Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   1/22/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:      9
TIME:     14:20                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             095  Hale
                                                         095-905  Plainview

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  HIGH SCHOOL PLV BLK 12 W20'-10   10170                      C       6/02         44,900          36,230        44,900     .8069
  COLLEGE HILL PLV BLK 54 LOT 8    10177                      C      10/02         32,500          29,212        32,500     .8988
  BROCK PLV BLK 15 N30'-14 S45'-   10209                      C       3/02        122,500         108,073       122,500     .8822
  BROCK PLV BLK 15 S66.1'-5 N33.   10228                      C       8/02        137,500         123,868       137,500     .9009
  ALEX-WESTM PLV BLK 79 LOT 5      10351                      C       5/02         30,000          26,956        30,000     .8985
  BOYNTON PLV BLK 4 LOT 12         10617                      C       8/02         35,000          26,362        35,000     .7532
  CAIN PLV BLK 1 S83.42-9          10795                      C       7/02         87,000          95,031        87,000    1.0923
  CAIN-COOPER PLV BLK 4 S83'-5     10884                      C       3/02        127,500          98,000       127,500     .7686
  LAKESIDE PLV BLK 44 70X140 OUT   11083                      C      12/02         59,500          47,654        59,500     .8009
  BOSS SMELSER PLV BLK 7 W10'-2    11123                      C       4/02        132,500         103,743       132,500     .7830
  ROBERSON PLV BLK 2 LOT 18        11194                      C      12/02         35,000          28,208        35,000     .8059
  SIMMONS PLV BLK 1 LOT 10         11229                      C       9/02         48,000          41,809        48,000     .8710
  SCHOOLVIEW PLV BLK 1 S52.5'-4    11419                      C       9/02         31,000          33,383        31,000    1.0769
  WARREN PLV BLK 2 LOT 10          11493                      C       2/02         46,500          38,511        46,500     .8282
  CURTIS PLV BLK 2 LOT 7           11599                      C      12/02         40,000          31,273        40,000     .7818
  COUNTRY CLUB PLV BLK 5 LOT 30    11718                      C       5/02         56,000          40,619        56,000     .7253
  HIGHLAND PLV BLK 6 LOT 11        12146                      C      10/02         32,000          58,111        32,000    1.8160
  WEST HILLCREST PLV BLK 11 LOTS   12164                      C       5/02        145,000         134,408       145,000     .9270
  PLEASANT HILLS UNIT 2 E.81.84'   12262                      C       5/02        116,000          97,947       116,000     .8444
