DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 1 TIME: 18:11 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 068 Ector 068-901 Ector County CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 7 B-1 BARROW PARK 017000-00070 B 7/02 88,500 82,114 88,500 .9300 181-9 B-2 BECKWOOD 02200-00220 B 4/02 65,000 61,875 65,000 .9500 20 B-11 BELLAIRE 02400-02340 B 3/03 45,000 38,344 45,000 .8500 36 B-18 BELLAIRE 02400-03630 B 6/02 40,000 40,999 40,000 1.0200 12 B-10 BRIARWOOD 03900-01870 B 3/03 55,000 57,835 55,000 1.0500 1 B-3 BUCHANAN 04700-00210 B 1/03 27,000 32,549 27,000 1.2100 88 B-1 CHRISTOPHER 05710-00880 B 4/02 63,000 61,985 63,000 .9800 1-11 B-3 CIELLO VISTA BLDG B U 05720-00040-00110 B 10/02 52,000 41,426 52,000 .8000 19 B-5 CIELO VISTA 05720-00118 B 9/02 63,500 61,446 63,500 .9700 5-6 B-176 COLLEGE 06200-05930 B 6/02 64,900 60,491 64,900 .9300 10 B-18 COUNTRY CLUB 06700-02000 B 1/03 192,000 192,684 192,000 1.0000 7 B-8 N COUNTRY 06800-00790 B 11/02 320,000 243,322 320,000 .7600 4 B-13 N COUNTRY CLUB 06800-01050 B 9/02 129,000 131,677 129,000 1.0200 3 B-17 N COUNTRY CLUB 06800-01500 B 4/02 99,900 102,897 99,900 1.0300 37 B-25 N COUNTRY CLUB 06800-02840-00050 B 7/02 74,000 69,256 74,000 .9400 14 B-6 CRESCENT 07000-00396 B 12/02 35,000 29,381 35,000 .8400 23 B-17 CRESCENT 07000-01424 B 2/03 49,900 47,239 49,900 .9500 9 B-19 CRESCENT PARK 07000-01560 B 5/02 52,500 49,398 52,500 .9400 1 B-40 CRESCENT PARK 07000-03244 B 9/02 51,000 48,824 51,000 .9600 42 B-95 CRESCENT PARK 07000-06308 B 1/03 98,500 91,064 98,500 .9200 22 B-102 CRESCENT PARK 07000-06656 B 1/03 30,500 41,638 30,500 1.3700 21 B-124 CRESCENT PARK 07000-08044 B 6/02 57,900 57,208 57,900 .9900 28 B-129 CRESCENT PARK 07000-08404 B 3/03 68,000 51,210 68,000 .7500 23 B-135 CRESCENT PARK 07000-08704 B 12/02 62,000 53,345 62,000 .8600 10 B-3 CRESTWOOD 07200-00500 B 3/03 16,000 21,613 16,000 1.3500 9 B-11 CRESTWOOD 07200-02720 B 4/02 37,000 33,608 37,000 .9100 19 B-1 DEVONIAN 08260-00115-00080 B 11/02 63,500 49,299 63,500 .7800 22 B-4 DEVONIAN 08260-00720 B 3/03 87,000 96,158 87,000 1.1100 16 B-2 EAST PARK 08870-00270 B 10/02 104,500 100,468 104,500 .9600 1 B-5 EAST PARK 08870-00920 B 3/03 73,500 73,482 73,500 1.0000 6 B-5 EAST PARK 08870-00970 B 6/02 85,900 90,979 85,900 1.0600 6 B-7 EDGEMERE 09200-01600 B 3/03 35,000 33,481 35,000 .9600 2 B-3 EMERALD FOREST 094450-00380 B 7/02 155,000 160,975 155,000 1.0400 16 B-28 EMERALD FOREST 09447-00160 B 8/02 179,900 178,676 179,900 .9900 17 B-28 EMERALD FOREST 09447-00170 B 7/02 241,500 201,209 241,500 .8300 41 B-2 ESMOND 09450-00077-00140 B 8/02 52,500 46,694 52,500 .8900 12 B-7 ESMOND 09450-00320 B 1/03 77,000 74,518 77,000 .9700 68 