Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   1/22/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:     62
TIME:     14:29                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             101  Harris
                                                         101-912  Houston

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  S-4  1111                        0051810000010              C       7/02        236,750         265,300       243,261    1.0906
  S-4  152                         0051920000001              C      12/02        179,000         241,400       179,447    1.3452
  S-3  111                         0141910000473              C      12/02        145,000         133,000       145,362     .9150
  S-2  152                         0152150030053              C      10/02         95,000          73,900        96,188     .7683
  S-4  152                         0200500000053              C       8/02        282,500         281,400       288,856     .9742
  S-2  111                         0200750000001              C      12/02         78,000          94,300        78,195    1.2060
  S-3  111                         0201300000012              C      12/02        187,000         187,000       187,467     .9975
  S-5  152                         0201540000013              C       2/03        765,000         643,900       759,262     .8481
  S-3  152                         0202100000019              C      12/02         99,000         120,100        99,248    1.2101
  S-4  152                         0202220000035              C       2/03        590,000         473,200       585,575     .8081
  S-5  152                         0261470000010              C       7/02        468,000         512,000       480,870    1.0647
  S-4  1521                        0261920010002              C       7/02        230,000         243,600       236,325    1.0308
  S-2  1111                        0283250050002              C       5/02         78,000          78,000        80,925     .9639
  S-3  1521                        0291720040012              C       6/02        231,000         194,700       238,507     .8163
  S-4  1111                        0331970000014              C       7/02        365,000         371,100       375,037     .9895
  S-4  152                         0350170310013              C       2/03        373,000         403,000       370,202    1.0886
  S-3  152                         0373120030009              C      10/02        165,000         150,800       167,062     .9027
  S-3  111                         0373150090004              C      10/02        169,000         169,000       171,112     .9877
  S-5  1421                        0393100000003              C       6/02      1,500,000       1,553,800     1,548,750    1.0033
  S-4  1211                        0511170050019              C       4/02        285,000         299,400       297,112    1.0077
  S-4  152                         0520600660013              C       9/02        385,000         372,500       391,737     .9509
  S-4  152                         0520610400008              C       9/02        250,000         255,600       254,375    1.0048
  S-4  171                         0520650160021              C       5/02        465,000         379,800       482,437     .7873
  S-3  152                         0520800070019              C       1/03        175,000         179,400       174,562    1.0277
  S-4  111                         0522650000006              C       2/03        230,000         281,800       228,275    1.2345
  S-4  152                         0540900000009              C       3/03        577,500         467,000       570,281     .8189
  S-4  1521                        0541200000023              C       5/02        409,500         382,400       424,856     .9001
  S-5  152                         0550990450010              C      12/02        910,000         969,900       912,275    1.0632
  S-5  111                         0560170000064              C       5/02        945,000         877,500       980,437     .8950
  S-4  111                         0571770000009              C       6/02        360,000         331,000       371,700     .8905
  S-5  152                         0571780000003              C       6/02        639,900         582,900       660,697     .8823
  S-5  152                         0580220000001              C      10/02        705,000         622,300       713,812     .8718
  S-5  111                         0590370000016              C      11/02        490,000         551,400       493,675    1.1169
  S-5  111                         0590440000027              C       4/02        483,000         523,100       503,527    1.0389
