Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   1/22/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:     23
TIME:     13:54                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             071  El Paso
                                                         071-905  Ysleta

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  4 BELLEWOOD REPLAT  LOT 4        B35199900400700            B       1/03         52,000          49,992        51,968     .9600
  4 CAPISTRANO PARK  LOT 2         C11899900400300            B      10/02         58,000          57,000        58,181     .9800
  14 CAPISTRANO PARK  LOT 10       C11899901401900            B      10/02         62,000          58,550        62,193     .9400
  2 CARIBE ESTATES  #2  LOT 7      C13199900200700            B       1/03         60,000          57,908        59,963     .9700
  CINECUE PARK  PRT TR 52          C57299900100630            B       9/02         52,750          44,000        52,981     .8300
  4 COLONIA DEL PRADO  LOT 26      C72999900405100            B       9/02         58,000          56,323        58,253     .9700
  7 COLONIA DEL PRADO #2  LOT 13   C72999900702500            B       1/03         54,000          53,685        53,966     .9900
  10 COLONIA DEL PRADO  LOT 38     C72999901007500            B       4/02         49,000          68,485        49,521    1.3800
  15 COLONIA DEL VALLE  LOT 4      C73299901500700            B      12/02         65,000          51,014        65,041     .7800
  23 COLONIA DEL VALLE #3  LOT 1   C73299902302700            B       9/02         55,000          53,262        55,241     .9600
  3 COLONIA MARGARITA  LOT 13      C73499900302500            B      11/02         59,000          54,016        59,111     .9100
  9 DALE BELLAMAH  LOT 25          D04799900904900            B       2/03         77,000          73,041        76,856     .9500
  10 DALE BELLAMAH  LOT 24         D04799901009400            B       8/02         69,900          67,869        70,293     .9700
  14 DOLPHIN TERRACE  #3  LOT 6    D67299901402100            B       1/03         52,000          63,957        51,968    1.2300
  12 EAST GLEN PRT LOT 2           E05499901200690            B       2/03         85,000          92,697        84,841    1.0900
  35 EAST GLEN #3  LOT 26          E05499903605100            B       2/03         79,500          68,765        79,351     .8700
  43 EAST GLEN #3  LOT 19          E05499904303700            B       8/02         92,770          86,301        93,292     .9300
  52 EAST GLEN PRT LOT 1           E05499905200100            B      11/02        515,000         514,330       515,966    1.0000
  59 EAST GLEN  LOT 1              E05499905900100            B       4/02         70,000          63,859        70,743     .9000
  59 EAST GLEN  LOT 24             E05499905904700            B       3/03         53,000          61,138        52,834    1.1600
  A EASTRIDGE  LOT 3               E073999000A1500            B      12/02        149,000         115,441       149,093     .7700
  FF EASTRIDGE  LOT 34             E0789990FF06700            B      12/02        120,000         117,490       120,075     .9800
  10 EASTWOOD  LOT 7               E20799901001900            B       4/02         68,200          57,032        68,925     .8300
