Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   1/22/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:      9
TIME:     14:29                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             101  Harris
                                                         101-903  Alief

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  S-3 111                          0982790000009              C       8/02         95,000          92,500        97,565     .9481
  S-4 152                          0985130000008              C       4/02         86,000          97,800        90,386    1.0820
  S-3 152                          0986160000014              C       4/02         86,900          89,600        91,332     .9810
  S-3 152                          0993020000019              C      10/02         84,500          86,400        85,768    1.0074
  S-4 111                          1001850000075              C      11/02        105,750         100,300       106,702     .9400
  S-2 152                          1003060000006              C       2/03         94,500          74,700        93,650     .7977
  S-3 152                          1003060000008              C       5/02         92,900          93,900        97,081     .9672
  S-3 152                          1003130000019              C       2/03         92,000          90,800        91,172     .9959
  S-3 152                          1003150000015              C       3/03         94,000          89,300        92,590     .9645
  S-4 111                          1005080000039              C      11/02        109,000         102,200       109,981     .9293
  S-3 152                          1005110000011              C       5/02         85,000          85,100        88,825     .9581
  S-4 152                          1010350000001              C       6/02        107,000         102,600       111,173     .9229
  S-4 152                          1010380000017              C       2/03        110,000         107,100       109,010     .9825
  S-2 342                          1010950100362              C       7/02         65,500          62,700        67,662     .9267
  S-3 111                          1013450000013              C      10/02         96,000          92,300        97,440     .9472
  S-2 152                          1013490000018              C       7/02         91,900          81,800        94,933     .8617
  S-3 152                          1013550000022              C       4/02         84,000          95,100        88,284    1.0772
  S-4 111                          1013950000026              C       9/02         75,777          98,100        77,368    1.2680
  S-3 111                          1014250000171              C      10/02         94,900          90,300        96,324     .9375
  S-4 111                          1014400000024              C      12/02        104,000          99,500       104,312     .9539
  S-2 342                          1020400000071              C       4/02         45,000          52,200        47,295    1.1037
  S-2 152                          1022520000025              C       6/02         80,000          78,700        83,120     .9468
  S-3 152                          1025130000028              C       2/03        107,000          95,000       106,037     .8959