  S-5  1211                        0590500000009              C       7/02        814,000         728,400       836,385     .8709
  S-4  111                         0600250000011              C       7/02        300,000         274,800       308,250     .8915
  S-5  152                         0600260000005              C      10/02        790,000         766,600       799,875     .9584
  S-5  1521                        0600320000009              C       4/02        510,000         515,300       531,675     .9692
  S-5  111                         0600360100009              C       7/02        523,000         510,600       537,382     .9502
  S-4  111                         0600360260017              C       7/02        389,000         343,200       399,697     .8586
  S-5  1111                        0601150040003              C       5/02        660,000         648,300       684,750     .9468
  S-5  152                         0601390000003              C      12/02      1,100,000       1,132,100     1,102,750    1.0266
  S-5  152                         0601520330003              C      12/02      2,170,000       2,541,400     2,175,425    1.1682
  S-5  171                         0601540390016              C       7/02        560,000         687,800       575,400    1.1953
  S-5  152                         0601560510007              C       7/02        739,000         670,200       759,322     .8826
  S-5  142                         0601590570008              C       7/02      1,055,000       1,026,100     1,084,013     .9466
  S-5  152                         0601600680002              C       6/02        855,000         988,700       882,787    1.1200

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 63 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-912 Houston CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ S-3 111 0620710000014 C 3/03 209,500 197,700 206,881 .9556 S-3 111 0621020000002 C 5/02 162,000 154,300 168,075 .9180 S-3 111 0621230000008 C 12/02 170,000 188,100 170,425 1.1037 S-4 1521 0630270030034 C 5/02 382,000 346,800 396,325 .8750 S-4 152 0640890000021 C 2/03 379,000 410,000 376,157 1.0900 S-4 152 0641130000024 C 6/02 227,000 231,800 234,377 .9890 S-4 152 0660450040026 C 3/03 221,800 224,000 219,027 1.0227 S-4 111 0660450160021 C 10/02 237,000 238,500 239,962 .9939 S-3 131 0660460360021 C 6/02 128,000 154,900 132,160 1.1721 S-2 1521 0660640230035 C 6/02 103,000 99,500 106,347 .9356 S-5 131 0681250120021 C 12/02 546,500 546,500 547,866 .9975 S-5 111 0681250170006 C 6/02 655,000 700,400 676,287 1.0357 S-4 1111 0681250240017 C 5/02 277,500 271,600 287,906 .9434 S-5 152 0700050010036 C 9/02 665,000 665,000 676,637 .9828 S-2 152 0700420060010 C 1/03 63,000 59,000 62,843 .9389 S-5 111 0730610020002 C 5/02 647,000 562,700 671,262 .8383 S-2 152 0730990130010 C 1/03 115,000 112,200 114,712 .9781 S-3 1521 0731000320008 C 6/02 124,900 127,600 128,959 .9895 S-4 1521 0740370000026 C 6/02 439,990 477,800 454,290 1.0518 S-2 1521 0750710020010 C 8/02 65,000 75,000 66,463 1.1285 S-5 111 0751390100012 C 8/02 665,900 641,500 680,883 .9422 S-3 342 0751870180004 C 7/02 164,800 167,000 169,332 .9862 S-5 152 0752010010005 C 2/03 935,500 1,268,600 928,484 1.3663 S-5 111 0752020030003 C 8/02 1,950,000 1,917,700 1,993,875 .9618 S-5 1111 0752020350003 C 7/02 730,000 713,900 750,075 .9518 S-5 152 0752020430003 C 3/03 780,000 761,200 770,250 .9883 S-5 152 0752020440014 C 9/02 885,000 802,200 900,487 .8909 S-5 152 0752060030038 C 3/03 640,000 645,000 632,000 1.0206 S-5 152 0761800080287 C 6/02 580,000 619,200 598,850 1.0340 S-5 142 0761800150389 C 12/02 524,900 589,700 526,212 1.1207 S-5 1111 0761930080026 C 6/02 615,000 616,500 634,987 .9709 S-5 152 0770130040002 C 2/03 630,000 634,500 625,275 1.0148 S-4 152 0770130040022 C 12/02 290,000 268,200 290,725 .9225 S-5 171 0770250000010 C 1/03 750,000 722,700 748,125 .9660 S-5 111 0771150000002 C 7/02 588,000 608,600 604,170 1.0073 S-4 152 0771610010004 C 12/02 363,100 341,700 364,008 .9387 S-3 7111 0772040330008 C 4/02 180,000 184,100 187,650 .9811 S-2 152 0772590070027 C 7/02 79,800 76,800 81,995 .9366 S-4 1521 0772850040019 C 6/02 274,500 307,000 283,421 1.0832 S-4 152 0780110020031 C 9/02 262,850 257,000 267,450 .9609 S-5 111 0790350020010 C 11/02 667,500 681,400 672,506 1.0132 S-5 152 0801190000020 C 12/02 584,500 545,400 585,961 .9308 S-4 152 0802570000181 C 11/02 234,500 225,900 236,259 .9562 S-2 771 0804530000028 C 10/02 85,000 109,600 86,063 1.2735 S-2 152 0811260000017 C 2/03 75,000 70,200 74,438 .9431 S-4 1521 0812230000028 C 7/02 340,000 325,700 349,350 .9323 S-3 1521 0812430000009 C 7/02 220,000 215,600 226,050 .9538

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 64 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-912 Houston CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ S-2 152 0833940000008 C 8/02 85,000 81,700 86,913 .9400 S-2 1211 0834230000001 C 6/02 89,000 94,400 91,893 1.0273 S-3 1521 0834430000019 C 5/02 133,700 130,700 138,714 .9422 S-3 152 0840420000014 C 5/02 163,100 155,900 169,216 .9213 S-2 111 0844420000024 C 3/03 118,000 111,000 116,525 .9526 S-4 111 0850740000891 C 6/02 385,750 378,300 398,287 .9498 S-3 152 0850840000004 C 2/03 106,000 150,800 105,205 1.4334 S-2 152 0851220000028 C 9/02 124,500 118,300 126,679 .9339 S-3 111 0853860000004 C 2/03 195,000 190,700 193,537 .9853 S-3 1521 0860090000001 C 7/02 161,000 138,600 165,427 .8378 S-2 152 0870920000013 C 6/02 48,500 49,000 50,076 .9785 S-3 1521 0871390000023 C 5/02 144,500 135,400 149,919 .9032 S-3 1111 0880760000015 C 6/02 138,500 137,200 143,001 .9594 S-4 111 0881750000007 C 12/02 349,000 340,500 349,872 .9732 S-4 1111 0881780000007 C 6/02 270,000 271,700 278,775 .9746 S-2 142 0882290000019 C 4/02 100,000 86,900 104,250 .8336 S-3 152 0892050000002 C 12/02 270,000 200,400 270,675 .7404 S-4 111 0892890000009 C 12/02 254,000 247,500 254,635 .9720 S-3 152 0893120000003 C 7/02 220,000 205,900 226,050 .9109 S-2 152 0903830000017 C 2/03 102,000 106,700 101,235 1.0540 S-5 1421 0920970000002 C 6/02 1,125,000 1,101,400 1,161,563 .9482 S-5 1521 0920980000032 C 7/02 715,000 706,700 734,662 .9619 S-3 152 0922320000005 C 1/03 149,000 141,000 148,627 .9487 S-4 1111 0931960000159 C 5/02 279,000 259,800 289,462 .8975 S-5 152 0932210000859 C 4/02 576,800 604,400 601,314 1.0051 S-3 111 0935610000012 C 12/02 150,000 167,900 150,375 1.1165 S-3 1211 0950640000021 C 5/02 120,000 123,100 124,500 .9888 S-2 152 0952910000002 C 2/03 87,500 79,800 86,843 .9189 S-2 152 0960800000007 C 4/02 105,750 108,000 110,244 .9796 S-2 111 0961730000008 C 11/02 109,000 96,400 109,817 .8778 S-2 111 0964590000016 C 10/02 95,000 83,200 96,188 .8650 S-2 152 0973080000071 C 4/02 105,000 107,500 109,462 .9821 S-2 152 0973130000007 C 4/02 98,000 109,100 102,165 1.0679 S-4 152 0975470000021 C 8/02 256,000 239,900 261,760 .9165 S-2 111 0983200000330 C 12/02 92,500 113,400 92,731 1.2229 S-3 152 0983230000537 C 9/02 115,000 125,700 117,012 1.0742 S-3 152 1000340000005 C 10/02 133,000 150,700 134,662 1.1191 S-3 111 1014010000056 C 1/03 168,000 151,400 167,580 .9034 S-3 111 1021150000032 C 12/02 139,000 132,300 139,347 .9494 S-3 311 1024190000068 C 4/02 136,500 144,500 142,301 1.0155 S-2 152 1032200000034 C 4/02 119,900 110,600 124,996 .8848 S-3 111 1040330000021 C 12/02 130,000 132,500 130,325 1.0167 S-3 152 1043260000004 C 10/02 138,000 133,200 139,725 .9533 S-3 111 1057960000003 C 10/02 137,200 162,000 138,915 1.1662 S-2 152 1059190000008 C 11/02 124,900 107,800 125,837 .8567 S-2 152 1059230000029 C 1/03 122,000 118,700 121,695 .9754 S-3 152 1062820000005 C 10/02 238,000 194,700 240,975 .8080

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 65 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-912 Houston CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ S-3 152 1064160000011 C 8/02 198,900 191,800 203,375 .9431 S-3 152 1064200000028 C 9/02 153,000 152,400 155,677 .9789 S-2 111 1075090010013 C 12/02 85,900 80,700 86,114 .9371 S-4 152 1075860040001 C 3/03 310,000 342,900 306,125 1.1201 S-4 1211 1085540000011 C 6/02 239,000 239,600 246,767 .9710 S-2 342 1092940000011 C 6/02 73,000 80,000 75,373 1.0614 S-5 152 1095260000041 C 2/03 520,000 729,700 516,100 1.4139 S-2 311 1099620000004 C 10/02 70,000 81,800 70,875 1.1541 S-3 111 1101060080094 C 8/02 135,000 141,700 138,037 1.0265 S-2 342 1106310000012 C 4/02 57,900 62,700 60,360 1.0388 S-2 342 1106520010001 C 7/02 80,000 87,400 82,200 1.0633 S-4 142 1108270000097 C 6/02 244,500 228,700 252,446 .9059 S-3 1211 1110120000010 C 6/02 205,000 207,500 211,662 .9803 S-3 152 1111000000029 C 9/02 145,000 129,300 147,537 .8764 S-3 152 1111700010012 C 6/02 152,500 138,300 157,456 .8783 S-3 311 1117080000023 C 7/02 100,000 133,300 102,750 1.2973 S-2 142 1129120020001 C 10/02 80,000 41,900 81,000 .5173 S-3 342 1133520020002 C 9/02 128,000 134,700 130,240 1.0342 S-2 352 1134420000005 C 2/03 75,500 71,200 74,933 .9502 S-3 352 1136330000005 C 1/03 118,500 126,500 118,204 1.0702 S-2 1521 1141180020001 C 7/02 89,900 90,400 92,372 .9786 S-2 342 1141580030006 C 9/02 69,000 66,100 70,208 .9415 S-2 311 1141810090005 C 7/02 113,000 100,000 116,107 .8613 S-2 342 1142210100006 C 8/02 39,000 43,300 39,878 1.0858 S-2 311 1142280030005 C 10/02 43,925 41,700 44,474 .9376 S-2 311 1142860020001 C 10/02 82,900 77,300 83,936 .9209 S-2 311 1142860070012 C 6/02 48,000 55,900 49,560 1.1279 S-2 342 1142860110013 C 10/02 52,000 57,300 52,650 1.0883 S-3 311 1147430070003 C 10/02 170,000 164,100 172,125 .9534 S-2 311 1147430070004 C 11/02 108,000 