Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   1/22/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:      1
TIME:     14:29                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             101  Harris
                                                         101-902  Aldine

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  S-2 152                          041590000799               C       8/02         92,500          65,000        94,581     .6872
  S-2 152                          041790000316               C      10/02         45,000          62,200        45,563    1.3652
  S-5 152                          0430120000150              C      10/02        191,900         209,300       194,299    1.0772
  S-2 111                          0431760000363              C       5/02         60,000          42,900        62,250     .6892
  S-2 152                          0431880010009              C       1/03         69,500          52,500        69,326     .7573
  S-2 152                          0731850000464              C       2/03         79,900          64,800        79,300     .8171
  S-2 152                          0750590090168              C       6/02         40,000          37,600        41,300     .9104
  S-2 111                          0760010020006              C       5/02         65,000          59,900        67,438     .8882
  S-4 1521                         0761770040050              C       7/02         98,000          94,700       100,695     .9405
  S-2 111                          0791410030054              C       9/02         54,320          59,600        55,271    1.0783
  S-2 111                          0813230000013              C       6/02         65,000          58,000        67,113     .8642
  S-3 111                          0843480000017              C      10/02         83,000          74,800        84,038     .8901
  S-4 111                          0843520000004              C      10/02         82,000          86,500        83,025    1.0419
  S-2 152                          0900870000013              C      10/02         58,000          65,000        58,725    1.1069
  S-2 1521                         0900930000004              C       6/02         67,500          56,200        69,693     .8064
  S-2 152                          0900940000005              C       2/03         57,500          53,000        57,068     .9287
  S-3 1521                         092190150013               C       7/02         84,740          78,900        87,070     .9062
  S-3 1521                         092190150030               C       5/02         82,500          73,900        85,593     .8634
  S-4 152                          0923310000033              C      11/02         82,000          81,700        82,615     .9889
  S-3 111                          0923320000016              C       4/02         79,000          74,600        82,358     .9058
  S-4 152                          0923330000025              C      11/02         84,000          88,800        84,630    1.0493
  S-4 152                          0925210000054              C       1/03         99,000          92,900        98,753     .9407
  S-3 111                          0941180000003              C      12/02         77,000          74,100        77,193     .9599
  S-3 152                          0941180000017              C       3/03         85,000          74,100        83,938     .8828
  S-3 152                          0965810000004              C       7/02         85,400          71,500        87,749     .8148
  S-4 111                          0970380000012              C       3/03         92,000          92,000        90,850    1.0127