  S-2 342                          1031940010326              C       5/02         65,000          59,000        67,925     .8686
  S-2 342                          1031940010360              C       9/02         42,900          47,100        43,801    1.0753
  S-2 142                          1033600000007              C       3/03         91,000          82,600        89,635     .9215
  S-2 311                          1034270010007              C      12/02         70,000          65,900        70,210     .9386
  S-2 152                          1034470000012              C      11/02         84,000          83,300        84,756     .9828
  S-2 142                          1034550010178              C       9/02         52,000          52,400        53,092     .9870
  S-2 1421                         1034560010248              C       6/02         52,000          56,300        54,028    1.0421
  S-2 1421                         1034570030028              C       4/02         61,000          59,400        64,111     .9265
  S-4 111                          1041380000003              C       5/02         90,000         102,900        94,050    1.0941
  S-4 152                          1043700000027              C       8/02         89,000          97,900        91,403    1.0711
  S-4 152                          1043760000063              C       3/03        120,000         118,600       118,200    1.0034
  S-3 152                          1043780000011              C       1/03         95,900          94,100        95,612     .9842
  S-4 152                          1044010000022              C      11/02        110,000         109,400       110,990     .9857
  S-4 111                          1044030000038              C       3/03         91,000         107,800        89,635    1.2027
  S-2 152                          1047100000030              C      10/02         60,500          53,300        61,408     .8680
  S-3 152                          1047170000009              C       4/02         79,900          86,900        83,975    1.0348
  S-3 152                          1047220000011              C       5/02         94,000          93,100        98,230     .9478
  S-4 152                          1050350000030              C      10/02         98,500         107,600        99,978    1.0762
  S-2 131                          1050360040047              C      12/02         52,000          68,200        52,156    1.3076
  S-2 142                          1051740000003              C       6/02         55,000          50,900        57,145     .8907
  S-2 142                          1054610010001              C       4/02         72,000          78,800        75,672    1.0413
  S-4 152                          1055250000015              C       1/03        108,500         111,900       108,174    1.0344
  S-2 311                          1059390050001              C       6/02         49,500          46,400        51,431     .9022
  S-2 111                          1059620110002              C       7/02         70,000          61,000        72,310     .8436

