School and Appraisal Districts' Property Value Study 2003 Preliminary Report

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 6 TIME: 14:34 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 104 Haskell 104-902 Rochester CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER MOD OBS APPR VAL APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AB 898 CAROTHERS BLK 45 TR 8 R00109 .88 .00 35,930 37,588 .9600 ORIGINAL TOWN BLK 16 LOT 3-6 R00111 .88 .00 21,000 21,941 .9600 A B CAROTHERS BLK 24 TR 2 R00327 .88 .00 11,160 10,717 1.0400 AB 900 A B CAROTHERS BLK 26 L R00369 .88 .00 35,100 32,788 1.0700 ABST 100 A B CAROTHERS BLK 17 R00370 .88 .00 47,780 41,167 1.1600 ORIG TOWN BLK 25 LOT 5&^ ROCH R00676 .88 .00 19,280 28,072 .6900 AB 100 A B CAROTHERS ROCHESTER R00797 .88 .00 37,280 33,464 1.1100 A B CAROTHERS ADD BLK 24 TR 3 R00798 .88 .00 9,850 13,328 .7400 ABST 100 A B CAROTHERS R00970 .88 .00 59,840 55,056 1.0900 A B CAROTHERS BLK 1 TR 2 R01021 .88 .00 9,295 10,573 .8800 A B CAROTHERS BLK 5 LOT 1 (NEC R01742 .88 .00 19,510 20,388 .9600 ABST 898 CAROTHERS BLK 45 H&TC R02095 .88 .00 53,670 48,060 1.1200 A B CARTOHERS BLK 6 LOT 6 R02226 .88 .00 38,420 34,805 1.1000 ORIGINAL TOWN BLK 33 LOT 9-12 R02609 .88 .00 41,330 39,350 1.0500 AB 700 A B CAROTHERS BLK 9 LOT R02733 .88 .00 48,250 41,635 1.1600 ORIGINAL TOWN BLK 32 LOT 1 R02915 .88 .00 15,340 16,349 .9400 ORIGINAL TOWN BLK 11 LOT 1-3 R03286 .88 .00 11,670 10,634 1.1000 ABST 100 A B CAROTHERS BLK 8 L R04153 .88 .00 41,030 37,770 1.0900 ORIGINAL TOWN BLK 38 LOT 1-3 N R04234 .88 .00 43,520 43,908 .9900 A B CAROTHERS BLK 6 LOT 4 & 5 R04460 .88 .00 13,090 15,146 .8600 AB 700 A B CAROTHERS BLK 13 TR R04999 .88 .00 11,140 11,373 .9800 A B CAROTHERS BLK 13 TR 1 (NEC R05046 .88 .00 27,100 28,791 .9400 AB 1000 A B CAROTHERS BLK 18 L R05344 .88 .00 54,800 50,992 1.0700 ROCHESTER A B CAROTHERS BLK 11 R05359 .88 .00 18,520 20,029 .9200 A B CAROTHERS ROCHESTER BLK 2 R05448 .88 .00 53,460 50,645 1.0600 A B CAROTHERS BLK 4 LOT 3-5 R05587 .88 .00 12,010 14,473 .8300 ABST 700 BLK 10 LOT 7 & 8 R06427 .88 .00 46,050 39,768 1.1600 A B CAROTHERS BLK 15 LOT 9-12 R06523 .88 .00 49,910 44,290 1.1300 A B CAROTHERS BLK 28 LOT 3-6 R06872 .88 .00 10,310 10,664 .9700 ORIGINAL TOWN BLK 38 LOTS 1-3 R31530 .88 .00 43,520 40,560 1.0700 30 APPRAISALS WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9865 CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ABST WCRR CO SUR 1 TRACT 2A AC R07551 W 11/02 67,200 100,000 .6700 1 SALES

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 7 TIME: 14:34 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 104 Haskell 104-902 Rochester CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER APPR VAL APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ABST 405 WISE CO SCHOOL LAND R00519 39,060 42,000 .9300 ABST 672 WEST A SUR #4 TRACT # R02206 178,640 189,197 .9400 ABST 1 ALFORD GEO SUR # 43 TR R02686 22,800 26,110 .8700 AB 262 H&TC RR SUR 229 BLK 45 R03929 24,270 24,458 .9900 ABST 262 H&TC RR CO SUR #229 B R03931 36,380 34,901 1.0400 ABST WHITTEN J D SUR #111 TR 3 R06383 66,390 77,891 .8500 AB 413 WILSON JANE TR 7 ACES 5 R07028 22,620 25,785 .8800 ABST 347 RED RIVER CSL SUR #75 R07075 46,780 50,000 .9400 ABST 347 RED RIVER CSL SUR #75 R07103 76,370 72,184 1.0580 ABST 347 RED RIVER CSL ACRES 1 R07105 71,370 75,000 .9500 ABST 347 RED RIVER CO SCHOOL L R07128 44,670 42,500 1.0500 ABST 347 RED RIVER CSL ACS 200 R07174 65,330 70,000 .9300 ABST 364 SLAYDON ARTHUR SUR #5 R07247 27,790 28,180 .9900 ABST 328 MONTGOMERY J TR 4 ACS R07464 21,640 24,000 .9000 ABST 329 MCCLANAHAN TR 3 ACRES R07499 24,980 26,211 .9500 ABST 413 WILSON JANE TR 1 ACS R07542 56,120 57,140 .9800 ABST 453 W C RR CO SUR #1 TR 5 R07576 27,710 27,375 1.0100 ABST 455 W C RR CO SUR 3 TR 1 R07579 46,580 49,350 .9400 ABST 450 W C RR CO SUR 1 TR 2C R12208 49,200 44,320 1.1101 ABST 929 JUSTICE FEEDONY SUR 2 R24177 60,470 69,080 .8800 20 APPRAISALS WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9314 CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE.