Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   1/22/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:     34
TIME:     13:38                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             057  Dallas
                                                         057-906  DeSoto

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  BRIARWOOD 2 BLK 10 LT 16         20005800100160000          B       6/02        167,000         160,670       167,000     .9621
  BRIARWOOD 2 BLK 14 LOT 30        20005800140300000          B       6/02        158,900         151,800       158,900     .9553
  BRIARWOOD 2 BLK 14  LT 32        20005800140320000          B       5/02        162,250         148,080       162,250     .9127
  BRIARWOOD 2 BLK 16 LOT 5         20005800160050000          B       4/02         99,900         125,040        99,900    1.2517
  BROOK HOLLOW ESTATES 3 BLK 6 L   20008500060020000          B       1/03        105,000         103,240       105,000     .9832
  BROOK HOLLOW ESTATES 3 BLK 8 L   20008500080220000          B       9/02        104,000         107,690       104,000    1.0355
  BROOK HOLLOW ESTATES 4 BLK 10    20009500100150000          B       4/02        106,500         102,760       106,500     .9649
  BROOK HOLLOW ESTATES 5 0011 LT   20010500110240000          B      11/02        110,900         108,900       110,900     .9820
  BROOK HOLLOW ESTATES 5 BLK 11    20010500110280000          B       1/03        123,900         111,170       123,900     .8973
  BROOK HOLLOW ESTATES 5 BLK 12    20010500120110000          B       3/02        114,275         115,730       114,275    1.0127
  BROOK HOLLOW ESTATES 6 BLK 12    20011500120170000          B       5/02         96,000          99,080        96,000    1.0321
  CANDLE MEADOW PH 1 BLK A LT 2    200149100A0020000          B       3/02        257,580         256,850       257,580     .9972
  CEDAR PARK 1ST INST BLK D  LT    20016500040010000          B       8/02        110,000         113,870       110,000    1.0352
  CENTRE ESTATES BLK A LOT 11      200175500A0110000          B       7/02         86,617         105,640        86,617    1.2196
  CENTRE ESTATES BLK A LOT 33      200175500A0330000          B       9/02        115,000         116,610       115,000    1.0140
  CENTRE ESTATES BLK B  LT 4       200175500B0040000          B       3/02        114,900         110,990       114,900     .9660
  CENTRE ESTATES BLK B LOT 6       200175500B0060000          B       9/02        116,500         116,610       116,500    1.0009
  CENTRE ESTATES BLK B LOT 21      200175500B0210000          B      10/02        116,900         116,610       116,900     .9975
  CENTRE ESTATES BLK C LT 1        200175500C0010000          B      12/02        118,500         114,480       118,500     .9661
  CENTRE ESTATES BLK D  LT 33      200175500D0330000          B       5/02         98,500         102,880        98,500    1.0445
  CENTRE ESTATES BLK I LOT 27      200175500I0270000          B       4/02        155,990         151,340       155,990     .9702
  CENTRE ESTATES BLK J LOT 8       200175500J0080000          B       5/02        160,500         159,970       160,500     .9967
  CHAPEL HILL 1 BLK 5 LOT 6 VOL2   20017580050060000          B       3/02        145,000         183,930       145,000    1.2685
