DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 43 TIME: 13:54 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 071 El Paso 071-909 Socorro CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 2 ASHFORD GOLF ESTATES #1 LOT A78800000200200 B 1/03 131,750 127,860 131,668 .9700 2 ASHFORD GOLF ESTATES #1 LOT A78800000200900 B 9/02 135,000 150,000 135,591 1.1100 3 ASHFORD GOLF ESTATES #1 LOT A78800000301000 B 10/02 158,000 146,166 158,494 .9200 5 ASHFORD GOLF ESTATES #1 LOT A78800000500100 B 4/02 154,500 155,225 156,142 .9900 1 BAGGE ESTATES LOT 4 B10000000010004 B 3/03 67,500 53,384 67,289 .7900 6 BAUMAN ESTATES #2 LOT 11 B28700000601100 B 7/02 80,000 79,067 80,550 .9800 3 EDGEMERE PLACE LOT 19 E24099900301900 B 11/02 65,000 59,239 65,122 .9100 13 FREIDMAN ESTATES #2 LOT 29 F80000201300290 B 5/02 45,000 41,359 45,422 .9100 11 HACIENDAS DEL VALLE #1 LO H01100001100200 B 7/02 65,000 61,929 65,447 .9500 2 HORIZON HGHTS #11-A LOT 3 H78200000200300 B 6/02 93,000 91,274 93,756 .9700 6 HORIZON HGHTS #11-C LOT 10 H78200000601000 B 4/02 119,000 119,811 120,264 1.0000 7 HORIZON HGHTS #11-C LOT 7 H78200000700700 B 8/02 93,650 92,421 94,177 .9800 9 HORIZON HGHTS #11-C LOT 10 H78200000901000 B 8/02 90,000 93,985 90,506 1.0400 11 HORIZON HGHTS #11-B LOT 7 H78200001100700 B 5/02 104,900 111,392 105,883 1.0500 2 HORIZON GOLF HOMESITES LOT 1 H78300000201000 B 3/03 132,000 112,018 131,587 .8500 2 HORIZON GOLF HOMESITES LOT 1 H78300000201300 B 6/02 110,000 101,178 110,894 .9100 HORIZON COUNTRY CLUB TOWNHOUSE H78600000000160 B 12/02 50,000 46,542 50,031 .9300 HORIZON COUNTRY CLUB TOWNHOUSE H78600000000200 B 7/02 62,000 60,482 62,426 .9700 HORIZON COUNTRY CLUB TOWNHOUSE H78600000000700 B 10/02 52,000 52,121 52,163 1.0000 12 HORIZON HGHTS #2 LOT 10 H78800201200100 B 9/02 72,000 73,753 72,315 1.0200 22 HORIZON HGHTS #4 LOT 6 H78800402200060 B 9/02 116,000 114,537 116,507 .9800 23 HORIZON HGHTS #4 LOT 18 H78800402300180 B 2/03 104,000 103,717 103,805 1.0000 36 HORIZON HGHTS #6 LOT 4 H78800603600040 B 2/03 87,000 87,794 86,837 1.0100 43 HORIZON HGHTS #10 PRT LOT H78801004300070 B 5/02 97,000 95,205 97,909 .9700 43 HORIZON HGHTS #10 REPLAT A H78801004300560 B 5/02 89,000 86,879 89,834 .9700 43 HORIZON HGHTS #10 REPLAT A H78801004300590 B 2/03 65,000 73,923 64,878 1.1400 47 HORIZON HGHTS #10 LOT 1 H78801004700010 B 1/03 110,000 106,884 109,931 .9700 48 HORIZON HGHTS #10 REPLAT A H78801004800200 B 2/03 78,500 83,486 78,353 1.0700 49 HORIZON HGHTS #10 REPLAT A H78801004900020 B 7/02 66,500 66,436 66,957 .9900 7 HORIZON HGHTS #11-D LOT 18 H78801100701800 B 5/02 98,200 89,351 99,121 .9000 7 HORIZON HGHTS UNIT 11-D LOT H78801100704600 B 6/02 119,950 95,538 120,925 .7900 7 HORIZON HGHTS #11-D