DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 16 TIME: 19:51 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 146 Liberty 146-906 Liberty CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 000971 F FRUGER , TRACT 13, AC R101014 B 2/03 35,000 41,260 35,000 1.1789 RYE SMITH & ADAMS TRACT, LT TR R124490 W 4/02 59,000 49,070 59,000 .8317 32 JOS DUNMAN, TR 141, AC 0.50 R13514 W 3/02 30,000 21,230 30,000 .7077 DAVIDGE , BLOCK 1, LOT 3, TRAC R142757 B 4/02 24,100 24,740 24,100 1.0266 PARTLOW L-LIB, BLOCK 1, LOT 8, R144932 C 5/03 75,000 72,890 75,000 .9719 000051 WILLIAM HARRIS, TRACT 6 R15237 C 5/03 83,000 70,170 83,000 .8500 000073 JAMES MARTIN, TRACT 174 R16838 C 1/02 43,401 42,500 43,401 .9792 000091 GEO ORR, TRACT 59, ACRE R17999 B 6/02 131,000 141,310 131,000 1.0787 000125 T D YOACUM, TRACT 127 1 R21207 M C 3/02 43,000 42,630 43,000 .9914 000196 B C FRANKLIN, TRACT 53 R23462 C 7/02 105,000 84,540 105,000 .8100 COUNTRY CLUB, BLOCK 1, LOT PT R35828 B 6/02 102,500 108,670 102,500 1.0602 CAIN, BLOCK 5, LOT 1 2 R36382 C 6/03 44,400 30,910 44,400 .6962 DAVIDGE , BLOCK 3, LOT 13 14 R45966 C 1/02 84,000 92,760 84,000 1.1043 DAVIDGE , BLOCK 3, LOT 15 16 R45967 B 10/02 87,350 79,670 87,350 .9121 DAVIDGE , BLOCK 4, LOT 10, 11 R45977 C 6/03 88,000 73,590 88,000 .8400 EASTLAWN , BLOCK 2, LOT 1 PT 2 R47463 B 10/02 68,900 65,250 68,900 .9470 FOREST HILLS , BLOCK 3 SEC 2, R47970 Y 5/02 122,000 117,660 122,000 .9644 FOREST HILLS , BLOCK 4 SEC 2, R47993 C 7/02 105,000 88,220 105,000 .8402 FOREST HILLS , BLOCK 6 SEC 2, R48031 C 4/03 108,500 94,350 108,500 .8696 LIBERTY INNER BLOCKS , BLOCK 4 R55842 B 4/02 50,000 46,240 50,000 .9248 LIBERTY INNER BLOCKS , BLOCK 1 R55926 B 1/03 55,000 84,750 55,000 1.5409 LIBERTY INNER BLOCKS , BLOCK 1 R55927 C 6/03 89,000 81,230 89,000 .9127 LIBERTY INNER BLOCKS , BLOCK 6 R56190 B 5/02 53,600 50,040 53,600 .9336 LIBERTY INNER BLOCKS , BLOCK 6 R56193 B 3/03 69,400 69,880 69,400 1.0069 LIBERTY INNER BLOCKS , BLOCK 7 R56198 B 3/03 76,000 83,890 76,000 1.1038 LIBERTY INNER BLOCKS , BLOCK 7 R56209 B 11/02 175,000 137,750 175,000 .7871 LIBERTY INNER BLOCKS , BLOCK 1 R56449 B 8/02 89,900 92,780 89,900 1.0320 LIBERTY OUTER BLOCKS , BLOCK 2 R56528 Y 8/02 95,000 108,370 95,000 1.1407 NEWBERRY , LOT 16 PT 15 17 R60237 B 3/03 72,000 71,510 72,000 .9932 OAK FOREST , LOT PT 40 41, ACR R62700 C 5/02 72,420 73,480 72,420 1.0100 OAK FOREST , LOT 43 44, PT 42, R62702 B 1/03 185,000 159,120 185,000 .8601 OAKS REPLAT , BLOCK 3 SEC 1, L R62983 B 12/02 80,000 78,230 80,000 .9779 PARTLOW L-LIB, BLOCK 1, LOT 1 R63286 C 2/02 76,000 77,080 76,000 1.0142 PARTLOW L-LIB, BLOCK 1, LOT 6 R63289 C 4/02 145,000 115,280 145,000 .7950 PARTLOW L-LIB, BLOCK 12, LOT 1 R63349 Y 6/02 102,500 103,840 102,500 1.0131 PARTLOW L-LIB, BLOCK 20, LOT P R63404 C 9/02 50,000 46,450 50,000 .9290 PARTLOW L-LIB, BLOCK 24, LOT 4 R63437 C 5/03 54,500 40,480 54,500 .7428 PARTLOW L-LIB, BLOCK 24 TR 1 2 R63447, R63445 M C 6/03 54,900 41,970 54,900 .7645 PARTLOW L-LIB, BLOCK 26, LOT P R63454 C 6/03 37,620 28,200 37,620 .7496 PINE PLACE , LOT 4 5 R63908 B 4/02 96,500 101,980 96,500 1.0568 