Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   1/22/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:     90
TIME:     13:38                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             057  Dallas
                                                         057-914  Mesquite

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  FREEWAY FOREST 4 BLK F LT 9      12018500060090000          B      12/02         73,500          75,190        73,500    1.0230
  HERITAGE PARK BLK 1 LT 15 81.4   12029500010150000          B       6/02         78,000          68,820        78,000     .8823
  HERITAGE PARK BLK 5 LOT 7 61X1   12029500050070000          B       4/02         85,900          86,760        85,900    1.0100
  HICKORY CREEK MEADOWS BLK B  L   120309000B0170000          B      11/02        109,966         107,730       109,966     .9797
  HILLTOP ESTATES BLK A LOT 24     120325500A0240000          B       3/03        112,900         115,280       112,900    1.0211
  HILLTOP ESTATES BLK B LOT 4      120325500B0040000          B       6/02        108,000          99,160       108,000     .9181
  HILLTOP ESTATES BLK J LOT 7      120325500J0070000          B       9/02        113,000         105,870       113,000     .9369
  PIONEER OAKS BLK 3 LT 6          12060100030060000          B       3/03         66,500          81,310        66,500    1.2227
  PIONEER OAKS BLK 4 LT 10         12060100040100000          B       3/03         87,000          81,880        87,000     .9411
  PIONEER OAKS BLK 4 LOT 22        12060100040220000          B       3/03        100,000         107,300       100,000    1.0730
  PIONEER OAKS BLK 4 LT 58         12060100040580000          B      11/02         87,000          76,380        87,000     .8779
  SPRING OAKS 1 BLK 2 LOT 1        12071500020010000          B       3/03         90,000          91,440        90,000    1.0160
  SPRING OAKS 3RD INST BLK 20 LT   12073500200270000          B       4/02         62,500          62,600        62,500    1.0016
  SPRING OAKS 4TH INST BLK 22 LO   12075500220040000          B       6/02         79,500          66,300        79,500     .8340
  SPRING OAKS 5TH INST BLK 2 LOT   12076500020120000          B       3/03         85,000          83,970        85,000     .9879
  LA PRADA 6 CLK 1 LOT 6           26309200010060000          B      11/02         76,500          91,750        76,500    1.1993
  LA PRADA 6 BLK 3 LT 11           26309200030110000          B       6/02        101,000          97,920       101,000     .9695
  TRAIL VALLEY 1 BLK 1 LOT 2       26610800010020000          B      11/02        125,900         123,980       125,900     .9847
  TRAIL VALLEY 1 BLK 2  LOT 5      26610800020050000          B       6/02        133,900         134,690       133,900    1.0059
  BROADMOOR ESTATES 5 BLK J LT 7   38011600100070000          B       9/02        109,900         113,920       109,900    1.0366
  BYRD ESTATES BLK 1 LT 4          38013500010040000          B       5/02         91,000          82,360        91,000     .9051
  CASA TERRACE 1 BLK 3 LT 1        38024500030010000          B       4/02        102,785          75,230       102,785     .7319
  CASA TERRACE 4 BLK K LOT 34      380264900K0340000          B       7/02        116,000         115,410       116,000     .9949
  CASA TERRACE 3 BLK 12 LT 8       38026500120080000          B       3/03         91,400          73,350        91,400     .8025
  CASA VIEW HEIGHTS 15 BLK 7 LT    38027500070080000          B       5/02         80,000          90,990        80,000    1.1374