115,700 108,810 1.0633 S-2 352 1148650060012 C 1/03 64,000 57,400 63,840 .8991 S-2 311 1148970050003 C 2/03 80,000 100,000 79,400 1.2594 S-3 111 1149770050003 C 9/02 124,900 150,800 127,086 1.1866 S-2 311 1150040310004 C 5/02 45,500 52,800 47,206 1.1185 S-5 331 1150060150004 C 7/02 454,000 506,800 466,485 1.0864 S-2 152 1150270280015 C 1/03 81,900 64,700 81,695 .7920 S-2 311 1153500240001 C 5/02 67,000 83,700 69,513 1.2041 S-2 342 1153620080018 C 4/02 46,000 50,500 47,955 1.0531 S-2 152 1157780040001 C 2/03 92,900 94,500 92,203 1.0249 S-3 152 1158450010005 C 1/03 154,000 143,600 153,615 .9348 S-5 111 1171840000004 C 6/02 1,475,000 1,532,000 1,522,938 1.0060 S-5 111 1172170000002 C 9/02 728,000 983,400 740,740 1.3276 S-5 142 1172180010018 C 11/02 1,150,000 1,372,800 1,158,625 1.1849 S-4 152 1176140010009 C 2/03 455,000 366,200 451,587 .8109 S-5 111 1177580010001 C 7/02 630,000 670,900 647,325 1.0364 S-4 152 1184370020038 C 9/02 520,000 505,700 529,100 .9558 S-4 111 1185920020026 C 4/02 449,000 407,900 468,082 .8714

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 66 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-912 Houston CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ S-4 152 1187580010024 C 11/02 316,200 314,700 318,571 .9878 S-5 131 1198250010001 C 5/02 2,762,500 2,762,500 2,866,094 .9639 S-4 152 1204110010037 C 2/03 387,500 384,940 384,594 1.0009 S-4 142 1205370000002 C 12/02 250,000 257,600 250,625 1.0278 S-5 152 1205790010003 C 3/03 650,000 624,000 641,875 .9722 S-4 152 1205800010001 C 10/02 362,000 293,600 366,525 .8010 S-4 152 1208530010011 C 4/02 235,000 225,500 244,987 .9205 S-3 142 1211830010004 C 1/03 130,000 130,000 129,675 1.0025 S-3 152 1213450010006 C 3/03 180,500 153,000 178,244 .8584 S-4 152 1213870010001 C 3/03 235,000 230,200 232,062 .9920 S-4 1311 1215900010001 C 4/02 369,900 421,700 385,621 1.0936 S-4 1311 1218340010027 C 4/02 246,900 271,600 257,393 1.0552 200 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9816 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AVONDALE 0041360000002 C 4/02 140,000 140,000 140,000 1.0000 AVONDALE 0041360000015 C 9/02 582,500 498,550 582,500 .8559 BROOKLINE 0071720000006 C 10/02 1,375,000 1,283,000 1,375,000 .9331 BURNS 0082310000006 C 6/02 175,000 167,690 175,000 .9582 HOLMAN OUTLOT 39 0191820030005 C 10/02 144,900 142,220 144,900 .9815 HOUSTON HEIGHTS 0200310000029 C 6/02 175,000 163,640 175,000 .9351 HOUSTON HEIGHTS 0202510000009 C 12/02 400,000 539,800 400,000 1.3495 LITTLE FARMS 0222370020013 C 6/02 2,075,000 2,145,300 2,075,000 1.0339 MACGREGOR BLODGETT PARK SEC 3 0250240460011 C 9/02 375,000 269,960 375,000 .7199 MONTROSE 0262030000015 C 4/02 380,000 319,860 380,000 .8417 PORTER & BAKER 0291810290001 C 3/03 1,150,000 1,150,000 1,150,000 1.0000 BROOKE SMITH 0330870000002 C 9/02 170,000 196,360 170,000 1.1551 SOUTHLAND 0332070270017 C 5/02 149,000 158,640 149,000 1.0647 SOUTHMORE 116 0332570060011 C 8/02 285,000 279,240 285,000 .9798 STINDE SEC 1 0342540000010 C 6/02 376,000 199,600 376,000 .5309 TURNER N P 0360460000006 C 5/03 160,000 205,720 160,000 1.2858 WESTMORELAND FARMS 0370590250011 C 12/02 18,425,000 14,432,900 18,425,000 .7833 MONTLEW PLACE 0382140000006 C 2/03 407,500 424,360 407,500 1.0414 ABST 27 J R HARRIS 0402340000002 C 12/02 1,200,000 683,500 1,200,000 .5696 ABST 134 J R BLACK 0410900000042 C 5/02 2,433,000 1,518,540 2,433,000 .6241 ABST 325 D W C HARRIS 0421960000037 C 11/02 20,085,000 17,335,760 20,085,000 .8631 ABST 544 S MCCLELLAND 0432100000212 C 5/03 675,000 610,100 675,000 .9039 ABST 545 C MARTINEZ 0432110000525 C 4/02 16,500,352 16,103,100 16,500,352 .9759

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 67 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-912 Houston CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ HYDE PARK MAIN SEC 3 0520660600016 C 5/02 315,000 288,520 315,000 .9159 DEARBORN PLACE 0561220000020 C 7/02 380,000 346,440 380,000 .9117 DEARBORN PLACE 0561230000014 C 5/02 630,000 582,500 630,000 .9246 DEARBORN PLACE 0561230000016 C 8/02 250,000 174,130 250,000 .6965 WEST LANCASTER PLACE 0562710000009 C 5/03 177,000 177,000 177,000 1.0000 EDMUNDSON SEC 4 0563150000061 C 8/02 600,000 597,200 600,000 .9953 GARDEN VILLAS 0600070070031 C 10/02 585,000 570,500 585,000 .9752 RIVERSIDE TERRACE SEC 1 0610990000009 C 5/02 150,000 129,660 150,000 .8644 MAYFAIR SEC 1 0650840040005 C 8/02 580,000 554,000 580,000 .9552 LOGAN 0720470000014 C 7/02 135,000 118,040 135,000 .8744 WEST LANE ANNEX 0720790040088 C 4/02 220,000 217,490 220,000 .9886 MONTCLAIR 0740710110008 C 11/02 470,000 391,320 470,000 .8326 BRIARMEADOW SEC 1 0892870000013 C 8/02 6,600,000 5,750,900 6,600,000 .8700 WOODSIDE PLAZA SEC 1 0911550000006 C 8/02 270,000 269,390 270,000 .9977 SHARPSTOWN COUNTRY CLUB TERR 2 0933340000003 C 7/02 1,836,000 1,702,100 1,836,000 .9271 WOODLAKE SEC 5 1042690000003 C 7/02 11,300,000 9,988,400 11,300,000 .8839 FONDREN SW NORTHBROOK 1 RP EXT 1043280000183 C 8/02 5,700,000 3,813,200 5,700,000 .6690 40 SALES CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD APPR TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER MOD OBS VALUE APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ TR 1E 0150750000056 1.00 .00 2,019,500 2,658,475 .7600 TR 13 0421300000003 1.00 .00 7,888,200 7,437,715 1.0600 TRS 16E 16F & 16F-1 0422240000205 1.00 .00 6,431,700 6,600,023 .9700 TR 4B-1 ... 