Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   1/22/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:      1
TIME:     15:40                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             152  Lubbock
                                                         152-901  Lubbock

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  MURRYHILL L 104                  100963                     C       8/02         89,500          99,774        92,319    1.0807
  STUBBS BLK 28 ANDREWS UNREC L    101708                     C       8/02         23,000          35,176        23,725    1.4827
  FORREST HTS BLK 2 E35'OF L 12&   101826                     C       6/02        157,000         157,000       164,143     .9565
  SIMMONS BLK 4 L 5                101935                     C       4/02         74,500          66,407        78,933     .8413
  SUNNY HILL BLK 20 L 4            102647                     C       5/02         82,500          82,454        86,831     .9496
  LAMAR HTS BLK 5 L 9 & 10         102827                     C       3/03        163,500         163,498       160,639    1.0178
  SUNNY HILL BLK 21 L 13           103384                     C       8/02         75,000          83,628        77,363    1.0810
  APRIL PARK L 48                  103708                     C       6/02         88,950          86,992        92,997     .9354
  APRIL PARK L 56-A-1              103929                     C       2/03         99,500          98,169        98,455     .9971
  SIMMONS BLK 7 L 8                104051                     C       5/02         83,000          68,051        87,358     .7790
  SUNNY HILL BLK 23 L 8            104132                     C      11/02         51,900          59,758        52,444    1.1394
  CARLTON HTS BLK 5 L 33           104486                     C       4/02         53,000          46,573        56,154     .8294
  LANE ACRES L 4                   104574                     C       6/02        285,000         284,999       297,967     .9565
  SUNNY SIDE BLK 2 L 12            105494                     C      11/02         50,000          48,512        50,525     .9602
  MCAFEE HTS BLK 2 L 4             105752                     C       5/02         52,500          51,467        55,256     .9314
  MARTIN BLK 4 L 14                106122                     C      10/02         24,000          37,581        24,420    1.5389
  SUNNY SLOPE BLK 1 E30'OF L 17&   106275                     C       7/02         58,000          70,408        60,233    1.1689
  FORREST HTS BLK 12 W45'OF L3 &   106632                     C       7/02         35,000          35,000        36,348     .9629
  UNIVERSITY PINES L 140           107981                     C       8/02         50,000          51,500        51,575     .9985
  SUNNY SLOPE BLK 5 L 11           108227                     C       4/02         57,500          56,317        60,921     .9244
  SUNNY SLOPE BLK 8 L 2            109600                     C      10/02         60,000          56,900        61,050     .9320
  WHISPERWOOD L 5-B                110161                     C       8/02        155,000         165,299       159,882    1.0339
  REDBUD HTS L 72                  110731                     C      11/02         63,000          63,945        63,662    1.0045
  UNIVERSITY PINES L 253           110983                     C       3/03         65,500          52,932        64,354     .8225
  WHISPERWOOD L 46                 111446                     C       1/03        161,500         145,002       160,935     .9010
  REDBUD HTS L 121                 112036                     C       9/02         76,000          71,074        77,862     .9128
  PIEDMONT BLK 4 L 12              112257                     C       4/02         79,950          81,121        84,707     .9577
  BRENTWOOD PLAZA L 1              116002                     C      10/02        268,000         276,674       272,690    1.0146
  LEFTWICH MONTEREY HTS L 291      116070                     C       9/02         94,000          90,954        96,303     .9445
  BRENTWOOD PLAZA L 4              116076                     C      10/02        235,000         219,616       239,113     .9185