  BRANDES PLV BLK 3 S30'-5&6 N43   12319                      C      11/02         31,000          39,171        31,000    1.2636
  BRANDES PLV BLK 5 LOT 5 N16'OF   12433                      C      11/02         69,500          61,469        69,500     .8844
  HIGHLAND PLV BLK 9 N130'-6 E3'   12589                      C       9/02         55,500          31,378        55,500     .5654
  HIGH SCHOOL PLV BLK 3 LOT 1 W1   12657                      C       8/02         54,000          47,831        54,000     .8858
  HIGHLAND PLV BLK 36 N40'-11 S2   12707                      C       4/02         41,000          34,393        41,000     .8389
  BROCK PLV BLK 7 LOT 6 UNIT 2     12727                      C       2/02         40,000          44,441        40,000    1.1110
  WESTERN MEADOWS PLV UNIT 1 LOT   12791                      C       6/02         90,000          89,648        90,000     .9961
  GRANDVIEW PLV LOT 27             12806                      C       8/02        157,500         145,775       157,500     .9256
  EDGEMERE PARK PLV UNIT 3 E23'-   13174                      C      10/02         83,500          88,120        83,500    1.0553
  BROCK PLV BLK 12 LOT 1 UNIT 2    13409                      C       7/02         72,900          65,547        72,900     .8991
  BROCK PLV BLK 13 LOT 11 UNIT 7   13506                      C       3/02         92,000          87,585        92,000     .9520
  TERRY PLV BLK 1 LOT 14           13664                      C       3/02         59,500          62,286        59,500    1.0468
  TERRY PLV BLK 1 LOT 9            13670                      C       1/03        107,250          89,206       107,250     .8318
  HIGHLAND PLV BLK 68 LOT 7        13671                      C      12/02         19,000          24,706        19,000    1.3003
  SHEPARD-COUCH PLV BLK 2 LOT 14   13927                      C       1/03         25,000          34,132        25,000    1.3653
  BROCK PLV BLK 16 S26'-6 N69'-7   13995                      C       5/02        129,000         114,421       129,000     .8870
  ROWE-GOODE PLV BLK 5 LOT 13      14188                      C       2/02         28,500          27,507        28,500     .9652
  PLANKS PLV BLK 2 LOT 3           14240                      C       9/02         43,000          44,323        43,000    1.0308
  CAIN-COOPER PLV BLK 3 LOT 1 N1   14293                      C       5/02        130,600         101,863       130,600     .7800
  WAYLAND HEIGHTS PLV BLK B-10 L   143                        C       5/02         58,500          56,138        58,500     .9596
  COLLEGE HILL PLV BLK 9 LOTS 3-   14481                      C      11/02         40,000          48,634        40,000    1.2159
  WESTRIDGE PARK PLV UNIT 3 LOT    14501                      C       1/03        470,000         386,191       470,000     .8217
