Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   1/22/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:      3
TIME:     14:32                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             102  Harrison
                                                         102-902  Marshall

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  HOL132BSWVOL132-ISW              R0000904 R0000905          W      11/02         20,000          32,110        20,000    1.6055
  HL5B11MOCKINGBIRDHILL3RD         R0001136                   B       7/02         96,000          87,500        96,000     .9115
  H L7-8 B2 IRVINE                 R0001279                   C      10/02         42,000          38,310        42,000     .9100
  HOL15&14NE                       R0001323                   O       5/02         20,000          33,700        20,000    1.6850
  H L2 B8 JASPER 3RD               R0001351                   C       1/03         72,000          69,860        72,000     .9700
  H L4-5 B3 H L SMITH              R0001610                   S       6/02        113,000         109,960       113,000     .9700
  H L4 B7 S-4                      R0001926                   C      11/02        184,500         209,200       184,500    1.1300
  HLE761W/PT2B4ZEPHYR              R0002250                   B       6/02        107,000          92,260       107,000     .8622
  HL1B3PORTCADDOACRES              R0002947                   B       6/02         69,900          70,270        69,900    1.0053
  H L2 B-C W R BARNES              R0003027                   C      11/02        109,000         101,430       109,000     .9300
  HLW/PT1B17LONGINOTTI             R0003182                   W      10/02         40,000          21,540        40,000     .5385
  HL10-11B2GLENDALE                R0003774                   B      11/02         72,500          81,940        72,500    1.1302
  H2ACAB49PALSTON                  R0004218                   B      11/02         63,500          64,160        63,500    1.0104
  H L10 B10 SOUTH HIGHLANDS        R0005261                   C       7/02         90,000         101,150        90,000    1.1200
  H2.825AB10HHALL                  R0005976                   O       8/02         82,000          88,700        82,000    1.0817
  H L30 HIDDEN LAKE                R0006117                   C       4/02        190,000         134,390       190,000     .7100
  H L1 B2 N COLLEGE SEC I          R0006551                   C      12/02         90,000          85,770        90,000     .9500
  H L8 B6 JASPER 3RD               R0006606                   C       9/02         53,000          58,260        53,000    1.1000
  HLPT2B6SUNSET1ST                 R0007023                   B       8/02         53,500          48,160        53,500     .9002
  HL1N/22B7SUGARCREEKS1            R0007234                   B       4/02         70,000          70,910        70,000    1.0130
  HL8-9B4BELAIR                    R0007258                   B       5/02         75,000          88,820        75,000    1.1843
  HL5-6B1COUNTRYCLUBESTS1          R0007365                   B       6/02        125,000         140,620       125,000    1.1250
  H L4 B9 SOUTH HIGHLANDS          R0007707                   C       4/02        120,750         105,470       120,750     .8700