  WEST WIND L 246                  116155                     C       3/03         64,000          80,359        62,880    1.2780
  AVALON BLK 6 L 5                 116339                     C      10/02         86,000          86,601        87,505     .9897
  AVALON BLK 6 L 19                116717                     C      10/02         82,400          87,736        83,842    1.0464
  LEFTWICH MONTEREY HTS L 338      117281                     C       9/02        108,600         109,886       111,260     .9876
  SUNSET HEIGHTS BLK 12 L 10       117719                     C       8/02         50,000          47,846        51,575     .9277
  LAKERIDGE C C EST L 390          118406                     C       4/02        205,000         204,556       217,198     .9418
  URBAN HEIGHTS BLK 2 L 15         118638                     C       1/03         20,000          31,881        19,930    1.5996
  PLAINSMEN L 41                   120385                     C       1/03         60,000          75,564        59,790    1.2638
  BRIERCROFT L 96                  120452                     C      12/02         95,000          98,361        95,333    1.0318
  DEPAUW MCLARTY E60'OF W65'OF L   120526                     C      11/02         51,582          51,722        52,124     .9923
  RICHLAND HILLS L 129             121829                     C       8/02        103,500         103,764       106,760     .9719
  HORIZON WEST L 218               121884                     C       5/02         48,000          70,042        50,520    1.3864
  CENTRAL HTS BLK 5 L 6            122502                     C      12/02        327,500         295,771       328,646     .9000
  HORIZON WEST L 255               122922                     C       2/03         70,000          69,069        69,265     .9972
  PLEASANT HEIGHTS BLK 1 L 2       123361                     C       5/02         65,000          60,272        68,413     .8810
  LISEMBY BLK 4 L 1                123496                     C       6/02         44,000          47,827        46,002    1.0397
  DIXON BEN BLK 2 L 3              124898                     C       2/03         45,000          58,195        44,528    1.3069

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 2 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-901 Lubbock CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ TANGLEWOOD S110'OF L 5 124908 C 8/02 630,000 639,832 649,845 .9846 TANGLEWOOD L 9 LESS SW 7404 SQ 125065 C 10/02 157,500 147,500 160,256 .9204 BROADMOOR L 28 & 29 126307 C 3/03 154,900 132,406 152,189 .8700 MCCULLOCH L 105 126905 C 5/02 38,000 38,000 39,995 .9501 DOLLIE MAC #3 L 43 127582 C 7/02 52,000 53,723 54,002 .9948 TARRYTOWN L 96 127693 C 8/02 61,200 59,458 63,128 .9419 BENT TREE L 121 127892 C 8/02 80,500 73,009 83,036 .8792 SLATON MYRTLE BLK 32 L 41 128586 C 12/02 76,500 72,594 76,768 .9456 SLATON MYRTLE BLK 32 L 43 & W1 128640 C 2/03 62,000 72,070 61,349 1.1748 DOLLIE MAC #7 L 88 128853 C 12/02 41,800 37,292 41,946 .8890 SLATON MYRTLE BLK 32 L 71 128882 C 3/03 79,900 72,695 78,502 .9260 DOLLIE MAC #4 L 107 129393 C 7/02 55,000 54,610 57,118 .9561 KINGS ROW L 27 130004 C 9/02 580,000 575,615 594,210 .9687 KINGS POINT L 9-A 130107 C 1/03 326,000 280,040 324,859 .8620 KINGS GATE L 527 130957 C 12/02 215,000 204,886 215,752 .9496 BENT TREE L 228 131785 C 3/03 89,500 77,362 87,934 .8798 RICHLAND HILLS L 562 131815 C 2/03 73,250 58,527 72,481 .8075 SLIDELL BLK 7 L 6 132549 C 5/02 84,000 82,612 88,410 .9344 BROADMOOR L 322 133238 C 9/02 112,000 107,786 114,744 .9394 BENT TREE L 283 133387 C 4/02 55,250 58,401 58,537 .9977 LEFTWICH C C BLK 6 L 23-B 133831 C 5/02 67,950 68,547 71,517 .9585 MELONIE GARDENS L 330 133946 C 12/02 165,000 157,256 165,577 .9497 TARRYTOWN L 339 134488 C 4/02 53,000 53,818 56,154 .9584 SLIDELL ANNEX BLK 4 L 19 135764 C 9/02 87,000 92,625 89,132 1.0392 SLIDELL ANNEX BLK 7 L 14 137224 C 1/03 79,900 68,295 79,620 .8578 SLIDELL ANNEX BLK 8 L 2 137454 C 9/02 59,831 60,439 61,297 .9860 RIDGE CREST BLK 6 L 7 137500 C 12/02 36,000 33,007 36,126 .9137 BROADMOOR NE35'OF L 578 & W54' 138094 C 4/02 87,500 91,920 92,706 .9915 SUMMERFIELD L 8 138711 C 8/02 88,000 89,913 90,772 .9905 SUMMERFIELD L 107 138811 C 6/02 99,977 93,246 104,526 .8921 PIEDMONT BLK 1 L 14-A 138835 C 3/03 137,250 119,602 134,848 .8869 REMINGTON PARK L 192 