Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   1/22/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:     48
TIME:     13:38                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             057  Dallas
                                                         057-909  Garland

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  ANCHOR POINT BLK 2  LT 6         26004600200060000          B       5/02        145,000         127,180       145,000     .8771
  ARAPAHO EAST 1 REV BLK 1 LOT 3   26013500010030000          B       9/02        106,000         106,190       106,000    1.0018
  ARAPAHO EAST 4 BLK 2 LOT 15      26016600020150000          B      11/02        112,270         112,270       112,270    1.0000
  BUCKINGHAM VILLAGE ESTATES 1 B   26063500010160000          B       8/02         89,000          82,720        89,000     .9294
  BULLOCK ESTATES BLK 1  LOT 23    26069500010230000          B       8/02        108,000         107,010       108,000     .9908
  CENTURY PARK BLK 3 LOT 1         26086500030010000          B       3/03        126,500         106,720       126,500     .8436
  CENTURY PARK BLK 8 LT 8          26086500080080000          B       8/02        110,500         107,190       110,500     .9700
  CENTURY PARK BLK 9 LT 0015       26086500090150000          B      11/02        121,000         129,420       121,000    1.0696
  CENTURY PARK 3 BLK 1 LOT 7       26086700010070000          B       2/03         95,000         116,080        95,000    1.2219
  CLUB COUNTRY BLK 13  LT 19       26092700130190000          B      11/02        164,000         159,820       164,000     .9745
  CLUB CREEK BLK 2 LOT 16          26092750020160000          B       9/02        257,500         250,160       257,500     .9715
  FAIRWAYS AT FIREWHEEL BLK 1 LT   26117600010130000          B       7/02        325,000         326,110       325,000    1.0034
  FAIRWAYS AT FIREWHEEL BLK 1 LT   26117600010240000          B       9/02        370,430         370,960       370,430    1.0014
  FAIRWAYS AT FIREWHEEL BLK 3 LT   26117600030190000          B      12/02        280,000         294,000       280,000    1.0500
  CREST RIDGE ESTATES 2 BLK 1 LO   26123500010130000          B       4/02         65,505          70,780        65,505    1.0805
  CREST RIDGE ESTATES 2 BLK 8 LO   26123500080090000          B       4/02         86,500          89,700        86,500    1.0370
  EAST PARK VILLAGE 1      LT 00   26162600030240000          B       6/02        114,900         110,760       114,900     .9640
  ENGLISH ESTATES BLK 9 LOT 2      26168500090020000          B       5/02         98,000         100,960        98,000    1.0302
  ENGLISH ESTATES 2 BLK 15 LOT 6   26169500150060000          B      12/02        100,000          98,440       100,000     .9844
  FIREWHEEL FARMS NO 4 BLK 3 LT    26179330030350000          B       4/02        165,750         167,120       165,750    1.0083
  FIREWHEEL ESTATES 8 BLK 1 LT 1   26179350010180000          B       5/02        310,400         309,570       310,400     .9973
  FIREWHEEL ESTATES 6 BLK 3 LT 7   26179360030070000          B       3/03        245,000         212,520       245,000     .8674
  FIREWHEEL ESTATES 2 BLK 1 LT 3   26179430010340000          B       8/02        253,895         250,000       253,895     .9847
  FIREWHEEL ESTATES 2 BLK 2 LOT    26179430020220000          B       4/02        165,000         173,240       165,000    1.0499
  FIREWHEEL FARMS 5 BLK 10 LT 3    26179530100030000          B      12/02        222,000         232,180       222,000    1.0459
  GARLAND GROVES BLK F LOT 7       26203500060070000          B       2/03         85,000          83,850        85,000     .9865
  GLENBROOK MEADOWS 2ND SEC BLK    26238500050010000          B      12/02        126,400         129,320       126,400    1.0231
  GLENBROOK MEADOWS 3RD SEC 000U   26238600210060000          B       7/02        145,000         144,640       145,000     .9975