0432050010030 1.00 .00 4,218,080 3,837,531 1.1000 TRS 8E & 8F 0440900000002 1.00 .00 31,857,990 29,250,031 1.0900 TR 3J 0450010000023 1.00 .00 15,800,900 15,972,578 .9900 TRS 6 6A1 7 & 8 0450290000163 1.00 .00 21,232,410 21,745,884 .9800 TR 5D 0451380010147 1.00 .00 7,320,400 6,151,923 1.1900 TR 1A-2 0461710000006 1.00 .00 4,940,520 5,865,950 .8400 RES 5C BLK 5 0845310000014 1.00 .00 2,285,900 2,323,011 .9800 RES A 0970040000003 1.00 .00 5,290,700 5,181,810 1.0200 TR B1 1033260000001 1.00 .00 4,320,000 4,517,300 .9600 RES A BLK 1 1115320000001 1.00 .00 10,760,100 9,865,450 1.0900 BLDGS 1 - 10 1171500000001 1.00 .00 15,473,160 15,731,689 .9800 BLDGS 1 - 29 1187340000001 1.00 .00 29,095,680 32,744,156 .8900 BLDGS 1 - 6 1189100010001 1.00 .00 7,107,500 6,925,844 1.0300 RES A BLK 1 1193420010001 1.00 .00 5,139,900 5,133,495 1.0000 BLDGS 1 - 10 1193990010001 1.00 .00 27,500,000 30,004,122 .9200 RES BLK 1 1194620010001 1.00 .00 16,445,600 18,191,578 .9000 RES A BLK 1 1195230010001 1.00 .00 19,014,900 18,498,333 1.0300 RES A BLK 1 1211120010001 1.00 .00 30,481,810 30,657,378 .9900 21 APPRAISALS

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 67 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-912 Houston STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9292 CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LTS 3 4 5 9 10 & 11 & TR 13 BL 0012050000004 C 9/02 204,000 215,910 204,000 1.0584 LT 3 BLK 349 0020670000003 C 4/02 97,884 100,000 97,884 1.0216 TR 9 BLK 542 0022620000009 C 4/02 16,000 15,000 16,000 .9375 TR 10A BLK 54 0050110000021 C 9/02 68,000 36,000 68,000 .5294 LT 4 BLK 241 0050660000004 C 4/02 72,000 45,000 72,000 .6250 TRS 7 8 & 9 BLK 385 0051770000007 C 8/02 150,000 93,600 150,000 .6240 LT 7 BLK D 0082360000007 C 8/02 120,000 54,060 120,000 .4505 TRS 3 3B 4 & 4A BLK 10 0152620000003 C 8/02 17,500 17,500 17,500 1.0000 LTS 12 THRU 16 BLK 65 0161440000012 C 12/02 85,000 78,750 85,000 .9265 LT 9 0170710000004 C 8/02 49,500 39,600 49,500 .8000 LT 8 0170710000012 C 7/02 49,500 39,600 49,500 .8000 LT 29 0191830000029 C 11/02 120,000 40,200 120,000 .3350 LTS 21 & 22 BLK 35 0200310000021 C 5/02 60,000 60,000 60,000 1.0000 LTS 15 & 16 BLK 36 0200320000015 C 4/02 45,000 45,000 45,000 1.0000 LT 20 BLK 168 0201640000020 C 5/02 159,900 132,000 159,900 .8255 LT 10 & TR 11A BLK 263 0202590000010 C 9/02 65,000 59,300 65,000 .9123 LT 35 BLK 266 0202620000035 C 5/02 39,500 41,380 39,500 1.0476 TR 24 BLK 287 0210190000024 C 4/03 43,500 30,000 43,500 .6897 (001*TR 29) 0210210000026 C 3/03 65,775 44,600 65,775 .6781 (001*TR 238B) 0261200000280 C 7/02 80,000 31,800 80,000 .3975 TRS 6 7 8 9 & 52 BLK 14 0300560000006 C 12/02 225,000 107,310 225,000 .4769 LT 2 & TR 3A BLK 5 0332470050002 C 8/02 290,000 140,250 290,000 .4836 LT 21 LESS N 20 FT BLK 3 0392150030021 C 1/03 37,000 41,170 37,000 1.1127 (001*TR 22) 0393220000009 C 6/02 375,000 322,500 375,000 .8600 TR 5B BLK 34 0393250000005 C 8/02 380,000 322,500 380,000 .8487 (001* S PT TR 48) 0420030000088 C 5/02 36,000 30,000 36,000 .8333 (001*TR 11) 0422270000170 C 8/02 165,000 162,130 165,000 .9826 TR 1A 0461120000005 C 1/03 67,000 48,020 67,000 .7167 TRS 7 17 0480010000255 C 12/02 225,000 214,850 225,000 .9549 LT 22 0513530000022 C 4/02 157,000 153,730 157,000 .9792 TR 12 BLK 3 0523650000012 C 12/02 98,000 45,600 98,000 .4653 LT 13 & TR 12A BLK 7 0523690000013 C 4/02 147,000 135,500 147,000 .9218 LT 15 & TR 16A BLK 15 0540810000015 C 10/02 475,000 310,100 475,000 .6528 LT 16 BLK 17 0551570000016 C 4/02 250,000 235,400 250,000 .9416 LT 25 BLK 2 0560560000025 C 4/02 480,000 349,300 480,000 .7277 LT 22 BLK 3 0560570000022 C 6/02 350,000 265,100 350,000 .7574 RES C BLK B 0581840000011 C 4/02 41,000 22,440 41,000 .5473 LTS 7 & 8 BLK D 0581860000007 C 5/02 20,000 18,750 20,000 .9375 TR 3A BLK 1 0590210010011 C 12/02 110,000 113,100 110,000 1.0282 GOLFCREST 0590760000023 C 7/03 115,000 41,290 115,000 .3590 LT 3 BLK 25 0600360250003 C 7/02 250,000 210,000 250,000 .8400 LT 144 0600520000144 C 5/02 7,900 7,000 7,900 .8861 LTS 1 & 2 BLK 4 0600830040001 C 12/02 180,000 82,500 180,000 .4583 LT 2 BLK 6 0620170000002 C 6/02 180,000 160,000 180,000 .8889

