300 139,556 152,304 .9163 MEADOWS SOUTH L 206 167292 C 12/02 132,500 132,500 132,897 .9970 MEADOWS SOUTH L 210 167296 C 3/03 147,950 138,580 145,731 .9509 MEADOWS SOUTH L 211 167297 C 11/02 135,660 125,055 136,881 .9136 MEADOWS SOUTH L 213 167299 C 12/02 125,000 135,861 125,375 1.0836 MEADOWS SOUTH L 214 167300 C 12/02 140,000 134,985 140,420 .9613

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 23 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-906 Lubbock-Cooper CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ MEADOWS SOUTH L 233 167319 C 2/03 111,000 91,722 110,001 .8338 SUNRISE ESTATES L 201 167385 C 1/03 81,500 78,971 81,256 .9719 SUNRISE ESTATES L 202 167387 C 10/02 90,000 83,885 91,350 .9183 SUNRISE ESTATES L 205 167390 C 1/03 88,000 84,393 87,736 .9619 SUNRISE ESTATES L 209 167394 C 3/03 85,000 79,138 83,725 .9452 SUNRISE ESTATES L 215 167400 C 8/02 75,900 72,983 77,949 .9363 SUNRISE ESTATES L 216 167401 C 8/02 78,000 72,983 80,106 .9111 SUNRISE ESTATES L 217 167402 C 8/02 79,500 72,983 81,647 .8939 SUNRISE ESTATES L 218 167403 C 9/02 81,000 72,983 82,701 .8825 SUNRISE ESTATES L 219 167404 C 8/02 77,850 72,983 79,951 .9128 SUNRISE ESTATES L 220 167405 C 9/02 75,900 74,133 77,494 .9566 SUNRISE ESTATES L 235 167420 C 12/02 81,000 73,360 81,243 .9030 SUNRISE ESTATES L 237 167422 C 11/02 77,800 73,360 78,500 .9345 SUNRISE ESTATES L 238 167423 C 11/02 77,400 73,360 78,097 .9393 SUNRISE ESTATES L 239 167424 C 11/02 77,400 73,353 78,097 .9393 SUNRISE ESTATES L 242 167427 C 11/02 79,200 73,353 79,913 .9179 SUNRISE ESTATES L 243 167428 C 12/02 78,400 73,360 78,635 .9329 SUNRISE ESTATES L 244 167429 C 12/02 77,400 73,360 77,632 .9450 KINGS RIDGE L 15 167702 C 3/03 185,000 118,098 182,225 .6481 LAKEVIEW HTS L 101 & 102 35487 C 1/03 165,000 154,782 164,505 .9409 BLK AK SEC 3 AB 188 TR 61 OF N 36980 C 2/03 249,000 248,238 246,759 1.0060 BLK AK SEC 3 AB 188 TR 98 OF N 39999 C 4/02 235,000 235,000 246,985 .9515 PUTTY VIRGINIA LOU L 12 46632 C 4/02 35,000 33,471 36,785 .9099 SUN COUNTRY L 47 70473 C 6/02 30,000 44,835 31,170 1.4384 SUN COUNTRY L 70 71315 C 4/02 64,000 46,445 67,264 .6905 HIGH COUNTRY L 14 72732 C 3/03 102,000 106,272 100,470 1.0577 HIGH COUNTRY L 21 72951 C 6/02 116,500 108,387 121,043 .8954 HIGH COUNTRY L 35 73408 C 4/02 118,000 109,230 124,018 .8808 HIGH COUNTRY L 41 73584 C 9/02 117,500 109,809 119,967 .9153 HIGH COUNTRY L 43 73638 C 3/03 106,016 105,499 104,426 1.0103 HIGH COUNTRY L 65 74338 C 8/02 95,000 86,329 97,565 .8848 HIGH COUNTRY L 75 74636 C 10/02 97,500 94,703 98,963 .9570 HIGH COUNTRY L 96 75229 C 10/02 109,900 104,683 111,548 .9385 HIGH COUNTRY L 105 75515 C 11/02 101,000 100,491 101,909 .9861 HIGH COUNTRY L 111 75700 C 8/02 99,000 98,932 101,673 .9730 HIGH COUNTRY L 123 76076 C 5/02 90,000 96,336 94,050 1.0243 HIGH COUNTRY L 