DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 5 TIME: 20:34 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 183 Panola 183-902 Carthage CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AB 4 W ANDERSON MH 14X66 DK GR 00004-00321-00000-000000 W 12/02 20,000 24,120 20,000 1.2060 AB 598 WM SCANTLEBERRY P-3 00598-00050-00000-000000 W 12/02 62,898 67,490 62,898 1.0730 AB 649 F W SMITH P-4B 00649-00055-00000-000000 B 5/02 138,500 109,900 138,500 .7935 AB 699 E WHITE P-16 00699-00170-00000-000000 O 11/02 64,200 60,050 64,200 .9354 BLK 73 LT 7 P-6 01405-02370-00000-000000 O 6/02 21,500 23,910 21,500 1.1121 BLK 75 LT 21 (LT 2 BLK 2 OLD0) 01405-02820-00000-000000 O 10/02 40,335 29,260 40,335 .7254 BLK 76 LT 1 P-1 01405-02890-00000-000000 B 8/02 38,000 44,120 38,000 1.1611 BLK 78 42' LT 7,ALL LT 8,W/2 O 01405-03140-00000-000000 B 8/02 80,000 80,050 80,000 1.0006 BLK 81 LT 9 P-16 01405-03610-00000-000000 O 12/02 78,700 71,300 78,700 .9060 BLK 82 LT 14 P-13 01405-03780-00000-000000 O 2/03 64,000 44,530 64,000 .6958 BLK 83 LT 1C P-4 01405-03840-00000-000000 B 7/02 44,300 33,190 44,300 .7492 BLK 87 LT 5 P-5 01405-04060-00000-000000 O 10/02 57,500 36,960 57,500 .6428 BLK 88 LT 3 P-3 01405-04150-00000-000000 O 7/02 55,800 37,420 55,800 .6706 BLK 89 LT 2 P-2 01405-04250-00000-000000 B 11/02 42,000 38,380 42,000 .9138 BLK 92-A LT 8,E/2 LT 9 BLK 94- 01405-04590-00000-000000 O 10/02 78,500 63,300 78,500 .8064 BLK 94-B W 59' LT 14,E 30' LT9 01405-05035-00000-000000 B 11/02 67,000 51,320 67,000 .7660 BLK 94-C PT LT 4 P-4 01405-05190-00000-000000 B 9/02 152,000 142,170 152,000 .9353 BLK 109 LOT 10 & PT BLK 109 DA 01410-00149-00000-000000 O 9/02 186,000 204,670 186,000 1.1004 BLK 110 LT 7 P-9 01410-00230-00000-000000 B 8/02 65,430 53,890 65,430 .8236 BLK 112-C LT 13 P-13 01410-00880-00000-000000 B 7/02 63,250 57,530 63,250 .9096 BLK 112-D W 28.5' LT 5,ALL LT6 01410-01001-00000-000000 O 10/02 78,000 54,520 78,000 .6990 BLK 112-G LT 7,W 55' LT 8 BLK 01410-01130-00000-000000 O 5/02 69,000 66,240 69,000 .9600 BLK 201 LT 4,8,9 P-5,9,10 01415-00160-00000-000000 B 7/02 89,500 95,290 89,500 1.0647 BLK 210 LT 5 P-5 01415-00860-00000-000000 W 11/02 32,000 38,080 32,000 1.1900 BLK 211 LT 8 P-11 01415-01040-00000-000000 B 7/02 69,000 56,810 69,000 .8233 BLK 214 LT 12 P-11 01415-01800-00000-000000 B 10/02 39,400 36,240 39,400 .9198 BLK 216 LT 8 OLD LT 9 P-5 01415-02010-00000-000000 S 12/02 56,500 46,290 56,500 .8193 BLK 221 LT 5 P-5 01415-02260-00000-000000 O 5/02 43,000 39,800 43,000 .9256 BLK 222 PT LT 1 P-1-2 01415-02280-00000-000000 O 9/02 30,930 38,940 30,930 1.2590 BLK 222 LT 7,8 & PT LT 1 P-7 01415-02330-00000-000000 O 10/02 85,900 97,640 85,900 1.1367 BLK 232 LT 7 P-7 01415-02630-00000-000000 B 9/02 46,000 37,220 46,000 .8091 BLK 239-D LT 6 P-6 01415-03090-00000-000000 O 7/02 32,000 28,240 32,000 .8825 BLK 239-D '95 LT 9 01415-03120-00000-000000 Y 6/02 50,000 42,690 50,000 .8538 BLK 259 LT 4 P-4 01420-00910-00000-000000 O 8/02 46,100 