  14 EASTWOOD  LOT 5               E20799901402100            B      11/02         72,950          55,911        73,087     .7600
  142 EASTWOOD HGHTS  LOT 20       E22299914205800            B       9/02         86,500          74,080        86,878     .8500
  163 EASTWOOD HGHTS   LOT 23      E22299916306400            B      12/02         69,705          78,532        69,749    1.1300
  164 EASTWOOD HGHTS  REPLAT  LO   E22299916400400            B       7/02         95,000          93,768        95,653     .9800
  174 EASTWODD  HGHTS #C  LOT 31   E22299917406300            B      11/02        104,000          99,214       104,195     .9500
  3 EL DORADO  REPLAT B PRT LOT    E29999900302950            B       4/02         77,500          74,678        78,323     .9500
  2 EL SOL LINDO  LOT 12           E39099900202300            B       8/02         54,000          54,000        54,303     .9900
  2 EL SOL LINDO  LOT 18           E39099900203500            B       9/02         67,000          70,000        67,293    1.0400
  7 EL SOL LINDO  LOT 15           E39099900702900            B       4/02         61,000          60,817        61,648     .9900
  36 HACIENDA HGHTS  LOT 2         H01299903600500            B       1/03         67,500          59,579        67,458     .8800
  8 INDIAN RIDGE LOT 27            I25699900805300            B       9/02         65,000          72,914        65,284    1.1200
  15 INDIAN RIDGE #2  LOT 7        I25699901501300            B       9/02         79,500          78,993        79,848     .9900
  16 INDIAN RIDGE  #2  LOT 1       I25699901600100            B       8/02        109,000         101,320       109,613     .9200
  2 IVANHOE PRT LOT 11             I90099900204300            B       8/02         51,250          62,189        51,538    1.2100
  2 LA PALOMA PARK  LOT 17         L06499900204900            B       8/02         68,000          55,998        68,383     .8200
  1 LAMPLITER PARK  LOT 4          L19699900100700            B       3/03         84,500          84,225        84,236    1.0000
  9 LANCASTER  #3  PRT LOT 23      L20499900904500            B      10/02         54,950          60,000        55,122    1.0900
  11 LANCASTER   #3  LOT 16        L20499901103100            B      11/02         60,500          60,000        60,613     .9900
  7-E LE BARRON PARK  REPLAT C     L217999007E0500            B       4/02         66,500          54,274        67,207     .8100
  1 LIDO SQUARE  LOT 12            L26099900102300            B      10/02         49,999          48,649        50,155     .9700
  LOMA TERRACE #4-C  TR 541        L536999001B6300            B       1/03         52,000          55,384        51,968    1.0700
  LOMA VALE  TR 11                 L58499900107100            B       7/02         58,000          60,000        58,398    1.0300
  14 MARIAN MANOR  LOT 9           M05999901405000            B       7/02         71,500          69,379        71,992     .9600
  14 MARIAN MANOR  LOT 9           M09599901405000            B       7/02         71,500          69,379        71,992     .9600