  S-4 152                          0970600000017              C      10/02         94,000          96,600        95,175    1.0150
  S-4 1521                         0970600000021              C       6/02         86,500          85,900        89,311     .9618
  S-4 152                          0972710000563              C       2/03         91,900          85,800        91,210     .9407
  S-5 152                          0981210000484              C      10/02         97,500          99,200        98,718    1.0049
  S-4 1111                         0981250000593              C       5/02         88,900          84,700        92,233     .9183
  S-4 152                          0981830000026              C       8/02         97,500          91,100        99,693     .9138
  S-5 1521                         0982400000014              C       5/02        130,000         155,000       134,875    1.1492
  S-3 142                          0993750000005              C      11/02         73,500          79,300        74,051    1.0709
  S-5 111                          0993790000834              C      10/02        105,500         104,500       106,819     .9783
  S-5 152                          0993800000856              C       1/03        109,000          99,200       108,727     .9124
  S-5 1111                         1000970000031              C       5/02        114,000         110,200       118,275     .9317
  S-5 152                          1000980000005              C       1/03        155,000         113,900       154,612     .7367
  S-3 111                          1001760010057              C       7/02         76,500          74,200        78,603     .9440
  S-3 152                          1002050000027              C       7/02         78,000          72,900        80,145     .9096
  S-3 152                          1002090000004              C      10/02         85,000          74,700        86,063     .8680
  S-3 111                          1002790000062              C       9/02         92,500          78,500        94,118     .8341
  S-4 152                          1003880000156              C       1/03         86,000          82,300        85,785     .9594
  S-5 1111                         1004350000546              C       7/02        125,000         128,700       128,437    1.0020
  S-4 152                          1004390000623              C       2/03         78,000          84,800        77,415    1.0954
  S-5 111                          1004390000631              C       2/03        132,500         133,400       131,506    1.0144
  S-5 152                          1004430000003              C       3/03        115,950         103,000       114,501     .8996

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 2 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-902 Aldine CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ S-3 152 1013140000106 C 4/02 82,000 76,900 85,485 .8996 S-5 1211 1014650000013 C 6/02 100,750 109,000 104,024 1.0478 S-5 152 1015110000018 C 2/03 122,000 110,100 121,085 .9093 S-4 1211 1020210000046 C 7/02 86,500 94,000 88,878 1.0576 S-4 1111 1020210000050 C 8/02 95,000 96,900 97,138 .9976 S-4 1521 1020250000002 C 5/02 83,000 88,000 86,113 1.0219 S-3 152 1020290000002 C 8/02 65,149 78,500 66,615 1.1784 S-3 152 1020920000280 C 7/02 77,500 74,300 79,631 .9331 S-5 152 1021540000018 C 8/02 125,000 134,200 127,812 1.0500 S-5 152 1023460000008 C 6/02 97,500 100,400 100,669 .9973 S-5 111 1024340000016 C 9/02 107,000 99,800 108,872 .9167 S-5 111 1030170000011 C 6/02 132,900 140,500 137,219 1.0239 S-3 111 1030560000405 C 12/02 79,350 70,400 79,548 .8850 S-3 111 1030670000191 C 5/02 79,000 72,200 81,963 .8809 S-3 152 1030670000209 