  CASA VIEW HEIGHTS 15 BLK 7  LT   38027500070470000          B       3/03         89,000          71,630        89,000     .8048
  CASA VIEW HEIGHTS 15 BLK 11 LO   38027500110160000          B       3/03         78,000          79,520        78,000    1.0195
  CASA VIEW HEIGHTS 15 BLK 14  L   38027500140220000          B       8/02         86,000          69,300        86,000     .8058
  CASA VIEW HEIGHTS 16 2ND SEC B   38030500080180000          B       7/02         84,900          61,010        84,900     .7186
  CASA VIEW HEIGHTS 16 2ND SEC B   38030500090160000          B       3/03         91,000          76,659        91,000     .8424
  CASA VIEW HEIGHTS 16 4TH SEC B   38032500100280000          B       7/02         65,000          84,610        65,000    1.3017
  CASA VIEW HEIGHTS 16 5TH SEC B   38033500130060000          B       3/03         85,000          90,839        85,000    1.0687
  CASA VIEW HEIGHTS 16 5TH SEC B   38033500140130000          B       3/03         55,850          88,930        55,850    1.5923
  CASA VIEW HEIGHTS 16 6TH SEC B   38034500070210000          B       4/02         48,500          72,080        48,500    1.4862
  CASA VIEW HEIGHTS 16 6TH SEC B   38034500150060000          B       7/02         84,900          79,550        84,900     .9370
  CASA VIEW HEIGHTS 16 6TH SEC B   38034500150140000          B       8/02         92,400          85,960        92,400     .9303
  CASA VIEW HEIGHTS 17 BLK 4 LOT   38036500040070000          B       5/02         79,900          78,850        79,900     .9869
  CASA VIEW HEIGHTS 18 2ND INST    38038500130150000          B       6/02         87,100          87,560        87,100    1.0053
  CASA VIEW HEIGHTS 18 2ND INST    38038500200240000          B      11/02         86,500          85,480        86,500     .9882
  CASA VIEW HEIGHTS 21 BLK 3 LT    38040500030070000          B       9/02         92,000          84,067        92,000     .9138
  CAYMAN ESTATES PH 2 BLK A LT 1   380407500A0180000          B       8/02        114,900         105,580       114,900     .9189
  CAYMAN ESTATES PH 2 BLK A LOT    380407500A0190000          B       3/03        130,000         130,960       130,000    1.0074
  CAYMAN ESTATES PH 2 BLK E LOT    380407500E0160000          B       5/02        142,000         135,660       142,000     .9554
  CHAMBERLAIN PLACE 1 PH 2 REP B   380412100E0160000          B      11/02        113,000         117,770       113,000    1.0422
  CHAMBERLAIN PLACE 1 PH 2 REP B   380412100G0170000          B       9/02        113,000         110,470       113,000     .9776
  CHAMBERLAIN PLACE 3R BLK A LT    380412200A0430000          B      11/02        117,000         118,342       117,000    1.0115
  CLUB ESTATES 1ST SEC BLK 3 LOT   38044100030040000          B       3/03         88,000         101,430        88,000    1.1526

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 91 TIME: 13:38 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-914 Mesquite CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ CLUB ESTATES 1ST SEC BLK 7 LT 38044100070030000 B 6/02 97,500 97,840 97,500 1.0035 CLUB ESTATES 2ND SEC BLK 7 LT 38044160070040000 B 6/02 98,500 91,140 98,500 .9253 CLUB ESTATES 2ND SEC BLK 9 LT 38044160090130000 B 4/02 95,000 103,180 95,000 1.0861 CLUB ESTATES 2ND SEC BLK 10 LO 38044160100130000 B 7/02 103,500 103,180 103,500 .9969 CLUB ESTATES 2ND SEC BLK 11 L 38044160110160000 B 9/02 100,000 95,830 100,000 .9583 COLLEGE PARK BLK K LOT 16 38044600110160000 B 9/02 115,000 118,010 115,000 1.0262 COPELAND LT 3 87X100 38046500000030000 B 11/02 107,850 107,720 107,850 .9988 COUNTRY CLUB ESTATES 1 BLK 2 L 38047500020030000 B 5/02 89,000 79,050 89,000 .8882 COUNTRY CLUB ESTATES 2 BLK 15 38048500150060000 B 5/02 66,000 74,230 66,000 1.1247 COUNTRY CLUB GROVE 1ST SEC BLK 38049500010030000 B 3/03 147,500 138,730 147,500 .9405 COUNTRY CLUB GROVE 1ST SEC BLK 38049500010100000 B 3/03 137,500 132,000 137,500 .9600 COUNTRY CLUB GROVE 2ND SEC BLK 38050500030050000 B 4/02 133,500 132,106 133,500 .9896 COUNTRY MEADOW 1 BLK 1 LT 8 38051800010080000 B 5/02 140,000 123,770 140,000 .8841 COUNTRY MEADOW 1 BLK 5 LOT 7 38051800050070000 B 3/03 110,000 104,460 110,000 .9496 COUNTRY MEADOW 1 BLK 10 LOT 3 38051800100030000 B 10/02 115,750 106,570 115,750 .9207 COUNTRY MEADOW 2 BLK 8 LT 24 A 38051850080240000 B 12/02 106,000 87,500 106,000 .8255 COUNTRY MEADOW 2 BLK 11 LOT 42 38051850110420000 B 5/02 135,500 143,140 135,500 1.0564 COUNTRY MEADOW 2 BLK 12 LOT 7 38051850120070000 B 8/02 130,500 128,010 130,500 .9809 COUNTRY MEADOW 2 BLK 15 LOT 20 38051850150200000 B 7/02 115,000 120,580 115,000 1.0485 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 5 PH 2 38053640040050000 B 3/03 145,000 137,550 145,000 .9486 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 15 PH B 380537100A0230000 B 6/02 215,000 214,600 215,000 .9981 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 20 BLK 380537200A0050000 B 8/02 180,000 180,740 180,000 1.0041 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 8 BLK A 380537500A0060000 B 9/02 142,900 132,550 142,900 .9276 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 18 BLK 380537600B0030000 B 3/03 149,000 144,860 149,000 .9722 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 4 PH A 380537900A0120000 B 8/02 164,000 170,690 164,000 1.0408 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 4 PH A 380537900B0040000 B 8/02 164,500 184,720 164,500 1.1229 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 2 BLK B 380538100B0010000 B 3/03 139,500 135,850 139,500 .9738 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 2 BLK B 380538100B0080000 B 10/02 132,900 125,810 132,900 .9467 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 2 BLK D 380538100D0540000 B 3/03 125,000 118,940 125,000 .9515 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 2 BLK E 380538100E0080000 B 6/02 140,000 135,850 140,000 .9704 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 2 BLK F 380538100F0150000 B 4/02 100,799 109,020 100,799 1.0816 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 2 BLK G 380538100G0050000 B 9/02 145,900 134,730 145,900 .9234 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 2 BLK H 380538100H0180000 B 5/02 143,500 131,460 143,500 .9161 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 2 BLK H 380538100H0320000 B 5/02 131,870 121,770 131,870 .9234 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 3 BLK D 380538200D0030000 B 10/02 158,000 148,460 158,000 .9396 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 3 BLK F 380538200F0060000 B 12/02 125,000 120,650 125,000 .9652 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 6 PH 1 38053850040090000 B 5/02 115,000 102,600 115,000 .8922 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 6 PH 1 38053850040210000 B 6/02 128,000 122,600 128,000 .9578 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 7 PH 2 38053870070130000 B 7/02 134,900 125,540 134,900 .9306 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 7 PH 2 38053870090210000 B 7/02 158,900 159,650 158,900 1.0047 CREEK CROSSING 9 BLK 2 LOT 16 38053880020160000 B 11/02 155,000 143,000 155,000 .9226 CREEK CROSSING 9 BLK 4 LOT 15 38053880040150000 B 4/02 163,000 159,890 163,000 .9809 