Skip to content
Quick Start for:


DATE:   6/27/2004                        COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION                         PAGE:     10
TIME:     16:48                                      2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY                                          RPT: VAL7018
                                                   FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET
                                                             001  Anderson
                                                         001-907  Palestine

CATEGORY A:  SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
             LEGAL                  APPRAISAL ROLL            S       SALE          SALE            CAD          ADJ         IND
          DESCRIPTION               ACCOUNT NUMBER            C       DATE         PRICE         APPR VAL    SALE PRICE     RATIO
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  AB 3 GEO ANDING SUR BLK 1542 T   R10344                     B       6/02         22,500          20,120        22,500     .8900
  AB 8 E A BOWEN SUR BLK 490 TR    R11110                     B      11/02        105,000         110,270       105,000    1.0500
  AB 8 ELI A BOWEN SUR BLK 494 T   R11143                     O      11/02        165,000         172,390       165,000    1.0400
  AB 40 M MAIN SUR BLK 869 TR 8    R15241                     B       8/02         29,000          47,020        29,000    1.6200
  AB 40 M MAIN SUR BLK 873 TR 4    R15300                     W      12/02         12,000          21,100        12,000    1.7600
  AB 43 W S MCDONALD SUR BLK 898   R15778                     B       3/02         80,500          98,530        80,500    1.2200
  AB 43 W S MCDONALD SUR BLK 898   R15783                     W       7/02         74,600          84,360        74,600    1.1300
  AB 63 J SNIVELY SUR BLK 862-3    R17796                     W       3/02         25,000          34,310        25,000    1.3700
  AB 527 D MCKENZIE SUR BLK 1258   R23963                     O       7/02         39,000          34,930        39,000     .9000
  LOT 1B & 2B BLK A BROYLES .391   R28497                     B      10/02         18,000          30,680        18,000    1.7000
  LOT 3A BLK B BROYLES     .7454   R28512                     O      10/02        125,000         119,800       125,000     .9600
  LOT 2B BLK E BROYLES             R28529                     O       8/02         56,000          52,050        56,000     .9300
  LOT 3 BLK E BROYLES .9932 ACRE   R28530                     O       3/03        103,000          99,640       103,000     .9700
  LOTS 1, 2, 3B, & 4B   BLK G BR   R28537                     O       2/03         63,494          55,220        63,494     .8700
  LOT 3 & ALLEY BLK I BROYLES &    R28561                     Y       2/02         69,500          69,380        69,500    1.0000
  LOTS 1-6 BLK K BURKITT/BORDEAU   R28681                     B      11/02         41,800          43,960        41,800    1.0500
  LOT 4 & 5 BLK C ELMER E DAVIS    R28866                     O       2/03         40,000          43,540        40,000    1.0900
  LOT 7A & 8 BLK C ELMER E DAVIS   R28868                     O       2/03         25,000          20,570        25,000     .8200
  LOTS 1A, 2A, 3A BLK D DEBARD     R28902                     B      11/02         34,000          46,940        34,000    1.3800