138970 C 8/02 159,000 152,499 164,009 .9298 KINGS LAKE L 12 139243 C 1/03 325,000 305,471 323,863 .9432 LAKERIDGE C C EST L 971 142897 C 9/02 250,000 250,162 256,125 .9767 REMINGTON PARK L 230 142933 C 6/02 156,500 148,132 163,621 .9053 REMINGTON PARK L 244 142947 C 2/03 159,000 149,113 157,330 .9478 SUMMERFIELD SOUTH L 1 147269 C 2/03 74,000 73,581 73,223 1.0049 SUMMERFIELD L 176 147446 C 7/02 95,500 91,267 99,177 .9202 SUMMERFIELD L 292 150194 C 6/02 106,900 104,636 111,764 .9362 PRAIRIE POINT EAST L 143 150756 C 6/02 62,400 73,999 65,239 1.1343 BRYAN PARK GARDENS L 5 153447 C 10/02 183,500 185,247 186,711 .9922 BRYAN PARK GARDENS L 9 153451 C 12/02 207,500 166,447 208,226 .7994 SOUTH MESA L 11 153488 C 11/02 89,999 86,751 90,944 .9539 SOUTH POINTE L 60 153855 C 3/03 89,950 79,756 88,376 .9025 HILLCREST SOUTH L 1 159229 C 3/03 177,500 138,606 174,394 .7948 SOUTH MESA L 288 162323 C 4/02 90,010 95,580 95,366 1.0022 SOUTH POINTE L 96 163705 C 12/02 91,634 84,140 91,955 .9150

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 3 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-901 Lubbock CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ SOUTHRIDGE L 10 166599 C 2/03 95,375 85,539 94,374 .9064 SOUTHRIDGE L 32 166621 C 8/02 105,030 106,755 108,338 .9854 SOUTHRIDGE L 56 166645 C 8/02 79,472 82,531 81,975 1.0068 SOUTHRIDGE L 66 166655 C 2/03 81,000 66,109 80,150 .8248 SOUTHRIDGE L 73 166662 C 8/02 80,532 82,531 83,069 .9935 SOUTH POINTE L 134 166694 C 10/02 74,000 78,918 75,295 1.0481 BROADMOOR L 605 25420 C 9/02 111,000 105,337 113,720 .9263 CHAPARRAL THE L 181 25474 C 9/02 101,000 102,879 103,474 .9942 MELONIE PARK L 123 25525 C 11/02 124,900 117,755 126,211 .9330 OVERTON BLK 20 L 5 25612 C 10/02 38,500 39,609 39,173 1.0111 CHAPARRAL THE L 197 25888 C 5/02 87,500 96,822 92,093 1.0513 CHAPARRAL THE L 224 26569 C 12/02 110,000 99,127 110,385 .8980 KINGS GATE L 276 26942 C 8/02 147,500 152,840 152,146 1.0046 WINDWICK L 2 26986 C 7/02 110,000 101,490 114,235 .8884 MELONIE PARK L 188 27226 C 7/02 170,000 146,084 176,545 .8275 PLEASANT RIDGE L 699 28557 C 7/02 70,500 58,854 73,214 .8039 KINGS GATE L 341 28858 C 2/03 164,950 148,903 163,218 .9123 INDIAN ACRES L 62 28968 C 6/02 122,000 115,183 127,551 .9030 MELONIE PARK L 262 LESS SW PT& 29189 C 5/02 119,600 102,227 125,879 .8121 KINGS GATE L 354 29226 C 9/02 98,700 115,659 101,118 1.1438 INDIAN ACRES L 76 29357 C 4/02 75,200 78,819 79,674 .9893 BELLAIRE HTS BLK 1 L 21 29483 C 3/03 63,000 45,853 61,898 .7408 KINGS GATE L 372 29717 C 11/02 122,000 120,500 123,281 .9774 GREEN ACRES BLK 6 L 10 30178 C 11/02 114,500 73,556 115,702 .6357 KINGS GATE L 397 30433 C 11/02 157,500 154,977 159,154 .9738 MELONIE PARK L 314 30679 C 2/03 232,000 166,061 229,564 .7234 INDIAN HILLS L 43 31415 C 7/02 52,500 54,343 54,521 .9967 GREENLAWN L 4 31656 C 2/03 110,500 101,248 109,340 .9260 ROBERT NEILL HTS BLK 3 E/2 L10 31776 C 11/02 56,900 53,376 57,497 .9283 WEBB BLK 4 L 4 & W17.5'OF 3 32608 C 1/03 142,500 117,488 142,001 .8274 ROBERT NEILL HTS BLK 5 W/2 L11 32898 C 9/02 46,500 50,840 47,639 1.0672 GREENLAWN L 61 33244 C 4/02 95,900 117,801 101,606 1.1594 TECH TERRACE BLK 7 L 5 34650 C 9/02 224,000 250,701 229,488 1.0924 GREENLAWN L 128 35060 C 12/02 110,000 109,447 110,385 .9915 SNOW W C BLK 1 L 9 & E40'OF 8 35355 C 3/03 105,000 112,965 103,162 1.0950 MELONIE PARK L 491 35637 C 2/03 275,000 223,613 272,113 .8218 MELONIE PARK L 492 35662 C 4/02 250,000 199,948 264,875 .7549 MELONIE PARK L 538 37025 C 7/02 210,000 170,998 218,085 .7841 MELONIE PARK L 548 37312 C 8/02 123,000 125,258 126,874 .9873 KINGS PARK L 33 37827 C 8/02 190,000 222,315 195,985 1.1343 OVERTON BLK 46 L 23 37989 C 10/02 66,000 91,310 67,155 1.3597 MELONIE PARK L 616 39106 C 2/03 182,000 164,398 180,089 .9129 ELLWOOD PL BLK 10 L 1 & 2 39503 C 7/02 150,000 170,648 155,775 1.0955 MELONIE PARK L 645 39847 C 12/02 199,500 147,972 200,198 .7391 PRESTON HILLS L 225 40280 C 6/02 184,500 189,637 192,895 .9831 MELONIE PARK L 675 40623 C 9/02 140,000 156,496 143,430 1.0911 WOODLAWN BLK 4 L 5 41068 C 2/03 66,000 60,335 65,307 .9239