  CHAPEL HILL 1 BLK 7  LT 10       20017580070100000          B      10/02        125,000         149,890       125,000    1.1991
  CHAPEL HILL 1 BLK 8 LOT 17       20017580080170000          B       7/02        134,400         137,170       134,400    1.0206
  CHAPEL HILL 1 BLK 9 LOT 34       20017580090340000          B       6/02        155,000         152,220       155,000     .9821
  COUNTRY PLACE ESTATES BLK 1  L   20021500010140000          B      10/02        121,500         121,930       121,500    1.0035
  CREEK TREE ESTATES BLK C    LO   200223500C0130000          B       5/02        144,900         145,020       144,900    1.0008
  CREEK TREE ESTATES BLK D LT 3    200223500D0030000          B       8/02        140,000         131,240       140,000     .9374
  CREEK TREE ESTATES BLK D LOT 1   200223500D0100000          B       1/03        131,000         121,000       131,000     .9237
  CREEK TREE ESTATES BLK E     L   200223500E0160000          B       6/02        149,000         144,160       149,000     .9675
  CREEK TREE ESTATES BLK F  LT 2   200223500F0260000          B      11/02        136,000         143,350       136,000    1.0540
  CREEK TREE ESTATES BLK H LOT 1   200223500H0130000          B       5/02        145,000         149,360       145,000    1.0301
  CREEK TREE ESTATES BLK K LOT 1   200223500K0010000          B       3/02        132,000         116,550       132,000     .8830
  CREEK TREE ESTATES BLK L LOT 1   200223500L0010000          B       8/02        160,000         154,650       160,000     .9666
  CREEK TREE ESTATES PH 3B BLK B   200223700B0250000          B       7/02        196,000         188,900       196,000     .9638
  CREEK TREE ESTATES PH 2 BLK N    200223800N0200000          B       5/02        136,000         135,600       136,000     .9971
  CREEK TREE ESTATES PH 2 BLK N    200223800N0410000          B       4/02        160,000         162,990       160,000    1.0187
  CREEK TREE ESTATES PH 3A REP L   20024400000110000          B       3/03        100,000         126,700       100,000    1.2670
  CRESTWOOD VILLAGE BLK 3 LT 16    20024500030160000          B       1/03         79,900          82,010        79,900    1.0264
  CRYSTAL CREEK RIDGE BLK G LOT    200265200G0220000          B       6/02        137,000         124,790       137,000     .9109
  W C DAVIS SR BLK 2 LOT 11        20027500020110000          B       7/02         79,900          79,680        79,900     .9972
  EAGLE DOWNS PH 2 REP PH 2A BLK   200313100D0180000          B       6/02        135,000         121,110       135,000     .8971
  EAGLE DOWNS PH 2 REP PH 2A BLK   200313100E0220000          B       2/02        119,000         120,950       119,000    1.0164
  EAGLE DOWNS PH 2 REP PH 2A BLK   200313100F0020000          B      10/02        134,900         127,900       134,900     .9481
  EAGLE DOWNS PH 2 REP PH 2B BLK   200313200H0020000          B       5/02        120,400         113,410       120,400     .9419
  EAGLE DOWNS PH 2 REP PH 2B PH    200313200H0050000          B       7/02        134,000         136,710       134,000    1.0202