51,190 46,100 1.1104 BLK 263 ALL LT 2, N 25' LT 3 P 01420-01210-00000-000000 B 7/02 55,000 43,270 55,000 .7867 BLK 410 LT 4 P-4 01425-01270-00000-000000 B 6/02 62,000 67,210 62,000 1.0840 BLK 656 PT LT 1 P-3A 01450-02731-00000-000000 B 5/02 41,200 38,650 41,200 .9381 BLK 659-A LTS 8,9 & 20' LT 10 01450-03080-00000-000000 B 2/03 65,000 67,390 65,000 1.0368 BLK 95-L LT 3 MEADOW WOOD SEC 01470-00120-00000-000000 B 5/02 124,000 114,590 124,000 .9241 BLK 95-L LT 5 MEADOW WOOD SEC 01470-00140-00000-000000 O 1/03 121,750 104,110 121,750 .8551 BLK 95-M LT 5,N 20' LT 6 MEADO 01470-00240-00000-000000 O 6/02 125,000 117,580 125,000 .9406 BLK 95-H PT LT 12,PT LT 13 MEA 01490-00380-00000-000000 O 10/02 100,000 106,140 100,000 1.0614 BLK 248-B LT 4 PATTERSON PLACE 01495-00018-00000-000000 B 7/02 80,000 82,550 80,000 1.0319 BLK 41-A LT 2 & 3 ROLLING ACRE 01500-00030-00000-000000 O 7/02 66,000 51,440 66,000 .7794 BLK 42 LT 2,3 ROLLING ACRES P- 01500-00280-00000-000000 O 4/02 87,000 83,770 87,000 .9629 BLK 269 LT 4 UNIVERSITY PARK V 01515-00014-00000-000000 O 11/02 107,500 102,260 107,500 .9513 BLK 96-D LT 6 P-6 01520-00310-00000-000000 B 6/02 49,000 35,800 49,000 .7306DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 6 TIME: 20:34 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 183 Panola 183-902 Carthage CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BLK 96-H LT 8 WESTWOOD 01520-00574-00000-000000 O 1/03 92,000 80,900 92,000 .8793 BLK 96-I PT LT 9-10 WESTWOOD P 01520-00745-00000-000000 O 4/02 77,250 93,280 77,250 1.2075 APPLEGATE ACRES LT 14 P-2-14 01560-00130-00000-000000 B 1/03 92,500 86,790 92,500 .9383 APPLEGATE ACRES LT 43 P-2-43 01560-00390-00000-000000 B 6/02 95,500 77,610 95,500 .8127 WILDWOOD EST LT 22 P-41-23 01600-00210-00000-000000 O 6/02 175,000 170,920 175,000 .9767 WILDWOOD EST LT 36 P-41-36 01600-00340-00000-000000 W 5/02 87,500 99,460 87,500 1.1367 HUNTER CREEK EST TR 11 01615-00110-00000-000000 B 8/02 199,900 177,820 199,900 .8895 LAKE MURVAUL SEC C LT 6-F MH 1 01660-00270-00000-000000 W 7/02 35,500 29,410 35,500 .8285 MURVAUL PINES LT 107 1/77 UND 01665-00650-00000-000000 O 11/02 75,654 106,910 75,654 1.4131 LAKE MURVAUL SEC 1-N PT LT 56 01675-00490-00000-000000 O 8/02 140,000 95,960 140,000 .6854 BLK 9 LT 2 B 1400-00870 C 2/03 90,000 89,740 90,000 .9971 BLK 9 LT 5 1400-00920 C 7/02 79,000 65,150 79,000 .8247 BLK 33 LT 10,11 1400-02020 C 4/02 53,500 47,470 53,500 .8873 BLK 58 LT 11 1405-01050 C 2/03 52,000 43,450 52,000 .8356 BLK 62 LT 3 1405-01540 C 4/02 34,500 31,640 34,500 .9171 BLK 74 LT 7 1405-02470 C 4/02 75,000 46,860 75,000 .6248 BLK 82 LT 14 1405-03780 C 2/03 64,000 44,530 64,000 .6958 BLK 89 LT 11 1405-04330 C 10/02 50,000 43,600 50,000 .8720 BLK 92 PT LT 1,PT 2,PT 14 1405-04390 C 12/02 52,000 33,390 52,000 .6421 BLK 93 PT 3, BLK 94B LT 10 1405-05040 C 7/02 56,000 52,720 56,000 .9414 BLK 109 LT 10 1410-00149 C 9/02 186,000 204,670 186,000 1.1004 BLK 110 PT LT 2, ALL 14 1410-00350 C 9/02 63,650 