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 4 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-901 Lubbock CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ POTOMAC PARK L 339 42741 C 3/03 85,500 79,236 84,004 .9432 COLLEGE HTS BLK 21 E50'OF L 5 43572 C 5/02 65,000 64,991 68,413 .9500 LAKERIDGE C C EST L 701 43619 C 9/02 220,000 219,999 225,390 .9761 PRAIRIE POINT EAST L 81 45095 C 5/02 53,000 51,527 55,783 .9237 POTOMAC PARK L 430 45277 C 3/03 72,600 66,188 71,330 .9279 THE MEADOWS L 253 46316 C 9/02 90,000 108,167 92,205 1.1731 OAK PARK L 29 46926 C 5/02 72,000 75,822 75,780 1.0006 OAK PARK L 30 46950 C 11/02 81,950 78,080 82,810 .9429 THE MEADOWS L 284 47160 C 6/02 115,000 107,694 120,233 .8957 OAK PARK L 40 47210 C 10/02 72,500 72,349 73,768 .9808 WESTERN MEADOWS L A 4 48207 C 3/03 83,200 63,938 81,744 .7822 WEST GATE DRIVE BLK 2 L 4 & E1 49047 C 12/02 165,000 199,856 165,577 1.2070 SOUTHPORT BLK 10 L 10 & W3.5' 49717 C 8/02 49,500 49,877 51,059 .9768 WEST GATE DRIVE BLK 11 L 6 50906 C 3/03 195,000 153,132 191,588 .7993 MELONIE PARK SOUTH L 265 51158 C 6/02 139,900 126,643 146,265 .8658 COLLEGE VIEW BLK 8 L 15 52470 C 12/02 72,000 60,057 72,252 .8312 OVERTON BLK 76 L 18 52884 C 1/03 57,000 52,119 56,801 .9176 THE MEADOWS L 503 53164 C 8/02 80,000 80,000 82,520 .9695 WEST GATE DRIVE BLK 17 E115.69 53367 C 6/02 195,000 191,824 203,873 .9409 EVANS BLK 8 L 14 53672 C 3/03 53,000 37,157 52,073 .7136 GUILLOT GARDENS L 21 54230 C 4/02 80,000 84,513 84,760 .9971 MELONIE PARK SOUTH L 381 & 382 54480 C 6/02 169,000 169,847 176,689 .9613 FARRAR DEL NORTE L 19 55385 C 6/02 109,000 99,132 113,960 .8699 QUAIL RIDGE L 8 56460 C 6/02 103,945 102,459 108,674 .9428 FARRAR DEL NORTE L 60 56613 C 9/02 126,000 126,261 129,087 .9781 THE MEADOWS L 680 58282 C 2/03 79,900 74,903 79,061 .9474 MESA PARK L 8 58526 C 3/03 102,500 100,519 100,706 .9981 BENHALL MANOR E15'OF L 82 & W4 58924 C 2/03 36,250 36,120 35,869 1.0070 KINGS GATE L 41 59479 C 1/03 187,780 211,439 187,123 1.1299 FARRAR ESTATES L 39 61175 C 4/02 105,500 94,300 111,777 .8436 KINGS GATE L 102 61214 C 4/02 310,000 287,173 328,445 .8743 KINGS GATE L 132 62104 C 5/02 184,050 184,000 193,713 .9499 MESA PARK L 153 62743 C 8/02 123,500 112,894 127,390 .8862 HAMMAN HTS L 32 63065 C 3/03 66,500 49,753 65,336 .7615 KINGS GATE L 194 63996 C 12/02 200,000 232,423 200,700 1.1581 BENHALL MANOR L 284 65114 C 9/02 39,000 56,424 39,956 1.4122 THE MEADOWS L 915 65329 C 10/02 106,500 105,548 108,364 .9740 HUNTERS GLEN L 31 65333 C 3/03 92,000 81,148 90,390 .8978 OAKWOOD L 429 65668 C 2/03 87,000 82,405 86,087 .9572 WESTOVER HTS BLK 6 L 6 66291 C 9/02 100,000 105,374 102,450 1.0285 CASTLERIDGE L 61 66653 C 10/02 181,000 172,539 184,168 .9369 BENHALL MANOR L 345 67015 C 6/02 60,000 59,997 62,730 .9564 CASTLERIDGE L 88 67515 C 4/02 150,600 157,664 159,560 .9881 RUSHLAND PK BLK 23 L 7 67836 C 5/02 240,000 252,598 252,600 1.0000 OLDHAMS MESA BLK 2 L 2 67881 C 10/02 88,500 84,111 90,049 .9341 THE MEADOWS L 1171 68046 C 8/02 97,750 89,263 100,829 .8853 RUSHLAND PK BLK 24 W108'OF L 9 68146 C 6/02 190,000 223,278 198,645 1.1240

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 5 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-901 Lubbock CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ WESTOVER HTS BLK 8 L 20 68719 C 4/02 85,000 83,436 90,058 .9265 MIDWAY PARK L 302K 69568 C 12/02 70,000 62,717 70,245 .8928 CAPROCK E5'OF L 307 & W65'OF 3 70388 C 5/02 79,000 81,892 83,148 .9849 THE MEADOWS L 1271 71023 C 5/02 68,623 75,490 72,226 1.0452 HUNTERS GLEN L 161 71133 C 9/02 83,450 76,328 85,495 .8928 WESTOVER HTS BLK 11 L 6 71258 C 11/02 53,000 51,455 53,557 .9608 RUSHLAND PK BLK 32 L 9 71297 C 12/02 152,500 152,500 153,034 .9965 FARRAR ESTATES L 435 & W10'OF 73451 C 3/03 108,000 124,475 106,110 1.1731 COBBLESTONE L 38 73452 C 3/03 204,900 204,477 201,314 1.0157 KUYKENDALL HTS L 79 74113 C 9/02 65,000 56,486 66,593 .8482 SAGEMONT L 34 74229 C 5/02 77,000 72,672 81,043 .8967 SAGEMONT L 40 74387 C 4/02 70,000 69,999 74,165 .9438 PACE & STOKES BLK 2 L 21 74753 C 4/02 40,000 44,622 42,380 1.0529 LAKERIDGE C C EST L 565 75331 C 9/02 405,000 405,000 414,922 .9761 SAGEMONT E62'OF 80 & W2'OF 81 75589 C 3/03 87,450 67,166 85,920 .7817 BENT TREE L 8 76111 C 6/02 56,750 58,157 59,332 .9802 WHISPERWOOD L 162-A 76279 C 9/02 108,500 105,646 111,158 .9504 WESTRIDGE BLK 3 L 6 76661 C 8/02 131,500 96,939 135,642 .7147 BEVERLY HTS E5'OF L 81 & W70' 77533 C 5/02 72,500 74,228 76,306 .9728 FARRAR ESTATES L 576 77773 