DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 6 TIME: 19:51 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 146 Liberty 146-902 Dayton CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LAKEVIEW, SEC 3, BLOCK 1, LOT R103636 M C 3/02 29,000 35,000 29,000 1.2069 LAKEVIEW, SEC 3, BLOCK 3, LOT R103698 W 11/02 110,000 102,100 110,000 .9300 PINE PLACE, BLOCK 1, LOT 4, AC R103700 B 5/02 94,762 92,110 94,762 .9720 PINE PLACE, BLOCK 2, LOT 2, AC R103711 W 5/02 105,000 100,420 105,000 .9564 LAKEVIEW, SEC 3, BLOCK 4, LOT R103723 B 6/02 102,000 92,340 102,000 .9053 RIVERBOAT BEND, SEC 1, BLOCK 2 R107825 M B 3/03 66,300 65,310 66,300 .9851 SUBURBAN ACRES, SEC 1, LOT PT R110293 C 6/03 93,500 91,580 93,500 .9795 WEST WOODLAND HILLS, LOT 27, A R111316 B 10/02 87,500 76,510 87,500 .8744 WOODLAND HILLS VI, BLOCK 1, LO R111349 M W 2/02 30,000 37,030 30,000 1.2343 WOODLAND HILLS VI, BLOCK 1, LO R111352 M B 7/02 39,000 49,290 39,000 1.2638 WOODLAND HILLS VI, BLOCK 3, LO R111437 M B 6/02 66,900 55,820 66,900 .8344 000172 J DORSETT, TRACT 124, A R115679 M C 1/02 30,000 21,920 30,000 .7307 WEST WOODLAND HILLS III, BLK 9 R117405 M B 8/02 83,475 78,840 83,475 .9445 WEST WOODLAND HILLS III, BLOCK R117406 C 1/03 128,000 113,920 128,000 .8900 WEST WOODLAND HILLS III, BLOCK R117455 M W 7/02 25,000 30,840 25,000 1.2336 JONES ZACK-DAY, BLOCK 3, LOT 7 R119101 B 3/03 102,000 101,950 102,000 .9995 BROWN TRAIL, SEC 2, LOT 10, AC R119636 B 1/03 132,500 132,890 132,500 1.0029 INDIAN RIDGE, SEC 1, LOT 44, A R125053 M C 1/03 70,000 75,910 70,000 1.0844 STILSON-HILL, LOT PT 33, TRACT R129079 B 10/02 140,000 124,880 140,000 .8920 000957 E P MILLER #30 , TRACT R131567 M B 1/03 73,900 78,160 73,900 1.0576 OAKS OF TRINITY, SEC 1, BLOCK R134989 B 5/02 149,000 146,850 149,000 .9856 OAKS OF TRINITY, SEC 1, BLOCK R135020 B 10/02 148,500 148,250 148,500 .9983 OAKS OF TRINITY, SEC 1, BLOCK R135072 B 4/02 201,000 217,950 201,000 1.0843 CHARLES LESLIE WALLACE SUBD, L R135074 M Y 3/02 30,000 29,740 30,000 .9913 SOUTH WOODLAND HILLS, SEC 2, B R138068 M B 12/02 120,950 90,030 120,950 .7444 OAK RIDGE, SEC 1, LOT 17, ACRE R139078 Y 8/02 85,000 76,770 85,000 .9032 OAKWOOD, SEC 1, LOT 45, ACRES R139754 B 4/02 129,900 123,930 129,900 .9540 INDIAN SPRINGS, BLOCK 3, LOT 3 R141836 C 10/02 81,750 80,020 81,750 .9800 HIGH MEADOWS-4 DAY, BLOCK 9, L R142963 B 7/02 102,000 94,640 102,000 .9278 THE MEADOWS, LOT 28, ACRES 0.1 R143286 B 11/02 97,300 100,460 97,300 1.0325 THE MEADOWS, LOT 29, ACRES 0.1 R143287 B 11/02 99,265 95,950 99,265 .9666 THE MEADOWS, LOT 31, ACRES 0.1 R143289 B 7/02 97,480 98,150 97,480 1.0069 THE MEADOWS, LOT 32, ACRES 0.1 R143290 B 8/02 98,900 106,030 98,900 1.0721 JONES ZACK-DAY, LOT 75, ACRES R144427 C 3/03 115,000 130,850 115,000 1.1378 43 REASON GREEN, TRACT 143, AC R14704 W 6/02 93,700 83,080 93,700 .8867 000119 J A WILLIAMS, TRACT 35, R20916 C 4/02 160,000 159,660 160,000 .9979 000119 J A WILLIAMS, TRACT 55 R20925 B 6/02 182,000 179,080 182,000 .9840 122 ROBERT WISEMAN, TR 92, AC1 R21055 W 11/02 83,000 90,520 83,000 1.0906 000172 J DORSETT, TRACT 2, ACR R22847 C 12/02 115,000 93,380 115,000 .8120 266 H&TC-115, TR 48, MH SERIAL R25486 M W 10/02 50,000 30,650 50,000 .6130 000286 IG&N-8, TRACT 2, ACRES R25877 B 8/02 85,000 66,340 85,000 .7805 000490 ED PRUITT-138, TRACT 9, R30197 B 7/02 112,500 103,800 112,500 .9227 000714 B F