B-18 ESMOND 09450-02070-00230 B 8/02 94,000 96,708 94,000 1.0300 6 B-23 ESMOND 09450-03080 B 12/02 165,000 163,372 165,000 .9900 2 B-4 FLEETWOOD 10100-00288 B 9/02 53,500 42,457 53,500 .7900 9 B-25 FLEETWOOD 10100-03624 B 6/02 49,000 45,796 49,000 .9300 3 B-5 GREENWAY 13100-01080 B 5/02 29,000 24,799 29,000 .8600 10 B-25 HENDERSON 13700-03780 B 3/03 44,500 29,649 44,500 .6700 10 B-53 HENDERSON 13700-06600-00045 B 11/02 41,000 44,214 41,000 1.0800 8 B-4 HILLSIDE 14200-00880 B 5/02 35,000 31,505 35,000 .9000 8 B-7 HILLSIDE 14200-01380 B 2/03 37,000 36,394 37,000 .9800 3-4 B-4 IDLEWILD 15000-00320 B 2/03 235,000 212,845 235,000 .9100DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 2 TIME: 18:11 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 068 Ector 068-901 Ector County CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 2 B-7 IDLEWILD 15000-00710 B 2/03 117,500 110,415 117,500 .9400 6 B-8 LAKESIDE 16850-01650 B 9/02 75,500 71,531 75,500 .9500 8 B-12 LAKESIDE 16870-00010-00070 B 8/02 149,000 134,574 149,000 .9000 12 B-11 LAWNDALE 17300-01440 B 5/02 69,900 62,075 69,900 .8900 25 B-18 MCKINNEY 17800-01590 B 10/02 22,000 26,576 22,000 1.2100 8 B-1 ERNEST MARTINEZ 18420-00080 B 5/02 59,200 62,529 59,200 1.0600 14 B-6 PARKER HTS 23300-01470 B 4/02 40,300 38,158 40,300 .9500 22 21 B-9 PARKER 23300-02360 B 8/02 82,500 86,027 82,500 1.0400 4 B-13 RIDGECREST 27200-02450 B 6/02 39,500 39,913 39,500 1.0100 2 B-91 S WILLIAMS 28100-00920 B 10/02 32,000 29,628 32,000 .9300 16 B-1 SCOTTSDALE 28440-00160 B 10/02 66,000 67,658 66,000 1.0300 B-4 SCOTTSDALE BLDG C 28440-05080 B 8/02 24,000 25,044 24,000 1.0400 8 B-12 SCOTTSDALE WEST 28460-01570 B 3/03 89,000 85,486 89,000 .9600 22 B-12 SCOTTSDALE WEST 28460-01710 B 11/02 86,500 85,583 86,500 .9900 6 B-19 SCOTTSDALE WEST 28460-02740 B 10/02 93,000 91,967 93,000 .9900 13 B-9 SHERWOOD 28600-01224 B 2/03 27,000 28,149 27,000 1.0400 11 B-14 SHERWOOD 28600-02000 B 5/02 53,000 46,314 53,000 .8700 7 B-29 SHERWOOD 28600-04096 B 8/02 80,000 81,919 80,000 1.0200 SHERWOOD TOWNHOUSES B-20 L-37 28600-06640 B 7/02 33,000 27,595 33,000 .8400 24 B-69 SHERWOOD 28600-09808 B 5/02 48,950 46,192 48,950 .9400 14 B-9 SPRINGDALE 29700-01910 B 1/03 49,650 44,419 49,650 .8900 12 B-13 SPRINGDALE 29700-03120 B 3/03 79,900 69,873 79,900 .8700 3 B-1 STEEPLECHASE 29970-00030 B 8/02 188,500 206,381 188,500 1.0900 1 B-14 SUNSET 30600-02030 B 3/03 29,500 30,976 29,500 1.0500 2 B-20 TERRACE HILLS 31700-02390 B 2/03 39,900 31,578 39,900 .7900 2 B-25 UNIVERSITY GARDENS 32660-06180 B 9/02 125,000 122,195 125,000 .9800 5 B-25 UNIVERSITY GARDENS 32660-06225 B 11/02 135,000 141,565 135,000 1.0500 12 B-33 UNIVERSITY GARDENS 32660-06782 B 9/02 116,000 120,512 116,000 1.0400 37 B-33 UNIVERSITY GARDENS 32660-06832 B 4/02 120,000 118,215 120,000 .9900 46 B-37 UNIVERSITY GARDENS 32660-07126 B 6/02 107,500 100,773 107,500 .9400 1 B-4 WEDGEWOOD 33800-00430 B 9/02 67,500 64,723 67,500 .9600 2 B-10 WEDGEWOOD 33800-01410 B 3/03 95,000 76,192 95,000 .8000 7 B-11 WEDGEWOOD 33800-01510 B 7/02 89,000 86,689 89,000 .9700 14-16 B-2 WESTERLEIGH 34099-00170 B 3/03 58,900 70,121 58,900 1.1900 12 B-11 WINDSOR 36600-01400 B 5/02 71,500 73,657 71,500 1.0300 12 B-15 WINDSOR 36600-01904 B 12/02 75,000 78,805 75,000 1.0500 61 B-32 WINDSOR 36600-04448 B 3/03 57,000 46,509 57,000 .8200 28-29 B-38 WINDSOR 36600-05560 B 4/02 48,500 41,563 48,500 .8600 18 B-46 WINDSOR 36600-06696 B 2/03 128,500 132,284 128,500 1.0300 34 B-49 WINDSOR 36600-07376 B 9/02 57,500 47,018 57,500 .8200 50 B-56 WINDSOR 36600-08136 B 12/02 100,000 90,821 100,000 .9100 21 B-58 WINDSOR 36600-08264 B 1/03 82,500 84,844 82,500 1.0300 33 B-59 WINDSOR 36600-08360 B 8/02 88,500 81,964 88,500 .9300 4 B-64 WINDSOR 36600-09080 B 6/02 87,000 80,317 87,000 .9200 10 B-2 WINDSOR 36800-00180 B 5/02 65,000 73,110 65,000 1.1200 10 B-6 WINWOOD 36800-00800 B 2/03 93,000 92,487 93,000 .9900 93 SALES
DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 3 TIME: 18:11 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 068 Ector 068-901 Ector County STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9506 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 1-6 B-14 AIRWAY 00200-00790 C 11/02 100,000 96,100 100,000 .9600 8 B-44 AIRWAY ACRES 0200-04155 C 10/02 87,500 50,905 87,500 .5800 2-3 B-1 COLIN 06000-00020 C 1/02 2,950,000 2,685,842 2,950,000 .9100 T-5 COLIN 06100-00032 C 10/02 200,000 149,765 200,000 .7500 4-7 B-64 COLLEGE 06200-00710 C 1/02 90,000 92,589 90,000 1.0300 10-12 B-4 COLLEG CAMPUS 06400-00300 C 7/02 45,000 37,334 45,000 .8300 1-2 B-42 CRESCENT PARK 07000-03484 C 7/02 45,000 40,569 45,000 .9000 17-19 B-114 CRESCENT PARK 07000-07524 C 4/02 90,000 79,396 90,000 .8800 B-2 CROWELL AND HELD 07300-00020 C 2/02 135,000 109,008 124,630 .8700 4 B-1 FRENCH TOOL 10700-00100 C 8/02 1,250,000 807,952 1,250,000 .6500 1 B-3 GIBSON 11180-00070 C 5/02 840,000 840,000 840,000 1.0000 2-5 B-5 GOLDER 11500-00760 C 4/02 240,000 220,706 240,000 .9200 12 B-6 HARRISDALE 13600-00801 C 5/02 59,000 52,538 59,000 .8900 3-4 B-8 HARRISDALE 13600-00940 C 3/02 85,000 89,510 85,000 1.0500 2 B-10 HARRISDALE 13600-01174-00010 C 9/02 95,000 143,737 95,000 1.5100 12 B-31 HERBERT WIGHT 13900-00510 C 5/02 33,000 47,516 33,000 1.4400 21 B-9 HILLSIDE 14200-01660 C 1/02 33,000 32,261 33,000 .9800 4 B-3 JUDKINS 15900-00176 C 8/02 50,000 82,295 50,000 1.6500 1 B-1 LUCERO 