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 11 PH 1 38053900080360000 B 8/02 134,500 134,350 134,500 .9989 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 11 PH 2 38053910120140000 B 3/03 106,000 107,020 106,000 1.0096 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 11 PH 2 38053910120150000 B 9/02 133,500 133,290 133,500 .9984 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 11 PH 2 38053910140070000 B 6/02 116,000 122,560 116,000 1.0566 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 12 PH 1 380539200B0310000 B 5/02 167,900 169,230 167,900 1.0079

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 92 TIME: 13:38 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-914 Mesquite CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 12 PH 1 380539200C0140000 B 6/02 182,000 178,250 182,000 .9794 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 12 PH 1 380539200L0010000 B 7/02 178,000 173,220 178,000 .9731 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 12 PH 2 380539300U0130000 B 10/02 117,000 146,430 117,000 1.2515 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 13 (A) 380539400A0040000 B 7/02 119,000 110,670 119,000 .9300 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 13 (A) 380539400A0050000 B 8/02 112,500 110,900 112,500 .9858 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 13 (A) 380539400E0030000 B 3/03 121,000 114,630 121,000 .9474 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 14 BLK 380539500B0060000 B 3/03 137,000 145,740 137,000 1.0638 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 14 SEC 380539600E0170000 B 3/03 140,000 147,860 140,000 1.0561 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 17 BLK 380539800G0180000 B 8/02 105,000 106,050 105,000 1.0100 EAST GLEN PH 1 REP BLK B LOT 5 380601500B0580000 B 10/02 87,000 88,050 87,000 1.0121 EAST GLEN PH 2 BLK D LT 54 380601600D0540000 B 7/02 88,000 85,700 88,000 .9739 EAST GLEN PH 2 BLK K LT 22 380601600K0220000 B 3/03 96,000 105,790 96,000 1.1020 EAST GLEN PH 2 BLK L LT 3 380601600L0030000 B 3/03 110,000 110,090 110,000 1.0008 EAST GLEN PH 2 BLK M LOT 4 380601600M0040000 B 10/02 89,000 99,110 89,000 1.1136 EASTERN HEIGHTS 2 BLK L LOT 6 38061500120060000 B 7/02 81,000 61,910 81,000 .7643 EASTERN HEIGHTS 2 BLK L LOT 23 38061500120230000 B 3/03 89,900 74,330 89,900 .8268 EASTERN HEIGHTS 4 BLK F LT 3 38063500060030000 B 10/02 80,000 68,730 80,000 .8591 EASTERN HEIGHTS 4 BLK F LT 8 38063500060080000 B 3/03 93,500 85,790 93,500 .9175 EASTRIDGE PARK 7 BLK B-1 LT 2 38072500020020000 B 11/02 125,000 108,710 125,000 .8697 EASTRIDGE PARK 8 BLK 14 LT 21 38073500140210000 B 11/02 110,000 116,120 110,000 1.0556 EDGEMONT PARK BLK 6 LOT 29 38075500060290000 B 5/02 72,000 64,300 72,000 .8931 EDGEMONT PARK BLK 7 LT 29 38075500070290000 B 11/02 45,800 60,470 45,800 1.3203 EL TIERRA ESTATES 1 BLK00C LT 38085500030210000 B 9/02 73,500 76,520 73,500 1.0411 C C FREEMAN 2 BLK A PT LT 11 A 38091500010110100 B 4/02 178,000 200,350 178,000 1.1256 GALLOWAY PLACE BLK A LOT 15 380925900A0150000 B 8/02 81,000 81,890 81,000 1.0110 GALLOWAY PLACE BLK C LT 22 380925900C0220000 B 8/02 98,500 99,880 98,500 1.0140 GREEN CANYON ESTATES BLK 1 LT 38094900010400000 B 3/03 123,900 125,510 123,900 1.0130 HIGHLAND HILLS BLK H LT 19 38103500080190000 B 5/02 71,000 64,290 71,000 .9055 HIGHLAND HILLS 2ND SEC BLK B L 38104500020080000 B 11/02 84,900 80,210 84,900 .9448 HIGHLAND HILLS 2ND SEC BLK C L 38104500030230000 B 11/02 93,500 77,280 93,500 .8265 HILLCREST PARK REP BLK A LOT 3 381077000A0330000 B 3/03 95,000 93,880 95,000 .9882 IDLEWYLD PLACE PH 2 BLK C LT 5 381108900C0510000 B 11/02 