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 68 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-912 Houston CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LT 10 BLK 7 0620180000010 C 8/02 215,000 181,900 215,000 .8460 LT 2 BLK 4 0622180040001 C 9/02 105,000 50,000 105,000 .4762 LT 129 0630540000129 C 8/02 12,500 13,000 12,500 1.0400 TR 55A 0630630000110 C 8/03 90,000 50,100 90,000 .5567 26 27 28 29 30 31 & 32 BLK A 0640130000001 C 4/02 120,900 100,050 120,900 .8275 (001*TR 1A & 3A) 0641110000003 C 5/02 65,000 65,340 65,000 1.0052 LT 67 0641130000067 C 9/02 180,000 129,100 180,000 .7172 LT 51 BLK 3 0642380000051 C 12/02 50,000 27,200 50,000 .5440 LTS 20 21 & 22 BLK 1 0642420010020 C 7/02 65,000 32,700 65,000 .5031 (001*TR 49) 0650170080028 C 4/02 58,500 19,600 58,500 .3350 TR 27 BLK 4 0650270040027 C 5/03 33,000 19,000 33,000 .5758 LT 4 BLK 2 0651160020004 C 3/03 50,000 48,500 50,000 .9700 LT 1 BLK 9 0681250230001 C 4/02 236,000 183,900 236,000 .7792 TRS 59A 60A BLK 4 0681310040060 C 12/02 33,000 24,380 33,000 .7388 LT 30 BLK 5 0690150050030 C 5/02 7,100 7,100 7,100 1.0000 LTS 32 & 33 & TR 132 BLK 2 0700470020032 C 7/02 15,000 13,100 15,000 .8733 LT 135 BLK 4 0710310040135 C 3/03 23,500 7,900 23,500 .3362 LT 1 BLK 3 0710330030001 C 9/02 55,000 55,000 55,000 1.0000 LT 4 BLK 23 0720070210004 C 11/02 153,000 122,100 153,000 .7980 TR 26A & LT 27 BLK 3 0720970030027 C 4/02 40,000 33,350 40,000 .8338 TR 2B BLK 2 & ADJ ST 0720980010001 C 9/02 436,611 370,010 436,611 .8475 LT 9 BLK 2 0730210020010 C 4/02 228,000 205,200 228,000 .9000 LT 8 BLK 8 0730990080008 C 12/02 62,000 36,000 62,000 .5806 10 11 11A & 12A WHITE 0731630000004 C 10/02 1,750,000 1,048,570 1,750,000 .5992 LT 7 0731910000010 C 7/02 40,000 31,700 40,000 .7925 21 217 SF 0731910000094 C 3/03 39,000 21,200 39,000 .5436 LTS 13 & 14 BLK 1 0740610010013 C 7/03 34,500 12,100 34,500 .3507 LT 13 BLK 3 0750010030013 C 7/03 21,500 14,000 21,500 .6512 LT 5 BLK 3 0761330030005 C 4/02 185,000 169,600 185,000 .9168 LT 22 BLK 3 0761750030022 C 5/03 12,500 12,360 12,500 .9888 LT 11 BLK 11 0761930110011 C 7/02 227,000 204,700 227,000 .9018 LT 2 BLK 3 0770870030002 C 11/02 169,400 158,400 169,400 .9351 LT 4 BLK 24 0770870240004 C 5/02 186,000 164,300 186,000 .8833 E 1/2 OF LT 18 BLK 22 0772790260035 C 6/02 13,500 10,600 13,500 .7852 LT 7 BLK 44 0772800440013 C 4/02 40,000 34,780 40,000 .8695 LT 11 BLK 44 0772800440021 C 4/02 46,000 38,280 46,000 .8322 (COMMERCIAL RESERVE) 0772800470061 C 6/02 25,000 19,920 25,000 .7968 LT 11 BLK 19 0810670000011 C 4/02 438,000 322,200 438,000 .7356 LT 3 BLK 27 0854590000003 C 5/02 177,000 147,400 177,000 .8328 LT 5 BLK 2 0855580000005 C 4/02 13,000 7,200 13,000 .5538 LTS 1 THRU 41 0923120000227 C 5/02 100,000 153,960 100,000 1.5396 LT 1 BLK 3 0951690010001 C 7/02 65,000 42,600 65,000 .6554 LT 9 BLK 32 0963780000009 C 8/02 75,000 67,700 75,000 .9027 LT 12 BLK 7 1014170000012 C 5/02 15,500 15,100 15,500 .9742 LT 9 BLK 11 1021200000009 C 10/02 60,000 21,400 60,000 .3567 FONDREN SW 1106770000003 C 4/02 13,000 8,000 13,000 .6154 RES A A4 A4-C BLK 1 1146970010007 C 9/02 20,000 22,500 20,000 1.1250

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 69 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-912 Houston CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LT 13 BLK 1 1147800010013 C 4/02 21,800 22,700 21,800 1.0413 LT 32 BLK 2 1147800020032 C 6/02 20,000 17,000 20,000 .8500 LT 22 BLK 1 1149750010022 C 6/02 18,750 17,000 18,750 .9067 LT 23 BLK 1 1149750010023 C 6/02 18,750 17,000 18,750 .9067 LT 25 BLK 1 1149750010025 C 6/02 17,500 17,000 17,500 .9714 LT 26 BLK 1 1149750010026 C 6/02 18,750 17,200 18,750 .9173 RES B & B2 BLK 2 1157300020005 C 10/02 92,304 79,120 92,304 .8572 LT 13 BLK 3 1157810030013 C 7/02 20,000 8,700 20,000 .4350 LT 12 BLK 1 1177580010012 C 12/02 210,000 178,600 210,000 .8505 LT 4 1207270000004 C 5/02 550,000 524,800 550,000 .9542 RES A BLK 1 1235290010001 C 8/02 196,180 196,180 196,180 1.0000 LT 3 BLK 8 1235740010001 C 10/02 156,000 216,100 156,000 1.3853 103 SALES CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER APPR VAL APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LTS 9 & 10 7 TRS 8A & 11 BLK 9 0010950000010 1,715,300 1,200,710 1.4300 LT 15 BLK 36 0601530360020 1,196,200 1,395,680 .8600 TR 7A BLK 92 U/D .50 0601620920012 792,050 841,524 .9400 TR 1 BRIARWOOD 0650580000014 1,927,900 1,931,487 1.0000 TR 45 0681070000045 1,174,970 1,131,455 1.0400 RES A3 BLK 1 1158700010007 1,079,240 1,316,673 .8200 RES B BLK 1 1204230010002 5,481,240 5,656,602 .9700 7 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .8047 CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ABST 96 G ALLEN 0410520000160 C 6/03 219,460 251,487 .8726 ABST 128 M C BULRICE 0410840000245 C 6/02 152,460 180,000 .8470 ABST 128 M C BULRICE 0410840000275 C 5/03 30,560 211,000 .1448 TR 1A & 1C ABST 839 E P WHITEH 0451430000001 C 1/03 6,008,240 4,853,659 1.2379 ABST 1020 WCRR CO SEC 2 0461220000020 C 10/02 315,020 325,000 .9693 5 SALES