  GLENBROOK MEADOWS 5 PH 1 BLK 3   26238900030130000          B      11/02        103,000         141,630       103,000    1.3750
  GLENBROOK MEADOWS 6 BLK 14  LO   26238920140400000          B      12/02        146,250         134,510       146,250     .9197
  GOLDEN MEADOWS 8 BLK 17 LOT 11   26249600170110000          B       9/02        114,900         117,560       114,900    1.0232
  GREENBROOK ESTATES BLK 12 LOT    26252500120130000          B       4/02        107,900         107,480       107,900     .9961
  HIGH MEADOWS 2 BLK 4 LT 1        26255010040010000          B       9/02         94,000          91,410        94,000     .9724
  HIGH MEADOWS 2 BLK 4  LT  28     26255010040280000          B       6/02         93,500          91,280        93,500     .9763
  HIGHCREST BLK 1 LOT 20           26262600010200000          B      11/02        124,000         119,960       124,000     .9674
  HILLS AT FIREWHEEL 1 BLK 7 LT    26264200070180000          B       6/02        193,000         194,490       193,000    1.0077
  HOLIDAY PARK NORTH 2 REV BLK 1   26268500170110000          B       4/02         93,000          94,980        93,000    1.0213
  HOLIDAY PARK NORTH 3 REV 0004    26269500040420000          B       9/02         96,800          88,510        96,800     .9144
  HOLIDAY PARK NORTH 4 BLK 1 LOT   26270500010190000          B       9/02         92,500          74,900        92,500     .8097
  HOLIDAY PARK NORTH 6 BLK K LT    26272500110110000          B       9/02        104,750         112,400       104,750    1.0730
  HUBBARD HILL 2 BLK 6 LOT 20      26275550060200000          B       3/03        143,000         164,940       143,000    1.1534
  HUNTINGTON PARK BLK 1 LOT 4      26276600010040000          B       5/02        112,000         122,550       112,000    1.0942
  LAKE CREST PARK 2 BLK 6 LOT 9    26296800060090000          B       9/02         93,500          94,490        93,500    1.0106
  LAKERIDGE 1 BLK 2 LT 1           26297500020010000          B       5/02        141,000         135,870       141,000     .9636
  LAKESIDE MEADOWS ESTATES 1 BLK   26299500020100000          B       6/02         91,000         107,700        91,000    1.1835
  LAKESIDE MEADOWS ESTATES 6 BLK   26303500060330000          B       7/02        170,000         131,180       170,000     .7716
  LAKEVIEW VILLAGE 2 BLK 6 LOT 1   26306620060130000          B      11/02        135,000         134,740       135,000     .9981

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 49 TIME: 13:38 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-909 Garland CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LAKEWOOD 1 BLK D LOT 6 26307500040060000 B 3/03 75,800 66,010 75,800 .8708 LA PRADA 1 BLK 10 LT 21 26308600100210000 B 7/02 124,500 125,950 124,500 1.0116 LA PRADA 5 LOT 29 BLK 3 26309100030290000 B 5/02 164,900 170,380 164,900 1.0332 MARYLAND LOT 71 26322500000710000 B 7/02 69,900 72,650 69,900 1.0393 MEADOWCREEK COURT BLK 2 LT 30 26333450020300000 B 3/03 110,250 110,770 110,250 1.0047 MEADOWCREEK PARK 4 BLK L LT 2 26336500120290000 B 11/02 107,900 84,020 107,900 .7787 MEADOWCREEK PARK 5TH SEC BLK 3 26337500030240000 B 9/02 110,000 120,800 110,000 1.0982 MEADOWCREEK PARK 7TH SEC BLK 6 26339500060060000 B 9/02 90,000 74,450 90,000 .8272 MEADOW CREST ESTATES BLK 4 LOT 26343720040040000 B 4/02 182,500 185,530 182,500 1.0166 MEADOW CREST ESTATES BLK 5 LOT 26343720050130000 B 7/02 200,000 198,100 200,000 .9905 MEADOWLARK ESTATES 2 BLK F LOT 26345500060080000 B 11/02 130,000 107,770 130,000 .8290 MEADOWOOD 1 BLK 1 LT 23 26346000010230000 B 11/02 117,383 114,410 117,383 .9747 MILL CREEK CROSSING 1 BLK 1 LT 26346650010100000 B 1/03 123,000 121,790 123,000 .9902 MONICA PARK 1 BLK 4 LT 12 26352500040120000 B 9/02 78,000 66,570 78,000 .8535 MONICA PARK 2 BLK13 LT 38 26353500130380000 B 4/02 83,000 80,800 83,000 .9735 MONICA PARK 4 BLK 17 LT 27 26355500170270000 B 3/03 94,000 88,350 