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 10 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-903 Alief CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ S-2 142 1059630040011 C 3/03 59,000 59,900 58,115 1.0307 S-4 111 1067810000032 C 4/02 105,000 105,400 110,355 .9551 S-5 152 1067860000001 C 4/02 125,000 141,600 131,375 1.0778 S-2 142 1071640010002 C 8/02 57,000 54,600 58,539 .9327 S-2 142 1072420070008 C 6/02 78,500 79,800 81,562 .9784 S-2 142 1072420150006 C 5/02 77,000 81,500 80,465 1.0129 S-3 152 1072440050009 C 1/03 97,500 91,400 97,208 .9403 S-4 111 1084840000038 C 5/02 86,000 99,200 89,870 1.1038 S-2 111 1086540000018 C 12/02 85,000 82,800 85,255 .9712 S-4 152 1087260040047 C 2/03 92,500 96,100 91,668 1.0484 S-3 111 1087260050007 C 4/02 79,900 85,600 83,975 1.0194 S-4 111 1096050000067 C 11/02 104,900 102,400 105,844 .9675 S-4 152 1096070000023 C 4/02 100,900 114,000 106,045 1.0750 S-2 311 1096600020001 C 12/02 49,900 45,500 50,050 .9091 S-4 111 1097270000025 C 7/02 121,600 107,900 125,612 .8590 S-3 152 1097320000023 C 8/02 97,000 85,900 99,619 .8623 S-4 152 1099740000007 C 6/02 112,500 109,000 116,887 .9325 S-5 1521 1102400000064 C 4/02 120,000 138,400 126,120 1.0974 S-2 152 1103730000033 C 9/02 78,000 74,800 79,638 .9393 S-2 1421 1104050030003 C 8/02 47,500 48,200 48,783 .9881 S-5 152 1105040000049 C 2/03 128,750 135,000 127,591 1.0581 S-3 152 1105430000033 C 5/02 95,000 93,500 99,275 .9418 S-4 152 1107680000012 C 7/02 125,000 118,100 129,125 .9146 S-4 152 1108000000006 C 10/02 117,000 120,700 118,755 1.0164 S-5 152 1108060000038 C 12/02 131,500 127,300 131,894 .9652 S-5 142 1108060000043 C 1/03 133,000 135,400 132,601 1.0211 S-3 152 1108320000003 C 3/03 93,000 90,700 91,605 .9901 S-3 152 1108340000002 C 10/02 93,500 88,900 94,903 .9368 S-3 152 1108360000015 C 10/02 79,200 92,900 80,388 1.1556 S-4 152 1108390000074 C 6/02 104,900 116,300 108,991 1.0671 S-4 152 1108390000075 C 5/02 95,900 103,700 100,215 1.0348 S-3 152 1108400000009 C 12/02 95,500 87,700 95,787 .9156 S-4 742 1109310000040 C 11/02 85,000 123,300 85,765 1.4376 S-2 152 1109610120007 C 1/03 62,000 59,900 61,814 .9690 S-2 111 1111270010010 C 8/02 66,000 65,500 67,782 .9663 S-2 152 1111270010080 C 11/02 72,000 66,500 72,648 .9154 S-3 152 1113010000020 C 9/02 88,000 95,200 89,848 1.0596 S-3 152 1113030000027 C 11/02 96,850 84,800 97,721 .8678 S-4 152 1113030000066 C 6/02 99,900 96,600 103,796 .9307 S-3 152 1114080000023 C 7/02 93,500 87,000 96,586 .9008 S-4 152 1114080000026 C 2/03 96,000 99,200 95,136 1.0427 S-4 152 1114090000068 C 6/02 85,000 95,700 88,315 1.0836 S-3 152 1114090000074 C 7/02 91,500 84,500 94,520 .8940 S-3 111 1114100000015 C 6/02 88,660 85,500 92,117 .9282 S-3 152 1117460000014 C 10/02 87,800 93,400 89,117 1.0481 S-4 152 1123320000044 C 1/03 125,000 122,500 124,625 .9829 S-2 152 1123910000032 C 10/02 79,900 82,000 81,099 1.0111

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 11 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-903 Alief CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ S-4 152 1124240000023 C 9/02 131,250 121,100 134,006 .9037 S-2 152 1126350000003 C 8/02 84,900 80,300 87,192 .9210 S-4 152 1126350000019 C 1/03 112,000 98,700 111,664 .8839 S-4 152 1126930000033 C 1/03 99,900 97,000 99,600 .9739 S-3 111 1127000000015 C 5/02 98,000 92,000 102,410 .8983 S-3 152 1127030000018 C 3/03 88,000 93,700 86,680 1.0810 S-3 152 1127060000004 C 2/03 95,000 