159 77178 C 7/02 93,500 101,834 96,586 1.0543 HIGH COUNTRY L 164-A 77355 C 1/03 90,000 90,736 89,730 1.0112 HIGH COUNTRY L 166-A 77408 C 11/02 128,000 127,921 129,152 .9905 HIGH COUNTRY L 214-A 78911 C 2/03 82,000 76,315 81,262 .9391 HIGH COUNTRY L 216-A 78961 C 4/02 94,000 86,826 98,794 .8789 BLK 20 SEC 18 AB 967 TR C5A AC 79110 C 1/03 114,000 70,153 113,658 .6172 HIGH COUNTRY L 221-A 79126 C 6/02 83,500 85,004 86,757 .9798 HIGH COUNTRY L 243-A 79780 C 8/02 90,000 85,874 92,430 .9291 HIGH COUNTRY L 253-A 80077 C 10/02 83,500 76,407 84,753 .9015 HIGH COUNTRY L 262 80349 C 6/02 88,000 87,768 91,432 .9599 HIGH COUNTRY L 266-A 80480 C 6/02 99,500 89,136 103,380 .8622

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 24 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-906 Lubbock-Cooper CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ HIGH COUNTRY L 267-A 80507 C 6/02 91,500 102,464 95,069 1.0778 HIGH COUNTRY L 278-A 80832 C 4/02 79,000 80,363 83,029 .9679 HIGH COUNTRY L 283-A 81010 C 3/03 88,000 79,942 86,680 .9223 HIGH COUNTRY L 293-A 81316 C 4/02 82,000 79,423 86,182 .9216 HIGH COUNTRY L 297-A 81455 C 4/02 87,000 93,316 91,437 1.0205 BLK E SEC 23 AB 1114 TR 89 PRI 86105 C 4/02 79,000 71,473 83,029 .8608 BLK E SEC 20 AB 832 TR C11 AC: 86620 C 9/02 115,000 108,548 117,415 .9245 BLK E2 SEC 24 AB 1331 TR 11 ME 88678 C 9/02 169,000 150,919 172,549 .8746 HAYS ESTATES L 10 93340 C 7/02 199,000 232,874 205,567 1.1328 WINCO TERRACE L 41 97838 C 8/02 72,000 69,848 73,944 .9446 245 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9509 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BLK S SEC 75 AB 299 TR B (W110 102596 C 2/02 110,000 110,000 1.0000 BLK 20 SEC 104 AB 1110 TR 2A5 133159 C 6/02 28,000 38,500 .7273 WEST WOODROW ADD TR 3 140044 C 4/02 195,719 275,000 .7117 BLK 20 SEC 128 AB 1125 TR K4 K 155351 C 3/03 70,680 75,000 .9424 WOODROW COUNTRY ESTATES L 12 157751 C 1/02 7,538 8,000 .9423 SOUTH FLINT ESTATES L 25 159785 C 3/02 25,500 17,000 1.5000 BLK AK SEC 3 AB 188 TR E E1 E2 169351 C 4/02 349,050 485,000 .7197 BLK E SEC 10 AB 493 TR B7 & B1 30798 C 11/02 16,800 22,400 .7500 BLK 20 SEC 128 AB 1125 TR H OF 62097 C 3/02 40,000 60,000 .6667 BLK AK SEC 21 AB 264 TR A AC: 83868 C 8/02 1,357,468 1,178,000 1.1523 BLK E SEC 7 AB 48 TR A2 ACS: 5 89726 C 2/02 142,936 150,000 .9529 BLK E SEC 10 AB 493 TR B14A AC 90091 C 11/02 3,200 22,400 .1429 12 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9613

