Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   1/22/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:      7
TIME:     13:54                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             071  El Paso
                                                         071-902  El Paso

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  2 ALTA MIRA  LOT 16              A49099900203100            B       4/02         49,000          50,441        49,521    1.0200
  21 APOLLO HGHTS  LOT 6           A64299902101100            B       6/02         85,500          79,943        86,195     .9300
  28 APOLLO HGHTS  LOT 78          A642999028C1500            B       1/03         54,500          69,780        54,466    1.2800
  6 ARLINGTON HGHTS REPLAT  LOT    A70099900600100            B       5/02         78,900          76,633        79,640     .9600
  1 CARVEL ACRES  LOT 6            C16799900102500            B       8/02        125,000         124,832       125,703     .9900
  2 CASITAS CORONADO  LOT 141      C21499900209942            B       6/02        152,500         152,673       153,739     .9900
  1 CASTNER HGHTS #1  LOT 5        C23199900100900            B       5/02        110,000         104,225       111,031     .9400
  24-A CASTNER HGHTS #4  LOT 7     C231999024A0700            B       8/02         80,950          78,592        81,405     .9700
  8 CHAPARRAL PARK  LOT 5          C34099900800900            B       9/02         97,000          95,655        97,424     .9800
  8 CHAPARRAL PARK LOT 43          C34099900808500            B       2/03        109,900          96,130       109,694     .8800
  18 CHAPARRAL PARK  LOT 19        C34099901803700            B      10/02        149,950         143,860       150,419     .9600
  24 CHAPARRAL PARK  LOT 7         C34099902401300            B       5/02        162,500         148,918       164,023     .9100
  27 CHAPARRAL PARK  LOT 52        C34099902706800            B       5/02        134,500         134,586       135,761     .9900
  41 CHAPARRAL PARK #13  LOT 10    C34099904101900            B      11/02        107,000          97,887       107,201     .9100
  51 CHAPARRAL PARK  LOT 20        C34099905103900            B       2/03         85,000          82,350        84,841     .9700
  83 CHAPARRAL PARK #19  LOT 29    C34099908305700            B       8/02        135,000         127,881       135,759     .9400
  84 CHAPARRAL PARK #19  LOT 23    C34099908404500            B       7/02         94,000          83,632        94,646     .8800
  93 CHAPARRAL PARK  LOT 16        C34099909303100            B       8/02        138,000         131,564       138,776     .9500
  105 CHAPARRAL PARK #21  LOT 20   C34099910503900            B       5/02         86,000          87,231        86,806    1.0000
  107 CHAPARRAL PARK  LOT 14       C34099910702700            B       1/03        119,000         107,410       118,926     .9000
  117 CHAPARRAL PARK #24  LOT 15   C34099911702900            B      11/02         86,200          79,853        86,362     .9200
  123 CHAPARRAL PARK #28  LOT 1    C34099912300100            B       5/02        132,000         129,096       133,237     .9700
  130 CHAPARRAL PARK #28  PRT LO   C34099913000300            B       4/02        115,900         104,626       117,131     .8900