94,000 .9399 MONTCLAIR 2 BLK 4 LT 8 26365500040080000 B 8/02 102,500 102,820 102,500 1.0031 NEW WEST 2 BLK 12 LOT 12 26379500120120000 B 4/02 108,000 115,751 108,000 1.0718 NEW WORLD 1 BLK 20 LT 22 26383500200220000 B 9/02 101,500 89,750 101,500 .8842 NEW WORLD 2 BLK 29 LOT 5 26384500290050000 B 7/02 98,000 100,190 98,000 1.0223 NORTHLAKE ESTATES 2 BLK 10 LT 26396500100130000 B 8/02 55,000 70,050 55,000 1.2736 NORTHLAKE ESTATES 6 BLK C LT 3 26400500030310000 B 7/02 102,900 85,980 102,900 .8356 NORTHLAKE ESTATES 6 BLK C LOT 26400500030340000 B 5/02 99,500 96,760 99,500 .9725 NORTHLAKE ESTATES 6 BLK D LOT 26400500040170000 B 1/03 99,900 98,110 99,900 .9821 NORTHLAKE ESTATES 7 BLK K LT 26402500110050000 B 8/02 96,000 86,730 96,000 .9034 NORTHLAKE ESTATES 8 BLK O LOT 26403500150180000 B 11/02 103,500 94,390 103,500 .9120 NORTHLAKE ESTATES 9 BLK Q LT 5 26404500170050000 B 5/02 97,000 88,690 97,000 .9143 NORTHLAKE ESTATES 9 BLK R LT 3 26404500180300000 B 7/02 96,500 95,240 96,500 .9869 NORTH STAR ESTATES 1 BLK C LOT 26406500030010000 B 12/02 99,900 99,500 99,900 .9960 NORTH STAR WEST ESTATES 5TH SE 26414500120090000 B 1/03 111,900 114,710 111,900 1.0251 NORTH STAR WEST ESTATES 7TH SE 26415700090060000 B 7/02 133,000 129,440 133,000 .9732 OAKRIDGE 1 BLK 3 LOT 19 26421580030190000 B 10/02 160,000 163,000 160,000 1.0188 OAKS 1 BLK 11 LT 15 26421600110150000 B 5/02 122,000 119,610 122,000 .9804 OAKS 7 BLK 3 LT 12 26421930030120000 B 3/03 114,000 110,120 114,000 .9660 OAKS AT STONEY CREEK 1 BLK 1 L 26422000010210000 B 4/02 302,000 302,000 302,000 1.0000 ORCHARD HILLS ESTATES 3 BLK 15 26429500150080000 B 9/02 147,000 143,890 147,000 .9788 ORCHARD HILLS ESTATES 4 BLK 6 26430500060020000 B 3/03 88,500 88,470 88,500 .9997 PICKETT PLACE BLK 11 LT 2 26449450110020000 B 10/02 94,500 95,710 94,500 1.0128 QUAIL CREEK 1 BLK 6 LT 14 26458500060140000 B 11/02 90,000 90,880 90,000 1.0098 QUAIL CREEK 2 REP BLK 7 LOT 15 26460570070150000 B 4/02 80,900 84,020 80,900 1.0386 QUAIL CREEK 2 REP BLK 7 LOT 17 26460570070170000 B 8/02 92,500 93,160 92,500 1.0071 QUAIL CREEK 2 REP BLK 7 LOT 31 26460570070310000 B 4/02 89,900 87,730 89,900 .9759 QUAIL CREEK 3 BLK 16 LT 26 26461500160260000 B 11/02 86,000 85,600 86,000 .9953 RICHLAND MEADOWS BLK F LOT 9 26482500060090000 B 5/02 131,000 134,080 131,000 1.0235 RIDGEWOOD ESTATES 1 BLK 10 LOT 26485500100230000 B 5/02 109,900 104,760 109,900 .9532 RIDGEWOOD PARK BLK D LOT 28 26490500040280000 B 7/02 220,000 222,380 220,000 1.0108 RIDGEWOOD PARK 5 BLK A LT 17 26494500010170000 B 3/03 133,000 138,500 133,000 1.0414

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 50 TIME: 13:38 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-909 Garland CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ SATURN SPRINGS ESTATES 2 BLK G 26510500070060000 B 5/02 134,400 133,410 134,400 .9926 SHORES OF EASTERN HILLS 1 BLK 26521400070280000 B 9/02 182,500 175,080 182,500 .9593 SHORES OF EASTERN HILLS 1 BLK 26521400080120000 B 10/02 174,500 174,690 174,500 1.0011 SHORES OF EASTERN HILLS 2 BLK 26521400080240000 B 10/02 213,000 192,020 213,000 .9015 SHOREHAVEN 7 BLK 15 LOT 33 26527500150330000 B 11/02 90,000 73,280 90,000 .8142 SHOREHAVEN 8 BLK 21 LOT 22 26528500210220000 B 11/02 85,000 76,510 85,000 .9001 SHORES OF WELLINGTON 2 BLK 9 L 26531600090070000 B 7/02 174,000 169,030 174,000 .9714 SKILLMAN FOREST 2 BLK 16 LT 6 26534500160060000 B 9/02 90,900 88,800 90,900 .9769 SOUTHGATE ACRES 1 BLK 2 LOT 24 26560500020240000 B 6/02 156,900 151,880 156,900 .9680 SOUTHGATE ACRES 1 BLK 3 LOT 7 26560500030070000 B 7/02 108,000 139,810 108,000 1.2945 SOUTHGATE ESTATES BLK 5 LT 22 26562500050220000 B 11/02 125,000 122,980 125,000 .9838 SPRINGFIELD ESTATES 2 BLK 1 LT 26578650010300000 B 11/02 155,000 138,250 155,000 .8919 SPRINGFIELD ESTATES 3 BLK 2 LT 26578670020110000 B 6/02 174,490 171,320 174,490 .9818 STAR CREST ESTATES 3 BLK 7 LO 26583500070160000 B 10/02 90,500 107,770 90,500 1.1908 STAR CREST ESTATES 5 LT 0 