104,900 101,350 104,900 .9662 IDLEWYLD PLACE PH 2 BLK F LT 381108900F0150000 B 8/02 115,000 112,150 115,000 .9752 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 1 PH 1 38112010030130000 B 3/03 138,000 130,000 138,000 .9420 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 1 PH 2 38112020010030000 B 8/02 132,900 134,060 132,900 1.0087 CREEK CROSSING ESTATES 1 PH 2 38112020070050000 B 6/02 145,000 157,200 145,000 1.0841 LOS ALTOS 1 BLK E LOT 41 381193000E0410000 B 8/02 120,000 105,480 120,000 .8790 LOS ALTOS 1 BLK E LOT 53 381193000E0530000 B 5/02 119,900 105,640 119,900 .8811 LOS ALTOS 2 BLK E LT 65 381193100E0650000 B 5/02 111,490 127,390 111,490 1.1426 LOS ALTOS 3 BLK E LOT 81 381193200E0810000 B 9/02 117,500 100,160 117,500 .8524 MEADOW CREEK PH 1B BLK C LT 57 381204400C0570000 B 3/03 103,180 95,350 103,180 .9241 MEADOWDALE 2 BLK 4 LOT 4 38120470040040000 B 11/02 98,900 100,170 98,900 1.0128 MEADOWVIEW FARMS BLK 7 LT 14 38120800070140000 B 3/03 141,000 186,650 141,000 1.3238 MEADOWVIEW FARMS 2 BLK E LOT 9 381208100E0090000 B 6/02 157,000 164,900 157,000 1.0503 MELTON 4 LOT 105 38123500001050000 B 12/02 59,000 58,340 59,000 .9888 MESQUITE HIGHLANDS BLK 5 LT 8 38124500050080000 B 8/02 75,000 68,500 75,000 .9133 NORTHRIDGE ESTATES 1 BLK 9 LOT 38136500090150000 B 10/02 85,000 83,530 85,000 .9827

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 93 TIME: 13:38 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-914 Mesquite CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ NORTHRIDGE ESTATES 1 BLK 10 LT 38136500100150000 B 10/02 89,000 80,175 89,000 .9008 NORTHRIDGE ESTATES 1 BLK 18 LT 38136500180320000 B 3/03 89,000 89,420 89,000 1.0047 NORTHRIDGE ESTATES 1 BLK 20 LO 38136500200090000 B 12/02 50,555 69,740 50,555 1.3795 NORTHRIDGE ESTATES 3 BLK 40 LO 38138500400010000 B 9/02 68,500 78,960 68,500 1.1527 NORTHRIDGE ESTATES 3 BLK 40 LO 38138500400260000 B 5/02 83,000 75,080 83,000 .9046 NORTHRIDGE ESTATES 4 BLK 57 L 38139500570180000 B 3/03 52,000 59,220 52,000 1.1388 PALOS VERDES 9 BLK 1 LOT 9 IR 38149800010090000 B 5/02 113,900 113,670 113,900 .9980 PALOS VERDES ESTATES 1 BLK 4 L 38150500040050000 B 5/02 115,900 115,900 115,900 1.0000 PALOS VERDES ESTATES 1 BLK 5 L 38150500050190000 B 4/02 108,000 107,240 108,000 .9930 PALOS VERDES 11 PH 2 REP BLK 1 381527400140A0000 B 9/02 149,900 153,900 149,900 1.0267 PARK AT CREEK CROSSING 1 BLK C 381535300C0100000 B 11/02 134,900 136,440 134,900 1.0114 PARK AT CREEK CROSSING PH 3 BL 381535500H0240000 B 10/02 149,500 149,730 149,500 1.0015 PARK AT CREEK CROSSING PH 5 BL 381535800M0060000 B 9/02 129,500 132,870 129,500 1.0260 PARK AT CREEK CROSSING PH 6 BL 381535800N0720000 B 5/02 114,900 116,180 114,900 1.0111 PARKCHASE PH 1 BLK G LT 6 381535900G0060000 B 12/02 151,500 155,700 151,500 1.0277 PARKVIEW BLK O LT 3 381574000O0030000 B 5/02 107,500 121,860 107,500 1.1336 PARKVIEW 2 BLK R LOT 21 381574100R0210000 B 8/02 188,500 182,710 188,500 .9693 PARKVIEW 4 BLK C LT 4 381574300C0040000 B 9/02 156,000 152,380 156,000 .9768 PEACHTREE VILLAGE BLK 1 LT 10 38158550010100000 B 12/02 93,000 95,210 93,000 1.0238 PEACHTREE VILLAGE BLK 3 LT 10 38158550030100000 B 9/02 86,500 86,090 86,500 .9953 PEACHTREE VILLAGE BLK 4 LOT 22 38158550040220000 B 7/02 100,000 101,960 100,000 1.0196 PECAN BEND BLK B LT 23 65X114. 