LOT 57 H78801100705700 B 10/02 115,450 114,451 115,811 .9900 12 HORIZON HGHTS UNIT 11-D LOT H78801101200400 B 12/02 104,500 103,971 104,565 .9900 12 HORIZON HGHTS UNIT 11-D LO H78801101201400 B 5/02 112,400 106,974 113,454 .9400 12 HORIZON HGHTS #11-D LOT 18 H78801101201800 B 5/02 130,000 131,622 131,219 1.0000 13 HORIZON HGHTS #11-D LOT 8 H78801101300800 B 10/02 111,450 104,633 111,798 .9400 13 HORIZON HGHTS #11-D LOT 18 H78801101301800 B 10/02 115,950 89,791 116,312 .7700 13 HORIZON HGHTS #11-D PRT LOT H78801101302100 B 10/02 123,950 109,323 124,337 .8800 14 HORIZON HGHTS #11-D LOT 9 H78801101400900 B 5/02 129,900 127,085 131,118 .9700 14 HORIZON HGHTS #11-D LOT 10 H78801101401000 B 4/02 99,950 112,280 101,012 1.1100 15 HORIZON HGHTS #11-D LOT 6 H78801101500600 B 6/02 121,200 121,458 122,185 .9900 15 HORIZON HGHTS #11-D LOT 7 H78801101500700 B 11/02 97,000 88,774 97,182 .9100 16 HORIZON HGHTS #11-D LOT 6 H78801101600600 B 7/02 115,055 106,518 115,846 .9200 17 HORIZON HGHTS #11-D LOT 5 H78801101700500 B 10/02 125,609 106,610 126,002 .8500 22 HORIZON HGHTS #12 LOT 2-A H7880120220002A B 3/03 41,800 44,555 41,669 1.0700 22 HORIZON HGHTS #12 LOT 3-A H7880120220003A B 7/02 124,000 123,329 124,852 .9900 25 HORIZON HGHTS #12 LOT 18 H78801202500180 B 12/02 135,000 133,827 135,084 .9900DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 44 TIME: 13:54 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 071 El Paso 071-909 Socorro CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 1 HUECO MTN VILLAGE REPLAT A H80199900102825 B 1/03 93,950 75,189 93,891 .8000 3 HUECO MTN VILLAGE REPLAT A H80199900301300 B 1/03 85,950 75,013 85,896 .8700 5 HUECO MTN VILLAGE REPLAT A H80199900500925 B 10/02 85,950 74,815 86,219 .8700 3 LYNN PARK LOT 14 L98500000030014 B 6/02 50,000 62,557 50,406 1.2400 6 LYNN PARK LOT 3 L98500000060003 B 4/02 55,000 51,593 55,584 .9300 9 MONTWOOD HGHTS #1 LOT 6 M77199900900600 B 9/02 62,500 63,667 62,773 1.0100 9 MONTWOOD HGHTS #2 LOT 27 M77199900902700 B 4/02 77,000 75,021 77,818 .9600 9 MONTWOOD HGHTS #2 LOT 29 M77199900902900 B 8/02 73,000 74,110 73,411 1.0100 9 MONTWOOD HGHTS #2 LOT 36 M77199900903600 B 1/03 64,000 62,835 63,960 .9800 11 MONTWOOD HGHTS #2 LOT 17 M77199901101700 B 6/02 71,000 69,069 71,577 .9600 12 MONTWOOD HGHTS #2 LOT 2 M77199901200200 B 3/03 64,900 62,220 64,697 .9600 12 MONTWOOD HGHTS #2 LOT 4 M77199901200400 B 7/02 69,000 67,277 69,474 .9700 14 MONTWOOD HGHTS #4 LOT 10 M77199901401000 B 10/02 52,700 53,345 52,865 1.0100 20 MONTWOOD HGHTS #5 LOT 18 M77199902001800 B 10/02 54,500 61,911 54,670 1.1300 20 MONTWOOD HGHTS #5 LOT 23 M77199902002300 B 9/02 77,200 74,699 77,537 .9600 21 MONTWOOD HGHTS #5 LOT 6 M77199902100600 B 1/03 65,000 