C 9/02 151,000 140,552 154,700 .9085 CRESTHILL L 23 77799 C 5/02 159,950 160,788 168,347 .9551 KUYKENDALL HTS W28'OF L 226 & 78199 C 11/02 69,500 60,862 70,230 .8666 HIGHLAND HTS BLK 35 L 3 78586 C 9/02 36,000 33,475 36,882 .9076 LAKERIDGE C C EST L 521 78790 C 7/02 259,950 242,317 269,958 .8976 SANDERS CARL BLK 2 L 8 78825 C 2/03 55,000 55,041 54,423 1.0114 FARRAR ESTATES L 636 79601 C 12/02 143,000 144,446 143,500 1.0066 FARRAR ESTATES L 640 & W10'OF 79745 C 4/02 164,500 168,539 174,288 .9670 LAKERIDGE C C EST L 548 80213 C 8/02 205,000 230,675 211,457 1.0909 FARRAR ESTATES L 664 80470 C 2/03 146,500 136,732 144,962 .9432 MODERN MANORS RES BLK 25 L 5 81125 C 12/02 56,177 49,950 56,374 .8861 LAKERIDGE C C EST L 436 81146 C 5/02 152,500 152,444 160,506 .9498 TOWN WEST S79.26'OF L 47 81853 C 4/02 94,500 102,913 100,123 1.0279 RAINTREE L 229 & E5'OF 230 82322 C 5/02 88,500 92,205 93,146 .9899 BEVERLY HTS L 269 82325 C 4/02 60,000 56,573 63,570 .8899 BLANKENSHIP #2 UNIT 110 SAVOY 82554 C 9/02 42,000 45,682 43,029 1.0617 HIGHRIDGE L 35 82909 C 8/02 215,000 209,858 221,772 .9463 RAINTREE L 248 82918 C 12/02 136,000 121,178 136,476 .8879 ABERDEEN PLACE L 1-D 83690 C 7/02 320,000 319,999 332,320 .9629 RAINTREE L 283 83999 C 6/02 129,000 125,974 134,870 .9340 RAINTREE L 291 84242 C 9/02 118,000 113,898 120,891 .9422 PLAINSMEN L 123B 84705 C 11/02 104,500 113,273 105,597 1.0727 SANDLEWOOD VILLAGE L 111 85545 C 7/02 69,950 68,649 72,643 .9450 HIGHLAND PARK BLK 5 L 15 & E30 85902 C 2/03 73,500 72,307 72,728 .9942 TRACY HEIGHTS L 31 86136 C 12/02 65,000 59,952 65,228 .9191 FARRAR MESA L 82 86412 C 8/02 161,000 138,500 166,072 .8340 BRYAN PARK L 32A 86703 C 1/03 100,000 109,705 99,650 1.1009 FARRAR MESA L 115 87444 C 10/02 135,000 136,200 137,362 .9915

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 6 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-901 Lubbock CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ SANDLEWOOD VILLAGE L 177 87560 C 10/02 74,900 72,576 76,210 .9523 WEST WIND L 298 88799 C 6/02 72,500 78,566 75,798 1.0365 BICENTENNIAL EST L 80 89008 C 10/02 83,000 82,962 84,453 .9824 WEST WIND L 310 89152 C 7/02 75,400 72,916 78,303 .9312 RAINTREE L 466 89538 C 7/02 93,000 95,962 96,581 .9936 ALFORD TERRACE W35'OF L 159 & 89658 C 4/02 97,500 79,000 103,301 .7648 RAINTREE L 554 92059 C 1/03 128,000 113,486 127,552 .8897 WHISPERWOOD L 233-A 92345 C 7/02 157,000 147,765 163,045 .9063 WHISPERWOOD L 234-A 92376 C 10/02 158,500 153,750 161,274 .9533 BICENTENNIAL EST L 199 92465 C 6/02 44,680 67,785 46,712 1.4511 LAKERIDGE C C EST L 41 92572 C 3/03 146,000 148,133 143,445 1.0327 HIGHLAND PL BLK 9 L 10 92646 C 5/02 33,876 53,563 35,654 1.5023 LAKERIDGE C C EST L 45 92697 C 7/02 137,500 151,314 142,794 1.0597 HIGHLAND PL BLK 11 L 3 92965 C 8/02 53,705 52,710 55,397 .9515 ALFORD TERRACE L 285 & E1'OF 2 93160 C 12/02 86,000 114,336 86,301 1.3249 ALFORD TERRACE L 296 93476 C 5/02 90,000 91,925 94,725 .9704 RAINTREE L 612 93672 C 6/02 127,000 135,771 132,778 1.0225 SUNNY HILL BLK 2 L 14 95066 C 9/02 73,300 70,415 75,096 .9377 LAKERIDGE C C EST L 170 96234 C 2/03 257,000 186,677 254,302 .7341 LAKERIDGE C C EST L 172 96280 C 3/03 228,500 210,726 224,501 .9386 LAKERIDGE C C EST L 183 96573 C 12/02 163,000 157,838 163,570 .9650 SEIBER BLK 12 N120'OF L 5 & 6 97557 C 9/02 23,000 38,641 23,564 1.6399 LAKERIDGE C C EST L 248 98314 C 5/02 175,000 196,462 184,187 1.0666 ROBBIE MARION HTS L 110 99546 C 5/02 61,500 48,231 64,729 .7451 PARRISH PINK L 117 & W16.5'OF 99752 C 9/02 87,500 75,958 89,644 .8473 260 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9570 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ UNIVERSITY PINES L 190 109342 C 8/02 65,000 63,935 65,000 .9836 UNIVERSITY PINES L 264 111302 C 3/02 66,000 63,235 66,000 .9581 REDBUD HTS W41'OF L 149 & E19' 112918 C 9/02 90,000 73,892 90,000 .8210 MASSEY HTS BLK 7 E60'OF L 16 116292 C 4/03 67,500 44,842 67,500 .6643 UNIVERSITY PINES L 474 116893 C 11/02 73,000 68,622 73,000 .9400 UNIVERSITY PINES L 478 117010 C 1/02 60,921 97,163 60,921 1.5949 BRIERCROFT N6'OF L 108 & S54'O 120742 C 5/02 60,000 50,794 60,000 .8466 ORIG T LUBBOCK BLK 193 L 9-10 121800 C 5/02 55,000 48,255 55,000 .8774 MELONIE GARDENS L 2 124912 C 2/03 141,500 124,318 141,500 .8786 UND 1/2 INT MELONIE GARDENS L 125085 C 8/02 140,000 66,749 140,000 .4768