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 24 TIME: 13:54 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 071 El Paso 071-905 Ysleta CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 7 MILLERS LAKESIDE LOT 6-A M45299900703700 B 11/02 45,500 60,093 45,585 1.3200 2 MOUNTAINAIRE #2 LOT 27 M88999900205300 B 3/03 64,950 64,561 64,747 1.0000 8 NEWPORT LOT 34 N22999900803400 B 4/02 83,000 70,662 83,882 .8400 13 NEWPORT ESTATES #3 LOT 3 N24199901300300 B 9/02 99,000 101,380 99,433 1.0200 6 NORTHTOWNE VILLAGE #2 LOT 6 N40999900606100 B 4/02 76,900 75,696 77,717 .9700 6 NORWTOWNE VILLAGE #2 LOT 39 N49099900603900 B 5/02 61,500 53,223 62,077 .8600 5 OASIS RANCH O10199900501800 B 12/02 38,500 44,900 38,524 1.1700 4 PAINTED DUNES LOT 1 P08099900400100 B 10/02 64,000 74,129 64,200 1.1500 2 PALM GROVE LOT 1 P13399900200100 B 1/03 88,950 87,443 88,894 .9800 5 PARK EAST LOT 15 P29999900502900 B 10/02 96,000 93,504 96,300 .9700 12 PARKWOOD LOT 9 P48199901201700 B 5/02 49,000 68,030 49,459 1.3800 30 PARKWOOD LOT 5 P48199903000900 B 10/02 75,000 74,217 75,234 .9900 34 PARKWOOD LOT 18 P48199903403500 B 3/03 94,870 82,181 94,574 .8700 23 PEBBLE HILLS LOT 10 P65499902301900 B 5/02 105,900 98,191 106,893 .9200 24 PEBBLE HILLS LOT 8 P65499902401500 B 11/02 117,000 88,110 117,219 .7500 52 PEBBLE HILLS REPLAT 15-A P65499905202815 B 9/02 72,525 67,699 72,842 .9300 73 PEBBLE HILLS #8 LOT 19 P65499907303700 B 9/02 74,000 67,893 74,323 .9100 94 PEBBLE HILLS #10 LOT 1 P65499909400100 B 4/02 74,500 71,128 75,292 .9400 105 PEBBLE HILLS #2 LOT 5 P65499910500900 B 3/03 82,200 79,547 81,943 .9700 17 PECAN GROVE #2 REPLAT B L P65699901700900 B 12/02 64,500 54,078 64,540 .8400 20 PECAN GROVE #2 REPLAT B L P65699902001300 B 12/02 64,011 60,608 64,051 .9500 PENDALE TR 25 P67199900105200 B 3/03 73,400 83,428 73,171 1.1400 7 PENROSE LOT 21 P68299900704100 B 6/02 54,000 51,270 54,438 .9400 7 PENROSE LOT 25 P68299900704900 B 5/02 43,000 53,756 43,403 1.2400 1 PRADO LINDO LOT 35 P88099900103500 B 5/02 57,600 53,233 58,140 .9200 6 PRADO LINDO REPLAT A PRT LO P88099900601750 B 3/03 56,900 53,457 56,722 .9400 QUADRI COURT LOT 2 Q50899900000300 B 1/03 49,900 47,000 49,869 .9400 RANCHLAND HILLS #3 LOT 30 R210999001A5900 B 1/03 66,000 65,099 65,958 .9900 ROSEWAY PLACE TR 18 R87199900106900 B 5/02 55,900 60,000 56,424 1.0600 9 SCOTADALE #2 LOT 8 S23199900902900 B 8/02 112,500 91,942 113,133 .8100 10 SCOTSDALE #2 LOT 14 S23199901006600 B 9/02 70,000 70,358 70,306 1.0000 27 SCOTSDALE #3 LOT 14 S23799902707900 B 11/02 69,000 61,661 69,129 .8900 28 SCOTSDALE #3 LOT 11 S23799902808100 B 7/02 73,771 60,225 74,278 .8100 34 SCOTSDALE #3 LOT 13 S23799903409700 B 12/02 85,000 64,057 85,053 .7500 49 SCOTSDALE #4 PRT LOT 9 S24399904901700 B 5/02 78,000 70,078 78,731 .8900 7 SHERMAN LOT 16 S36399900703100 B 10/02 59,000 59,705 59,184 1.0100 9 SHERMAN #3 LOT 36 S36399900907100 B 11/02 46,000 47,978 46,086 1.0400 SINGH LOT 74 S44599900107400 B 3/03 64,000 60,000 63,800 .9400 SINGH #3 LOT 224 S455999001B4900 B 8/02 45,000 44,320 45,253 .9800 7 STILES GARDENS LOTS 22-23 S65899900703000 B 11/02 170,000 155,401 170,319 .9100 1 STONEBRIDGE ADDN LOT 4 S67099900100040 B 10/02 64,000 56,335 64,200 .8800 6 STONERIDGE ADDN LOT 11 S67099900600110 B 10/02 64,000 49,743 64,200 .7700 G THOMAS MANOR LOT 21 T240999000G4100 B 2/03 59,000 49,665 58,889 .8400 27 THOMAS MANOR LOT 31 T24099902706100 B 3/03 71,500 51,277 71,277 .7200 2 VISTA DEL SOL LOT 20 V89399900203900 B 8/02 93,400 89,413 93,925 .9500 16 VISTA DEL SOL LOT 22 V89399901604300 B 9/02 135,000 121,088 135,591 .8900 77 VISTA DEL SOL LOT 13 V89399907702500 B 10/02 167,700 158,282 168,224 .9400