PINE PLACE , LOT 31 R63935 C 5/03 94,000 97,440 94,000 1.0366 PIRTLE # 1 , LOT PT 12 R64406 B 5/02 35,000 30,420 35,000 .8691 PIRTLE # 2 , LOT PT 19 R64416 W 11/02 40,000 24,340 40,000 .6085 RIDGEWOOD , LOT 40 41 R65223 B 11/02 120,000 120,480 120,000 1.0040 RYE SMITH & ADAMS TRACT , LOT R65537 C 11/02 95,000 66,040 95,000 .6952 SAN JACINTO PARK , LOT 26 (L-8 R67270 Y 6/02 35,000 41,570 35,000 1.1877 TRINITY RIVER RETREAT , LOT 47 R72827, R72828 MU M Y 12/02 35,000 29,100 30,770 .9500DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 17 TIME: 19:51 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 146 Liberty 146-906 Liberty CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ TRINITY RIVER RETREAT , LOT 54 R72836 B 5/02 68,500 66,820 68,500 .9755 TRINITY RIVER RETREAT , LOT 13 R72906 C 2/03 72,800 68,160 72,800 .9363 TRAVIS PARK , LOT 80 SEC 1 R73161 B 3/03 110,000 99,130 110,000 .9012 TRAVIS PARK RESERVE , LOT 96, R73177 C 8/02 92,500 107,430 92,500 1.1614 TRAVIS PARK RESERVE , LOT 101, R73181 B 12/02 215,000 203,100 215,000 .9447 TREETOP TERRACE , LOT 35, ACRE R73222 B 11/02 74,500 67,710 74,500 .9089 TREETOP TERRACE , LOT 42, ACRE R73230 B 12/02 70,924 71,970 70,924 1.0147 TREETOP TERRACE , LOT 45 R73233 B 6/02 69,000 69,920 69,000 1.0133 WHITTINGTON EXT-B, LOT 5, PT 6 R74438 B 4/02 58,000 57,470 58,000 .9909 WOODSLAWN , BLOCK A, LOT 2 R75748 Y 8/02 52,250 63,650 52,250 1.2182 ZICKEFOOSE, LOT 16, ACRES 5.83 R76358 B 12/02 120,000 114,600 120,000 .9550 000125 T D YOACUM, TRACT 156, R92088 M B 4/02 46,500 51,740 46,500 1.1127 REGENCY PLACE, LOT 31 R95902 B 6/02 127,000 116,910 127,000 .9206 REGENCY PLACE, LOT 56 R95927 B 5/02 130,000 130,640 130,000 1.0049 61 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9363 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 000032 JOS DUNMAN, TRACT PT 13 R13507, R13508 C 9/02 38,250 33,500 1.1418 000091 GEO ORR, TRACT 273, ACR R144019 C 7/02 30,900 37,511 .8238 000104 J E SELF, TRACT 35, ACR R18847 C 6/02 24,000 21,000 1.1429 000270 H&TC-167, TRACT 16, ACR R25589 B 12/02 60,560 63,750 .9500 000330 WM PHELPS, TRACT 1, ACR R26889 B 7/02 342,070 350,000 .9773 000348 T T SEELEY, TRACT 1, AC R27620 B 6/03 196,610 198,000 .9930 6 SALES CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER APPR VAL APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 18 TIME: 19:51 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 146 Liberty 146-906 Liberty CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER APPR VAL APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ IMP ONLY M/H A-125, YOACUM, LA M142015 EM 24,960 21,261 1.1700 32 J DUNMAN, TR 143 R13515 140,140 134,626 1.0400 91 G ORR, TR 42 R17982 E 66,060 62,995 1.0500 125 T D YOACUM, TR 150 R21230 E 48,880 43,373 1.1300 LIBERTY OUTER BLOCKS, BLOCK O- R57068 E 18,630 19,201 .9700 5 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0059 CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 91 GEO ORR, TR 163 R18121 W 7/02 200,000 251,300 200,000 1.2565 000196 B C FRANKLIN, TRACT 13, R23426 B 4/03 200,000 200,880 200,000 1.0044 HAYES , LOT 6 7 8 R52943 