DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 1 TIME: 21:54 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 252 Young 252-901 Graham CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ CLEO WOLF 12165 Y 8/02 19,000 17,996 19,000 .9472 JAMES E BURGTORF ETUX 1220 Y 5/02 45,000 42,328 45,000 .9406 JIMMIE D WESTERMAN ETUX 12369 W 10/02 15,000 22,330 15,000 1.4887 WILLIAM L GORAY 1247 C 1/02 35,000 35,290 35,000 1.0083 JAMES M JONES ETUX 1274 C 8/02 55,000 47,935 55,000 .8715 THOMAS N CLARK SR ETUX 12809 Y 4/02 60,000 67,461 60,000 1.1244 RUTH P PARKER 12828 C 7/02 60,000 33,618 60,000 .5603 BEVERLY S GARVEY 1290 C 8/02 52,500 54,924 52,500 1.0462 FRIEDA N STURGILL TR 13295 C 5/02 65,500 64,469 65,500 .9843 JOE F BUSSEY ETUX 13315 C 5/02 47,500 46,225 47,500 .9732 BOBBY COX ETUX 13408 W 10/02 32,000 31,627 32,000 .9883 ALVAREZ JOHN VERA ETUX 13588 C 11/02 45,000 44,559 45,000 .9902 ROBERT D ROGERS 13594 W 9/02 67,500 47,024 67,500 .6967 BILLY B SMITH 1399 Y 1/02 60,000 59,169 60,000 .9862 JEFFREY C BEVILL ETUX 1430 Y 10/02 85,000 103,201 85,000 1.2141 MARK A RICHARDS ETUX 14697 Y 8/02 45,000 88,050 45,000 1.9567 BILLY D CARNEY 1517 C 10/02 78,865 88,883 78,865 1.1270 MICHAEL SMITH ETUX 15251 C 1/02 42,000 50,503 42,000 1.2025 CHARLES E PARKER JR ETUX 15337 C 1/02 22,500 19,515 22,500 .8673 JO FRANCES BREWER 1542 Y 6/02 67,000 82,965 67,000 1.2383 ROY MCGEHEE ETUX 15453 Y 8/02 55,000 53,929 55,000 .9805 KENT A CLARK 1550 C 3/02 80,000 74,963 80,000 .9370 JANICE E MOLPUS 15576 Y 6/02 39,000 38,123 39,000 .9775 JUANITA ANTINONE 15590 C 12/02 30,000 30,233 30,000 1.0078 LUIS SIMENTAL 15621 W 11/02 35,000 39,294 35,000 1.1227 KEVIN B PATTY ETUX 15697 C 12/02 210,000 210,408 210,000 1.0019 KAREN MCMILLIAN 15698 C 12/02 82,000 81,398 82,000 .9927 LALLIE F KIRKLAND 15731 C 3/02 31,500 30,384 31,500 .9646 BARBARA HOLZER 15897 C 6/02 33,500 32,381 33,500 .9666 JOEL A FLAGG 15957 C 9/02 20,000 19,131 20,000 .9566 LLOYD SWAYNE ETUX 15974 C 11/02 98,000 99,651 98,000 1.0168 JAMES R WATKINS 1602 Y 2/02 65,000 64,276 65,000 .9889 LEAH B SMITH 16139 Y 1/02 94,000 92,859 94,000 .9879 LISA D PRICE 16140 C 9/02 150,000 147,614 150,000 .9841 CHRISTOPHER J CARRIGAN ETUX 16147 C 3/02 65,000 62,101 65,000 .9554 ROBERT N & RUBYETTA CAIN 16301 W 4/02 179,000 162,420 179,000 .9074 RICHESON MANAGEMENT CORP 18108 C 12/02 400,000 396,776 400,000 .9919 ROYCE M BRISCO 1820 Y 9/02 8,000 22,408 8,000 2.8010 BILLY H STOUT 1990 Y 7/02 49,000 52,086 49,000 1.0630 NICK NEVAREZ 1993 C 9/02 26,500 26,413 26,500 .9967 BRADLEY WARD LAND 2007 C 8/02 105,000 101,804 105,000 .9696 DENNIS G BRYAN 2010 C 1/02 325,000 321,998 325,000 .9908 SHANNON B GRAY ETUX 2034 C 7/02 90,000 90,681 90,000 1.0076 CHARLES L FORGY ETUX 2132 W 11/02 62,000 56,138 62,000 .9055 AMY WILLIAMS ET VIR 2473 C 1/02 55,000 59,383 55,000 