93,800 94,145 .9963 S-5 152 1127460000016 C 5/02 136,000 136,000 142,120 .9569 S-5 111 1127480000006 C 10/02 130,000 146,200 131,950 1.1080 S-2 152 1127780060008 C 1/03 56,000 53,200 55,832 .9529 S-2 142 1127790050003 C 9/02 71,000 66,000 72,491 .9105 S-3 152 1128310000049 C 9/02 90,000 93,600 91,890 1.0186 S-4 152 1128960000011 C 6/02 115,000 113,700 119,485 .9516 S-2 152 1129440000026 C 2/03 78,000 76,400 77,298 .9884 S-3 111 1129450000002 C 11/02 87,900 86,700 88,691 .9776 S-3 152 1129450000042 C 7/02 85,000 90,100 87,805 1.0261 S-5 111 1131080000005 C 4/02 155,000 172,600 162,905 1.0595 S-5 131 1131100000017 C 12/02 141,900 141,900 142,325 .9970 S-5 1111 1131110000026 C 7/02 150,000 160,300 154,950 1.0345 S-5 152 1131130000002 C 12/02 202,000 191,400 202,606 .9447 S-5 152 1131880000045 C 11/02 126,000 129,100 127,134 1.0155 S-5 111 1131920000006 C 12/02 128,500 131,400 128,885 1.0195 S-4 111 1131920000007 C 6/02 114,659 111,200 119,131 .9334 S-5 111 1136790000003 C 4/02 135,000 144,700 141,885 1.0198 S-5 152 1136800000028 C 6/02 130,000 132,900 135,070 .9839 S-5 152 1136830000009 C 5/02 136,500 139,000 142,642 .9745 S-3 152 1136860000005 C 7/02 97,900 87,500 101,130 .8652 S-5 1521 1136880000006 C 5/02 129,000 124,800 134,805 .9258 S-4 152 1141220010004 C 10/02 95,000 111,100 96,425 1.1522 S-3 152 1141220020022 C 3/03 88,500 94,000 87,173 1.0783 S-5 1521 1141220030017 C 4/02 110,500 126,600 116,135 1.0901 S-3 111 1141220180005 C 2/03 94,900 87,700 94,046 .9325 S-3 152 1141250020027 C 7/02 95,000 94,300 98,135 .9609 S-3 152 1141250020033 C 9/02 94,900 90,300 96,893 .9320 S-5 111 1141290050005 C 11/02 121,000 130,200 122,089 1.0664 S-2 342 1142270000007 C 5/02 44,000 47,100 45,980 1.0244 S-2 342 1142270060016 C 6/02 45,990 47,100 47,783 .9857 S-3 111 1143070020040 C 12/02 92,000 84,800 92,276 .9190 S-4 152 1143460080015 C 5/02 104,000 105,200 108,680 .9680 S-3 1521 1143660010026 C 4/02 87,500 84,300 91,963 .9167 S-3 152 1143660040009 C 10/02 92,500 90,400 93,888 .9629 S-3 152 1143660040015 C 9/02 95,000 92,500 96,995 .9537 S-2 152 1143810070001 C 4/02 85,000 80,200 89,335 .8977 S-5 111 1144450100038 C 12/02 125,000 127,600 125,375 1.0177 S-5 111 1144460050050 C 12/02 137,000 154,900 137,411 1.1273 S-5 131 1144460050051 C 2/03 125,000 124,300 123,875 1.0034 S-5 152 1144460050057 C 12/02 125,000 125,500 125,375 1.0010

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 12 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-903 Alief CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ S-3 152 1144630030015 C 8/02 89,000 85,000 91,403 .9299 S-4 111 1144940060005 C 8/02 95,000 96,900 97,565 .9932 S-4 152 1144940060006 C 10/02 98,000 96,100 99,470 .9661 S-5 152 1144940070010 C 9/02 117,000 128,100 119,457 1.0724 S-5 111 1144940070025 C 11/02 148,000 156,800 149,332 1.0500 S-4 152 1144940070030 C 5/02 95,000 108,400 99,275 1.0919 S-2 311 1144950010026 C 10/02 47,000 44,700 47,705 .9370 S-2 142 1146060150004 C 4/02 68,000 68,200 71,468 .9543 S-4 152 1146180040034 C 2/03 80,000 106,900 79,280 1.3484 S-4 152 1146180090032 C 9/02 100,000 97,700 102,100 .9569 S-5 111 1146950160001 C 11/02 129,900 141,900 131,069 1.0826 S-5 152 1146950160045 C 8/02 122,500 132,700 125,807 1.0548 S-2 342 1147950010014 C 9/02 86,500 78,500 88,317 .8888 S-4 152 