  HL10MARTINDALE                   R0008346                   W      11/02         35,000          50,060        35,000    1.4303
  HLPT4B2COXHESTERPOWER            R0008714                   S       4/02         48,000          49,710        48,000    1.0356
  HL1B8LOUGHMOIN&LW601B1WINGWOOD   R0008842                   B      10/02        110,000         111,820       110,000    1.0165
  HL9B9BELAIR                      R0009080                   B       6/02         55,100          66,000        55,100    1.1978
  HOL113DSE                        R0009174                   W       8/02         25,000          32,800        25,000    1.3120
  HL3PT2-4B3SHADYACRESS3AB404ALA   R0009419                   B      11/02        185,000         182,730       185,000     .9877
  HL3-4B4LOUGHMOIN                 R0009536                   B       7/02         69,000          49,390        69,000     .7158
  HL5N/PT6B6HLSMITH                R0009729                   B       8/02        112,000         127,260       112,000    1.1400
  HOL48BPT48SE                     R0009801                   B       8/02         96,500         109,370        96,500    1.1334
  HL910PTL8B4BSHADYACRES           R0009803                   B       7/02        320,000         278,520       320,000     .8704
  H L18 B3 MOCKINGBIRD HILL        R0009997                   C       8/02         54,000          64,480        54,000    1.1900
  HL2B3PINEHAVEN                   R0010993                   S      12/02         55,500          56,360        55,500    1.0155
  H L12 B2 MEADOWBROOK             R0011028                   C       1/03         38,000          32,380        38,000     .8500
  HL20B4S3SHADOWOODLAKEEST         R0011060                   S       5/02        157,000         124,470       157,000     .7928
  H L9 PT 8 B4 MEDILL & BOM        R0011500                   C      12/02         49,227          45,310        49,227     .9200
  HL10TANGLEWOODWESTU1&.459AB361   R0011534                   B      11/02         78,500          77,260        78,500     .9842
  H L1 B1 HILLCREST                R0011783                   C       1/03         69,900          70,120        69,900    1.0000
  HL11PT/L10SOUTHWOODHTS           R0011800                   B       4/02         66,500          58,620        66,500     .8815
  HL4MOCKINGBIRDHILL4TH            R0011810                   B       5/02         94,000         112,410        94,000    1.1959
  HL14B1S1SHADOWOODLAKEEST         R0011835                   S       9/02        156,566         128,550       156,566     .8211
  HL12B2SHADYACRES                 R0011937                   B       9/02         80,000          79,120        80,000     .9890
  HL7B3SOUTHERNMANORS2U1           R0012052                   B       5/02        115,000         113,070       115,000     .9832
  HL14B9PARKVIEW                   R0012128                   W      10/02         18,000          24,590        18,000    1.3661
  H L5 N25 7 B6 BEL AIR 1ST        R0012801                   C       1/03         57,000          70,830        57,000    1.2400

