DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 1 TIME: 20:12 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 165 Midland 165-901 Midland CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ SE/4 SEC: R000006121 B 7/02 65,000 64,870 66,073 .9818 BLK: 007 R000009922 B 5/02 40,000 40,340 40,900 .9863 BLK: 008 R000010825 B 3/03 164,500 165,670 163,266 1.0147 BLK: 004 R000010876 B 4/02 28,000 30,000 28,714 1.0448 BLK: 007 R000012130 B 6/02 173,227 173,480 176,605 .9823 BLK: 004 R000012418 B 12/02 52,750 56,370 52,829 1.0670 BLK: 005 R000013343 B 7/02 66,640 77,260 67,739 1.1405 BLK: 002 R000013766 B 12/02 115,000 112,670 115,172 .9783 BLK: 010 R000013926 B 3/03 37,000 36,420 36,723 .9918 BLK: 022 R000015935 B 4/02 36,000 31,760 36,918 .8603 BLK: 016 R000016610 B 1/03 62,700 59,030 62,605 .9429 BLK: 005 R000016759 B 12/02 65,000 63,360 65,098 .9733 BLK: 010 R000017898 B 8/02 141,250 116,560 143,157 .8142 BLK: 003 R000018354 B 10/02 95,000 89,870 95,713 .9390 BLK: 022 R000018659 B 6/02 91,500 87,980 93,284 .9431 BLK: 028 R000018785 B 5/02 98,800 90,970 101,023 .9005 BLK: 005 R000019495 B 2/03 56,900 55,300 56,643 .9763 BLK: 007 R000019818 B 7/02 81,000 83,490 82,337 1.0140 BLK: 008 R000021169 B 8/02 101,000 112,910 102,363 1.1030 BLK: 1B R000021574 B 9/02 172,000 176,310 173,806 1.0144 BLK: 2B R000021594 B 6/02 171,300 159,650 174,640 .9142 BLK: 2B R000021613 B 7/02 153,500 156,440 156,033 1.0026 BLK: 014 R000021866 B 2/03 231,000 230,290 229,960 1.0014 BLK: 015 R000021926 B 10/02 208,500 205,000 210,064 .9759 BLK: 015 R000021935 B 11/02 164,900 155,580 165,642 .9393 BLK: 019 R000022072 B 4/02 265,000 248,400 271,757 .9141 BLK: 020 R000022113 B 4/02 270,000 247,730 276,885 .8947 BLK: 012 R000022424 B 8/02 136,250 136,670 138,089 .9897 BLK: 013 R000022474 B 11/02 135,500 128,890 136,110 .9470 BLK: 013 R000022475 B 1/03 137,900 139,530 137,693 1.0133 BLK: 002 R000022564 B 8/02 285,000 243,410 288,847 .8427 BLK: 002 R000022617 B 12/02 185,000 195,960 185,277 1.0577 BLK: 002 R000022628 B 10/02 160,000 169,850 161,200 1.0537 BLK: 001 R000022924 B 1/03 192,500 195,060 192,211 1.0148 BLK: 001 R000022929 B 7/02 218,500 219,160 222,105 .9867 BLK: 002 R000022981 B 5/02 283,500 254,340 289,879 .8774 BLK: 004 R000023059 B 10/02 350,000 327,220 352,625 .9280 BLK: 008 R000023162 B 10/02 194,900 198,810 196,362 1.0125 BLK: 009 R000023221 B 10/02 219,000 225,070 220,642 1.0201 BLK: 010 R000023259 B 8/02 257,000 248,510 260,469 .9541 BLK: 001 R000026144 B 3/03 142,500 122,920 141,431 .8691 BLK: 013 R000026516 B 7/02 80,000 81,330 81,320 1.0001 BLK: 005 R000026774 B 10/02 58,500 62,400 58,938 1.0587 BLK: 014 R000027905 B 7/02 137,450 129,340 139,718 .9257 BLK: 010 R000028286 B 4/02 73,500 72,270 75,374 .9588 BLK: 002 R000028475 B 8/02 94,500 79,860 95,775 .8338 BLK: 008 R000028888 B 6/02 39,000 33,880 39,761 .8521DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 2 TIME: 20:12 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 165 Midland 165-901 Midland CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BLK: 