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 7 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-901 Lubbock CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ RICHLAND HILLS L 614 128543 C 5/03 1,050,000 1,050,000 1,050,000 1.0000 MCLARTYS C V L 4A 132581 C 6/02 123,000 122,686 123,000 .9974 PLAZA BLK 1 L 2 136493 C 2/03 445,000 51,620 445,000 .1160 SANDLEWOOD VILLAGE L D3 160048 C 2/03 151,000 148,485 151,000 .9833 SANDLEWOOD VILLAGE L D5 160050 C 4/02 144,300 149,926 144,300 1.0390 SANDLEWOOD VILLAGE L D9 160054 C 3/02 149,000 139,486 149,000 .9361 SANDLEWOOD VILLAGE L D10 160055 C 3/02 153,000 149,926 153,000 .9799 EDWARDS SUB BLK 1 L 16 25610 C 5/03 26,500 43,306 26,500 1.6342 KINGS GATE L 289 27333 C 4/03 147,850 122,812 147,850 .8307 NAMRON BLK 2 L 4 32467 C 2/03 90,000 91,918 90,000 1.0213 MELONIE PARK L 435 33980 C 2/02 70,000 68,797 70,000 .9828 COLLEGE HTS BLK 6 W50'OF L 7 36941 C 5/02 15,000 43,065 15,000 2.8710 COLLEGE HTS BLK 6 E50'OF L 7 36970 C 5/02 15,000 43,065 15,000 2.8710 COLLEGE HTS BLK 7 LOT W70' OF 37315 C 5/02 15,000 49,846 15,000 3.3231 TELFORD BLK 1 L 2 37335 C 4/02 57,850 52,034 57,850 .8995 TELFORD BLK 1 L 3 37360 C 4/02 47,125 49,435 47,125 1.0490 TELFORD BLK 1 L 6 37435 C 3/03 47,500 47,500 47,500 1.0000 SOUTH ACRES L 62 38444 C 12/02 180,000 149,999 180,000 .8333 WESTERN ESTATES SE40'OF L 12 & 39607 C 9/02 89,500 80,428 89,500 .8986 WESTERN ESTATES SE20'OF L 14 & 39678 C 2/03 80,000 79,999 80,000 1.0000 SOUTHGATE L 97 42598 C 1/02 105,000 96,264 105,000 .9168 MELONIE PARK SOUTH S29.26'OF L 50887 C 5/02 92,250 120,774 92,250 1.3092 SOUTHPORT BLK 15 W57'OF L 3 51080 C 8/02 54,458 56,048 54,458 1.0292 SOUTHPORT BLK 15 L 4 & W34'OF 51109 C 8/02 54,458 56,848 54,458 1.0439 SOUTHPORT BLK 15 W31'OF L 6 & 51151 C 8/02 54,958 56,048 54,958 1.0198 OVERTON BLK 78 L 1 53674 C 10/02 66,000 82,222 66,000 1.2458 QUAKER HEIGHTS L 3 58939 C 3/03 109,500 129,311 109,500 1.1809 MESA PARK L 32 & E5'OF 31 59253 C 4/02 120,000 108,126 120,000 .9011 QUAKER HEIGHTS L 22 59524 C 7/02 110,000 112,550 110,000 1.0232 SOUTHWEST HAVEN BLK 1 W100'OF 59582 C 10/02 1,050,000 215,290 1,050,000 .2050 THE MEADOWS L 728 59681 C 10/02 90,000 83,664 90,000 .9296 QUAKER HEIGHTS L 29 59697 C 12/02 120,000 107,812 120,000 .8984 FARRAR ESTATES S70'OF N75'OF L 60272 C 4/02 102,500 96,601 102,500 .9424 ROTHWEBB E40'OF L 9 & W22.5'OF 60279 C 12/02 82,500 71,240 82,500 .8635 ROTHWEBB W/PT OF L 23A & 24A 60803 C 4/03 119,000 84,990 119,000 .7142 FARRAR ESTATES L 31 60942 C 1/02 144,000 131,678 144,000 .9144 HALBERT L 6 7 & W25'OF 8 & 11 62020 C 11/02 330,000 329,995 330,000 1.0000 WESTMORELAND BLK 10 L 1-A 62585 C 2/03 73,000 49,703 73,000 .6809 WESTMORELAND BLK 10 L 2-A 62645 C 2/03 73,000 49,652 73,000 .6802 WESTMORELAND BLK 10 L 3-A 62664 C 2/03 73,000 49,652 73,000 .6802 WESTMORELAND BLK 10 L 4-A 62690 C 2/03 73,000 49,687 73,000 .6806 OAKWOOD L 444 66120 C 4/03 60,000 52,510 60,000 .8752 HARRIS BLK 1 L 18 70946 C 1/03 90,000 90,006 90,000 1.0001 HUNTERS GLEN L 229 73168 C 1/02 74,000 74,612 74,000 1.0083 HUNTERS GLEN L 230 73195 C 1/02 74,000 75,332 74,000 1.0180 THE MEADOWS L 872-B 73784 C 9/02 96,500 89,628 96,500 .9288 PARK HILL BLK 2 L 2 78126 C 5/02 15,000 58,173 15,000 3.8782

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 8 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-901 Lubbock CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ SANDLEWOOD VILLAGE L 8 82375 C 9/02 145,000 148,636 145,000 1.0251 SANDLEWOOD VILLAGE L 20 82732 C 1/03 146,000 193,838 146,000 1.3277 SANDLEWOOD VILLAGE L 24 82866 C 2/03 106,000 82,902 106,000 .7821 BEVERLY HTS L 379 85715 C 3/02 61,000 65,390 61,000 1.0720 BEVERLY HTS L 380 85774 C 3/02 61,000 65,390 61,000 1.0720 TRACY HEIGHTS L 137 89382 C 12/02 1,920,000 2,200,000 1,920,000 1.1458 BICENTENNIAL EST L 237A 93509 C 9/02 23,900 46,232 23,900 1.9344 64 SALES CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD APPR TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER MOD OBS VALUE APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ HORIZON WEST LOT 275 - 298 129804 1.00 .00 3,667,311 3,787,024 .9700 FURR WOLF BLK 8 LOT 3 144180 1.00 .00 6,179,292 5,765,352 1.0700 DOMINION TR A 148094 1.00 .00 7,562,067 7,634,624 .9900 