26585500180030000 B 11/02 100,500 110,260 100,500 1.0971 SUMMERFIELD REVISED BLK 1 LT 2 26587300010260000 B 5/02 151,990 171,800 151,990 1.1303 TOWNGATE 75 BLK 2 LT 1 26604500020010000 B 5/02 95,900 79,580 95,900 .8298 TOWNGATE 75 BLK 3 LT 7 26604500030070000 B 10/02 81,000 67,960 81,000 .8390 TWO WORLDS APOLLO 1 BLK 1 LOT 26613500010010000 B 7/02 100,000 102,640 100,000 1.0264 TWO WORLDS APOLLO 1 BLK 0003 26613500030050000 B 9/02 62,900 69,600 62,900 1.1065 VILLAGE GLEN 1 BLK 4 LOT 45 26621700040450000 B 2/03 108,000 99,990 108,000 .9258 VILLAGES OF VALLEY CREEK 1 BLK 26625000010340000 B 3/03 100,000 92,090 100,000 .9209 VILLAGES OF VALLEY CREEK 9 BLK 26625080100030000 B 1/03 161,000 173,550 161,000 1.0780 VILLAGES OF VALLEY CREEK 12 BL 26625120030190000 B 11/02 205,000 201,060 205,000 .9808 WALNUT PARK ESTATES BLK 4 LOT 26642500040040000 B 6/02 130,000 132,370 130,000 1.0182 WATERFORD ESTATES BLK 4 LT 2 26657650040020000 B 8/02 198,405 181,100 198,405 .9128 WELLINGTON RUN 1 BLK 2 LT 11 26659000020110000 B 11/02 171,000 162,270 171,000 .9489 WESTERN HEIGHTS 3 BLK 13 LOT 26667500130350000 B 11/02 96,000 99,370 96,000 1.0351 WESTERN HEIGHTS 4 BLK 30A LOT 26668500300250000 B 2/03 94,900 90,540 94,900 .9541 WEST SHORE ESTATES 3 REP BLK A 26671740500340000 B 9/02 146,500 143,640 146,500 .9805 WILLIAMS ESTATES 1 BLK B LOT 7 26678500020070000 B 11/02 280,000 280,260 280,000 1.0009 WILLIAMS ESTATES 1 BLK F LOT 7 26678500060070000 B 8/02 87,500 79,790 87,500 .9119 WILLIAMS ESTATES 2 BLK M LOT 1 26679500130100000 B 10/02 86,500 88,490 86,500 1.0230 WINDSOR PARK 3 BLK 3 LT 14 26680410030140000 B 9/02 138,000 137,930 138,000 .9995 WINDSOR PARK 3 BLK 5 LOT 6 26680410050060000 B 4/02 140,000 139,820 140,000 .9987 WINDRIDGE 1 REP BLK 3 LOT 8A 26683600030080000 B 8/02 142,650 135,660 142,650 .9510 WOOD BEND BLK 5 LOT 15 26683640050150000 B 12/02 102,000 104,950 102,000 1.0289 WOOD BEND BLK 5 LOT 18 26683640050180000 B 9/02 114,000 118,400 114,000 1.0386 COLLEGE PARK BLK 9 LT 2 44001280090020000 B 6/02 110,900 104,910 110,900 .9460 COLLEGE PARK 2 BLK H LT 23 440012900H0230000 B 12/02 116,000 112,770 116,000 .9722 COUNTRY AIRE ESTATES SEC 1 BLK 44001300020070000 B 11/02 122,900 98,580 122,900 .8021 DALROCK ESTATES BLK 8 LOT 8 44001400080080000 B 1/03 109,080 97,470 109,080 .8936 DALROCK HEIGHTS BLK H LOT 5 440014100H0050000 B 5/02 176,500 177,350 176,500 1.0048 FLOWER HILL 1 BLK 5 LOT 4 44001550050040000 B 6/02 131,000 132,930 131,000 1.0147 FLOWER HILL 2 BLK 14 LT 8 44001560140080000 B 6/02 131,000 134,190 131,000 1.0244 FLOWER HILL 2 BLK 14 LOT 15 44001560140150000 B 10/02 127,000 123,770 127,000 .9746 FLOWER HILL 3 BLK 2 LOT 25 44001570020250000 B 5/02 116,900 114,940 116,900 .9832

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 51 TIME: 13:38 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-909 Garland CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ FLOWER HILL 3 BLK 7 LOT 7 44001570070070000 B 12/02 116,000 111,550 116,000 .9616 FLOWER HILL 3 BLK 12 LT 17 44001570120170000 B 2/03 117,000 112,880 117,000 .9648 HARBORVIEW 1 BLK 7 LT 20 44001910070200000 B 9/02 156,500 150,710 156,500 .9630 HARBORVIEW 1 BLK 8 LOT 19 44001910080190000 B 3/03 149,350 155,360 149,350 1.0402 KENWOOD HEIGHTS 1 BLK 2 LT 21 44004500020210000 B 8/02 93,500 94,540 93,500 1.0111 KENWOOD HEIGHTS 3 BLK 3 LT 26 44006600030260000 B 12/02 70,000 87,440 70,000 1.2491 KENWOOD HEIGHTS 3 BLK 12 LT 8 44006600120080000 B 1/03 99,500 92,350 99,500 .9281 LAKEVIEW MEADOWS ESTATES SEC 1 44013500050020000 B 1/03 77,500 103,540 77,500 1.3360 LIBERTY CREEK BLK A LT 1 440141900A0010000 B 2/03 230,000 229,200 230,000 .9965 MAGNOLIA SPRINGS PH 2A & 2B BL 440142900C0150000 B 4/02 157,800 188,356 157,800 1.1936 MARINERS COVE PH 1 BLK B LT 40 440143500B0400000 B 4/02 198,950 210,110 198,950 1.0561 MARINER PARK SEC 1 BLK B LT 34 440144000B0340000 B 2/03 189,900 182,510 189,900 .9611 MARINER PARK SEC 1 BLK F LT 2 440144000F0020000 B 10/02 163,770 168,190 163,770 