  132 CHAPARRAL PARK #29  REPLAT   C34099913202000            B       7/02         94,950          94,008        95,603     .9800
  138 CHAPARRAL PARK #30  LOT 9    C34099913800900            B       8/02        142,900         142,736       143,704     .9900
  143 CHAPARRAL PARK #32  LOT 21   C34099914302100            B      11/02        232,500         221,579       232,936     .9500
  143 CHAPARRAL PARK #32  LOT 24   C34099914302400            B       5/02        152,900         142,567       154,333     .9200
  147 CHAPARRAL PARK #36  LOT 29   C34099914702900            B       4/02        165,000         162,511       166,753     .9700
  149 CHAPARRAL PARK #34  LOT 2    C34099914900200            B       6/02        183,500         176,643       184,991     .9500
  3 CLOVERDALE  LOT 17             C67599900308100            B       1/03        136,000         136,631       135,915    1.0100
  2 COLONIA MIRAMONTE #1 LOT 8     C73699900201500            B       6/02        119,870         113,271       120,844     .9400
  16 COLONIA VERDE LOT 19          C74199901603700            B      12/02         52,000          53,105        52,033    1.0200
  6 COOPERSTOWN  LOT 3             C76299900600300            B       4/02         63,000          60,696        63,669     .9500
  6 COOPERSTOWN  LOT 5             C76299900600500            B       4/02         69,000          70,170        69,733    1.0100
  12 COOPERSTOWN  LOT 16           C76299901201600            B       7/02         63,900          62,992        64,339     .9800
  12 COOPERSTOWN  LOT 28           C76299901202800            B       8/02         61,000          61,467        61,343    1.0000
  16 COOPERSTOWN  LOT 8            C76299901600800            B       2/03         66,950          59,751        66,824     .8900
  18 COOPERSTOWN #2  LOT 16        C76299901801600            B      11/02         70,100          68,855        70,231     .9800
  8 CORONADO COUNTRY CLUB ESTATE   C80199900808890            B       7/02        230,000         227,701       231,581     .9800
  20 CORONADO COUNTRY CLUB ESTAT   C80199902004100            B       9/02        153,000         152,757       153,669     .9900
  5 CORONADO OAKS #2  LOT 21       C83499900502100            B       9/02        210,500         195,480       211,421     .9200
  11 CORONADO TERRACE  LOT 2       C84099901100400            B       8/02         79,900          77,281        80,349     .9600
  29 CORONADO TERRACE #4  LOT 1    C84099902900100            B       2/03         75,000          70,049        74,859     .9400
  33 CORONADO TERRACE LOT 21       C84099903304100            B       7/02         87,000          79,494        87,598     .9100
  1 COSTA DE ORO  LOT 2            C84699900100500            B       8/02        165,000         138,505       165,928     .8300
  1 COSTA DE ORO  LOT 15           C84699900107000            B       4/02        167,000         157,308       168,774     .9300
  3 FAIRBANKS HGHTS  LOT 22        F16799900302200            B       6/02         95,250          88,189        96,024     .9200