026 R000029187 B 5/02 35,000 35,050 35,788 .9794 BLK: 001 R000030086 B 6/02 90,000 95,050 91,755 1.0359 BLK: 003 R000030280 B 12/02 88,750 79,470 88,883 .8941 BLK: 003 R000030562 B 4/02 121,500 125,550 124,598 1.0076 BLK: 026 R000031180 B 2/03 35,000 30,110 34,843 .8642 BLK: 014 R000031388 B 3/03 85,890 76,160 85,246 .8934 BLK: 004 R000031562 B 9/02 152,000 174,290 153,596 1.1347 BLK: 010 R000031792 B 6/02 278,000 331,570 283,421 1.1699 BLK: 002 R000031983 B 1/03 158,000 142,580 157,763 .9038 BLK: 001 R000032090 B 4/02 320,000 312,330 328,160 .9518 BLK: 005 R000032165 B 12/02 190,000 187,550 190,285 .9856 BLK: 001 R000033168 B 5/02 69,500 70,100 71,063 .9864 BLK: 002 R000033454 B 6/02 68,000 72,750 69,326 1.0494 BLK: 006 R000033550 B 9/02 72,000 74,730 72,756 1.0271 BLK: 015 R000033798 B 4/02 85,000 80,940 87,168 .9286 BLK: 017 R000033837 B 6/02 91,000 92,220 92,775 .9940 BLK: 025 R000033918 B 1/03 65,000 68,410 64,903 1.0540 BLK: 008 R000034715 B 6/02 99,000 98,220 100,930 .9731 BLK: 002 R000036212 B 11/02 92,500 92,500 92,916 .9955 BLK: 054 R000038153 B 5/02 58,500 55,030 59,816 .9200 BLK: 026 R000039349 B 1/03 140,974 136,220 140,763 .9677 BLK: 010 R000039642 B 6/02 127,000 123,170 129,476 .9513 BLK: 013 R000039673 B 5/02 159,000 162,120 162,577 .9972 BLK: 001 R000040087 B 7/02 246,400 241,940 250,465 .9660 BLK: 006 R000040116 B 3/03 109,000 103,400 108,182 .9558 TRACTS 166-168 R000041246 B 11/02 170,000 157,710 170,765 .9235 BLK: 003 R000041457 B 5/02 57,900 56,150 59,202 .9484 BLK: 006 R000042299 B 5/02 198,500 207,130 202,966 1.0205 BLK: 004 R000042394 B 8/02 144,000 137,710 145,944 .9436 BLK: 003 R000042847 B 4/02 74,750 74,110 76,656 .9668 BLK: 001 R000042911 B 7/02 47,500 45,820 48,283 .9490 BLK: 006 R000043611 B 6/02 78,000 75,970 79,521 .9553 BLK: 013 R000043665 B 3/03 76,000 88,780 75,430 1.1770 BLK: 029 R000043918 B 6/02 125,000 122,000 127,437 .9573 BLK: 030 R000043924 B 5/02 111,700 108,500 114,213 .9500 BLK: 039 R000044030 B 3/03 90,000 91,850 89,325 1.0283 BLK: 046 R000044154 B 4/02 73,400 71,840 75,272 .9544 BLK: 004 R000044342 B 6/02 138,500 138,330 141,201 .9797 BLK: 012 R000047505 B 1/03 66,500 62,040 66,400 .9343 BLK: 018 R000047573 B 4/02 76,250 65,410 78,194 .8365 BLK: 001 R000047787 B 4/02 112,000 106,220 114,856 .9248 BLK: 001 R000047792 B 7/02 109,900 106,570 111,713 .9540 BLK: 009 R000048422 B 3/03 74,000 67,830 73,445 .9235 BLK: 003 R000048627 B 8/02 62,000 56,460 62,837 .8985 BLK: 003 R000048637 B 7/02 62,500 54,820 63,531 .8629 BLK: 009 R000049289 B 2/03 32,500 29,440 32,353 .9099 BLK: 002 R000049589 B 4/02 132,000 129,430 135,366 .9561
DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 3 TIME: 20:12 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 165 Midland 165-901 Midland CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BLK: 011 R000050365 B 4/02 360,000 335,450 369,180 .9086 BLK: 069 R000052217 B 3/03 218,000 212,000 216,365 .9798 BLK: 002 R000052590 B 11/02 89,000 76,290 89,401 .8534 BLK: 001 R000052840 B 5/02 105,000 107,700 107,362 1.0031 BLK: 001 R000052841 B 7/02 154,900 139,670 157,456 .8870 BLK: 018 R000053249 B 1/03 52,000 49,340 51,922 .9503 BLK: 005 R000053288 B 10/02 68,500 58,740 69,013 .8511 BLK: 009 R000053866 B 7/02 134,000 120,030 136,211 .8812 BLK: 094 R000054277 B 1/03 68,000 65,920 67,898 .9709 BLK: 142 R000055354 B 12/02 48,000 40,110 48,072 .8344 BLK: 006 R000056398 B 9/02 164,900 141,620 166,631 .8499 BLK: 009 R000056658 B 6/02 76,500 79,230 77,991 1.0159 BLK: 010 R000056673 B 2/03 81,000 79,100 80,636 .9810 BLK: 012 R000056806 B 10/02 87,000 86,750 87,653 .9897 108 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9607 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ NW/4 SEC: R000002988 C 8/02 50,000 47,660 50,000 .9532 NE/4 TR 7 SEC: R000004549 C 3/03 64,000 53,750 64,000 .8398 NW/4 SEC: R000005203 C 1/03 170,000 116,400 138,000 .8400 NE/4 SEC: R000005380 C 9/02 120,000 67,580 120,000 .5632 SE/4 SEC: R000007722 C 4/02 162,000 168,080 162,000 1.0375 BLK: 003 R000009859 C 1/03 75,000 57,470 75,000 .7663 BLK: 005 R000009861 C 11/02 365,000 354,540 365,000 .9713 BLK: 002 R000011520 C 6/02 330,000 531,490 330,000 1.6106 BLK: 002 R000020289 C 9/02 223,990 173,130 193,990 .8900 BLK: 017 R000025891 C 2/03 45,000 53,600 45,000 1.1911 BLK: 008 R000027290 C 12/02 1,690,000 1,742,740 1,690,000 1.0312 BLK: 010 R000031288 C 12/02 500,000 498,460 500,000 .9969
DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 4 TIME: 20:12 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 165 Midland 165-901 Midland CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BLK: 037 R000035188 C 12/02 1,000,000 1,114,800 1,000,000 1.1148 BLK: 059 R000035339 C 8/02 200,000 158,230 146,000 1.0800 BLK: 001 R000036204 C 5/02 55,000 64,120 55,000 1.1658 BLK: 010 R000037207 C 3/03 129,900 154,780 129,900 1.1915 BLK: 002 R000041949 C 8/02 140,000 118,800 140,000 .8486 BLK: 191 R000046186 C 5/02 100,000 92,830 100,000 .9283 BLK: 003 R000046585 C 6/02 65,000 63,580 65,000 .9782 BLK: 005 R000046603 C 12/02 185,000 157,300 185,000 .8503 BLK: 109 R000054578 C 5/02 47,000 65,160 47,000 1.3864 SW/4 R000058380 C 5/02 100,000 139,740 100,000 1.3974 22 SALES CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 32 B-39 T1S R000004257 .00 1.00 .00 2,167,540 1,899,845 1.1400 33 B-39 T1S R000004321 .00 1.00 .00 460,080 426,242 1.0800 1-2 B-2 AMARON R000009471 .00 1.00 .00 600,000 627,957 .9600 13 B-1 ANDREWS PARK R000009494 .00 1.00 .00 661,100 686,329 .9600 1 B-8 CLAYDESTA CHEVRON USA R000013624 .00 1.00 .00 3,777,590 3,410,938 1.1100 1 B-19 ELMWOD DINERO PLAZA R000017757 .00 1.00 .00 2,800,000 2,563,090 1.0900 3 B-45 FAIRMONT PARK R000019015 .00 1.00 .00 3,562,800 3,721,915 .9600 2-4 B-1 GARRETT PLACE R000020669 .00 1.00 .00 593,770 618,906 .9600 1 IMPERIAL HTS R0000266650 .00 1.00 .00 1,813,470 1,913,809 .9500 2 B-E JOHNSON AND MORAN R000027213 .00 1.00 .00 498,440 329,766 1.5100 1 B-2 MIDKIFF PLAZA R000030917 .00 1.00 .00 2,590,400 2,513,390 1.0300 1 B-23 OT R000035111 .00 1.00 .00 865,280 759,863 1.1400 7-9 B-28 