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 25 TIME: 13:54 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 071 El Paso 071-905 Ysleta CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 79 VISTA DEL SOL LOT 5 V89399907900900 B 9/02 180,000 161,887 180,787 .9000 93 VISTA DEL SOL LOT 6 V89399909301100 B 5/02 83,000 80,379 83,778 .9600 94 VISTA DEL SOL LOT 2 V89399909400300 B 6/02 80,900 78,300 81,557 .9600 98 VISTA DEL SOL LOT 5 V89399909800900 B 9/02 77,000 74,968 77,337 .9700 107 VISTA DEL SOL LOT 12 V89399910702300 B 9/02 70,000 71,250 70,306 1.0100 120 VISTA DEL SOL #23 LOT 4 V89399912000700 B 6/02 65,300 67,566 65,831 1.0300 152 VISTA DEL SOL LOT 4 V89399915200700 B 3/03 128,000 125,496 127,600 .9800 173 VISTA DEL SOL #29 LOT 7 V89399917301300 B 4/02 102,000 95,688 103,084 .9300 185 VISTA DEL SOL #32 LOT 10 V89399918506700 B 5/02 76,000 70,029 76,713 .9100 189 VISTA DEL SOL #32 LOT 17 V89399918903300 B 5/02 89,000 88,983 89,834 .9900 190 VISTA DEL SOL #32 LOT 2 V89399919000300 B 9/02 115,000 107,176 115,503 .9300 197 VISTA DEL SOL #34 LOT 5 V89399919700900 B 6/02 104,700 89,730 105,551 .8500 198 VISTA DEL SOL LOT 27 V89399919805300 B 1/03 134,000 108,732 133,916 .8100 206 VISTA DEL SOL #38 LOT 15 V89399920602900 B 11/02 110,000 95,230 110,206 .8600 223 VISTA DEL SOL #42 REPLAT V89399922300900 B 10/02 98,000 87,984 98,306 .9000 109 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9497 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 3 COLONIA LOS CUATRO UNIT A C73999900301500 B 11/02 52,500 50,687 52,500 .9700 2 EAST GLEN PRT LOT 1 E05499900200238 C 12/02 79,000 75,852 79,000 .9600 12 EAST GLEN PRT LOT 2 E05499901200650 C 8/02 78,500 76,080 78,500 .9700 102 EASTWOOD HGHTS PRT LOT 4 E22299910200900 C 12/02 65,900 63,200 65,900 .9600 102 EASTWOOD HGHTS PRT LOT 7 E22299910201300 C 7/02 55,000 53,931 55,000 .9800 2 EL DORADO PRT LOT 12 E29999900202400 C 9/02 49,950 47,289 49,950 .9500 4 EL DORADO PRT LOT 21 E29999900404100 C 9/02 46,500 45,138 46,500 .9700 4 EL DORADO PRT LOT 21 E29999900404200 C 11/02 46,500 45,138 46,500 .9700 6 NORTH LOOP GARDENS #1 LOTS N44299900601700 C 5/02 799,750 826,845 799,750 1.0300 25 PEBBLE HILLS PRT LOT 1 P65499902500600 C 6/02 58,000 52,372 58,000 .9000 25 PEBBLE HILLS PRT LOT 2 P65499902501400 C 7/02 52,000 50,789 52,000 .9800 49 PEBBLE HILLS PRT LOT 8 P65499904901500 C 10/02 47,972 50,204 47,972 1.0500 49 PEBBLE HILLS PRT LOT 8 P65499904901600 C 10/02 47,972 47,188 47,972 .9800 132 PEBBLE HILLS LOT 11 P65499913202100 C 5/02 95,000 89,350 95,000 .9400 133 PEBBLE HILLS PRT LOT 11 P65499913302100 C 8/02 58,500 55,167 58,500 .9400 VALLEY GATE PRT TRACT 64 V150999000C5700 C 5/02 70,000 67,687 70,000 .9700 32-A VISTA DEL SOL #6 REPLAT V893999032A0700 C 10/02 79,000 71,104 79,000 .9000 47 VISTA DEL SOL LOT 5 V89399904700900 B 3/03 144,000 142,358 144,000 .9900 113 VISTA DEL SOL #18 LOT 19 V89399911304900 C 10/02 159,000 151,789 159,000 .9500 116 VISTA DEL SOL #35 PRT LOT V89399911609400 C 10/02 65,500 59,149 65,500 .9000