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 35 TIME: 13:38 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-906 DeSoto CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ EAGLE DOWNS PH 2 REP PH 2B BLK 200313200I0050000 B 8/02 144,000 119,600 144,000 .8306 EAST PARK 2 BLK 4 LOT 9 20032500040090000 B 10/02 92,500 85,630 92,500 .9257 FERN HEIGHTS REP BLK A LOT 19R 200338500A19R0000 B 10/02 104,900 93,070 104,900 .8872 FERN HEIGHTS REP BLK A LOT 21R 200338500A21R0000 B 3/02 111,550 113,170 111,550 1.0145 FERN HEIGHTS REP BLK D LOT 2R 200338500D02R0000 B 9/02 137,500 129,160 137,500 .9393 FERN HEIGHTS REP BLK D LT 9R 200338500D09R0000 B 7/02 130,000 150,140 130,000 1.1549 FOREST PARK BLK 4 LOT 11 20034500040110000 B 3/03 135,000 136,490 135,000 1.0110 FROST FARMS BLK 1 LOT 24 20035000010240000 B 4/02 250,000 438,010 250,000 1.7520 FROST FARMS BLK 1 LOT 30 20035000010300000 B 7/02 575,000 576,970 575,000 1.0034 FROST FARMS BLK 1 LT 32 20035000010320000 B 6/02 375,000 441,450 375,000 1.1772 FROST FARMS BLK 2 LT 11 20035000020110000 B 8/02 430,000 460,000 430,000 1.0698 FROST FARMS BLK 4 LT 1 20035000040010000 B 10/02 515,000 408,100 515,000 .7924 FROST FARMS 2 PH 1 BLK A LOT 1 200350100A0180000 B 2/02 252,500 299,200 252,500 1.1850 HAMPTON PLACE ESTATES REV BLK 20040500020370000 B 9/02 109,000 110,053 109,000 1.0097 HAMPTON PLACE ESTATES 4TH INST 20044500140040000 B 5/02 99,000 124,667 99,000 1.2593 HAMPTON PLACE ESTATES 4TH INST 20044500150030000 B 7/02 104,900 113,993 104,900 1.0867 HAMPTON PLACE ESTATES 5TH INST 20045500150100000 B 7/02 102,500 103,865 102,500 1.0133 HAMPTON PLACE ESTATES 8TH INST 20049500110180000 B 7/02 114,900 141,344 114,900 1.2301 HIGH MEADOWS 2ND INST BLK 4 LO 20054500040250000 B 5/02 101,000 102,120 101,000 1.0111 LYNNWOOD ESTATES 1 REV BLK 1 20059500010150000 B 8/02 104,900 95,920 104,900 .9144 LYNNWOOD ESTATES 1 REV BLK 2 L 20059500020150000 B 2/02 100,000 77,690 100,000 .7769 MANTLEBROOK FARMS 1ST INST BLK 20062500050030000 B 3/03 104,280 133,970 104,280 1.2847 MANTLEBROOK FARMS 1ST INST BLK 20062500050160000 B 11/02 112,500 111,420 112,500 .9904 MANTLEBROOK FARMS 1ST INST BLK 20062500060070000 B 1/03 113,000 113,720 113,000 1.0064 MEADOW BROOK ESTATES 2ND INST 20068500150070000 B 8/02 140,000 144,070 140,000 1.0291 MEADOWBROOK ESTATES 3RD INST B 20068700010060000 B 12/02 135,900 144,300 135,900 1.0618 MEADOWBROOK ESTATES 5TH INST B 20069150230010000 B 12/02 216,900 209,830 216,900 .9674 MEADOWBROOK ESTATES 5TH INST B 20069150230110000 B 6/02 206,000 203,920 206,000 .9899 MESA VERDE 1 BLK 9 LT 14 20069500090140000 B 7/02 110,000 136,257 110,000 1.2387 MESA VERDE 1 BLK 10 LOT 14 20069500100140000 B 10/02 123,085 135,930 123,085 1.1044 MOCKINGBIRD HILL SEC 1 REV BLK 20070000010070000 B 4/02 97,500 95,600 97,500 .9805 MOCKINGBIRD HILL SEC 1 REV BLK 20070000050060000 B 7/02 96,000 91,800 96,000 .9563 MOCKINGBIRD HILL SEC 2 BLK 3 L 20070100030190000 B 3/02 103,000 98,090 103,000 .9523 MOCKINGBIRD HILL SEC 2 BLK 5 L 20070100050200000 B 6/02 96,800 98,820 96,800 1.0209 MOCKINGBIRD HILL SEC 2 BLK 9 L 20070100090240000 B 8/02 94,000 91,230 94,000 .9705 MOCKINGBIRD HILL SEC 3 BLK 7 L 20070150070110000 B 1/03 96,900 103,570 96,900 1.0688 MOCKINGBIRD HILL SEC 3 BLK 8 L 20070150080070000 B 8/02 102,900 104,580 102,900 1.0163 MOCKINGBIRD HILL SEC 3 BLK 10 20070150100110000 B 10/02 92,000 95,430 92,000 1.0373 NORTH MEADOWS REV BLK 2 LOT 3 20073400020030000 