38158600520230000 B 5/02 99,500 97,670 99,500 .9816 PECAN BEND BLK C LOT 2 38158600530020000 B 3/03 100,000 111,130 100,000 1.1113 PECAN BEND BLK E LT 12 51.49X1 38158600550120000 B 3/03 109,500 100,910 109,500 .9216 QUAIL HOLLOW BLK 3 LT 12 38159550030120000 B 6/02 128,500 128,020 128,500 .9963 ROYAL ACRES BLK 2 LOT 6 38162600020060000 B 8/02 96,500 97,630 96,500 1.0117 SAMUELL PARK FARMS EAST BLK K 381722500K0220000 B 3/03 94,950 94,130 94,950 .9914 SAMUEL PARKS FARMS SOUTH BLK A 381722700A0360000 B 3/03 119,000 96,060 119,000 .8072 SHERWOOD FOREST 1 & 2 LOT 108 38180500001080000 B 6/02 118,450 118,140 118,450 .9974 SKYLINE 3 1ST SEC BLK 32 LT 2 38186500320020000 B 3/03 118,500 111,180 118,500 .9382 SKYLINE 4 BLK 54 LOT 21 38188500540210000 B 3/03 95,500 96,040 95,500 1.0057 SOUTH WILDWOOD LOT 15 38197500000150000 B 4/02 68,000 68,940 68,000 1.0138 SPRING RIDGE ESTATES PH 4 BLK 381982500A0090000 B 3/03 112,000 92,340 112,000 .8245 STONERIDGE BLK 3 LT 33 55.91X7 38198540030330000 B 5/02 118,000 130,930 118,000 1.1096 STONEY GLEN BLK B LOT 41 38198600020410000 B 7/02 99,000 87,100 99,000 .8798 TEALWOOD PH 1 BLK B LOT 28 382007000B0280000 B 8/02 145,000 145,490 145,000 1.0034 TEALWOOD PH 1 BLK F LOT 11 382007000F0110000 B 9/02 139,000 143,340 139,000 1.0312 TIMBERLAND BLK 2 LT 17 38201300020170000 B 10/02 120,000 118,720 120,000 .9893 TOWN EAST ESTATES BLK Q LT 7 38202500170070000 B 12/02 83,500 66,970 83,500 .8020 TOWN EAST ESTATES BLK Q LT 32 38202500170320000 B 12/02 90,000 68,310 90,000 .7590 TOWN EAST ESTATES 8 2ND INST B 38211500060270000 B 4/02 92,000 77,400 92,000 .8413 TOWN EAST ESTATES 8 2ND INST B 38211500070200000 B 5/02 96,000 97,440 96,000 1.0150 TOWN EAST ESTATES 8 2ND INST B 38211500080210000 B 8/02 92,000 88,070 92,000 .9573 TOWN EAST ESTATES 10 BLK E LT 38213500050040000 B 3/03 99,000 98,970 99,000 .9997 TOWNE CENTRE VILLAGE BLKD LT 3 38216850540340000 B 3/03 93,000 99,920 93,000 1.0744 VALLEYCREEK PH 1 BLK B LOT 9 382249000B0090000 B 12/02 120,000 122,600 120,000 1.0217 VALLEYCREEK ESTATES PH 1 REV B 382249500U0050000 B 11/02 149,000 166,450 149,000 1.1171

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 94 TIME: 13:38 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-914 Mesquite CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ VALLEYCREEK ESTATES PH 1 REV B 382249500W0050000 B 11/02 158,000 170,000 158,000 1.0759 VALLEYCREEK ESTATES PH 2A BLK 382249600X0030000 B 9/02 176,528 175,710 176,528 .9954 WHITSON GARDENS 4 BLK K LOT 2 38233500110020000 B 3/03 57,000 80,150 57,000 1.4061 WHITSON GARDENS 6 BLK R LT 5 38235500180050000 B 9/02 95,300 94,860 95,300 .9954 WILLOW GLEN 2 BLK C LOT 23 38238770530230000 B 3/03 130,000 146,160 130,000 1.1243 WILLOW GLEN 3 BLK 3 LOT 17 6 38238810030170000 B 10/02 108,550 106,180 108,550 .9782 WILLOW GLEN 4 BLK 10 LT 4 38238820100040000 B 7/02 110,740 110,360 110,740 .9966 WILLOW GLEN 4 BLK 11 LT 14 38238820110140000 B 11/02 107,900 104,670 107,900 .9701 WILLOW GLEN 4 BLK 11 LOT 16 38238820110160000 B 3/03 123,500 120,800 123,500 .9781 VALLEYCREEK PH 2 BLK M LT 19 386170100M0190000 B 7/02 150,380 145,350 150,380 .9666 WOODFIELD CASTEEL ABST 343 PG 65034305010510000 B 7/02 80,820 81,300 80,820 1.0059 JOHN D SNIDER ABST 1349 PG 315 65134931510090000 B 3/03 39,000 62,560 39,000 1.6041 200 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9864 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ PIONEER CROSSING TOWNHOME APTS 12048000000010100 C 11/02 892,500 892,500 892,500 1.0000 CLUB ESTATES 3 BLK 3 LOT 22B 380441100322B0000 B 12/02 91,100 93,920 91,100 1.0310 CLUB ESTATES 3 BLK 3 LOT 27B 380441100327B0000 B 4/02 97,000 97,740 97,000 1.0076 CLUB ESTATES 3 BLK 3 LOT 29A 380441100329A0000 B 4/02 96,000 100,890 96,000 1.0509 EAST GLEN PH 2 BLK R LT 3B 380601600R03B0000 B 5/02 78,500 77,610 78,500 .9887 HEARTHSTONE MANOR BLK A LOT 4 380980000A0040000 B 5/02 78,900 79,690 78,900 1.0100 HEARTHSTONE MANOR BLK A LT 8 380980000A0080000 B 8/02 81,500 82,320 81,500 1.0101 HEARTHSTONE MANOR BLK A LOT 9 380980000A0090000 B 6/02 73,000 75,570 73,000 1.0352 IMPRESSIONS BLK B PT LOT 19 381110500B0190000 B 6/02 88,900 86,180 88,900 .9694 IMPRESSIONS REP BLK B LT 36 381110500B0360000 B 5/02 78,900 80,390 78,900 1.0189 IMPRESSIONS REP BLK B LOT 41 381110500B0410000 B 7/02 70,000 70,000 70,000 1.0000 TOWN EAST ESTATES 3 BLK 4 LT 2 38207750040200000 B 10/02 77,125 76,960 77,125 .9979 TOWN EAST ESTATES 3 BLK 4 LT 2 38207750040260000 B 7/02 71,000 71,000 71,000 1.0000 TOWNE CENTRE VILLAGE PH 2 REP 382158100A04A0000 B 9/02 73,000 69,010 73,000 .9453 TOWNE CENTRE VILLAGE PH 2 REP 382158100B06A0000 B 6/02 85,500 70,620 85,500 .8260 TOWNE CENTRE VILLAGE PH 2 REP 382158100C01A0000 B 6/02 75,000 74,060 75,000 .9875 TOWNE CENTRE VILLAGE PH 2 REP 382158100C09A0000 B 7/02 85,000 74,060 85,000 .8713 TOWNE CENTRE VILLAGE PH 2 REP 382158100D06A0000 B 12/02 74,000 69,010 74,000 .9326 VILLAGE EAST SEC B BLK C LOT 6 382265200C06A0000 B 11/02 72,000 69,080 72,000 .9594 VILLAGE EAST SEC B BLK C LT 12 382265200C12B0000 B 6/02 72,800 71,260 72,800 .9788 VILLAGE EAST SEC B BLK C LOT 1 382265200C16B0000 B 4/02 75,000 72,650 75,000 .9687 VILLAGE EAST SEC B BLK E LOT 1 382265200E14A0000 B 8/02 77,000 74,770 77,000 .9710 VILLAGE EAST SEC B BLK F LOT 1 382265200F01B0000 B 8/02 80,000 79,780 80,000 .9973

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 95 TIME: 13:38 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-914 Mesquite CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ VILLAGE EAST SEC B BLK F LT 6B 382265200F06B0000 B 7/02 72,900 71,870 72,900 .9859 WINDSOR MANOR 2 REV BLK F LT 2 382405600F0220000 B 5/02 71,500 70,260 71,500 .9827 MESQUITE 65006145010770100 C 1/02 99,900 99,900 99,900 1.0000 26 SALES CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD APPR TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER MOD OBS VALUE APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ASSOCIATED BUS DIST 380001500A0020000 1.00 .00 4,499,460 5,026,000 .9000 CAMELOT 380187500101R0000 1.00 .00 15,867,260 16,294,000 .9700 CREEK VILLAGE 380541000A0010000 1.00 .00 10,050,000 11,311,000 .8900 ECHELON AT MISSION RANCH 380750000A0010000 1.00 .00 18,000,000 18,329,000 .9800 EL ROSA 38082500220010000 1.00 .00 4,207,810 3,994,000 1.0500 EL ROSA 38082500220020000 1.00 .00 4,114,870 4,169,000 .9900 FAIRWAYS AT MESQUITE 380874500A0010000 1.00 .00 12,594,470 12,181,000 1.0300 GALLOWAY PLAZA 380925800A0020000 1.00 .00 6,208,000 6,809,000 .9100 MESQUITE APTS 38124000000040000 1.00 .00 12,000,000 10,072,000 1.1900 MESQUITE APTS 38124020000030000 1.00 .00 9,896,550 9,408,000 1.0500 TOWN CROSSING 381260000A0040000 1.00 .00 10,625,000 11,100,000 .9600 TOWN CENTRE 382159000B0010000 1.00 .00 8,323,000 9,218,000 .9000 TOWN CROSSING 382160000A0040000 1.00 .00 9,250,000 9,250,000 1.0000 TRAILS REP 382165600001D0000 1.00 .00 4,677,130 4,637,000 1.0100 14 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9832 CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 550 LAWSON RD. 00881700001340100M C 5/02 435,000 374,480 357,450 1.0500 2233 FRANKLIN DR. 380411000A01R0000 C 2/02 3,552,020 3,461,240 3,552,020 .9700 103 GROSS RD. 380575300A0010000 C 2/02 1,050,000 1,230,290 1,050,000 1.1700