B 1/03 225,000 214,220 225,000 .9521 LIBERTY INNER BLOCKS , BLOCK 3 R56063 B 3/03 335,000 311,060 335,000 .9285 LIBERTY INNER BLOCKS , BLOCK 3 R56068 Y 1/02 80,000 79,820 80,000 .9978 LIBERTY OUTER BLOCKS , BLOCK 1 R56717 C 1/03 101,840 113,260 101,840 1.1121 LIBERTY OUTER BLOCKS , BLOCK 1 R56722 B 3/03 170,000 158,810 170,000 .9342 RYE SMITH & ADAMS TRACT , LOT R65520 C 1/02 105,000 87,120 105,000 .8297 8 SALES CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ SLAY STRIP, LT TR 24 26, AC 0. R100937 .00 1.00 .00 58,960 54,927 1.0700 ABSHIER TRACT, BLK A, LT 22 29 R103023 .00 1.00 .00 105,040 92,711 1.1300 GEO ORR, TR 236 R104936 .00 1.00 .00 2,932,670 2,861,363 1.0200 91 GEO ORR, TR 246, UDI 26% R117273 .00 1.00 .00 460,650 497,210 .9300 000091 GEO ORR, TRACT 262, ACR R126808 .00 1.00 .00 46,320 43,243 1.0700 000356 N TWN LIBERTY, TR 51 53 R130188 .00 1.00 .00 88,320 82,196 1.0700 73 J MARTIN, TR 457 R131045 .00 1.00 .00 221,910 268,281 .8300 BLI LIBERTY LTD SUBD, LOT 2 R143335 .00 1.00 .00 749,630 899,554 .8300 GEO ORR, TRACT 207 R18163 .00 1.00 .00 1,699,690 1,881,400 .9000 196 B C FRANKLIN, TR 38, ACRES R23452 .00 1.00 .00 142,430 138,549 1.0300 CAIN, BLOCK O-14, LOT 33 34 R36449 .00 1.00 .00 48,300 46,166 1.0500 LIBERTY INNER BLOCKS, BLOCK 18 R55978 .00 1.00 .00 148,180 154,344 .9600
DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 19 TIME: 19:51 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 146 Liberty 146-906 Liberty CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LIBERTY INNER BLOCKS, BLOCK 32 R56061 .00 1.00 .00 1,183,190 1,170,772 1.0100 LIBERTY OUTER BLOCKS, BLOCK O- R56710 .00 1.00 .00 546,760 566,592 .9600 LIBERTY OUTER BLOCKS, BLOCK 15 R56712 .00 1.00 .00 1,025,740 1,137,104 .9000 LIBERTY OUTER BLOCKS, BLOCK O- R56858 .00 1.00 .00 275,620 288,609 .9500 16 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9688 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ PRODUCTION EQUIPMENT SUPPLY P102176 158,909 141,948 1.1200 WALMART 1186 P107109 4,922,489 4,951,680 .9900 HEB PANTRY FOODS P109321 1,171,935 1,171,935 1.0000 RENT A CENTER P112683 90,343 67,354 1.3400 MAS AMIGOS P115874 43,310 72,477 .6000 DOLLAR GENERAL 1653 P120594 374,943 368,075 1.0200 AUTO ZONE P123709 397,738 387,044 1.0300 LEASE PLAN USA P125985 347,510 343,956 1.0100 BAYTOWN SEAFOOD P126959 14,360 28,100 .5100 PALAIS ROYAL 244 P127174 400,655 413,446 .9700 SEARS ROEBUCK & CO P127220 190,035 190,357 1.0000 TRACTOR SUPPLY 462 P133347 674,467 698,596 .9700 BURGER KING P133349 167,926 180,887 .9300 GOLDEN CORRAL P138101 117,870 169,500 .7000 WESTERN FINANCE & LEASE P142465 71,540 69,497 1.0300 ALLISON FUNERAL SERVICE P76388 114,940 120,336 .9600 O'REILLY AUTO PARTS P76847 266,110 303,307 .8800 GOLDEN FURNITURE SHOWROOM P76913 425,740 561,080 .7600 CHEVRON DISTRIBUTOR P76987 288,270 278,788 1.0300 SHERWIN WILLIAMS CO 7002 P77613 160,440 164,366 .9800 SONIC DRIVE INN P77668 14,310 39,790 .3600 XEROX LEASED EQUIPMENT P81036 70,416 58,915 1.2000 TEXACO FOOD MART & STATION P92857 56,610 53,504 1.0600 23 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9496