PLEASANT RIDGE LOT 850 31974 1.00 .00 2,021,012 1,675,887 1.2100 BENDER CENTER TR B OF L H 40104 1.00 .00 1,908,629 2,030,788 .9400 KNOTT C C TR B-2 C & F 70108 1.00 .00 4,650,000 4,622,916 1.0100 KNOTT CC TR D & G 70154 1.00 .00 3,362,198 3,258,613 1.0300 KNOTT C C TR H 70261 1.00 .00 3,300,000 4,047,079 .8200 KNOTT C C TR I 91467 1.00 .00 4,091,777 4,019,821 1.0200 SENTRY PARK TR C 91835 1.00 .00 5,891,388 6,841,039 .8600 10 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9043 CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ MURRYHILL TR 9B OF L 204 103858 C 4/02 160,000 156,592 160,000 .9787 SIMMONS BLK 9 L 6 THRU 10 105025 C 7/02 140,000 135,999 140,000 .9714 ORIG T LUBBOCK BLK114 & ALLEYS 107414 C 6/02 4,100,000 3,580,468 4,100,000 .8733

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 9 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-901 Lubbock CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ HOBGOOD BLK 1 E52.5'OF N135'OF 108845 C 2/03 138,000 108,156 138,000 .7837 ORIG T LUBBOCK BLK 131 L 11-13 109893 C 7/02 223,659 216,983 223,659 .9702 ORIG T LUBBOCK BLK 133 L 15 & 110483 C 1/02 148,750 151,723 148,750 1.0200 ORIG T LUBBOCK BLK 133 L 18 110554 C 1/02 285,000 240,177 285,000 .8427 SUNNY SLOPE BLK 10 L 11 & 12 & 110906 C 4/03 118,970 140,929 118,970 1.1846 WHISPERWOOD TR C-1-A 113004 C 12/02 1,575,052 1,575,051 1,575,052 1.0000 FURR WOLF BLK 2 L 1 113096 C 2/02 465,000 400,229 465,000 .8607 LUTHERAN L 3 & 4 & S87'OF E30' 113339 C 11/02 1,000,000 950,000 1,000,000 .9500 HORD BUCHANAN BLK 1 L 19 116045 C 10/02 235,000 234,000 235,000 .9957 GREENBRIER L H 121368 C 10/02 1,100,000 1,112,228 1,100,000 1.0111 ORIG T LUBBOCK BLK 192 L 18-20 121720 C 6/02 85,614 82,314 85,614 .9615 LISEMBY BLK 1 L 10 & E25'FORME 122083 C 1/03 82,000 81,427 82,000 .9930 BLANKENSHIP #2 S PT OF W369.69 122135 C 10/02 675,000 394,674 675,000 .5847 WESTERN MEADOWS TR D-1 122202 C 9/02 1,064,668 724,990 1,064,668 .6810 WILLIAMS R C BLK 1 L 12 & E80' 122282 C 4/02 170,000 369,569 170,000 2.1739 ORIG T LUBBOCK BLK 197 L 11-15 122661 C 2/03 225,000 222,693 225,000 .9897 GATEWOOD L 278 122835 C 4/02 125,000 126,938 125,000 1.0155 PLAN EX E/PT OF L 1 123065 C 1/02 225,000 220,001 225,000 .9778 BRIERCROFT OFF PK L 4 124883 C 6/02 110,000 112,433 110,000 1.0221 BRIERCROFT OFF PK L 5 124911 C 8/02 130,000 129,996 130,000 1.0000 BRIERCROFT OFF PK L 9 10 10A & 124990 C 10/02 295,000 294,998 295,000 1.0000 BRIERCROFT OFF PK L 14 125039 C 3/02 179,000 196,212 179,000 1.0962 BRIERCROFT OFF PK L 19 125193 C 1/02 125,000 117,833 125,000 .9427 BRIERCROFT OFF PK L 20 & 22 125219 C 10/02 600,000 499,855 600,000 .8331 ORIG T LUBBOCK BLK 212 L 6-10 125747 C 3/03 240,000 213,999 240,000 .8917 DOLLIE MAC #2 L 34 & 8'OF CLOS 126397 C 2/02 465,000 429,432 465,000 .9235 LAKERIDGE C C EST TR K 129221 C 2/02 1,040,000 1,040,000 1,040,000 1.0000 ORIG T LUBBOCK BLK 231 L 4 & 5 130814 C 10/02 350,000 281,756 350,000 .8050 LIVE OAK W100'OF L 197-E STE A 132656 C 3/02 115,500 123,989 115,500 1.0735 BRYAN PARK TR K UNIT 2/APT C C 133610 C 7/02 180,000 180,000 180,000 1.0000 BRYAN PARK TR K UNIT 3/APT A C 133657 C 5/02 89,000 88,999 89,000 1.0000 DUPREE BLK 1 L 55 & 56 134328 C 1/02 79,480 72,772 79,480 .9156 MELONIE GARDENS TR F & E/2 OF 135476 C 10/02 350,000 419,962 350,000 1.1999 VICKERS BLK 1 L 1-3 & W/2 OF 4 135601 C 5/02 500,000 484,401 500,000 .9688 WESTAC L 6-A-1 137425 C 3/03 605,000 604,999 605,000 1.0000 GATEWOOD TR C 139396 C 12/02 156,800 88,199 156,800 .5625 WESTAC L 1-A-2 147397 C 11/02 215,500 214,746 215,500 .9965 HODGES C N RESUB TR 9-A-2 150793 C 11/02 2,750,000 2,369,970 2,750,000 .8618 HODGES C N RESUB E/PT TR L 165279 C 3/02 290,000 289,999 290,000 1.0000 SADDLEWOOD VILLAGE TR A1B2 & C 169340 C 8/02 1,350,000 900,000 1,350,000 .6667 EDWARDS SUB BLK 1 N70'OF L 10 25475 C 1/03 75,000 73,780 75,000 .9837 GORDON HTS L 107 108 & E10.14' 25826 C 6/02 395,000 300,000 395,000 .7595 GORDON HTS PT OF TR A & B 27315 C 4/02 300,000 306,350 300,000 1.0212 WALDEN BLK 3 L 14 28666 C 4/02 105,000 105,000 105,000 1.0000 BARTOS N100'OF L 3 & BLK E SEC 28777 C 9/02 75,000 74,467 75,000 .9929 WARREN WALLACE BLK 1 L 8 & 9 29837 C 1/02 357,500 382,730 357,500 1.0706 GREENBRIER L 1B2 31459 C 4/02 3,650,000 3,618,995 3,650,000 .9915