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 96 TIME: 13:38 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-914 Mesquite CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 4356 N. GALLOWAY AVE. 38120820010040000 C 8/02 1,550,000 1,651,380 1,550,000 1.0700 920 E. HWY 80 381345700A0020000 C 2/02 2,203,108 2,203,100 2,203,108 1.0000 2033 MILITARY PKWY. 38193150010300000M C 5/02 500,000 453,200 453,200 1.0000 104 N. PEACHTREE RD. 38193150010320000M C 5/02 557,500 531,310 510,310 1.0400 4018 IH 30 38211500010120000 C 8/02 660,000 660,000 660,000 1.0000 4100 W. IH 30 382115000830R0000 C 1/02 400,000 441,730 400,000 1.1000 1418 N. TOWN EAST BLVD. 382143000D01R0000 C 5/02 1,590,000 1,590,010 1,590,000 1.0000 3600 GUS THOMASSON 382160000C0010000 C 5/02 7,350,000 7,350,000 7,350,000 1.0000 11 SALES CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 4202 PIONEER RD 12079600000010000 .00 1.00 .00 1,878,870 2,225,609 .8400 120 MAIN ST 38000500020110000 .00 1.00 .00 1,543,070 1,642,038 .9400 200 US HWY 80 380034800104R0000 .00 1.00 .00 11,600,000 11,960,900 .9700 915 TOWN EAST BLVD 380437500A0040000 .00 1.00 .00 5,294,260 5,200,472 1.0200 1765 TOWN EAST BLVD 380858900B0100000 .00 1.00 .00 7,408,310 7,757,940 .9500 1515 TOWN EAST BLVD 380859000A01A0000 .00 1.00 .00 27,033,430 27,885,790 .9700 3330 GALLOWAY AVE 380926100A0030000 .00 1.00 .00 8,821,930 8,535,950 1.0300 18885 LBY FRWY 381241000B0040000 .00 1.00 .00 10,059,510 9,916,297 1.0100 1420 PEACHTREE RD 381431000A03R0000 .00 1.00 .00 1,497,020 1,607,415 .9300 18690 LBJ FRWY 382143000A0030000 .00 1.00 .00 2,377,400 2,447,621 .9700 2736 TOWNE CENTRE DR 382143000B0020000 .00 1.00 .00 365,230 394,480 .9300 18601 LBY FRWY 38215600010010000 .00 1.00 .00 5,210,830 5,188,900 1.0000 1800 TOWN EAST BLVD 65109509610010000 .00 1.00 .00 101,166,160 100,308,215 1.0100 1620 TOWN EAST BLVD 65109509610120000 .00 1.00 .00 10,057,590 10,296,554 .9800 6300 GUS THOMASSON RD 65146262810210500 .00 1.00 .00 7,160,480 7,150,000 1.0000 15 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0042 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ NICHOLS JEWELERS 99000000116285000 60,075 60,075 1.0000 ALBERTSON'S 99000000145155000 2,472,764 2,251,751 1.1000 TOYS R US 99000000162785000 1,672,613 1,616,554 1.0300

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 97 TIME: 13:38 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-914 Mesquite CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ MINTER ELECTRIC 99200101700031300 123,504 161,729 .7600 FAMILY DOLLAR 99200108500050650 162,503 160,977 1.0100 WALMART 99200121400113750 2,608,224 2,552,930 1.0200 RENTWAY 99200126700020600 578,945 779,620 .7400 DRYPERS 99200203100033750 100,000 123,180 .8100 GE SILICONES 99200203100033800 100,000 100,000 1.0000 TIESO PAVING 99813640000458900 4,200,327 6,032,866 .7000 KROGER 99813640000478250 2,034,578 1,858,522 1.0900 DILLARD'S 99830030000316500 6,693,428 6,410,966 1.0400 NAPA DIST. CTR. 99830030000395250 8,349,776 7,519,023 1.1100 UPS 99850630000028300 12,234,102 12,233,417 1.0000 ALBERTSON'S 99872150000116600 2,185,418 2,121,383 1.0300 MERVYN'S 99872150000120950 1,764,019 1,502,940 1.1700 KROGER 99872890000004700 1,038,233 905,860 1.1500 FOLEY'S 99882170000149650 5,971,293 5,411,935 1.1000 J C PENNEY 99882170000160950 7,659,320 7,071,768 1.0800 PEP BOYS DIST. CTR 99892330000180650 20,691,566 20,447,198 1.0100 CLAIRE'S BOUTIQUE 99892330000193500 57,649 50,356 1.1400 J E H CO 99902190000038550 583,637 579,696 1.0100 MEDICAL CENTER OF MESQUITE 99902190000059100 8,157,352 7,928,967 1.0300 BURLINGTON COAT FACTORY 99922950000194400 2,044,913 1,984,213 1.0300 HILEY CARS 99933490000087350 830,181 764,449 1.0900 WALGREEN 99962980000104050 1,220,388 1,161,623 1.0500 24 HR FITNESS 99962980000104700 740,035 649,172 1.1400 SOUPER SALAD 99962980000133200 93,054 91,118 1.0200 MARDEL'S 99980280000182350 881,356 868,234 1.0200 29 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9847