64,000 63,650 1.0055 BLK 112-D LT 4,51' LT 5 1410-01000 C 1/03 93,500 71,790 93,500 .7678 BLK 112-D W'100 LT 11,PT12 1410-01050 C 9/02 78,000 73,100 78,000 .9372 BLK 112G,112 H PT LT 6,7,8 1410-01130 C 4/02 69,000 66,240 69,000 .9600 BLK 207 LT 5, PT LT 6 1415-00600 C 1/03 43,000 40,760 43,000 .9479 BLK 211 LT 14 1415-01100 C 12/02 43,000 38,340 43,000 .8916 BLK 213 LT 5 1415-01530 C 7/02 53,000 44,690 53,000 .8432 BLK 214 LT 3 1415-01740 C 6/02 35,000 39,750 35,000 1.1357 BLK 217 N 1/2 LT 4, ALL 5 1415-02040 C 1/03 36,500 42,070 36,500 1.1526 BLK 220 LT 6, N 72' LT 5 1415-02180 C 9/02 85,000 88,660 85,000 1.0431 BLK 239-C LT 1 1415-02970 C 9/02 75,000 72,770 75,000 .9703 BLK 239-E PT LT 5, LT 4 1415-03190 C 9/02 46,500 47,870 46,500 1.0295 BLK 239-E LT 7 1415-03210 C 6/02 42,500 37,010 42,500 .8708 BLK 257 LT 19 1420-00830 C 3/03 49,000 53,360 49,000 1.0890 BLK 260 LT 5A 1420-01010 C 6/02 26,500 20,320 26,500 .7668 BLK 422 B PT LT 9,ALL 10 1425-01790 C 2/03 75,000 76,390 75,000 1.0185 BLK 428 ALL 1425-02250 C 6/02 39,500 32,930 39,500 .8337 BLK 416 LT 2 1485-00360 C 2/03 40,000 32,220 40,000 .8055 BLK 416 LT 3 1485-00370 C 6/02 30,600 24,630 30,600 .8049 BLK 248-A LT 14 1495-00012 C 8/02 100,000 88,060 100,000 .8806 BLK 41-A LT 4 1500-00040 C 8/02 43,000 44,420 43,000 1.0330 BLK 242 LT 4 1510-00040 C 6/02 40,000 35,210 40,000 .8803 BLK 96-I PT LT 9,10 1520-00745 C 4/02 77,250 93,280 77,250 1.2075 BLK 96- P LT 2 1520-00890 C 4/02 66,000 71,750 66,000 1.0871 GLENBROOK V. LTS 37-39 1565-00201 C 10/02 125,000 69,390 125,000 .5551 AB 158 S. DUNCAN 158-02070 C 2/03 57,850 52,880 57,850 .9141
DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 7 TIME: 20:34 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 183 Panola 183-902 Carthage CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AB 158 S. DUNCAN 158-02130 C 8/02 55,000 51,570 55,000 .9376 SUNSET ACRES LTS 57,58 1590-00111 C 4/02 19,500 20,580 19,500 1.0554 WILDWOOD EST. LT 15 1600-00150 C 8/02 86,200 95,310 86,200 1.1057 WILDWOOD EST LT 31 1600-00281 C 7/02 125,000 85,260 125,000 .6821 AB 165 J. DAUGHTERY 165-00271 C 12/02 65,000 50,390 65,000 .7752 SEC C LT 1 D 1660-00040 C 8/02 60,000 64,210 60,000 1.0702 SEC 1-N LT 20 1675-00200 C 5/02 68,000 49,330 68,000 .7254 SEC 1-N LT 50 1675-00450 C 4/02 66,000 68,610 66,000 1.0395 SEC 1-N N PT LT 56,PT 57 1675-00490 C 8/02 140,000 95,960 140,000 .6854 SEC 2-N LT 9 1680-00080 C 8/02 30,000 19,150 30,000 .6383 COUNTRY LAKE LT 11,12 1890-00060 C 4/02 215,000 223,870 215,000 1.0413 AB 355 G JANUARY 355-00012 C 1/03 74,000 70,370 74,000 .9509 AB 398 WM LIDDY 398-00806 C 11/02 103,000 103,090 103,000 1.0009 AB 427 A. MOORMAN 427-00530 C 8/02 56,000 39,860 56,000 .7118 AB 427 A. MOORMAN 427-00560 C 11/02 50,000 34,870 50,000 .6974 AB 427 A. MOORMAN 427-00610 C 4/02 95,000 97,170 95,000 1.0228 AB 525 S. PEARCE 525-00080 C 9/02 85,000 67,620 85,000 .7955 AB 525 S. PEARCE 525-00115 C 8/02 65,000 55,450 65,000 .8531 AB 672 W. THOMPSON 