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 4 TIME: 14:32 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 102 Harrison 102-902 Marshall CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ H 4.15 AC R0012804 C 3/03 59,000 64,140 59,000 1.0900 H4.575ACAB608WBRHEA R0012924 O 7/02 49,000 61,270 49,000 1.2504 H OL 6C NW R0013410 C 3/03 90,000 89,460 90,000 .9900 H PT/OL 264B NW R0014814 C 6/02 60,500 56,630 60,500 .9400 H L7 B1 MADELYN R0014933 C 3/03 70,000 72,860 70,000 1.0400 HL5B1JASPER2ND R0015107 B 8/02 47,895 52,830 47,895 1.1030 HLN/PT5B4HARPERJHARRIS R0015451 W 5/02 35,000 41,110 35,000 1.1746 HL4B21RAINEY R0015597 B 11/02 40,000 33,680 40,000 .8420 HL8B5SOUTHHIGHLANDS R0015725 B 8/02 94,500 97,340 94,500 1.0301 HLW851B9SUNSET2ND R0017244 B 4/02 76,000 83,850 76,000 1.1033 HL12B5HESTERPOWER R0017245 B 7/02 36,500 31,560 36,500 .8647 H L14 B14 BEL AIR 1ST R0017310 Y 10/02 53,000 58,480 53,000 1.1000 HL7B2BRASSELL R0017364 B 11/02 68,500 67,900 68,500 .9912 HL2B33RAILROADW40L1&4B3S23E80L R0017520 B 10/02 52,500 55,610 52,500 1.0592 HL2B1HLSMITH R0018231 B 8/02 90,000 91,550 90,000 1.0172 H L16 EASTMOOR R0018615 C 1/03 126,000 130,400 126,000 1.0300 HL3-4PT2B4HILLCREST R0019006 O 6/02 45,000 76,720 45,000 1.7049 H 10 AC AB 15 S MURPHY R0019225 C 8/02 90,000 77,500 90,000 .8600 H1ACL3AB400ALANGFORD R0019284 S 6/02 75,000 77,030 75,000 1.0271 HL7-8B1GLENDALE&V80X135AB12JHA R0019564 B 5/02 72,500 66,990 72,500 .9240 HL12B1BRASSELL R0019700 O 7/02 58,000 63,270 58,000 1.0909 H L1 B10 SOUTH HIGHLANDS R0019795 Y 6/02 154,500 128,130 154,500 .8300 HL6B6SOUTHHIGHLANDS R0019798 B 8/02 103,000 99,430 103,000 .9653 HL10B1SOUTHERNMANORS2U1 R0020180 S 8/02 98,000 93,600 98,000 .9551 HOL42NW R0020889 S 8/02 79,500 83,800 79,500 1.0541 HL5B6COUNTRYCLUBESTU2 R0021322 W 7/02 78,000 104,800 78,000 1.3436 HL6B5MADELYN R0021352 B 10/02 72,000 73,530 72,000 1.0213 HL7B1NACIREMA2ND R0022126 B 7/02 51,000 47,880 51,000 .9388 HL3B5LOUGHMOIN R0022214 B 8/02 76,000 67,070 76,000 .8825 HPTB6JASPERHTS1ST R0022248 O 8/02 81,300 74,810 81,300 .9202 HOL274BNW R0022894 B 4/02 44,000 54,670 44,000 1.2425 HL2B6COUNTRYCLUBS1 R0023361 W 7/02 103,000 85,940 103,000 .8344 H L8 B1 R0023745 C 12/02 125,000 98,430 125,000 .7900 H L12 B7 HIGHLAND ACRES S R0023755 C 9/02 220,000 235,290 220,000 1.0700 HL5B9MOCKINGBIRDHILL2ND R0024125 S 4/02 84,500 80,420 84,500 .9517 H L20-21 PT/L22 R0024914 C 1/03 85,000 81,660 85,000 .9600 HL5B1TRAVISHTS R0025277 S 7/02 69,000 65,600 69,000 .9507 HL3B8HIGHLANDACRESSECTION4 R0025295 B 6/02 137,500 122,790 137,500 .8930 HL9PT8B3CFADAMS R0025345 B 11/02 109,000 99,110 109,000 .9093 HL30B1HIGHLANDACRESS4 R0025600 S 4/02 155,000 139,660 155,000 .9010 HL1B1SHERWOODPARK R0025880 S 5/02 64,500 70,280 64,500 1.0896 H L S/2 1-2 B5 R0026053 C 5/02 34,500 30,890 34,500 .8954 HL9B12SOUTHHIGHLANDS R0026511 O 10/02 106,000 94,950 106,000 .8958 H L5 B9 BEL AIR R0026603 C 4/02 37,000 47,540 37,000 1.2800 HL7B2PINECREST R0027981 W 11/02 28,500 29,130 28,500 1.0221 H 1.001 AC AB 571 T PERRY R0028569 C 9/02 85,000 76,690 85,000 .9000 H.959ACAB400ALANGFORD R0029113 B 7/02 49,500 46,960 49,500 .9487