1.0270 MARINER PARK SEC 2 BLK I LT 6 440144000I0060000 B 9/02 205,000 187,510 205,000 .9147 PENINSULA 3B REP BLK E LT 10 440161700E0100000 B 8/02 125,900 119,500 125,900 .9492 PENINSULA 4 PH B REP BLK D LOT 440162100D0140000 B 2/03 150,000 145,200 150,000 .9680 PENINSULA 7 BLK A LT 6 440162500A0060000 B 3/03 149,600 151,200 149,600 1.0107 PENINSULA 7 BLK A LT 14 440162500A0140000 B 2/03 148,000 169,980 148,000 1.1485 PRINCETON PARK PH 1A BLK 7 LOT 44016400070290000 B 12/02 113,950 104,160 113,950 .9141 PRINCETON PARK PH 3 BLK 7 LT 4 44016420070400000 B 5/02 121,900 108,090 121,900 .8867 PRINCETON PARK PH 3 LK 11 LT 44016420110100000 B 7/02 115,360 107,850 115,360 .9349 PRINCETON POINTE PH 1A REP BLK 440164300C0040000 B 8/02 107,000 96,590 107,000 .9027 SPINNAKER COVE BLK 10 LOT 21 44021700100210000 B 4/02 119,000 108,860 119,000 .9148 SPRINGFIELD SEC 2 BLK 2 LOT 16 44022260020160000 B 4/02 133,500 131,930 133,500 .9882 SPRINGFIELD SEC 4 BLK 4 LOT 2 44022280040200000 B 4/02 139,000 143,790 139,000 1.0345 SPRINGFIELD SEC 4 BLK 12 LOT 9 44022280120090000 B 6/02 182,400 191,970 182,400 1.0525 SPRINGFIELD SEC 5A BLK 3 LT 3 44022290030030000 B 4/02 115,500 108,940 115,500 .9432 SPRINGFIELD SEC 5A BLK 9 LT 1 44022290090010000 B 5/02 117,500 115,730 117,500 .9849 SPRINGFIELD SEC 5A BLK 10 LOT 44022290100080000 B 11/02 128,500 128,150 128,500 .9973 SPRINGFIELD 6 BLK E LT 6 440223000E0060000 B 1/03 130,000 133,920 130,000 1.0302 SPRINGFIELD ESTATES PH A BLK E 440224000E0090000 B 5/02 165,000 155,420 165,000 .9419 SPRINGFIELD ESTATES PH A BLK F 440224000F0010000 B 7/02 185,000 182,500 185,000 .9865 SPRINGFIELD ESTATES PH B BLK C 440224100C0160000 B 10/02 152,500 162,050 152,500 1.0626 SPRINGFIELD ESTATES PH B BLK K 440224100K0210000 B 5/02 162,500 156,450 162,500 .9628 SPRINGTREE ESTATES BLK B LT 27 440224300B0270000 B 4/02 161,990 167,730 161,990 1.0354 PENINSULA BLK A LT 5 440227000A0050000 B 6/02 111,780 112,330 111,780 1.0049 PENINSULA 2 BLK F LT 15 440227200F0150000 B 12/02 79,100 78,230 79,100 .9890 TOLER RIDGE 2 BLK 4 LOT 17 44023050040170000 B 11/02 119,900 121,600 119,900 1.0142 WATERVIEW PH 2 BLK GG LT 17 44023560GG0170000 B 8/02 178,500 180,030 178,500 1.0086 WATERVIEW PH 4B BLK A LT 14 440235600A0140000 B 10/02 149,900 162,078 149,900 1.0812 WATERVIEW PH 4A BLK A LT 82 440235600A0820000 B 2/03 156,000 160,620 156,000 1.0296 WATERVIEW PH 4A BLK D LT 19 440235600D0190000 B 3/03 137,000 126,310 137,000 .9220 WESTWOOD SHORES PH 1 BLK C LT 440236300C0030000 B 8/02 225,000 204,860 225,000 .9105 WESTWOOD SHORES PH 1 BLK D LT 440236300D0070000 B 5/02 279,000 246,940 279,000 .8851 WESTWOOD SHORES PH 2 BLK E LT 440236300E0270000 B 2/03 255,000 243,950 255,000 .9567 WESTWOOD ESTATES 6 BLK 4 LOT 5 44023640040050000 B 5/02 155,000 147,067 155,000 .9488 WINNERS CIRCLE BLK B LT 30 440240100B0300000 B 12/02 225,000 206,700 225,000 .9187

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 52 TIME: 13:38 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-909 Garland CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BROOKVIEW ESTATES PH 2 BLK C L 480012000C0070000 B 11/02 95,790 95,250 95,790 .9944 JOHN C HERRING BLK 2 LOT 4 48001500020040000 B 5/02 106,000 92,370 106,000 .8714 HUDSON CROSSING PH 1 BLK F LT 480031000F0040000 B 12/02 139,900 134,220 139,900 .9594 HUNTERS RIDGE BLK G LOT 16 480032500G0160000 B 3/03 129,500 120,720 129,500 .9322 PEACHTREE ESTATES PH 2 BLK 6 L 48004580060060000 B 9/02 128,500 113,570 128,500 .8838 SALMON ESTATES 8 BLK C LT 39 480113900C0390000 B 1/03 104,900 108,190 104,900 1.0314 SHEPERDS GLEN 2 BLK 6 LT 29 48011420060290000 B 2/03 135,000 120,420 135,000 .8920 WOODBRIDGE PH 2C BLK P LT 11 480160200P0110000 B 2/03 232,200 257,090 232,200 1.1072 PLEASANT VALLEY RANCH ESTATES 60158500020080000 B 6/02 172,000 171,810 172,000 .9989 J L ANDERSON ABST 25 PG 187 TR 65002518710170000 B 2/03 109,500 88,200 109,500 .8055 HANSE HAMILTON ABST 548 PG 595 65054859510110000 B 3/03 36,000 72,000 