  BELL PLV BLK 1 LOT 6             14545                      C       9/02         56,500          29,951        56,500     .5301
  BELL PLV BLK 2 LOT 6             14669                      C       7/02         52,500          44,177        52,500     .8415
  ROBERSON PLV BLK 1 LOT 4         14703                      C       3/02         60,000          50,772        60,000     .8462
  SPRINGER PLV BLK 1 LOT 5         14828                      C       4/02         58,000          53,958        58,000     .9303
  SIMMONS PLV BLK 1 LOT 11 S3.5'   14841                      C       2/02         70,000          65,949        70,000     .9421
  COLLEGE HILL PLV BLK 10 W47'-4   14899                      C       1/03         89,500          81,364        89,500     .9091

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 10 TIME: 14:20 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 095 Hale 095-905 Plainview CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ EDGEMERE PLV BLK 9 W3'-4 E59'- 14901 C 9/02 67,000 58,928 67,000 .8795 BRYAN PLV LOTS 4-5 N6'-6 UNIT 15206 C 2/02 82,500 71,968 82,500 .8723 LEMONS PLV BLK 1 LOTS 1-2 15240 C 12/02 139,500 119,832 139,500 .8590 ALEX-WESTM PLV BLK 86 LOTS 7-8 15248 C 7/02 90,000 77,006 90,000 .8556 COUNTRY CLUB PLV BLK 4 LOT 1 15271 C 9/02 45,000 40,239 45,000 .8942 COUNTRY CLUB PLV BLK 5 LOT 16 15392 C 5/02 65,000 47,541 65,000 .7314 COLLEGE HILL PLV BLK 14 LOT 4 15454 C 3/02 32,000 29,539 32,000 .9231 WILCOX PLV BLK 4 LOT 1 15586 C 2/02 138,500 122,585 138,500 .8851 COLLEGE HILL PLV BLK 15 W70'-9 15615 C 6/02 58,500 54,554 58,500 .9325 COLLEGE HILL PLV BLK 15 E/2-9& 15642 C 7/02 57,000 56,698 57,000 .9947 ALEX-WESTM PLV BLK 89 W/2 OF L 15692 C 1/03 61,000 71,545 61,000 1.1729 R B JONES PLV BLK 1 LOT 15 15822 C 7/02 39,500 32,489 39,500 .8225 COLLEGE HILL PLV BLK 69 LOT 14 15847 C 8/02 37,800 29,037 37,800 .7682 HARRIS MALONE PLV BLK 2 LOT 1 16017 C 6/02 73,500 54,003 73,500 .7347 CENT PLS CONS PLV BLK 50 LOTS 16058 C 1/03 20,412 23,882 20,412 1.1700 BROCK PLV BLK 5 LOT 7 UNIT 1 16129 C 9/02 79,000 74,576 79,000 .9440 WESTRIDGE PLV BLK 2 LOT 6 16173 C 8/02 138,700 179,692 138,700 1.2955 HIGHLAND PLV BLK 9 LOT 12 16186 C 11/02 48,000 33,631 48,000 .7006 BROCK PLV BLK 6 LOT 12 UNIT 2 16241 C 12/02 56,900 48,660 56,900 .8552 BROCK PLV BLK 5 S7.36'-2 N62.6 16280 C 5/02 82,600 69,518 82,600 .8416 WESTERN MEADOWS PLV UNIT 2 LOT 16321 C 2/03 75,000 72,297 75,000 .9640 WATSON PLV BLK 2 N50'-8 16367 C 7/02 25,000 22,199 25,000 .8880 VILLA WEST PLV LOT 14 UNIT 1 16384 C 6/02 61,675 58,618 61,675 .9504 VILLA WEST PLV LOT 9 UNIT 1 16397 C 1/02 52,500 64,883 52,500 1.2359 WESTERN MEADOWS PLV UNIT 1 W56 16444 C 11/02 76,000 75,682 76,000 .9958 AB 1589 BLK JK-2 SEC 34 NE/C 2 16513 C 1/02 102,500 94,751 102,500 .9244 HIGHLAND PLV BLK 12 LOT 2 16534 C 5/02 33,500 29,369 33,500 .8767 HIGHLAND PLV BLK 62 LOTS 12-13 16537 C 7/02 25,000 22,578 25,000 .9031 WAYLAND HEIGHTS PLV BLK B-10 L 16731 C 7/02 43,000 42,004 43,000 .9768 HIGH SCHOOL PLV BLK 9 LOT 7 E1 16967 C 2/02 41,000 35,441 41,000 .8644 EDGEMERE PLV BLK 1 E90'-14 17177 C 7/02 99,500 93,300 99,500 .9377 HIGH SCHOOL PLV BLK 11 LOTS 7- 17200 C 4/02 69,500 64,144 69,500 .9229 BLOXOM-PATRICK PLV BLK 2 S128. 17228 C 6/02 26,750 26,782 26,750 1.0012 BLOXUM-PATRICK PLV BLK 2 E42'O 17237 C 3/02 68,500 61,830 68,500 .9026 TERRY PLV BLK 3 E5'-25 LOT 26 17519 C 11/02 85,000 74,768 85,000 .8796 RIVERSIDE PLV BLK 1 LOT 1 E7'- 17560 C 5/02 51,000 44,090 51,000 .8645 TERRY PLV BLK 4 LOT 5 17613 C 3/02 67,500 62,860 67,500 .9313 BOSS SMELSER PLV BLK 3 LOT 9 S 17692 C 8/02 85,900 70,714 85,900 .8232 RIVERSIDE PLV BLK 3 LOT 1 17839 C 10/02 55,500 67,073 55,500 1.2085 TOWN WEST PLV LOT 34 17850 C 2/02 88,500 85,207 88,500 .9628 CAIN PLV BLK 2 LOT 6 17937 C 1/02 108,500 105,142 108,500 .9691 HERRING PLV BLK 2 S/2-2 LOT 3 17999 C 8/02 70,000 64,044 70,000 .9149 COLLEGE HILL PLV BLK 9 N17.5'- 18028 C 10/02 39,000 29,173 39,000 .7480 BOSS SMELSER PLV BLK 5 S34'-4 18130 C 5/02 78,500 72,364 78,500 .9218 ROBERSON PLV BLK 2 LOT 15 18366 C 6/02 44,000 41,793 44,000 .9498 CAIN PLV BLK 4 LOT 7 UNIT 3 18465 C 9/02 96,000 92,617 96,000 .9648 BABITZKE PLV BLK 3 W/2 OF LOTS 18696 C 9/02 62,500 46,817 62,500 .7491

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 11 TIME: 14:20 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 095 Hale 095-905 Plainview CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ COUNTRY CLUB PLV BLK 4 LOT 7 18896 C 4/02 87,000 79,262 87,000 .9111 HIGHLAND PLV BLK 3 LOTS 8-10 19095 C 4/02 131,000 116,601 131,000 .8901 BROCK PLV BLK 25 N70'-3 UNIT 1 19105 C 5/02 87,000 81,022 87,000 .9313 HIGHLAND PLV BLK 4 LOTS 3-4 19243 C 2/02 52,500 44,393 52,500 .8456 HARRIS MALONE PLV BLK 1 LOT 11 19323 C 8/02 96,000 98,908 96,000 1.0303 HIGHLAND PLV BLK 4 E/2-13&14 19328 C 11/02 15,000 20,196 15,000 1.3464 COLLEGE HILL PLV BLK 93 SMALL 19358 C 12/02 125,000 117,540 125,000 .9403 BRANDES PLV BLK 4 N17'-22 S41' 19654 C 8/02 47,500 46,034 47,500 .9691 NSLS PLV BLK 23 S/2-17 LOT 18 19714 C 4/02 27,000 24,219 27,000 .8970 ALEX-WESTM PLV BLK 65 S33'-3 N 19750 C 5/02 55,000 49,223 55,000 .8950 WESTGATE PLV UNIT 3 S62'-89 19779 C 4/02 95,000 82,558 95,000 .8690 HIGHLAND PLV BLK 35 LOT 8 19884 C 8/02 15,000 21,944 15,000 1.4629 JR HIGH PLV BLK 2 E9'-3 W63'-4 20071 C 11/02 84,000 66,439 84,000 .7909 GREEN ACRES PLV BLK 3 W 50' OF 20352 C 4/02 61,900 44,542 61,900 .7196 HILLCREST PLV BLK 2 LOT 7 20501 C 8/02 45,500 39,738 45,500 .8734 JR HIGH PLV BLK 6 W30'-18 E35' 20511 C 7/02 47,000 35,234 47,000 .7497 LA MESA PLV UNIT 8 LOT 51 206815 C 2/02 192,500 161,539 192,500 .8392 LA MESA PLV UNIT 8 LOT 50 206943 C 7/02 185,000 162,329 185,000 .8775 WAYLAND HEIGHTS PLV BLK A-10 E 20709 C 6/02 63,500 68,054 