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 5 TIME: 14:32 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 102 Harrison 102-902 Marshall CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ HL22B4SHADOWOODLAKEESTS3 R0029207 S 5/02 210,000 196,030 210,000 .9300 HL18B1S3HIGHLANDACRES R0029594 B 6/02 99,000 85,880 99,000 .8675 H L E/2 3 B14 LONGINOTTI R0029611 C 5/02 35,000 35,280 35,000 1.0080 H L4 B1 CAROLYN HTS R0029651 C 1/03 60,000 54,430 60,000 .9100 H6.162ACAB1HBLOSSOM R0029941 B 9/02 199,900 142,360 199,900 .7122 HPT/OL293CNW R0030025 W 11/02 18,500 19,540 18,500 1.0562 HL20B3CFADAMS R0030102 B 10/02 48,000 44,430 48,000 .9256 HL1B5S1SOUTHERNMANOR R0030157 B 11/02 107,900 102,370 107,900 .9487 HOL4NW R0030858 B 8/02 175,000 148,700 175,000 .8497 HL5-7TWYMAN R0030863 S 10/02 164,500 143,770 164,500 .8740 HL2B1ACHESTER R0030876 S 10/02 57,000 58,880 57,000 1.0330 H L6 B4 HILLCREST R0031023 C 3/03 52,000 56,090 52,000 1.0800 H L6 B5 MEDILL & BOMAR R0031645 C 4/02 34,500 29,340 34,500 .8500 HL1-2B1CONWAY&COCK R0031769 B 12/02 25,181 31,800 25,181 1.2629 HL5-6B3PINEHAVEN R0032067 S 6/02 68,000 69,280 68,000 1.0188 HLPT7B2HARPER R0032293 B 5/02 41,200 38,930 41,200 .9449 HOL86-86C-69-69A-69B-70B-83-84 R0032485 S 6/02 185,000 227,240 185,000 1.2283 HL5B1MATTHEWSONPARK R0032575 W 8/02 21,441 29,150 21,441 1.3595 H L3B B6 ADAMS R0032952 Y 9/02 61,000 57,380 61,000 .9400 HL3B5HLSMITH R0033020 B 11/02 72,000 73,540 72,000 1.0214 HL13B4CEDARCREST R0033249 S 10/02 83,000 72,190 83,000 .8698 HL31HIDDENLAKEAB391PLINDSEY R0033314 B 11/02 88,500 85,880 88,500 .9704 H L3 B2 PINE SHADOWS R0033341 C 3/03 51,000 57,520 51,000 1.1300 HL3B10BELAIR R0033355 W 12/02 62,000 37,020 62,000 .5971 HL4B3COUNTRYCLUBESTS1 R0034380 B 7/02 98,000 105,750 98,000 1.0791 HL1&.136ACOAKCREEKPL2 R0034577 B 7/02 68,900 75,830 68,900 1.1006 HL34SOUTHFIELDESTAB10HHALL R0034638 B 11/02 74,900 84,260 74,900 1.1250 H L7 W/2 8 B3 C F ADAMS R0035308 C 3/03 59,900 53,650 59,900 .9000 HL15B4ROSBOROUGH&BYRNE R0035510 B 7/02 64,000 57,930 64,000 .9052 H L15 B9 R0035859 C 3/03 115,000 109,270 115,000 .9500 H L7 B6 R0036251 C 7/02 80,544 77,550 80,544 .9600 H L5 B7 R0036655 C 3/03 78,500 78,970 78,500 1.0100 HL5B3MOCKINGBIRDHILL R0037244 B 8/02 64,200 60,250 64,200 .9385 HL5B3SLONE R0037478 B 7/02 105,000 100,410 105,000 .9563 HL8B14BELAIR1ST R0037614 O 5/02 60,000 76,200 60,000 1.2700 HL10B7HIGHLANDACRESS3 R0037751 W 8/02 170,000 141,070 170,000 .8298 H PT/OL 262 SW R0037790 C 8/02 86,000 90,480 86,000 1.0500 HL12B11MOCKINGBIRDHILL3RD R0037829 B 8/02 81,000 75,130 81,000 .9275 HL25B13BELAIR1ST R0037959 B 9/02 80,000 77,670 80,000 .9709 H L PT 3 B3 DEUPREE R0038004 C 3/03 23,500 21,880 23,500 .9311 HL2B5SOUTHERNMANOR R0038150 S 8/02 126,800 122,140 126,800 .9632 H L2-3 B3 TURNER R0038151 Y 8/02 26,000 22,450 26,000 .8600 HPT/OL252A&N14252C-252DSW R0038176 B 6/02 88,000 57,950 88,000 .6585 HL9-10B5MADELYN R0038358 O 5/02 80,000 91,760 80,000 1.1470 H5.4ACAB135ECARROLL R0039135 B 11/02 151,596 151,390 151,596 .9986 HL1B1MEADOWOODALANGFORDAB400 R0039647 S 8/02 127,000 121,200 127,000 .9543 HL18B2SHERWOODPARK R0039751 O 12/02 213,000 200,990 213,000 .9436

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 6 TIME: 14:32 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 102 Harrison 102-902 Marshall CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ HL27B5SOUTHERNMANORS2U2 R0040437 S 7/02 140,000 132,300 140,000 .9450 HL30B5SOUTHERNMANORS2U2 R0040440 B 10/02 136,300 134,020 136,300 .9833 HL19B2CYPHERSU3 R0044282 B 6/02 175,000 146,710 175,000 .8383 H L PT 5 B3 CYPHERS U 3 R0044289 C 5/02 139,500 125,740 139,500 .9000 HL11S/212B3CYPHERSU3 R0044295 S 11/02 215,000 202,480 215,000 .9418 HL10B1PECANRIDGEU2 R0044314 B 6/02 70,000 65,430 70,000 .9347 H L2 B2 R0044512 C 3/03 105,000 116,840 105,000 1.1100 HN80L5MOCKINGBIRDLANE R0047664 B 11/02 122,500 110,890 122,500 .9052 HL3B3S2SUGARCREEK R0047733 O 11/02 65,000 64,740 65,000 .9960 H6ACAB1HBLOSSOM R0047769 B 8/02 30,495 42,540 30,495 1.3950 HL2B3PARKPLACEEU1 R0048276 B 6/02 107,500 97,590 107,500 .9078 H L9 B2 S-2 R0048846 Y 12/02 29,500 29,290 29,500 .9900 H5ACAB10HHALL R0049008 B 4/02 210,000 193,540 210,000 .9216 H1ACAB1HBLOSSOMV15.61ACAB1HBLO R0050354 R0045785 B 6/02 139,500 123,880 139,500 .8880 H L13 B4 R0050632 C 7/02 118,000 121,010 118,000 1.0300 HL15B4SOUTHERNMANORS2U3 R0050634 S 9/02 150,000 145,860 150,000 .9724 HL34B5SOUTHERNMANORS2U3 R0050661 S 10/02 137,000 134,060 137,000 .9785 HL1AB6SOUTHERNMANORS2U3 R0050667 B 9/02 133,000 129,760 133,000 .9756 HL36B7SOUTHERNMANORS2U4 R0056039 O 6/02 182,000 171,480 182,000 .9422 HL5B8SOUTHERNMANORS2U4 R0056047 B 10/02 160,000 150,000 160,000 .9375 H PT L8 B-4B R0063442 Y 11/02 241,000 197,890 241,000 .8200 H8.172ACAB744LWALLACE R0063603 B 7/02 147,500 133,250 147,500 .9034 HTR7AB568NBPHILLIPS R0064709 B 6/02 167,500 171,880 167,500 1.0261 HL2B4PINEHAVEN R0066333 S 10/02 70,000 81,510 70,000 1.1644 H L9 SCOTTSVILLE CROSSING R0067361 C 1/03 160,000 161,460 160,000 1.0100 HL3W/PTL2B8S2U4SOUTHERNMANOR R0067655 B 7/02 130,000 138,580 130,000 1.0660 H 1.73 AC R0068244 C 7/02 134,000 128,800 134,000 .9600 HL1CLARASSUBAB15SMURPHY R0068648 W 1/03 279,000 200,950 279,000 .7203 HL5PARKPLACEADDNU2 R0072364 O 8/02 162,500 147,650 162,500 .9086 MH L6 HERITAGE PARK R0073790 C 3/03 70,000 63,690 70,000 .9100 MH4.09ACAB135ECARROLL198929X45 R8956959 O 5/02 40,000 45,890 40,000 1.1473 172 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9805 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE.

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 7 TIME: 14:32 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 102 Harrison 102-902 Marshall CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ VUND100.5ACAB750LWATKINS R0002273 W 6/02 3,760 6,250 .6016 V 4.735 AC AB 12 J HARRIS R0011557 R0067234 C 8/02 28,700 40,000 .7175 V 12.211 AC R0018465 C 10/02 24,420 24,000 1.0175 V41.5ACAB1HBLOSSOM R0020433 W 3/02 17,850 12,000 1.4875 V22.085ACAB754WMWALKER R0028615 W 1/02 11,040 12,500 .8832 H 3.28 AC R0028654 C 6/02 9,790 9,500 1.0305 H5.98ACAB10HHALL R0031265 B 6/02 123,220 139,000 .8865 V70ACAB472WMMCKINNEY R0032391 W 8/02 64,050 120,000 .5338 V L4 WOODLAWN OAKS R0046598 C 8/02 22,800 25,000 .9120 V25ACAB538JPAGE R0050757 W 9/02 37,500 50,000 .7500 V L7 CROSS CREEK RANCH R0069987 C 1/03 43,220 44,500 .9712 V45ACTRBAB10HHALL R0075871 W 9/02 33,750 23,750 1.4211 V 7 AC R8956981 C 4/02 8,400 15,000 .5600 V2ACAB15SMURPHY R8956983 W 7/02 2,400 4,000 .6000 V10ACAB789SWAGLEY R8957115 W 9/02 15,000 12,000 1.2500 15 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .8296 CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BLDW30OFE53OFL3-4&20INL3B35OTS R0004755 -4756 -4779 W 11/02 87,500 72,300 87,500 .8263 BLD L N/PT 6 B29 ORIGINAL R0007446 C 1/03 65,000 68,230 65,000 1.0497 BLD L1 PT 3 B8 GILLUM R0019719 C 2/02 130,000 90,320 130,000 .6948 IMP OL 90-I NE R0038224 C 12/02 45,000 39,920 45,000 .8871 MOTEL 8.143 AC R8957505 C 12/02 1,400,000 1,406,470 1,400,000 1.0046 5 SALES CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BLD L2 PT L1 B2 JASPER HTS R0005972 .00 1.00 .00 613,250 557,303 1.1000 BLD OL 111 SW R0006506 .00 1.00 .00 458,950 434,137 1.0600 BLD B25 ORIGINAL TOWN R0010054 .00 1.00 .00 1,814,350 1,908,316 .9500 IMP 1 AC AB 20 B ROGERS R0010970 .00 1.00 .00 234,280 163,863 1.4300 STR PT/OL 89A NE R0011833 .00 1.00 .00 106,750 136,178 .7800 STR L3-4 B19 TURNER R0013223 .00 1.00 .00 34,570 67,244 .5100