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 8 TIME: 13:54 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 071 El Paso 071-902 El Paso CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 1 FALCON HILLS #2 LOT 17 F16999900101700 B 9/02 151,000 148,288 151,661 .9800 3 FALCON HILLS #3 LOT 28 F16999900302800 B 4/02 144,500 145,051 146,035 .9900 9 FIESTA HILLS REPLAT LOT 2 F31599900900400 B 6/02 73,000 67,687 73,593 .9200 93 FRANKLIN HGHTS LOTS 8-9 F60799909302500 B 9/02 60,000 56,405 60,263 .9400 3 GREENWAY PARK LOT 12 G77099900302300 B 9/02 115,900 110,864 116,407 .9500 5 GREENWAY PARK LOT 10 G77099900501900 B 1/03 248,000 247,370 247,845 1.0000 142 HIGHLAND PARK LOTS 25-27 H45399914207300 B 8/02 59,500 55,548 59,835 .9300 1 HIGHLAND NORTH #2 LOT 26 H45499900102600 B 2/03 165,000 149,902 164,691 .9100 54 KERN PLACE LOT 18 K21699905404100 B 7/02 63,500 61,562 63,937 .9600 10 MANHATTAN HGHTS LOTS 45-48 M05699901008600 B 12/02 148,500 148,500 148,593 1.0000 6 MARWOOD LOT 11 M13099900602100 B 4/02 68,000 56,710 68,723 .8300 MARWOOD #1 REPLAT LOT 31 M14199900003100 B 12/02 67,000 64,969 67,042 .9700 1 MCRUTH LOT 7 M29999900101300 B 7/02 76,000 70,654 76,523 .9200 8 MESA DEL CASTILLO #4 LOT 17 M32799900801700 B 6/02 120,000 116,009 120,975 .9600 14 MESA DEL CASTILLO #4 LOT 4 M32799901400400 B 12/02 102,000 102,782 102,064 1.0100 16 MESA HILLS #4 LOT 11 M34499901601100 B 11/02 143,000 143,754 143,268 1.0000 16 MESA HILLS #4 LOT 53 M34499901605300 B 4/02 183,500 163,671 185,450 .8800 27 MESA HILLS #11 LOT 10 M34499902701000 B 2/03 248,000 239,133 247,535 .9700 14 MILAGRO HILLS LOT 22 M42599901408500 B 10/02 73,000 69,134 73,228 .9400 39 MILAGRO HILLS LOT 41 M42599903908100 B 4/02 70,000 68,805 70,743 .9700 27 MISSION HILLS LOT 20 M57699902705800 B 4/02 79,500 81,983 80,345 1.0200 MONTE VISTA #3 REPLAT TR 9 M71899900004100 B 6/02 102,000 78,307 102,829 .7600 2 MORNING STAR ESTATES #1 LOT M79199900200900 B 11/02 375,000 373,067 375,703 .9900 34 MORNINGSIDE HGHTS LOTS 13- M79499903403700 B 9/02 56,000 50,786 56,245 .9000 MOUNTAIN BROOK VILLAS #L M800999000D2300 B 12/02 55,000 56,995 55,034 1.0400 3 NORTH HILLS #2 LOT 27 N42599900302700 B 9/02 118,000 115,783 118,516 .9800 15 NORTH HILLS #5 LOT 47 N42599901504700 B 6/02 73,500 70,815 74,097 .9600 17 NORTH HILLS #5 LOT 24 N42599901702400 B 8/02 76,950 73,965 77,383 .9600 17 NORTH HILLS #5 LOT 27 N42599901702700 B 9/02 81,000 86,167 81,354 1.0600 22 NORTH HILLS #7 LOT 7 N42599902200700 B 5/02 75,000 70,581 75,703 .9300 23 NORTH HILLS #13 LOT 67 N42599902306700 B 8/02 96,000 94,799 96,540 .9800 32 NORTH HILLS #3 LOT 45 N42599903204500 B 12/02 135,000 126,541 135,084 .9400 3 PARK HILLS #1 LOT 31 P32799900303100 B 9/02 255,500 255,763 256,618 1.0000 279 PIERCE FINLEY PRT LOT 4 P79599927903100 B 4/02 85,000 77,171 85,903 .9000 6 REGAL CREST LOT 10 R33099900601900 B 7/02 82,500 74,307 83,067 .8900 4 RIDGECREST ESTATES REPLAT R45799900406700 B 9/02 108,000 88,654 108,472 .8200 8 RIDGE VIEW ESTATES #4 LOT 2 R46099900802500 B 7/02 220,000 206,307 221,512 .9300 4 RIO ESTANCIAS LOT 8 R53499900402200 B 10/02 196,000 197,171 196,612 1.0000 7 RIVER RUN #2 LOT 29 R57799900702900 B 2/03 190,000 176,754 189,644 .9300 1 SANDCASTLE #1 LOT 3 S10299900100700 B 4/02 98,000 95,623 99,041 .9700 15 SARAH ANNE PARK #2 LOT 19 S16299901503700 B 12/02 71,900 71,005 71,945 .9900 7 SCENIC HGHTS LOT 6 S17199900701100 B 7/02 86,000 78,851 86,591 .9100 SIERRA DEL SOL CONDOS UNIT 12 S375999000A1900 B 8/02 44,000 42,605 44,248 .9600 7 SIERRA HILLS #2 LOT 41 S38099900704100 B 11/02 95,000 89,016 95,178 .9400 8 SIERRA HILLS #2 LOT 40 S38099900804000 B 2/03 138,400 111,785 138,140 .8100 16 SIERRA HILLS #4 LOT 27 S38099901602700 B 6/02 130,000 123,876 131,056 .9500 21 SIERRA HILLS #4 LOT 21 S38099902102100 B 2/03 130,000 104,208 129,756 .8000

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 9 TIME: 13:54 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 071 El Paso 071-902 El Paso CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 21 SIERRA HILLS #4 LOT 23 S38099902102300 B 5/02 119,000 111,976 120,116 .9300 1 SILVER SPRINGS VILLAGE #2 S43199900100400 B 11/02 150,000 126,407 150,281 .8400 7 SUN VALLEY LOT 3 S81699900701300 B 9/02 58,500 48,475 58,756 .8300 97 SUN VALLEY LOT 38 S81699909707500 B 5/02 59,500 61,274 60,058 1.0200 1 SUNSET RIDGE LOT 12 S99199900101200 B 5/02 310,000 306,170 312,906 .9800 3 THE HIGHLANDS #1 LOT 35 T21399900303500 B 7/02 134,900 129,948 135,827 .9600 6 THE HIGHLANDS #2 LOT 6 T21399900600600 B 6/02 85,000 81,340 85,691 .9500 8 THE HIGHLANDS #5 LOT 39 T21399900803900 B 7/02 116,500 114,357 117,301 .9700 11 THE HIGHLANDS #2 LOT 23 T21399901102300 B 5/02 84,000 83,497 84,788 .9800 14 THE HIGHLANDS #3 LOT 2 T21399901400200 B 5/02 172,900 160,643 174,521 .9200 19 THE HIGHLANDS #6 LOT 52 T21399901905200 B 4/02 95,500 97,883 96,515 1.0100 1 THE PARK AT CHAPARRAL LOT 2 T21699900102400 B 12/02 192,000 185,216 192,120 .9600 2 THE WILLOWS #1 LOT 5 T23099900200500 B 5/02 160,000 162,671 161,500 1.0100 8 THE WILLOWS #1 LOT 7 T23099900800700 B 1/03 470,000 405,591 469,706 .8600 6 THUNDERBIRD VALLEY LOT 19 T28199900606400 B 9/02 137,000 131,250 137,599 .9500 29 TOBIN PARK LOT 14 T52799902905300 B 12/02 51,500 49,907 51,532 .9700 2 VILLA VERDE LOT 7 V85299900201300 B 7/02 115,000 99,881 115,791 .8600 132 WASHINGTON HGHTS LOT 9 W09299913206100 B 10/02 89,500 77,548 89,780 .8600 1 WEST HILLS #1 LOT 6 W14599900100600 B 10/02 126,000 124,996 126,394 .9900 4 WEST HILLS #2 LOT 23 W14599900402300 B 2/03 85,000 82,262 84,841 .9700 9 WEST HILLS #7 LOT 20 W14599900902000 B 11/02 113,000 116,742 113,212 1.0300 13 WEST HILLS #4 LOT 34 W14599901303400 B 9/02 85,000 82,561 85,372 .9700 19 WEST HILLS #7 LOT 29 W14599901902900 B 12/02 75,000 70,252 75,047 .9400 23 WEST HILLS #5 LOT 1 W14599902300100 B 6/02 80,500 72,358 81,154 .8900 24 WEST HILLS #7 LOT 8 W14599902400800 B 2/03 95,000 97,346 94,822 1.0300 33 WEST HILLS #14 LOT 11 W14599903301100 B 8/02 85,500 85,577 85,981 1.0000 64 WEST HILLS #18 LOT 11 W14599906401100 B 11/02 101,000 93,356 101,189 .9200 74 WEST HILLS #19 LOT 28 W14599907402800 B 12/02 122,000 114,886 122,076 .9400 75 WEST HILLS #19 LOT 15 W14599907501500 B 1/03 141,000 130,789 140,912 .9300 76 WEST HILLS #19 LOT 37 W14599907600370 B 2/03 127,000 104,095 126,762 .8200 76 WEST HILLS #19 LOT 41 W14599907600410 B 6/02 108,000 106,500 108,877 .9800 80 WEST HILLS #22 LOT 9 W14599908000900 B 6/02 94,500 88,026 95,268 .9200 81 WEST HILLS #22 LOT 4 W14599908100400 B 11/02 95,000 96,392 95,178 1.0100 8 WESTWOOD LOT 15 W19599900804900 B 6/02 84,210 83,985 84,894 .9900 1 WILLOW BEND #1 LOT 1 W41899900100100 B 5/02 270,000 216,805 272,531 .8000 E BENNETT SURV 11 TR 13-B ET X011999000A6500 B 6/02 20,000 42,588 20,163 2.1100 81 TSP 2 SEC 22 SURV 21 TR 4 X58199922200443 B 12/02 57,000 43,113 57,036 .7600 131 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9513