1.0797 MONTFORT MISTY L 2703 C 6/02 15,000 25,251 15,000 1.6834 WILLIAM PERKINS ETUX 2712 C 8/02 69,500 68,651 69,500 .9878DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 2 TIME: 21:54 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 252 Young 252-901 Graham CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LOUISE JOHNSON 2721 C 6/02 40,000 50,835 40,000 1.2709 MAICHAEL S BARRETT ETUX 2807 Y 5/02 80,000 81,782 80,000 1.0223 ALVIS L MOORE ETUX 2893 Y 5/02 115,000 113,855 115,000 .9900 RONNIE W ROBERTSON 2922 C 7/02 135,000 132,595 135,000 .9822 GREGORY S THOMAS ETUX 2933 Y 7/02 145,000 151,465 145,000 1.0446 GENE CHAMNESS ETUX 2941 Y 5/02 105,000 107,425 105,000 1.0231 JERRY E MARCHMAN 2942 W 9/02 112,500 88,052 112,500 .7827 RICHARD B LANG ETAL 3004 C 6/02 25,000 24,180 25,000 .9672 STEVEN G STUTZMAN ETUX 3119 Y 6/02 34,500 34,198 34,500 .9912 TOMMY E GLEASON ETUX 3127 C 6/02 20,000 19,849 20,000 .9925 JAMES TINKLE ETUX 3134 C 4/02 82,500 80,349 82,500 .9739 JEFFREY R HUTSON ETUX 3140 C 8/02 125,000 124,038 125,000 .9923 BILLIE R BROCKMAN 3308 Y 11/02 106,844 105,452 106,844 .9870 OSCAR E MCCOMMAS 3349 C 4/02 25,000 25,025 25,000 1.0010 CARLTON R LARY 3369 C 8/02 18,500 18,105 18,500 .9786 STEARNS ROBERT J ETUX 3533 C 8/02 132,500 128,872 132,500 .9726 RENFRO PATRICIA H 3541 C 1/03 120,000 119,179 120,000 .9932 PHILLIP R ROBERTSON ETUX 3615 C 6/02 41,000 40,823 41,000 .9957 JUDITH C HANNA 3621 C 9/02 35,000 34,977 35,000 .9993 DORIS E JONES 4071 C 2/02 37,000 37,222 37,000 1.0060 MORALES ELOY ETUX 4074 C 4/02 39,900 38,883 39,900 .9745 HERSHAL ROSE ETUX 4129 W 2/02 28,000 17,671 28,000 .6311 BRENT E UPTON ETUX 4342 C 5/02 78,000 78,072 78,000 1.0009 TRAVIS D LAWSON ETUX 61064 Y 7/02 50,000 48,803 50,000 .9761 M & D APARTMENTS 61338 C 4/02 22,500 23,993 22,500 1.0664 JERRY YOUNG ETUX 61363 Y 6/02 8,000 17,950 8,000 2.2438 KING TOMIVA JR & REX D 61704 C 11/02 78,500 77,125 78,500 .9825 PATSY J SNOW 61710 Y 3/02 69,000 68,892 69,000 .9984 ZEBBIE J SUMPTERETUX 61711 C 7/02 74,600 74,395 74,600 .9973 WESLEY ALBERT ETUX 63411 W 8/02 75,000 67,601 75,000 .9013 HERNDON STEWART ETUX 67591 C 5/02 28,000 28,125 28,000 1.0045 KING WILLIAM ORELL 68325 C 2/02 26,000 25,896 26,000 .9960 JEFFREYS RUBY RHEA 68380 C 1/02 78,500 73,356 78,500 .9345 J W BURKHART 8319 C 5/02 70,000 70,829 70,000 1.0118 JAMES V DONAHUE 8672 C 5/02 31,000 31,918 31,000 1.0296 MITCHEL L BROWN ETUX 8679 C 7/02 132,500 131,235 132,500 .9905 83 SALES CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER MOD OBS APPR VAL APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LOT 30 & PART 31 ROLLING HILLS 02927 1.00 .00 131,987 139,731 .9400 LOT 9 & PART 8 TIMBER RIDGE LA 64019 1.00 .00 176,583 200,344 .8800 2 APPRAISALS
DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 3 TIME: 21:54 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 252 Young 252-901 Graham STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9977 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ TEXAS VET LAND BD 12573 C 3/03 21,205 39,000 .5437 TIMOTHY W BUSH ETUX 131412 C 4/02 31,767 60,000 .5295 KEVIN L FERGUSON ETUX 61639 W 5/02 20,000 25,000 .8000 SMITH KEVIN SHANE ETUX 61991 C 9/02 136,202 84,680 1.6100 KEVIN BARNETT ETUX 6327 W 5/02 53,245 40,000 1.3311 DOYLE STEVE ETUX 67658 C 5/02 182,878 236,000 .7700 POSSUM KINGDOM RECREATION CORP 68044 W 6/02 15,930 8,827 1.8000 CLARK AGATHA RUSSO 68710 C 3/02 5,600 6,000 .9300 COMPTON LINDA NELL ETAL 68717 W 3/02 6,180 2,700 2.2900 HENRY STEVE RAY ETUX 68718 C 4/02 11,973 14,100 .8500 HARRISON JOHN ETUX 68734 C 6/02 14,022 5,000 2.8044 SCHREIBER STEPHEN C ETAL 68736 C 4/02 56,366 49,010 1.1500 SMITH RAYMOND D ETUX 68738 Y 5/02 44,743 90,000 .5000 FORD KENNETH C ETUX 68774 C 8/02 13,650 12,500 1.0900 FOSTER MARION L ETUX 76272 C 4/02 172,793 217,000 .8000 ROBERT D VELASQUEZ 79962 C 11/02 97,844 233,000 .4200 KENNETH SHEPARD ETUX 8094 W 11/02 27,457 45,000 .6102 AGT RANCH PROPERTIES 9575 W 9/02 385,351 440,308 .8752 FREEMAN ENGINEERING INC 96722 C 9/02 12,500 8,500 1.4700 STEVEN R HENRY ETUX 9746 C 4/02 20,493 28,620 .7200 20 SALES CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER APPR VAL APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AB 1425 D D FRANKLIN 142512 55,925 62,813 .8900 AB 1370 AB&M 61243 63,419 75,531 .8400 2 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .8127
DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 4 TIME: 21:54 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 252 Young 252-901 Graham CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ EDWARD S WIESEN 11517 C 6/02 8,500 29,232 8,500 3.4391 GRAHAM NEWSPAPER INC 13703 C 5/02 53,500 56,968 53,500 1.0648 FIGG JAMES ETUX 13826 C 4/02 22,550 21,207 22,550 .9404 ERNEST M JENNINGS 15398 C 6/02 45,000 33,063 45,000 .7347 GFC LEASING CORP 15776 W 5/02 238,605 67,776 238,605 .2841 GUY L WAGGONER JR 17819 Y 7/02 40,000 21,724 40,000 .5431 GRAHAM ELECTRONICS 1873 C 12/02 67,000 25,986 67,000 .3879 LITTLEPAGE OIL PROPERTIES 3331 W 4/02 70,000 79,372 70,000 1.1339 8 SALES CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ROLLING HILLS BLK 3 LOT 9-11 P 01259 .00 1.00 .00 343,350 321,961 1.0700 BLK 1 LOT 13-15 PART RIBBLE 01788 .00 1.00 .00 306,976 323,156 .9500 BLK 54 158' X 320' BEN HILL 01848 .00 1.00 .00 151,368 142,232 1.0600 BLK 55 LOT 3 BEN HILL 01852 .00 1.00 .00 23,802 31,595 .7500 BLK 1 LOT 5-6 PARTS JOHNSON 02181 .00 1.00 .00 30,477 28,640 1.0600 BLK 7 LOT 17 COLLEGE HEIGHTS 03027 .00 1.00 .00 152,360 145,037 1.0500 WHITE SUR 03174 .00 1.00 .00 98,438 98,633 1.0000 BLK 78 BEN HILL 125' X 150' 03202 .00 1.00 .00 58,217 56,012 1.0400 BLK 86 BEN HILL 