B 3/03 158,900 130,600 158,900 .8219 NORTH MEADOWS BLK 3 LT 19 20073400030190000 B 2/02 120,000 120,590 120,000 1.0049 NORTH PARK 2 BLK 6 LOT 3 20074500060030000 B 8/02 99,900 95,670 99,900 .9577 NORTHWEST ESTATES 2 BLK 7 LT 20076500070160000 B 10/02 89,900 93,340 89,900 1.0383 NORTHWEST ESTATES 2 BLK 8 LOT 20076500080110000 B 8/02 98,880 102,890 98,880 1.0406 NORTHWEST ESTATES 2 BLK 8 LT 1 20076500080130000 B 7/02 75,900 98,680 75,900 1.3001 NORTHWEST ESTATES 4 BLK 9 LOT 20078500090020000 B 7/02 90,100 92,450 90,100 1.0261 OAKMONT BLK B LT 2 200790000B0020000 B 3/03 125,400 125,910 125,400 1.0041 OAKMONT BLK B LT 5 200790000B0050000 B 11/02 134,500 134,150 134,500 .9974

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 36 TIME: 13:38 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-906 DeSoto CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OAKMONT BLK F LT 27 200790000F0270000 B 3/03 136,500 136,750 136,500 1.0018 L H OWENS BLK B LT 4 20079500020040000 B 11/02 98,000 89,080 98,000 .9090 PARK PLACE PH 1 BLK D LT 15 200795500D0150000 B 12/02 129,300 118,990 129,300 .9203 PARK PLACE PH 1 BLK F LOT 9 200795500F0090000 B 8/02 135,000 122,890 135,000 .9103 PARK RIDGE ESTATES BLK 1 LT 7 20079570010070000 B 8/02 99,500 79,640 99,500 .8004 PARK RIDGE ESTATES BLK 3 LOT 9 20079570030090000 B 5/02 105,100 95,030 105,100 .9042 PARK RIDGE ESTATES BLK 10 LOT 20079570100010000 B 11/02 115,000 104,970 115,000 .9128 PLEASANT LAKE ESTATES BLK 7 LT 20082500070190000 B 5/02 113,000 109,970 113,000 .9732 PLEASANT LAKE ESTATES 2 BLK 17 20083500170180000 B 5/02 90,900 91,230 90,900 1.0036 REGENTS PARK BLK 6 LT 14 20091250060140000 B 10/02 550,000 560,000 550,000 1.0182 ROCK CREEK BLK 1 LT 8 20092550010080000 B 7/02 92,000 94,440 92,000 1.0265 ST GEORGE'S PLACE BLK A LT 1 200953500A0010000 B 3/02 350,000 306,310 350,000 .8752 SILVER CREEK CROSSING 1 INST R 20095650020150000 B 1/03 187,700 175,100 187,700 .9329 SILVER CREEK CROSSING 1ST INST 20095650140190000 B 8/02 205,000 214,980 205,000 1.0487 SILVER CREEK CROSSING 1 INST R 20095650150080000 B 3/02 135,000 179,310 135,000 1.3282 SILVER CREEK CROSSING 2ND INST 20095670120240000 B 9/02 251,000 212,240 251,000 .8456 SOUTHAMPTON ESTATES BLK D LT 5 20096500040050000 B 1/03 112,000 108,020 112,000 .9645 SOUTHAMPTON ESTATES BLK F LT 1 20096500060160000 B 4/02 104,000 110,350 104,000 1.0611 SOUTH MEADOWS 2ND SEC BLK K LT 20098500110060000 B 8/02 105,000 149,930 105,000 1.4279 SOUTH MEADOWS 2ND SEC BLK L LT 20098500120090000 B 3/02 127,400 104,920 127,400 .8235 SOUTH MEADOWS 3RD SEC BLK 1 20098560010430000 B 12/02 142,500 123,020 142,500 .8633 SOUTH MEADOWS 4TH SEC BLK 1 20098570010610000 B 7/02 123,000 110,000 123,000 .8943 SOUTH MEADOWS 4TH SEC BLK 4 LT 20098570040190000 B 2/02 130,600 115,020 130,600 .8807 SOUTH MEADOWS 4TH SEC BLK 4 LT 20098570040310000 B 2/02 118,000 117,250 118,000 .9936 SOUTH MEADOWS 4TH SEC BLK 8 LT 20098570080080000 B 4/02 150,000 152,990 150,000 1.0199 SOUTHPOINTE BLK 6 LOT 19 20098790060190000 B 12/02 96,000 103,660 96,000 1.0798 SOUTHPOINTE BLK 7 LOT 7 20098790070070000 B 9/02 96,775 98,330 96,775 1.0161 SOUTHPOINTE BLK 7 LOT 10 20098790070100000 B 11/02 102,200 97,670 102,200 .9557 SOUTHPOINTE BLK 7 LOT 44 20098790070440000 B 1/03 99,900 94,960 99,900 .9506 TIMBERBROOK 1ST REP