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 26 TIME: 13:54 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 071 El Paso 071-905 Ysleta CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 234 VISTA DEL SOL #42 LOT 49 V89399923409300 C 8/02 127,500 113,104 127,500 .8900 259 VISTA DEL SOL #45 LOT 6 V89399925901600 C 4/02 165,704 145,095 165,704 .8800 261-A VISTA DEL SOL #50 PRT L V893999261A1200 C 10/02 65,000 63,178 65,000 .9700 261-A VISTA DEL SOL #50 REPL V893999261A1300 C 10/02 65,000 71,004 65,000 1.0900 19 VISTA GRANADA #2 REPLAT A V89499901901100 C 5/02 48,000 49,391 48,000 1.0300 19 VISTA GRANADA #2 REPLAT A V89499901901550 W 7/02 47,250 49,055 47,250 1.0400 19 VISTA GRANADA #2 REPLAT A V89499901901850 C 12/02 48,250 49,183 48,250 1.0200 19 VISTA GRANADA #2 REPLAT A V89499901901900 C 9/02 48,250 48,753 48,250 1.0100 28 SALES CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD APPR TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER MOD OBS VALUE APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 1 ANISE PRT LOT 5 A52999900100500 1.00 .00 49,953 54,736 .9100 1 ASCARATE TR 1-A-25 ETC A765999001A0359 1.00 .00 4,654,035 4,876,600 .9500 5 ASCARATE TR 1-C-18-C ETC A765999005C0142 1.00 .00 831,305 886,957 .9400 3 CIELO VISTA PARK EAST #2 LO C52299900301000 1.00 .00 3,684,356 3,611,209 1.0200 5 CIELO VISTA PARK EAST LOT 1 C52299900500100 1.00 .00 4,916,816 4,810,993 1.0200 23 COLONIA DEL VALLE #3 LOT 1 C73299902303500 1.00 .00 610,362 654,545 .9300 CORONADE PLACE PRT 13 C83599900106500 1.00 .00 270,275 266,688 1.0100 DORBANDT PRT LOTS 12-13 D76199900105100 1.00 .00 154,208 153,340 1.0100 53 EAST GLEN PRT LOT 1 E05499905300500 1.00 .00 4,554,831 4,651,200 .9800 103 EASTWOOD HGHTS PRT LOT 15 E22299910302800 1.00 .00 57,792 72,945 .7900 1 EL DORADO PRT LOT 21 E29999900104100 1.00 .00 45,294 49,069 .9200 4 EL DORADO PRT LOT 20 E29999900404000 1.00 .00 43,844 47,520 .9200 7 EL DORADO PRT LOT 12 E29999900702300 1.00 .00 43,321 48,285 .9000 5 NORTH LOOP GARDENS #1 LOT 5 N44299900501300 1.00 .00 156,943 158,269 .9900 4 OASIS RANCH LOT 23 O10199900402300 1.00 .00 50,640 54,720 .9300 1 PEBBLE HILLS #7 PRT LOT 20 P65499900104700 1.00 .00 110,560 112,944 .9800 11 PEBBLE HILLS LOT 21 P65499901104100 1.00 .00 52,807 54,000 .9800 29 PEBBLE HILLS #3 PRT LOT 20 P65499902903900 1.00 .00 2,119,431 2,023,810 1.0500 46 PEBBLE HILLS REPLAT A PRT P65499904603500 1.00 .00 86,117 82,656 1.0400 78 PEBBLE HILLS REPLAT PRT LO P65499907800500 1.00 .00 90,209 110,838 .8100 9 PECAN GROVE #2 LOT 3 & PRT L P65699900905000 1.00 .00 1,683,102 1,720,695 .9800 10 PECAN GROVE POT 4 & PRT LOT P65699901004500 1.00 .00 2,331,155 2,408,354 .9700 1 RANCHLAND COMMERCIAL DIST #3 R18399900100900 1.00 .00 1,403,701 1,552,174 .9000 2 RANCHO ALEGRE PRT LOT 1 R22899900200100 1.00 .00 488,499 588,600 .8300 ROSEDALE FARMS #2 TRS 31-32 R745999001C1900 1.00 .00 78,031 79,695 .9800 SOUTH PARKLAND PRT TRS 248-250 S54699924900100 1.00 .00 715,310 771,136 .9300 3 SUMMER FIELD PRT LOT 9 S77599900300950 1.00 .00 49,630 49,860 1.0000 1 VALLE VERDE HGHTS LOT 1 V12899900100100 1.00 .00 7,775,519 7,742,674 1.0000 3 VISTA DEL SOL #3 LOT 23 ET V89399900303500 1.00 .00 5,154,491 4,968,164 1.0400 14 VISTA DEL SOL 12 ACS OF LOT V89399901409900 1.00 .00 6,215,678 6,300,604 .9900