C 1/03 78,900 69,400 78,702 .8818 S-2 1521 1030670000214 C 4/02 72,900 68,300 75,998 .8987 S-3 1521 1030720000398 C 4/02 49,900 73,000 52,020 1.4033 S-3 152 1030740000463 C 1/03 79,900 69,100 79,700 .8670 S-3 152 1030750000508 C 3/03 84,500 75,500 83,443 .9048 S-2 1521 1030770000581 C 7/02 57,500 68,000 59,081 1.1510 S-4 152 1032030000009 C 2/03 89,900 85,700 89,225 .9605 S-5 152 1041150000011 C 2/03 113,000 110,500 112,152 .9853 S-5 152 1041280000013 C 3/03 132,000 130,500 130,350 1.0012 S-3 1211 1042030000725 C 7/02 79,900 76,200 82,097 .9282 S-2 111 1045740000058 C 11/02 73,900 65,700 74,454 .8824 S-2 152 1045780000029 C 3/03 81,000 68,800 79,988 .8601 S-2 152 1045870000177 C 9/02 82,600 68,700 84,046 .8174 S-2 171 1045890000201 C 8/02 76,000 68,800 77,710 .8853 S-3 111 1045930000286 C 1/03 85,000 73,900 84,788 .8716 S-5 1521 1051440000957 C 5/02 84,900 98,400 88,083 1.1171 S-4 111 1051460000990 C 8/02 86,000 83,200 87,935 .9462 S-3 1521 1052990000032 C 7/02 76,000 73,800 78,090 .9451 S-5 1521 1054620000021 C 7/02 109,000 112,800 111,997 1.0072 S-5 111 1054620000048 C 12/02 129,000 118,400 129,322 .9155 S-4 152 1056050000028 C 3/03 95,999 90,300 94,799 .9525 S-3 152 1056070000018 C 5/02 88,000 76,800 91,300 .8412 S-3 311 1057140060004 C 5/02 84,000 79,000 87,150 .9065 S-3 311 1057160030037 C 6/02 72,000 72,300 74,340 .9726 S-3 311 1057170010005 C 4/02 69,500 72,300 72,453 .9979 S-2 342 1057190030001 C 5/02 60,500 60,500 62,768 .9639 S-3 342 1057190040003 C 8/02 70,000 70,400 71,575 .9836 S-4 152 1058230000012 C 1/03 94,000 93,500 93,765 .9972 S-4 1111 1059340000013 C 6/02 91,800 87,500 94,784 .9232 S-3 152 1062310000034 W 5/02 79,900 76,600 82,896 .9240 S-5 152 1062490001200 C 9/02 88,000 98,100 89,540 1.0956 S-5 152 1062500001226 C 3/03 110,000 109,000 108,625 1.0035 S-2 152 1064120000002 C 5/02 80,500 63,900 83,518 .7651

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 3 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-902 Aldine CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ S-3 311 1069220000238 C 9/02 75,600 75,600 76,923 .9828 S-3 152 1070670000015 C 5/02 76,000 72,000 78,850 .9131 S-3 152 1070720000011 C 8/02 83,000 79,900 84,868 .9415 S-3 152 1074010000547 C 12/02 78,000 79,900 78,195 1.0218 S-3 1521 1074040000629 C 8/02 87,900 78,800 89,877 .8767 S-4 1521 1079450000014 C 5/02 90,000 94,500 93,375 1.0120 S-4 1421 1079460000024 C 4/02 85,000 95,100 88,613 1.0732 S-5 111 1079470000013 C 11/02 103,500 104,300 104,276 1.0002 S-4 111 1079480000003 C 12/02 93,000 88,300 93,233 .9471 S-3 152 1081670000001 C 10/02 82,900 76,000 83,936 .9054 S-5 152 1081690000031 C 11/02 98,563 98,600 99,302 .9929 S-4 152 1081700000012 C 10/02 99,900 91,300 101,149 .9026 S-4 152 1081720000025 C 10/02 95,000 90,200 96,188 .9378 S-4 111 1084240001312 C 8/02 96,000 96,600 98,160 .9841 S-4 152 1084350000045 C 5/02 88,900 82,900 92,233 .8988 S-4 152 1084400000005 C 7/02 89,610 94,100 92,074 1.0220 S-4 152 1086030000006 C 7/02 88,000 96,700 90,420 1.0695 S-4 1521 1087290000673 C 5/02 75,000 84,900 77,813 1.0911 S-3 111 1087340000855 C 6/02 74,900 77,200 77,334 .9983 S-2 152 1087390000010 C 11/02 87,400 65,500 88,056 .7438 S-3 1521 1091170001291 C 6/02 84,000 78,600 86,730 .9063 S-4 1521 1091200001370 C 5/02 78,500 88,700 81,443 1.0891 S-5 152 1091220001436 C 4/02 105,000 107,700 109,462 .9839 S-5 152 1091220001445 C 3/03 109,500 106,000 108,131 .9803 S-5 111 1093380000028 C 12/02 93,617 97,200 93,851 1.0357 S-3 111 1106700000041 C 9/02 85,000 78,100 86,488 .9030 S-4 152 1112890000016 C 9/02 83,000 86,700 84,453 1.0266 S-2 142 1115590010001 C 12/02 85,000 45,700 85,213 .5363 S-2 152 1115590010005 C 1/03 78,200 48,800 78,005 .6256 S-2 152 1115590030015 C 2/03 75,000 