BLK B LOT 201033000B0180000 B 4/02 99,900 97,910 99,900 .9801 TIMBERBROOK 1ST REP BLK E LT 1 201033000E0010000 B 5/02 95,500 98,180 95,500 1.0281 TWIN CREEK PH 1 BLK 8 LOT 4 20104700080040000 B 9/02 146,000 145,100 146,000 .9938 TWIN CREEK PH 1 BLK 10 LOT 10 20104700100100000 B 6/02 140,000 144,120 140,000 1.0294 TWIN CREEK PH 1 BLK 11 LT 6 20104700110060000 B 4/02 118,593 127,790 118,593 1.0776 TWIN CREEK PH 2 BLK 1 LT 16 20104710010160000 B 10/02 150,000 153,640 150,000 1.0243 TWIN CREEK PH 2 BLK 2 LOT 4 20104710020040000 B 12/02 177,000 160,100 177,000 .9045 WESTERN HILLS ESTATES 1 BLK A 20110500010100000 B 8/02 101,000 80,690 101,000 .7989 WESTERN HILLS ESTATES 2 BLK 4 20110600040110000 B 8/02 94,900 81,280 94,900 .8565 WESTERN HILLS ESTATES 3 BLK 4 20110700040130000 B 4/02 104,989 93,770 104,989 .8931 WESTERN HILLS ESTATES 3 BLK 8 20110700080140000 B 2/02 72,400 100,830 72,400 1.3927 WILDWOOD 1ST INST BLK 1 LT 10 20111000010100000 B 8/02 147,000 150,580 147,000 1.0244 WILDWOOD 1ST INST REP BLK 1 LO 20111000010230000 B 11/02 110,650 124,050 110,650 1.1211 WILDWOOD 1ST INST BLK 1 LT 43A 201110000143A0000 B 6/02 109,500 85,440 109,500 .7803 WILDWOOD 1ST INST BLK 4 LOT 28 20111000040280000 B 8/02 125,000 125,060 125,000 1.0005 WILDWOOD 2ND INST BLK 6 LT 37 20111100060370000 B 7/02 114,900 118,480 114,900 1.0312 WYNDMERE BLK 1 LOT 13 20114500010130000 B 2/02 285,000 229,850 285,000 .8065 BEAVER CREEK ESTATES PH 1 BLK 270001400A0020000 B 4/02 140,000 134,550 140,000 .9611

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 37 TIME: 13:38 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-906 DeSoto CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BEAVER CREEK ESTATES PH 1 BLK 270001400A0030000 B 5/02 149,260 149,000 149,260 .9983 BEAVER CREEK ESTATES PH 1 BLK 270001400B0050000 B 5/02 114,000 115,000 114,000 1.0088 BEAVER CREEK ESTATES PH 1 BLK 270001400B0070000 B 6/02 158,399 158,000 158,399 .9975 BEAR CREEK MEADOWS BLK E LOT 7 270001500E0070000 B 10/02 103,400 94,430 103,400 .9132 BEAR CREEK MEADOWS 2 BLK B LT 270001700B0200000 B 10/02 91,000 83,930 91,000 .9223 BEAR CREEK MEADOWS 2 BLK C LOT 270001700C0130000 B 9/02 95,000 93,120 95,000 .9802 BEAR CREEK MEADOWS 2 BLK P LOT 270001700P0060000 B 7/02 99,900 98,800 99,900 .9890 BEAR CREEK MEADOWS 2 BLK P LT 270001700P0100000 B 4/02 100,000 99,100 100,000 .9910 BEAR CREEK MEADOWS 2 BLK P LT 270001700P0110000 B 8/02 100,000 99,100 100,000 .9910 MESA PH 1 BLK 2 LT 1 27000900020010000 B 9/02 87,000 90,980 87,000 1.0457 MESA PH 2 BLK 2 LOT 35 27000920020350000 B 5/02 85,000 82,210 85,000 .9672 TOP OF THE HILL FARMS BLK B LO 27001500020120000 B 5/02 94,000 95,730 94,000 1.0184 TOP OF THE HILL FARMS BLK C LT 27001500030090000 B 1/03 97,000 93,060 97,000 .9594 TOP OF THE HILL FARMS BLK D L 27001500040030000 B 5/02 123,000 123,620 123,000 1.0050 HERITAGE HEIGHTS BLK C LT 4 270030200C0040000 B 4/02 99,500 89,890 99,500 .9034 HERITAGE HEIGHTS BLK D LT 29 270030200D0290000 B 1/03 94,001 96,870 94,001 1.0305 HERITAGE HEIGHTS BLK D LOT 40 270030200D0400000 B 3/02 117,000 109,410 117,000 .9351 HERITAGE HEIGHTS BLK G LT 8 270030200G0080000 B 8/02 108,500 112,570 108,500 1.0375 HERITAGE HEIGHTS BLK G LT 10 270030200G0100000 B 6/02 108,500 99,930 108,500 .9210 HERITAGE HEIGHTS BLK H LT 12 270030200H0120000 