63,500 1.0717 COLLEGE HILL PLV BLK 53 LOT 11 21056 C 9/02 50,000 40,226 50,000 .8045 HIGHLAND PLV BLK 18 LOT 4 21265 C 3/02 35,000 33,856 35,000 .9673 NORTHSIDE PLV BLK 2 LOT 12 21404 C 10/02 20,000 37,306 20,000 1.8653 RIVERSIDE PLV BLK 2 LOT 12 21513 C 7/02 34,500 27,320 34,500 .7919 EAST COLLEGE HTS PLV BLK B 100 21587 C 6/02 65,000 43,987 65,000 .6767 AYLESWORTH PLV BLK 1 LOT 14 21720 C 1/02 48,000 52,978 48,000 1.1037 TOWN WEST PLV LOT 15 21749 C 7/02 70,000 64,471 70,000 .9210 AYLESWORTH PLV BLK 1 S40'-9 N2 21773 C 3/02 39,000 38,786 39,000 .9945 OT PLV BLK 58 LOT 16 21876 C 4/02 38,000 29,674 38,000 .7809 TERRY PLV BLK 7 W56'-6 E44'-7 21917 C 7/02 85,000 82,502 85,000 .9706 HANNA PLV BLK 1 N20'-19 LOT 20 21945 C 7/02 61,000 46,193 61,000 .7573 GRAND CASTLE EST PLV UNIT 1 LO 22067 C 1/03 140,000 109,901 140,000 .7850 EDGEMERE PLV BLK 8 LOT 16 22114 C 1/02 62,500 56,058 62,500 .8969 ROBERSON PLV BLK 2 LOT 16 22266 C 8/02 57,500 48,442 57,500 .8425 COUNTRY CLUB PLV BLK 2 LOT 3 22386 C 10/02 45,000 53,284 45,000 1.1841 LEMONS PLV BLK 2 LOTS 28-29 22804 C 10/02 147,500 104,476 147,500 .7083 EDGEMERE PLV BLK 12 LOT 1 22817 C 7/02 85,000 90,496 85,000 1.0647 BROCK PLV BLK 25 S5'-8 N66'-9 22919 C 4/02 132,500 103,435 132,500 .7806 BRANNON PLV BLK 1 W70' OF 9, 23124 C 7/02 60,000 43,442 60,000 .7240 COLLEGE HILL PLV BLK 41 S60'N1 23170 C 1/03 25,000 27,401 25,000 1.0960 BRANNON PLV BLK 1 S30.82'-4 LO 23229 C 7/02 48,500 46,435 48,500 .9574 CB JONES PLV BLK 3 W65'-7 E10' 23366 C 6/02 88,000 88,143 88,000 1.0016 HARRIS MALONE PLV BLK 3 LOT 8 23615 C 9/02 47,000 49,229 47,000 1.0474 WESTRIDGE PLV BLK 2 LOT 8 23652 C 7/02 145,000 131,914 145,000 .9098 OT PLV BLK 43 S38'-6 23656 C 5/02 30,000 33,441 30,000 1.1147 WESTERN MEADOWS PLV UNIT 1 LOT 23921 C 7/02 88,000 81,925 88,000 .9310 GREEN ACRES PLV BLK 2 LOT 1 23949 C 2/02 68,000 55,837 68,000 .8211 HILLCREST PLV BLK 2 LOT 8 24279 C 7/02 57,000 61,048 57,000 1.0710

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 12 TIME: 14:20 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 095 Hale 095-905 Plainview CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ HIGHLAND PLV BLK 13 S50'-9&10 24322 C 2/02 35,000 29,122 35,000 .8321 MASTEN PLV BLK 1 S65'-7 ALL 8- 24455 C 5/02 67,900 69,485 67,900 1.0233 AB 18 BLK JK-2 SEC 15 OUT OF W 24576 C 6/02 156,000 124,605 156,000 .7988 DAY PLV BLK 2 S33'-9 N41'-10 24672 C 6/02 61,500 61,218 61,500 .9954 COLLEGE HILL PLV BLK 2 LOT 11 24695 C 2/02 15,000 23,115 15,000 1.5410 TERRY PLV BLK 1 LOT 12 24820 C 11/02 56,000 55,555 56,000 .9921 THUNDERBIRD PLV BLK 7 LOT 7 UN 24925 C 7/02 31,000 31,504 31,000 1.0163 TERRY PLV BLK 2 LOT 7 24943 C 6/02 65,500 67,219 65,500 1.0262 BOSS SMELSER PLV BLK 1 LOT 6 S 25020 C 10/02 100,000 80,696 100,000 .8070 ALEX-WESTM PLV BLK 78 E50' OF 25057 C 1/02 41,500 33,169 41,500 .7993 HERRING PLV BLK 1 