672-00281 C 5/02 41,000 44,080 41,000 1.0751 AB 704 G. WEEDEN 704-00128 C 6/02 21,600 22,870 21,600 1.0588 AB 899 J. PARMER 899-00560 C 5/02 38,000 42,000 38,000 1.1053 115 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9227 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AB 1 M ROMERO 00001-00440 00001-00442 0 O 8/02 117,470 130,000 .9036 AB 4 W ANDERSON P-88 00004-01280-00000-000000 W 12/02 30,780 20,000 1.5390 AB 254 E GRISWOLD P-1 00254-00010-00000-000000 O 8/02 40,180 43,500 .9237 AB 275 H HUDSON 00275-00201-00000-000000 W 11/02 21,600 13,500 1.6000 AB 349 A JOHNSON P-10B-17 00349-00460 00349-00470 O 4/02 94,130 84,500 1.1140 AB 387 C LINDSEY P-21 00387-00290 00387-00300 O 12/02 60,000 63,000 .9524 AB 667 WM TAYLOR P-85 00667-00970 00667-00971 O 4/02 167,710 177,500 .9448 AB 708 H WOLF P-6B 00708-00101 00708-00102 O 8/02 129,460 162,500 .7967
DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 8 TIME: 20:34 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 183 Panola 183-902 Carthage CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AB 743 S WHITE P-2 00743-00030-00000-000000 W 12/02 7,620 7,102 1.0729 BLK 656 LT 2 BLK 656 PT LT 3 P 01450-02740 01450-02760 0 O 6/02 174,950 232,000 .7541 AB 121 J. COUGHRAN 121-00232,233 C 3/03 97,620 92,000 1.0611 AB 127/169 CULVER/DECKER 127-110,169-113,620-10 C 1/03 145,780 150,000 .9719 BLK 226 1415-02365 C 4/02 40,050 42,500 .9424 BLK 643 1450-02170 C 7/02 46,360 47,500 .9760 BLK 656 PT LT 1 1450-02720 C 7/02 22,650 25,000 .9060 BLK 606,618,621 1450-540,800,860,861 C 4/02 165,430 196,108 .8436 AB 157 H. DAVIS 157-00210 C 1/03 22,000 35,800 .6145 AB 567 H. RUNNELS I CREEK 1570-00011 C 6/02 18,300 14,000 1.3071 AB 191 A. EVERLY 191-00060 C 2/03 43,280 39,000 1.1097 AB 216 T FORSYTHE 216-00017 C 9/02 8,000 10,000 .8000 AB 278 HUGHES;BLK 238A 278-60;1415-02905 C 6/02 109,530 100,000 1.0953 AB 279 T. HOUGH 279-00174 C 10/02 21,300 18,000 1.1833 AB 295 J. HILL 295-00020,30 C 7/02 66,390 79,000 .8404 AB 330 M. HOFFMAN 330-00060 C 4/02 12,100 12,500 .9680 AB 372 T. KELLY 372-00171,172 C 12/02 81,090 90,000 .9010 AB 422 J. MCADAMS 422-00220,00295 C 5/02 40,320 35,000 1.1520 AB 422 J. MCADAMS 422-00300 C 5/02 18,060 19,855 .9096 AB 423 A. MCFADDIN 423-00151 C 12/02 93,260 96,000 .9715 AB 423 A. MCFADDIN 423-00390 C 4/02 71,590 72,500 .9874 AB 429 H. MCKELVY 429-00430,00431 C 11/02 58,310 56,000 1.0413 AB 435 J. MCADAMS 435-00080 C 9/02 109,300 105,000 1.0410 AB 449 S. MIMMS 449-00010 C 4/02 40,530 32,900 1.2319 AB 46 A. BARR 46-00390 C 4/02 33,220 40,000 .8305 AB 699 E. WHITE 699-00360,361 C 3/03 83,850 89,000 .9421 AB 74 F. BOUNDS 74-00040,50 C 8/02 77,270 70,000 1.1039 AB 773 B. WALLACE(VARIOUS) 773-10(VARIOUS) C 9/02 244,820 214,250 1.1427 AB 83 D. BAKER 83-00070 C 2/03 21,950 26,000 .8442 AB 999 R. W. PREIST 999-00020 C 4/02 52,090 60,000 .8682 38 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9596 CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE.