71,617 64,959 1.1000 24 MONTWOOD HGHTS #5 LOT 3 M77199902400300 B 12/02 59,999 61,389 60,036 1.0200 5 MOON ADDN #3 LOT 12 M77200300501200 B 3/03 45,000 44,025 44,859 .9800 1 PUEBLO MONTANA UNIT 1 LOT 1 P91599900101100 B 7/02 84,950 83,561 85,534 .9800 6 RANCHOS DEL SOL #4 LOT 38 R24699900603800 B 6/02 175,000 148,242 176,422 .8400 13 SANDY CREEK #1 REPLAT B PR S12799901301900 B 9/02 60,500 56,982 60,765 .9400 15 SANDY CREEK #1 REPLAT B L S12799901500700 B 12/02 75,000 67,188 75,047 .9000 3 SOCORRO TR 4-M-5 S53300000304460 B 10/02 67,899 70,581 68,111 1.0400 1 SUN RIDGE #1 LOT 4 S81299900100400 B 1/03 106,000 106,868 105,934 1.0100 1 SUN RIDGE #1 LOT 21 S81299900102100 B 7/02 155,000 113,545 156,066 .7300 2 SUN RIDGE #1 LOT 5 S81299900200500 B 8/02 145,000 145,230 145,816 1.0000 7 SUN RIDGE #2 LOT 32 S81299900703200 B 11/02 120,000 112,615 120,225 .9400 8 SUN RIDGE #2 LOT 27 S81299900802700 B 12/02 114,000 104,315 114,071 .9100 9 SUN RIDGE #2 LOT 7 S81299900900700 B 11/02 158,000 154,289 158,296 .9700 19 SUN RIDGE #5 LOT 33 S81299901903300 B 12/02 52,200 53,647 52,233 1.0300 20 SUN RIDGE #5 LOT 9 S81299902000900 B 1/03 68,000 62,754 67,958 .9200 20 SUN RIDGE #6 LOT 31 S81299902003100 B 5/02 81,950 73,351 82,718 .8900 26 SUN RIDGE #7 LOT 3 S81299902600300 B 5/02 147,000 142,413 148,378 .9600 27 SUN RIDGE #7 LOT 23 S81299902702300 B 6/02 133,000 130,577 134,081 .9700 28 SUN RIDGE #7 LOT 16 S81299902801600 B 10/02 106,000 101,824 106,331 .9600 29 SUN RIDGE #7 LOT 12 S81299902901200 B 9/02 149,000 144,204 149,652 .9600 32 SUN RIDGE UNIT 8 LOT 3 S81299903200300 B 3/03 112,450 89,422 112,099 .8000 3 VISTA DEL PRADO LOT 13 V88799900302500 B 8/02 75,000 75,766 75,422 1.0000 246-A VISTA DEL SOL #89 LOT 7 V893999246A3650 B 8/02 106,000 108,296 106,596 1.0200 422 VISTA DEL SOL #93 LOT 11 V89399942201100 B 10/02 68,500 65,701 68,714 .9600 497 VISTA DEL SOL #108 LOT 12 V89399949701200 B 6/02 76,400 71,204 77,020 .9200 509 VISTA DEL SOL #119 LOT 28 V89399950902800 B 4/02 65,000 62,515 65,691 .9500 527 VISTA DEL SOL #124 LOT 27 V89399952702700 B 11/02 93,000 88,563 93,174 .9500 546 VISTA DEL SOL #143 LOT 57 V89399954605700 B 1/03 103,000 93,591 102,936 .9100 567 VISTA DEL SOL #149 LOT 17 V89399956701700 B 6/02 89,000 82,850 89,723 .9200 75 VISTA HILLS #23 LOT 42 V89799907504200 B 1/03 70,000 68,172 69,956 .9700 75 VISTA HILLS #23 LOT 48 V89799907504800 B 1/03 78,000 73,949 77,951 .9500
DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 45 TIME: 13:54 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 071 El Paso 071-909 Socorro CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 77 VISTA HILLS #23 LOT 6 V89799907700600 B 11/02 94,500 91,719 94,677 .9700 88 VISTA HILLS #26 LOT 42 V89799908804200 B 11/02 146,150 112,386 146,424 .7700 105 VISTA HILLS#31 LOT 32 V89799910503200 B 6/02 88,000 77,380 88,715 .8700 13 VISTA REAL #1 LOT 50 V92799901305000 B 8/02 78,000 74,392 78,438 .9500 14 VISTA REAL #1 LOT 31 V92799901403100 B 4/02 88,900 80,479 89,845 .9000 25 VISTA REAL #2 LOT 18 V92799902501800 B 4/02 85,000 86,030 85,903 1.0000 31 VISTA REAL #3 LOT 20 V92799903102000 B 9/02 66,500 61,915 66,791 .9300 51 VISTA REAL #4 LOT 56 V92799905105600 B 1/03 75,000 67,743 74,953 .9000 2 VISTA RIDGE #1 LOT 8 V93099900200800 B 1/03 64,000 59,632 63,960 .9300 1 WISEMAN ESTATES LOT 8 W59000000100800 B 3/03 70,000 60,346 69,781 .8600 79 TSP 3 SEC 8 T&P SURV TR 17- X579999308A9585 B 8/02 64,000 46,189 64,360 .7200 105 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9540 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 5-C A,ERICAS TEN REPLAT A PR A523999005C0125 C 4/02 2,000,000 1,913,198 2,000,000 .9600 1 SALES CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ PRT LOT 1 BLK 3 AMERICAS TEN A52399900300150 .00 1.00 .00 4,808,683 4,973,029 .9700 PRT LOT 1 BLK 3 AMERICAS TEN A52399900300600 .00 1.00 .00 4,478,094 4,504,761 .9900 PRT LOT 1 BLK 1 AMERICAS BUS A52799900100170 .00 1.00 .00 2,861,342 2,861,808 1.0000 LOT 1 EL CAMPESTRE UNIT 2 E27500000000100 .00 1.00 .00 390,147 409,951 .9500 LOT 17 BLK 1 GENERAL LEE INDU G22099900101700 .00 1.00 .00 191,041 202,283 .9400
DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 46 TIME: 13:54 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 071 El Paso 071-909 Socorro CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ PRT LOT 13 BLK 2 HUECO VIEW H81799900205950 .00 1.00 .00 269,952 302,641 .8900 PRT LOT 2 BLK 1 LETTY SUB L22999900100250 .00 1.00 .00 379,080 402,264 .9400 LOT 1 BLK 1 VISTA DEL SOL IND V89299900100150 .00 1.00 .00 7,789,383 8,055,482 .9700 PRT LOT 22 BLK 316 VISTA DEL V89399931606000 .00 1.00 .00 2,758,115 2,664,091 1.0400 PRT LOT 1 BLK 352 VISTA DEL S V89399935200300 .00 1.00 .00 4,119,123 4,703,093 .8800 PRT LOT 3 BLK 352 VISTA DEL V89399935200500 .00 1.00 .00 3,595,354 3,919,970 .9200 PRT LOT 1 BLK 355 VISTA DEL S V89399935500150 .00 1.00 .00 1,074,483 1,067,622 1.0100 PRT LOT 1 BLK 370 VISTA DEL V89399937000120 .00 1.00 .00 1,470,602 1,316,574 1.1200 PRT LOT 1 BLK 372 VISTA DEL V89399937200100 .00 1.00 .00 4,785,043 4,834,741 .9900 PRT LOT 1 BLK 379 VISTA DEL S V89399937900200 .00 1.00 .00 3,775,430 3,800,901 .9900 LOT 1 BLK 433 VISTA DEL SOL # V89399943300100 .00 1.00 .00 2,279,353 3,127,705 .7300 PRT LOT 3 BLK 540 VISTA DEL V89399954000310 .00 1.00 .00 4,692,096 4,675,536 1.0000 LOT 3 BLK 548 VISTA DEL SOL V89399954800300 .00 1.00 .00 6,527,665 6,706,058 .9700 LOT 3 BLK 