45,300 74,438 .6086 S-2 142 1115590030017 C 6/02 63,000 32,000 65,048 .4919 S-2 142 1115590040023 C 9/02 58,500 45,300 59,523 .7610 S-2 152 1117730000014 C 2/03 68,000 58,900 67,490 .8727 S-2 152 1117730000017 C 3/03 70,000 66,800 69,125 .9664 S-2 152 1117730000022 C 3/03 84,000 62,100 82,950 .7486 S-2 152 1117730000024 C 12/02 59,000 59,000 59,148 .9975 S-3 152 1117770000007 C 5/02 70,000 70,300 72,625 .9680 S-4 152 1125280000002 C 4/02 90,000 89,700 93,825 .9560 S-3 1521 1125950000050 C 5/02 92,000 80,800 95,450 .8465 S-2 152 1131730000010 C 1/03 79,900 60,100 79,700 .7541 S-3 152 1131740000042 C 2/03 90,000 69,100 89,325 .7736 S-3 152 1135880000023 C 5/02 91,000 80,300 94,413 .8505 S-4 111 1138050000006 C 1/03 76,000 83,900 75,810 1.1067 S-5 152 1138070000003 C 11/02 139,900 106,200 140,949 .7535 S-4 111 1138090000023 C 1/03 92,000 89,900 91,770 .9796 S-3 111 1138770000015 C 10/02 85,900 75,600 86,973 .8692 S-4 111 1138790000018 C 5/02 86,640 86,300 89,889 .9601

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 4 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-902 Aldine CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ S-3 152 1138830000017 C 6/02 85,000 78,400 87,763 .8933 S-4 152 1138850000058 C 8/02 93,500 86,200 95,603 .9016 S-5 111 1142410020037 C 7/02 145,000 149,500 148,987 1.0034 S-5 111 1142410030054 C 5/02 129,000 130,700 133,837 .9766 S-5 152 1142410040066 C 4/02 117,500 116,500 122,494 .9511 S-4 111 1143520050027 C 3/03 87,600 81,300 86,505 .9398 S-3 152 1143520050036 C 3/03 83,000 80,000 81,963 .9761 S-4 152 1143520070019 C 3/03 91,000 91,300 89,863 1.0160 S-2 152 1143550030018 C 9/02 50,500 59,800 51,383 1.1638 S-2 111 1143550040033 C 12/02 60,000 62,100 60,150 1.0324 S-2 111 1143550050015 C 11/02 57,000 63,600 57,428 1.1075 S-3 152 1144180010002 C 11/02 68,500 78,000 69,013 1.1302 S-4 1521 1144180010007 C 8/02 100,900 96,300 103,170 .9334 S-5 152 1144180030031 C 7/02 114,000 112,700 117,135 .9621 S-4 111 1144270010011 C 4/02 89,900 96,300 93,720 1.0275 S-4 152 1144270010015 C 12/02 99,900 96,400 100,150 .9626 S-5 111 1144270020005 C 5/02 98,000 99,200 101,675 .9757 S-4 152 1144270060019 C 5/02 82,000 90,400 85,075 1.0626 S-4 152 1144590010009 C 10/02 100,000 89,700 101,250 .8859 S-5 171 1144590020031 C 10/02 80,000 99,000 81,000 1.2222 S-4 152 1144590040008 C 6/02 99,900 89,000 103,147 .8628 S-4 152 1145730020001 C 11/02 97,000 95,200 97,728 .9741 S-2 152 1147310060036 C 2/03 48,800 56,300 48,434 1.1624 S-2 1421 1147310080062 C 4/02 55,650 57,100 58,015 .9842 S-2 152 1147310110009 C 2/03 55,000 60,100 54,588 1.1010 S-2 1421 1147310110029 C 5/02 53,000 56,800 54,988 1.0330 S-2 1111 1147310110052 C 8/02 58,487 62,200 59,803 1.0401 S-2 1421 1147310110163 C 8/02 65,000 64,700 66,463 .9735 S-5 152 1148060020055 C 2/03 103,000 97,500 102,227 .9538 S-3 152 1148740110001 C 8/02 73,000 78,500 74,643 1.0517 S-2 152 1148900010167 C 1/03 43,000 43,600 42,893 1.0165 S-2 152 1148900010213 C 12/02 44,500 43,800 44,611 .9818 S-5 152 1150490010029 C 9/02 116,000 115,300 118,030 .9769 S-4 152 1150490060001 C 1/03 67,000 88,900 66,833 1.3302 S-5 152 1150490060029 C 8/02 104,900 100,400 107,260 .9360 S-5 111 1150490100012 C 9/02 101,400 110,000 103,174 1.0662 S-5 111 1154950150437 C 10/02 156,000 159,200 157,950 1.0079 S-4 142 1156900020013 C 5/02 96,000 85,800 99,600 .8614 S-4 152 1156900050004 C 2/03 95,000 92,700 94,288 .9832 S-5 111 1159340030012 C 12/02 256,000 251,000 256,640 .9780 S-2 152 1160190010003 C 3/03 64,900 65,100 64,088 1.0158 S-2 1521 1160190010023 C 7/02 68,000 66,700 69,870 .9546 S-2 152 1160190020034 C 5/02 58,900 64,300 61,108 1.0522 S-2 152 1160350000105 C 11/02 54,400 43,200 54,808 .7882 S-2 152 1160350000114 C 4/02 52,900 43,200 55,148 .7833 S-2 152 1160350000128 C 11/02 54,000 41,900 54,405 .7701 S-2 171 1160350000130 C 8/02 62,725 47,900 64,136 .7468