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 10 TIME: 13:54 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 071 El Paso 071-902 El Paso CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 1 BALCONES CORONADO PRT LOT 1 B19099900104120 W 8/02 118,000 104,646 118,000 .8900 1 CAMELOT HGHTS REPLAT B PRT C00799900105550 C 7/02 92,000 96,362 92,000 1.0500 10 CHAPPARRAL PARK PRT LOT 6 C34099901001700 C 6/02 140,000 138,014 140,000 .9900 14 CHAPPARRAL PARK #5 REPLAT C34099901401650 C 8/02 74,700 68,040 74,700 .9100 67-A CHAPPARRAL PARK #22 PRT C340999067A2300 C 8/02 66,000 64,293 66,000 .9700 7 COLONIA MIRAMONTE #1 PRT OF C73699900700450 B 10/02 64,000 62,366 64,000 .9700 22 CORONADO TERRACE REPLAT L C84099902204500 C 8/02 103,700 100,725 103,700 .9700 7 DEL NORTE ACRES D36199900704100 B 12/02 113,000 81,184 113,000 .7200 16 DEL NORTE ACRES LOT 17 D36199901603400 C 2/03 55,000 56,597 55,000 1.0300 1 DOUBLE TREE LOT 9 D77599900100900 C 7/02 90,000 86,254 90,000 .9600 60 EAST EL PASO LOTS 21-22 E01499906005600 C 3/03 88,500 79,048 88,500 .8900 121 EAST EL PASO LOTS 4-5 E01499912100500 C 10/02 80,000 65,381 80,000 .8200 1 EMORY PARK LOT 3 E82099900100300 C 2/03 95,000 91,146 95,000 .9600 83 FRANKLIN HGHTS LOTS 14-16 F60799908308900 C 12/02 105,000 98,584 105,000 .9400 84 FRANKLIN HGHTS LOTS 46-48 F60799908409600 C 8/02 105,000 113,094 105,000 1.0800 110 GRANDVIEW LOTS 29-31 G68699911008500 C 8/02 87,000 102,364 87,000 1.1800 133 HIGHLAND PARK LOTS 9-10 H45399913302900 C 11/02 58,000 55,487 58,000 .9600 1 LAWNDALE PLACE REPLAT A LO L21299900102400 C 8/02 155,000 130,931 155,000 .8400 1 LAWNDALE PLACE REPLAT A LO L21299900102500 C 8/02 150,000 103,753 150,000 .6900 9 LOMAS DEL REY REPLAT L62499900900600 B 10/02 87,000 67,805 87,000 .7800 10 LOMAS DEL REY REPLAT LOT L62499901002100 C 10/02 110,000 107,269 110,000 .9800 9 MESA DEL CASTILLO #3 PRT LOT M32799900903705 C 8/02 92,500 91,294 92,500 .9900 9 MESA DEL CASTILLO M32799900903706 C 8/02 92,500 91,294 92,500 .9900 9 MESA DEL CASTILLO PRT LOT 3 M32799900903750 C 5/02 153,000 147,312 153,000 .9600 7 MESA HILLS #1 REPLAT B PRT M34499900700300 C 1/03 89,000 82,238 89,000 .9200 7 MESA HILLS REPLAT PRT LOT M34499900703880 C 7/02 84,000 81,466 84,000 .9700 1 MESA LINDA REPLAT A PRT LOT M34899900101850 C 5/02 81,700 70,825 81,700 .8700 1 MESA TERRACE PRT LOT 13 M37299900105300 C 10/02 108,000 101,938 108,000 .9400 3 MUNDY HGHTS ALL OF BLOCK M94699900300100 C 8/02 146,000 111,404 146,000 .7600 4 NORTHGATE REPLAT B LOTS 2-4 N57999900405500 C 6/02 4,300,500 4,413,164 4,300,500 1.0300 1 PASEO ESCONDIDO PRT LOT 3 P58899900100500 C 5/02 74,900 60,525 74,900 .8100 2 PASEO ESCONDIDO PRT LOT 5 P58899900201510 C 2/03 67,375 58,127 67,375 .8600 1 WEST HILLS #1 LOT 17 W14599900101700 C 10/02 130,000 130,822 130,000 1.0100 2 WEST HILLS #1 LOT 7 W14599900200700 C 5/02 128,000 124,936 128,000 .9800 4 WEST HILLS #2 LOT 15 W14599900401500 C 7/02 125,000 125,727 125,000 1.0100 35 SALES CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD APPR TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER MOD OBS VALUE APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 1 ACACIA COMMERCIAL PARK LOTS A12299900100400 1.00 .00 7,387,246 7,756,608 .9500 10 ALEXANDER LOTS 14-15 A46299901004900 1.00 .00 149,865 160,118 .9400 92 ALEXANDER LOTS 11-15 A46299909205100 1.00 .00 129,447 122,988 1.0500