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 70 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-912 Houston CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER APPR VAL APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ TR 2D 0150750000032 48,100 58,815 .8200 LT 152 0261170000152 52,600 64,843 .8100 TR 266 0261220000266 49,800 50,454 .9900 TR 3 0431920030010 421,300 532,303 .7900 BLK 18 1033580000001 230,390 245,748 .9400 5 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.1114 CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ V-C/145438/SSBB LT 6 TR 7A 22 0010790000001 B 5/02 17,000,000 16,165,000 17,000,000 .9500 V-C/148292/SSBB 8B 12B 15 BK 9 0010940000013 B 9/02 5,808,888 4,965,000 5,808,888 .8547 V-C/149101/SSBB (001*TR 14) LT 0011630000008 C 4/02 155,000 221,050 155,000 1.4261 V-T/146827/COTTAGE GROVE SEC 2 0102050000037 C 10/02 435,000 338,260 435,000 .7776 V-Q/148435/HEISS GREGOR LT 30 0162030000034 B 1/03 175,000 161,290 175,000 .9217 V-Q/147593/HYDE PK LT 13 TR 12 0180200000012 B 9/02 495,459 317,240 495,459 .6403 V-T/143794/HOLMAN OUTLOT 20 LT 0190870000012 C 4/02 675,000 675,000 675,000 1.0000 V-T/147062/HOU HGHTS LT 23 BK 0202310000024 C 9/02 242,400 272,000 242,400 1.1221 V-T/148307/HOU HGHTS 317 LT 1 0210440000013 C 2/03 1,000,000 1,282,400 1,000,000 1.2824 V-T/148018/TOWN OF JEANETTA TR 0212470070003 C 1/03 160,000 175,070 160,000 1.0942 V-T/146446/LITTLE YORK ANNEX T 0222460000235 C 8/02 450,000 290,250 450,000 .6450 V-F/147389/RICE MILITARY LT 15 0300710000017 C 9/02 875,000 608,810 875,000 .7000 V-C/147381/ROSSLYN HGHTS SEC 2 0302810010005 B 11/02 450,000 346,350 450,000 .7697 V-T/145883/BROOKE SMITH LT 3 T 0331210720003 C 7/02 285,000 269,330 285,000 .9450 V-C/147549/A-87 S M WILLIAMS T 0371650000011 B 1/03 320,000 320,000 320,000 1.0000 V-F/147455/A-87 S M WILLIAMS T 0371950000009 C 1/03 280,000 175,380 280,000 .6264 V-R/145447/FORRESTER LT 8 9 BK 0381710000008 C 5/02 650,000 584,040 650,000 .8985 V-T/145521/A-1 J AUSTIN TR 1B 0401140000005 C 5/02 559,000 547,300 559,000 .9791 V-Q/147006/A-32 HARRIS WILSON 0402630000045 B 12/02 321,000 293,750 321,000 .9151 V-Q/147737/A-32 HARRIS WILSON 0402640040046 B 7/02 1,150,000 700,110 1,150,000 .6088 V-Q/146441/A-61 A C REYNOLDS T 0410170020325 C 8/02 1,300,000 763,910 1,300,000 .5900 V-C/148698/A-72 J D TAYLOR TR 0410280030119 B 7/02 415,000 415,000 415,000 1.0000 V-C/145154/A-75 H TIERWESTER T 0410310010002 B 8/02 1,000,000 1,000,000 1,000,000 1.0000 V-C/145439/A-284 M B GRAY TR 1 0421540000008 B 5/02 3,550,000 3,464,060 3,550,000 .9800 V-C/144510/A-642 J REINERMAN 2 0440680000055 B 6/02 11,767,136 11,715,500 11,767,136 .9956 V-C/145396/A-645 P W ROSE TR 1 0440920010124 B 5/02 6,800,000 6,484,170 6,800,000 .9536 V-C/148701/A-834 E WILLIAMS T 0451380010060 B 6/03 11,500,000 11,500,000 11,500,000 1.0000 V-A/145764/A-836 W WHITE TR 1F 0451400040008 C 11/02 63,452,658 60,375,250 63,430,375 .9500 V-Q/145343/A-836 W WHITE TR 9B 0451400040099 Y 3/02 25,000,000 21,000,000 24,303,710 .8600

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 71 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-912 Houston CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ V-A/145761/A-836 W WHITE TR 1M 0451400040244 C 11/02 39,608,566 37,793,800 39,608,566 .9542 V-V/142712/A-836 W WHITE (LAND 0451400060462 C 3/02 42,000,000 33,747,200 35,938,644 .9400 V-Q/146735/A-1068 HT&CRR SEC 1 0461680000053 Y 8/02 330,000 288,800 330,000 .8752 V-Q/145959/S LANCASTER PLC THR 0540090000001 B 7/02 2,000,000 1,677,280 2,000,000 .8386 V-Q/145963/ALBEMARLE PLC LT 1 0540640000001 B 12/02 1,250,000 1,040,430 1,250,000 .8323 V-Q/146651/SAUER (001*TR 70A) 0590030290006 B 10/02 780,000 640,500 780,000 .8212 V-C/146665/SAUER (001*TR 69) T 0590030290008 B 10/02 950,000 950,000 950,000 1.0000 V-Q/147668/MONONA CRT LT 19 BK 0591590020019 B 1/03 460,000 384,130 460,000 .8351 V-F/145918/DIXIE ACRES TR C D 0620310020006 C 8/02 250,000 177,430 250,000 .7097 V-C/145962/EUREKA ACRES TR 65B 0641870000136 Y 7/02 680,000 668,600 680,000 .9832 V-C/148636/GREENS BAYOU PK TR 0642250150007 B 12/02 2,485,667 2,194,910 2,485,667 .8830 V-R/144961/ATLAS PLC LT 4 5 BK 0660310010004 C 10/02 675,000 500,990 675,000 .7422 V-Q/145378/BLOSSOM HGHTS LT 15 0710330050016 B 5/02 291,698 248,620 291,698 .8523 V-Q/148427/WESTHEIMER GDNS EXT 0731880000204 B 3/03 250,000 211,700 250,000 .8468 V-Q/144095/SUNNYSIDE GRDNS LT 0751990040008 Y 4/02 230,000 280,000 230,000 1.2174 V-F/146743/WEST GROVE CRT