1 VISTA ESTRELLA V89699900100300 .00 1.00 .00 4,573,329 4,528,951 1.0100 LOT 5 BLK 1 VISTA ESTRELLA V89699900100500 .00 1.00 .00 1,011,533 1,165,652 .8700 PRT LOT 35 BLK 54 VISTA HILL V89799905403525 .00 1.00 .00 3,059,177 3,020,919 1.0100 PRT LOT 35 BLK 54 VISTA HILLS V89799905403550 .00 1.00 .00 1,591,783 1,440,659 1.1000 LOT 20 BLK 90 VISTA HILLS #44 V89799909002000 .00 1.00 .00 3,263,010 3,384,473 .9600 LOT 1 BLK 2 WALMART COMMERCI W06699900200100 .00 1.00 .00 11,808,728 12,116,334 .9700 TR 1-A-8-A LEIGH CLARK SURVEY X293000L00A0375 .00 1.00 .00 169,774 175,691 .9700 TRACT 2-K LEIGH CLARK SURVEY 2 X293000L00B0370 .00 1.00 .00 1,699,999 1,744,130 .9700 TRACT 9 LEIGH CLARK SURVEY 29 X29400000000200 .00 1.00 .00 678,203 649,074 1.0400 TR 1-B ETC BLK 79 TSP 2 SEC X57900023500600 .00 1.00 .00 436,847 531,099 .8200 TR 13-A BLK 7 SOCORRO 2533000007013A0 .00 1.00 .00 281,283 283,127 .9900 29 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9635 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ TONY LAMA INC 082099910510050 987,445 986,553 1.0000 AVERY DENNISON 082799914690042 5,142,082 5,144,591 1.0000 QUICKIE MANUFACTURING 082799917300050 1,370,707 1,405,719 .9800 K-MART OF TEXAS LP #3919 082799922090050 2,011,447 2,002,318 1.0000 CONTRACT FREIGHTERS INC 082899916290050 1,183,333 1,055,579 1.1200 WHITE ROGERS DIVISION 199499904500034 6,844,724 6,938,379 .9900 G E CAPITAL 199499911740042 1,508,207 1,726,881 .8700 RADIO SHACK #9213 199699912130050 132,981 131,936 1.0100 HARTEC INC 199699921580050 20,271,790 20,543,400 .9900 FOSTER ELECTRIC AMERICA 199699932860042 8,352,710 8,285,913 1.0100 EPSON 199799901430034 14,689,940 14,735,910 1.0000
DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 47 TIME: 13:54 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 071 El Paso 071-909 Socorro CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ WALGREENS #3826 199799901780050 707,093 541,010 1.3100 PEP BOYS #445 199799906580050 634,295 690,305 .9200 IONTENSIVE HOME CARE SERVICES 199799908080042 1,205,533 905,485 1.3300 SAMMEX INC 199799913200034 73,744,639 73,909,480 1.0000 SETON COMPANY 199899921400034 7,295,061 7,290,642 1.0000 WALMART #2612 199999910430042 8,021,826 8,503,471 .9400 DIAMOND SHAMROCK 199999919450050 370,828 373,215 .9900 HOBBY LOBBY 200099913320050 1,015,986 1,043,988 .9700 ECHOSTAR COMMUNICATIONS 200099917590050 6,294,048 7,872,978 .8000 YAZAKI NORTH AMERICA 200299901000050 31,357,860 31,357,860 1.0000 RUSH TRUCK CENTER OF EL PASO 200299913860050 915,004 891,274 1.0300 MELROSE #85 200299934730050 85,838 84,447 1.0200 ELECTRONIC PRODUCT INTERGRATIO 200399915850050 2,308,053 2,332,846 .9900 24 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0043