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 25 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-906 Lubbock-Cooper CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ KINGS GATE TR K 142476 C 6/02 500,000 304,270 500,000 .6085 WESTCOTT L 9 146776 C 9/02 150,000 166,211 150,000 1.1081 BLK AK SEC 8 AB 959 TR E3A1 AC 147802 C 1/02 330,000 317,340 330,000 .9616 SANDY MARIAH ESTATES N/2 TR A 157709 C 2/03 325,000 245,640 325,000 .7558 BLK E SEC 15 AB 39 TR B2A AC: 166209 C 2/02 110,000 144,807 110,000 1.3164 5 SALES CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BLK AK SEC 9 AB 161 TR 15 120674 .00 1.00 .00 343,694 314,093 1.0900 BLK 20 SEC 25 AB 413 TR 4A 120817 .00 1.00 .00 2,354,923 2,156,107 1.0900 BLK E SEC 13 AB 44 TR F3B 147938 .00 1.00 .00 849,982 887,525 .9600 STONEBROOK TR A 155957 .00 1.00 .00 367,923 346,701 1.0600 ROWDEN TR A 163649 .00 1.00 .00 976,504 949,371 1.0300 BLK E SEC 15 AB 39 TR A11C4 7 46851 .00 1.00 .00 348,122 378,786 .9200 BLK E SEC 15 AB 39 TR A5A 54590 .00 1.00 .00 43,710 45,102 .9700 BLK 20 SEC 18 AB 967 TR C5 65085 .00 1.00 .00 65,244 56,020 1.1600 BLK E SEC 15 AB 39 TR 68249 .00 1.00 .00 100,393 104,416 .9600 BLK E SEC 15 AB 39 TR A9E 68311 .00 1.00 .00 95,500 90,098 1.0600 BLK E SEC 17 AB 130 TR 1A OF N 69270 .00 1.00 .00 248,933 250,444 .9900 BLK E SEC 23 AB 1114 TR 28 PRI 84140 .00 1.00 .00 129,951 137,915 .9400 BLK E SEC 10 AB 493 TR C1 PRAT 89125 .00 1.00 .00 41,690 41,905 .9900 BLK E SEC 14 AB 495 TR A5C 91523 .00 1.00 .00 85,143 89,906 .9500 BLK E SEC 13 AB 44 TR B & C 92160 .00 1.00 .00 180,765 195,328 .9300 REYNOLDS SUB L 32 94022 .00 1.00 .00 103,499 92,524 1.1200 BLK E2 SEC 24 AB 1331 TR 3 OF 97369 .00 1.00 .00 200,730 199,044 1.0100 BLK E2 SEC 21 AB 270 TR 5 OF N 97854 .00 1.00 .00 55,283 53,011 1.0400 18 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9806 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ JOHN WEBB MOVERS 137404 25,000 23,495 1.0600 D & DCABLE SERVICES 143342 814,725 860,771 .9500 WASTE SYSTEMS 145348 21,300 20,495 1.0400

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 26 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-906 Lubbock-Cooper CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ TOWN & COUNTRY 147102 160,735 154,570 1.0400 OSHKOSH/MCNEILUS FINANCIAL SER 148233 318,525 297,459 1.0700 PELONNES CONCRETE 153250 162,550 152,848 1.0600 BOLDES TRUCKING 153620 354,025 321,895 1.1000 KCI COMPRESSION VECHILES 153983 25,000 21,795 1.1500 LAMAR ADVERTISING 156838 207,662 201,459 1.0300 BACK TO NATURE 157272 75,315 75,286 1.0000 TAST OF TEXAS 160112 25,000 25,487 .9800 C & R TRANSPORTATION 163660 59,000 61,108 .9700 C & R TRANSPORTATION 163666 259,200 251,489 1.0300 BUTLER CONSTUCTION 31242 867,400 796,471 1.0900 GREENSTREET 39763 152,706 147,171 1.0400 DOC LIQUOR & BEER 42480 828,456 833,346 .9900 CARTER DRILLING 47900 93,604 98,203 .9500 CONCRETE SPECIALTY 53405 33,225 34,927 .9500 A ROCK MATERIALS 56393 123,325 118,106 1.0400 SPARKMANS 77536 401,451 408,775 .9800 LUBBOCK COTTEN GROWERS 92478 397,986 370,049 1.0800 GREAT PLAINS DIST 95729 1,079,135 1,089,679 .9900 22 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0166