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 11 TIME: 13:54 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 071 El Paso 071-902 El Paso CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD APPR TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER MOD OBS VALUE APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 2 ASCARATE TR 4-A-30-H A765999002D0468 1.00 .00 6,688,100 6,761,164 .9900 140 CAMPBELL LOT 6 & PRT LOT 5 C05099914002500 1.00 .00 111,238 115,239 .9700 CANYON TERRACE LOTS 1 THRU 24 C11599900000010 1.00 .00 3,727,852 3,850,000 .9700 1 CELINA PLAZA PRT LOT 1-2-3 C32899900103000 1.00 .00 6,941,276 6,881,773 1.0100 122 CHAPARRAL PARK #26 PRT LOT C34099912200925 1.00 .00 60,805 59,380 1.0200 1 COOPERSTOWN PRT LOT 1 C76299900100195 1.00 .00 46,700 46,600 1.0000 1 CORONA DEL VALLE LOT 1 C79199900100100 1.00 .00 2,434,824 2,425,950 1.0000 22 CORONADO TERRACE #6 REPLAT C84099902204900 1.00 .00 91,658 93,600 .9800 27 CORONADO TERRACE REPLAT L C84099902705400 1.00 .00 82,610 93,690 .8800 6 DEL NORTE ACRES LOTS A&B D36199900600400 1.00 .00 135,748 129,707 1.0500 6 DEL NORTE HGHTS LOTS E-F D36199900601100 1.00 .00 134,043 143,875 .9300 16 FRANKLIN HGHTS LOTS 31-32 E F60799901609701 1.00 .00 63,202 65,468 .9700 59 GRANDVIEW LOTS 5-7 G68699905901500 1.00 .00 64,710 66,263 .9800 110 GRANDVIEW LOTS 21-22 G68699911006400 1.00 .00 79,840 85,800 .9300 3 HIDDEN CREST LOT 11 H41099900301100 1.00 .00 133,014 123,302 1.0800 88-D LOGAN HGHTS LOTS 10-17 L447999088D2500 1.00 .00 166,475 174,045 .9600 1 LOS CERRITOS LOT 1 L71499900100100 1.00 .00 7,488,000 7,113,600 1.0500 20 MESA HILLS #7 LOTS 1-2 M34499902000100 1.00 .00 6,375,907 6,476,190 .9800 1 MESA LINDA REPLAT A PRT LOT M34899900101270 1.00 .00 74,623 76,500 .9800 23 NORTH HILLS #8 ALL UNIT 8 N42599902300000 1.00 .00 13,989,064 15,310,110 .9100 43 PARK FOOTHILLS TR 763-A&76 P32499904302900 1.00 .00 1,839,204 1,784,028 1.0300 2 PASEO ESCONDIDO PRT LOTS 1-2 P58899900200200 1.00 .00 152,290 188,136 .8100 1 PATRIOT APARTMENTS #1 LOTS 1 P60399900100100 1.00 .00 7,094,125 7,285,714 .9700 5-A PIEDMONT ADDN LOTS 1-4 P774999005A0100 1.00 .00 151,796 157,104 .9700 1 PUNTO ALEGRE LOT 3 & PRT LOT P95099900100310 1.00 .00 6,900,000 6,946,683 .9900 1 RADFORD TERRACE PRT LOT 3 R03899900100350 1.00 .00 69,483 68,880 1.0100 1 RUSHFAIR PRT LOTS 2-3 R87699900102500 1.00 .00 1,324,865 1,664,864 .8000 2 TOWN & COUNTRY REPLAT PRT O T64599900200100 1.00 .00 1,227,188 1,367,251 .9000 3 WASHINGTON PARK LOTS 13&14 W09699900304900 1.00 .00 51,203 67,770 .7600 1 WEST HILLS #1 LOT 10 W14599900101000 1.00 .00 133,564 131,155 1.0200 2 WESTSIDE CENTER LOT B W18299900205000 1.00 .00 6,426,202 6,437,787 1.0000 AF MILLER SURV 213 ABST 3597 X21399900001159 1.00 .00 3,116,588 3,000,239 1.0400 AF MILLER SURV 215 ABST 3599 X21599900003200 1.00 .00 1,633,985 1,743,282 .9400 AF MILLER SURV 215 ABST 3599 T X21599900003310 1.00 .00 2,149,964 2,150,000 1.0000 A F MILLER SURV 215 ABST 359 X21599900003655 1.00 .00 6,219,978 5,918,600 1.0500 81 TSP 1 SEC 29 T&P SURV TR 4 X581999129B0450 1.00 .00 1,343,363 1,325,000 1.0100 39 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9617 CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE.