17450-00010 C 9/02 65,000 66,269 65,000 1.0200 8 B-1 MCCONNELL 17700-00070 C 3/02 600,000 600,000 600,000 1.0000 2 B-1 MCMILLAN 17840-00020 C 12/02 110,000 160,000 110,000 1.4500 30 ODESSA OFFICE PARK 21800-00310 C 1/02 100,000 121,449 100,000 1.2100 4 B-19 OT 22000-00800 C 6/02 20,000 32,340 20,000 1.6200 1 B-29 OT 22000-01640 C 12/02 48,000 48,000 48,000 1.0000 1 2 B-47 OT 22000-03140 C 4/02 99,700 104,265 99,700 1.0500 10-12 B-52 OT 22000-03600 C 7/02 100,000 59,364 78,105 .7600 4-5 B-55 OT 22000-03811 C 12/02 28,500 39,634 28,500 1.3900 1 B-72 OT 22000-04945 C 8/02 150,000 127,893 150,000 .8500 5-6 B-2 OWEN 22300-00120-00050 C 4/02 85,000 70,481 78,748 .9000 1 B-1 PARKWAY OFFICE PARK 23660-00010 C 2/02 750,000 737,595 750,000 .9800 7 B-1 PARKWAY 23660-00060 C 11/02 425,000 425,000 425,000 1.0000 AB-12 B-1 ROYALTY 27750-00130 C 5/02 50,000 43,280 45,000 .9600 AB-4 C3 B-2 ROYALTY 27750-00310 C 5/02 145,000 187,809 145,000 1.3000 BC-3 B-3 ROYALTY 27750-00670 C 2/02 95,000 76,310 95,000 .8000 AB-9 B-4 ROYALTY 27750-01160 C 1/02 104,000 77,147 99,176 .7800
DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 4 TIME: 18:11 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 068 Ector 068-901 Ector County CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 5 21 B-7 ROYALTY 27750-02370 C 3/02 129,000 139,965 129,000 1.0900 3-6 B-28 SCHARBAUER 28400-02022 C 2/02 90,000 104,350 90,000 1.1600 18 B-4 SCOTTSDALE 28440-05094 C 11/02 275,000 232,748 229,250 1.0200 9 B-3 SOUTHWEST IND 29550-00170 C 6/02 70,000 90,928 70,000 1.3000 22-26 B-2 SUNSET COMM. 30500-00170 C 4/02 215,000 215,000 215,000 1.0000 12-15 B-1 THAIN 31800-00100 C 12/02 47,500 47,280 47,500 1.0000 23 B-2 385 RANCH ESTATE 31850-00490 C 8/02 30,000 44,147 30,000 1.4700 14-17 B-2 WEST FREEWAY 33900-00225 C 4/02 53,000 75,243 53,000 1.4200 8 B-3 WEST INTERSTATE IND. 34060-00130 C 5/02 48,000 29,586 48,000 .6200 3 B-3 WESTLAND 35000-00081 C 6/02 70,000 70,000 70,000 1.0000 11-13 B-5 WESTMOOR 35200-00660-00010 C 12/02 140,000 56,001 140,000 .4000 6 B-41 T1S 39340-00760 C 11/02 100,000 54,666 89,689 .6100 41 B-42 T1S 40080-00248-00010 C 12/02 270,000 191,821 270,000 .7100 25 B-42 T2S 42300-00080 C 7/02 345,000 345,000 345,000 1.0000 28 B-42 T2S 42330-00050 C 2/02 98,500 102,052 98,500 1.0400 41 B-42 T2S 42460-00110 C 10/02 47,000 43,222 47,000 .9200 4 B-42 T3S 43850-00220 C 9/02 46,040 52,604 46,040 1.1400 52 SALES CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 1-3 5 B-12 CIELO VISTA 5 05720-00542 .00 .89 .00 4,700,054 5,952,367 .7900 9 B-1 DOS PLAYAS 08640-00045-00050 .00 .89 .00 1,014,560 1,248,140 .8100 1 B-3 NORTH PERMIAN MALL 21250-00080 .00 .89 .00 718,631 989,119 .7300 