STRAWBRIDGE, TRACT R31042 B 10/02 57,000 61,190 57,000 1.0735 BENTON, BLOCK 6, LOT 2 R35089 Y 4/02 72,000 71,910 72,000 .9988 BERRY , LOT PT 4 R35115 C 3/02 30,400 30,800 30,400 1.0132 DAYTON, BLOCK 6, LOT 1, TRACT R46238 B 10/02 72,500 72,190 72,500 .9957 DAYTON, BLOCK 6, LOT 1, TRACT R46244 C 10/02 50,000 42,680 50,000 .8536DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 7 TIME: 19:51 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 146 Liberty 146-902 Dayton CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ DAYTON, BLOCK 9, LOT 1 TR 9, A R46355 C 3/03 67,500 51,660 67,500 .7653 DAYTON HEIGHTS , BLOCK 2, LOT R47034 Y 4/02 78,000 79,150 78,000 1.0147 DAYTON DEVELOPMENT , BLOCK 3, R47061 B 12/02 119,500 117,540 119,500 .9836 ENTZMINGER , BLOCK C, LOT PT 1 R47918 B 5/02 65,000 60,090 65,000 .9245 ENTZMINGER , BLOCK C, LOT PT 1 R47920 B 12/02 69,000 72,570 69,000 1.0517 HIGH MEADOWS, SEC 3, BLOCK 9, R53067 C 4/02 135,000 102,900 135,000 .7622 HILLCREST , LOT 8, ACRES 0.275 R53125 C 8/02 100,900 98,990 100,900 .9811 JONES ZACK-DAY, BLOCK 3, LOT T R53956 B 7/02 58,000 59,720 58,000 1.0297 JONES ZACK-DAY, BLOCK 3, LOT T R53983 B 6/02 99,700 108,000 99,700 1.0832 LAKEVIEW, SEC 1, BLK 3, LT 10, R55628 M W 4/02 27,000 34,040 27,000 1.2607 LIBERTY PINES , BLOCK 1, LOT 6 R57372 C 4/02 192,000 197,580 192,000 1.0291 LINNEY CREEK RANCH, SEC 1, LOT R57413 B 5/02 140,000 143,970 140,000 1.0284 LITTLE JOHN , LOT 34 SEC II R57489 B 4/02 141,000 137,300 141,000 .9738 MAYSVILLE , BLOCK 24 25, LOT T R58793 C 2/02 40,000 47,020 40,000 1.1755 MEADOW GLEN, LOT 49, ACRES 0.4 R59330 Y 1/02 20,000 20,410 20,000 1.0205 NORTH PARK , BLOCK 7, LOT 9, A R60619 C 11/02 76,000 82,300 76,000 1.0829 OAK MEADOWS , BLOCK 2, SEC 1, R60908 M C 1/02 51,850 51,520 51,850 .9936 OAK RIDGE, SEC 1, LOT TRACT 27 R61061 M B 12/02 34,900 34,600 34,900 .9914 SOUTH DAYTON OAKS , LOT 5, MH R68550 M C 2/03 60,000 58,650 60,000 .9775 STERLING, SEC 2, LOT 44, LOT P R69203 C 11/02 139,000 114,060 139,000 .8206 STERLING INVESTMENTS , BLOCK 3 R69229 C 2/02 49,900 51,780 49,900 1.0377 SUBURBAN ACRES, SEC 1, LOT 6, R69663 C 3/03 124,900 107,000 124,900 .8567 SUBURBAN ACRES, SEC 1, LOT 10, R69667 C 3/02 138,000 158,320 138,000 1.1472 SUBURBAN ACRES, SEC 2, BLOCK 1 R69674 B 9/02 70,000 71,880 70,000 1.0269 WEST LAKE , LOT B-4, ACRES 6.0 R73360 C 6/02 169,950 160,170 169,950 .9425 WEST PARK , LOT 8 SEC 1 R73515 C 1/03 90,200 85,940 90,200 .9528 WEST PARK , LOT 9, SEC 1 R73516 B 5/02 81,000 82,980 81,000 1.0244 WEST PARK , LOT 38 SEC 1 R73545 B 5/02 77,250 81,200 77,250 1.0511 WINTER VALLEY , LOT 64, ACRES R73651 B 10/02 151,500 151,150 151,500 .9977 WINTER VALLEY , LOT 427, ACRES R73869 B 5/02 102,000 75,450 102,000 .7397 WEST ACRES , BLOCK A, LOT 2 R73911 B 8/02 68,500 57,710 68,500 .8425 WEST ACRES , BLOCK A, LOT 10 R73919 B 4/02 70,000 84,920 70,000 1.2131 WOODRIDGE PARK , LOT TRACT 1-A R75579 Y 8/02 185,000 168,050 185,000 .9084 WOODRIDGE PARK , LOT TRACT 24 R75603 B 5/02 235,000 200,620 235,000 .8537 WOODWAY, SEC 2, BLOCK 5, LOT 9 R76040 M C 3/02 60,000 43,950 60,000 .7325 LAKEVIEW, SEC 1, BLOCK 2, LOT R92534 M B 3/03 51,500 55,460 51,500 1.0769 MEADOWOOD S/D, LOT 11, MH LABE R96250 M B 8/02 135,260 100,130 135,260 .7403 84 SALES WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9601 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE.
DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 8 TIME: 19:51 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 146 Liberty 146-902 Dayton CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ T&NO-74, BLOCK 12, LOT TRACT 1 R108671 B 6/02 52,450 64,500 .8132 000383 T&NO-5, TRACT 17, ACRES R124968 B 4/02 25,000 30,000 .8333 DAYTON, BLOCK 46, LOT PT 1, TR R126504, R46903 C 8/02 11,640 10,000 1.1640 SECURITY TRUST , LOT 29 TR 1, R136984 C 5/02 71,170 81,000 .8786 000258 H&TC-131, TRACT 13 (GIN R140482 C 1/03 45,870 48,500 .9458 000060 D L KOKERNOT, TRACT 34 R142223 B 4/02 45,770 43,900 1.0426 000060 D L KOKERNOT, TRACT 37 R142226 B 6/02 45,640 45,900 .9943 000060 D L KOKERNOT, TRACT 38 R142227 B 6/02 45,550 41,310 1.1026 000634 HT&B-7, TRACT 21, ACRES R142848 C 5/02 50,740 108,000 .4698 000088 E MUNSON, TRACT 102, AC R142888 C 7/02 30,530 42,500 .7184 000288 IG&N-7, TRACT 73, ACRES R142941 B 5/02 33,930 42,500 .7984 000060 D L KOKERNOT, TRACT 47 R143123 - 28 B 6/02 137,120 342,500 .4004 000088 E MUNSON, TRACT PT 103, R143708, R142966 C 9/02 62,340 70,000 .8906 000088 E MUNSON, TRACT PT 104, R143709, R143129 C 7/02 68,340 70,000 .9763 000197 R GREEN, TRACT 153, ACR R23616 Y 4/02 10,010 12,500 .8008 207 JAMES HANEY, TR PT 8, AC 5 R23830, R23831, R23865 E B 9/02 40,020 45,900 .8719 000295 IG&N-32, TRACT 5 16 19, R26066, R26070 E B 7/02 93,610 115,000 .8140 000714 B F STRAWBRIDGE, TRACT R31043 B 11/02 18,530 15,500 1.1955 A-754, TR 1, AC 39.370, A-747, R31324, R31306, R90718, R C 10/02 181,910 210,840 .8628 000957 E P MILLER #30 , TRACT R32352 EM Y 6/02 110,030 108,000 1.0188 MAYSVILLE , BLOCK 4, LOT TRACT R58543 C 5/02 32,900 37,310 .8818 000045 T J HAGGERTY, TRACT 22, R94079 Y 6/02 71,810 150,000 .4787 MEADOWOOD S/D, LOT 49, ACRES 1 R96288 B 8/02 20,000 30,000 .6667 23 SALES CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER APPR VAL APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ A-33 WM EVERETT, TR PT 33 R13653 E 31,290 25,149 1.2400 A-43 R GREEN, TR 88 R14656 E 72,930 69,066 1.0600 A-493 R PRUITT-116, TR 4, AC 5 R30253 E 96,510 89,268 1.0800 A-714 BF STRAWBRIDGE, TR 42, M R31083 EM 44,970 41,255 1.0900 841 GEORGE ARMSTRONG TR 12 MH R319133 E 58,440 57,133 1.0200 MAYSFILLE, BK 63, LT TR 2, AC R58999 E 235,540 220,195 1.0700 T&NO-74, BK 15, LT TR 1, AC 16 R70047 E 373,650 368,469 1.0100 7 APPRAISALS WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .8415 CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE.
DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 9 TIME: 19:51 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 146 Liberty 146-902 Dayton CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE.