  LOT 2 BLK 33 DEBARD              R29130                     O       5/02         10,500          25,700        10,500    2.4500
  LOT 5 BLK 1 DEERWOOD PARK        R29197                     B       5/02         97,000         102,390        97,000    1.0600
  LOT 1 BLK C DOGWOOD HILLS NORT   R29371                     B       2/03        112,000         108,380       112,000     .9700
  LOT 2 BLK D DOGWOOD HILLS NORT   R29377                     B       6/02        116,200         101,820       116,200     .8800
  LOT 8 BLK F DOGWOOD HILLS NORT   R29414                     B       7/02        160,000         158,100       160,000     .9900
  LOT 6 BLK 7 ESTATES    .4591 A   R29515                     B       2/03         51,000          43,470        51,000     .8500
  LOT 5 BLK 15 ESTATES             R29579                     Y       4/02         45,000          51,400        45,000    1.1400
  LOT 6 & 7A BLK 33 GREEN    .29   R30269                     O      11/02         23,500          29,200        23,500    1.2400
  LOT 3 BLK 35 GREEN    .1458 AC   R30285                     B       9/02         22,000          26,900        22,000    1.2200
  LOT 5R BLK 51 GREEN     .1875    R30392                     O       5/02         40,000          42,980        40,000    1.0700
  LOT 16C & 17C BLK 54 GREEN ADD   R30420                     B       9/02         16,000          23,770        16,000    1.4900
  LOT 4R BLK 56 GREEN    .1997 A   R30435                     B       2/03         30,000          29,480        30,000     .9800
  LOT 1 & TRACT A BLK 2 HIGHLAND   R30727                     B       7/02         63,500          63,270        63,500    1.0000
  LOT 5 BLK 2 HIGHLAND   .3444 A   R30731                     B      10/02         53,000          53,270        53,000    1.0100
  LOT 8 BLK 4 HIGHLAND   .5379 A   R30753                     B       9/02        105,000         105,340       105,000    1.0000
  LOT 4A BLK 6 HIGHLAND      1.4   R30769                     B       5/02        108,500         109,280       108,500    1.0100
  LOT 18A BLK 7 HIGHLAND   .3277   R30790                     B       9/02         45,000          49,810        45,000    1.1100
  LOTS 3 & 4 BLK 8 HIGHLAND        R30793                     O       6/02        147,000         132,510       147,000     .9000
  LOT 4A BLK 11 HIGHLAND  .2458    R30819                     W       8/02         62,600          62,600        62,600    1.0000
  LOT 6R BLK 16 REVISED HIGHLAND   R30865                     O       5/02         83,500          78,080        83,500     .9400
  LOT 10 BLK 16 REVISED HIGHLAND   R30871                     B      10/02        110,000          81,860       110,000     .7400
  LOT 40B BLK 16 REVISED HIGHLAN   R30898                     B      10/02         85,500          87,590        85,500    1.0200
  LOT 1R BLK 2 R J HORN     .861   R31000                     S       8/02         78,500          83,530        78,500    1.0600
  LOT 3 G HUTCHERSON SUR    .498   R31033                     S       5/02         88,000          78,260        88,000     .8900
  LOT 11B IDLEWILD   .9986 ACRES   R31057                     B       8/02         35,500          35,440        35,500    1.0000
  TRACK D BLK 8 INDIAN CREEK       R31165                     O       2/03         76,000          65,590        76,000     .8600
  LOT 41B & 42A INWOOD TERRACE     R31203                     O       7/02         63,500          58,260        63,500     .9200