1148370030045 C 9/02 87,500 102,300 89,338 1.1451 S-3 152 1148370030055 C 8/02 94,000 91,300 96,538 .9457 S-2 152 1148530020036 C 3/03 91,700 82,800 90,325 .9167 S-5 111 1148530050029 C 5/02 115,000 125,300 120,175 1.0426 S-4 111 1148530100007 C 6/02 109,900 118,400 114,186 1.0369 S-2 152 1148570190052 C 1/03 87,000 78,400 86,739 .9039 S-4 152 1148790030034 C 10/02 102,900 97,200 104,443 .9306 S-2 152 1149220020046 C 5/02 72,150 70,600 75,396 .9364 S-2 152 1149220020049 C 1/03 68,000 70,300 67,796 1.0369 S-2 111 1149220030027 C 12/02 65,000 70,200 65,195 1.0768 S-3 111 1149540020010 C 11/02 89,500 89,600 90,306 .9922 S-4 152 1149540050028 C 9/02 99,950 98,300 102,049 .9633 S-4 171 1151230030060 C 9/02 103,000 106,500 105,163 1.0127 S-2 152 1152890040027 C 7/02 68,900 73,100 71,174 1.0271 S-3 111 1156140040006 C 10/02 105,000 94,300 106,575 .8848 S-3 152 1157050100028 C 11/02 92,500 92,600 93,333 .9922 S-2 152 1157790060001 C 4/02 64,900 66,600 68,210 .9764 S-2 1111 1157790070004 C 7/02 85,000 75,600 87,805 .8610 S-2 111 1160500040020 C 1/03 48,000 56,200 47,856 1.1744 S-4 352 1164400140003 C 2/03 110,000 104,000 109,010 .9540 S-5 152 1177220010020 C 2/03 162,000 150,800 160,542 .9393 S-5 152 1177220010024 C 1/03 155,000 147,800 154,535 .9564 S-5 111 1181610040004 C 12/02 184,200 201,000 184,752 1.0879 S-5 152 1181610040016 C 2/03 200,000 187,600 198,200 .9465 S-5 152 1181620010017 C 5/02 261,000 253,000 272,745 .9276 S-5 152 1181620020020 C 11/02 218,000 236,600 219,962 1.0756 S-5 111 1181910010042 C 10/02 116,500 126,000 118,247 1.0656 S-5 111 1181910020009 C 5/02 155,000 157,100 161,975 .9699 S-5 111 1186940010001 C 7/02 210,000 262,100 216,930 1.2082 S-5 152 1186940010050 C 8/02 194,000 184,900 199,238 .9280 S-5 152 1186940010065 C 5/02 247,500 237,800 258,637 .9194 S-5 111 1186940030001 C 8/02 264,900 250,900 272,052 .9222 S-5 152 1187180010022 C 8/02 192,000 200,700 197,184 1.0178 S-5 111 1187180010050 C 3/03 174,000 170,000 171,390 .9919

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 13 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-903 Alief CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ S-4 152 1189210010003 C 11/02 105,000 103,000 105,945 .9722 S-5 152 1189600020008 C 2/03 185,900 182,000 184,226 .9879 S-3 152 1191450020002 C 2/03 89,900 85,700 89,091 .9619 S-5 152 1194940010010 C 4/02 155,000 155,000 162,905 .9515 S-5 152 1194940010019 C 4/02 142,000 149,700 149,242 1.0031 S-4 152 1196230020016 C 3/03 104,000 105,600 102,440 1.0308 S-5 111 1199530020026 C 8/02 254,000 281,700 260,858 1.0799 S-5 152 1204730010011 C 6/02 165,000 160,900 171,435 .9385 S-5 152 1210430020031 C 3/03 145,000 143,200 142,825 1.0026 S-5 152 1211370030009 C 7/02 440,000 443,300 454,520 .9753 S-5 142 1211490020031 C 7/02 580,000 635,100 599,140 1.0600 S-3 111 1954020040050 C 6/02 87,500 87,500 90,913 .9625 200 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9863 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ABST 1362 HT&BRR CO SEC 12 0471340000012 C 4/03 2,950,000 2,447,600 2,950,000 .8297 WESTCHASE SEC 5 1088560000004 C 5/02 6,500,000 6,500,000 6,500,000 1.0000 WEST BELT PLAZA 1152550000001 C 6/02 9,650,000 8,590,700 9,650,000 .8902 EQUINOX APTS AT WESTCHASE 1191940000001 C 5/02 26,000,000 22,674,300 26,000,000 .8721 4 SALES CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD APPR TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER MOD OBS VALUE APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ UNITS A B C BLDGS 1 - 44 0402250010001 1.00 .00 4,981,320 4,881,500 1.0200 TRS 1A-1 & 1A-6 0420640000006 1.00 .00 5,314,030 5,251,809 1.0100 TR 1A-2 0420640000021 1.00 .00 6,259,840 5,558,800 1.1300 TRS 3 3B 3C 0432270000006 1.00 .00 15,203,260 16,382,883 .9300 TR - 5B-4 0471340000033 1.00 .00 2,547,580 2,798,558 .9100 RES A1 1071630000002 1.00 .00 4,143,640 4,253,992 .9700 RES C2 BLK 3 1080580000002 1.00 .00 2,366,000 2,321,575 1.0200 RES C 1090410000003 1.00 .00 7,744,950 7,056,425 1.1000 RES A BLK 1 1096720000001 1.00 .00 5,240,000 5,305,070 .9900 RES N BLK 14 1097050000001 1.00 .00 7,830,500 7,694,458 1.0200

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 14 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-903 Alief CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD APPR TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER MOD OBS VALUE APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ RES P2 BLK 16 1101420000002 1.00 .00 5,134,000 4,391,992 1.1700 RERS B2 BLK 2 RES B1 BLK 2 1105790000002 1.00 .00 6,148,440 5,628,392 1.0900 RES D2 BLK 1 1112990000071 1.00 .00 4,899,020 4,920,050 1.0000 RES B1 1121370000021 1.00 .00 3,277,900 3,945,983 .8300 RES A 1142990000001 1.00 .00 3,131,200 2,843,808 1.1000 RES E1 BLK 5 1144110050002 1.00 .00 9,647,760 9,173,575 1.0500 RES B BLK 1 1145970010002 1.00 .00 8,602,900 8,399,925 1.0200 RES D 1146840000004 1.00 .00 6,005,900 6,508,000 .9200 KEEGANS GLEN SEC 5 1147550000004 1.00 .00 3,259,700 3,647,258 .8900 RES A1 1150860000002 1.00 .00 5,818,020 5,377,367 1.0800 RES K 1152040000011 1.00 .00 9,880,000 9,739,583 1.0100 RES S1 1152040000033 1.00 .00 5,430,000 5,090,475 1.0700 RES A 1152340010001 1.00 .00 6,300,000 6,133,433 1.0300 RES C 1153810000003 1.00 .00 3,951,740 4,225,767 .9400 RES G BLK 7 1154730000012 1.00 .00 7,746,500 7,354,158 1.0500 RES A BLK 1 1159400010003 1.00 .00 9,963,600 9,145,717 1.0900 BLDGS 1 - 22 1195430000001 1.00 .00 15,169,220 17,323,144 .8800 BLDGS 1 -13 1196790000001 1.00 .00 19,358,020 20,114,911 .9600 BLDGS 1 - 8 1197370000001 1.00 .00 18,538,000 17,287,322 1.0700 BLDGS 1 - 12 1199600000001 1.00 .00 20,027,800 19,869,411 1.0100 30 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9884 CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ V-C/148182/A-516 W N LYON TR 3 0431820000023 B 1/03 870,000 800,000 870,000 .9195 V-C/144125/LEAWOOD SEC 4 RES C 1010990000001 Y 6/02 1,000,000 925,000 1,000,000 .9250 V-Q/145355/TOWN PK RES D3 BK 4 1052570000013 B 4/02 2,600,000 2,402,090 2,600,000 .9200 V-C/144414/WESTHAMPTON VILLAGE 1063440000035 Y 6/02 2,400,000 2,400,000 2,400,000 1.0000 V-H/147053/SW PK SEC 3 RES A2 1080670000002 C 9/02 535,000 518,230 518,230 1.0000 V-C/148314/WESTWOOD CTR SEC 3 1104080000002 B 2/03 3,830,000 3,830,000 3,830,000 1.0000 V-Q/147717/FORUM SEC 1 RES B1 1112610000014 B 12/02 1,900,000 2,034,310 1,900,000 1.0707 V-Q/146602/WESTCHASE SEC 19 RE 1145970020001 B 10/02 2,900,000 1,720,300 2,900,000 .5932 V-C/144124/CENTRE BUS PK RES E 1150880000006 Y 6/02 4,000,000 3,791,920 4,000,000 .9480