OT R000035134 AND R000035132 .00 1.00 .00 4,787,300 4,525,606 1.0600 B-29 OT R000035139 .00 1.00 .00 5,425,000 5,202,541 1.0400 4 B-2 PAVILION PARK R000036771 .00 1.00 .00 789,150 819,076 .9600 21 B-82 PERMIAN ESTATES R000038825 .00 1.00 .00 290,020 303,148 .9600 2A B-10 POLO PARK S-13 R000039632 .00 1.00 .00 4,697,800 4,759,218 .9900 3 B-1 PORRAS R000039713 .00 1.00 .00 721,480 698,235 1.0300 1 B-17 SKYLINE TERRACE MIDLAND R000043793 .00 1.00 .00 24,000,000 22,215,889 1.0800 1 B-17 SKYLINE TERRACE DILLA R000043794 .00 1.00 .00 3,903,770 4,342,550 .9000 1 B-17 SKYLINE TERRACE JC PENN R000043795 .00 1.00 .00 3,997,630 4,019,512 .9900 1A B-2 WESTRIDGE PARK R000051291 .00 1.00 .00 3,420,000 4,006,674 .8500 1 B-3 WESTRIDGE PARK R000051295 .00 1.00 .00 657,890 729,100 .9000 5 B-44 FAIRMONT PARK R000057404 .00 1.00 .00 919,160 1,027,350 .8900 24 APPRAISALS
DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 5 TIME: 20:12 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 165 Midland 165-901 Midland STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0145 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ CIT COMMUNICATIONS P000000069 610,836 615,672 .9900 ABELL HANGER FOUNDATION P000000136 31,180 23,375 1.3300 ACME BRICK P000000187 713,980 726,112 .9800 DAVID ARRINGTON P000000803 38,430 38,432 1.0000 BASS ENTERPRISES P000001326 52,280 52,200 1.0000 BUILDERS AND HOMEOWNERS P000002208 706,720 732,298 .9700 CLAYDESTA P000003081 26,930 22,950 1.1700 FORD MOTOR CREDIT P000005240 2,307,040 1,911,757 1.2100 FREE UNFLOOD P000005369 32,550 33,325 .9800 VERIZON CREDIT P000005542 131,710 112,061 1.1800 GELCO CORP P000005732 5,498,620 5,815,464 .9500 GOLDEN CORRAL P000005922 179,510 249,024 .7200 IBM CREDIT P000007318 454,950 615,104 .7400 IKES RENT TO BUY P000007348 62,200 78,401 .7900 AUS MEX COMPANY P000008328 32,320 25,025 1.2900 LYON FINANCIAL SERVICES P000008962 254,760 249,485 1.0200 BANK OF AMERICA P000010604 594,780 441,266 1.3500 J C PENNEYS P000011438 2,108,390 1,933,161 1.0900 PERMIAN BASIN DIALYSIS P000011493 260,240 199,362 1.3100 PERMIAN RESOURCES P000011594 547,990 475,001 1.1500 PETERSON DL TRUST P000011626 6,089,700 4,871,760 1.2500 SAMS EAST P000013135 5,573,080 5,754,089 .9700 SEARS 2657 P000013394 2,218,200 2,310,892 .9600 STEWART AND STEVENSON P000014262 2,913,050 2,703,031 1.0800 CITICAPITAL COMMERCIAL LEASING P000015395 1,847,310 1,606,356 1.1500 SUMMIT PROPERTIES - AIRPLANE P000015706 5,310,331 5,310,330 1.0000 WASSENBERG CHIROPRACTIC P000015867 21,840 14,569 1.5000 WHEELS INC P000016189 1,488,080 1,526,470 .9700 XEROX P000016668 924,030 1,057,868 .8700 HEALTH SOUTH SPORTS MEDICINE P000020433 962,670 1,046,538 .9200 LOWES 63 P000022294 5,455,690 5,422,996 1.0100 FIFTY FIVE LLC P000022861 5,321,350 5,321,351 1.0000 HOME DEPOT 561 P000023641 4,690,300 4,715,782 .9900 LAMAR ADVERTISING P000024977 364,910 325,641 1.1200 PATEL PV P000026301 2,305,030 2,808,989 .8200 SHOE CARNIVAL 224 P000028074 577,180 615,930 .9400 36 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9915