  LOT 69 INWOOD TERRACE     .274   R31229                     O      10/02         54,500          50,440        54,500     .9300

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 11 TIME: 16:48 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 001 Anderson 001-907 Palestine CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LOT 78 INWOOD TERRACE .3275 R31236 S 12/02 55,000 50,870 55,000 .9200 LOT 99 INWOOD TERRACE .3874 R31258 O 3/03 60,000 56,200 60,000 .9400 LOT 114 INWOOD TERRACE .3036 R31273 W 8/02 58,000 58,130 58,000 1.0000 LOTS 1B & 2B INWOOD TERRACE AN R31339 O 12/02 46,000 58,690 46,000 1.2800 LOT 26B & 27 INWOOD TERRACE AN R31363 W 9/02 50,000 60,480 50,000 1.2100 LOT 47 INWOOD TERRACE ANNEX #2 R31382 O 5/02 63,000 55,160 63,000 .8800 LOTS 64A & 65B INWOOD TERRACE R31400 O 2/03 66,000 62,800 66,000 .9500 LOT 72B & 73B INWOOD TERRACE A R31409 O 9/02 50,000 52,380 50,000 1.0500 LOTS 3, 4, & 5A BLK A JOW R31742 B 8/02 114,500 119,670 114,500 1.0500 LOT 10 JOWERS HEIGHTS REVISED R31761 O 1/03 81,000 70,460 81,000 .8700 LOT 43 JOWERS HEIGHTS REVISED R31777 O 11/02 88,500 87,220 88,500 .9900 LOT 51 JOWERS HEIGHTS REVISED R31785 W 12/02 63,000 55,330 63,000 .8800 LOT 13 KELLER .2572 ACRES R31799 B 9/02 59,000 57,440 59,000 .9700 LOT 2 BLK 1 KURTWOOD .6233 R31818 B 12/02 91,000 100,420 91,000 1.1000 LOT 20B BLK 20 LARKIN & CAMPBE R32033 B 7/02 55,000 85,700 55,000 1.5600 LOT 29C & 29D BLK 29 LARKIN & R32065 O 8/02 32,000 41,690 32,000 1.3000 LOT 43B BLK 43 LOT 39C BLK 39 R32104 O 6/02 23,500 22,170 23,500 .9400 LOTS 1-2 & 12-14 BLK F MEADOWB R32550 B 8/02 218,000 220,130 218,000 1.0100 LOTS 3 & 4A BLK 8 MICHEAUX PAR R32639 B 8/02 44,250 43,660 44,250 .9900 LOT 4B & 5B BLK 11 MICHEAUX PA R32657 W 3/02 34,000 37,510 34,000 1.1000 LOT 1B & 2C BLK 13 MICHEAUX PA R32665 B 11/02 20,000 20,190 20,000 1.0100 LOT 8B & 9C BLK 20 MICHEAUX PA R32722 S 5/02 32,500 26,460 32,500 .8100 LOT 14A BLK 9 FAIRVIEW LOT 21H R32734 O 1/03 73,500 64,000 73,500 .8700 LOT 18 & 19B BLK 45 MICHEAUX P R32833 W 5/02 42,500 45,870 42,500 1.0800 LOTS 43, 44, 45B BLK 45 MICH R32849 B 6/02 123,000 124,340 123,000 1.0100 LOTS 60, 61A, 61B, 62 & 63A BL R32857 Y 9/02 89,000 89,670 89,000 1.0100 LOTS 4 & 5 BLK 1 MISTY MEADOWS R32914 B 3/03 215,000 220,390 215,000 1.0300 LOT 5 BLK 2 SECTION I MISTY ME R32925 B 4/02 128,000 128,250 128,000 1.0000 LOT 16 BLK 2 MISTY MEADOWS SEC R32947 B 6/02 158,500 158,580 158,500 1.0000 LOT 41R BLK 1 MONTROSE S/D R33014 B 4/02 59,500 54,050 59,500 .9100 LOT 5 BLK 2 MOONLITE .6748 R33072 O 9/02 30,000 39,390 30,000 1.3100 LOT 1 BLK 1 FRANK MOORE .99 R33114 B 10/02 31,500 39,380 31,500 1.2500 LOT 19 MCFARLANE ESTATES #3 R33418 B 7/02 95,000 88,700 95,000 .9300 LOT 23 NECHES TRACT 1.323 A R33503 B 12/02 79,000 92,770 79,000 1.1700 LOT 4 BLK 1 NORTH HILLS .74 R33518 O 2/03 69,500 67,230 69,500 .9700 LOT 10A BLK 1 OAKDALE DRIVE R33710 O 11/02 20,000 37,750 20,000 1.8900 LOT 53 & 54B TR C BLK 1 OAKDAL R33742 O 5/02 20,000 24,030 20,000 1.2000 LOT 1 BLK 45 ORIGINAL 1.6847 R33977 O 2/03 97,000 106,130 97,000 1.0900 LOT 2 BLK 45 ORIGINAL R33978 B 6/02 43,000 45,610 43,000 1.0600 LOT 4 BLK 95 ORIGINAL .2824 AC R34201 W 5/02 95,000 77,520 95,000 .8200 LOT 19 BLK 97 EAST ORIGINAL R34254 B 1/03 136,200 136,150 136,200 1.0000 LOT 8 BLK 98 EAST ORIGINAL . R34276 Y 6/02 164,900 164,760 164,900 1.0000 LOT 15A BLK 98 (WEST) ORIGINAL R34286 W 12/02 57,500 58,830 57,500 1.0200 LOT 2B & 3A BLK 99B ORIGINAL R34303 S 12/02 55,000 40,490 55,000 .7400 LOT 4 BLK 100 EAST ORIGINAL R34324 B 11/02 49,800 66,790 49,800 1.3400 LOT 7 PER - LANG ESTATES 2.0 R34509 O 3/03 128,500 87,380 128,500 .6800 LOT 1C BLK C REAGAN & WORD . R34874 O 9/02 215,000 241,510 215,000 1.1200

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 12 TIME: 16:48 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 001 Anderson 001-907 Palestine CATEGORY A: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LOT 1A BLK G REAGAN & WORD R34891 Y 10/02 34,900 34,370 34,900 .9800 LOT 3 BLK 11 REAGAN & WORD ADD R35053 S 8/02 74,000 65,310 74,000 .8800 LOT 4A BLK A SOUTHWEST HILLS # R35401 O 8/02 72,500 78,200 72,500 1.0800 LOT 1 BLK C SOUTHWEST HILLS #3 R35414 B 3/03 77,000 69,980 77,000 .9100 LOT 2B & 3 BLK 3 VENTURE NORTH R36233 B 8/02 91,750 96,810 91,750 1.0600 LOT 3C, 3E &4B BLK 1 WRIGHTS 1 R36821 O 5/02 63,500 37,240 63,500 .5900 LOT 15 BLK 1 WRIGHTS 3RD 1 R36918 O 8/02 145,000 134,580 145,000 .9300 LOT 16A BLK 1 WRIGHTS 3RD R36919 O 9/02 118,000 114,360 118,000 .9700 LOT 21C BLK 1 WRIGHTS 3RD .3 R36931 Y 3/02 52,500 52,990 52,500 1.0100 LOT 6, 11 & CLOSED STREET WRIG R36956 O 2/03 155,000 139,080 155,000 .9000 LOTS 4 & 5 JOWERS HEIGHTS REVI R42066 O 1/03 78,000 75,520 78,000 .9700 AB 43 W S MCDONALS SUR BLK 898 R42172 O 7/02 98,500 100,780 98,500 1.0200 LOT 21 BLK 9 VENTURE NORTH SEC R42259 B 1/03 90,000 93,070 90,000 1.0300 AB 723 J SHIPLEY SUR BLK 1257 R46541 B 8/02 51,000 47,080 51,000 .9200 AB 34 W KIMBROUGH SUR BLK 1272 R60258 B 8/02 39,500 43,780 39,500 1.1100 LOTS 3R & 10R BLK 3 MOONLITE R60279 Y 2/02 49,900 43,590 49,900 .8700 LOT 6B BLK 6 HIGHLAND .409 R60398 B 10/02 133,000 123,280 133,000 .9300 LOT 1 NECHES TRACE 1.165 ACRE R60912 B 11/02 75,000 92,190 75,000 1.2300 LOT 7 LAURA'S ADDITION SECTION R61844 B 4/02 195,000 194,290 195,000 1.0000 LOT 8 LAURA'S ADDITION SECTION R61845 B 4/02 171,000 176,770 171,000 1.0300 LOT 18 LAURA'S ADDITION SECTIO R61856 O 3/03 185,000 174,540 185,000 .9400 LOTS 3 & 4 BLK A DOGWOOD HILLS R63667 B 7/02 84,000 83,950 84,000 1.0000 LOT 3 SOUTHWEST HILLS REPLAT R63742 O 9/02 110,850 102,070 110,850 .9200 LOTS 1-3 EDGEWOOD NORTH 1.97 R64819 B 9/02 125,000 125,450 125,000 1.0000 LOT 7A EDGEWOOD NORTH .41 ACR R64823 O 10/02 80,000 82,550 80,000 1.0300 AB 286 D FARIS SUR BLK 1295 TR R65445 B 8/02 187,000 185,010 187,000 .9900 LOT 6 BLK 3 WOODGATE SECTION I R65860 O 3/03 210,000 196,410 210,000 .9400 LOT 144 CIRCLE R LAKE R66288 O 12/02 33,000 37,430 33,000 1.1300 AB 286 D FARIS BLK 12195 TR 7A R66587 B 6/02 225,000 218,680 225,000 .9700 LOT 4 BLK 1 PARK MEADOWS ADDN R832295 B 8/02 286,000 278,620 286,000 .9700 LOT 5 & TRACK A BLK 2 PARK MEA R832301 B 11/02 189,000 225,140 189,000 1.1900 LOT 23 WILLIAMSBURG VILLAGE R833412 B 10/02 130,000 125,650 130,000 .9700 AB 34 W KIMBROUGH SUR BLK 1272 R834954 B 9/02 159,900 159,630 159,900 1.0000 LOT 4 TRACT 1 DAVEY LAKE ESTAT R835966 B 9/02 255,000 252,900 255,000 .9900 AB 6 S TAYLOR SUR BLK 837 TR 1 R838375 B 7/02 198,000 195,820 198,000 .9900 LOT 2 BLK C HOMESTEAD AT FORT R840641 B 11/02 96,000 109,080 96,000 1.1400 LOT 6 BLK C HOMESTEAD AT FORT R840645 B 11/02 95,000 109,080 95,000 1.1500 LOT 8 BLK C HOMESTEAD AT FORT R840647 W 7/02 96,850 105,890 96,850 1.0900 132 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0134 CATEGORY B: MULTIFAMILY RESIDENCES INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE. CATEGORY C: VACANT LOTS/TRACTS INSUFFICIENT SALES OR APPRAISALS IN SAMPLE; STAFF ASSIGNED LOCAL VALUE.

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 13 TIME: 16:48 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 001 Anderson 001-907 Palestine CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AB 3 G ANDING SUR BLK 1541 TR R10321 O 4/03 72,150 96,195 .7500 AB 3 G ANDING SUR BLK 1544 TR R10374 Y 6/02 76,950 85,000 .9100 AB 8 E A BOWEN SUR BLK 488 TR R11075 B 8/02 182,260 200,000 .9100 AB 8 E A BOWEN SUR BLK 490 TR R11100 B 7/02 230,600 389,778 .5900 AB 15 S CRIST SUR BLK 905 TR 1 R11665 O 7/02 615,510 570,000 1.0800 AB 15 S CRIST SUR BLK 905 TR 1 R11685 O 4/03 52,110 60,000 .8700 AB 15 S CRIST SUR BLK 906 TR 3 R11699 O 1/02 38,790 29,220 1.3300 AB 15 S CRIST SUR BLK 912 TR 4 R11828 O 7/02 109,300 118,000 .9300 AB 28 E GROCE SUR BLK 1381 TR R13462 Y 3/02 100,310 75,000 1.3400 AB 29 J HALL SUR BLK 1370 TR 5 R13547 B 2/03 67,640 80,000 .8500 AB 34 W KIMBROUGH SUR BLK 1272 R14462 B 11/02 21,050 22,836 .9200 AB 34 W KIMBROUGH SUR BLK 1261 R14487 B 8/02 118,670 90,000 1.3200 AB 34 W KIMBROUGH SUR BLK 1274 R14618 O 5/03 42,680 38,000 1.1200 AB 34 W KIMBROUGH SUR BLK 1274 R14619 B 5/02 41,780 28,120 1.4900 AB 40 M MAIN SUR BLK 495 TR 1B R15177 B 3/02 51,260 41,870 1.2200 AB 40 M MAIN SUR BLK 497 TR 1 R15198 O 4/03 28,900 50,000 .5800 AB 58 M RIONDO SUR BLK 1822 TR R17036 B 5/02 191,780 205,000 .9400 AB 58 M RIONDO SUR BLK 1831 TR R17048 B 12/02 69,570 65,000 1.0700 AB 62 I SIMPSON SUR BLK 1572-1 R17664 W 7/02 39,170 35,000 1.1200 AB 161 R CRIST SUR BLK 445 TR R19816 O 1/02 20,270 29,058 .7000 AB 286 D FARIS SUR BLK 1295 TR R21277 B 3/03 189,680 240,000 .7900 AB 299 J N FITZGERALD SUR BLK R21420 B 2/03 86,020 86,000 1.0000 AB 324 W M GIBSON SUR BLK 41 T R21751 B 3/02 82,740 131,000 .6300 AB 355 D HASSELL SUR BLK 833 T R22100 B 7/02 281,430 285,000 .9900 AB 430 M JAMERSON SUR BLK 562 R22829 B 7/02 43,790 36,975 1.1800 AB 606 R S PATTON SUR BLK 1597 R24756 B 3/03 270,350 350,080 .7700 AB 620 R R POWERS SUR BLK 1289 R24902 B 4/03 207,890 225,900 .9200 AB 631 J E PALMER SUR BLK 416 R24987 O 3/03 27,860 24,987 1.1100 AB 665 R RUCKER SUR BLK 414B T R25388 B 3/03 92,550 105,000 .8800 AB 713 M SALISAR SUR BLK 1306 R26064 B 10/02 28,370 47,969 .5900 AB 766 SA & NG RR CO BLK 1287 R26659 B 3/03 61,890 65,549 .9400 AB 914 J T DELK SUR BLK 507 TR R27663 B 4/03 18,770 18,833 1.0000 LOTS 1-4 & 9-24 3.055 AC R30990 B 2/02 19,620 12,300 1.6000 AB 19 W ELLIOTT SUR BLK 819 TR R59201 O 2/03 93,110 125,000 .7400 AB 161 R CRIST SUR BLK 445 TR R63653 O 2/03 86,950 93,000 .9300 AB 34 W KIMBROUGH SUR BLK 1279 R64108 B 11/02 161,390 167,500 .9600 AB 44 J B MCNEALY SUR BLK 1361 R66437 B 2/03 52,250 44,000 1.1900 AB 302 G W FORBES SUR BLK 1318 R66601 B 5/02 49,010 77,550 .6300 AB 62 I SIMPSON SUR BLK 1565-1 R68156 Y 1/02 178,630 215,000 .8300 AB 62 I SIMPSON SUR BLK 1566 T R70070 B 6/02 65,110 55,000 1.1800 AB 28 BLK 1368 TR 1A, 1A1, 1A2 R826908 B 9/02 199,330 200,000 1.0000 AB 34 W KIMBROUGH SUR BLK 1263 R829408 Y 4/02 12,540 15,680 .8000 AB 993 P G ADAMS SUR BLK 1583 R831811 O 4/03 45,270 46,105 .9800 AB 232 S DAVIS SUR BLK 46 TR 8 R833689 B 9/02 119,160 69,176 1.7200 AB 815 J W WRIGHT SUR BLK 1613 R837347 W 4/02 100,560 98,000 1.0300 AB 286 D FARIS SUR BLK 1317 TR R838047 B 2/02 29,150 42,000 .6900 LOT 1 BLK F DOGWOOD HILLS NORT R839666 O 1/02 7,430 7,000 1.0600

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 14 TIME: 16:48 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 001 Anderson 001-907 Palestine CATEGORY D: RURAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE APPR VAL SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AB 964 W C BROWN SUR BLK 1265 R841066 O 10/02 10,000 8,000 1.2500 AB 713 M SALISAR SUR BLK 1285 R841100 B 3/03 3,720 4,284 .8700 AB 940 H H AULD SUR BLK 1337 T R841251 W 12/02 4,880 5,000 .9800 50 SALES STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: .9213 CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL S SALE SALE CAD ADJ IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER C DATE PRICE APPR VALUE SALE PRICE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AB 65 S G WELLS SUR BLK 854 TR R18081 B 1/03 85,500 75,300 85,500 .8800 LOTS 1 & 2 BLK 23 GREEN .3134 R30222 O 5/03 52,000 66,640 52,000 1.2800 GREEN, BLOCK 33, LOT 11B R30273 C 2/02 70,000 58,300 70,000 .8329 MOORE, FRANK, BLOCK 1, LOT 13B R33127 Y 3/02 81,500 92,760 81,500 1.1400 LOTS 11A & 12B BLK 93-N1/2 ORI R34177 B 2/02 74,000 80,270 74,000 1.0800 LOT 9B (0RTH PART) BLK 95 ORIG R34208 Y 10/02 70,000 70,880 70,000 1.0100 LOT 1A BLK L REAGAN & WORD .24 R34948 W 5/02 25,000 44,540 25,000 1.7800 LOT 2 BLK 1 TRINITY VALLEY MED R825436S B 9/02 210,000 206,163 210,000 .9800 LOTS 4 & 5 BLK 141 ORIGINAL .1 R837352 W 2/02 85,000 72,770 85,000 .8600 9 SALES CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AB 40 MICKUM MAIN SUR BLK 893 R15356 .00 1.00 .00 126,870 124,978 1.0200 AB 43 WM S MCDONALD SUR BLK 89 R15729 .00 1.00 .00 231,650 239,510 .9700 AB 43 WM S MCDONALD SUR BLK 89 R15739 .00 1.00 .00 777,710 806,795 .9600 AB 43 WM S MCDONALD SUR BLK 89 R15744 .00 1.00 .00 336,590 320,253 1.0500 TRACT 2A1 PALESTINE SHOPPING C R15754 .00 1.00 .00 3,109,520 3,311,312 .9400 AB 43 WM S MCDONALD SUR BLK 90 R15807 .00 1.00 .00 12,317,750 12,246,922 1.0100 AB 63 JACOB SNIVELY SUR BLK 86 R17749 .00 1.00 .00 383,840 395,224 .9700 AB 65 SAMUEL G WELLS SUR BLK 8 R18011 .00 1.00 .00 407,270 393,491 1.0400 LOT 1 BLK 1 HOLIDAY INN R30988 .00 1.00 .00 1,528,760 1,584,926 .9600 ALL OF BLK 37 LARKIN & CAMPBEL R32093 .00 1.00 .00 320,080 396,823 .8100 LOTS 11B-15B, 16B-20B, 21 & 22 R34492 .00 1.00 .00 1,043,820 1,027,989 1.0200 LOT 18 BLK 1 SOUTHSIDE HEIGHTS R35267 .00 1.00 .00 274,520 274,595 1.0000 LOTS 1A, 1B & 1C BLK L YUKUM & R37015 .00 1.00 .00 293,700 294,021 1.0000 LOTS 1-10 BLK 163 ORIGINAL TOW R42425 .00 1.00 .00 672,820 727,274 .9300

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 15 TIME: 16:48 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 001 Anderson 001-907 Palestine CATEGORY F: COMMERCIAL REAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL LOC ADD CAD TOTAL IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER BCM MOD OBS APPR VALUE APPR VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LOT 1A, 1B, 2A, 2B BLK 21 ORIG R45095 .00 1.00 .00 96,150 94,885 1.0100 LOT 3 AMERICAN BANK & TRUST CO R60426 .00 1.00 .00 563,690 591,079 .9500 LOT 6 & TRACT 1 AMERICAN BAMK R66754 .00 1.00 .00 604,430 524,191 1.1500 LOT 2 BLK 1 TRINITY VALLEY MED R825436 .00 1.00 .00 687,210 652,361 1.0500 LOT 1A WALTON S/D 30.231 ACRES R829736 .00 1.00 .00 7,257,690 7,217,432 1.0100 AB 43 WM S MCDONALD SUR BLK 90 R835090 .00 1.00 .00 2,148,680 1,585,763 1.3500 AB 43 WM S MCDONALD SUR BLK 90 R836113 .00 1.00 .00 872,740 872,136 1.0000 LOT 1B AMERICAN BANK AND TRUST R837175 .00 1.00 .00 1,422,200 1,382,323 1.0300 22 APPRAISALS STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO: 1.0159 CATEGORY L: COMMERCIAL PERSONAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEGAL APPRAISAL ROLL CAD APPR IND DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER VALUE VALUE RATIO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BROOKSHIRE FOOD STORE NO 30 P100234 1,009,850 836,040 1.2100 CITY SHOE SHOP P100400 26,579 26,653 1.0000 ECKERD DRUGS # 915 P100659 608,338 599,446 1.0100 CAPITAL GAINES P100809 133,705 129,847 1.0300 GREGG BUTANE COMPANY P100908 87,677 90,000 .9700 T & P SERVICES P102313 189,300 150,000 1.2600 TYER'S AUTO AIR INC / TAXIDERM P102433 34,865 37,712 .9200 FERGUSON ENTERPRISES INC P102440 225,366 230,679 .9800 REGIONS BANK P102739 307,036 214,034 1.4300 PALESTINE BOWLING CENTER P61129 173,659 181,439 .9600 EL TORO MEXICAN RESTAURANT P66522 204,400 185,000 1.1000 TAMCO PROFESSIONAL SERVICES P67991 188,415 189,000 1.0000 PALESTINE REGIONAL MEDICAL CEN P69447 9,811,455 8,820,140 1.1100 PAL-TEX URTHANE P825431 35,250 35,200 1.0000 THOMAS PLUMBING P830127 49,036 44,681 1.1000 WAL-MART SUPER CENTER P830794 8,215,715 7,931,198 1.0400 DR CHARLES BENNETT P832930 32,798 30,360 1.0800 TRACTOR SUPPLY CO #384 P833174 813,539 817,855 .9900 AMERICAN EXPRESS EQUIPMENT FIN P834932 43,310 43,500 1.0000 SADLER BAR B QUE SALES INC P837799 415,509 415,000 1.0000 BATH & BODY WORKS INC P837838 129,819 117,672 1.1000 OFFICE DEPOT P837901 1,199,054 1,200,000 1.0000 GOODY'S FAMILY CLOTHING P838108 568,022 471,359 1.2100 BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD P838136 488,140 457,187 1.0700 THOMAS DOZER CONSTRUCTION P838177 75,595 75,000 1.0100 25 APPRAISALS

DATE: 6/27/2004 COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PAGE: 16 TIME: 16:48 2003 PROPERTY VALUE STUDY RPT: VAL7018 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 001 Anderson 001-907 Palestine STRATIFIED WEIGHTED MEAN RATIO WITH EXCEPTIONS: 1.0588