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 10 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-901 Lubbock CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ GREENBRIER L F 31506 C 10/02 550,000 506,995 550,000 .9218 NEAL & ALEXANDER BLK 1 L 13-16 33083 C 4/02 750,000 577,333 750,000 .7698 COLLEGE HTS BLK 2 L 6 & 7 34907 C 6/02 150,000 169,021 150,000 1.1268 FIESTA AUTOLAND CNT CENTER PT 35263 C 4/02 170,000 169,997 170,000 1.0000 OVERTON BLK 41 L 13 35645 C 6/02 115,000 106,464 115,000 .9258 OVERTON BLK 42 L 3 & 4 35882 C 5/02 278,500 270,507 278,500 .9713 IRIS GARDENS E120'OF L 12 37383 C 1/02 350,000 349,998 350,000 1.0000 KINGS PARK TR E 37963 C 8/02 615,000 749,997 615,000 1.2195 OVERTON BLK 56 L 20 42662 C 11/02 109,000 103,618 109,000 .9506 PUTTY ROSS BLK 2 L 1-A-2 45204 C 4/03 100,000 132,710 100,000 1.3271 HELM SUB BLK 30 L 3 THRU 9 47839 C 2/02 110,000 104,776 110,000 .9525 JARROTT JOHN W BLK 6 L 1 & 2 48878 C 2/03 1,955,800 1,935,583 1,955,800 .9897 BURLINGTON IND #2 BLK 3 L 2 & 54194 C 10/02 1,035,000 1,034,995 1,035,000 1.0000 MEMORIAL CENTER BLK 7 L 2A 56426 C 11/02 475,000 451,659 475,000 .9509 WOODLAND PARK L D-2 58523 C 11/02 715,000 527,054 715,000 .7371 WOODLAND PARK L F15 & E25.66'O 59142 C 9/02 140,000 140,249 140,000 1.0018 COPE L 1-B-1 59784 C 3/02 90,000 200,052 90,000 2.2228 OVERTON BLK 99 L 9 & 10 59790 C 5/02 100,000 91,553 100,000 .9155 ROY J V BLK 1 L 3 THRU 10 & CL 61504 C 12/02 250,000 219,231 250,000 .8769 BENNETT KERR TR C OF L 3 67846 C 5/02 80,000 76,796 80,000 .9600 HAPPY HOMES E/2 BLK 16 69393 C 8/02 170,000 178,389 170,000 1.0493 FIESTA AUTOLAND CNT W33.42'OF 70698 C 9/02 95,000 93,500 95,000 .9842 SQUYRES PLACE BLK 2 L 11-13 70983 C 3/02 550,000 587,978 550,000 1.0691 SOUTHWEST HAVEN TR C 71649 C 3/02 531,035 908,735 531,035 1.7113 PAINTER RAYMOND BLK 2 L 7-A 75533 C 8/02 100,000 100,000 100,000 1.0000 TOWNHOUSE L 1 80355 C 10/02 383,406 368,404 383,406 .9609 KUYKENDALL HTS L 533 86939 C 4/02 106,000 98,643 106,000 .9306 LIBERTY VILLAGE L 1-55 OF TR A 90965 C 1/02 1,600,000 1,548,611 1,600,000 .9679 FIESTA AUTOLAND CNT L R-4-A 92717 C 12/02 110,000 133,093 110,000 1.2099 MURPHY PLACE BLK 2 E51'OF L 11 97762 C 6/02 858,994 1,464,944 858,994 1.7054 GPC L 1 98620 C 10/02 2,200,000 2,619,820 2,200,000 1.1908 81 SALES CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ WESTAC L 12 LESS ORW 139413 .00 1.00 .00 5,895,951 5,527,024 1.0700 VENTURE L 4, 5 & 6 139825 .00 1.00 .00 8,142,140 8,206,443 .9900 FURR WOLFE BLK 8 L 2 37759 .00 1.00 .00 4,885,301 5,024,620 .9700 SOUTH PLAINS W5.57ACS OF TR TR 47892 .00 1.00 .00 6,290,002 6,126,524 1.0300 AMERICAN STATE BANK L 1A & 2 & 89794 .00 1.00 .00 6,349,718 6,264,241 1.0100 SENTRY PARK TR A-2 & A-3 91586 .00 1.00 .00 1,738,612 1,695,041 1.0300 6 APPRAISALS

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 11 TIME: 15:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 152 Lubbock 152-901 Lubbock STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9846 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ECKERD DRUGS 103089 612,495 613,549 1.0000 B & G ORTHOPEDIC APPLIANCES 107098 77,436 81,652 .9500 PLAINS NATIONAL BANK 111691 1,459,578 1,471,579 .9900 J C PENNY 132704 5,979,830 6,064,865 .9900 K-MART 136250 3,045,994 3,158,150 .9600 WAL-MART 141208 8,451,766 8,392,633 1.0100 OLD NAVY 144182 1,980,269 2,187,772 .9100 CANYON AMPHITHEATER 160741 51,000 51,592 .9900 OMEGA FRIEGHT 161007 166,633 170,199 .9800 EDWARD THORNE DDS 161139 240,600 248,389 .9700 ROADWAY EXPRESS 26428 50,992 52,422 .9700 B T HEALTH CARE 31724 470,925 464,710 1.0100 FLEMING COMPANYS 33431 10,044,199 9,920,415 1.0100 GUAJARDO FUNERAL HOME 37404 116,365 112,444 1.0300 BMW CREDIT 47405 1,683,167 1,574,598 1.0700 ASSOC LEASING 56003 2,720,426 2,158,964 1.2600 PITNEY BOWES 56161 1,752,429 1,751,450 1.0000 PLAINS COTTEN 56947 872,311 855,292 1.0200 BUCKLE 62257 622,223 629,857 .9900 LUBBOCK SPORTS REHAB 76356 533,344 539,653 .9900 LUBBOCK AJ 80486 3,220,211 3,310,013 .9700 STEPHEN CORD 84847 49,517 47,779 1.0400 BURGESS AUTO SALVAGE 89666 74,920 75,211 1.0000 SCOTT TRACTOR 95026 511,357 511,144 1.0000 UNITED 96694 2,120,798 2,075,610 1.0200 LEE LEWIS 98666 1,493,200 1,433,786 1.0400 WAL-MART 99022 9,033,519 8,801,986 1.0300 27 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0091