LOT 9 S20'-1 25275 C 3/02 45,000 40,832 45,000 .9074 HIGHLAND PLV BLK 19 S120'-5 S1 25301 C 3/02 90,500 84,012 90,500 .9283 TOWN WEST PLV LOT 81 UNIT 2 25306 C 3/02 68,000 66,521 68,000 .9783 BOSWELL PLV BLK 2 LOT 8 25331 C 2/02 27,000 26,131 27,000 .9678 BROCK PLV BLK 19 TRI-OFF-N/SID 25334 C 5/02 95,000 104,420 95,000 1.0992 TOWN WEST PLV LOT 11 25442 C 6/02 62,000 62,066 62,000 1.0011 WESTRIDGE PARK PLV UNIT 3 LOT 25546 C 10/02 200,000 252,449 200,000 1.2622 GARDENVILLE PLV BLK 5 W60'-14 25594 C 10/02 42,500 30,985 42,500 .7291 BOSS SMELSER PLV BLK 8 LOT 1 E 25857 C 7/02 65,900 61,846 65,900 .9385 CAIN PLV BLK 4 LOT 4 UNIT 3 25927 C 10/02 125,000 94,394 125,000 .7552 BRANDES PLV BLK 2 W80'-8 W80'O 26 C 11/02 55,500 53,110 55,500 .9569 COWART PLV BLK 2 LOT 4 N30'-5 26025 C 3/02 106,000 88,276 106,000 .8328 LEMONS PLV BLK 2 W34.37'-14 E4 26420 C 2/02 72,500 70,346 72,500 .9703 EDGEMERE PLV BLK 13 LOT 2 26458 C 7/02 73,000 71,391 73,000 .9780 CB JONES PLV BLK 2 LOT 8 26616 C 7/02 106,000 92,487 106,000 .8725 BROCK PLV BLK 1 S55'-5 N45'-6 26721 C 7/02 95,000 74,471 95,000 .7839 BROCK PLV BLK 2 S20'-5 LOT 6 26834 C 2/02 95,500 87,852 95,500 .9199 NSLS PLV BLK 24 LOT 19 26915 C 1/02 23,750 22,076 23,750 .9295 VILLA WEST PLV LOT 58 UNIT 2 27190 C 12/02 67,000 72,579 67,000 1.0833 BROCK PLV BLK 7 LOT 20 UNIT 2 27213 C 1/03 70,000 62,897 70,000 .8985 WESTERN MEADOWS PLV UNIT 1 LOT 27269 C 8/02 75,000 74,241 75,000 .9899 CENT PLS CONS PLV BLK 51 LOTS 27297 C 9/02 35,000 21,727 35,000 .6208 GRANDVIEW PLV LOT 11 E40'-12 27352 C 1/02 150,000 155,608 150,000 1.0374 TITUS PLV BLK 3 W63'-8 27381 C 1/02 36,000 33,768 36,000 .9380 BROCK PLV BLK 9 N75'-15 UNIT 2 27456 C 12/02 162,000 144,970 162,000 .8949 BROCK PLV BLK 9 S10'-5 N60'-6 27595 C 5/02 81,000 79,137 81,000 .9770 HILLCREST PLV BLK 3 LOTS 9-10 27707 C 12/02 85,500 89,461 85,500 1.0463 WAYLAND HEIGHTS PLV BLK A-10 E 27861 C 10/02 27,500 27,929 27,500 1.0156 PROSSER PLV BLK 2 LOTS 8-9 27923 C 4/02 44,800 38,912 44,800 .8686 HARRIS MALONE PLV BLK 1 LOT 14 28162 C 1/02 49,900 52,022 49,900 1.0425 WESTRIDGE PARK PLV UNIT 4 LOT 61540 C 10/02 140,000 147,574 140,000 1.0541 WESTGATE PLV UNIT 1 S60'-15 66 C 8/02 84,500 85,302 84,500 1.0095 VILLA WEST PLV LOT 66 UNIT 2 72619 C 3/02 60,000 67,195 60,000 1.1199 CENT PLS CONS PLV BLK 37 LOTS 75395 C 5/02 15,000 20,779 15,000 1.3853 WESTRIDGE PARK PLV UNIT 5 LOT 77057 C 10/02 305,000 225,182 305,000 .7383 TOWN WEST PLV UNIT 2 LOT 59 77431 C 8/02 95,000 94,284 95,000 .9925 TOWN WEST PLV UNIT 2 SW 56' OF 77722 C 9/02 76,000 76,056 76,000 1.0007