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 27 TIME: 13:54 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 071 El Paso 071-905 Ysleta CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD APPR TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER MOD OBS VALUE APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 46 VISTA DEL SOL #4 LOTS 1-12 V89399904600100 1.00 .00 1,260,000 1,358,893 .9300 113 VISTA DEL SOL #18 LOT 20 V89399911305100 1.00 .00 41,695 39,200 1.0600 116 VISTA DEL SOL #35 LOT 17 V89399911603300 1.00 .00 98,213 99,099 .9900 142 VISTA DEL SOL #26 LOT 2 V89399914201000 1.00 .00 4,459,391 4,539,800 .9800 155 VISTA DEL SOL #30 PRT LOT V89399915505035 1.00 .00 47,302 47,655 .9900 178 VISTA DEL SOL #32 LOT 1 V89399917800100 1.00 .00 5,563,822 4,711,429 1.1800 261-A VISTA DEL SOL #50 REPLA V893999261A2100 1.00 .00 57,968 57,240 1.0100 22-A VISTA GRANADA #2 REPLAT A V894999022A1200 1.00 .00 146,219 148,410 .9900 80 TSP SEC 39 T&P SURVEY TR 3- X580999239B0301 1.00 .00 1,437,510 1,607,875 .8900 33 YSLETA TR 7-B ETC Y80599903300702 1.00 .00 1,481,196 1,486,080 1.0000 40 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9746 CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 128 VISTA DEL SOL#22 PRT LOT V89399912804000 C 6/02 505,000 357,784 505,000 .7100 346 VISTA DEL SOL #80 LOT 3 V89399934500300 C 4/02 475,000 470,262 475,000 .9900 28 YSLETA TR 10-E Y80599902801040 C 2/03 205,000 204,619 205,000 1.0000 3 SALES CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ TRACT 1-A-21-E-C-4 ETC BLK 1 A765999001A0344 .00 1.00 .00 482,306 590,997 .8200 LOT 5 BLK 1 COPPERFIELD INDU C76399900100500 .00 1.00 .00 1,885,948 2,682,656 .7000 IMPS ONLY PRT OF BLK 2 EASTW E20799900209500 .00 1.00 .00 2,240,000 2,354,000 .9500 PRT LOT 16 BLK 1 HIDDEN VALL H41399900103100 .00 1.00 .00 1,361,446 1,375,854 .9900 LOT 1 BLK 9 INTERSTATE 10 IN I00399900900100 .00 1.00 .00 7,580,728 7,548,335 1.0000 LOT 2 BLK 4 KESSLER INDUSTRIA K28399900400210 .00 1.00 .00 3,343,133 3,205,977 1.0400 LOT 1 BLK 13 NEWPORT ESTATES N24199901300150 .00 1.00 .00 5,687,085 5,829,468 .9800

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 28 TIME: 13:54 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 071 El Paso 071-905 Ysleta CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ PRT LOT 18 BLK 30 PEBLE HILL P65499903003500 .00 1.00 .00 3,672,549 4,150,974 .8800 LOT 17 BLK 16 SCOTSDALE #2 R S23199901609100 .00 1.00 .00 244,949 211,408 1.1600 LOT 1 BLK 1 TEXAS CANCER CEN T19499900100100 .00 1.00 .00 6,354,092 6,327,905 1.0000 LOT 2 BLK 1 THE VILLAGE T22399900100200 .00 1.00 .00 1,375,000 1,409,609 .9800 PRT LOT 4 BLK 5 VALLEY CREST V13999900500425 .00 1.00 .00 242,508 257,845 .9400 PRT LOT 2 BLK 11 VISTA DEL S V89399901101000 .00 1.00 .00 1,933,270 1,974,449 .9800 LOT 4 BLK 13 VISTA DEL SOL V89399901303000 .00 1.00 .00 1,730,189 1,786,334 .9700 TRACT 2-B ETC BLK 14 VISTA V89399901403050 .00 1.00 .00 1,047,288 989,143 1.0600 LOTS 3-9 BLK 113 VISTA DEL V89399911301800 .00 1.00 .00 2,105,968 2,178,689 .9700 PRT LOT 12-14 BLK 113 VISTA D V89399911303600 .00 1.00 .00 828,436 821,937 1.0100 PRT LOTS 3-4 BLK 129 VISTA V89399912903000 .00 1.00 .00 1,888,875 1,951,150 .9700 PRT LOT 1 BLK 142 VISTA DEL V89399914200100 .00 1.00 .00 5,040,000 5,723,090 .8800 PRT LOT 4 BLK 160 VISTA DEL S V89399916001500 .00 1.00 .00 161,226 178,234 .9000 PRT LOT 17 BLK 193 VISTA DE V89399919303650 .00 1.00 .00 554,995 550,825 1.0100 LOTS 16-19 BLK 265 VISTA DE V89399926503700 .00 1.00 .00 1,341,000 1,211,191 