Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   1/22/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:     50
TIME:     14:40                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             108  Hidalgo
                                                         108-911  Sharyland

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  ALADDIN VILLAS PH 2 LOT 69       R110328                    C      12/02         79,000          70,494        79,067     .8916
  ALADDIN VILLAS PH 2 LOT 83       R110342                    C      10/02        104,000          73,790       104,442     .7065
  ALADDIN VILLAS PH 2 LOT 156      R110415                    C       5/02         72,500          64,836        73,424     .8830
  ALADDIN VILLAS PH 2 LOT 199      R110458                    C       5/02         74,000          64,553        74,944     .8614
  ALADDIN VILLAS PH 2 LOT 254      R110513                    C       8/02         73,000          62,386        73,558     .8481
  ALADDIN VILLAS PH 2 LOT 257      R110516                    C       6/02         85,000          73,340        85,939     .8534
  CIMARRON COUNTRY CLUB SECTION    R135420                    C       9/02        152,000         149,963       152,904     .9808
  CIMARRON COUNTRY CLUB SECTION    R135444                    C      10/02        160,000         161,512       160,680    1.0052
  CIMARRON COUNTRY CLUB SECTN 2    R135468                    C       8/02        136,000         126,307       137,040     .9217
  CIMARRON COUNTRY CLUB SECTN 2    R135524                    C      10/02        270,000         256,061       271,147     .9444
  CIMARRON COUNTRY CLUB SECTN 2    R135554                    C      10/02        236,500         213,386       237,505     .8984
  CIMARRON COUNTRY CLUB SECTN 2    R135563                    C       5/02        242,250         223,635       245,339     .9115
  CIMARRON COUNTRY CLUB SECTN 2    R135578                    C      12/02        218,360         197,256       218,546     .9026
  CIMARRON COUNTRY CLUB SECTN 3    R135597                    C       9/02        155,500         151,112       156,425     .9660
  CIMARRON COUNTRY CLUB SECTN 3    R135629                    C       6/02        212,000         201,694       214,342     .9410
  CIMARRON COUNTRY CLUB SECTN 3    R135630                    C       5/02        139,900         132,580       141,684     .9357
  CIMARRON COUNTRY CLUB SECTN 3    R135680                    C       5/02        230,000         248,058       232,932    1.0649
  CIMARRON COUNTRY CLUB SECTN 4    R135706                    C       6/02        234,000         237,566       236,585    1.0041
  CIMARRON COUNTRY CLUB SECTN 4    R135710                    C       4/02        289,000         295,315       293,176    1.0073
  CIMARRON COUNTRY CLUB SECTN 4    R135787                    C      10/02        162,500         147,394       163,191     .9032
  CIMARRON COUNTRY CLUB SECTN 4    R135817                    C       7/02        135,000         149,593       136,262    1.0978
  CIMARRON COUNTRY CLUB SECTN 4    R135822                    C       9/02        222,000         215,673       223,320     .9658