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 12 TIME: 13:54 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 071 El Paso 071-902 El Paso CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 42 ALEXANDER LOTS 11-12 A46299904204100 C 6/02 182,000 122,808 182,000 .6700 206 ALEXANDER PRT OF BLOCK A46299920602000 C 12/02 220,000 280,442 220,000 1.2700 A BASSETT LOTS 40-47 B202999000A5600 C 7/02 140,000 151,174 140,000 1.0800 1 BOYKIN COMMERCIAL DIST PRT O B69299900100100 C 5/02 235,000 246,514 235,000 1.0500 1 BUENA VISTA PRT LOTS 5-6 B80099900104900 C 4/02 140,000 145,702 140,000 1.0400 1 CORONADO DEL SOL PRT LOT 1 C81599900100125 C 5/02 2,635,000 3,183,942 2,635,000 1.2100 74 COTTON PRT OF BLOCK C84999907406600 C 5/02 95,000 99,022 95,000 1.0400 15 MESA HILLS PRT LOT 1 M34499901501300 C 12/02 1,250,000 1,258,311 1,250,000 1.0100 SUNRISE ACRES #2 PRT LOT 110 S917999002D8800 C 7/02 415,000 167,451 415,000 .4000 SUNRISE ACRES #2 PRT LOT 111 S917999002E0100 C 7/02 415,000 155,720 415,000 .3800 16 WOMBLE PRT LOT 14 W81399901603700 C 5/02 114,000 112,007 114,000 .9800 11 SALES CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ TR 4-A-30-G-1-C BLK 2 ASCARA A765999002D0467 .00 1.00 .00 4,917,061 4,763,327 1.0300 TR 4-C-2-A BLK 2 ASCARATE A765999002E0426 .00 1.00 .00 1,565,408 1,686,742 .9300 PRT BLK 71 BASSETT B20299907102000 .00 1.00 .00 521,738 570,966 .9100 LOT 2 BASSETT CENTER B22099900102100 .00 1.00 .00 35,036,326 27,902,325 1.2600 LOTS 1-2 BLK 1 BOYKIN COMMER B69499900100100 .00 1.00 .00 6,420,943 5,747,231 1.1200 EAST PRT BLK 210 CAMPBELL C05099921005100 .00 1.00 .00 482,739 512,316 .9400 PRT BLK 3 CELINA PLAZA C32899900302000 .00 1.00 .00 8,464,189 8,984,313 .9400 LOTS 1-4 BLK 5 CELINA PLAZA C32899900500100 .00 1.00 .00 15,229,566 14,901,981 1.0200 LOT 40 BLK 100 CHAPARRAL PARK C34099910007900 .00 1.00 .00 1,669,541 1,941,698 .8600 LOT 2 BLK 1 COVENTRY PARK WE C88499900100200 .00 1.00 .00 1,342,623 1,348,916 1.0000 LOT 10 BLK B EXECUTIVE PARK E978999000B9400 .00 1.00 .00 1,762,940 1,685,544 1.0500 PRT SEC 1 BLK 4 FARRAH REP F1759900400100 .00 1.00 .00 2,112,030 2,045,448 1.0300 LOTS 5-14 BLK 7 HIGHLAND PA H45399900704600 .00 1.00 .00 6,411,313 5,193,688 1.2300 LOTS 1-2 BLK 30 MESA HILLS M34499903000275 .00 1.00 .00 953,076 1,130,303 .8400 LOTS 2-3 BLK 2 MESA HILLS P M34699900200200 .00 1.00 .00 5,844,694 4,771,570 1.2200 LOTS 1-10 BLK 21 MILLS M47399902100100 .00 1.00 .00 1,418,268 1,129,502 1.2600 PRT OF BLK 41 MILLS M47399904104900 .00 1.00 .00 1,641,063 1,473,919 1.1100 LOT 4 BLK 1 MYSTIC HILL UNI M99899900100400 .00 1.00 .00 8,299,310 7,987,661 1.0400 BLK 2 NORTHGATE N57999900200500 .00 1.00 .00 2,634,067 2,459,662 1.0700 LOT 1-A BLK 6 NORTHGATE REPL N57999900607000 .00 1.00 .00 1,600,485 1,954,408 .8200 LOT 1 BLK 2 PARK WEST #2 P39399900201000 .00 1.00 .00 11,553,113 10,537,920 1.1000 PRT LOT 1 BLK 2 PARK WEST 1 P39599900201000 .00 1.00 .00 488,514 520,706 .9400 PRT LOT 1 BLK 4 WEST TEN W13899900400150 .00 1.00 .00 842,809 1,179,713 .7100 TRACT 5 BLK 1 MOREHEAD IMPS X001999M00A5800 .00 1.00 .00 732,805 622,289 1.1800 TR 34-A-1 H F FISHER SURVEY X293999F00A5425 .00 1.00 .00 5,071,765 4,794,117 1.0600 25 APPRAISALS