36,000 2.0000 CHARLES D MERRELL ABST 957 PG 65095785810410000 B 10/02 81,950 82,000 81,950 1.0006 200 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9843 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ COLLEGE MANORS BLK 3 LOT 1 26095500030010000 B 3/03 81,600 71,610 81,600 .8776 COLLEGE MANORS BLK 4 LT 15 26095500040150000 B 9/02 125,000 79,440 125,000 .6355 COUNTRY BROOK 3 BLK 4 LT 104 26105820041040000 B 6/02 95,000 79,560 95,000 .8375 COUNTRY BROOK 3 BLK 5 LOT 15 26105820050150000 B 10/02 89,000 77,570 89,000 .8716 COUNTRY BROOK 3 BLK 5 LOT 17 26105820050170000 B 6/02 90,000 83,350 90,000 .9261 COUNTRY BROOK SOUTH 1 BLK 2 LO 26105840020290000 B 8/02 103,000 95,630 103,000 .9284 COUNTRY BROOK SOUTH 1 BLK 4 LT 26105840040200000 B 6/02 98,000 83,760 98,000 .8547 COUNTRY BROOK SOUTH 1 BLK 5 LT 26105840050120000 B 12/02 90,000 78,490 90,000 .8721 COUNTRY BROOK SOUTH 1 BLK 5 LO 26105840050240000 B 11/02 96,500 73,900 96,500 .7658 SCOTT GARDENS APTS. 26109900020010000 C 5/02 1,125,000 1,125,000 1,125,000 1.0000 FOREST AT DUCK CREEK BLK 1 LT 26180460010150000 B 12/02 177,000 89,700 177,000 .5068 FOREST AT DUCK CREEK BLK 1 LT 26180460010160000 B 12/02 177,000 89,700 177,000 .5068 NORTH STAR WEST ESTATES 2ND SE 26409500180220000 B 6/02 150,000 110,480 150,000 .7365 OAKRIDGE 10 BLK 3 LT 25 26421760030250000 B 12/02 97,000 104,300 97,000 1.0753 OAKRIDGE 10 BLK 5 LOT 75 26421760050750000 B 11/02 124,000 101,110 124,000 .8154 OAKRIDGE 10 BLK 5 LOT 79 26421760050790000 B 11/02 120,000 109,680 120,000 .9140 OAKRIDGE 10 BLK 5 LOT 82 26421760050820000 B 6/02 116,500 102,000 116,500 .8755 OAKRIDGE 10 BLK 5 LT 95 26421760050950000 B 10/02 118,450 107,670 118,450 .9090 OAKRIDGE 10 BLK 6 LOT 3 26421760060030000 B 10/02 110,000 102,300 110,000 .9300 OAKRIDGE 10 BLK 6 LT 6 26421760060060000 B 3/03 112,000 97,860 112,000 .8738 OAKRIDGE 10 BLK 6 LOT 8 26421760060080000 B 7/02 114,000 100,670 114,000 .8831 OAKRIDGE 10 BLK 6 LOT 13 26421760060130000 B 10/02 114,500 91,000 114,500 .7948 REGAL ESTATES 3 BLK 1 LOT 9 26480620010090000 B 3/03 80,500 71,640 80,500 .8899

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 53 TIME: 13:38 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-909 Garland CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ REGAL ESTATES 3 BLK 2 LT 11 26480620020110000 B 9/02 72,000 72,990 72,000 1.0138 SCHREIBER ESTATES 2 BLK 22 LOT 26512640220010000 B 3/03 90,000 74,370 90,000 .8263 SCHREIBER ESTATES 2 BLK 22 LT 26512640220130000 B 12/02 79,900 74,370 79,900 .9308 SCHREIBER ESTATES 2 BLK 22 LOT 26512640220190000 B 10/02 87,900 71,520 87,900 .8137 SCHREIBER ESTATES 2 BLK 22 LT 26512640220210000 B 5/02 89,500 75,870 89,500 .8477 SCHREIBER ESTATES 2 BLK 23 LT 26512640230300000 B 7/02 84,900 73,240 84,900 .8627 SCHREIBER ESTATES 2 BLK 24 LOT 26512640240200000 B 7/02 87,500 73,240 87,500 .8370 PENINSULA 3A REP BLK B LT 13A 440161800B13A0000 B 5/02 85,500 73,320 85,500 .8575 PENINSULA 3A REP BLK C LT 16B 440161800C16B0000 B 6/02 81,000 76,420 81,000 .9435 BROOKVIEW ESTATES BLK BB LT 4 48001000BB0040000 B 3/03 223,000 188,880 223,000 .8470 BROOKVIEW ESTATES BLK BB LT 5 48001000BB0050000 B 3/03 242,000 202,440 242,000 .8365 BROOKVIEW ESTATES BLK BB LOT 6 48001000BB0060000 B 6/02 205,000 224,730 205,000 1.0962 BROOKVIEW ESTATES BLK BB LT 7 48001000BB0070000 B 3/03 253,000 209,940 253,000 .8298 BROOKVIEW ESTATES BLK BB LOT 9 48001000BB0090000 B 5/02 205,000 205,000 205,000 1.0000 THE KENT APARTMENTS 65040416310190000 C 3/02 920,000 596,150 920,000 .6480 38 SALES CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD APPR TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER MOD OBS VALUE APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BROADWAY APTS 26047400010010000 1.00 .00 9,321,940 9,326,000 1.0000 BROADWAY COMMONS 26047560020010000 1.00 .00 5,611,380 6,731,000 .8300 CENTERVILLE POINTE 26084600010010000 1.00 .00 14,480,940 16,894,000 .8600 EDGEWOOD DRIVE APTS 26163500130010000 1.00 .00 4,790,400 4,825,000 .9900 EQUINOX APTS 26174700010010000 1.00 .00 19,604,000 19,494,000 1.0100 EUROPEAN VILLAGE 26175500010020000 1.00 .00 4,259,060 3,909,000 1.0900 FAULKNER CREEK 26178200010010100 1.00 .00 6,253,430 5,981,000 1.0500 FAULKNER MEADOWS 26178420010010900 1.00 .00 2,591,050 2,758,000 .9400 FAULKNER POINT 26178690010030000 1.00 .00 1,742,620 1,931,000 .9000 GREENTREE APTS 26254800010010000 1.00 .00 6,800,000 6,624,000 1.0300 KINGSLEY ROAD 26294500000010000 1.00 .00 3,000,000 2,979,000 1.0100 NEW WEST 6 26381700010010000 1.00 .00 6,290,690 6,664,000 .9400 OAKRIDGE 26421650011R10000 1.00 .00 12,922,000 13,064,000 .9900 PARK NORTH EST 26445560010010000 1.00 .00 3,485,000 3,183,000 1.0900 STONELEIGH ON SPRING CREEK 26586690010010000 1.00 .00 16,367,830 16,552,000 .9900 VISTA DE LAGO 44023080000010000 1.00 .00 5,760,000 5,231,000 1.1000 BENJAMIN FROST 65048070710190000 1.00 .00 4,750,000 4,516,000 1.0500 17 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9514

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 54 TIME: 13:38 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-909 Garland CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER APPR VAL APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BONITA EST 26041500000170000 44,000 45,000 .9800 BROADWAY WALMART 26051100000100000 343,450 317,028 1.0800 CARMAX IH 635 26079600020020000 670,220 622,343 1.0800 DUCK CREEK EST 26142800030010000 30,000 28,000 1.0700 DUCK CREEK ESTATES 26142800030330000 30,000 28,000 1.0700 ENGLISH EST 26168500030150000 68,090 65,000 1.0500 NORTHLAKE EST 26402500190010000 352,840 352,836 1.0000 SAMPSON EST 26507200010010000 210,000 208,910 1.0100 TRADEMARK/MACFARLAN, BLK 1, LT 26608300010030000 1,923,500 1,790,970 1.0700 WELLINGTON RUN 26659000040270000 25,000 24,000 1.0400 LAKE FOREST EST 440108000A0150000 64,560 60,000 1.0800 WATERVIEW 440235600Z0180000 56,000 55,000 1.0200 WATERVIEW 4402359HHH0330000 35,000 32,000 1.0900 WATERVIEW 44023590II0100000 26,260 27,000 .9700 WATERVIEW PH 11A 440236100F0330000 25,000 27,000 .9300 POT O GOLD GARDENS 60163500000140000 164,970 152,597 1.0800 POT O GOLD GARDENS 60163500000300000 174,240 191,664 .9100 A2, TR 3.1 65000204510030100 2,186,640 2,342,829 .9300 A-26 65002619010090000 393,780 381,440 1.0300 ATKINSON CLEMENTS 65025577510470000 20,650 20,000 1.0300 JOHN CASEY A-256 TR 11 65025678110110000 871,230 1,089,148 .8000 A-542, TR 4 65054255010040000 976,620 941,640 1.0400 A738 65073810510510000 233,700 210,330 1.1100 A-789, TR 12 65078988610120000 549,200 514,879 1.0700 A-791 TR 3 65079189810030000 54,880 54,884 1.0000 A-945 65094502510130000 122,160 137,428 .8900 A-1099 65109912010420000 45,000 41,250 1.0900 A-1241, TR 11 65124141510110000 1,004,460 990,825 1.0100 28 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0096 CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 13701 JUPITER RD. 0080420A0001A0000 C 5/02 2,750,000 2,773,000 2,750,000 1.0100 201 E. BUCKINGHAM RD. 26128500010060000 C 4/02 360,000 394,850 360,000 1.1000 1855 WALL ST. 26209550010050000 C 7/02 350,506 350,510 350,506 1.0000 3728 MARQUIS DR. 26210500020110000 C 7/02 212,000 210,000 212,000 .9906

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 55 TIME: 13:38 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-909 Garland CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 1909 COPPER ST. 26223800010150000 C 12/02 271,000 271,000 271,000 1.0000 2820 MARKET ST. 26278750010010000 C 7/02 1,000,000 1,000,000 1,000,000 1.0000 2713 INDUSTRIAL LN. 26295500020050000 C 9/02 520,000 640,000 520,000 1.2300 2709-2719 NATIONAL CIRCLE 26296500010040300 C 5/02 275,000 270,000 275,000 .9800 2623 NATIONAL CIR. 26296500010060100 C 2/02 627,000 627,000 627,000 1.0000 5701 BROADWAY BLVD. 26296520010010000 C 9/02 2,250,000 2,250,730 2,250,000 1.0000 301 W. CENTERVILLE RD. 26312500010070000 C 1/02 270,000 270,000 270,000 1.0000 3929 FOREST LN. 26423440010010000 C 3/02 240,000 230,000 240,000 .9583 5402 BROADWAY 26476670010010000 C 5/02 355,000 355,000 355,000 1.0000 713-717 S. 5TH ST. 26577500000010000 C 5/02 540,000 572,420 540,000 1.0600 1933 & 1935 E. CENTERVILLE RD. 26616500010020000M C 8/02 376,750 375,750 376,750 1.0000 322 N. BARNES DR. 26629500010010600 C 6/02 325,000 325,000 325,000 1.0000 2121 W. WALNUT ST. 26640640010020000 C 1/02 263,000 278,470 263,000 1.0600 5326 LAKEVIEW 44023500030100000 C 3/02 335,000 346,140 335,000 1.0333 1115 N. 1ST ST. 65003223210310000M C 1/03 200,000 161,340 161,340 1.0000 19 SALES CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 13745 JUPITER RD 00000786868870000 .00 1.00 .00 5,219,000 5,015,680 1.0400 12610 E NORTHWEST HWY 0080480D000040000 .00 1.00 .00 2,360,000 2,506,782 .9400 12670 E NORTHEAST HWY 0080480D0002A0000 .00 1.00 .00 2,899,680 2,323,092 1.2500 1950 PLAZA DR 261620000101R0000 .00 1.00 .00 2,411,950 2,435,000 .9900 1200 S JUPITER RD 26174900010010000 .00 1.00 .00 11,245,180 11,413,918 .9900 1200 S JUPITER RD 26174900010010100 .00 1.00 .00 5,305,490 5,262,509 1.0100 725 S JUPITER RD 26210500030060100 .00 1.00 .00 1,000,000 1,028,491 .9700 3615 SECURITY ST 26280500020070000 .00 1.00 .00 1,429,210 1,216,591 1.1700 3178 STATE HWY 78 26346510010010000 .00 1.00 .00 5,711,000 5,429,400 1.0500 823 W MILLER RD 26349600010020000 .00 1.00 .00 746,340 741,542 1.0100 2220 MERRITT DR 26392600030010000 .00 1.00 .00 4,663,300 4,742,818 .9800 902 NICHOLSON RD 263926100202R0000 .00 1.00 .00 2,537,340 2,533,662 1.0000 1036N INTERNATIONAL RD 26392610030010100 .00 1.00 .00 7,200,000 7,020,940 1.0300 530 INTERNATIONAL RD 263926102R0010000 .00 1.00 .00 3,721,000 3,700,000 1.0100 252 W I - H 30 26422430010010000 .00 1.00 .00 1,000,000 630,945 1.5800 3101 W MILLER RD 26512500000010000 .00 1.00 .00 6,576,150 6,992,845 .9400 1601 W NORTHWEST FRWY 26561600010010000 .00 1.00 .00 766,410 787,260 .9700 3159 S GARLAND AVE 266306600112R0000 .00 1.00 .00 10,229,080 11,132,020 .9200 3002 EDGEWOOD DR 26639500020010100 .00 1.00 .00 909,570 842,527 1.0800 5522 CHIESA RD 440014900A01A0000 .00 1.00 .00 775,000 631,883 1.2300 20 APPRAISALS

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 56 TIME: 13:38 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-909 Garland STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0328 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BOISE CASCADE CORP 99000000018465000 10,300,938 10,547,285 .9800 TOM THUMB 99199929900130350 3,446,254 3,340,492 1.0300 TEXANS CREDIT UNION 99200001000062750 312,810 298,565 1.0500 TOM THUMB 99200021600117800 3,704,180 3,678,630 1.0100 CARPET OUTLETS OF TX 99200029800013850 81,324 81,558 1.0000 INVENTEC APPLIANCES 99200108500119950 3,002,267 2,772,700 1.0800 WALMART SUPERCENTER 99200126700166800 8,939,539 8,903,166 1.0000 SWINCO DISTR. 99813640000372400 261,679 203,720 1.2800 SEARS 99820130000175200 8,951,287 7,956,910 1.1200 ALBERTSON'S 99860020000542700 2,522,791 2,250,980 1.1200 WALMART 99872150000131500 8,477,014 8,336,568 1.0200 SOFTWARE SPECTRUM 99872150000144750 5,862,967 6,708,916 .8700 BIRDS EYE FOODS 99890060000196450 1,464,773 1,464,773 1.0000 SEARS LOGISTICS SVCS 99900800000022600 6,107,662 4,251,787 1.4400 DR PEPPER / 7UP 99902190000041700 641,853 641,853 1.0000 OFFICE DEPOT 99912830000112600 1,117,140 1,238,040 .9000 CHEARLEADER DANZ 99940730000021250 1,837,566 1,828,774 1.0000 ALLIANT FOOD SVC 99950650000001900 19,438,303 19,837,018 .9800 SALLY BEAUTY SUPPLY 99950650000002200 95,300 89,752 1.0600 GULF SOUTH MEDICAL SUPPLY 99950650000201300 3,292,550 3,266,321 1.0100 AARONS RENTS 99952150000151750 690,000 869,081 .7900 EZ MART 99960440000018350 60,782 53,955 1.1300 DAP INC 99971150000095200 3,637,052 3,571,832 1.0200 BUCKINGHAM DENTAL 99982160000154000 61,728 61,728 1.0000 ECKERD 99982600000181200 29,440,022 29,103,025 1.0100 ECKERD 99983420000033850 836,238 817,695 1.0200 CARMAX 99990220000089500 1,001,418 906,717 1.1000 27 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0309