Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   6/27/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:     19
TIME:     17:56                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             057  Dallas
                                                         057-905  Dallas

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  ASCOT PLACE CONDOS BLK X/1861    00C02560000B00209          B       9/02        126,000         129,210       126,000    1.0255
  BELVEDERE CONDOS BLK C/563 LT    00C04190000A00229          B       9/02        234,000         227,910       234,000     .9740
  BRYAN PLACE PHASE V SEC 1 & 2    00C06680000A00126          B       1/03        113,500         121,800       113,500    1.0731
  THE CLARIDGE CONDOS BLK A/1044   00C1015000000005C          B       3/02        575,000         560,000       570,630     .9814
  THE CLARIDGE CONDOS BLK A/1044   00C1015000000012C          B       6/02        540,000         560,000       537,192    1.0425
  THE CLARIDGE CONDOS BLK A/1044   00C1015000000012D          B      11/02        850,000       1,143,390       848,980    1.3468
  CRESTPARK IN HIGHLAND PARK CON   00C12000000000N26          B       5/02        425,000         134,070       425,000     .3155
  3711 HOLLAND CONDOS BLK 9/1046   00C29520000000303          B      11/02        182,900         184,790       182,900    1.0103
  THE LAKES OF BENT TREE CONDOS    00C41870000105038          B       6/02        230,000         246,500       230,000    1.0717
  LIFESCAPE VILLAS ON MONTFORT B   00C43500000100330          B       4/02        105,000          98,700       105,000     .9400
  MAYFAIR AT TURTLE CREEK CONDOS   00C45550000001402          B      12/02        490,000         663,460       489,804    1.3545
  MAYFAIR AT TURTLE CREEK CONDOS   00C45550000001606          B       7/02        450,900         565,460       448,916    1.2596
  MAYFAIR AT TURTLE CREEK CONDOS   00C45550000001806          B       3/02        365,000         500,000       362,226    1.3804
  MONTICELLO CROSSROADS CONDO PH   00C47500000Y00002          B      11/02         87,900         100,720        87,900    1.1458
  OAKS OF PRESTON RIDGE CONDOMIN   00C51850000B00301          B       3/02         67,500          63,000        67,500     .9333
  PLAZA AT TURTLE CREEK RES PH 1   00C57100000000205          B       4/02        452,000         452,000       452,000    1.0000
  PRESTON ON THE CREEK CONDOS BL   00C58750000E00526          B       9/02         75,000          73,080        75,000     .9744
  RAWLINS PARK CONDOMINIUMS BLK    00C60190000000206          B       5/02        148,500         159,140       148,500    1.0716
  ROSS AVENUE LOFTS CONDOS BLK I   00C6245000005803B          B       5/02        136,000         136,000       136,000    1.0000
  SPRINGSTEAD CONDOS BLK B/8166    00C69250000I00276          B      10/02        123,500         124,140       123,500    1.0052
  SUTTON PLACE CONDOS BLK 17/965   00C70130000000103          B       9/02         90,750         106,130        90,750    1.1695
  3920-22 TRAVIS STREET CONDOS B   00C73380000C00019          B       4/02        170,500         168,380       170,500     .9876
  4134 TRAVIS STREET CONDOMINIUM   00C73480000000009          B       5/02        165,000         158,810       165,000     .9625
  AVENUE HEIGHTS BLK D/770 LT 19   00000124447000000          B       7/02        235,300         238,520       235,300    1.0137
  TURTLE CREEK TERRACE CONDOMINI   00000136222860000          B       8/02         74,000          73,570        74,000     .9942
  OAK LAWN PLACE BLK 8/1013 LT 2   00000138335000000          B       3/02        198,000         179,980       198,000     .9090
  4000 RAWLINS PLACE CONDOMINIUM   00000148882100000          B      12/02        125,000         124,540       125,000     .9963
  TWENTY-ONE TURTLE CREEK CONDOS   00000149806910000          B       8/02        283,000         277,840       283,000     .9818
  BRISTLE CONE TOWNHOUSE CONDO B   00000157536500000          B       4/02        115,500         109,510       115,500     .9481
  CLIFTON PLACE BLK 9/1616 PT 9-   00000166501000000          B       4/02        550,000         544,450       546,260     .9967
  CLIFTON PLACE BLK 10/1616 PT L   00000166531000000          B       5/02        127,000         129,820       127,000    1.0222
  MUNGER PLACE NE 70FT LOT 3       00000181675000000          B       9/02        535,000         567,950       533,502    1.0646
  MUNGER PLACE BLK 11/1863 NE 59   00000181792000000          B       5/02        475,000         460,850       475,000     .9702
  MUNGER PLACE BLK 17/1871 LT 5    00000182110000000          B      11/02        580,000         543,170       579,304     .9376
  MUNGER PLACE BLK 9/1884 LT 13    00000183325000000          B       9/02        189,000         155,620       189,000     .8234
  VICKERY PLACE BLK 10/1928 LOT    00000186403000000          B       3/02        403,000         391,970       403,000     .9726
  VICKERY PLACE & VICKERY PARK R   00000188170000000          B       5/02        192,500         199,820       192,500    1.0380
  HENDERSON AVE BLK 1/1975  LT 2   00000191008000000          B       8/02        116,500         123,350       116,500    1.0588
  TURTLE CREEK PARK BLK 5/2023     00000195802000000          B      11/02        780,000         515,830       779,064     .6621
  CARUTH PLACE E 25FT 6 AND 27FT   00000198007000000          B      11/02        271,000         279,880       271,000    1.0328
  LAKEWOOD HEIGHTS BLK 3/2090 LT   00000199474000000          B      11/02        191,000         166,420       191,000     .8713
  GENEVA HEIGHTS BLK 1/2164 LOT    00000203368000000          B       5/02        190,000         301,590       190,000    1.5873
  GREENLAND HILLS LT 15 BLK N/21   00000204331000000          B       6/02        309,900         321,360       309,900    1.0370
  BLK R/2186 LT 11                 00000204601000000          B      11/02        285,000         312,830       285,000    1.0976
  GREENLAND HILLS BLK 1/2193 LT    00000205069000000          B      12/02        328,000         343,460       328,000    1.0471
  HOLLYWOOD REV BLK 1/2209 LT 6    00000205975000000          B       3/02        258,000         202,420       258,000     .7846
  OAK LAWN HEIGHTS LOT 24 STONEL   00000211987000000          B       5/02        185,000         180,190       185,000     .9740