4.065 AC 03329 .00 1.00 .00 520,005 582,632 .8900 BLK 20 LOT 27-32 OT GRAHAM 13710 .00 1.00 .00 59,893 71,368 .8400 BLK 21 LOT 11-16 PART OT GRAHA 13717 .00 1.00 .00 117,526 115,729 1.0200 BLK 24 LOT 12-16 PART OT GRAHA 13754 .00 1.00 .00 142,578 140,785 1.0100 BLK 17 LOT 15-16 PART OT GRAHA 15637 .00 1.00 .00 44,251 40,714 1.0900 AB 0164 J E JONES 17149 .00 1.00 .00 114,189 110,221 1.0400 AB 0164 J E JONES 17171 .00 1.00 .00 955,712 992,300 .9600 PAUL PIER TR E15 18224 .00 1.00 .00 170,473 181,844 .9400 AB 1406 DUDNEY286.1' X 388' 18225 .00 1.00 .00 801,211 900,922 .8900 BEN HILL NW/CORNER BLK 114 64270 .00 1.00 .00 812,918 898,438 .9000 AB 0271 TR 19 ELI SHERRELL 64314 .00 1.00 .00 155,311 217,442 .7100 BLK 29 OT GRAHAM 64336 .00 1.00 .00 1,274,089 1,442,534 .8800 20 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .8725
DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 5 TIME: 21:54 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 252 Young 252-901 Graham CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ DON FREEZE ETUX 8200-100-00027 25,020 24,269 1.0300 SERVICE PARTS & SUPPLY 8200-100-00076 77,000 74,690 1.0300 BUCHANAN SUPPLY ROAD 8200-100-00253 167,496 167,496 1.0000 SUPER VALUE DRUG 8200-100-00261 130,000 136,397 .9500 HAWKINS SUB SURFACE & PUMP 8200-100-00262 156,000 162,281 .9600 MORRISON'S FUNERAL HOME INC 8200-100-00419 133,176 135,844 .9800 LEXTRON TEXAS LLP 8200-100-00557 367,155 369,797 .9900 GRAHAM POLELINE LTD 8200-100-01222 216,290 222,870 .9700 TUCORP INC 8200-100-01246 73,220 70,240 1.0400 MOVIE GALLERY #1013 8200-100-01312 66,476 68,250 .9700 VINEYARD BRANCH 8200-100-01336 21,877 22,500 .9700 CAPROCK FIBER NETWORK LTD 8200-100-01405 123,750 129,615 .9500 PEGASUS SATELLITE TELEVISION 8200-100-01428 12,680 12,300 1.0300 AMC MARKET PLACE 8200-100-01480 25,000 26,100 .9600 KEY ENERGY NORTH TEXAS DIVISIO 8200-100-01935 461,840 451,650 1.0200 SOUTHERN BLEACHER CO INC 8200-100-01945 500,000 500,000 1.0000 SOUTHERN BLEACHERS CO LTD 8200-100-01946 350,000 364,000 .9600 TEXAS MRI LP 8200-100-01960 31,560 31,500 1.0000 TOWN & COUNTRY HOMES 8200-100-01983 1,251,690 1,170,000 1.0700 TURNCO INC 8200-200-00117 179,270 173,892 1.0300 TEXAS MRE LP 8200-200-00346 1,061,840 1,170,000 .9100 W W AUTO & TRUCK PARTS 8200-200-01081 204,320 198,190 1.0300 HENDRIX FOODS 8200-200-01123 25,500 26,539 .9600 RIG TESTERS INC 8200-300-00355 15,000 14,550 1.0300 OIL CITY SUPPLY CO 8200-300-00402 168,250 161,122 1.0400 KRAMER INVESTMENT 8200-300-01069 74,000 71,780 1.0300 SUNWEST MUD CO 8200-300-01101 58,000 58,940 .9800 VFS RESIDUAL HOLDING 8200-300-01149 75,570 38,454 1.9700 GRAHAM LIVESTOCK SALES CORP 8200-300-01285 53,200 54,600 .9700 D L PETERSON TRUST 8200-400-00310 369,100 369,100 1.0000 30 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO WITH EXCEPTIONS: 1.0015