  CIMARRON  C C SEC -4 PH -I SEC   R135828                    C       8/02        229,000         200,607       230,752     .8694
  CITRUS CITY LAKE #1 LOT 5        R136986                    C      11/02         92,362          80,540        92,598     .8698
  CURL TEX LOT 4                   R156456                    C      11/02        136,000         131,853       136,346     .9670
  GLENSHIRE ESTATES LOT 3          R179600                    C      10/02        149,000         157,983       149,633    1.0558
  GLENWOOD TERRACE LOT 16          R179634                    C       5/02         50,000          48,837        50,638     .9644
  GOLDEN CREST MANOR LOT 3 BLK 1   R180240                    C      11/02        190,000         275,436       190,484    1.4460
  GOLDEN CREST MANOR LOT 10 BLK    R180267                    C       8/02        175,000         166,644       176,339     .9450
  GRANADA ESTATES LOT 11           R181869                    C       8/02        100,000          78,449       100,765     .7785
  GRANADA ESTATES LOT 14           R181873                    C       9/02         89,000          82,906        89,529     .9260
  GRANADA ESTATES LOT 16           R181875                    C       4/02         83,900          73,569        85,112     .8644
  LA HACIENDA LOT 23               R209175                    C      11/02         64,000          59,989        64,163     .9349
  SCHMIDT LOT 4 & SOUTH 0.06AC O   R279305                    C       6/02         77,000          81,680        77,850    1.0492
  SENDERO LOT 6                    R280037                    C       4/02        430,150         362,598       436,366     .8309
  JOHN H SHARY 0.69AC AN IRR TR    R280978                    C       4/02         41,000          71,550        41,592    1.7203
  JOHN H SHARY 1.63AC FOR H/S-N1   R281008                    C      10/02        160,000         143,220       160,680     .8913
  JOHN H SHARY N 190' - S 670' -   R281349                    C       5/02        140,000         187,660       141,785    1.3236
  JOHN H SHARY LT 335 N 80'-W 19   R281847                    C       9/02        117,400         103,227       118,099     .8741
  JOHN H SHARY N 155'-S 815'-E 1   R282062                    C       8/02        186,000         172,823       187,422     .9221
  JOHN H SHARY 1.0AC-SE COR FOR    R282155                    C      10/02        138,000         170,836       138,586    1.2327
  JOHN H SHARY-N132'-E405.5'-W73   R282603                    C       5/02        250,000         232,394       253,187     .9179
  STONEGATE PHASE II LOT 13        R291034                    C      10/02        152,097         136,426       152,743     .8932
  STONEGATE PHASE II LOT 37        R291058                    C       4/02        138,000         136,237       139,994     .9732
  THE RETREAT AT CIMARRON CONDOS   R301750                    C       4/02         76,000          78,660        77,098    1.0203
  TIERRA GRANDE ESTATES LOT 45     R304374                    C       5/02         87,500          75,544        88,616     .8525
  TIERRA GRANDE ESTATES LOT 87     R304416                    C       6/02         74,500          72,615        75,323     .9640

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 51 TIME: 14:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 108 Hidalgo 108-911 Sharyland CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ VALLEY VIEW ESTATES LOT 9 BLK R313547 C 4/02 40,000 38,691 40,578 .9535 WARE SHADOWS LOT 34 R320680 C 7/02 115,000 83,895 116,075 .7228 WOLSEY LOT 8 R330425 C 10/02 90,000 86,071 90,383 .9523 SHARY COUNTRY ACRES LOT 5 R346118 C 7/02 121,000 113,405 122,131 .9285 JOHN H SHARY W 0.35AC FOR IMPS R346179 C 7/02 105,000 109,651 105,982 1.0346 ZULEY MANOR LOT 5 R347589 C 10/02 290,000 293,095 291,232 1.0064 ZULEY MANOR LOT 12 R347596 C 8/02 364,000 359,280 366,784 .9795 JOHNSON CITY, LOT 2 R498640 C 7/02 70,000 68,515 70,655 .9697 JOHNSON CITY, LOT 3 R498641 C 12/02 76,000 94,062 76,065 1.2366 TANO LOT 1 R505380 C 5/02 135,800 147,076 137,531 1.0694 CIMARRON COUNTRY CLUB SECTION R505410 C 9/02 170,000 157,920 171,011 .9234 DURANGO LOT 14 R514053 C 11/02 265,000 266,401 265,676 1.0027 DURANGO LOT 15 R514054 C 9/02 480,000 452,028 482,856 .9362 TITO'S LOT A R514096 C 9/02 125,000 121,852 125,744 .9691 EL LAGO ESTATES LOT 6 R517335 C 4/03 370,000 370,453 367,798 1.0072 COUNTRY ESTATES LOT 33 R520075 C 9/02 135,000 122,506 135,803 .9021 COUNTRY ESTATES LOT 39 R520090 C 9/02 124,500 113,437 125,241 .9058 COUNTRY ESTATES LOT 54 R520124 C 8/02 130,000 137,041 130,994 1.0462 SHARYWOOD ESTATES LOT 9 R523654 C 12/02 425,000 343,543 425,361 .8076 SPRING GATE ESTATES LOT 4 R523671 C 9/02 185,000 180,342 186,101 .9691 SUNSET RIDGE LOT 7 R525707 C 10/02 94,000 96,285 94,400 1.0200 SUNSET RIDGE LOT 21 R525725 C 6/02 85,500 94,851 86,445 1.0972 SUNSET RIDGE LOT 32 R525748 C 7/02 99,000 92,030 99,925 .9210 SUNSET RIDGE LOT 40 R525758 C 4/02 96,000 94,096 97,387 .9662 SUNSET RIDGE LOT 72 R525799 C 6/02 87,000 89,795 87,961 1.0208 ORANGE ESTATES LOT 11 R534217 C 12/02 119,000 109,333 119,101 .9180 ORANGE ESTATES LOT 12 R534218 C 9/02 87,500 88,388 88,021 1.0042 STEWART TERRACE LOT 17 R536357 C 5/02 180,000 172,725 182,295 .9475 SHARY PALMS UT 2 LOT 46 R536907 C 4/02 86,700 78,500 87,953 .8925 SHARY PALMS UT 2 LOT 74 R536935 C 5/02 86,500 78,455 87,603 .8956 SPRINGFIELD PH 3 LOT 78 R536974 C 8/02 124,900 109,436 125,855 .8695 SPRINGFIELD PH 3 LOT 82 R536978 C 10/02 130,000 112,481 130,552 .8616 SPRINGFIELD PH 2 LOT 98 R537053 C 9/02 108,000 106,494 108,642 .9802 SPRINGFIELD PH 2 LOT 101 R537056 C 6/02 125,000 152,744 126,381 1.2086 CAPISTRANO LOT 6 R537845 C 8/02 185,000 175,245 186,415 .9401 CAPISTRANO LOT 25 R537874 C 4/02 195,000 214,239 197,818 1.0830 SHARY PALMS UT 3 LOT 108 R539978 C 10/02 125,000 107,934 125,531 .8598 THE GROVES AT CIMARRON LOT 8 R540414 C 5/02 170,000 201,152 172,167 1.1684 COUNTRY ESTATES PH 3 LOT 12 R545386 C 4/02 184,000 168,465 186,658 .9025 COUNTRY ESTATES PH 3 LOT 16 R545390 C 8/02 133,500 117,420 134,521 .8729 OAK GLENN LOT 1 R545423 C 7/02 90,000 85,825 90,842 .9448 OAK GLENN LOT 8 R545431 C 11/02 83,500 80,553 83,713 .9623 OAK GLENN LOT 16 R545439 C 8/02 84,500 84,959 85,146 .9978 ORANGE ESTATES PH 2 LOT 3 R545487 C 4/02 78,000 77,027 79,127 .9735 SHARY PALMS IV LOT 1 R545551 C 7/02 85,700 79,110 86,501 .9146 SHARY PALMS IV LOT 14 R545565 C 8/02 87,000 77,706 87,665 .8864 SILVERADO SOUTH LOT 7 R545598 C 5/03 560,000 562,211 555,716 1.0117

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 52 TIME: 14:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 108 Hidalgo 108-911 Sharyland CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ SILVERADO SOUTH LOT 11 R545602 C 8/02 503,500 366,849 507,352 .7231 EL ENCINO LOT 7 R552318 C 11/02 365,000 360,480 365,931 .9851 BENTSEN HEIGHTS UT 1 LOT 10 R556717 C 6/02 100,000 105,688 101,105 1.0453 BENTSEN HEIGHTS UT 1 LOT 71 R556778 C 9/02 104,000 101,485 104,618 .9700 BENTSEN HEIGHTS UT 1 LOT 72 R556779 C 9/02 139,900 120,479 140,732 .8561 SPRINGFIELD PH 4 LOT 5 R556851 C 8/02 93,000 91,158 93,711 .9728 SPRINGFIELD PH 4 LOT 39 R556885 C 11/02 100,000 93,606 100,255 .9337 SPRINGFIELD PH 4 LOT 58 R556904 C 10/02 95,500 89,810 95,906 .9364 SPRINGFIELD PH 4 LOT 68 R556914 C 12/02 95,705 90,913 95,786 .9491 SPRINGFIELD PH 4 LOT 77 R556923 C 6/02 95,000 94,397 96,049 .9828 SHARY PALMS UT 5 LOT 3 R563518 C 4/02 74,500 76,129 75,577 1.0073 SHARY PALMS UT 5 LOT 40 R563555 C 11/02 89,900 85,497 90,129 .9486 SHARY PALMS UT 5 LOT 51 R563566 C 8/02 83,500 84,845 84,139 1.0084 SHARY PALMS UT 5 LOT 53 EXC S5 R563568 C 8/02 95,000 83,156 95,726 .8687 BRIARWOOD ESTATES II LOT 4 R566414 C 5/02 89,900 98,335 91,046 1.0801 BRIARWOOD ESTATES II LOT 10 R566420 C 10/02 97,000 78,050 97,412 .8012 BENTSEN HEIGHTS UT 2 LOT 137 R569286 C 7/02 110,000 103,605 111,028 .9331 CROWN POINTE PH 2 LOT 11 R569535 C 6/02 222,000 205,856 224,453 .9171 CROWN POINTE PH 2 LOT 15 R569539 C 9/02 299,000 295,119 300,779 .9812 SHARY PALMS UT VI LOT 74 R569552 C 7/02 85,700 78,749 86,501 .9104 SHARY PALMS UT VI LOT 95 R569573 C 8/02 82,500 83,489 83,131 1.0043 SILVERADO NORTH LOT 3 R572991 C 4/02 405,000 356,997 410,852 .8689 LOST PINES PH 2 LOT 33 R573052 C 7/02 239,000 229,448 241,235 .9511 SHARY GARDENS LOT 5 BLK 2 R574154 C 4/02 87,250 82,903 88,511 .9366 MONACO LOT 6 R574192 C 9/02 145,000 148,566 145,863 1.0185 MONACO LOT 14 R574200 C 6/02 302,000 283,140 305,337 .9273 MONACO LOT 18 R574204 C 2/03 145,000 147,105 144,630 1.0171 SHARYWOOD MANOR LOT 31 R574303 C 9/02 125,000 109,464 125,744 .8705 SHARY FOREST III LOT 25 R574415 C 4/02 130,280 120,047 132,163 .9083 TRINITY GROVE AT CIMARRON LOT R574879 C 9/02 330,000 362,102 331,963 1.0908 CROWN POINTE PH 3 LOT 21 R582083 C 7/02 214,500 222,529 216,506 1.0278 CROWN POINTE PH 3 LOT 24 R582086 C 4/02 257,000 291,984 260,714 1.1199 SHARY ESTATES LOT 12 R582141 C 7/02 88,000 84,368 88,823 .9498 SHARY PALMS UT 7 LOT 14 R582164 C 8/02 93,000 84,825 93,711 .9052 SHARY PALMS UT 7 LOT 18 R582168 C 10/02 106,000 97,223 106,450 .9133 SHARY PALMS UT 7 LOT 20 R582170 C 10/02 97,400 82,739 97,813 .8459 SHARY PALMS UT 7 LOT 25 R582175 C 5/02 95,000 87,120 96,211 .9055 PALAZZO AT CIMARRON LOT 11 R587444 C 10/02 370,000 419,968 371,572 1.1302 EL JARDIN DE LAS FLORES LOT 31 R592065 C 10/02 249,000 223,602 250,058 .8942 EL JARDIN DE LAS FLORES LOT 55 R592089 C 7/02 183,000 158,078 184,711 .8558 EL JARDIN DE LAS FLORES LOT 76 R592110 C 10/02 254,500 235,636 255,582 .9220 EL JARDIN DE LAS FLORES LOT 83 R592117 C 10/02 250,000 227,730 251,062 .9071 SHARYLAND PLANTATION VILLAGE S R593187 C 5/02 675,000 663,766 683,606 .9710 LOS MILAGROS PH 1 LOT 5 R593222 C 4/02 392,400 380,549 398,070 .9560 LOS MILAGROS PH 1 LOT 9 R593226 C 8/02 360,500 340,976 363,258 .9387 SEFELA EMERALD FOREST LOT 7 R599655 C 4/02 133,195 128,381 135,120 .9501 BENTSEN HEIGHTS UT 3 LOT 154 R601162 C 11/02 149,000 144,890 149,380 .9699

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 53 TIME: 14:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 108 Hidalgo 108-911 Sharyland CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BENTSEN HEIGHTS UT 3 LOT 165 R601173 C 7/02 141,000 139,551 142,318 .9806 TAURUS ESTATES #7 LOT 22 R603360 C 5/02 142,750 154,364 144,570 1.0677 TAURUS ESTATES #8 LOT 5 - AMEN R603385 C 10/02 174,900 175,906 175,643 1.0015 CROWN POINTE PH 4 LOT 40 R613471 C 7/02 290,325 273,921 293,040 .9348 SOMMERSET LOT 4 R613481 C 6/02 153,900 160,632 155,601 1.0323 SOMMERSET LOT 15 R613492 C 8/02 198,227 189,122 199,743 .9468 SOMMERSET LOT 29 R613506 C 7/02 199,362 212,654 201,226 1.0568 SOMMERSET LOT 36 R613513 C 9/02 159,065 182,748 160,011 1.1421 SOMMERSET LOT 52 R613529 C 7/02 157,900 169,821 159,376 1.0655 SOMMERSET LOT 54 R613531 C 4/02 170,717 162,879 173,184 .9405 SOMMERSET LOT 57 R613534 C 8/02 168,000 222,290 169,285 1.3131 SOMMERSET LOT 58 R613535 C 6/02 135,000 133,732 136,492 .9798 LAS PALMAS DEL SOL,SHARYLAND P R616467 C 5/02 108,500 118,727 109,883 1.0805 OLIVE TREE ESTATES LOT 7 R620031 C 6/02 210,000 183,933 212,320 .8663 ORANGE COVE LOT 23 R622800 C 9/02 97,000 92,819 97,577 .9512 LOS NOGALES PH 1, SHARYLAND PL R623684 C 4/02 146,900 143,560 149,023 .9633 LOS NOGALES PH 1, SHARYLAND PL R623709 C 7/02 130,000 141,166 131,215 1.0758 LOMA VERDE PH 1, SHARYLAND PLA R623851 C 11/02 89,900 74,530 90,129 .8269 LOMA VERDE PH 1, SHARYLAND PLA R623854 C 10/02 86,500 89,179 86,868 1.0266 LOMA VERDE PH 1, SHARYLAND PLA R623879 C 5/02 87,950 100,276 89,071 1.1258 LOMA VERDE PH 1, SHARYLAND PLA R623888 C 10/02 79,000 82,670 79,335 1.0420 LOMA VERDE PH 1, SHARYLAND PLA R623912 C 4/02 90,675 96,432 91,985 1.0483 HIDDEN VILLAGE LOT 10 R629788 C 10/02 156,000 154,519 156,663 .9863 HIDDEN VILLAGE LOT 50 R629828 C 4/02 124,900 111,796 126,705 .8823 HIDDEN VILLAGE LOT 56 R629834 C 7/02 150,000 136,719 151,402 .9030 HIGHLAND ESTATES LOT 2 R631169 C 12/02 97,000 100,003 97,082 1.0301 LOS NOGALES PH 2, SHARYLAND PL R639200 C 6/02 131,612 140,598 133,066 1.0566 LOS NOGALES PH 3,SHARYLAND PLA R639275 C 4/02 155,600 158,058 157,848 1.0013 CAMINO REAL PH 2,SHARYLAND PLA R639310 C 11/02 239,595 201,236 240,206 .8378 CAMINO REAL PH 2,SHARYLAND PLA R639312 C 12/02 253,805 235,694 254,021 .9279 CAMINO REAL PH 1,SHARYLAND PLA R639316 C 9/02 282,500 235,585 284,181 .8290 CAMINO REAL PH 2,SHARYLAND PLA R639336 C 11/02 225,529 211,457 226,104 .9352 CAMINO REAL PH 1,SHARYLAND PLA R639359 C 12/02 316,350 231,343 316,619 .7307 CAMINO REAL PH 1,SHARYLAND PLA R639366 C 4/02 221,731 193,631 224,935 .8608 CAMINO REAL PH 1,SHARYLAND PLA R639372 C 4/02 271,920 231,851 275,849 .8405 TAYLOR OAKS ESTATES LOT 2 R639480 C 4/02 91,500 90,405 92,822 .9740 TAYLOR OAKS ESTATES LOT 8 R639486 C 5/02 93,483 91,587 94,675 .9674 TAYLOR OAKS ESTATES LOT 12 R639490 C 6/02 82,170 95,790 83,078 1.1530 TAYLOR OAKS ESTATES LOT 18 R639496 C 5/02 93,764 100,323 94,959 1.0565 TAYLOR OAKS ESTATES LOT 56 R639534 C 5/02 100,900 95,376 102,186 .9334 PASEO LINDO PH 1, SHARYLAND PL R639585 C 5/02 123,200 144,712 124,770 1.1598 PASEO LINDO PH 1, SHARYLAND PL R639613 C 2/03 128,000 128,676 127,673 1.0079 PASEO LINDO PH 1, SHARYLAND PL R639615 C 4/02 120,675 129,612 122,419 1.0588 PASEO LINDO -1, SHARYLAND PLAN R639622 C 8/02 141,500 144,050 142,582 1.0103 PASEO LINDO PH 1, SHARYLAND PL R639636 C 4/02 142,900 144,456 144,965 .9965 PASEO LINDO PH 1, SHARYLAND PL R639637 C 7/02 123,500 153,442 124,655 1.2309 PASEO LINDO PH 2, SHARYLAND PL R639695 C 7/02 122,000 121,740 123,140 .9886

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 54 TIME: 14:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 108 Hidalgo 108-911 Sharyland CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ PASEO LINDO PH 2, SHARYLAND PL R639713 C 6/02 119,500 129,843 120,820 1.0747 PASEO LINDO PH 2, SHARYLAND PL R639720 C 11/02 152,000 151,180 152,387 .9921 PASEO LINDO PH 2, SHARYLAND PL R639726 C 6/02 126,000 126,822 127,392 .9955 PASEO LINDO -2, SHARYLAND PLAN R639727 C 6/02 122,000 165,857 123,348 1.3446 PASEO LINDO PH 2, SHARYLAND PL R639734 C 6/02 135,000 135,748 136,492 .9946 PASEO LINDO PH 2, SHARYLAND PL R639750 C 8/02 120,000 112,770 120,918 .9326 LOMA VERDE PH 2, SHARYLAND PLA R651120 C 12/02 108,478 117,405 108,570 1.0814 195 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9559 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ CIMARRON COUNTRY CLUB SECTN 1 R135336 C 2/02 34,900 33,200 34,900 .9513 CIMARRON COUNTRY CLUB SECTION R135413 C 6/02 40,000 39,845 40,000 .9961 CIMARRON COUNTRY CLUB SECTN 3 R135695 C 8/02 62,000 61,791 62,000 .9966 LAS VILLAS DE CIMARRON LOT 18 R216982 C 3/02 26,500 28,350 26,500 1.0698 JOHN H SHARY E168'-S411.53'-N6 R281844 C 4/02 50,000 50,040 50,000 1.0008 JOHN H SHARY LOT 458 S 130' OF R282600 C 8/02 45,000 39,794 45,000 .8843 JOHN H SHARY E 5.0 AC -W 10.0 R282918 C 11/02 58,500 67,900 58,500 1.1607 ZULEY MANOR LOT 8 R347592 C 6/02 53,000 52,715 53,000 .9946 PARADISE LAKE, LOT 6 R499495 C 9/02 36,500 35,648 36,500 .9767 THE GREENS AT CIMARRON LOT 29 R505448 C 9/02 90,000 76,891 90,000 .8543 THE GREENS AT CIMARRON LOT 30 R505449 C 6/03 68,000 70,486 68,000 1.0366 THE LAKEFRONT ESTATES AT CIMAR R514707 C 12/02 99,000 99,062 99,000 1.0006 RUBY LOT 5 R520231 C 9/02 62,000 61,827 62,000 .9972 PARADISE LAKE PH 2 LOT 10 R536450 C 9/02 41,000 39,947 41,000 .9743 SILVERADO SOUTH LOT 15 R545606 C 4/02 76,000 75,870 76,000 .9983 STEWART HEIGHTS LOT 3 R560618 C 5/02 53,000 51,767 53,000 .9767 CROWN POINTE PH 2 LOT 12 R569536 C 4/02 40,000 37,247 40,000 .9312 TRINITY GROVE AT CIMARRON LOT R574870 C 6/02 32,900 32,832 32,900 .9979 THE OAKLANDS LOT 4 R575046 C 6/02 57,000 55,504 57,000 .9738 SHARYLAND PLANTATION VILLAGE S R593186 C 4/02 125,000 125,979 125,000 1.0078 EBONY ESTATES LOT 27 R599586 C 2/02 20,900 22,598 20,900 1.0812 GLASSCOCK OAKS LOT 21 R613456 C 1/02 32,000 30,492 32,000 .9529 HADA2000 LOT 1 R622801 C 3/02 34,000 33,936 34,000 .9981 SHARYLAND PLNTN VILLAGE SOLERA R622821 C 5/02 114,000 107,012 114,000 .9387 CIMARRON COUNTRY CLUB SECTION R639091 C 6/02 42,000 37,444 42,000 .8915

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 55 TIME: 14:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 108 Hidalgo 108-911 Sharyland CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ SHARYLAND BUSINESS PARK #8 N41 R639136 C 3/02 460,429 347,371 460,429 .7500 CIMARRON COUNTRY CLUB SECTN 1 R644200 C 6/02 39,000 37,805 39,000 .9694 SERENDIPITY LOT 8 R654662 C 8/02 45,000 47,045 45,000 1.0454 LOS MILAGROS PH 2, SHARYLAND P R654937 C 6/02 70,000 55,140 70,000 .7877 LOS MILAGROS PH 2, SHARYLAND P R654948 C 9/02 85,000 79,966 85,000 .9408 LOS MILAGROS PH 2, SHARYLAND P R654949 C 8/02 85,000 80,392 85,000 .9458 LOS MILAGROS PH 2, SHARYLAND P R654950 C 1/03 92,000 91,899 92,000 1.0000 LOS MILAGROS PH 2, SHARYLAND P R654954 C 1/03 92,500 83,541 92,500 .9000 LOS MILAGROS PH 2, SHARYLAND P R654956 C 12/02 90,000 84,691 90,000 .9410 LOS MILAGROS PH 2, SHARYLAND P R654957 C 11/02 95,000 90,211 95,000 .9496 LOS MILAGROS PH 2, SHARYLAND P R654961 C 12/02 90,000 84,758 90,000 .9418 LOS MILAGROS PH 2, SHARYLAND P R654965 C 1/03 85,000 75,723 85,000 .8900 LOS MILAGROS PH 2, SHARYLAND P R654966 C 1/03 84,000 76,199 84,000 .9071 38 SALES CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER APPR VAL APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ L 146/PT PRIDE OF TX R262552 16,632 20,790 .8000 L 507/PT J H SHARY R282908 18,630 20,000 .9300 L 524/PT J H SHARY R283017 14,258 13,400 1.0600 L2 SPARKS & TOWNSEND PLAZA R534296 126,978 117,210 1.0800 L31 STEWART VLG -1 R605582 18,100 16,000 1.1300 L2 PLANT GRV R623942 164,031 149,508 1.1000 L3 CIMARRON CROSSING -2 R629917 474,860 474,860 1.0000 L17 B2 SHARYLAND WOODS R630349 12,690 11,216 1.1300 L3 SHARYLAND PLANT GRV HOTEL/B R631928 116,651 124,760 .9400 L52 TAYLOR OAKS EST R639530 12,544 12,544 1.0000 L65 TAYLOR OAKS EST R639543 14,490 14,490 1.0000 11 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9683 CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ JOHN H SHARY 15.40AC-S920.14'- R281178 C 10/02 769,760 983,850 .7824 JOHN H SHARY-N660' EXC W2.04AC R281309 C 5/02 426,615 430,000 .9921

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 56 TIME: 14:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 108 Hidalgo 108-911 Sharyland CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ JOHN H SHARY N416.13' LOT 267 R281369 C 8/02 159,520 159,520 1.0000 JOHN H SHARY .25 AC-E 190'-W58 R282328 C 10/02 168,605 175,000 .9635 JOHN H SHARY LT 417 W227.20'-E R282337 C 6/02 88,965 145,000 .6100 JOHN H SHARY N457.03'-S905.95' R457926 C 4/02 247,400 250,000 .9896 JOHN H SHARY E1.0AC FOR IMPS-S R531976 C 3/02 263,560 350,000 .7530 7 SALES CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER APPR VAL APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ L 326/PT J H SHARY R281759 215,810 218,042 .9900 L 447/PT J H SHARY R282494 152,550 160,609 .9500 L 507/PT J H SHARY R282909 285,649 243,730 1.1700 LT - A DEAN EST R505370 43,373 41,169 1.0500 4 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .8938 CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ L 47/PT SHARYLAND ORCH R283437 C 5/03 105,000 99,354 105,000 .9500 SPRINGFIELD PH 1 COMMERCIAL LO R534339 C 12/02 128,000 133,712 128,000 1.0446 UT-16 SHARY BUS CTR CONDOS R624492 C 4/03 207,900 128,145 207,900 .6200 UT-18 SHARY BUS CTR CONDOS R624494 C 1/03 277,250 225,350 277,250 .8100 4 SALES CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ L 1&2 GRAPEFRUIT BOWL R182167 .00 1.00 .00 625,393 628,303 1.0000 L 317/PT J H SHARY R281711 .00 1.00 .00 331,446 337,380 .9800 L11 B1 TIERRA GRANDE COMM PLA R304271 .00 1.00 .00 77,729 86,992 .8900

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 57 TIME: 14:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 108 Hidalgo 108-911 Sharyland CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ L 1/PT SHYLND PL R505361 .00 1.00 .00 6,552,052 6,873,791 .9500 L4 SPARKS & TOWNSEND PLAZA R534298 .00 1.00 .00 85,191 111,023 .7700 L1 B1 SPRINGFIELD -1 R534327 .00 1.00 .00 526,236 508,053 1.0400 L2 B1 SPRINGFIELD -1 R534328 .00 1.00 .00 159,118 153,682 1.0400 L 172 B2 SPRINGFIELD -1 R534344 .00 1.00 .00 473,386 413,133 1.1500 L18 RIVER OAKS PLAZA R568730 .00 1.00 .00 127,630 154,749 .8200 L1 TINSLETOWN R574046 .00 1.00 .00 8,379,483 8,400,305 1.0000 L11 B3 SHY GDNS R574181 .00 1.00 .00 322,112 370,223 .8700 L1 GONZALEZ, J R582113 .00 1.00 .00 438,194 449,692 .9700 LT-A WINFIELD EST R587225 .00 1.00 .00 1,448,618 1,595,103 .9100 L12 SHYLND BUS PK -1 R593191 .00 1.00 .00 3,222,861 3,193,433 1.0100 L10 SHYLND BUS PK R606134 .00 1.00 .00 4,662,970 4,504,409 1.0400 L 11/PT SHYLND BUS PK -1 R623973 .00 1.00 .00 3,164,844 3,352,719 .9400 L3 SHYLND SRV CTR -2 R639130 .00 1.00 .00 6,028,023 5,793,670 1.0400 L16 SHYLND BUS PK -2 R639138 .00 1.00 .00 13,331,410 13,736,827 .9700 18 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO WITH EXCEPTIONS: .9466 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ WAL - MART #395 P517447 8,029,990 7,917,406 1.0100 HOTTIE'S GRILL & BAR P565978 114,345 112,728 1.0100 TINSLETOWN U S A P582668 1,150,179 1,182,375 .9700 CLUB AT CIMARRON P590310 53,071 52,752 1.0100 WHATABURGER #719 P590341 181,404 194,905 .9300 L & L MFG OF CALIFORNIA P607017 2,457,514 2,413,292 1.0200 AUTO ZONE #1401 P618224 381,338 369,395 1.0300 FAMILY HLTH CTR OF MISSION P620009 43,583 40,637 1.0700 RENEE'S P620136 135,397 152,560 .8900 PANASONIC SRVS P624336 12,899,902 12,887,730 1.0000 EMERSON ELECTRIC P625260 6,229,510 6,168,817 1.0100 JAGUAR CREDIT P625675 927,792 976,477 .9500 SUBWAY P632391 48,600 55,728 .8700 HAWTHORN SUITES P638698 633,973 627,889 1.0100 SYMBOL TECH P640275 133,733,189 133,084,857 1.0000 BANK OF AMERICA LSE P642746 75,787 76,034 1.0000 16 APPRAISALS

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 58 TIME: 14:40 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 108 Hidalgo 108-911 Sharyland STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO WITH EXCEPTIONS: 1.0003