6 B-1 ODESSA INDUSTRIAL PARK 21690-00040 .00 .89 .00 964,160 806,978 1.1900 9-12 B-31 OT 22000-01790 .00 .89 .00 2,200,000 2,381,915 .9200 1 B-1 REGENCY 26770-00010 .00 .89 .00 2,785,015 2,961,628 .9400 L2 B-2 ROYALTY 27750-00235 .00 .89 .00 449,220 357,465 1.2600 24 B-2 SPRINGDALE 29700-00387 .00 .89 .00 3,229,014 3,020,780 1.0700 3 B-3 TIERRA VERDE 3 31910-00070 .00 .89 .00 3,541,538 3,861,619 .9200 1 B-1 UNITED INDUSTRIES 32610-00010 .00 .89 .00 489,731 462,939 1.0600 13 B-1 VONWAY 33200-00065 .00 .89 .00 1,000,000 942,239 1.0600 26 B-54 WINDSOR 36600-07865 .00 .89 .00 3,300,000 3,014,570 1.0900 1 B-13 WINWOOD 36800-01631 .00 .89 .00 2,146,562 2,215,584 .9700 13 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9538
DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 5 TIME: 18:11 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 068 Ector 068-901 Ector County CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ GELCO CORP LC800-28102 2,177,677 1,585,435 1.3700 FORD MOTOR CREDIT LC808-00135 969,682 847,285 1.1400 IBM CORP LC808-01145 59,048 71,161 .8300 LAMAR ADVERTISING LC808-10040 902,017 884,852 1.0200 TRANSAMERICA EQUIP LC808-10195 186,003 170,853 1.0900 KMART PP200-02799 2,298,935 2,631,987 .8700 SOUTHWEST 66 CREDIT UNION PP200-03849 214,346 198,381 1.0800 SEARS PP200-04692 3,252,146 3,130,779 1.0400 UNIFIRST PP200-05283 419,425 425,250 .9900 STOCKADE GROCERY PP200-17661 98,048 84,816 1.1600 ALBERTSONS 4215 PP200-21634 2,307,874 2,226,073 1.0400 GOLDER CAT SCAN PP200-22264 160,570 110,315 1.4600 ENTERPRISE RENT A CAR PP200-33333 1,334,945 1,509,348 .8800 ALBERTSONS 4155 PP200-33359 2,203,892 2,118,658 1.0400 C AND C PACKER PP200-33990 89,625 86,178 1.0400 WATERS AND WATERS SERVICES PP200-33999 912,129 830,875 1.1000 FALCON ENVIRONMENTAL LINING PP200-34024 250,060 314,999 .7900 COMPUTALOG WIRELINE SERVICES PP200-34176 1,417,647 1,454,941 .9700 STANDARD STRUCTURES INC PP200-34240 983,118 1,008,330 .9700 DICK GLOVER CO. PP200-34421 285,500 265,300 1.0800 WEST TEXAS CANCER CENTER PP200-34613 2,239,283 1,707,685 1.3100 SITEL CORP PP200-35569 679,402 726,291 .9400 HEB PP200-36078 2,899,194 2,892,441 1.0000 B AND H MAINTENANCE PP200-36361 308,800 271,450 1.1400 NEFF RENTAL PP200-36561 1,821,953 2,036,469 .8900 RHW METALS PP200-37130 283,140 286,000 .9900 MODCO IND PP200-37209 58,992 58,992 1.0000 DESERT INDUSTRIAL PP200-37747 569,079 581,880 .9800 S AND E PROPERTIES PP200-38068 813,159 731,842 1.1100 VIPER BLASTING AND COATING PP200-38151 324,389 308,670 1.0500 UNIVAR USA PP200-38161 2,177,259 1,896,991 1.1500 M AND M SALES AND EQUIP PP200-38331 440,518 438,788 1.0000 32 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0373