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 13 TIME: 14:20 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 095 Hale 095-905 Plainview CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ TOWN WEST PLV UNIT 3 LOTS 108- 77733 C 5/02 87,900 97,928 87,900 1.1141 WESTRIDGE PARK PLV UNIT 5 LOT 77941 C 9/02 197,000 166,105 197,000 .8432 WESTGATE PLV UNIT 4 LOT 124 78430 C 4/02 78,000 72,112 78,000 .9245 WESTGATE PLV UNIT 4 LOT 129 78435 C 7/02 79,250 82,290 79,250 1.0384 WESTGATE PLV UNIT 4 LOT 130 78436 C 2/02 84,000 78,397 84,000 .9333 WESTGATE PLV UNIT 4 LOT 148 78454 C 1/03 85,500 78,670 85,500 .9201 CLARK SUB PLV LOT 1 78987 C 1/02 98,000 89,436 98,000 .9126 CLARK SUB PLV LOT 11 78997 C 12/02 97,000 90,561 97,000 .9336 CLARK SUB PLV LOT 12 78998 C 8/02 115,000 95,883 115,000 .8338 197 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9172 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AB 729 PRE W E STEWART 159.5 A 11234 C 4/02 40,630 47,850 .8491 AB 1639 BLK D-2 SEC 68 E/2 OF 12157 C 3/03 51,737 62,500 .8278 AB 27 BLK JK-2 SEC 31 OUT OF S 12259 C 3/03 142,227 110,200 1.2906 AB 1362 BLK JK-3 SEC 2 SW/4 15 16597 C 2/02 70,128 78,307 .8956 AB 1284 BLK JK-2 SEC 24 OUT OF 207097 C 3/02 48,757 70,000 .6965 AB 1013 PRE J R LOGAN ALL 152. 208061 C 3/02 57,456 60,000 .9576 AB 1467 BLK D-6 SEC 22 OUT OF 208458 C 5/02 9,917 10,000 .9917 AB 2030 BLK A-1 SEC 58 OUT SE/ 208518 C 9/02 943 19,860 .0475 MARTIN-HARLAN PLV BLK 15 LOT 2 209001 C 1/03 7,718 15,400 .5012 AB 1595 BLK D-6 SEC 8 E/2 209. 20931 C 10/02 118,209 135,000 .8756 AB 299 BLK 0 SEC 11 SW/4 160 A 21953 C 12/02 73,280 136,000 .5388 AB 2397 BLK 0 SEC 14 S/PT OF S 23665 C 1/02 76,803 54,119 1.4192 AB 1906 BLK C-3 SEC 16 N 85.23 24195 C 2/02 34,276 31,295 1.0953 AB 942 BLK N SEC 21 NE/4 IN HA 25086 C 2/03 45,630 65,600 .6956 AB 933 PRE L A WHITE OUT OF 26 25495 C 3/03 106,627 125,000 .8530 AB 277 BLK K SEC 53 S & W OF H 25687 C 3/03 21,479 34,000 .6317 AB 1435 BLK O SEC 14 S40 E50 & 28133 C 1/02 39,490 40,375 .9781 AB 2493 BLK 0 SEC 14 S/PT OF N 28134 C 1/02 9,308 13,880 .6706 AB 1328 BLK JK-4 SEC 12 OUT OF 71440 C 4/03 79,774 94,500 .8442 AB 2148 BLK JK SEC 24 OUT NE/C 73549 C 6/03 102,406 115,000 .8905

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 14 TIME: 14:20 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 095 Hale 095-905 Plainview CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BROWNING SUB LOT 8 78860 C 3/02 167,051 175,000 .9546 21 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .8728 CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ HIGHLAND PLV BLK 2 LOT 1 S5'-2 11658 C 4/02 24,000 27,701 24,000 1.1542 WEST LYNN PLV BLK 3 LOTS 9-10 12979 C 10/02 36,000 28,977 36,000 .8049 OT PLV BLK 52 LOTS 4-6 13708 C 9/02 41,000 44,505 41,000 1.0855 WESTRIDGE PLV UNIT 1 LOT 1 4 16762 C 8/02 1,050,000 307,934 1,050,000 .2933 SLATON PLV BLK 1 LOT 9 20860 C 12/02 55,000 42,664 55,000 .7757 AB 1472 BLK JK-2 SEC 28 OUT OF 22417 C 4/03 90,000 81,124 90,000 .9014 ALEX-WESTM PLV BLK 73 LOTS 4-5 24402 C 2/02 112,000 103,763 112,000 .9265 OT PLV BLK 34 LOT 7-8 25784 C 7/02 115,000 84,980 115,000 .7390 MARTIN-HARLAN PLV BLK 1 150X15 26198 C 1/02 150,000 83,415 150,000 .5561 MCCLELLAND PLV BLK 7 LOTS 1-3 27354 C 8/02 30,000 24,176 30,000 .8059 10 SALES CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ EDGEMERE HEIGHTS PLV BLK 4 LOT 10949 .00 1.00 .00 753,255 759,538 .9900 AB 2257 BLK JK-2 SEC 28 15537 .00 1.00 .00 229,913 234,221 .9800 GRANDVIEW PLV LOT 44 17732 .00 1.00 .00 1,374,203 1,285,231 1.0700 COLLEGE HILL PLV BLK 86 18197 .00 1.00 .00 672,181 785,175 .8600 WILCOX PLV UNIT 3 PART LOTS 7- 18644 .00 1.00 .00 657,306 1,206,216 .5400 AB 500 BLK JK-2 SEC N40 20085 .00 1.00 .00 99,501 83,951 1.1900 MESA VERDE PLV UNIT 1 LOT PORT 205709 .00 1.00 .00 1,090,137 1,119,489 .9700 MESA VERDE PLV UNIT 1 PORTION 206777 .00 1.00 .00 1,997,191 1,994,063 1.0000 SLATON PLV BLK 1 LOTS 4-8 20880 .00 1.00 .00 152,877 151,623 1.0100 COLLEGE HILL PLV BLK 30 ALL PL 21183 .00 1.00 .00 650,980 702,785 .9300 GRANDVIEW PLV LOTS 45-48 22383 .00 1.00 .00 2,305,731 2,393,380 .9600 WESTRIDGE PLV UNIT 2 LOT 1 23902 .00 1.00 .00 903,989 879,942 1.0300 COLLEGE HILL PLV BLK 77 LOT 1- 24651 .00 1.00 .00 144,346 147,951 .9800 AB 26 BLK JK-2 SEC 29 OUT OF W 26654 .00 1.00 .00 172,859 186,336 .9300 ALEX-WESTM PLV BLK 73 W72' OF 27717 .00 1.00 .00 174,389 172,425 1.0100

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 15 TIME: 14:20 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 095 Hale 095-905 Plainview CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ MESA VERDE PLV UNIT 1 LOT 1 73241 .00 1.00 .00 1,219,084 1,370,641 .8900 MESA VERDE PLV UNIT LOT 2 LESS 73320 .00 1.00 .00 529,877 600,187 .8800 WESTRIDGE PLV UNIT 6 E11' OF L 76115 .00 1.00 .00 1,846,971 1,831,332 1.0100 18 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .8468 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ GEBOS DIST 160 436,707 438,561 1.0000 EIGHTY FOUR LUMBER CO 20182 553,352 543,350 1.0200 DOLLAR GENERAL 206711 268,221 285,563 .9400 UNITED SUPERMARKETS 206817 1,441,147 1,444,724 1.0000 HALFWAY FARM CHEMICAL 20694 64,030 39,876 1.6100 SHERWIN-WILLIAMS CO #7128 21162 125,300 121,458 1.0300 AGRIGENETICS INC 317 553,630 558,775 .9900 MCDONALDS RESTUARANT 61688 167,390 148,781 1.1300 WAL-MART STORES INC 73675 4,806,150 4,839,695 .9900 AMERICAN STATE BANK 76749 87,816 71,870 1.2200 DCS SANITATION MANANGEMENT 76770 31,465 36,663 .8600 CITICAPITAL COMMERCIAL LEASING 77050 484,224 432,274 1.1200 COLORFUL CREATIONS 77091 55,555 93,066 .6000 AMERICAN HOME PATIENT 77420 137,116 137,194 1.0000 FAMILY DOLLAR 77684 130,583 126,093 1.0400 ENTERPRISE RENT A CAR 77763 273,916 331,779 .8300 CHEP USA 78099 709,982 709,982 1.0000 BEALLS 78196 621,635 622,099 1.0000 SEARS ROEBUCK 78259 195,379 193,750 1.0100 TRI STATE CHEMICAL 79512 2,458,227 2,443,485 1.0100 STERLING FLUID SYSTEMS USA INC 79667 1,270,793 1,252,201 1.0100 21 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0041