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 8 TIME: 14:32 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 102 Harrison 102-902 Marshall CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BLD L1-3 PT 4 B34 ORIGINAL TWN R0020779 .00 1.00 .00 75,650 107,178 .7100 IMP L8 PT3-4 N/2 5-7 B8 MERZBA R0026216 .00 1.00 .00 153,120 185,275 .8300 BLD OL 71A N/PT 71 NE R0032699 .00 1.00 .00 778,660 785,706 .9900 B 6.86 AC AB 400 A LANGFORD R0037059 .00 1.00 .00 569,870 751,545 .7600 BLD L1 B10 MERZBACHER R0037819 .00 1.00 .00 204,910 229,722 .8900 MOTEL 2.295 AC AB 538 J PAGE R0047387 .00 1.00 .00 1,137,910 794,530 1.4300 B 37.422 AC AB 20 B ROGERS R0048331 .00 1.00 .00 5,450,810 5,548,984 .9800 IMP 4.289 AC AB 20 B ROGERS R0050340 .00 1.00 .00 259,500 278,272 .9300 IMP PT/OL 66 67 68H 68 K NE B3 R0053386 .00 1.00 .00 1,480,290 1,544,968 .9600 B L PT 1-2 B-B W R BARNES R0059488 .00 1.00 .00 1,304,060 1,472,715 .8900 BLD L1 B2 T WHALEY PT OL 89 B R0067256 .00 1.00 .00 642,070 686,978 .9300 B .8 AC AB 10 H HALL R0068902 .00 1.00 .00 196,610 230,222 .8500 B L1 B1 NORTHPARK W 30 CLOSED R0071950 .00 1.00 .00 341,580 348,735 .9800 AB 571 T PERRY R0074982 .00 1.00 .00 332,210 397,053 .8400 20 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9203 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BROOKSHIRES GROCERY CO # 36 R0041634 1,452,460 1,331,745 1.0900 DOLGENCORP STORE #0286 R0041777 253,440 246,143 1.0300 EDWARD JONES & CO LP R0042037 19,900 16,468 1.2100 THE DRUG SHOP R0042626 152,660 133,984 1.1400 ECKERD DRUG #2247 R0047214 1,056,180 1,035,585 1.0200 RENT-WAY OF TTIG LP #1015 R0051736 175,370 313,897 .5600 WAL-MART STORES TEXAS LP #0191 R0053920 7,167,590 6,922,978 1.0400 MERRYTIMER PRODUCTS INC R0055083 226,870 188,340 1.2000 GELCO CORP R0056187 162,950 146,475 1.1100 LAMAR ADVERTISING OF TYLER R0058336 510,190 543,719 .9400 MAULDIN DAVID PHOTOGRAPHY R0058711 86,290 92,902 .9300 IOS CAPITAL R0061581 447,130 574,767 .7800 CINDY'S TRAVEL EMPORIUM INC R0064588 29,360 29,825 .9800 CALIFORNIA COMMUNICATIONS LLC R0068997 45,280 41,392 1.0900 HOME & GARDEN PARTY INC R0069128 17,534,680 16,070,967 1.0900 BID ROTH TRUST R0069177 60,980 49,692 1.2300 BUTCH LAWRASON R0072614 80,000 80,350 1.0000 ABC AUTO PARTS R0073660 370,890 375,857 .9900 O REILLY AUTO PARTS #399 R0075137 361,150 355,993 1.0100 WENDY'S INTERNATIONAL INC R0075245 220,540 218,587 1.0100 GREATAMERICA LEASING R0075877 21,300 21,948 .9700

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 9 TIME: 14:32 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 102 Harrison 102-902 Marshall CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ CBI LEASING INC R0076215 49,290 39,753 1.2400 WALGREENS #0691-S-PPT R8956198 469,180 449,745 1.0400 KENNY M HALL MD 0059764 195,000 168,626 1.1600 24 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO WITH EXCEPTIONS: 1.0181