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 13 TIME: 13:54 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 071 El Paso 071-902 El Paso STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9656 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ HERTZ CORPORATION 000299960000000 11,881,261 12,460,100 .9500 MENLO WORLDWIDE FOWARDING 000799910040000 423,081 424,859 1.0000 ALL TEMP INSULATION 005499930060000 54,023 66,962 .8100 UNITED PARCEL SERVICE 014499960010000 1,609,028 1,786,046 .9000 J C PENNEY CORPORATION 028599950010000 6,743,265 6,521,110 1.0300 JOHN HANCOCK MUTUAL LIFE 029499980000000 68,302 78,382 .8700 ECONOMY CASH & CARRY 046999940000000 5,450,032 5,465,646 1.0000 GRAYBAR ELECTRIC CO INC 055699990000000 1,102,834 1,133,258 .9700 GRAY REFRIGERATION 082099900430034 361,043 340,794 1.0600 CSK AUTO INC 082099904870034 1,313,268 1,320,184 .9900 DISCOUNT TIRE CO 082199904610034 291,754 294,394 .9900 SALLY'S BEAUTY SUPPLY 082299909290034 119,485 120,570 .9900 A O SMITH CORPOARTION 082299914260034 10,348,510 10,720,740 .9700 CAZADOR TRANSPORT INC 082399923880034 315,226 362,138 .8700 DILLARD'S 082599914000034 8,803,828 8,867,413 .9900 SUNTORY WATER GROUP INC 082599927710034 1,518,226 1,795,831 .8500 CASH AMERICA PAWN 082599927800034 166,594 167,307 1.0000 EL PASO HEAT TRANSFER 082699916760034 110,191 120,414 .9200 ALBERTSON'S #933 199399908490034 1,811,448 1,813,872 1.0000 BEST BUY STORES 199399908550042 3,599,692 4,121,180 .8700 TARGET #849 199499935580034 3,204,106 3,632,798 .8800 BARNES & NOBLES 199599900760034 1,227,606 1,322,049 .9300 THINGS REMEMBERED INC 199599901610034 29,308 25,453 1.1500 SAM EAST INC 199599904230042 5,893,923 5,909,016 1.0000 WAL-MART STORES EAST 199599904240042 6,031,774 6,084,533 .9900 INTERNATIONAL OUTSOURCING 199699907840110 1,417,688 1,383,189 1.0200 BIG 5 SPORTING GOODS INC 199699907980034 518,850 526,008 .9900 ROSS DRESS FOR LESS 199699909720034 650,935 681,174 .9600 ALLTELL 199699930050034 8,442,374 8,066,230 1.0500 THE SPORTS AUTHORITY #355 199899906500034 2,121,775 2,169,593 .9800 EZ PAWN 199999901880034 81,478 92,233 .8800 AKAL SECURITY 199999913060034 33,547 29,656 1.1300 BORDER STATES ELECTRIC SUPPLY 199999917360034 821,186 820,641 1.0000 RECORD TOWN INC 200099904190034 1,009,136 1,065,743 .9500 ALAMOSA PROPERTIES 200099922780034 5,307,400 4,951,600 1.0700 FORT BLISS FEDERAL CREDIT UNIO 200199905570034 40,000 57,220 .7000 LOWE'S HOME CENTERS INC 200199909260034 6,808,127 7,973,563 .8500 LOWE'S HOME CENTERS INC 200199941410034 6,527,327 6,571,828 .9900 COMPREHENSIVE MEDICAL 200299927850034 268,914 306,154 .8800 MIDWEST CAR CORP 200299929520034 5,056,242 4,998,458 1.0100 FOLEY'S 200399907340034 7,876,896 7,901,272 1.0000 41 APPRAISALS

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 14 TIME: 13:54 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 071 El Paso 071-902 El Paso STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9628