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 15 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-903 Alief CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ V-C/149086/WEST BELT PLAZA RES 1152550000002 C 5/03 8,100,000 8,100,000 8,100,000 1.0000 V-C/144709/PKWEST CTRL-RES C R 1157080010001 B 6/02 1,957,500 1,957,500 1,957,500 1.0000 V-C/148609/PAVILION VILLAGE R/ 1163300000023 B 3/03 570,000 570,000 570,000 1.0000 V-C/147322/BELTWAY PLZ CENTRE 1182920010001 B 9/02 4,333,000 4,333,000 4,333,000 1.0000 V-C/143981/BISSONNET KIRKWOOD 1193580010002 B 5/02 4,900,000 4,367,000 4,900,000 .8912 14 SALES CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ TRS 2A-1 2B-1 5A-1 PARKSDALE 0280950000322 .00 1.00 .00 13,517,600 13,900,000 .9700 TR 2 IN C 3C 1C BLK 8 A-561 RE 1041560000002 .00 1.00 .00 27,500,000 28,000,000 .9800 RES A1 SEAR SOUTHWEST 1044250000001 .00 1.00 .00 6,942,800 7,147,195 .9700 RES N4-A BLK 14 WESTCHASE SEC 1097050000005 .00 1.00 .00 10,169,330 11,100,000 .9200 RES O-4-1 BLK 15 WESTCHASE SEC 1101410000012 .00 1.00 .00 19,084,600 19,700,000 .9700 RES S2 S3 BLK 19 WESTCHASE SEC 1108620000002 .00 1.00 .00 28,506,530 32,660,776 .8700 RES S7 BLK 19 WESTCHASE SEC 10 1108620000015 .00 1.00 .00 14,600,000 14,700,000 .9900 RESU1 BLK 21 WESTCHASE SEC 11 1113780000002 .00 1.00 .00 32,061,500 32,300,000 .9900 RES V4 BLK 22 WESTCHASE SEC 11 1113790000006 .00 1.00 .00 2,225,000 3,500,000 .6400 RES A BLK 1 WESTCHASE SEC 13 1141460010010 .00 1.00 .00 11,699,100 12,000,000 .9700 RES B BLK 2 WESTCHASE SEC 14 1144110020001 .00 1.00 .00 19,534,250 19,400,000 1.0100 RES C1 WESTMINISTER PLAZA 1152130000003 .00 1.00 .00 6,580,940 6,156,894 1.0700 12 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9338 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ WESTERN GECO L.L.C. 0017874 15,706,210 19,172,739 .8200 HIGHLANDS INSURANCE 0046739 1,848,810 1,514,531 1.2200 STERLING MCCALL TOYATO 0051145 1,685,650 1,769,136 .9500 TARGET 0086731 2,663,760 2,598,395 1.0300 FOLEY'S 0113620 6,804,230 6,801,920 1.0000 MERVYNS 0259152 1,721,370 1,687,165 1.0200 AD MAR INDUSTRIES 0300776 63,710 60,202 1.0600 EQUIPMENT VALVE & SUPPLY 0425900 702,540 705,060 1.0000 FIESTA MART BEVERAGE 0461997 191,970 191,973 1.0000

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 16 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-903 Alief CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ J C PENNY 0477067 1,832,880 1,824,041 1.0000 OFFICE DEPOT 0549399 1,230,720 1,327,286 .9300 DILLARD'S 0551025 5,992,010 6,851,387 .8700 ROSS DRESS FOR LESS #327 0647658 481,890 467,917 1.0300 AUCHAN HYPERMARKET 0660306 5,672,020 4,974,499 1.1400 DYNAMIC MAKETING SERVICES 0660925 568,750 503,937 1.1300 HTI 0678627 1,447,630 1,538,469 .9400 SOUTHERN CRUSHED CONCRETE 0687357 212,150 292,478 .7300 CARDPRO INC 0715783 949,620 952,415 1.0000 ZETTY WILSON DEVELOPEMENT 0813321 49,020 50,000 .9800 DOLLAR GENERAL 0830640 258,050 260,510 .9900 FROMM AIRPAD 0835967 119,200 120,482 .9900 THIEN PHU WEDDING RESTAURANT 0858950 26,370 32,227 .8200 COLUMBIA ANALYTICAL SERVICES 0861775 266,880 363,214 .7300 WAYNE ALANI 0900399 37,130 33,498 1.1100 LOWES HOME CENTER 0914365 5,465,510 5,440,522 1.0000 KRATON POLYMERS 0921473 5,240,840 5,242,707 1.0000 HI-LO AUTOMOTIVE 0926039 351,560 365,473 .9600 27 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9563