B 12/02 119,000 127,260 119,000 1.0694 HERITAGE HEIGHTS PH 3A BLK E L 270280000E0080000 B 3/03 110,000 131,480 110,000 1.1953 HERITAGE HEIGHTS PH 3A BLK E L 270280000E0270000 B 8/02 104,000 126,590 104,000 1.2172 HERITAGE HEIGHTS PH 3A BLK E L 270280000E0430000 B 3/03 86,000 123,940 86,000 1.4412 HERITAGE HEIGHTS PH 3A BLK F L 270280000F0600000 B 2/02 95,000 115,410 95,000 1.2148 MESA PH 3 BLK 4 LT 3 27102250040030000 B 6/02 81,500 81,220 81,500 .9966 MESA PH 4 REP BLK 2 LT 10 27226000020100000 B 2/02 84,000 82,990 84,000 .9880 MESA PH 4 REP BLK 5 LT 17 27226000050170000 B 5/02 85,000 84,940 85,000 .9993 MESA PH 5 SEC 2 BLK 3 LT 12 27226050030120000 B 10/02 95,000 83,600 95,000 .8800 MESA PH 5 BLK 4 LT 12 27226050040120000 B 2/02 90,000 88,470 90,000 .9830 MESA PH 5 SEC 2 BLK 5 LT 22 27226050050220000 B 11/02 68,777 83,100 68,777 1.2083 MESA PH 5 SEC 2 BLK 7 LOT 5 27226050070050000 B 11/02 112,900 126,940 112,900 1.1244 WILLIAM CALDWELL ABST 234 PG 6 65023466010130000 B 5/02 775,000 691,220 775,000 .8919 173 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0004 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ARBOR PLACE REV BLK 2 PT LT 13 20000850020130000 B 5/02 89,000 83,030 89,000 .9329 ARBOR PLACE REV BLK 3 LOT 10.1 20000850030100100 B 10/02 84,400 73,340 84,400 .8690 ARBOR PLACE REV BLK 4 LT 1.1 W 20000850040010100 B 1/03 92,700 89,570 92,700 .9662

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 38 TIME: 13:38 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-906 DeSoto CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ARBOR PLACE REV BLK 5 S 1/2 LO 20000850050070100 B 11/02 84,900 69,830 84,900 .8225 ARBOR PLACE REV BLK 5 E 1/2 L 20000850050110000 B 10/02 79,900 72,870 79,900 .9120 BROOK HOLLOW ESTATES 3 BLK 8 L 20008500080180000 B 11/02 117,000 62,810 117,000 .5368 BROOK HOLLOW ESTATES 3 BLK 8 L 20008500080200001 B 5/02 117,000 63,540 117,000 .5400 GREEN MEADOWS ESTATES 1ST SEC 20037520010010000 B 4/02 129,900 125,710 129,900 .9677 HAMPTON PLACE ESTATES 6TH INST 20046500190050000 B 10/02 114,000 111,190 114,000 .9754 HAMPTON PLACE ESTATES 6TH INST 20046500190140000 B 12/02 119,000 121,870 119,000 1.0241 MANTLEBROOK FARMS 4 BLK 2 LOT 20063500020200000 B 4/02 151,000 147,500 151,000 .9768 MEADOWBROOK ESTATES 4TH INST B 20069100180450000 B 5/02 174,500 90,310 174,500 .5175 MEADOWBROOK ESTATES 4TH INST B 20069100180450001 B 5/02 174,500 90,310 174,500 .5200 PARK PLACE PH 1 BLK B LT 6 200795500B0060000 B 10/02 30,000 68,110 30,000 2.2703 PARK PLACE PH 1 BLK C LOT 3 AC 200795500C0030000 B 3/03 84,000 76,140 84,000 .9064 PARK PLACE PH 1 BLK C PT LOT 8 200795500C0080000 B 6/02 74,000 70,640 74,000 .9546 PARK PLACE PH 1 BLK C LOT 11.1 200795500C0110100 B 7/02 78,000 72,880 78,000 .9344 PARK PLACE PH 1 BLK C PT LT 14 200795500C0140000 B 10/02 70,000 72,880 70,000 1.0411 PARK PLACE PH 1 BLK E LOT 4.1 200795500E0040100 B 12/02 78,000 71,360 78,000 .9149 PARK PLACE PH 1 BLK N LT 10.1 200795500N0100100 B 5/02 78,080 76,910 78,080 .9850 PARK PLACE PH 1 BLK N W PT LT 200795500N0120100 B 5/02 75,500 72,420 75,500 .9592 PARK RIDGE ESTATES BLK 11 LT 3 200795701133A0000 B 1/03 68,000 70,370 68,000 1.0349 PARK RIDGE ESTATES BLK 11 LT 3 200795701133B0000 B 12/02 82,000 76,770 82,000 .9362 DYNASTY BLK 1 LOT 7 27000190010070000 B 7/02 