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 20 TIME: 17:56 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-905 Dallas CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ HIGHLAND PARK WEST TOWNHOMES B 00000218475100000 B 11/02 227,950 200,000 227,950 .8774 SANTA MONICA BLK B/2704 TR 5 6 00000226798000000 B 7/02 188,000 137,380 188,000 .7307 SANTA MONICA BLK 3/2711 LOT 16 00000227119000000 B 10/02 162,000 190,910 162,000 1.1785 SANTA MONICA BLK 16/2717 LT 5 00000227350000000 B 5/02 333,450 333,450 333,450 1.0000 BLK D/2732 LT 14-A 00000227977000000 B 7/02 190,500 191,470 190,500 1.0051 LAKESHORE HILLS REV BLK 2/2748 00000228547000000 B 6/02 215,000 255,990 215,000 1.1907 GASTONWOOD BLK A/2749 LT 16 AT 00000228835000000 B 6/02 619,000 560,480 615,781 .9102 02770 LOT 1 LA VISTA & BRENDEN 00000229840000000 B 4/02 284,500 229,410 284,500 .8064 COUNTRY CLUB ESTATES BLK C/278 00000230356000000 B 10/02 497,000 479,760 496,006 .9672 COUNTRY CLUB ESTATES BLK K/27 00000230827000000 B 3/02 675,000 723,430 669,870 1.0800 COUNTRY CLUB ESTATES W 35FT 12 00000231085000000 B 6/02 574,500 577,920 571,512 1.0112 DUNIVEN E F BLK D/2805 W 65FT 00000231280000000 B 2/02 420,000 300,500 420,000 .7155 GASTON PLACE BLK E/2806 LOT 6 00000231394000000 B 7/02 309,000 278,860 309,000 .9025 PASADENA BLK D/2810 LOT 2 00000231550000000 B 1/03 270,900 303,430 270,900 1.1201 MONTICELLO BLK E/2829 TR 15 59 00000232486000000 B 10/02 350,000 407,860 350,000 1.1653 MONTICELLO BKJ K/2839 LT 15 & 00000233023000000 B 4/02 820,000 524,280 814,424 .6437 MONTICELLO LOT 3 & 1/2 LOT 2 00000233044000000 B 6/02 610,000 610,000 606,828 1.0052 BLK C/2856 E 1OFT LOT 3 AND W 00000234271000000 B 1/03 285,000 255,670 285,000 .8971 BLK E/2858 LT 4 00000234340000000 B 3/02 265,000 249,920 265,000 .9431 GREENVILLE CREST ANNEX BLK 2/2 00000237892000000 B 1/03 249,900 235,050 249,900 .9406 GREENVILLE CREST ANNEX BLK 5/2 00000238096000000 B 6/02 280,000 266,430 280,000 .9515 ANITA HEIGHTS BLK D/2968 LOT 1 00000244228000000 B 11/02 291,000 276,410 291,000 .9499 NORTH RIDGE ESTS BLK B/2972 LO 00000244807000000 B 3/02 349,000 326,210 349,000 .9347 LEWIS H G BLK 1/2984 LT 9 00000247369000000 B 10/02 257,000 255,950 257,000 .9959 WILLIAMSON-CARUTH TERRACE BLK 00000247747000000 B 1/03 295,000 270,810 295,000 .9180 MAPLEWOOD # 4 BLK C/2998 LOT 00000248750120000 B 1/03 325,000 259,040 325,000 .7970 OAK CLIFF ANNEX BLK 2/3454 LOT 00000272806000000 B 12/02 147,000 144,530 147,000 .9832 RAVINIA HEIGHTS BLK 1/3946 LT 00000298219000000 B 1/03 83,900 81,920 83,900 .9764 LAWTHER DR ESTATES BLK A/4402 00000321484000000 B 5/02 935,000 935,880 929,390 1.0070 GREEN COVE ESTATES BLK C/4404 00000321688000000 B 10/02 745,000 719,690 743,510 .9680 CLOISTERS BLK B/4405 LOT 1 BEN 00000321838000000 B 6/02 450,000 475,990 450,000 1.0578 BOETTCHER HERMAN BLK A/4407 LT 00000322138000000 B 4/02 619,000 638,290 614,790 1.0382 DANIELS EDW W BLK B/4416 PT LO 00000322594000000 B 12/02 559,000 494,100 558,776 .8843 LAWTHERWOOD BLK A/4418 LOT 31 00000322703550000 B 6/02 325,000 315,000 325,000 .9692 SUNSET VIEW REV BLK 10/4516 LT 00000327007000000 B 2/02 142,900 87,000 142,900 .6088 MONT CLAIR ACRES BLK 1/4621 E 00000332005000000 B 11/02 127,250 112,580 127,250 .8847 EAST KESSLER BLK 5/4639 LOT 17 00000332851000000 B 7/02 360,000 364,060 360,000 1.0113 BLK 1/4736 ACS 0.363 OAK CLIFF 00000336187000000 B 6/02 179,000 176,030 179,000 .9834 LAKEWOOD ESTATES 3RD SEC BLK 1 00000346591000000 B 4/02 192,500 181,830 192,500 .9446 GREENWAY PARKS EPT LOT 9 8OFT 00000349456000000 B 1/03 525,000 634,340 525,210 1.2078 GREENWAY PARKS BLK 2/4938 LT 1 00000349471000000 B 5/02 835,000 875,450 829,990 1.0548 GREENWAY PARKS BLK 16/4952 LO 00000350224000000 B 5/02 775,000 793,200 770,350 1.0297 GREENWAY PARKS BLK 17/4953 LT 00000350278000000 B 11/02 1,075,000 1,067,640 1,073,710 .9943 BLUFFVIEW ESTATES BLK F/4976 L 00000351635000000 B 10/02 1,065,000 1,069,530 1,062,870 1.0063 BLUFF VIEW ESTATES BLK O/4984 00000352036000000 B 10/02 474,900 525,880 473,950 1.1096 BLUFFVIEW ESTATES BLK T/4989 W 00000352351000000 B 6/02 332,500 279,630 332,500 .8410 BLUFFVIEW ESTATES BLK T/4989 N 00000352354000000 B 5/02 292,500 274,990 292,500 .9401

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 21 TIME: 17:56 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-905 Dallas CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BRIARWOOD BLK A/5006 LT 5 00000354094000000 B 11/02 318,000 314,820 318,000 .9900 SHORE CREST GARDENS BLK 2/5071 00000358045000000 B 7/02 795,000 795,230 791,502 1.0047 CHAPEL VALLEY BLK A/5074 LT 4 00000358207260000 B 5/02 350,000 257,300 350,000 .7351 BLK D/5084 LOT 19 00000358503860000 B 1/03 295,000 296,180 295,000 1.0040 NORTHWEST HEIGHTS BLK 10/5085 00000359011000000 B 1/03 246,750 238,510 246,750 .9666 EAST INWOOD ESTATES BLK 2/5168 00000365143000000 B 11/02 273,000 270,410 273,000 .9905 EAST INWOOD ESTATES BLK 4/5170 00000365173000000 B 6/02 230,000 266,980 230,000 1.1608 FAIR OAKS TOWNHOMES PHASE I BL 00000366731400000 B 5/02 115,500 118,250 115,500 1.0238 EASTRIDGE TERRACE CONDOMINIUM 00000368124300000 B 8/02 60,000 58,720 60,000 .9787 EASTRIDGE TOWNHOMES PH I BLK 6 00000368308600000 B 12/02 91,500 63,400 91,500 .6929 LAKELAND TERRACE BLK 15/5242 L 00000370021000000 B 10/02 154,900 150,750 154,900 .9732 FOREST HILLS BLK 8/5259 LT 8 00000370855000000 B 6/02 850,000 822,460 845,580 .9727 FOREST HILLS BLK 11/5262 LOT 1 00000371008000000 B 11/02 250,000 247,870 250,000 .9915 FOREST HILLS BLK 29/5280 LT 15 00000371818000000 B 6/02 515,000 512,000 512,322 .9994 SHAMROCK SHORES BLK 1/5285 LT 00000372490000000 B 3/02 145,000 125,900 145,000 .8683 CASA LINDA ESTATES BLK 1/5329 00000374962000000 B 12/02 172,000 174,220 172,000 1.0129 CASA LINDA ESTATES BLK 11/5334 00000375082000000 B 3/02 251,000 255,730 251,000 1.0188 CENTERVILLE TERRACE LOT 13 & 6 00000377542000000 B 12/02 60,000 86,550 60,000 1.4425 EASTRIDGE PARK BLK 19/5361 LOT 00000379105000000 B 3/02 100,800 99,710 100,800 .9892 EASTRIDGE PARK BLK 19/5361 LOT 00000379111000000 B 6/02 94,500 94,570 94,500 1.0007 LOCHWOOD BLK 32/5364 LOT 24 00000382174000000 B 6/02 149,000 155,070 149,000 1.0407 LAKE PARK ESTATES REV BLK 1/53 00000383533000000 B 5/02 187,000 187,000 187,000 1.0000 LOVELAND BLK 1/5374 LT 9 00000389350000000 B 10/02 78,000 77,900 78,000 .9987 EASTWOOD ESTS BLK J/5379 LT 5 00000391360000000 B 4/02 165,000 177,780 165,000 1.0775 LAKE HIGHLANDS BLK 8/5387 LO 00000392146000000 B 12/02 267,500 272,660 267,500 1.0193 LAKE HIGHLANDS BLK 12/5390 LT 00000392281000000 B 7/02 169,500 161,400 169,500 .9522 LOVERS LANE EAST BLK L/5408 L 00000394318420000 B 6/02 210,000 218,000 210,000 1.0381 RIDGEWOOD PARK BLK 9/5419 LT 1 00000395347000000 B 4/02 205,000 202,530 205,000 .9880 RIDGEWOOD PARK BLK 5/5420 LT 9 00000395620000000 B 4/02 227,000 233,630 227,000 1.0292 TOWN NORTH TOWNHOUSE LOT 3 PVT 00000398153080000 B 1/03 143,000 170,340 143,000 1.1912 TOWN NORTH TOWNHOUSE LOT 43 PV 00000398153860000 B 5/02 168,500 154,080 168,500 .9144 WINDSOR PARK BLK G/5454 LT 22 00000403381900000 B 11/02 595,000 732,690 594,286 1.2329 WINDSOR PARK BLK J/5454 LT 23 00000403383450000 B 10/02 535,000 536,180 533,930 1.0042 WINDSOR PARK BLK M/5454 LT 23 00000403558000000 B 6/02 465,000 464,840 465,000 .9997 GLEN LAKES LOT 4 GLEN ALBENS C 00000403752060000 B 11/02 600,000 734,530 599,280 1.2257 GLEN LAKES BLK 2/5454 LT 44 00000403752820000 B 9/02 475,000 567,850 473,670 1.1988 MEADOW'S THE LOT 3 LAKEHURST A 00000404152000000 B 5/02 355,000 350,460 355,000 .9872 MEADOW'S THE LOT 1-A BLK H/54 00000404335000000 B 3/02 350,000 342,340 350,000 .9781 CREST MEADOW ESTATES BLK 5/545 00000404752300000 B 7/02 510,000 486,650 507,756 .9584 NORTH RIDGE BLK B/5463 LT 21 D 00000405208000000 B 2/02 295,000 284,500 295,000 .9644 PRESTON HILLS ADDITION #3 BLK 00000406075000000 B 5/02 257,900 263,410 257,900 1.0214 PRESTON HILLS BLK 8/5465 LOT 8 00000406246000000 B 10/02 414,500 361,040 414,500 .8710 PRESTON ESTS BLK C/5472 LOT 7 00000407005000000 B 7/02 527,700 512,470 525,378 .9754 PARNELL REV LOT 14 PARK LANE A 00000407065000000 B 9/02 880,000 835,981 877,536 .9526 CESCO BLK 1/6475 LOT 4 00000407356000000 B 7/02 482,000 477,540 479,879 .9951 JACKSON HEIGHTS BLK D/5477 LT 00000407764000000 B 5/02 910,000 917,170 904,540 1.0140 STEFANI BLK D/5480 LOT 1 STEFA 00000408235000000 B 8/02 632,500 623,350 630,223 .9891

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 22 TIME: 17:56 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-905 Dallas CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ DEVONSHIRE LOT 3 DESCO 00000408619000000 B 12/02 544,000 520,940 543,782 .9580 HAMILTON & MCCONNELL BLK 1/548 00000408820000000 B 10/02 1,092,841 1,124,990 1,090,655 1.0315 HILLCREST PARK BLK F/5491 LOT 00000409792000000 B 7/02 550,000 530,810 547,580 .9694 FISK LOT 4-B BLK 10/5492 00000410383000000 B 4/02 635,000 556,000 630,682 .8816 PRESTON ROAD EST BLK 12/5492 L 00000410539000000 B 7/02 795,000 796,840 791,502 1.0067 WAGGONER PLACE BLK O/5496 LOT 00000411400000000 B 7/02 850,000 691,500 846,260 .8171 PEMBERTON BLK 6/5498 LOT 7 00000412078000000 B 12/02 330,225 351,890 330,225 1.0656 PEMBERTON BLK 7/5498 LOT 7 00000412132000000 B 10/02 975,000 1,087,380 973,050 1.1175 ROYAL HILLS BLK 14/5498 LOT 3 00000412243000000 B 5/02 490,000 483,040 487,060 .9917 PRESTON ROYAL REV BLK 5/5499 00000412450000000 B 4/02 1,300,000 1,300,000 1,291,160 1.0068 ROYAL CREST BLK C/5500 LT 16 00000412615000000 B 9/02 718,500 697,396 716,488 .9734 ROYAL CREST BLK E/5500 LT 1 00000412651000000 B 4/02 1,050,000 884,310 1,042,860 .8480 ROYAL CREST BLK 10/5500 LT 5 00000413104000000 B 7/02 634,900 537,430 632,106 .8502 BLK A/5510 LT 3 00000414742480000 B 1/03 1,045,000 862,500 1,045,418 .8250 MEADERS LANE BLK A/5511 LOT 2 00000414751000000 B 8/02 699,900 701,690 697,380 1.0062 MAYFLOWER ESTATES BLK E/5517 L 00000415606000000 B 5/02 1,775,000 1,754,810 1,764,350 .9946 ROYAL RIDGE ADDN BLK 1/5535 L 00000416611000000 B 8/02 327,500 324,760 327,500 .9916 LES JARDINS BLK 3/5535 LT 56 00000416929000000 B 11/02 280,000 278,970 280,000 .9963 KELSEY SQUARE BLK 2/5539 LT 7 00000418246000000 B 11/02 475,000 479,210 474,430 1.0101 BLK 5542 LOT 14 00000419044000000 B 5/02 400,000 432,140 400,000 1.0804 BLK 5542 LOT 58 00000419173000000 B 2/02 355,000 502,460 352,018 1.4274 MEADOWOOD EST SEC 2 BLK 5543 00000419386000000 B 7/02 2,160,000 2,160,000 2,150,496 1.0044 ROCKBROOK ESTS BLK B/5549 LT 3 00000419707000000 B 9/02 950,000 994,830 947,340 1.0501 SUNNYBROOK ESTATES BLK 3/5576 00000420622000000 B 11/02 1,325,000 1,324,910 1,323,410 1.0011 SUNNYBROOK ESTATES BLK 6/5579 00000420778000000 B 8/02 2,550,000 2,665,160 2,540,820 1.0489 PRESTON HOLLOW PT 3-15X128.65X 00000421339000000 B 2/02 570,000 633,520 565,212 1.1209 BATESONS BLK 7/5597 E142FT LT 00000421465000000 B 5/02 1,070,000 1,075,120 1,063,580 1.0109 IDLEWILD ACRES BLK D/5634 LT 1 00000423694000000 B 4/02 277,000 282,200 277,000 1.0188 BLK F/5636 LT 8-A 00000423760000000 B 1/03 365,000 364,870 365,000 .9996 IDLEWILD ACRES BLK N/5641 LOT 00000424117000000 B 8/02 285,000 296,340 285,000 1.0398 IDLEWILD ACRES BLK N/5641 LT 00000424123000000 B 10/02 385,000 375,600 385,000 .9756 COLONY RIDGE BLK 2/5671 LT 12 00000425290000000 B 6/02 275,000 277,040 275,000 1.0074 LINWOOD PLACE BLK B/5680 LOT 5 00000425692000000 B 9/02 231,000 234,120 231,000 1.0135 LINWOOD PLACE LOT 4 HANOVER 00000425785000000 B 7/02 181,875 180,840 181,875 .9943 KESSLER WOODS REV BLK 3/5928 L 00000459538000000 B 1/03 247,500 243,610 247,500 .9843 MERRIFIELD MANOR BLK L/5954 LO 00000460543000000 B 2/02 150,000 117,190 150,000 .7813 ROLAND HILLS BLK H/5961 LOT 18 00000463345000000 B 5/02 66,500 66,350 66,500 .9977 WEST CLIFF BLK 6/5961 LOT 3 00000463906000000 B 11/02 86,900 86,000 86,900 .9896 WESTMORELAND HEIGHTS BLK 5/596 00000464920000000 B 7/02 96,000 49,670 96,000 .5174 WYNNEWOOD BLK 55/5973 LOT 5 MA 00000468064000000 B 7/02 302,000 243,670 302,000 .8069 WYNNEWOOD PARK #3 BLK 13/5976 00000471856000000 B 3/02 53,545 55,700 53,545 1.0402 GLENVIEW ADDN BLK 7/6017 LT 15 00000484162000000 B 12/02 88,000 79,420 88,000 .9025 CLEARVIEW BLK 3/6026 LOT 29 GL 00000488986000000 B 11/02 91,000 78,150 91,000 .8588 ACREAGE ESTATES BLK 2/6028 LT 00000490390000000 B 10/02 164,500 110,420 164,500 .6712 BUCKNER TERRACE BLK 6/6127 LO 00000515509100000 B 9/02 138,000 153,800 138,000 1.1145 LAKE TERRACE BLK E/6133 LT 5 B 00000518035000000 B 8/02 182,000 176,180 182,000 .9680 LOT 11 00000527071000000 B 8/02 158,000 171,000 158,000 1.0823

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 23 TIME: 17:56 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-905 Dallas CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ DAVILLA DRIVE ESTATES BLK D/61 00000529801000000 B 5/02 98,000 97,020 98,000 .9900 NORTH DAVILLA DR ESTATES BLK 1 00000531007000000 B 4/02 150,000 227,210 150,000 1.5147 BUCKNER PARK BLK 33/6237 LOT 1 00000548710000000 B 8/02 75,300 67,080 75,300 .8908 OAK HILL PARK ANNEX BLK 6/6323 00000565477000000 B 3/02 84,400 79,490 84,400 .9418 BLK 6332 LT 102 00000567778000000 B 1/03 37,000 48,250 37,000 1.3041 CRAWFORD PARK TERRACE REV BLK 00000571582000000 B 12/02 78,500 58,960 78,500 .7511 NORTHAVEN PARK BLK B/6388 LOT 00000578455000000 B 7/02 310,000 309,120 310,000 .9972 RUSSWOOD ACRES BLK 4/6389 LT 00000578764000000 B 5/02 569,000 618,780 565,586 1.0941 RUSSWOOD ACRES LOT 27 ROYAL CR 00000578836000000 B 6/02 681,250 664,090 677,707 .9799 RUSSWOOD ACRES BLK 6/6389 LOT 00000578965000000 B 8/02 775,000 785,460 772,210 1.0172 RUSSWOOD ACRES BLK 6/6389 LT 2 00000579007000000 B 7/02 803,750 802,810 800,213 1.0032 RUSSWOOD ACRES BLK 7/6389 LT 7 00000579052000000 B 9/02 775,000 777,040 772,830 1.0054 NORTHAVEN ESTATES LOT 17 CROOK 00000579142000000 B 2/02 461,250 481,180 457,375 1.0520 HOCKADAY SQUARE BLK8/6392 LOT 00000579550000000 B 3/02 327,750 343,170 327,750 1.0470 HOCKADAY MANOR LOT 3 MENDENHAL 00000580423000000 B 6/02 250,000 256,660 250,000 1.0266 NORTH HIGHLANDS ESTS BLK I/639 00000580855000000 B 6/02 335,000 387,490 335,000 1.1567 NORTH HIGHLANDS ESTS BLK L/639 00000580996000000 B 12/02 213,000 202,800 213,000 .9521 HOCKADAY SQUARE BLK A/6398 LT 00000581186350000 B 4/02 330,000 330,000 330,000 1.0000 SAN GABRIEL ESTS BLK 1/6400 L 00000581488000000 B 6/02 420,000 417,310 420,000 .9936 MIDWAY HILLS BLK 1/6403 LT 16 00000582016000000 B 5/02 356,000 302,020 356,000 .8484 GLEN COVE BLK 2/6406 LT 19 00000583156000000 B 8/02 198,900 196,960 198,900 .9902 GLEN COVE BLK 7/6406 LT 16 00000583525000000 B 11/02 205,500 201,370 205,500 .9799 MIDWAY HILLS LOT 4 WEEBURN DR 00000583981000000 B 5/02 335,000 286,370 335,000 .8548 ROYAL OAKS PARK BLK D/6412 LOT 00000584851220000 B 8/02 312,000 311,700 312,000 .9990 WALNUT GARDENS BLK 5/6426 LOT 00000586201000000 B 5/02 196,500 147,740 196,500 .7519 HIGHLAND NORTH REV BLK G/6429 00000587503000000 B 11/02 164,500 174,440 164,500 1.0604 BLK D/6436 LOT 19 00000591994000000 B 9/02 161,500 161,910 161,500 1.0025 CORAL HILLS BLK 17/6441 PT LOT 00000594136000000 B 11/02 139,900 140,640 139,900 1.0053 UNDERWOOD ESTATES LOT 10 PALLO 00000595447000000 B 4/02 305,000 294,630 305,000 .9660 WALNUT HILLS LOT 5 CATAMORE LA 00000598927000000 B 8/02 128,500 119,270 128,500 .9282 NORTHAVEN HILLS BLK B/6586 LT 00000606166000000 B 5/02 499,010 481,500 496,016 .9707 ROYALHAVEN BLK 3/6596 LOT 17 00000607198000000 B 8/02 129,700 112,550 129,700 .8678 SANDLEWOOD BLK A/6598 LOT 9 TA 00000607855000000 B 8/02 110,000 120,060 110,000 1.0915 SANDLEWOOD LOT 5 WILDFLOWER DR 00000607900000000 B 6/02 146,000 139,440 146,000 .9551 ROYALHAVEN REV BLK 5/6600 LT 1 00000608542000000 B 6/02 127,900 106,700 127,900 .8342 BLK 10/6688 LT 14 00000624435760000 B 12/02 66,500 67,530 66,500 1.0155 BRUTON TERRACE LOT 24 CASTLEFI 00000628591000000 B 11/02 85,000 76,490 85,000 .8999 WALDRUM #1 BLK 6743 LOT 31 00000629995000000 B 6/02 65,000 65,680 65,000 1.0105 WOODLAND CANYON LK 7/6909 LOT 00000648262000000 B 12/02 97,500 93,710 97,500 .9611 GLEN OAKS BLK 13/6912 LT 14 00000650344000000 B 9/02 93,000 104,920 93,000 1.1282 KIEST FOREST LOT 11 KIESTHILL 00000656392000000 B 12/02 115,000 115,850 115,000 1.0074 PRESTON SQUARE TOWN HOMES BLK 00000661764600000 B 2/02 188,000 217,760 188,000 1.1583 PRESTON SQUARE TOWN HOMES BLK 00000661765300000 B 10/02 204,500 224,380 204,500 1.0972 PRESTON SQUARE TOWN HOMES BLK 00000661767800000 B 3/02 182,500 224,750 182,500 1.2315 PRESTON SQUARE TOWN HOMES BLK 00000661768200000 B 9/02 174,000 169,000 174,000 .9713 MELSHIRE ESTATES BLK 2/6995 L 00000661822000000 B 7/02 450,000 375,910 450,000 .8354 FOREST MEADE REV B/7040 LT 24 00000663793000000 B 8/02 219,800 183,820 219,800 .8363

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 24 TIME: 17:56 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-905 Dallas CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ CLAREMONT BLK 2/7060 LT 21 00000665053000000 B 12/02 120,000 114,740 120,000 .9562 NORTH LAKE ESTS BLK C/7271 LT 00000704080000000 B 8/02 469,250 478,330 467,560 1.0230 HIGH HOLLOWS CONDOMINIUM BLDG 00000706482900000 B 1/03 105,000 76,230 105,000 .7260 CASA LINDA FOREST BLK G/7295 L 00000706903000000 B 5/02 160,000 160,900 160,000 1.0056 CASA VIEW OAKS BLK 4/7300 LOT 00000709102000000 B 6/02 80,000 87,070 80,000 1.0884 EUDORA ESTATES LOT 16 EUDORA & 00000721441000000 B 3/02 433,500 410,190 433,500 .9462 JANMAR CIRCLE BLK 15/7347 LOT 00000722683000000 B 10/02 538,500 536,040 537,423 .9974 SHILOH TERRACE BLK A/7352 LT 3 00000723727000000 B 7/02 93,000 76,630 93,000 .8240 WHITE ROCK VILLAGE BLK F/7375 00000725327750000 B 10/02 119,000 117,850 119,000 .9903 SAN JUAN HEIGHTS BLK F/7403 L 00000730060000000 B 10/02 120,000 121,600 120,000 1.0133 FOREST PLACE BLK 6/7405 LT 06 00000730938250000 B 5/02 525,500 530,300 522,347 1.0152 PRESTON RD NORTH ESTS REV BLK 00000731197000000 B 6/02 750,000 757,450 746,100 1.0152 HUFFHINES HILL BLK 3/7445 LT 7 00000732952000000 B 10/02 212,000 240,000 212,000 1.1321 PRESTON CLUB BLK E/7454 LT 16 00000733726000000 B 1/03 1,032,750 1,033,920 1,033,163 1.0007 PRESTON CLUB ESTS BLK F/7454 L 00000733744000000 B 10/02 870,000 798,310 868,260 .9194 RACEY-GRAHAM BLK 28/7460 LT 2 00000734350000000 B 12/02 1,175,000 1,225,000 1,174,530 1.0430 PRESTON BROOK BLK 39/7460 LT 00000734572000000 B 7/02 470,000 500,380 467,932 1.0693 AUDUBON ESTATES BLK 43/7460 L 00000734686000000 B 4/02 315,000 301,900 315,000 .9584 PARC DU LAC ESTS BLK 23/7460 L 00000734717040000 B 7/02 699,000 597,000 695,924 .8579 CASA VIEW HEIGHTS BLK A/7470 00000735286000000 B 4/02 49,000 49,800 49,000 1.0163 POLK TERRACE LOT 15 WOODSHIRE 00000746878000000 B 4/02 43,500 58,630 43,500 1.3478 CARTER SQUARE BLK 2/7565 LOT 1 00000750815110000 B 4/02 79,900 75,430 79,900 .9441 LOCHWOOD MEADOWS BLK 7/7691 LT 00000764356000000 B 9/02 187,500 209,370 187,500 1.1166 LOCHWOOD MEADOWS BLK 10/7691 L 00000764593000000 B 1/03 186,750 186,440 186,750 .9983 LOCHWOOD MEADOWS BLOCK 23/7692 00000764692460000 B 12/02 207,000 198,649 207,000 .9597 LOCHWOOD ESTATES BLK 4/7694 LO 00000765280000000 B 4/02 130,000 123,130 130,000 .9472 BLK 7773 LOT 18 00000769507000000 B 7/02 29,035 51,370 29,035 1.7692 BRAIRWOOD ESTS BLK 4/8049 LT 6 00000786971600000 B 7/02 119,000 111,100 119,000 .9336 BRAIRWOOD ESTS BLK 4/8049 LOT 00000786971730000 B 1/03 106,000 109,050 106,000 1.0288 PRESTON TRAILS BLK 10/8209 LOT 00000799734000000 B 12/02 1,694,000 1,800,760 1,693,322 1.0634 PRESTON PARK BLK 1A/8218 LT 7 00000799885150000 B 9/02 450,000 480,260 448,740 1.0702 BENT TREE BLK 2/8227 LOT 51A 00000799934500000 B 3/02 360,000 400,000 360,000 1.1111 BENT TREE VILLAGE BLK 2B/8229 00000799941140000 B 10/02 275,000 270,540 275,000 .9838 MEADOW PARK BLK E/8385 LOT 6 00000808255000000 B 9/02 165,000 167,890 165,000 1.0175 MEADOW PARK #5 BLK G/8386 LT 1 00000808480000000 B 6/02 173,000 177,120 173,000 1.0238 ROSSER VILLAGE BLK AA/8387 LO 00000808580200000 B 5/02 135,000 135,560 135,000 1.0041 CRESTPARK CLUB BLK X/8387 LT 00000808591660000 B 5/02 218,300 218,890 218,300 1.0027 SCHREIBER MANOR BLK 8/8396 LOT 00000809242000000 B 2/02 253,000 260,190 253,000 1.0284 INWOOD NORTH ESTATES BLK 3/839 00000809869000000 B 4/02 288,000 283,930 288,000 .9859 BUCKNER TERRACE BLK U/8473 LT 00000812749000000 B 10/02 148,775 144,580 148,775 .9718 PRESTONWOOD BLK 35/8189 LT 19 00000820448360000 B 11/02 207,000 208,300 207,000 1.0063 GARDEN HEIGHTS BLK A/8800 LT 2 00000899751200000 B 8/02 79,900 79,410 79,900 .9939 BRYAN PLACE PHASE FOUR SECTION 0005030B000020000 B 1/03 172,000 165,540 172,000 .9624 BRYAN PLACE PHASE FOUR SECTION 0005030B000180000 B 8/02 260,000 231,520 260,000 .8905 THOMAS COURT PH 1B BLK L/574 L 000574000L0240000 B 4/02 315,000 318,500 315,000 1.0111 PERRY HALLSVILLE BLK I/592 LT 000592000I09D0000 B 7/02 402,636 402,640 402,636 1.0000 BOWSER METRO BLK D/1056 LT 14A 001056000D14A0000 B 8/02 465,000 447,070 465,000 .9614

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 25 TIME: 17:56 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-905 Dallas CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ REIGER COLLETT SUBDIVISION BLK 0014300A0008A0000 B 4/02 371,061 371,060 371,061 1.0000 GREGORY TOWNHOMES 1 BLK I/1531 001531000I08A0000 B 10/02 552,566 552,570 551,461 1.0020 HOLLAND-REAGAN 2 BLK 3/1567 LT 001567000316D0000 B 6/02 352,000 397,990 352,000 1.1307 PARKLAWN BLK 13/1578 LT 24 00157800130240000 B 9/02 248,000 248,000 248,000 1.0000 CARLTON CORNER 3 BLK 7/1579 L 001579000709D0000 B 9/02 362,982 428,270 362,982 1.1799 TREMONT-ABRAMS BLK C/1665 LT 1 001665000C01B0000 B 4/02 298,800 297,750 298,800 .9965 THE WARRINGTON BLK 1345 2.1 0019O82000010008B B 3/02 840,000 886,000 833,616 1.0628 OAK GROVE CONDO BLK 971 LOT 2 0019O950000B00107 B 1/03 89,000 89,010 89,000 1.0001 BONAVENTURE CONDOS BLK 8707 LO 0029N800000100123 B 4/02 237,000 350,400 237,000 1.4785 BONAVENTURE CONDOS BLK 8707 LO 0029N800000101017 B 10/02 169,000 227,500 169,000 1.3462 OAKS ON MONTFORT PH II,III,IV 0029N830000S01901 B 8/02 71,500 60,010 71,500 .8393 PRESTON OAKS CROSSING CONDOS 1 0029N87000HH00003 B 6/02 86,500 89,900 86,500 1.0393 KELLER SPRINGS CONDOS BLK 8707 0029N880000G00721 B 7/02 89,000 95,160 89,000 1.0692 BENT TREE FOREST DR. CONDOS BL 0029N890000M00150 B 4/02 56,900 55,970 56,900 .9837 HM WADES BLK V/2983 LOT 18 0.2 0029830V000180000 B 3/02 515,000 476,320 511,086 .9320 COCHRAN HOLLOW BLK D/5074 LT 1 005074000D0160000 B 12/02 680,000 646,080 679,728 .9505 ENCLAVE AT WHITE ROCK BLK B/52 005250000B0490000 B 5/02 293,000 289,920 293,000 .9895 HIGHLAND ON THE CREEK REPLAT B 0052520A000170000 B 4/02 329,000 368,010 329,000 1.1186 HIGHLAND ON THE CREEK REP BLK 0052520A000450000 B 7/02 345,000 346,850 345,000 1.0054 CARUTH VILLAGE REPLAT BLK D/54 0054500D0010A0000 B 1/03 510,000 540,650 510,204 1.0597 BLK F/5453 LOT 63 0054530F000630000 B 6/02 440,000 424,180 440,000 .9640 GLEN LAKES 9 BLK 13/5454 LT 11 00545400130110000 B 9/02 950,000 940,590 947,340 .9929 WALNUT ESTATES BLK F/5540 LT 1 005540000F0010000 B 12/02 998,500 837,930 998,100 .8395 WALNUT ESTATES BLK F/5540 LOT 005540000F0040000 B 7/02 940,000 893,670 935,864 .9549 WALNUT ESTATES BLK F/5540 LT 6 005540000F0060000 B 6/02 953,000 893,650 948,044 .9426 BORDEAUX VILLAGE CONDOS BLK 56 0059M570000G06472 B 2/02 92,680 105,990 92,680 1.1436 BORDEAUX VILLAGE CONDOMINIUM B 0059M570000R06323 B 10/02 104,900 105,990 104,900 1.0104 OAK PARK NORTH BLK V/6048 LOT 0060480V000120000 B 12/02 115,000 104,460 115,000 .9083 EVERGLADE PARK SEC 7 PHASE 1 B 0061270CC00130000 B 3/02 134,000 166,770 134,000 1.2446 EVERGLADE PARK 5TH SEC BLK 13/ 00612700130070000 B 9/02 118,900 117,320 118,900 .9867 ST FRANCIS PLACE PH 3 BLK 10A/ 006127010A0130000 B 4/02 123,600 101,890 123,600 .8244 RIVERWAY ESTS BLK 1/6315 LOT 00631500010030000 B 11/02 86,000 79,520 86,000 .9247 NORTHTOWN SQUARE BLK 4B/6595 L 0065950B040250000 B 4/02 123,000 131,830 123,000 1.0718 HILLSIDE OAKS PHS 5 #1 BLK 5/6 00676400051380000 B 3/02 83,000 85,660 83,000 1.0320 HILLSIDE OAKS PH 5 #2 BLK 14/6 00676400140570000 B 7/02 80,000 86,120 80,000 1.0765 INDEPENDENCE PARK #2 REPLAT BL 0067850E0046A0000 B 3/02 69,900 59,870 69,900 .8565 PRESTON SQUARE TOWN HOMES BLK 00699400011330000 B 4/02 205,000 210,110 205,000 1.0249 ASH CREEK ADDN BLK E/7378 LOT 0073780E000250000 B 3/02 122,000 126,950 122,000 1.0406 PRESTON VALLEY 11 BLK 7416 LT 007416000044A0000 B 12/02 152,500 140,070 152,500 .9185 DOWNS OF HILLCREST PH 1B-R BLK 00745700D107A0000 B 11/02 945,000 941,700 943,866 .9977 DOWNS OF HILLCREST PH 2 BLK G- 00745700G10650000 B 5/02 970,000 880,000 964,180 .9127 DOWNS OF HILLCREST PH 1A BLK E 007457000E0160000 B 9/02 720,500 771,590 718,482 1.0739 DALLAS PROJECT NO 1 EAST BLK 2 00746000200130000 B 2/02 662,500 633,870 656,935 .9649 LAKE FOREST PH C BLK C/7462 LT 007462000C0610000 B 2/02 915,000 1,156,840 907,314 1.2750 LAKE FOREST PH F BLK K/7462 LT 007462000K0200000 B 8/02 695,000 750,650 692,498 1.0840 LAKE HIGHLANDS POINTE BLK A/74 007484000A0270000 B 4/02 259,500 234,060 259,500 .9020 PEBBLEBROOK BLK G/7487 LT 5 0074870G000050000 B 7/02 115,000 122,580 115,000 1.0659

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 26 TIME: 17:56 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-905 Dallas CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ CAMBRIDGE PLACE AT PRESTON TRA 00820900130270000 B 7/02 679,000 728,930 676,012 1.0783 GLEN ABBEY BLK A/8212 LT 15 008212000A0150000 B 3/02 500,000 581,070 496,200 1.1710 BRIARWOOD ADDN BLK C/8474 LT 0084740C000090000 B 12/02 82,200 82,370 82,200 1.0021 ADDISON PLACE BLK C LOT 4 100006500C0040000 B 2/02 155,000 171,610 155,000 1.1072 ADDISON PLACE REV BLK K LT 13 100006500K0130000 B 12/02 180,000 183,890 180,000 1.0216 MIDWAY MEADOWS BLK C LOT 54 10000926196040000 B 9/02 175,000 162,590 175,000 .9291 AVENTURA CONDOS THE ASHTON BLK 10001500000000214 B 6/02 245,000 251,450 245,000 1.0263 GRAND ADDISON 3 BLK 3 LT 24 10004350030240000 B 6/02 236,000 200,020 236,000 .8475 LES LACS PH 1 BLK A LOT 19 100048100A0190000 B 6/02 264,000 259,680 264,000 .9836 WATERFORD BLK A LOT 188 100059500A1880000 B 5/02 285,000 277,400 285,000 .9733 WATERFORD PARK 2 BLK B LOT 3 100060200B0030000 B 2/02 309,000 275,990 309,000 .8932 WATERFORD PARK 2 BLK D LOT 9 100060200D0090000 B 5/02 254,000 250,890 254,000 .9878 WOODS REV REP LT 1 10008010000010000 B 8/02 925,000 980,300 921,670 1.0636 BRIARWYCK ESTATES PH 1 BLK J L 14006600100100000 B 5/02 153,000 158,090 153,000 1.0333 COUNTRY VILLAS BLK A LOT 4 14027700010040000 B 5/02 109,934 98,750 109,934 .8983 COUNTRY VILLAS BLK D LOT 22 14027700040220000 B 1/03 112,000 113,700 112,000 1.0152 COUNTRY VILLAS BLK E LOT 4 14027700050040000 B 4/02 124,100 125,000 124,100 1.0073 WELLINGTON RUN PH 1 AMND BLK F 141101600F0090000 B 12/02 220,000 212,470 220,000 .9658 JOHNSTON PARK 3 BLK 21 LT 12 24099500210120000 B 11/02 124,900 122,210 124,900 .9785 TOWN NORTH ESTATES BLK 3 LOT 6 24169500030060000 B 8/02 122,900 117,970 122,900 .9599 HIGHLAND PARK BLK 154 LT 7 60084501540070000 B 11/02 380,000 327,360 380,000 .8615 HIGHLAND PARK WEST 9TH INST BL 60084501590050000 B 7/02 700,000 740,410 696,920 1.0624 JOHN D MERCHANT ABST 850 PG 07 65085007110340000 B 3/02 200,000 176,900 200,000 .8845 352 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9837 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LA FINA APARTMENTS 00000110125000000 C 8/02 342,000 342,000 342,000 1.0000 BONA VENTURE APTS. 00000120088000000 C 5/02 320,000 344,390 320,000 1.0800 KNICKERBOCKER APTS. 00000120751000000 C 5/02 235,000 150,980 235,000 .6400 DALLAS 00000121117000000 C 7/02 170,000 170,000 170,000 1.0000 DUNCAN BLK 10/732 LT 9 & 10 F 00000122965000000 B 10/02 152,000 99,530 152,000 .6548 AVENUE HEIGHTS BLK B/770 40FT 00000124360000000 B 3/03 184,900 135,260 184,900 .7315 DALLAS 00000124759000000 C 6/02 349,000 360,000 349,000 1.0300 DALLAS 00000125056000000 C 10/02 109,000 113,170 109,000 1.0400 DALLAS 00000125572000000 C 8/02 147,000 149,290 147,000 1.0200 RAYS E H BLK 1/799-1/2 PT LT 4 00000126043000000 B 7/02 155,300 170,630 155,300 1.0987 DALLAS 00000131269000000 C 6/02 785,000 785,000 785,000 1.0000 EDGEWOOD BLK 3/1283 LTS 1 & 2 00000147196000000 B 6/02 785,000 100,000 785,000 .1274

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 27 TIME: 17:56 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-905 Dallas CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ HANN & KENDALLS BLK 1/1318 LT 00000148723000000 B 1/03 495,000 372,440 495,000 .7524 DALLAS 00000156601000000 C 4/02 450,000 450,000 450,000 1.0000 KNIGHTSBURY APTS. 00000157966000000 C 10/02 395,000 408,230 395,000 1.0300 DALLAS 00000158011000000 C 2/02 319,000 331,020 319,000 1.0400 F R WILSONS NORTH DALLAS BLK 1 00000158716000100 B 4/02 560,000 560,000 560,000 1.0000 DIMENSION I 00000160828000000 C 4/02 735,000 422,630 735,000 .5800 BLK 35/1575 LT 1 00000160840000000 B 4/02 735,000 422,630 735,000 .5750 DELMAR HEIGHTS BLK 10/1920 LOT 00000185830000000 B 3/03 155,000 233,370 155,000 1.5056 DELMAR HEIGHTS BLK 11/1923 LT 00000186085000000 B 6/02 205,000 173,270 205,000 .8452 DELMAR HEIGHTS BLK 12/1924 LT 00000186115000001 B 1/03 229,000 114,500 229,000 .5000 VICKERY PLACE BLK 17/1930 LOT 00000186571000000 B 10/02 118,000 116,230 118,000 .9850 VICKERY PLACE BLK 27/1946 LT 00000187849000000 B 5/02 120,000 121,770 120,000 1.0148 VICKERY PARK BLK 7/1973 N PT L 00000190657000000 B 9/02 221,000 109,400 221,000 .4950 UNIVERSITY PLACE BLK 17/2029 L 00000196246000000 B 6/02 380,000 141,000 380,000 .3711 DALLAS 00000196504000000 C 3/02 415,000 500,000 415,000 1.2000 UNIVERSITY PLACE BLK 21/2036 L 00000196570000000 B 12/02 196,500 233,420 196,500 1.1879 NORTH OAK LAWN BLK 8/2044 LOT 00000196915000001 B 8/02 255,750 145,640 255,750 .5695 ALTADENA REV LOT 15 REVERE PL 00000237256000000 B 12/02 198,000 198,000 198,000 1.0000 DALLAS 00000238195000000 C 5/02 400,000 400,000 400,000 1.0000 BEL AIR 00000252952000000 C 1/02 285,000 285,000 285,000 1.0000 JORDAN ARMS 00000252973000000 C 4/02 335,000 335,000 335,000 1.0000 VIRGINA APTS. 00000252991000000 C 6/02 172,000 172,000 172,000 1.0000 WINNETKA HEIGHTS BLK 11/3259 L 00000259960000000 B 10/02 177,000 177,340 177,000 1.0019 SUNSET HILL BLK 18/3447 LT 00000270358000000 B 11/02 110,000 100,750 110,000 .9159 INWOOD HOUSE 00000342778000000 C 5/02 535,000 537,480 535,000 1.0000 GATES OF BLUFFVIEW 00000359317000000 C 10/02 13,200,000 13,200,000 13,200,000 1.0000 ACACIA VILLAGE I 00000367039000000 C 2/02 2,450,000 2,450,000 2,450,000 1.0000 CLARIDGE POINT APTS. 00000367576500000 C 8/02 4,200,000 4,200,000 4,200,000 1.0000 CASA LINDA HIGHLANDS BLK C/530 00000373630000000 B 7/02 198,000 102,580 198,000 .5181 PARK PRESTON #1 BLK A/5508 LT 00000414700520100 B 6/02 232,050 228,990 232,050 .9868 KIEST MANOR 00000491320000000 C 7/02 220,000 252,370 220,000 1.1500 VILLAGE OAKS 00000510752000000 C 9/02 5,300,000 5,269,650 5,300,000 .9900 BUCKNER TERRACE BLK L/6127 LOT 00000515472740000 B 4/02 112,000 122,050 112,000 1.0897 BLK 4A/6595 LOT 19.1 N PT 00000606908360100 B 4/02 93,500 107,990 93,500 1.1550 CHAPEL FOREST ADDN BLK 2B/6595 00000607011020000 B 5/02 117,000 109,570 117,000 .9365 CHAPEL FOREST BLK 2B/6595 E 1/ 00000607011240100 B 4/02 106,000 101,760 106,000 .9600 CHAPEL FOREST BLK 2B/6595 LOT 00000607011520100 B 7/02 112,200 101,960 112,200 .9087 ASH CREEK ESTS BLK B/6643 LT 00000619600000000 B 7/02 145,000 125,350 145,000 .8645 HIGHLAND HILLS APTS. 00000639603000000 C 10/02 8,200,000 8,200,000 8,200,000 1.0000 ARBORETUM AT CLIFF CREEK 00000654103300000 C 3/02 5,050,000 5,050,000 5,050,000 1.0000 CREST MEADOW ESTATES BLK E/728 00000706425740000 B 3/03 150,000 150,000 150,000 1.0000 CREST MEADOW ESTATES N PT LT 7 00000706426910000 B 3/03 175,000 196,990 175,000 1.1257 CREST MEADOW ESTATES 6TH INST 00000706426970100 B 6/02 210,000 210,000 210,000 1.0000 CREST MEADOW ESTATES BLK J/728 00000706427160000 B 5/02 175,000 172,620 175,000 .9864 CREST MEADOW ESTS BLK M/7288 L 00000706427980001 B 4/02 174,900 173,150 174,900 .9900 CREST MEADOW ESTATES BLK M/728 00000706431240100 B 7/02 170,000 171,510 170,000 1.0089 COBBLESTONE 00000706458500000 C 10/02 17,600,000 15,000,000 17,600,000 .8523

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 28 TIME: 17:56 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-905 Dallas CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LOFTS 00013000280210000 C 4/02 500,000 500,000 500,000 1.0000 HERSCHAL TOWNHOMES BLK 11/2034 002034001109A0000 B 4/02 395,000 397,000 395,000 1.0100 BEL AIR BLK D/2869 LOT 4 1/2 D 0028690D000040000 B 4/02 113,500 119,660 113,500 1.0543 MARIN WAY BLK A/5417 LT 17 1/2 0054170A000179900 B 7/02 265,000 116,400 265,000 .4392 BUCKNER TERRACE APTS #2 BLK 1/ 00612700010010600 B 3/03 107,250 137,700 107,250 1.2839 BUCKNER TERRACE APTS #2 BLK 1/ 00612700010020500 B 3/03 110,000 110,000 110,000 1.0000 ERINS WAY 00695900190060000 C 5/02 956,000 950,000 956,000 .9900 MIDWAY MEADOWS REV BLK A LT 5A 10000926194080000 B 3/03 169,800 148,260 169,800 .8731 COUNTRY PLACE SEC 6 BLK A LOT 14023600010240100 B 9/02 147,500 132,450 147,500 .8980 COUNTRY PLACE SEC 6 BLK A W P 14023600010320100 B 5/02 146,500 147,640 146,500 1.0078 COUNTRY PLACE DUPLEX BLK 1 LOT 14024500010070000 B 8/02 334,900 335,000 334,900 1.0003 70 SALES CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD APPR TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER MOD OBS VALUE APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ CARUTH MANOR 00000394300000000 1.00 .00 3,695,540 3,312,000 1.1200 VILLAGE MEADOW 00000394347970000 1.00 .00 9,644,000 10,117,000 .9500 TIMBERCREEK 00000394919000000 1.00 .00 23,640,000 24,853,000 .9500 HIGHLAND MEADOWS 00000738184500000 1.00 .00 4,000,000 4,129,000 .9700 PARKWAY PLACE 00000794402500000 1.00 .00 14,000,000 17,336,000 .8100 LOFTS OF 588 000588000U01A0000 1.00 .00 13,100,000 16,081,000 .8100 CRESCENT VILLAS 000945000A0010000 1.00 .00 19,500,000 22,783,000 .8600 COLE & HALL APTS 000972000901A0000 1.00 .00 12,909,000 13,044,000 .9900 WEST VILLAGE 000980000A01A0000 1.00 .00 40,099,200 37,485,000 1.0700 BELCOURT VILLAS 001619000B07A0000 1.00 .00 13,800,000 14,378,000 .9600 MOCKINGBIRD PHOENIX 002940000A0030000 1.00 .00 37,500,000 36,845,000 1.0200 VISTGA DEL LAGO 004414000B0020000 1.00 .00 20,203,680 18,735,000 1.0800 PRESTON VILLAGE APTS 005464000701A0000 1.00 .00 30,748,500 35,671,000 .8600 HEATHERWOOD APTS 0067960A000010100 1.00 .00 2,992,460 3,328,000 .9000 14 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9391 CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ JOHN D COLES ADDN BLK 1/635 LO 00000117079000000 C 6/02 109,500 109,560 109,500 1.0005

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 29 TIME: 17:56 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-905 Dallas CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ MONARCH PLACE BLK 4/694 LOT 6 00000121066000000 C 6/02 35,000 35,030 35,000 1.0000 SNODGRASS BLK A/0904 PT LOT 4 00000132997000000 C 12/02 28,000 28,000 28,000 1.0000 BLK 3/4736 LTS 1-3 & PT LTS 4, 00000336211000000 C 8/02 599,000 600,390 599,000 1.0023 GREENWAY PARKS BLK 6/4942 LT 1 00000349639000000 C 3/02 585,000 528,000 585,000 .9026 05508C LT 20 BLK C/5508 00000414703380000 C 11/02 236,000 231,250 236,000 .9799 PRESTON HOLLOW REV BLK A/5591 00000421282000000 C 5/02 975,000 777,600 975,000 .7975 05601 TRACT 2 - 1.965 ACRES 00000421714000000 C 6/02 1,775,000 1,257,600 1,775,000 .7085 INWOOD BLK 3/5604 LOT 4 00000421786000000 C 2/02 950,000 829,600 950,000 .8733 KIESTWOOD ESTS BLK A/6032 LOT 00000491218000000 C 2/03 16,500 15,750 16,500 .9545 BLK 6572 PT LT 7 ACS 5.1802 00000604957000000 C 7/02 5,000,000 4,513,000 5,000,000 .9000 BLK 6885 S PT 13-75X727.6X81.6 00000640524140000 C 2/03 18,500 12,000 18,500 .6486 MELSHIRE ESTATES LOT 12 MELETI 00000661585000000 C 1/03 326,900 244,000 326,900 .7464 BLK 7005 SPLIT 1 ACS 4.702 94. 00000662854000100 C 1/02 6,715,000 5,733,160 6,715,000 .8500 BLK 7043 TR 5 ACS 0.187 00000664204000000 C 4/02 100,000 100,000 100,000 1.0000 BLK 8489 TR 1 ACS 10.84 WEST 00000813388000000 C 4/02 40,000 71,520 40,000 1.7880 BLK 8773 TR 1 ACS 3.50 SEE CHA 00000823120000000 C 2/03 195,000 108,460 195,000 .5600 TURTLE CREEK CIRCLE 2 BLK A/99 000995000A0020000 C 6/02 285,000 285,000 285,000 1.0000 PLACE DES VOSGES BLK 3/2063 LT 00206300030010000 C 3/02 550,000 550,000 550,000 1.0000 J DANIEL SPEARS BLK 8/3826 LT 003826000819A0000 C 4/02 179,000 70,098 179,000 .3916 ESTATES 3 BLK 14/6378 LT 5A AC 006378001405A0000 C 5/02 710,000 358,830 710,000 .5054 GRISSOM LANE BLK 6608 LT 1A AC 006608000001A0000 C 4/02 190,000 162,500 190,000 .8600 FIFTY THREE FIFTY NINE ALPHA B 007004000A09A0000 C 6/02 383,850 383,020 383,850 .9978 FOREST PLACE REV BLK 5/7405 LT 007405000501A0000 C 4/02 275,000 250,000 275,000 .9091 LAKE FOREST PH A BLK B/7462 LT 007462000B0060000 C 9/02 223,000 225,000 223,000 1.0090 OAK FOREST ESTATES BLK A/7489 007489000A0060000 C 4/02 600,000 450,000 600,000 .7500 MARRIOTT PLAZA 2 BLK 7896 LT 3 007896000003A0000 C 5/02 3,525,000 3,520,730 3,525,000 .9988 G W FISHER ABST 482 PG 731 TR 10000901914000000 C 12/02 3,250,000 3,309,990 3,250,000 1.0200 BUFORD JETT LOT 10 BLK 3 100X4 12037500030100000 C 4/03 14,000 10,350 14,000 .7393 CARLETONS LOT 6 26079500000060000 C 4/02 115,000 116,030 115,000 1.0100 DUCK CREEK BLK 00006 S 1/2 LT 26142500060060200 C 4/02 91,875 91,880 91,875 1.0000 EMBREE BLK 15 LOTS 1 & 2 26165500150010000 C 12/02 90,000 97,270 90,000 1.0800 ENGLISH ESTATES BLK 5 LTS 11-1 26168500050100000 C 5/02 195,000 193,490 195,000 .9923 INTERSTATE CORNERS BLK 1 LOT 1 26281740010010000 C 1/02 200,000 195,630 200,000 .9782 OAKRIDGE 12 BLK 13 LOT 36 ACS 26421780130360000 C 11/02 87,500 25,000 87,500 .2857 OAKRIDGE 12 BLK 13 LOT 38 ACS 26421780130380000 C 10/02 87,500 25,000 87,500 .2857 OAKRIDGE 12 BLK 13 LOT 39 ACS 26421780130390000 C 9/02 90,000 25,000 90,000 .2778 OAKRIDGE 12 BLK 13 LOT 40 ACS 26421780130400000 C 11/02 90,000 25,000 90,000 .2778 RIDGEWOOD PARK 3 BLK G LOT 13 26492500070130000 C 11/02 25,000 24,000 25,000 .9600 SHORES OF WELLINGTON 3 BLK 7 26531600070160000 C 8/02 159,000 198,470 159,000 1.2500 V F W 5076 BLK 1 LOT 1.1 ACS 26616500010010100 C 8/02 400,000 23,520 400,000 .0588 HILO/O'REILLY ROWLETT BLK 1 LT 44001790010030000 C 7/02 200,000 218,740 200,000 1.0900 LAKE FOREST ESTATES BLK A LT 7 440108000A0070000 C 12/02 65,000 52,010 65,000 .8002 LAKE FOREST ESTATES BLK A LT 2 440108000A0290000 C 12/02 69,500 53,800 69,500 .7741 LAKESHORE CHURCH BLK 1 LT 1 AC 44012880010010000 C 5/02 550,000 619,620 550,000 1.1266 PINNACLE OAKS ESTATES PH 2 SEC 480046600A0100000 C 12/02 59,900 60,000 59,900 1.0017 PINNACLE OAKS ESTATES PH 2 SEC 480046600B0050000 C 10/02 60,000 60,000 60,000 1.0000 PINNACLE OAKS ESTATES PH 2 SEC 480046600B0110000 C 4/03 59,500 60,000 59,500 1.0084

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 30 TIME: 17:56 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-905 Dallas CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ PINNACLE OAKS ESTATES PH 2 SEC 480046600C0080000 C 2/03 65,000 60,000 65,000 .9231 SACHSE RANCH ESTATES 7 BLK F L 48009850060230000 C 1/03 60,000 60,000 60,000 1.0000 EAST RIDGE BLK 2 LT 7 50014550020070000 C 4/03 19,000 12,950 19,000 .6816 CROUCH LT 1 ORIG TOWN WILMER 54003500000010000 C 9/02 42,500 40,000 42,500 .9412 CRYSTAL ACRES BLK H PT LT 34 A 60040500000340200 C 9/02 124,500 114,830 124,500 .9200 WHEATLAND FARMS BLK B LT 33 60243500020330000 C 2/03 15,900 10,000 15,900 .6289 THOMAS J CAMPBELL ABST 299 PG 65029934020050000 C 6/02 85,000 81,300 85,000 .9565 BENNETT J DOEN ABST 382 PG 045 65038204510100300 C 4/02 40,000 39,740 40,000 .9935 JAMES HOBBS ABST 571 PG 716 TR 65057171610190000 C 6/02 119,000 124,000 119,000 1.0420 OLIVER V LEDBETTER ABST 790 P 65079056610010400 C 1/02 1,029,087 1,029,080 1,029,087 1.0000 CHARLES D MERRELL ABST 957 PG 65095712210280000 C 10/02 27,500 28,310 27,500 1.0295 MCKINNEY & WMS ABST 1036 PG 58 65103658010110500 C 9/02 32,700 34,500 32,700 1.0550 C A WARFIELD ABST 1612 PG 065 65161206510250000 C 4/02 35,000 34,920 35,000 .9977 61 SALES CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER APPR VAL APPR VAL RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ HOUSTON ST 00000100039000100 3,189,900 2,994,600 1.0700 W GRIGSBY SURVEY 00000149808000000 3,792,180 3,686,844 1.0300 DALLAS PKWY 00000799918000000 1,875,390 1,875,380 1.0000 3 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .8423 CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 510 S. GOOD LATIMER EXPY. 00000103555000000 C 7/02 450,000 450,550 450,000 1.0000 1845 WOODALL ROGERS 00000106771000000 C 1/02 13,400,000 12,797,050 13,400,000 .9600 2501 CEDAR SPRINGS 00000135109000000 C 1/02 12,300,000 12,300,000 12,300,000 1.0000 2609 WELBORN ST. 00000138253000000 C 8/02 309,000 300,000 309,000 .9709 2660 BRENNER DR. 00000600736000000 C 8/02 715,000 769,050 715,000 1.0800 11102 ABLES LN. 00000602096000000 C 8/02 645,000 680,420 645,000 1.0549 7100 S. WESTMORELAND 00000654137000000M C 3/02 2,605,000 2,605,000 2,605,000 1.0000

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 31 TIME: 17:56 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-905 Dallas CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 3434 DILIDO RD. 00000725302000000 C 9/02 475,000 475,000 475,000 1.0000 1331 RIVER BEND 00000778109520000 C 9/02 310,000 310,000 310,000 1.0000 9218 VISCOUNT ROW 00000779419000000 C 12/02 308,000 308,000 308,000 1.0000 9100 JOHN W. CARPENTER FWY. 00000779485000000 C 2/02 1,200,000 1,200,000 1,200,000 1.0000 2100 MCKINNEY AVENUE 000540000A0010000M C 11/02 70,000,000 72,330,000 70,000,000 1.0300 2515 MCKINNEY AVE. 00095400020010000 C 11/02 22,000,000 22,351,210 22,000,000 1.0200 3100 MONTICELLO 0016230J0003A0000M C 5/02 11,367,230 12,125,320 11,367,230 1.0700 6401 ABRAMS RD. 0054340B0002A0000 C 7/02 3,120,000 3,120,000 3,120,000 1.0000 8024 WALNUT HILL LN. 0054590F000020100 C 9/02 1,590,000 1,563,360 1,590,000 .9800 2324 S. VERNON 00597300000010000 C 7/02 900,000 881,970 900,000 .9800 9585/10001 SCYENE RD. 0067850D0031B0000 C 9/02 850,000 850,000 850,000 1.0000 13727 NOEL RD. 007003000B01A0300 C 10/02 51,000,000 49,875,070 51,000,000 .9800 4505 RATLIFF LN. 10000905440000000 C 1/03 350,000 339,730 350,000 .9700 4139 CENTURION WAY 10000906483200000 C 7/02 1,400,000 1,399,770 1,400,000 1.0000 16633 DALLAS PKWY. 10004530010020000 C 2/03 33,200,000 33,200,000 33,200,000 1.0000 4180 BELT LINE RD. 100053900A0020000 C 1/02 1,296,851 1,198,990 1,296,851 .9200 2774 E. TRINITY MILLS RD. 14034660010010000 C 7/02 700,000 700,000 700,000 1.0000 2125 CHENAULT DR. 140537000F01B0000 C 9/02 2,400,000 2,400,000 2,400,000 1.0000 14015 WELCH RD. 240421000A0010000 C 7/02 3,450,000 3,239,360 3,450,000 .9400 4245-4255 LYNDON B. JOHNSON FW 24131600010010000 C 8/02 16,450,000 18,912,040 16,450,000 1.1500 11900 LBJ FWY. 26322550010010000 C 6/02 6,173,442 5,600,000 6,173,442 .9100 601 E. MALLOY BRIDGE RD. 50046580000010000 C 5/02 1,450,000 1,550,000 1,450,000 1.0700 712 E. DANIELDALE RD. 65046257510180100 C 6/02 300,000 301,820 300,000 1.0100 30 SALES CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 208 S AKARD ST 00000101086000000 .00 1.00 .00 60,972,920 66,006,820 .9200 308 AKARD ST 00000101131000000 .00 1.00 .00 12,188,550 18,346,300 .6600 2121 SAN JACINTO ST 00000105412000000 .00 1.00 .00 50,800,690 53,798,420 .9400 300 REUNION BLVD 00000108921000000 .00 1.00 .00 70,000,000 78,725,755 .8900 8080 N CENTRAL EXPY 00000366504500000 .00 1.00 .00 26,203,640 24,102,740 1.0900 11888 MARSH LN 00000582613000000 .00 1.00 .00 6,598,620 6,266,755 1.0500 5400 LBJ FRWY 00000662581250000 .00 1.00 .00 45,743,480 42,680,030 1.0700 12200 PRESTON RD 00000734274000000 .00 1.00 .00 3,307,630 3,227,782 1.0200 17120 DALLAS PKWY 00000799937580100 .00 1.00 .00 2,741,830 2,789,857 .9800 2323 BRYAN ST 000316000007A0000 .00 1.00 .00 54,535,410 54,304,200 1.0000 2300 HICKORY ST 000472000A01B0100 .00 1.00 .00 3,394,230 3,190,945 1.0600 7901 NORTHWEST HWY 000543000K01A0000 .00 1.00 .00 172,400,000 167,993,979 1.0300 6770 SKILLMAN ST 005435000101A0000 .00 1.00 .00 13,600,000 13,634,760 1.0000 6070 N CENTRAL EXPY 005453000K01A0000 .00 1.00 .00 7,737,490 10,798,164 .7200 14900 LANDMARK BLVD 10004750020010000 .00 1.00 .00 3,300,000 3,754,010 .8800

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 32 TIME: 17:56 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-905 Dallas CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 14643 DALLAS PKWY 10005370010020000 .00 1.00 .00 17,000,000 17,138,660 .9900 5005 LBY FRWY 24073740000050000 .00 1.00 .00 54,051,400 52,845,810 1.0200 14325 GILLIS RD 24130600040040000 .00 1.00 .00 4,294,080 4,454,164 .9600 18 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9767 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ NATIONAL POTAL MAIL HANDLERS 99000000216076250 362,500 362,500 1.0000 YOUNG CHEVROLET 99000000216642650 4,648,089 4,640,883 1.0000 HI LO AUTOMOTIVE 99199929900242400 20,879,378 20,987,417 .9900 NEIMAN MARCUS CHEF'S CATALOG 99200006100228150 4,609,411 4,610,606 1.0000 UNIPOINT HOLDINGS 99200021600209850 1,156,716 1,156,716 1.0000 MCGRAW HILL PUBLISHING 99200108500156400 34,654,726 34,651,994 1.0000 EXXON MOBIL 99200213600001150 53,530,422 55,610,570 .9600 HUGHES SUPPLY 99200313500019900 1,361,690 1,206,652 1.1300 NEIMAN MARCUS 99820580000051400 20,498,512 19,720,050 1.0400 TESTAMERICA 99820850000104800 1,795,621 1,526,424 1.1800 SAKS FIFTH AVE 99830030000169700 10,066,591 9,686,394 1.0400 KEYSTONE AUTOMOTIVE 99843380000066700 693,675 692,233 1.0000 ECOM ATLANTIC 99850030000030800 78,708 66,194 1.1900 ECKERD 99902140000039750 975,140 969,168 1.0100 NATIONAL CAR RENTAL 99923630000098400 5,435,977 5,535,910 .9800 MARY KAY INC 99932280000191350 12,630,059 12,579,832 1.0000 BURLINGTON COAT FACTORY 99932850000006650 2,817,844 2,803,012 1.0100 TOM THUMB 99933060000054050 4,207,841 3,545,764 1.1900 HUDSON CO NEWS GATE 99952140000193550 1,076,258 915,459 1.1800 AETNA LIFE INS 99960920000058700 17,968,345 17,939,645 1.0000 NATIONS PREFERRED HOME WARRANT 99962120000092900 66,487 35,874 1.8500 FIESTA MART 99962560000032400 1,637,469 1,372,377 1.1900 SEARS 99970440000067250 11,901,149 12,460,448 .9600 JACK IN THE BOX 99972050000013750 127,470 124,271 1.0300 COCA COLA 99980280000151550 6,515,672 6,962,176 .9400 WACHOVIA 99982160000177400 1,718,974 1,627,945 1.0600 WASH WORKS 99983420000117550 193,608 153,676 1.2600 ADVANCED HEART CARE 99990610000033900 625,945 602,795 1.0400 GMAC DALLAS 99990610000040850 17,583,016 17,583,016 1.0000 29 APPRAISALS

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 33 TIME: 17:56 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 057 Dallas 057-905 Dallas STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0293