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 5 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-902 Aldine CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ S-5 152 1161170060074 C 9/02 134,500 134,300 136,854 .9813 S-5 152 1164620030006 C 7/02 115,000 106,500 118,162 .9013 S-2 152 1194050030010 C 1/03 45,500 60,900 45,386 1.3418 S-3 152 1194050030011 C 2/03 62,700 77,600 62,229 1.2470 S-3 1211 1199060040010 C 12/02 55,000 71,800 55,138 1.3022 S-5 152 1201530010012 C 1/03 107,980 111,800 107,710 1.0380 S-5 152 1201530020032 C 10/02 112,900 109,200 114,311 .9553 S-5 152 1201530020050 C 8/02 108,900 110,400 111,350 .9915 S-5 152 1201530030048 C 2/03 112,500 113,500 111,656 1.0165 S-5 142 1205950030027 C 11/02 135,000 135,700 136,012 .9977 S-5 152 1211250010008 C 8/02 114,900 123,700 117,485 1.0529 S-5 111 1218440020019 C 11/02 122,000 118,800 122,915 .9665 200 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9475 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ NORTHBOROUGH SEC 3 1145860000008 C 7/02 6,840,000 4,595,400 6,840,000 .6718 1 SALES CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD APPR TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER MOD OBS VALUE APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ TR 6C BLK 17 0092210170016 1.00 .00 1,946,780 3,306,233 .5900 TR 16B 0410660000076 1.00 .00 3,730,350 3,418,330 1.0900 TR 1A-9 0420740000065 1.00 .00 3,700,000 4,216,362 .8800 TRS 5D & 5F 0430120000012 1.00 .00 6,541,500 6,544,483 1.0000 TR 22A 0430120000121 1.00 .00 5,283,000 5,886,269 .9000 TR 1G 0432390000015 1.00 .00 2,446,460 2,696,592 .9100 TR 57A 0552280270038 1.00 .00 597,470 529,438 1.1300 RES A4 1031120000007 1.00 .00 1,731,470 3,105,458 .5600 RES A5 & A6 1035040000017 1.00 .00 7,037,000 7,312,458 .9600 RES B4 1086170000004 1.00 .00 6,313,500 6,372,960 .9900 RES D6 1088270000006 1.00 .00 1,366,200 1,500,288 .9100 RES D3 1088270000011 1.00 .00 3,190,760 3,102,883 1.0300 RES E1 1088280000001 1.00 .00 2,900,380 3,241,623 .8900

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 6 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-902 Aldine CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD APPR TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER MOD OBS VALUE APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ RES E3 1088280000003 1.00 .00 4,495,270 4,527,917 .9900 RES K BLK 6 1121170000001 1.00 .00 4,139,340 4,271,955 .9700 RES D & D1 1127570000001 1.00 .00 5,140,000 4,779,575 1.0800 RES A BLK 4 1145340040001 1.00 .00 7,900,000 7,874,608 1.0000 RES A BLK 1 1146740010001 1.00 .00 3,081,420 2,683,948 1.1500 RES A1 BLK 1 1146740010002 1.00 .00 3,281,700 3,051,975 1.0800 RES I & I2 1150260000009 1.00 .00 12,452,600 12,048,464 1.0300 RES L 1151320000012 1.00 .00 5,650,720 5,024,758 1.1200 RES A3BLK 1 1161440010003 1.00 .00 3,483,600 3,195,017 1.0900 RES A 1165300010001 1.00 .00 1,293,070 1,130,017 1.1400 BLDGS 1 - 18 1166160000001 1.00 .00 1,557,940 1,601,458 .9700 BLDGS 1 - 6 1178320000001 1.00 .00 2,624,930 2,240,917 1.1700 BLDGS 1 - 11 1186870000001 1.00 .00 5,677,100 7,895,505 .7200 BLDGS 1 - 51 1196920000001 1.00 .00 5,780,000 5,622,567 1.0300 RES A BLK 1 1216200010001 1.00 .00 7,397,310 8,612,178 .8600 28 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9346 CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ V-Q/148037/ALDINE GRDNS SEC 2 0041750000345 B 2/03 271,000 242,130 271,000 .8935 V-C/145882/ORANGE GROVE BRITTO 0280610000039 B 7/02 280,000 280,000 280,000 1.0000 V-Q/146587/A-1394 J E DURKEE T 0471660000046 Y 6/02 900,000 748,900 805,019 .9300 V-Q/147701/AIRLINE