120,000 118,400 120,000 .9867 DYNASTY LOT 1 BLK 3 27000190030010000 B 6/02 109,000 108,710 109,000 .9973 DYNASTY INST 2 BLK 6 LT 9 27000200060090000 B 7/02 102,500 106,090 102,500 1.0350 MORGAN HEIGHTS BLK C LT 3 60133500030030000 B 8/02 150,000 148,120 150,000 .9875 27 SALES CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD APPR TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER MOD OBS VALUE APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEO L BARROWS 20003500000010000 1.00 .00 450,000 480,000 .9400 FOXMOOR MANOR 20034600010010000 1.00 .00 2,464,000 2,533,000 .9700 HAMPTON PLACE APTS 20039500000010000 1.00 .00 2,100,000 2,392,000 .8800 LAS CASITAS 20058500010010000 1.00 .00 2,900,000 3,289,000 .8800 PECAN CROSSING 20081700000010000 1.00 .00 7,459,870 6,308,000 1.1800 PECAN CROSSING 2 20081710000010000 1.00 .00 2,386,040 2,304,000 1.0400 PECAN CROSSING 2 20081710000020000 1.00 .00 997,570 858,781 1.1600 PLEASANT LAKE EST 20083750000000000 1.00 .00 6,149,930 5,618,000 1.0900 WINTERGREEN PLACE 20113250000010000 1.00 .00 6,000,000 6,469,000 .9300 9 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO WITH EXCEPTIONS: .9368

DATE: 1/22/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 39 TIME: 13:38 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-906 DeSoto CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 106 BARROWS 20051500010020000 C 6/02 150,000 150,000 150,000 1.0000 524 W. BELTLINE RD. 65023466010080000 C 5/02 175,000 178,620 175,000 1.0200 314 S. HAMPTON RD. 65112401010630000 C 12/02 165,000 165,000 165,000 1.0000 3 SALES CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 1001N BECKLEY AVE 20026480010010000 .00 1.00 .00 6,275,700 6,194,620 1.0100 1001 N BECKLEY RD 20026480010010100 .00 1.00 .00 2,648,980 2,849,600 .9300 1109 N BECKLEY AVE 20026480010040000 .00 1.00 .00 1,935,320 2,012,120 .9600 1135 N BECKLEY RD 20029560000030000 .00 1.00 .00 950,000 1,315,127 .7200 307 E BELTLINE RD 20031500010010000 .00 1.00 .00 556,320 471,355 1.1800 851 BECKLEY AVE 200337400A0010000 .00 1.00 .00 690,180 652,656 1.0600 607 N HAMPTON RD 20038500000100300 .00 1.00 .00 147,780 151,227 .9800 719 N HAMPTON RD 200385000014R0000 .00 1.00 .00 1,680,000 1,767,445 .9500 215 DALTON DR 20049800030010000 .00 1.00 .00 233,710 228,627 1.0200 1401 N BECKLEY RD 200549900A0010000 .00 1.00 .00 2,976,000 2,720,609 1.0900 849 N BECKLEY AVE 200580100002A0000 .00 1.00 .00 1,790,000 2,068,410 .8700 200 N HAMPTON RD 20062250010010000 .00 1.00 .00 1,200,000 1,024,680 1.1700 1031 E PLEASANT RUN RD 20086540500010000 .00 1.00 .00 628,010 617,232 1.0200 747 WESTMORELAND RD 200997600A0010000 .00 1.00 .00 1,755,000 1,914,153 .9200 210 E PLEASANT RUN RD 201039000A1RR0000 .00 1.00 .00 6,400,000 6,219,149 1.0300 900 N POLK ST 201040000B0010000 .00 1.00 .00 4,038,330 4,205,090 .9600 734 E PLEASANT RUN RD 201072000A0010000 .00 1.00 .00 1,918,890 2,077,682 .9200 1703 I - 35 27000240000000000 .00 1.00 .00 786,430 652,760 1.2000 801 S HAMPTON RD 65023466010460000 .00 1.00 .00 296,020 248,609 1.1900 416 BEAR CREEK RD 65120521510040000 .00 1.00 .00 293,880 200,482 1.4700 410 WINTERGREEN RD 65146636010080000 .00 1.00 .00 260,250 183,433 1.4200 21 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0186 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE.