Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   6/27/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:      1
TIME:     19:16                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             112  Hopkins
                                                         112-901  Sulphur Springs

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  A 1    TR 12-14   SURDIKES LEV   R000063                    B       2/03         54,800          44,450        54,800     .8100
  LT4    BLK311  1   3  ADDN: HI   R001731                    C       7/02         37,000          38,880        37,000    1.0500
  LT7    BLK216  4  ADDN: WOODBR   R001734                    B       8/02         52,500          38,790        52,500     .7389
  LT1    BLK215  1  ADDN: HIGHLA   R001826                    C       6/02        112,000         108,310       112,000     .9671
  LT26   BLK210  100 1  ADDN: CE   R001936                    B      12/02         41,500          41,650        41,500    1.0000
  A 160 TR 176  SURCLARK JOHN  0   R001951                    C       5/02         36,570          30,070        36,570     .8200
  LT11   BLK73   TOWN: SULPHUR S   R001964                    C       9/02         66,500          55,380        66,500     .8300
  LT1    BLK211  6   1  ADDN: GR   R001971                    C       1/03         34,000          27,350        34,000     .8000
  LT   2    BLK   20   100    AD   R002062                    C       7/02         30,000          27,640        30,000     .9200
  LT1    BLK47   2  ADDN: CALDWE   R002079                    C       9/02         44,000          45,170        44,000    1.0266
  LT   7    BLK   PHASE I ADDN     R002104                    B       7/02         94,000          90,740        94,000     .9653
  LT8A   BLK209  TOWN: SULPHUR S   R002176                    C       1/03         79,000          79,310        79,000    1.0039
  LT11   BLK200  2  ADDN: LEE HI   R002226                    C       4/02         54,000          54,540        54,000    1.0100
  A: 432  LT8    ADDN: PLEASANT    R002243                    B       8/02         57,500          36,440        57,500     .6300
  A 352  TR 1-22    SURGAVIN JAM   R002334                    C       7/02         33,000          26,450        33,000     .8000
  LT2    BLK202  ADDN: DANIELS 0   R002341                    B      10/02         56,700          57,440        56,700    1.0100
  LT59   BLKPHASE 4 ADDN: BRIARW   R002510                    C       4/02         28,500          30,590        28,500    1.0700
  A 372  TR 1-04    SURGRACE GEO   R002564                    C       6/02         32,800          25,810        32,800     .7900
  LT11 & PT 6B  BLK21   TOWN: SU   R002613                    C       1/03         87,110          83,680        87,110     .9606
  LT2    BLK209  1  ADDN: TURNAG   R002702                    C       9/02         43,000          43,710        43,000    1.0165
  LT1    BLK83   ADDN: HURLEY  0   R002729                    B       7/02         35,000          44,030        35,000    1.2580
  LT2    BLK214  1  ADDN: GREEN    R002741                    C       8/02         57,500          54,850        57,500     .9539
  LT64   BLKPHASE 4 ADDN: BRIARW   R002800                    B       4/02         38,000          39,710        38,000    1.0500
  LT36   BLK201  TOWN: SULPHUR S   R002905                    B       6/02         28,000          28,530        28,000    1.0200
  LT7    BLK607  100 1  ADDN: ST   R002943                    C       7/02         75,000          75,980        75,000    1.0131
  LT10   BLK216  5  ADDN: WOODBR   R003069                    C       5/02         63,900          56,100        63,900     .8800
  LT3    BLK211  3   1  ADDN: GR   R003109                    B       1/03         27,500          26,080        27,500     .9500
  LT6    BLK201  TOWN: SULPHUR S   R003119                    B      12/02         43,000          41,510        43,000     .9700
  LT2    BLK201  ADDN: VITITOW 0   R003134                    C       6/02         18,000          31,030        18,000    1.7200
  A 352  TR PT 1    SURGAVIN JAM   R003674                    C       9/02         77,500          64,750        77,500     .8400
  A 457 & AB 458   TR 4    SURHI   R004211                    C       5/02         42,000          32,960        42,000     .7800
  A 1    TR 10-23   SURDIKES LEV   R004239                    B      10/02         43,900          42,210        43,900     .9600
  LT17   BLK211 110 3   ADDN: MO   R004258                    B      10/02         58,000          58,750        58,000    1.0129
  LT1B   BLK203  TOWN: SULPHUR S   R004438                    C       4/02        123,500          90,440       123,500     .7323
  LT13B  BLK34   2  TOWN: SULPHU   R004641                    B       7/02         39,900          37,780        39,900     .9500
  LOT 14 BLK 56 SULPHUR SPRINGS    R004652                    O       3/03         65,000          66,460        65,000    1.0225
  LOT 7 BLK 56 MORRIS              R004737                    O       3/03         79,500          78,360        79,500     .9857
  LT7 & 8   A 1186    ADDN: SAND   R004764                    C       5/02         42,500          39,980        42,500     .9400
  LOT 5C BLK 64 SULPHUR SPRINGS    R004869                    O       3/03         56,000          54,490        56,000     .9730
  A 1020    TR 5-33    SURWETMOR   R004999                    C       9/02         60,000          61,680        60,000    1.0300
  LT   4D & 5A BLK   24  2   TOW   R005228                    C       8/02         49,220          43,430        49,220     .8824
  LT   PT 1    BLK   233  TOWN:    R005244                    B       8/02         81,500          81,910        81,500    1.0100
  LT9    BLK215  ADDN: SULPHUR S   R005245                    C       8/02         79,900          82,060        79,900    1.0270
  LT4    BLK215  1  ADDN: HIGHLA   R005356                    C      11/02         69,900          63,380        69,900     .9100
  LT8    BLK101  4  ADDN: WEST O   R005391                    C       7/02         76,000          65,020        76,000     .8555
  LOT 6 BLK 101 WEST OAKS          R005467                    O       3/03        106,000         108,080       106,000    1.0196
  LT6    A 1186    ADDN: SANDY R   R005477                    C      10/02         95,900          84,640        95,900     .8826

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 2 TIME: 19:16 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 112 Hopkins 112-901 Sulphur Springs CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LT12A BLK27 2 TOWN: SULPHU R005517 B 7/02 105,000 100,000 105,000 .9524 LT14 BLK23 300 3 ADDN: WE R005553 B 7/02 87,000 84,390 87,000 .9700 LT7A & EPT LT 7 BLK201 TOWN: R005563 C 11/02 105,000 104,890 105,000 .9990 LT14 15 BLK212 ADDN: MCCANN R005619 B 5/02 36,000 36,040 36,000 1.0000 LT1 & LT 4 BLK504 TOWN: SU R005798 C 9/02 69,000 67,770 69,000 .9822 LT5 BLK31 3 10 ADDN: BE R005807 C 7/02 52,000 52,820 52,000 1.0200 LTPT LT 2 AKA LT 2B1BLK24 1 R005809 B 7/02 40,000 41,540 40,000 1.0400 LT S PT 8 BLK 34 2 2 R005816 B 8/02 63,000 63,620 63,000 1.0098 A 199 TR 11 SURCAWTHRON R O R005834 C 4/02 87,000 83,230 87,000 .9567 LT13R BLK215 1 ADDN: HIGHLA R005848 B 9/02 76,900 76,200 76,900 .9909 LT23 BLK216 5 ADDN: WOODBR R005922 B 6/02 80,000 80,020 80,000 1.0000 A 1082 TR 4 SURWINN JOHN R006010 C 6/02 38,000 40,010 38,000 1.0500 LT21C BLK54 2 TOWN: SULPHU R006015 C 7/02 40,500 41,510 40,500 1.0200 LT3 BLK201 30 ADDN: BEEZLE R006027 C 4/02 59,850 61,430 59,850 1.0264 LT2 BLK211 7 A ADDN: GR R006035 C 10/02 65,000 68,020 65,000 1.0500 LT14B & 27A AKA LTS 4 & 5 BE R006104 C 4/02 82,000 83,810 82,000 1.0221 LT5 BLK221 2 ADDN: PATTER R006108 C 9/02 65,000 67,620 65,000 1.0403 LT10 BLK221 2 ADDN: PATTER R006136 B 10/02 52,500 55,910 52,500 1.0600 LT1 BLK48 2 3 ADDN: DO R006214 C 6/02 53,575 54,310 53,575 1.0137 A 585 TR PT TR 39 SURMITCH R006215 C 12/02 84,800 89,320 84,800 1.0500 A 591 TR 1 SURMILLER BENJ R006221 B 1/03 87,500 85,360 87,500 .9755 LT13 BLK211 110 1 ADDN: MO R006257 C 5/02 59,900 52,570 59,900 .8800 LT1R BLK216 5 ADDN: WOODBR R006276 C 8/02 52,980 48,080 52,980 .9100 LT28 BLK1 TOWN: SULPHUR S R006315 C 12/02 53,000 51,930 53,000 .9798 A 1069 & 1076 & 279 TR 2 S R006316 C 4/02 50,000 46,930 50,000 .9400 LT8 BLK201 30 ADDN: BEEZLE R006341 C 5/02 67,000 67,990 67,000 1.0148 LT13 & PT 12 BLK511 ADDN: WH R006356 C 12/02 57,500 57,230 57,500 1.0000 LT3 BLK421 TOWN: SULPHUR S R006396 B 10/02 60,500 56,370 60,500 .9300 LT 6 BLK 208 ADDN DAVIDSON R006534 O 10/02 45,000 45,360 45,000 1.0080 A 890 TR 5 SURSMITH WM R006538 C 8/02 60,000 60,890 60,000 1.0148 LT17 BLK216 1 ADDN: WOODBR R006576 C 10/02 66,000 66,100 66,000 1.0015 LT6 BLK48 6 5 ADDN: J R006581 B 4/02 37,000 39,240 37,000 1.0600 LT18 & 19 BLK101 6 ADDN: WES R006585 C 11/02 157,500 155,350 157,500 .9900 LT6A BLK21 TOWN: SULPHUR S R006607 B 9/02 33,250 35,080 33,250 1.0600 LT16 BLK47 1 6 ADDN: SM R006653 B 6/02 78,000 72,640 78,000 .9300 LT2 BLK210 100 1 ADDN: CE R006667 C 10/02 49,000 45,220 49,000 .9200 LT1D BLK93 TOWN: SULPHUR S R006675 B 8/02 63,200 59,460 63,200 .9400 BLK609 LT2 ADDN: J G KENNE R006684 C 1/03 72,000 72,720 72,000 1.0100 LT12J & K BLK27 2 TOWN: SUL R006712 C 10/02 101,500 90,110 101,500 .8900 A 40 TR 74-01 SURBALLANOVA R006736 B 12/02 90,000 97,570 90,000 1.0800 LT4A BLK86 TOWN: SULPHUR S R006741 C 5/02 112,500 111,510 112,500 .9900 A 689 TR 28-02 SURNORRIS SA R006756 B 1/03 105,000 104,000 105,000 .9900 A 1 TR 12-11 SURDIKES LEV R006801 C 1/03 144,900 154,620 144,900 1.0700 A 510 TR 62-11 SURJASPER CO R006806 B 11/02 123,000 121,550 123,000 .9900 A 341 TR 7-11 SURGAINES ED R006823 C 6/02 130,000 124,780 130,000 .9598 LOT 7 BLK 211 GREEN ACRES SEC R006840 O 3/03 129,900 103,290 129,900 .7952 LT5 BLK200 1 4 ADDN: LE R006843 B 7/02 122,000 126,300 122,000 1.0400

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 3 TIME: 19:16 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 112 Hopkins 112-901 Sulphur Springs CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LT4 BLK23 400 4 ADDN: LI R006871 B 1/03 121,000 109,700 121,000 .9066 A 694 100 LT26 ADDN: SAN R006965 C 9/02 157,000 154,670 157,000 .9900 LT49 BLK56 1 TOWN: SULPHU R006977 C 7/02 148,500 149,900 148,500 1.0100 A 689 TR 51 SURNORRIS SARAH R007030 C 10/02 182,000 181,330 182,000 1.0000 LT8 BLK221 2 ADDN: PATTER R007059 B 5/02 92,700 85,930 92,700 .9300 A 534 TR 21 SURKELLER JOHN R007080 C 6/02 64,900 66,090 64,900 1.0200 LT3D BLK47 1 TOWN: SULPHU R007087 C 1/03 65,000 64,990 65,000 1.0000 LOT 9 BLK 212 WEST R007104 O 7/02 95,000 93,950 95,000 .9889 A 1186 TR 14-20 SURLEE JA R007158 C 4/02 63,000 43,750 63,000 .6944 LT3 BLK70 100 ADDN: MU R007220 C 6/02 190,500 194,320 190,500 1.0201 LT5 BLK310 101 ADDN: WI R007223 C 11/02 155,000 138,590 155,000 .8900 LT7 BLK201 30 ADDN: BEEZLE R007231 C 9/02 184,500 180,640 184,500 .9800 BRANDY CR 1514 R007234 C 2/03 129,000 129,180 129,000 1.0000 LT9 BLK101 2 ADDN: WEST O R007267 B 10/02 65,000 65,090 65,000 1.0014 LT2 80X140 BLK31 3 8 A R007306 B 8/02 79,900 73,930 79,900 .9300 LT9 BLK607 100 2 ADDN: ST R007358 B 7/02 102,500 98,130 102,500 .9574 A 1 TR 8 SURDIKES LEVI P R007373 B 10/02 91,750 94,380 91,750 1.0287 LT16 BLK215 1 ADDN: HIGHLA R007406 C 2/03 112,000 116,090 112,000 1.0365 LT3 BLK202 C TOWN: SULPHU R007408 C 4/02 109,500 109,710 109,500 1.0019 LT1D & 1E BLK89 TOWN: SULPHU R007444 C 11/02 110,000 107,010 110,000 .9728 LT10 BLK211 4 3 ADDN: GR R007460 B 7/02 99,572 101,380 99,572 1.0182 LT49 BLK212 ADDN: MCCANN 0 R007462 C 12/02 102,000 98,920 102,000 .9698 LT7A BLK73 TOWN: SULPHUR S R007476 C 8/02 63,000 71,980 63,000 1.1425 A 874 TR 9-11 SURSTEWART T R007483 C 7/02 81,000 83,200 81,000 1.0272 LT3 BLK31 3 11 ADDN: BE R007484 B 8/02 91,500 89,640 91,500 .9797 LT7 BLK307 1 ADDN: COLLEG R007494 C 5/02 83,000 79,100 83,000 .9500 A 458 TR 3-01 SURHOUGH SIL R007507 C 6/02 88,900 86,630 88,900 .9745 LT7 BLK602 1 2 ADDN: RO R007672 B 9/02 82,000 87,300 82,000 1.0646 LT2 BLK211 110 1 ADDN:MOC R007674 C 9/02 135,000 136,670 135,000 1.0124 A 254 TR 1-01 A/K/A/ N PT R007675 B 5/02 116,500 112,720 116,500 .9676 A 694 100 LT36 ADDN: SAN R007677 C 10/02 106,750 96,040 106,750 .9000 LOT 12 BLK 222 LAKE HIGHLANDS R007731 O 3/03 92,500 75,990 92,500 .8215 A 1102 TR 227-02 SURY BARB R007743 B 11/02 69,900 68,300 69,900 .9800 LT13 BLK205 1 5 ADDN: ME R007841 C 12/02 50,000 62,490 50,000 1.2500 LT1 BLK602 2 ADDN: WALLS R007851 C 4/02 90,000 91,300 90,000 1.0100 LT14 BLK216 4 ADDN: WOODBR R007855 B 7/02 86,000 83,350 86,000 .9692 A 254 TR 5 AKA BLK 92 S R007948 B 8/02 70,500 63,860 70,500 .9100 A 144 TR 53-33 SURCARO A 1 R007959 C 9/02 86,000 85,410 86,000 .9900 A 160 TR 37-01 SURCLARK JOH R007966 C 7/02 55,000 54,030 55,000 .9824 A 1082 TR 7-00 SURWINN J R008044 C 4/02 80,000 77,890 80,000 .9736 LT13 15W PT 22 BLK21 SULPHUR R008071 B 2/03 42,230 36,570 42,230 .8700 LT2 BLK215 1 ADDN: HIGHLA R008098 B 10/02 62,500 62,980 62,500 1.0100 LT11 BLK305 ADDN: OAK GROVE R008143 C 10/02 35,750 33,780 35,750 .9400 LTPT 2 BLK24 1 TOWN: SUL R008165 C 5/02 65,000 63,150 65,000 .9700 A 432 LT12 ADDN: PLEASANT G R008190 C 5/02 56,000 54,600 56,000 .9800 LT1 BLK221 200 ADDN: TH R008241 C 10/02 67,000 69,290 67,000 1.0342 LT22 BLK210 2 ADDN: IRWIN R008247 B 1/03 65,000 63,920 65,000 .9834

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 4 TIME: 19:16 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 112 Hopkins 112-901 Sulphur Springs CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ A 510 TR 53-02 SURJASPER CO R008303 C 11/02 56,500 52,620 56,500 .9300 LT PT 7D BLK 30 2 TOW R008304 C 12/02 58,500 58,950 58,500 1.0077 LOT 15 BLK 311 HIGHLAND CREEK R008352 O 5/02 96,500 92,590 96,500 .9595 LT E PT 2 BLK 216 1 AN: W R008356 B 7/02 89,000 83,120 89,000 .9339 LT8 BLK211 3 1 ADDN: GR R008387 C 11/02 82,000 72,650 82,000 .8900 LT1A & LT 41C BLK28 TOWN: SU R008663 B 1/03 101,126 97,490 101,126 .9600 LT26 BLK216 2 ADDN: WOODBR R008682 C 12/02 178,000 171,770 178,000 .9700 LT20 BLK210 2 ADDN: IRWIN R008781 C 4/02 125,000 109,240 125,000 .8739 A 503 TR 26-04 SURJEWELL WI R008793 C 2/03 139,900 138,690 139,900 .9900 A 146 TR 22-34 SURCOY MARIA R008796 C 9/02 150,000 149,320 150,000 1.0000 LT10 BLK210 100 2 ADDN: CE R008842 B 1/03 163,500 141,150 163,500 .8600 A 155 TR 1-09 SURCLAPP WIL R008870 C 7/02 129,900 129,630 129,900 1.0000 LT45 BLK49 TOWN: SULPHUR S R008882 C 7/02 142,000 123,160 142,000 .8673 A 144 TR 50 SURCARO A 27.6 R008887 C 9/02 186,900 180,700 186,900 .9700 A 144 TR 37-02 SURCARO A 3 R008967 C 7/02 150,000 145,580 150,000 .9700 LT52 BLK216 1 ADDN: WOODBR R009005 B 4/02 200,000 200,190 200,000 1.0000 LT2A BLK89 TOWN: SULPHUR S R009024 C 4/02 275,000 274,950 275,000 .9998 LT14 BLK222 5 ADDN: LAKE H R009044 B 12/02 115,000 101,540 115,000 .8800 LT22 BLK305 ADDN: EAST SIDE R009069 C 1/03 115,000 110,640 115,000 .9621 A 146 TR 22-37 SURCOY MARIA R009156 B 5/02 166,900 168,330 166,900 1.0086 LT4R BLK602 1 2 ADDN: RO R009236 C 2/03 122,500 115,250 122,500 .9400 LOT 1 A 1186 SANDY RANCH WEST R009245 O 3/03 90,000 85,340 90,000 .9482 A 737 TR 4 SURPETTYJOHN JO R009250 B 10/02 65,000 65,020 65,000 1.0000 LT31 BLK210 100 1 ADDN: CE R009251 C 5/02 149,000 115,080 149,000 .7700 LT45 BLK215 1 ADDN: HIGHLA R009253 B 6/02 83,200 103,030 83,200 1.2400 LT2 BLK36 2 1 ADDN: BR R009270 B 1/03 245,000 244,640 245,000 .9985 A 40 TR 54 SURBALLANOVA M R009288 B 9/02 82,500 71,380 82,500 .8652 LT5 BLK30 4 2 ADDN: WE R009315 B 1/03 46,500 50,020 46,500 1.0800 LT6 A 1186 ADDN: SANDY R R009316 B 2/03 58,000 58,510 58,000 1.0100 LT10E BLK23 1 TOWN: SULPHU R011567 C 5/02 42,000 33,220 42,000 .7900 LT12A BLK43 TOWN: SULPHUR S R011598 C 9/02 172,000 133,730 172,000 .7800 LT19 BLK56 1 TOWN: SULPHU R011909 C 7/02 155,000 140,880 155,000 .9100 LT24A BLK36 1 TOWN: SULPHU R014166 C 6/02 54,500 55,490 54,500 1.0200 LT3E BLK47 1 TOWN: SULPHU R018137 B 1/03 80,000 57,950 80,000 .7200 LT7A BLK209 TOWN: SULPHUR S R019779 B 11/02 60,000 48,040 60,000 .8007 A 505 TR 2-01 SURJOHNSON J R021077 C 7/02 50,200 39,620 50,200 .7892 LT3R BLK 607 100 3 ADDN: R022434 C 9/02 112,500 88,960 112,500 .7900 LT7 BLK216 2 ADDN: WOODBR R024273 C 11/02 110,000 104,550 110,000 .9500 LT5 BLK210 1 TOWN: SULPHU R025492 C 9/02 125,000 121,120 125,000 .9690 180 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9587 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE.

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 5 TIME: 19:16 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 112 Hopkins 112-901 Sulphur Springs CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BLK311-100 LT3 ADDN: DALTON R000087 C 5/02 780 3,000 .2600 2B BLK 89 (SEE NOTES FOR A1 R005359 C 4/02 20,810 19,950 1.0431 LT25 BLK201 ADDN: BROOKWORT R008598 C 10/02 124,030 131,200 .9454 LT7 BLK210 1 ADDN: IRWIN R008647 C 9/02 141,180 140,000 1.0084 LT18 BLK48 5 ADDN: TANTON R008961 B 4/02 325,950 350,000 .9300 A 6 TR 30-01 SURARNOLD HA R009302 C 10/02 189,810 145,000 1.3100 LT27 BLK308 ADDN: KAROL HEI R009310 C 10/02 165,900 213,900 .7800 LT8 BLK29 2 ADDN: LEMON R009598 B 10/02 56,130 74,260 .7600 LT3 BLK56 1 ADDN: JEFFER R010087 B 9/02 81,520 81,384 1.0000 LT4 BLK205 1 3 ADDN: ME R010124 C 12/02 52,920 53,000 1.0000 LT9C BLK22 TOWN: SULPHUR S R010428 C 6/02 99,120 86,800 1.1419 LT15 BLK210 1 ADDN: IRWIN R010859 C 8/02 39,000 36,000 1.0800 LT7B BLK20 TOWN: SULPHUR S R010912 C 5/02 17,240 20,000 .8600 LT7 BLK200 1 4 ADDN: LE R011360 B 7/02 56,650 110,000 .5150 A 144 ALSO R011429 R011414 C 9/02 364,800 350,000 1.0400 A 146 TR 74 COY MARIA J SANTOR R011712 O 3/03 71,320 72,000 .9906 LT28 BLK222 5 ADDN: LAKE H R011814 C 7/02 52,650 40,000 1.3200 LT2A BLK36 1 TOWN: SULPHU R012081 C 7/02 35,330 32,000 1.1041 A573 TR 2-07 SUR LITCHFI R012475 C 4/02 17,160 13,000 1.3200 A 801 TR 1-01 ALSO AB 149 R012962 C 5/02 12,820 12,500 1.0256 LTPT LT 12 BLK82 TOWN SU R012969 C 8/02 15,050 13,500 1.1100 A 733 TR 2-04 SURPARK ALEX R013040 C 6/02 104,360 111,925 .9300 LT36F BLK56 1 TOWN: SULPHU R013249 C 11/02 70,000 73,000 .9589 LT1A & 1B BLK37 TOWN: SULPHU R013808 C 11/02 120,480 147,500 .8200 LT27 BLK203 ADDN: ROMACK 0 R013817 C 6/02 63,100 62,500 1.0096 LT PT 5 BLK 201 ADDN: R013991 C 7/02 320,040 325,000 .9800 A457 & 458 TR4-02 SUR: HIC R015039 C 5/02 30,000 44,200 .6787 LT15A BLK8 TOWN: SULPHUR S R015042 C 6/02 83,580 62,000 1.3500 LT24A BLK30 3 TOWN: SULPHU R015058 B 5/02 116,030 115,000 1.0100 LT50 BLK216 1 ADDN: WOODBR R015310 C 2/03 79,300 81,300 .9800 LT1C BLK92 2 TOWN: SULPHU R015494 C 7/02 81,440 82,000 .9900 A551 TR5-28 SUR: LEE THOMAS R015689 B 11/02 17,950 25,500 .7000 A 1186 TR 10-03 SURLEE JA R015711 C 11/02 57,750 53,000 1.0900 A 529 TR 4 JORDAN JOHN 18.838A R015880 O 7/02 46,530 35,000 1.3294 LT16 BLK210 1 ADDN: BELLAI R015958 B 6/02 45,950 42,500 1.0812 LT1A BLK305 TOWN: SULPHUR S R017705 C 4/02 30,150 30,000 1.0100 A 341 TR 3-02 &AB 275SURGAIN R018172 C 11/02 119,580 115,600 1.0300 LT10F BLK23 1 TOWN: SULPHU R018179 B 9/02 66,560 71,500 .9300 LT9 BLK31 ADDN: VALLEY VI R019587 C 6/02 146,310 170,000 .8600 LT3 BLK48 6 6 ADDN: MU R019665 C 10/02 147,600 188,000 .7900 LT5 BLK308 ADDN: HARRED 0 R019709 C 5/02 121,660 122,000 .9972 A 741 TR 2-14 SURPRUFER CH R020314 C 5/02 27,300 25,000 1.0920 A 874 TR 16 SURSTEWART THOM R020315 C 11/02 68,780 80,000 .8600 A 694 100 LT33 ADDN: SAN R020340 B 11/02 39,540 43,500 .9100

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 6 TIME: 19:16 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 112 Hopkins 112-901 Sulphur Springs CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LT6-01 BLK221 TOWN: SULPHU R020977 C 4/02 102,670 105,540 .9728 LT3 BLK12 ADDN: CICADA 0 R021204 C 8/02 36,080 20,000 1.8040 LT10B BLK57 1 TOWN: SULPHU R021868 B 12/02 37,770 24,000 1.5700 LT10K BLK12 TOWN: SULPHUR S R022876 C 4/02 157,700 163,576 .9600 LT14 BLK87 TOWN: SULPHUR S R022968 C 6/02 105,990 110,000 .9600 A 1102 TR 240 SURYBARBO JO R023078 B 1/03 25,440 23,480 1.0800 A 1102 TR 202 SURYBARBO JO R023120 C 1/03 25,270 23,280 1.0900 LT34 BLK203 ADDN: ROMACK 0 R023124 C 1/03 66,350 61,240 1.0800 A 807 TR 2 SURRUSSELL HENR R023754 C 11/02 167,150 175,000 .9600 A 1186 TR 1-04 SURLEE JA R023779 C 11/02 123,310 130,050 .9482 LT NE PT 11H BLK 27 2 R023794 C 4/02 50,960 40,000 1.2740 A 862 TR 4 SURSTEWART MARG R023855 C 4/02 36,070 35,500 1.0200 A 296 TR 1 SUREWING GEO S R024304 C 11/02 55,980 55,000 1.0200 A 689 63-07 NORRIS SARAH H 9.9 R024490 O 1/03 21,560 18,500 1.1654 LT11 BLK48 6 5 ADDN: J R024965 C 10/02 9,960 10,400 .9600 LT5 BLK7 TOWN: SULPHUR S R025203 C 6/02 21,000 29,700 .7100 LT14B BLK33 TOWN: SULPHUR S R025476 C 4/02 3,890 5,000 .7800 A 1211 TR 1-01 SURCRAIG R025518 C 4/02 11,830 20,000 .5900 62 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9708 CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LT10 BLK211 110 1 ADDN: MO R001972 C 2/03 225,000 215,110 225,000 .9560 LT20A BLK57 1 TOWN: SULPHU R002219 C 5/02 265,000 260,710 265,000 .9838 LT PT 1 BLK 219 TOWN: S R002401 C 6/02 180,000 74,840 180,000 .4200 A 148 TR 2-14 SURCRAFT RUS R003064 C 7/02 335,070 296,330 335,070 .8800 LT1 BLK200 1 2 ADDN: BE R003381 C 9/02 78,500 76,230 78,500 .9700 LT19A & PT 19 BLK28 TOWN: SULP R003673 Y 6/02 137,000 143,780 137,000 1.0500 LT7 BLK211 102 ADDN: SP R006281 C 12/02 52,500 52,100 52,500 .9924 LT5A BLK20 TOWN: SULPHUR S R007184 C 8/02 181,500 177,980 181,500 .9806 LT24B BLK34 1 TOWN: SULPHU R007581 C 6/02 710,000 763,680 710,000 1.0756 LT10A BLK31 TOWN: SULPHUR S R007642 C 4/02 178,000 152,790 178,000 .8600 LT7 & 8 BLK47 1 1 ADDN: R025129 C 10/02 45,000 50,230 45,000 1.1162 11 SALES

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 7 TIME: 19:16 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 112 Hopkins 112-901 Sulphur Springs CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ PROFESSIONAL LAND TITLE R001509 .00 1.00 .00 181,190 200,810 .9000 LOT 18 BLK 8 SULPHUR SPRINGS . R001596 .00 1.00 .00 86,950 88,965 .9800 LT 1 2 6 B BLK 2 SULPHUR SPRIN R1460 .00 1.00 .00 537,260 535,280 1.0000 A 698 NACOGDOCHES UNIV 1.277A R18795 .00 1.00 .00 352,530 356,758 .9900 LOT 2 BLK 24 5 ADDN WILLIAM 2. R2267 .00 1.00 .00 1,099,930 1,263,456 .8700 LOT 1 BLK 35 LOAN & BLDG ADD 2 R3095 .00 1.00 .00 533,710 534,939 1.0000 20B-R BLK 47 SULPHUR SPRINGS 1 R3664 .00 1.00 .00 362,730 356,820 1.0200 PT LT 3 BLK 127 SULPHUR SPRING R5719 .00 1.00 .00 247,490 256,822 .9600 C 3 12-17 TR B BLK 202 SULPHUR R6114 .00 1.00 .00 1,107,360 1,347,047 .8200 LT 2&3 BLK 206 R6482 .00 1.00 .00 367,240 461,316 .8000 LOT 15A BLK 207 SULPHUR SPRING R6505 .00 1.00 .00 357,270 353,520 1.0100 LOT 1 BLK 210 200 WAL MART R6779 .00 1.00 .00 6,509,160 6,631,322 .9800 LT 4 BLK 212 SULPHUR SPRINGS R R7045 .00 1.00 .00 248,340 257,492 .9600 LOT 3 & 2 & 6-01 BLK 214 SULPH R7174 OUTLET MALLS L P .00 1.00 .00 2,214,700 2,224,216 1.0000 PT 1A BLK 403 SULPHUR SPRINGS R8454 .00 1.00 .00 1,218,730 1,158,688 1.0500 15 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9333 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ GILLIS A K & SONS INC P000101 3,900,600 3,859,100 1.0100 CITCAPITAL COMMERCIAL LEASING P000215 739,340 726,395 1.0200 BROOKSHIRES GROCERY P000406 1,150,220 1,201,382 .9600 FACTORY BRAND SHOES P000409 226,110 220,122 1.0300 CANON FINANCIAL P000503 54,110 42,429 1.2800 COPY PRODUCTS P000638 722,000 511,804 1.4100 DOLGEN P000780 271,300 273,287 .9900 FAMILY DOLLAR STORE OF TEXAS P000879 112,790 115,232 .9800 FARM CREDIT LEASING P000884 604,210 539,679 1.1200 FARM CREDIT LEASING TAX P000886 275,160 275,156 1.0000 GROCERY SUPPLY CO P001114 8,239,770 7,879,429 1.0500 G S C ENTERPRISES INC P001120 675,000 675,000 1.0000 HINTON & HINTON TRUCKING P001269 31,000 23,478 1.3200 KIMBERLY CLARK P001457 1,265,310 1,265,310 1.0000 COWBOY TRUCKING P001868 102,180 49,740 2.0500 OSBORNE GROCERY P001885 300,360 264,230 1.1400 REDNECK INC P002101 541,780 514,267 1.0500 NORTHEAST JANITORIAL P002271 55,340 57,120 .9700 SULPHUR SPRINGS COUNTRY CLUB P002379 57,500 118,756 .4800 THORTON CONTRACTORS P002474 91,000 202,699 .4500

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 8 TIME: 19:16 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 112 Hopkins 112-901 Sulphur Springs CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ TRACTOR SUPPLY CORP P002511 678,630 636,067 1.0700 V F FACTORY P002559 738,400 770,682 .9600 WALMART STORES P002626 7,102,710 7,194,541 .9900 ENTERPRISE P003302 445,000 426,613 1.0400 24 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO WITH EXCEPTIONS: .9767