1.1100 LOT 1 BLK 345 VISTA DEL SOL V89399934500100 .00 1.00 .00 4,432,301 4,827,011 .9200 LOT 16-27 BLK 3 WFF INDUSTRI W22099900301605 .00 1.00 .00 4,698,948 4,161,992 1.1300 TR 1-C-2 ETC BLK 80 TSP 2 X58099923800650 .00 1.00 .00 2,750,000 2,782,693 .9900 TRACT 7-A ETC BLK 5 YSLETA Y80599900500701 .00 1.00 .00 850,967 904,287 .9400 TRACT 8-F BLK 33 YSLETA Y80599903300833 .00 1.00 .00 629,951 586,877 1.0700 TRACT 16-C BLK 38 YSLETA Y80599903801631 .00 1.00 .00 153,139 143,656 1.0700 TRACT 7-A BLK 44 YSELTA Y80599904400701 .00 1.00 .00 217,628 251,353 .8700 TRACTS 11-A ETC BLK 1 YUCC Y906999000A0100 .00 1.00 .00 1,583,309 1,572,323 1.0100 30 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9594 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ GEORGIA-PACIFIC CORP 000199950000000 645,095 646,574 1.0000 CSK AUTO INC 008399990020000 468,325 473,346 .9900 FEATHERLITE BLOCK CORP 028399980880000 4,081,830 4,231,306 .9600 LA QUINTA INN #452 081699928890042 519,847 474,708 1.1000 MERVYN'S #80 081899908640042 1,788,840 1,642,703 1.0900 ONTARIO DIE CO OF TEXAS 081899914670042 1,876,161 1,927,591 .9700 BENNIGANS TAVERN 081999903890042 106,956 136,892 .7800 BIG SUR WATERBEDS INC 081999911900034 709,066 705,242 1.0100 WAL-MART STORES EAST #512 082199900880042 5,660,131 5,736,318 .9900 SAM'S EAST INC 082399901490042 7,109,200 7,249,124 .9800 JUSTIN BOOTS 082399909700042 1,377,471 1,377,032 1.0000 WAQL-MART STORES EAST #964 082399910000042 8,371,620 8,449,359 .9900

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 29 TIME: 13:54 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 071 El Paso 071-905 Ysleta CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ TOY R US 082499901950042 1,475,133 1,522,139 .9700 GTE MOBILNET OF SOUTH TEXAS 082699926460042 10,081,592 9,842,487 1.0200 WHATABURGER OF EL PASO #565 082899909650042 74,219 73,301 1.0100 BURLINGTON COAT FACTORY 082899925130042 3,183,797 3,281,098 .9700 ALBERTSON'S #934 199399904900042 1,743,773 1,766,378 .9900 HOME DEPOT 199599922800042 5,625,375 5,659,752 .9900 OFFICE FURNITURE LIQUIDATORS 199699910280042 42,308 46,077 .9200 FURNITURE FACTORY WAREHOUSE 199699911110042 308,783 309,015 1.0000 DURLAND-LARSON SALES 199799907920042 2,173,313 2,176,131 1.0000 ROAD MACHINERY CO 199799911320042 2,555,006 2,622,557 .9700 SEARS ROEBUCK 199899918680042 317,829 297,206 1.0700 T-MOBILE 199899920990042 278,178 250,000 1.1100 REEBOK INTERNATIONAL 199928100034 53,150 66,330 .8000 OFFICE DEPOT OF TEXAS LP 199999900960042 1,144,968 1,299,076 .8800 RENTWAY OF TTIG 199999909780042 312,448 320,039 .9800 HARBOR FREIGHT TOOLS #55 199999916150042 423,591 427,057 .9900 DAVID BRIDAL OUTLET #902 199999926390042 220,112 235,899 .9300 LEXMARK INTERNATIONAL INC 199999926510042 1,108,472 1,374,318 .8100 GENERAL NUTRITION CENTER 200099900490042 66,625 74,592 .8900 CMV INDUSTRIES 200099900980042 38,278 54,598 .7000 GENBERAL ELECTRIC INC 200199948260042 5,437,177 5,437,277 1.0000 VERIZON WIRELESS DALLAS 200199950110042 307,402 340,538 .9000 CROWN CASTLE GT COMPANY 200199951090042 83,248 89,250 .9300 LOWE'S HOME CENTERS INC 200299904690042 6,996,159 7,001,317 1.0000 PROVIDIAN 200299914050042 10,125,195 10,053,807 1.0100 UNITED EQUIPMENT RENTALS GULF 200399933330042 4,856,498 4,867,132 1.0000 38 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9679