FARMS LT 11 0650010250063 B 7/02 563,000 312,140 563,000 .5500 V-Q/146881/HAHL SITES LT 92 0651300000092 B 11/02 625,000 597,330 625,000 .9557 V-C/145805/GREENSGATE SEC 1 RE 1086910000012 B 5/02 1,335,000 1,153,600 1,335,000 .8641 V-C/145095/GREENBRIAR N SEC 6 1089450000006 B 4/02 1,400,000 1,400,000 1,400,000 1.0000 V-Q/146407/NBOROUGH SEC 1 RES 1127540000006 C 12/02 24,500,000 21,217,800 24,500,000 .8660 O-C/144965/GREENBRIAR PLACE RE 1145840000001 O 2/02 32,000,000 31,670,300 32,000,000 .9897 V-Q/144960/PINE VILLAGE PLZ RE 1167250010002 B 3/02 1,431,292 1,431,290 1,431,292 1.0000 V-C/144335/HESSED DEV 2 PAR R/ 1182090010001 B 2/02 2,850,000 2,647,230 2,850,000 .9289 V-C/148700/I E C RES A1 BK 1 1183760010002 B 6/03 4,500,000 4,500,000 4,500,000 1.0000 V-C/145284/VETERANS MEMORIAL A 1198680010001 B 5/02 3,500,000 2,500,000 3,500,000 .7143 13 SALES

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 7 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-902 Aldine CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ TRS 1G & 1L A-220 S CONTRERAS 0420740000038 .00 1.00 .00 1,437,090 1,535,000 .9400 LT 1 BLK 3 HARTLAND ACRES 0670910030001 .00 1.00 .00 17,805,900 17,500,000 1.0200 RES D C GREENBRIAR NORTH SEC 6 1086150000010 .00 1.00 .00 2,556,400 2,337,539 1.0900 RES F3 GREENBRIAR NORTH SEC 1 1086210000006 .00 1.00 .00 2,228,000 3,100,000 .7200 RES B3 GREENBRIAR NORTH SEC 5 1088310000003 .00 1.00 .00 6,844,000 6,900,000 .9900 RESE6 E13-B E14 BLK 3 GREENSPO 1121140000009 .00 1.00 .00 20,334,790 20,800,000 .9800 RES D5 D9-A BLK 3 GREENSPOINT 1121140000025 .00 1.00 .00 33,247,620 32,700,000 1.0200 RES I BLK 8 GREENSPOINT SEC 1 1121190000001 .00 1.00 .00 5,850,000 6,100,000 .9600 RES C BLK 1 WORLD HOUSTON SEC 1140270010003 .00 1.00 .00 3,680,590 5,143,580 .7200 RES A BLK 1 BURLINGTON INDUST 1141420010001 .00 1.00 .00 5,306,210 5,311,174 1.0000 RES B GREENBRIAR PLACE 11415840000002 .00 1.00 .00 7,265,270 7,100,000 1.0200 RES A1 GREENBRIAR PLACE 1145840000005 .00 1.00 .00 13,470,000 15,500,000 .8700 RES C1 GREENS CROSSING SEC 4 1152140000231 .00 1.00 .00 5,495,700 5,500,000 1.0000 RES A PARAGON CENTER ONE 1156850000001 .00 1.00 .00 14,825,200 15,400,000 .9600 RES A CENTRAL GREEN SEC 4 1169860000001 .00 1.00 .00 6,289,340 7,213,670 .8700 15 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9116 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ HOUSTON PIPE BENDERS 0011489 1,411,550 1,020,871 1.3800 LANDMARK CHEVROLET 0011854 3,936,980 3,491,406 1.1300 LIFT ALL COMPANY 0011891 915,750 1,062,930 .8600 SEARS 0012748 3,735,330 3,789,762 .9900 SOUTHWESTERN ROAD BORING 0012859 605,250 856,544 .7100 NORTHWEST RENTALS 0013114 268,040 370,938 .7200 WISENBAKER CARPET INC 0051726 6,407,710 6,426,868 1.0000 GENUINE PARTS COMPANY 0273405 5,738,440 5,645,729 1.0200 GREENE TWEED AND COMPANY 0294951 9,911,840 10,158,141 .9800 ARNONI AVIATION 0369991 2,015,020 2,070,311 .9700 DERRICK EQUIPMENT COMPANY 0400205 3,777,130 3,809,637 .9900 A. M. CASTLE & COMPANY 0423048 5,994,940 6,003,575 1.0000 WAL-MART 0437349 8,572,540 8,972,315 .9600 W T BYLER CO 0498276 1,504,380 1,504,380 1.0000 SAMS WHOLESALE 0579786 6,317,370 6,536,417 .9700 AGH MACHINE 0703248 81,450 110,197 .7400 FINISH MASTER #72 0710707 202,770 203,746 1.0000 PALAIS ROYAL 0766530 954,120 994,832 .9600 STRIPES AND STOPS INC 0779360 335,990 335,990 1.0000 ALLSTATE INSURANCE 0831809 144,960 129,002 1.1200

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 8 TIME: 14:29 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 101 Harris 101-902 Aldine CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ FRYS ELECTRONICS 0881057 10,726,230 10,881,190 .9900 21 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9555