TR 1 0752130010020 C 10/02 550,000 516,000 550,000 .9382 V-T/147301/WESTWOOD SEC 5 RES 0805750000020 C 12/02 244,000 265,100 244,000 1.0865 V-Q/147003/SANTA FE IND DIST T 0836050000039 B 10/02 2,489,761 2,345,960 2,489,761 .9422 V-C/143843/SHARPSTOWN IND PK 5 0915450000003 B 4/02 7,025,000 7,025,000 7,025,000 1.0000 V-T/146668/SHARPSTOWN IND PK S 0930500000022 C 10/02 550,000 399,010 550,000 .7255 V-C/147654/SW MANOR COMMERCIAL 0930930000003 B 1/03 925,000 719,810 925,000 .7782 V-Q/148044/IND PK TR 9C 10B BK 0961020000011 B 2/03 325,000 228,030 325,000 .7016 V-C/147192/PK WEST PLZ RES A4 1034580000004 B 11/02 3,290,000 3,290,000 3,290,000 1.0000 V-C/145374/BRAEBURN VALLEY WES 1040460000013 B 5/02 190,000 190,000 190,000 1.0000 V-C/144508/SAN FELIPE GREEN RE 1040730000007 B 6/02 6,430,965 6,357,900 6,430,965 .9886 V-C/147808/SAN FELIPE GREEN RE 1040740000004 B 3/03 5,818,000 5,818,000 5,818,000 1.0000 V-F/147300/MELROSE PK T/H RES 1050220000002 C 11/02 170,000 176,890 170,000 1.0405 V-Q/147055/LONE STAR BUS PK RE 1062730000002 B 10/02 1,845,000 1,395,000 1,845,000 .7561 V-Q/144714/ARDMORE IND DIST SE 1067400000003 Y 7/02 2,150,000 2,018,500 2,150,000 .9388 V-Q/148031/BRIARHILLS SEC 2 RE 1079540000002 B 2/03 900,000 675,600 900,000 .7507 V-C/146583/FONDREN SW BELLFORT 1105330000005 B 9/02 2,050,000 1,500,000 2,050,000 .7317 V-H/144507/HEARTHWOOD BUS PK S 1145390000001 C 6/02 2,100,000 2,100,000 2,100,000 1.0000 V-C/146405/POST OAK PK SEC 2 R 1147960020002 C 12/02 64,750,000 58,682,260 64,750,000 .9063 V-Q/146095/WESTBRAE PK SEC 3 R 1157300030005 B 5/02 450,000 445,980 450,000 .9911 V-C/146150/WEDNESBURY MED COND 1159170040001 B 6/02 2,930,000 2,941,170 2,930,000 1.0038 V-C/147806/WESTHEIMER AT SAGE 1168840000006 B 3/03 36,200,000 33,455,160 36,200,000 .9242 V-Q/147807/POST OAK GRDNS SEC 1170360000001 C 3/03 8,060,000 8,060,000 8,060,000 1.0000 V-Q/147257/MEMORIAL OAKS GUEST 1171080000001 B 10/02 2,651,524 2,608,440 2,651,524 .9838 V-C/143978/ALBERTSONS PAR R/P 1182830010001 B 5/02 4,900,000 4,066,000 4,900,000 .8298 V-C/143983/ALBERTSONS-S MAIN/K 1213620010001 B 5/02 4,900,000 4,866,940 4,900,000 .9933 69 SALES

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 72 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-912 Houston CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LTS 1-12 BLK 83 SSBB 0010830000001 .00 1.00 .00 152,900,000 158,000,000 .9700 LTS 1-12 BLK 259 SSBB 0012470000001 .00 1.00 .00 133,325,500 137,000,000 .9700 TR 7F A-61 A C REYNOLDS 0410170050081 .00 1.00 .00 45,500,000 47,900,000 .9500 RES B1 CITY WEST PLACE SEC 1 1151720000005 .00 1.00 .00 62,916,800 62,000,000 1.0100 4 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9267 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ SEARS MERCHANDISE 0041270 4,591,040 4,563,735 1.0100 CHALKS TRUCK PARTS 0046146 2,636,610 2,634,541 1.0000 TEXAS CEMENT PRODUCTS INC 0048271 900,380 939,417 .9600 AZTEC RENTAL 0049562 1,529,080 1,681,908 .9100 SAKS FIFTH AVENUE 0055481 14,041,060 14,685,710 .9600 CHEVERON TEXACO 0241851 14,224,840 13,281,178 1.0700 COASATAL ALLOYS INC 0249572 317,920 311,938 1.0200 USF SURFACE PREPARATION 0352825 1,423,940 1,438,776 .9900 MACY'S 0356568 11,454,100 12,048,689 .9500 SOUTHWEST DISTRIBUTING CO 0391220 5,591,420 5,478,452 1.0200 SAMS WHOLESALE CLUB 0409647 6,718,970 6,955,238 .9700 KELLOGG BROWN AND ROOT 0419890 12,467,030 12,939,826 .9600 ELECTRICAL CONTROLLER PRODUCTS 0441773 844,010 840,479 1.0000 STAR YOUNG 0464369 75,410 75,708 1.0000 CHAMPION ELEVATORS INC 0474145 1,479,000 1,584,758 .9300 ARROW TRUCKING COMPANY 0485409 60,530 60,530 1.0000 VPSI INC 0485757 4,432,310 4,432,310 1.0000 PEARLEX MACHINE AND PUMP 0526046 30,660 30,660 1.0000 SOUTHWEST AIRLINES CO 0569620 32,191,620 32,078,004 1.0000 COCO LOCO NITE CLUB 0603884 47,950 92,053 .5200 WAL-MART 0644419 8,951,450 9,344,079 .9600 THE HOME DEPOT 0644434 5,596,750 5,619,158 1.0000 ECP TECH SERVICES INC 0688900 694,400 853,073 .8100 STUDIO 30 0755882 2,305,900 2,976,054 .7700 HOUSTON BAGGING & BLENDING 0784460 1,407,400 1,430,845 .9800 LVI ENVIROMENTAL SERVICES 0799130 272,060 434,100 .6300 SHERMAN CLAY WAREHOUSE 0829973 1,262,990 1,256,454 1.0100 LURE CAPITOL 0831336 305,990 399,434 .7700 SYNHRGY TECHNOLOGIES INC 0852048 2,574,650 2,991,853 .8600 CRESCENT MACHINERY CO 0852772 14,551,410 14,563,867 1.0000 POPEYES 0891082 56,190 51,045 1.1000

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 73 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-912 Houston CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ MEDICAL CENTER RADIOLOGY 0932102 1,418,750 1,752,788 .8100 BARNES AND NOBLE 0933882 58,010 53,987 1.0700 RELIANT ENERGY 0945463 19,593,530 21,542,875 .9100 34 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9200